Patent Application
20060134342
This invention provides methods for increasing the strength of wood. The invention also provides novel break resistant wooden articles of manufacture.
As supplies of old growth timber are depleted world wide, increased emphasis on new rapid growing sources of wood has developed. One major concern with new growth wood, especially certain rapid growth hybrids is the lack of strength in the new growth woods compared to the strength of old growth woods. Numerous agents have been reported to increase the strength of treated wood, for example, U.S. Pat. No. 6,686,056 teaches improved strength in wood imparted by drying oils. A trade secret material of unknown composition was marketed in the United States from shortly after the First World War until the late 1950s under the trade names Vaccinol or Seasonal. This product claimed to increase the strength of treated wood.
Among the various agents that can impart strength to wood are materials that impregnate the wood and crosslink its internal structural elements to increase the cohesion of the wood fibers to each other. These materials include polymer forming reagents such as siloxanes, silanes and methylsilioxanes.
In the prior art these materials have been applied to various aspects of wood treatment including dimensional stabilization and moisture control. One approach focuses on surface coatings such as paints stains, varnishes and sealants. These methods treat the surface of the material to be protected but do not fully penetrate the wood. Whenever the coating is broken or flawed the protective effect is decreased. Since the protection is localized on the surface, it is subject to weathering and as the coating is broken down, for example by mechanical abrasion or ultraviolet radiation damage, the protection is gradually lost. Typical examples of this group are U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,413,867; 5,354,832; 5,085,695; 4,913,972, and references cited therein. These patents teach the use of organosilanes and organosilicates for the preparation of coating materials, but do not focus on the goal of the present invention, modification of the internal structure of the wood to exclude moisture.
Modification of wood by treatment with siloxanes is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,652,026 and references cited therein. This approach focuses on altering wood to increase its fire resistance and only incidentally mention the additional benefits of increased dimensional stability derived from excluding water from the cellulose fiber structure. The methylsiloxanes disclosed require the presence of a boron or phosphorus function, while the references cited therein focused on formation of inorganic complexes with metal alkoxides within the wood cells. None of the references recognized that changing the surface activity of cellulose or lignocellulose structures with simple carbon substituted siloxanes would produce the beneficial results sought while avoiding the use of potentially toxic materials such as the metal salts, phosphorus and boron compounds.
Another use of siloxane reagents to modify wood or cellulose materials is found in U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,204,186 and 5,120,581. These patents teach a very broad group of compounds useful as fire retardants. These patents also note the additional benefits derived by moisture reduction in the treated materials. The silioxane materials disclosed require either at least a group in each molecule that contains a halogen, or a group having a silicon bond that requires less than 72 kcal/mole to break. Neither of these requirements is present in the compounds of the present invention.
U.S. Pat. No. 6,303,234 involves a process of imparting fire retardant properties to a cellulosic material comprising coating a cellulosic material with sodium silicate by contacting a sodium silicate solution with the material to be coated, dehydrating the coating, and depositing a coating of a silicon oxide glassy film on the sodium silicate coated material. In one embodiment, the coating of silicon oxide is a monomolecular layer of silicon monoxide. The “water glass” or liquid sodium silicate is a salt of silicic acid, and while it may include polysilicates is quite different from the siloxane polymers of the present invention.
No art was found that teaches altering the internal structures of wood to increase the strength of the wood by contacting the wood with a siloxane polymer optionally diluted with a hydrocarbon solvent carrier, and optionally a naturally occurring oil. A method and composition to practice the novel treatment are described below, and produce novel articles of manufacture are set out below.
The invention provides a method for increasing strength in wood that comprises contacting with the wood to be treated with a copolymer of silicone units having the general formula: (MaDbTcQd)x where M is R3SiO1/2—; D is R2SiO—; T is RSiO3/2—; Q is Si(O1/2)4—; R is a generalized organic radical selected from: linear or branched hydrocarbon radicals of 1-8 carbons containing 0-1 degree of unsaturation, or phenyl, or trifluoropropyl radicals; a, b, c, d are real numbers and further provided the ratio of a/(c+d) is between 0 and 4; the ratio of b to the rest is not subject to limitation provided the final base viscosity is between 50-3500 cSt; and at least one R group of each molecule must be a hydrolysable group; and maintaining the contact for a time sufficient to establish a change in the wood which is reflected in an increase in at least one measurable parameter reflecting an increase in the strength of the wood over an untreated wood from the same lot. Preferably the method further comprises mixing a cross-linking agent with the copolymer that comprises a siloxane polymer of the general formula: (MaDbTcQd)x meeting the following parameters apply: the ratio of a/(c+d) is between 0 and 4; the ratio of b to the rest is not subject to limitation provided the final cross-linking agent viscosity is below 350 cSt; and R is a generalized organic radical selected from: linear or branched hydrocarbon radicals of 1-8 carbons containing 0-1 degree of unsaturation, or phenyl, or trifluoropropyl radicals and at least one R group of each molecule must be a hydrolysable. It is also preferred to provide a crosslinking catalyst mixed with the copolymer. Any crosslinking catalyst known in the art may be used however preferred catalysts are tetraalkyl titanates or tetraalkyl zirconates where the alkyl groups may be the same or different. This mode of treatment provides a surface treatment and in some woods permeation of the wood is possible with some undiluted polymers; however, it is generally preferred to dilute the polymer with a solvent. While an aqueous solvent or even high pressure steam might be used, hydrocarbon solvents are preferred.
Because the viscosity of the copolymer may decrease or prevent penetration to the interior of the wood, it is desirable to dilute the copolymer with a hydrocarbon solvent. Use of a hydrocarbon solvent also decreases the rate of undesirable side reactions such as gel formation. Although any hydrocarbon solvent that carries the copolymer into cellulose fiber structures, such as wood, may be used the preferred solvents are aliphatic solvents composed primarily of C7-C16 paraffinic, cycloparaffinic and isoparaffinic hydrocarbons containing less than about 0.5% aromatic hydrocarbons. More preferably, the aliphatic solvent is composed primarily of C9-C14, paraffinic, cycloparaffinic and isoparaffinic hydrocarbons and of those range of C10-C13 is preferred. The current most preferred solvent is Conosol 145 marketed by Penreco, Inc, of Houston, Tex. Optionally additional benefits maybe obtained by adding to the treatment mixture a natural product oil selected from the group consisting of almond bitter oil, anise oil, basil oil, bay oil, caraway oil, cardamom oil, cedar oil, celery oil, chamomile oil, cinnamon oil, citronella oil, clove oil, coriander oil, cumin oil, dill oil, eucalyptus oil, fennel oil, ginger oil, grapefruit oil, lemon oil, lime oil, mint oil, parsley oil, peppermint oil, pepper oil, rose oil, spearmint oil (menthol), sweet orange oil, thyme oil, turmeric oil, oil of wintergreen, juniper oil, tall oil, pine oil; a synthetic natural product oil mimic that comprises at least one synthetically produced or isolated chemical identified as a component of a natural product oil elected from the group consisting of almond bitter oil, anise oil, basil oil, bay oil, caraway oil, cardamom oil, cedar oil, celery oil, chamomile oil, cinnamon oil, citronella oil, clove oil, coriander oil, cumin oil, dill oil, eucalyptus oil, fennel oil, ginger oil, grapefruit oil, lemon oil, lime oil, mint oil, parsley oil, peppermint oil, pepper oil, rose oil, spearmint oil (menthol), sweet orange oil, thyme oil, turmeric oil, oil of wintergreen, juniper oil, tall oil, pine oil. Preferred oils are cedar oil, cinnamon oil, citronella oil, clove oil, eucalyptus oil, juniper oil, tall oil, and pine oil. The most preferred oil is cedar oil.
In the copolymer the R groups may be the same or different and each is a lower alkyl group preferably of no more that four carbons. Especially preferred are those copolymers wherein all non-terminal copolymer R groups are methyl. In the preferred cross-linking agent each has an R group in an alkoxy group that is an alkyl group comprising from 1 to 4 carbon atoms. Especially preferred cross-linking agents further comprise methyl groups at each non-alkoxy position.
The invention also provides novel articles of manufacture comprising wood processed according to the various embodiments summarized above. Treatment according to the methods of the invention generates polymers within the structural matrix of the wood which increase the strength of the wood by increased cohesion of the wood fibers to each other.
General Description of the Invention
In order to understand the invention at its most basic level it is importation to understand the basic properties of wood. According to a standard text, “Construction: Principles, Materials, and Methods” by Simmons, H. Leslie.; Olin, Harold Bennett, New York, N.Y., John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (US), 2001, Chapter 6 page 366 et seq., {Cited below as Simmons et al.} (Captions deleted from quotation. “ . . . ” indicates deletions other than captions and [ ] indicates insertions or change in case), “ . . . [w]ood cells, or fibers, are primarily cellulose cemented together with lignin. The wood structure is about 70% cellulose, between 12% and 28% lignin, and up to 1% ash-forming materials. These constituents give wood its hygroscopic properties, its susceptibility to decay, and its strength. The bond between individual fibers is so strong that when tested in tension they commonly tear apart rather than separate. The rest of wood, although not part of its structure, consists of extractives that give different species distinctive characteristics such as color, odor, and natural resistance to decay.
It is possible to dissolve the lignin in wood chips using chemicals, thus freeing the cellulose fibers. By further processing, these fibers can then be turned into a pulp from which paper and paperboard products are made. It is also possible to chemically convert cellulose so that it may be used to make textiles (such as rayon), plastics, and other products that depend on cellulose derivatives.”
Just as it is possible to dissolve the lignin in wood chips and release the wood fibers it is also possible to add to the cohesion of the wood fibers by adding polymeric materials to the internal structure of the wood and strengthens the wood as a result. The treatment of the present invention results in increased strength for new growth lumber, making it a useful replacement of old growth materials.
A copolymer solution suitable for treating wooden materials according the invention is prepared by slowly adding 20 parts of a silicone polymer obtained from GT Products, Inc. of Grapevine, Tex. designated X5814 to 80 parts of Conosol 145. When the addition is complete, 4 foot sections cut from building grade 8 foot pine 2×4s are immersed in a tank of circulating solution for one hour and dried to constant weight. The untreated 4 ft section of each 2×4 was market and used as a control in subsequent tests.
Randomly selected treated and the matching untreated 2×4s are split and the interior portions of the split wood was sprayed with water. The treated wood showed water beading even in the center of the material while all surfaces of the untreated portions were readily wet, showing complete penetration of the copolymer to the interior of the wood.
Insect Protection and Interior Penetration
A solution containing 80 parts Conosol 145, 15 parts X5814 and 5 parts Cedar Oil available from CedarCide, Inc. of Spring, Tex. was prepared as described in example 2. When the matched 2×4s were split the beading of water sprayed on the interior surfaces demonstrated penetration of the copolymer to all portions of the wood.
When filter papers composed of cellulose fibers were treated with the mixture and tested against untreated controls, worker termites readily feed on the untreated paper but no feeding was observed on the treated papers.
Strength Increase
Substantially equivalent nominal 8 feet Pine 2×4s were purchased from a retail chain home improvement center in the Houston, Tex. metropolitan area. Randomly selected boards were cut into two 4 foot sections and marked, one section was retained as a control and the other was treated according to the invention by immersion in a composition of 80% Conosol 145, 15% X5814, and 5% cedar wood oil for one hour, and then being permitted to air dry for several days.
The 4 foot section boards were then tested to breaking for strength retention in static bending. The test pieces were supported at the ends and a hydraulic jack with a gauge indicated the applied pressure was applied at the center until the test piece broke. Two separate sample sets of short leaf southern pine were tested. The pressure was applied to the center of the span on the 4 inch width, toward the 2 inch dimension. Sample 1 untreated failed at 400 pounds applied pressure after bending 2.25 in, and broke cleanly in to two separate pieces. Sample 1 treated failed at 900 pounds after bending 1.25 in. and the break was with long shards, with many bent shards remaining attached. Sample 2 untreated failed at 600 pounds with a 1.25 in bend, and again broke cleanly. Sample 2 treated failed at 2000 pounds, and again splintered rather than breaking cleanly. Examination of the broken, treated samples showed that the treatment was distributed through out the piece with no evidence of untreated areas.
Hygroscopic Behavior
Two samples of 22.5 mm×89 mm (1 in. by 4 in.) southern short leaf pine were dried to constant weight by heating in an oven at 110 deg. C. and weighing daily until no weight change was observed. One sample of the wood was then treated as described above, dried for several days and then placed in a chamber maintained at 100% humidity. The samples were weighed daily and the weights in grams are reported in table 1 below.
As shown above the treated sample did not gain weight by absorbing moisture from the atmosphere, while the untreated control showed the typical hygroscopic behavior of wood.
