The relative statistical length scale of double-stranded DNA molecules (dsDNA, the terms “DNA” and “dsDNA” are used interchangeably throughout the present disclosure) is set by the number of statistical segments N=L/κ in the polymer, where L is the total length of the polymer and κ is the Kuhn length, described below. If N>>1, the dsDNA is said to be very long.
There are generally three ways to sort extremely long dsDNA as a function of L: gel electrophoresis at very low fields to avoid elongation of the spherical random-coil polymer [6] (which requires multi-day run times), by full elongation in crossed fields [1, 9], or by stretching in microfabricated structures [22]. While stretching of a dsDNA polymer in post arrays or in microstructures or nanochannels is attractive and popular [12], it lacks the scalable high throughput that continuous flow particle separation technologies can provide [18, 21], which are necessary for many preparative applications [3].
Techniques which do not stretch dsDNA rely on a conformation of the genomic dsDNA which is as close to spherical form as possible. Indeed, the first attempt to sort dsDNA in a microfabricated device [23] failed precisely because the dsDNA was so easily elongated in shear fields.
To that end, in embodiments of the present disclosure, methods and systems are presented to control the conformation of DNA to a non-elongated configuration so that it can be easily handled, e.g., sorted, concentrated, and the like, using, for example, a deterministic lateral displacement array for concentrating DNA).
Accordingly, in some embodiments, a method for manipulating DNA molecules for use in a microfluidic device are provided. In such embodiments, the method comprises providing a solution of a plurality of DNA molecules which have an approximately spherical shape and a first radius of gyration under under a zero flow velocity. The DNA molecules may be maintained in an approximately spherical shape under a useful range of flow velocity in a microstructured environment. For some embodiments, a useful range of flow velocity is from about 1 micron/second to about 1 millimeter/second.
In some embodiments (similar to that noted above), a method for manipulating DNA molecules in a microfluidic device is provided, where the method comprises providing a solution of a plurality of DNA molecules having a first radius of gyration under under a zero flow velocity. The first radius of gyration of the DNA molecules may be maintained and/or decreased under a useful range of flow velocity.
In some embodiments, a method for manipulating DNA molecules in a microfluidic device is provided, where the method comprises providing a plurality of DNA molecules in a solution comprising agents that increase the shear modulus of the DNA molecules. These embodiments may be configured such that the DNA molecules are able to maintain an approximately spherical conformation under a useful range of flow velocity.
In some embodiments, methods may be provided for maintaining an approximately spherical shape of the DNA molecules, or maintaining and/or decreasing the first radius of gyration of the DNA molecules, or increasing the shear modulus of the DNA molecules. Each of these results may be achieved by adding an amount of DNA condensation agent to the solution. The DNA condensation agent may be selected from the group consisting of: polyethylene glycol polymers (PEG), polyvinylpyrrolidone, spermine, spermidine, cobalt hexamine, and cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB).
In some embodiments, the amount of DNA condensation agent is between:
In some embodiments, one and/or another of the disclosed methods include flowing the solution (i.e., DNA combined with the the DNA condensation agent) through a microfludic device, where the microfluidic device comprises at least one of: a deterministic lateral displacement (DLD) array, a Brownian rachet array, a pinched flow fractionation device, a hydrodynamic filtration device, and a anisotropic nanofilter array. In some embodiments, the microfluidic device manipulates the DNA molecules, where manipulation may comprise at least one of: fractionation by size, purification, chemical modification, and enzymatic modification.
In some embodiments, a system for concentrating DNA in a microfluidic environment is provided, and may comprise a deterministic lateral displacement (DLD) array. In some embodiments, the DLD array may comprise one or the other of DLD arrays described in references [5, 10, 11, 14, 15, 16], each of which are hereby incorported by reference. In some embodiments, the DLD array is configured to cause concentration of DNA molecules having a radius of gyration greater than a first (e.g., critical) radius from a solution of DNA molecules comprising an amount of DNA condensation agent. The system may also additionally comprise a source of hydrodynamic pressure configured to cause the solution to flow in the microfluidic channels at a fluid flow velocity. One and/or ther other of the fluid flow velocity and amount of DNA condensation agent are configured so as to cause the DNA molecules to remain in an approximately spherical conformation.
In some embodiments, a system for concentrating DNA in a microfluidic environment is provided, and may comprise a deterministic lateral displacement (DLD) array. The DLD array may be configured to cause concentration of DNA molecules having a radius of gyration greater than a first (e.g., critical) radius from a solution of DNA molecules comprising an amount of DNA condensation agent. The embodiment may use electric fields to move DNA molecules through the DLD arrays at an electrophoretic mobility. Electrophoretic fields may be continuous [for some embodiments, see, e.g., 26], or alternating in direction and duration as in pulsed field electrophoresis [for some ebodiments, see, e.g., 9]. The electrophoretic mobility and amount of DNA condensation agent are configured so as to cause the DNA molecules to remain in an approximately spherical conformation.
In some embodiments, a system for concentrating DNA in a microfluidic environment is provided, and may comprise a deterministic lateral displacement (DLD) array having a critical diameter for bumping within the range of about 0.2 to about 3 microns (for example).
In some embodiments, the fluid flow velocity ranges from about 1 μm/s to about 1000 μm/s.
As noted above, in some embodiments, a DNA condensation agent is added to a solution of DNA molecules, which may be (e.g.) polyethylene glycol polymers (PEG). The presence of PEG molecules reduces the intrinsic radius of gyration of the DNA molecules, resulting in segments of DNA overlaping at an intersection to reduce the total volume of depletion zones (an excluded volume between DNA and PEG), which the PEG molecule cannot occupy due to the exclusion interaction between DNA and PEG molecule. This results in an increase of the shear modulus of DNA in microfluidic structures (e.g., in some embodiments, the increase may be up to about 104).
Using such methodology to control DNA conformation, DNA can then be flowed through a microfluidic device for certain purposes (such as sorting and/or concentrating). For example, the microfluidic device may comprise a deterministic lateral displacement (DLD) array, which enables the DNA to be concentrated and isolated.
Polymer dynamics studies begin by assuming a simple random walk in three-dimensional space with Kuhn step size κ equal to twice the persistence length Lp, and also include with respect to embodiments of the present disclosure (e.g., for statistical analysis) two physical constraints: (1) the (sequence dependent [8]) molecular Young's modulus Yi contribution to the persistence length; and (2) the influence of self-avoidance which must be included in the statistical analysis. These physical constraints make the problem of truly understanding the dynamics of the polymer under shear a formidable problem.
Accordingly, the connection between the Lp and the intrinsic (molecular) Young's modulus Yi is given by:
where IA is the surface moment of inertia of the polymer. That is, the intrinsic bending rigidity Yi of the polymer is folded into the thermodynamic parameter κ=2Lp which is not changed in the process of dsDNA compaction to first order in the distortion of the dsDNA molecular structure for the deformations discussed here [24].
In some embodiments, self-avoidance appears as a modification of the simple expected dependence L1/2 of the radius of gyration Rg of the dsDNA, where L is the total length of the polymer. Self-avoidance can be viewed in a mean-field approach as due to a repulsive interaction between segments of length κ caused by the interaction of irreducible excluded volume vex of each segment. In a mean field approximation [20] the local density of links ρ in a space of dimension d for a polymer of radius of gyration Rg is:
Since the excluded volume interaction energy Eex≈kBTvexNρ and the entropic energy due to expansion Een≈kBTRg2/Nκ2, the total free energy Gf=Eex+Een is:
Minimization of Eq. 3 with respect to Rg then yields that within the confines of Flory theory for self-avoidance in d=3 dimensions the radius of gyration (Rg) is:
As discussed below, a 166 kbp T4 dsDNA molecule of length L≈56 μm includes a persistence length Lp of about 50 nm [24], and the measured average radius of gyration Rg (also discussed below) is about 1.4 μm. From Eq. 4, this yields vex≈3.1×103 nm3.
Depletion forces occur when the DNA solution also contains solutes that are much larger than the solvent molecules. To that end, in some embodiments, a small flexible polymer (in some embodiments, PEG) is added to a solution containing dsDNA in order to reduce the radius of gyration of the DNA molecule. The radius of gyration is a measure for the characterization of the time-averaged configuration of a polymer, which measures the root-mean-square distance of the collection of segments from the common center of mass of the segments. In such embodiments, the volume around each DNA molecule includes additional regions of excluded volume where the DNA molecule and PEG molecules are in close proximity, which may be referred to as a depletion zones. Other PEG molecules cannot occupy these zones due to the exclusion interaction between DNA and the closely apposed PEG molecules. The overlap of two segments of DNA (at an intersection) reduces the total volume of the depletion zones around the DNA molecule, thereby increasing the volume accessible to PEG molecule (see
Although the “radius of gyration” is a convenient term when defining the principles of some of the embodiments of the present disclosure, the “effective” size that the DNA exhibits in microfluidic devices is only approximated by the calculated radius of gyration. In some embodiments, the exact relationship between the size of the DNA and radius of gyration is estimated using the approximation that the DNA molecules are hard spherical particles. Nevertheless, as shown below, under some conditions the two values appear to scale together, and therefore, the concept of radius of gyration is useful for describing the principles of the invention.
There is a minimum radius of gyration Rg which can be reached by depletion forces, since the persistence length Lp is not changed by the compaction process caused by the depletion forces. The total excluded Vex volume is then:
V
ex
=N×v
ex (5)
It can be assumed if this volume represents the smallest possible volume that the polymer can have at temperature T even at very high concentrations of PEG, then a minimum radius of gyration Rg,m is:
From the value for vex from Eq. 4, the minimum radius of gyration Rg,m can be computed from Eq. 6. For the T4 dsDNA molecule, the expected Rg,m≈75 nm, a factor of approximately 20 from the aqueous value and about twice the radius of the T4 capsid head [17].
Considering the entropic elasticity of polymer chains, the collective shear modulus Gc of the dsDNA network is roughly estimated as [20]:
where n* (in the range of 1 to N) is the number of effective strands. As the PEG volume fraction increases, more overlap regions are generated (as well as the DNA strands in between these regions), which leads to an increase of n*.
At zero PEG concentration, no DNA network is formed, n*=1, which yields Gc,o≈3.6×10−4 Pa (confirmed for small displacement using optical tweezer [24]). In the case of maximum compaction, n*=N, Gc,max≈kBT/vex is independent of L since it essentially represents an incompressible core of a compacted polymer, due to the physical constraints of self-avoidance and the elastic energy stored in the persistence length. For the T4 dsDNA molecules discussed below, the maximum value of the shear modulus Gc may be about 1.3×103 Pa.
Some embodiments of the present disclosure which use depletion force to hold dsDNA molecules in a relatively non-deformable, spherical conformation enable the use of, for example, rapid, scalable continuous flow methods for DNA manipulation [18, 21]. According to some embodiments, a DNA concentrator is provided which utilizes one or more DLD arrays to concentrate genomic length dsDNA molecules.
In such DLD arrays, particles smaller than a critical size Dc follow a laminar flow direction, weaving through array in a “zigzag” trajectory, while particles larger than the critical size are displaced laterally in the array (i.e., by posts at each column), following a migration angle ε in a bumping trajectory [5, 10, 11, 16, 14, 15].
The spherical DNA conformation (produced according to some embodiments) is not deformed upon meeting the posts; instead, the polymer is pushed into adjacent stream lines. Otherwise, if the dsDNA is elongated, it follows the laminar flow direction in a zigzag trajectory (since its short axis length is below the critical size). Deformation of the polymer from the desired spherical shape may occur when the shear strain γ≈1. Thus, in some useful embodiments, the shear stress τ should not exceed Gc in the device. Since the hydrodynamic shear stress
(where μ is the viscosity of solvent which depends on the PEG volume fraction [7]), the transverse velocity gradients
that can be tolerated:
EXAMPLE: DNA sample preparation (according to some embodiments). Phage T4 dsDNA (strain GT7, Wako) was equilibrated with YOYO1 (Life Technologies) at 50° C. for 1 hour under the following conditions: 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 1 mM EDTA, 0.5 M NaCl, 1 ng/L T4 dsDNA, 0.15 M YOYO1, 10 mM DTT (the ratio of YOYO1/DNA bp=1/10). Following equilibration, the YOYO1-labeled DNA was cooled to room temperature and diluted 100-fold with a buffer containing 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 1 mM EDTA, 10 mM DTT, and from 0 to 20% (w/v) PEG (Dow Carbowax Polyethylene Glycol 8000, average molecular weight 6000-9000) as indicated. The DNA solutions were stored at 4° C. in opaque plastic bottles until used. All solutions (except for those containing DNA) were filtered through 0.45 nm filters.
Further, the relationship between flow rate, PEG concentration, shear strain, and DNA conformation may be determined by analyzing video micrographs of T4 DNA molecules traversing DLD arrays and classifying the conformation of the DNA molecules according to the following convention. If the length is larger than about four times the radius of gyration Rg (≈6 μm, the shear strain γ>1), DNA molecules are classified as elongated; otherwise they are classified as spherical.
The results are shown in
As shown in
in the microfluidic arrays can be written as:
where d=1.7 μm is the minimum gap of this microfluidic structure. The collective shear modulus can be obtained from Eq. 8 and plotted in
A collection of data marking bumping and zig-zag 166 kbp T4 dsDNA as a function of PEG volume fraction and flow velocity is also shown in
The black dash line shown on
It should be pointed out that, in some embodiments, the effective size of the DNA for determining its behavior in the DLD array (that is, whether it bumps or not) may scale as the radius of gyration. Accordingly, for some embodiments, an important principle is that in the presence of condensing agents such as PEG, the effective size of the DNA as it moves through the DLD array doesn't decrease dramatically when the microfluidic flow velocity increases.
Thus, according to some embodiments of the present disclosure, dsDNA conformation can be controlled by molecular crowding induced depletion force via adjusting the shear modulus of DNA in microfluidic structures through the addition of PEG in determined amounts. This results in a simplified model and an increase in shear modulus of about 104. In some embodiments, by controlling DNA conformation, DNA can be concentrated and isolated using DLD arrays in hydrodynamic fluid flow with higher separation rate and resolution than in current preparative electrophoresis methods.
Also, various inventive concepts may be embodied as one or more methods and systems of which examples have been provided herein. The acts performed as part of the method may be ordered in any suitable way. Accordingly, embodiments may be constructed in which acts are performed in an order different than illustrated, which may include performing some acts simultaneously, even though shown as sequential acts in illustrative embodiments.
Any and all references to publications or other documents, including but not limited to, patents, patent applications, articles, webpages, books, etc., presented anywhere in the present application, are herein incorporated by reference in their entirety.
Although a few variations have been described in detail above, other modifications are possible. For example, any logic flows depicted in the accompanying figures and/or described herein do not require the particular order shown, or sequential order, to achieve desirable results. Other implementations may be within the scope of at least some of the following exemplary claims.
As noted elsewhere, these embodiments have been described for illustrative purposes only and are not limiting. Other embodiments are possible and are covered by the disclosure, which will be apparent from the teachings contained herein. Thus, the breadth and scope of the disclosure should not be limited by any of the above-described embodiments but should be defined only in accordance with claims supported by the present disclosure and their equivalents. Moreover, embodiments of the subject disclosure may include methods, systems and apparatuses/devices which may further include any and all elements from any other disclosed methods, systems, and devices, including any and all elements corresponding to binding event determinative systems, devices and methods. In other words, elements from one or another disclosed embodiments may be interchangeable with elements from other disclosed embodiments. In addition, one or more features/elements of disclosed embodiments may be removed and still result in patentable subject matter (and thus, resulting in yet more embodiments of the subject disclosure). Also, some embodiments correspond to systems, devices and methods which specifically lack one and/or another element, structure, and/or steps (as applicable), as compared to teachings of the prior art, and therefore represent patentable subject matter and are distinguishable therefrom (i.e. claims directed to such embodiments may contain negative limitations to note the lack of one or more features prior art teachings).
All definitions, as defined and used herein, should be understood to control over dictionary definitions, definitions in documents incorporated by reference, and/or ordinary meanings of the defined terms.
This application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 62/064,890, filed Oct. 16, 2014, and entitled “Methods and Systems for Controlling the Shear Modulus of Genomic Length dsDNA Molecules,” the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
This invention was made with government support under Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) Grant No. 143HG006818-01 awarded by the National Institutes of Health. The government has certain rights in the invention.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US15/56104 | 10/16/2015 | WO | 00 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62064890 | Oct 2014 | US |