Embodiments relate to reservoir evaluation. More specifically, example embodiments relate to methods and systems for determining bulk density, porosity, and pore size distribution of subsurface formations. These methods and systems utilize a combination of (Nuclear Magnetic Resonance) NMR and gravimetric techniques.
Bulk density is one of the most important parameters in reservoir evaluation. It is widely used for estimation of reserves of hydrocarbons in reservoirs. Traditionally, well logs and core measurements are the two approaches to obtain key petrophysical parameters for reservoir evaluation and description. These measurements are expensive and many times they require extra rig time, which is also very expensive.
For example, bulk density can be measured in real time with logging while drilling (LWD) density log or can be measured using wireline (WL) density log. Both use a gamma ray source and measure the attenuated gamma ray coming to the detector after interacting with the formation. Generally speaking, the LWD density measurement represents the bulk density of the rock with the formation fluids in the pore space, whereas the WL density measures the bulk density of the rock with invaded fluids; for low permeable unconventional rocks, the difference should be minimal. Bulk density can be precisely measured using core plugs when they are available.
Obtaining accurate petrophysical parameters from drill cuttings is beneficial and desirable for at least two reasons. First, drill cuttings are readily available from any drilled well and thus does not add extra rig time or extra cost to the operation. Second, measurement can be done at the wellsite and offers data for real-time operational decisions, such as drilling and the succeeding hydraulic fracturing.
However, it is a challenge to measure the volume of the cutting accurately as it is hard to remove the fluid on the surface of the cutting. The traditional sample preparation method uses a damp paper towel to remove the excess fluid from the surface, and due to the irregular shape of the surface features, the validity of the total removal of the surface fluid is always questionable. Moreover, if the paper towel is too dry, the fluid within the cutting sample can be lost due to capillary force.
Example embodiments disclosed herein relate to improved methods and systems for determining bulk density, porosity, and pore size distribution of subsurface formations.
One example embodiment is a method for determining matrix or grain density of a subsurface formation. The method includes measuring an in-air mass of a fluid-saturated sample of the subsurface formation, wherein the in-air mass includes mass of the matrix or grains of the sample, mass of a fluid surrounding the sample, and mass of the fluid inside the sample. The in-air mass of the fluid-saturated sample, ms, may be given by the formula
ms=Vmρm+(Vϕ+Vsur)ρl
where ρm is a density of the matrix of the subsurface formation, ρl is a density of the fluid inside and surrounding the sample, Vm is a volume of the matrix, Vϕ is a volume of the fluid inside the sample, and Vsur is a volume of the fluid surrounding the sample. The method also includes separately determining the volume of the fluid inside the sample, Vϕ, and the volume of the fluid surrounding the sample, Vsur, using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The method may further include placing the sample in a predetermined volume of a weighing fluid, and measuring mass of the fluid-saturated sample in the weighing fluid. The mass of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid in the weighing fluid, mf, may be given by the formula
mf=Vmρm+Vϕρm−Vcρf
where ρf is the density of the weighing fluid. The method may further include determining a volume of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, Vc, using the formula
Vc=(ms−mf−Vsurρl)/ρf.
The method may also include determining a bulk density of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, ρb, using the formula
The method may further include determining the volume of the matrix, Vm, using the formula
Vm=(ms−mf−Vsurρf)/ρf−Vϕ.
The method may also include determining the matrix or grain density of the subsurface formation, ρm, using the formula
Another example embodiment relates to computer programs stored in computer readable media. The non-transitory computer-readable media may have, for example, computer executable instructions that trigger the computer to perform the operation of receiving in-air mass of a fluid-saturated sample of the subsurface formation, wherein the in-air mass includes mass of the matrix or grains of the sample, mass of a fluid surrounding the sample, and mass of the fluid inside the sample. The in-air mass of the fluid-saturated sample, ms, may be given by the formula
ms=Vϕρm+(Vϕ+Vsur)ρl
where ρm is a density of the matrix of the subsurface formation, ρl is a density of the fluid inside and surrounding the sample, Vm is a volume of the matrix, Vϕ is a volume of the fluid inside the sample, and Vsur is a volume of the fluid surrounding the sample. The computer executable instructions may also trigger the computer to determine the volume of the fluid inside the sample, Vϕ, and volume of the fluid surrounding the sample, Vsur, from NMR measurements. The computer executable instructions may also trigger the computer to receive the mass of the fluid-saturated sample in a weighing fluid. The mass of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid in the weighing fluid, mf, may be given by the formula
mf=Vmρm+Vϕρl−Vcρf
where ρf is the density of the weighing fluid. The computer executable instructions may also trigger the computer to calculate a volume of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, Vc, using the formula
Vc=(ms−mf−Vsurρl)/ρf.
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to calculate a bulk density of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, ρb, using the formula
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to calculate the volume of the matrix, Vm, using the formula
Vm=(ms−mf−Vsurρf)/ρf−Vϕ.
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to calculate the matrix or grain density of the subsurface formation, ρm, using the formula
Another example embodiment is a system for determining matrix or grain density of a subsurface formation. The system may include a fluid-saturated sample of the subsurface formation, and a weighing balance, which may be configured to receive the fluid-saturated sample and output the in-air mass and in-fluid mass of the sample. The system may also include a computer having one or more processors and a non-transitory computer readable medium, which may include computer executable instructions that when executed by the one or more processors, trigger the computer to fetch in-air mass of the fluid-saturated sample of the subsurface formation from the weighing scale. The in-air mass may include mass of the matrix or grains of the sample, mass of a fluid surrounding the sample, and mass of the fluid inside the sample. The in-air mass of the fluid-saturated sample, ms, may be given by the formula
ms=Vmρm+(Vϕ+Vsur)ρl
where ρm is a density of the matrix of the subsurface formation, ρl is a density of the fluid inside and surrounding the sample, Vm is a volume of the matrix, Vϕ is a volume of the fluid inside the sample, and Vsur is a volume of the fluid surrounding the sample. The system may also include an NMR, which may be operably connected to the computer and configured to determine the volume of the fluid inside the sample, Vϕ, and volume of the fluid surrounding the sample, Vsur, using NMR. The computer may be configured to receive the volume of the fluid inside the sample, Vϕ, and volume of the fluid surrounding the sample, Vsur, from the NMR, and the mass of the fluid-saturated sample in a weighing fluid from the weighing scale. The mass of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid in the weighing fluid, mf, may be given by the formula
mf=Vmρm+Vϕρl−Vcρf
where ρf is the density of the weighing fluid. The computer executable instructions may also trigger the computer to determine a volume of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, Vc, using the formula
Vc=(ms−mf−Vsurρl)/ρf.
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to determine a bulk density of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, ρb, using the formula
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to determine the volume of the matrix, Vm, using the formula
Vm=(ms−mf−Vsurρf)/ρf−Vϕ.
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to determine the matrix or grain density of the subsurface formation, ρm, using the formula
Example embodiments disclosed propose a method to measure and analyze drill cuttings using a combination of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) measurements and mass measurements in-air and in-fluid to obtain multiple key petrophysical parameters accurately with little sample preparation. Example embodiments present a new and accurate method to measure the bulk density using saturated drill cuttings, which are readily available for any drilled hydrocarbon well. The method combines NMR and gravimetric techniques, and the results include bulk density, grain density, porosity, and pore-size distribution of the drill cuttings.
Turning now to the figures,
Additionally, the collected cuttings may be washed using sufficient fluid such that it minimizes the impact of small particles from drilling mud that stick to the cutting surface or in the surrounding fluid which can impact both mass measurements and NMR measurements. Washing may also benefit other subsequent measurements, such as gamma-ray measurement, on the drill cuttings because the effect of the small particles on the gamma ray measurements can be significant.
The figure on the left in
The next step of the method is to measure the in-air mass of the collected drill cutting 10.
ms=Vmρm+(Vϕ+Vsur)ρl
where ρm is a density of the matrix of the subsurface formation, ρl is a density of the fluid inside and surrounding the sample, Vm is a volume of the matrix, Vϕ is a volume of the fluid inside the sample, and Vsur is a volume of the fluid surrounding the sample.
The next step is to separately determine volume of the fluid inside the sample, Vϕ, and volume of the fluid surrounding the sample, Vsur, using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). To clearly separate the NMR signals for liquid inside and surrounding the cuttings, a sufficient amount of surrounding fluid may be used one time or in a step-wise fashion. Due to the clay sensitivity issues, many wells in unconventional plays are drilled using oil based mud (OBM). The example embodiments disclosed propose a new method to separate the NMR signal of the fluid on the cuttings surfaces and the fluids from the interior pores of the cutting samples based on two assumptions: (1) fluids inside the shale cuttings have short relaxation time, and (2) fluid from OBM has a longer T2, even in the presence of cuttings.
A series of NMR experiments with cuttings demonstrate that the mode position of the T2 signal of the OBM outside the cuttings does move to longer relaxation times as more fluid is gradually added (
No additional fluid is added in this variation of the method. A cut off 51 is selected from the incremental T2 distribution line (a vertical dotted line drawn at the trough on the incremental curve in
In case where excess fluid is present a plot can be graphed as seen in
The next step is to measure the sample mass in a weighing fluid.
The mass of the sample in the weighing fluid, mf, may be given by the formula
mf=Vmρm+Vϕρl−Vcρf
where ρf is the density of the weighing fluid. From the combination of two mass measurements and NMR measurement, multiple key parameters can be obtained as outlined in the following sections for reservoir characterization. These parameters include porosity, cutting total volume, bulk density, and matrix/grain density. For example, the method may further include determining a volume of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, Vc, using the formula
Vc=(ms−mf−Vsurρl)/ρf.
In the next step, the method may also include determining a bulk density of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, ρb, using the formula
In the next step, the method may further include determining the volume of the matrix, Vm, using the formula
Vm=(ms−mf−Vsurρf)/ρf−Vϕ.
As a last step, the method may include determining the matrix or grain density of the subsurface formation, ρm, using the formula
These measurements can be performed on the cutting samples along the entirety of the drilled well and, thus, data can be obtained to evaluate the heterogeneity of the vertical or horizontal wells. This could potentially be used in real time to optimize the number and placement of frac stages for unconventional reservoirs.
Here, the contribution of the sample support device (12 in
ms=Vmρm+(Vϕ+Vsur)ρl
where ρm is a density of the matrix of the subsurface formation, ρl is a density of the fluid inside and surrounding the sample, Vm is a volume of the matrix, Vϕ is a volume of the fluid inside the sample, and Vsur is a volume of the fluid surrounding the sample. The method also includes separately determining volume of the fluid inside the sample, Vϕ, and volume of the fluid surrounding the sample, Vsur, using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), at step 104. The method may further include placing the sample in a predetermined volume of a weighing fluid at step 106, and measuring the mass of the fluid-saturated sample in the weighing fluid, at step 108. The mass of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid in the weighing fluid, mf, may be given by the formula
mf=Vmρm+Vϕρl−Vcρf
where ρf is the density of the weighing fluid. At step 110, the method may further include determining a volume of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, Vc, using the formula
Vc=(ms−mf−Vsurρl)/ρf.
The method may also include determining a bulk density of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, ρb, using the formula
At step 112, the method may further include determining the volume of the matrix, Vm, using the formula
Vm=(ms−mf−Vsurρf)/ρf−Vϕ.
Finally, at step 114, the method may include determining the matrix or grain density of the subsurface formation, ρm, using the formula
Computer Readable Medium
Another example embodiment relates to computer programs stored in computer readable media. Referring to
ms=Vmρm+(Vϕ+Vsur)ρl
where ρm is a density of the matrix of the subsurface formation, ρl is a density of the fluid inside and surrounding the sample, Vm is a volume of the matrix, Vϕ is a volume of the fluid inside the sample, and Vsur is a volume of the fluid surrounding the sample. The computer executable instructions may also trigger the computer to determine volume of the fluid inside the sample, Vϕ, and volume of the fluid surrounding the sample, Vsur, using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The computer executable instructions may also trigger the computer to receive mass of the fluid-saturated sample in a weighing fluid. The mass of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid in the weighing fluid, mf, may be given by the formula
mf=Vmρm+Vϕρl−Vcρf
where ρf is the density of the weighing fluid. The computer executable instructions may also trigger the computer to determine a volume of the sample without the surrounding fluid, Vc, using the formula
Vc=(ms−mf−Vsurρl)/ρf.
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to determine a bulk density of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, ρb, using the formula
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to determine the volume of the matrix, Vm, using the formula
Vm=(ms−mf−Vsurρf)/ρf−Vϕ.
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to determine the matrix or grain density of the subsurface formation, ρm, using the formula
Example System
Another example embodiment is a system 1200 for determining matrix or grain density of a subsurface formation. The system 1200 may include a fluid-saturated sample 10 of the subsurface formation, as illustrated in
ms=Vmρm+(Vϕ+Vsur)ρl
where ρm is a density of the matrix of the subsurface formation, ρl is a density of the fluid inside and surrounding the sample, Vm is a volume of the matrix, Vϕ is a volume of the fluid inside the sample, and Vsur is a volume of the fluid surrounding the sample. The system 1200 may also include a NMR device 500, which may be operably connected to computer 200 and configured to determine the volume of the fluid inside the sample, Vϕ, and volume of the fluid surrounding the sample, Vsur, using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The computer 200 may be configured to receive the volume of the fluid inside the sample, Vϕ, and volume of the fluid surrounding the sample, Vsur, from the NMR device 500, and the mass of the fluid-saturated sample in a weighing fluid from the weighing scale 25. The mass of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid in the weighing fluid, mf, may be given by the formula
mf=Vmρm+Vϕρl−Vcρf
where ρf is the density of the weighing fluid. The computer executable instructions may also trigger the computer to determine a volume of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, Vc, using the formula
Vc=(ms−mf−Vsurρl)/ρf.
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to determine a bulk density of the fluid-saturated sample without the surrounding fluid, ρb, using the formula
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to determine the volume of the matrix, Vm, using the formula
Vm=(ms−mf−Vsurρf)/ρf−Vϕ.
The computer executable instructions may further trigger the computer to determine the matrix or grain density of the subsurface formation, ρm, using the formula
While the invention has been described with respect to a limited number of embodiments, those skilled in the art, having benefit of this disclosure, will appreciate that other embodiments can be devised which do not depart from the scope of the invention as disclosed herein. Accordingly, the scope of the invention should be limited only by the attached claims.
This application is a continuation of and claims priority to U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/673,996 filed on Aug. 10, 2017 titled “METHODS AND SYSTEMS FOR DETERMINING BULK DENSITY, POROSITY, AND PORE SIZE DISTRIBUTION OF SUBSURFACE FORMATIONS,” which is hereby incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3409092 | Doremus | Nov 1968 | A |
3494188 | Boatman | Feb 1970 | A |
4291271 | Lauffer | Sep 1981 | A |
5289124 | Jerosch-Herold et al. | Feb 1994 | A |
6453727 | Lenormand et al. | Sep 2002 | B1 |
6497139 | Locatelli | Dec 2002 | B1 |
6765380 | Freedman | Jul 2004 | B2 |
6958604 | An et al. | Oct 2005 | B2 |
7082812 | Lenormand et al. | Aug 2006 | B2 |
7131317 | Lenormand et al. | Nov 2006 | B2 |
7388373 | Lenormand et al. | Jun 2008 | B2 |
7924001 | Minh | Apr 2011 | B2 |
8686724 | Mitchell et al. | Apr 2014 | B2 |
8727145 | Zollondz et al. | May 2014 | B2 |
8857243 | Valenza, II et al. | Oct 2014 | B2 |
8967249 | Akkurt et al. | Mar 2015 | B2 |
9176251 | Singer et al. | Nov 2015 | B2 |
20030094946 | Galford et al. | May 2003 | A1 |
20060272812 | Yu et al. | Dec 2006 | A1 |
20100127701 | Wichers et al. | May 2010 | A1 |
20120065890 | Liu | Mar 2012 | A1 |
20130113480 | Viswanathan et al. | May 2013 | A1 |
20130234703 | Chen et al. | Sep 2013 | A1 |
20130259190 | Walls et al. | Oct 2013 | A1 |
20130282288 | Quinn et al. | Oct 2013 | A1 |
20140107928 | Roy et al. | Apr 2014 | A1 |
20150055675 | Dyshlyuk | Feb 2015 | A1 |
20150219782 | Kadayam Viswanathan et al. | Aug 2015 | A1 |
20150240633 | Akkurt et al. | Aug 2015 | A1 |
20160061803 | Hadj-Sassi et al. | Mar 2016 | A1 |
20160230482 | Rapoport | Aug 2016 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
103018153 | Apr 2013 | CN |
103267708 | Aug 2013 | CN |
106093299 | Nov 2016 | CN |
106990019 | Jul 2017 | CN |
2542406 | Mar 2017 | GB |
2011095170 | May 2011 | JP |
2134894 | Aug 1999 | RU |
2239180 | Oct 2004 | RU |
2411508 | Feb 2011 | RU |
2513630 | Apr 2014 | RU |
2535527 | Dec 2014 | RU |
9612976 | May 1996 | WO |
2006034072 | Mar 2006 | WO |
2011133859 | Oct 2011 | WO |
Entry |
---|
Anonymous, “Porosity”, AAPG Wiki, 2014, pp. 1-9. |
Boatman, W. A., “Measuring and Using Shale Density to Aid in Drilling W Measuring and Using Shale Density to Aid in Drilling Wells in High-pressure Areas”; American Petroleum Institute; 1967; API-67-121. |
Chen, Jonhong et al.; “Method for Measurement of Hydrocarbon Content in Shale Gas Reservoir” Research Report HRC-RET-201509-0xx, Reservoir Engineering Technology Aramco Research Centers—Houston, Sep. 15, 2015; pp. 1-17. |
Franklin, “Suggested Methods for Determining Water Content, Porosity, Density, Absorption and Related Propertie and Swelling and Slake-Durability Index Properties” International Society for Rock Mechanics, 1977, pp. 14, ISRM. |
International Search Report and Written Opinion for corresponding PCT/US2017/051527 (SA5493) dated Oct. 26, 2017; pp. 1-12. |
International Search Report and Written Opinion for related PCT application PCT/US2018/045931 (SA5712) dated Nov. 27, 2018; pp. 1-16. |
Lake, L., “Petroleum Engineering Handbook, vol. 6—Emerging and Peripheral Technologies”, Society of Petroleum Engineers, Chapter 7, pp. 295-353. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20190331825 A1 | Oct 2019 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 15673996 | Aug 2017 | US |
Child | 16508944 | US |