This application claims Paris Convention priority to EP 09 164 545.7 filed Jul. 3, 2009 the entire disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference.
The invention concerns a method for nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) measurements, comprising the steps:
A method as described above is known from reference 3.
The limited sensitivity of magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) experiments may be considerably improved by coupling the nuclear spins to energy states affording a larger polarisation such as those of electron spins, whereby “polarisation” is used as synonym for “longitudinal magnetisation”. Nuclear hyperpolarisation using the nucleus-electron spin-spin coupling may be achieved in two ways: (i) in-situ DNP experiments for polarisation enhancement in the magnet where signal detection is performed. These experiments can be performed repetitively at short time intervals in solid samples using gyrotrons1 or in liquid samples2 by relying on the Overhauser effect; (ii) ex-situ experiments, such as dissolution DNP3, where the polarisation of electron spins is transferred to nuclei in a polarising magnet prior to NMR one-shot detection in a high-resolution magnet. This approach can yield enhancements of up to four orders of magnitude, but since it takes a long time to build up the enhanced polarisation at temperatures of ca. 1.2 K, one can typically only perform a few experiments per day. The intrinsically short lifetimes of hyperpolarised polarisation, normally determined by the longitudinal relaxation time constants T1, compel one to make use of the enhanced polarisation quickly, within intervals of the order of a few tens of seconds. Therefore, reactions or transport phenomena that occur on longer time scales cannot be followed using dissolution DNP.
The longitudinal relaxation times T1 of the populations of ordinary Zeeman states of spins I=½ are usually limited by dipole-dipole couplings and anisotropic chemical shifts, both modulated by molecular tumbling. The dipolar interaction is often the dominant source of relaxation. It has been shown by Levitt and co-workers4, 6 that this mechanism may be silenced under particular circumstances, by rendering the spins equivalent, either through the application of a suitable radio frequency (rf) irradiation, or by the removing the sample from the magnetic field. Spin order, under these conditions, may be preserved as long-lived states (LLS), which, in the simple case of a system consisting of two coupled spins ½, correspond to a difference between the populations, on the one hand, of the singlet state
and, on the other hand, of the mean population of the three triplet states
This difference can be represented by the operator:
QLLS=−N{right arrow over (I)}·{right arrow over (S)}=−N(IxSx+IySy+IzSz)=−N(IzSz+ZQx) (1)
with the norm
It has been shown5,7-12 that long-lived states, i.e., states with lifetimes that are partly immune to dipolar relaxation, can exist in systems which may comprise as many as five coupled spins. These states may be associated with sensitive proton spins in endogenous substances such as glycerol or taurine and a variety of amino acids (Gly, Asp, Asn, Cys), particularly when these belong to mobile parts of proteins. A six-fold increase in the relaxation time constant (TLLS/T1=6) has been determined for glycine residues in the C-terminus of Ubiquitin13.
Applications have been developed to exploit long-lived spin states for the study of slow diffusion13-16, exchange17, and for sustaining enhanced magnetisation10, 11, 18.
The latter application has been intensely pursued because of the high costs, both in terms of time and equipment, which are involved in obtaining nuclear hyperpolarisation. Provided the population differences can be enhanced in organic molecules, and provided this polarisation can be sustained during in vivo studies, it may be possible to use endogenous substances to follow metabolic pathways. Increasing the magnetisation lifetime in polarised molecules will also lead to better spatial and temporal resolution in magnetic resonance imaging19. Some systems can sustain LLS transferred from the polarisation of para-hydrogen10, 11. In particular, in molecules featuring chemically equivalent nuclei, spin states with relatively long lifetimes are believed to exist. Their enhanced magnetisation may be converted to detectable magnetisation using hydration reactions18.
Object of the invention is to present a method for nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) measurements that allows one to extend the time needed between hyperpolarised magnetisation and NMR detection.
This object is achieved by a method according to the independent claim.
The inventive method comprises the steps:
Until recently, longitudinal relaxation time constants (T1) were believed to set an upper time limit for the study of slow processes by NMR. It has recently been found that the magnetisation of scalar-coupled groups of spins can be converted into long-lived states (LLS) with lifetimes TLLS that can be much longer than T1. This opens a potential for preserving spin order for longer times, with demonstrated applications to store polarisation enhanced using Dynamic Nuclear Polarisation (DNP) and to study slow diffusion, flow or exchange. The methods are illustrated by preserving DNP-enhanced magnetisation associated with sensitive proton spins in an Ala-Gly dipeptide during time intervals that are almost an order of magnitude longer than their spin-lattice relaxation time constant T1. By using the inventive method small fractions of the polarisation sustained in the form of LLS can be transformed into observable single-quantum coherences for detection at desired time intervals. This opens a way to follow slow chemical reactions or slow transport by enhanced NMR or MRI.
With the inventive method LLS are excited in systems containing J-coupled spins to preserve polarisation created by hyperpolarisation and these states are converted back to detectable magnetisation. The inventive method shows that the enhanced nuclear polarisation may be stored in so-called long-lived states (LLS4, 5), whose extended life-times TLLS relax the constraint on the interval between low-temperature pre-polarisation and room-temperature NMR detection.
Preferably the nuclei of the first kind have a longitudinal relaxation time T1 which is longer than the time required for the transfer of the polarised sample in step (ii), in particular 13C or 15N. At the moment transfer requires several seconds.
In a highly preferred variant the nuclei of the second kind are protons.
In an advantageous variant of the inventive method in step (iv) LLS are sustained by irradiation of the sample with an rf-field, which is less cumbersome than sustaining LLS by taking the sample out of the magnetic field.
In a highly preferred variant in step (v) the LLS are only partially converted into detectable magnetisation, and after carrying out step (v) the remaining part of the LLS (=part of the LLS which has not yet been converted into detectable magnetisation) is sustained during the subsequent period, prior to another detection period, and steps (iv) through (vi) are repeated n−1 times, whereby n is an integer number and n>1. Thus it is possible to maintain polarisation of the sample over a long time.
This partial conversion can be achieved by completely converting the LLS into a difference of longitudinal two spin order (ZZ) and zero quantum coherence (ZQC) in step (v) during an interval τ4, and subsequently partially converting this superposition into detectable magnetisation by applying a small-angle pulse, in particular a pulse with flip angle smaller or equal to 30°.
In an alternative variant in step (v) the LLS are partially converted into a difference of longitudinal two spin order (ZZ) and zero quantum coherence (ZQC) during an interval τ0, and subsequently entirely converting this superposition into detectable magnetisation by applying a 90° pulse.
A different variant of the inventive method comprises converting the entire amount of LLS into detectable magnetisation in step (v) and not repeating steps (iv) through (vi).
It is preferred that in step (i) the creation of enhanced polarisation is realized by dynamic nuclear polarisation (DNP), in particular dissolution DNP. Although any method for enhancing polarisation can be used, the dissolution-DNP experiments are widely believed to be most useful for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). However, the intrinsically short spin memory T1 compels one to use the slowly-built enhancement of the polarisation within short time intervals. Therefore, reactions occurring on time scales of tens of seconds or longer cannot be followed using this technique. Storing the enhanced nuclear polarisation in LLS reduces the strain on the time period that is allowed to elapse between polarisation and NMR detection.
The inventive method is preferably used for the study of chemical reactions and slow dynamic phenomena such as flow, diffusion, and exchange.
The invention is shown in the drawing:
a shows a fit of the exponential decay of DNP-enhanced magnetisation converted shot-by-shot into LLS, with TLLS=15±2 s.
b shows the decay monitored using a series of five consecutive detection periods (n=5, α=10°) interleaved with intervals τm=4 s where the LLS was sustained.
A method has been designed to convert a small fraction of LLS into detectable magnetisation. The dipeptide Ala-Gly was chosen to demonstrate this method. The J-coupled aliphatic protons Hα1 and Hα2 of glycine in Ala-Gly are diastereotopic and therefore apt to sustain long-lived states (
Natural-abundance 13CO of glycine (
When used in conjunction with hyperpolarisation, the new experiment comprises four steps: (i) create enhanced polarisation in a low magnetic field at cryogenic temperatures; (ii) rapidly transfer the polarised sample to room temperature; (iii) transform the enhanced carbon-13 magnetisation into long-lived states (LLS) associated with protons and (iv) preserve these LLS by suitable means, (v) ‘read out’ the long-lived states by (partial) conversion into observable magnetisation. Step (ii) typically lasts a few seconds, so it is advantageous to store polarisation on slowly relaxing nuclei (such as 13C nuclei) during this period. Due to the large enhancements afforded by dissolution-DNP, isotope labelling of the molecule of interest is not necessary and naturally-occurring isotopes of nitrogen or carbon (as in the present study) may be used. Step (v) may be repeated if only a small fraction of the long-lived states is converted into detectable terms and the rest is sustained as a long-lived state.
The pulse sequence denoted ‘Long-Lived States’ in
For the pulse sequence in
During the interval τ4=1/(4ΔνIS) where ΔνIS=ν(Hα1)−ν(Hα2) the ZQx part of QLLS evolves into:
ZQx→ZQy=IySx−IxSy (2)
(Symbols such as ZQ are universally recognized as product operators)17.
These terms are partly converted into detectable single-quantum coherences by a pulse with a phase y and a small flip angle α:
ZQy→−(IySz−IzSy)sin α+ZQy cos α, (3)
The leading antiphase single-quantum terms are detected and the remaining ZQy is converted back to ZQx during the subsequent interval pτ4-τ4, so that the operator QLLS is re-constituted.
The pulse sequence in
ZQx→ZQx cos(2πτ0ΔνIS)+ZQy sin(2πτ0ΔνIS) (4)
The second term is entirely converted to detectable single-quantum coherences by a 90° pulse:
ZQy→−(IySz−IzSy) (5)
The remaining (IzSz+ZQX) part, which commutes with the 90° pulse, is left intact. The ZQx term precesses through an even number of periods while detection is performed and LLS may be sustained again after the detection period.
Dissolution
DNP experiments have been performed, followed by the transfer of one or two samples of ca. 1 ml each of polarised sample to the high-resolution magnet. For each sample, a DNP-LLS experiment was performed with variable times τm, where the LLS is sustained, n=1, and converting the entire amount of magnetisation into detectable terms. The resulting intensities were scaled by the intensity of the enhanced 13C signal, measured in a preliminary experiment using a 13C pulse with α=10°, and the ratios I(DNP-LLS)/I(DNP-13C) were fitted to an exponential decay with three parameters (
In a second series of experiments (
The experiments were performed using 0.6 M Ala-Gly mixed with 50 mM TEMPO and dissolved in 5 ml 35%/65% v/v glycerol-d8/D2O. The frozen beads were placed in a home-built prepolariser,20 and irradiated with 30 mW microwaves at 94 GHz for 5 hours at 1.2 K and 3.35 T. The sample was dissolved in 5 ml D2O (preheated to 190° C. at 12 bar) to a final concentration of ca. 50 mM. The hyperpolarised solution was transferred to 10 mm tubes maintained at a temperature of 25° C. in an inverse broadband probe in a high-resolution 7 T wide-bore Bruker magnet. The time that elapsed between the start of the transfer from the polarising magnet and detection was ca. 6 s. The room-temperature experiments using nuclear polarisation at Boltzmann equilibrium were carried out at 300 MHz (B0=7.05 T) and 298 K using ˜20 mM Ala-Gly solutions in deuterated water. Eight transients were acquired for each LLS experiment using a relaxation delay of 30 s. Experimental relaxation time constants T1 and TLLS were obtained by fitting normalized spectral intensities to mono-exponentially decaying functions. A WALTZ sequence with an rf amplitude ν1=1.5 kHz was used to sustain the LLS.
For dissolution—DNP experiments, the polarisation of electron spins is transferred to nuclei in a polarising magnet prior to NMR detection in a high-resolution magnet3, using instrumentation developed at EPFL20
The inventive method allows one to preserve DNP-enhanced polarisation under the form of long-lived spin states and to convert small fractions back to detectable terms. This may open the way to follow metabolic pathways by magnetic resonance and providing the time needed for hyperpolarised magnetisation to reach the target areas in angiography studies. The new experiments may find applications for the study of chemical reactions and slow dynamic phenomena such as flow, diffusion, and exchange. Unlike methods that exploit the long lifetimes of nuclei with low gyromagnetic ratios such as carbon-13 and nitrogen-15 to increase the spatial and temporal resolution of MRI19, the methods described in this work do not require any isotopic labelling, and use the advantageous sensitivity of proton NMR. The new hyperpolarised methods may be extended to multiple scans, phase-cycling and even 2D spectroscopy, provided the partial decay of the LLS is taken into consideration.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
09164545 | Jul 2009 | EP | regional |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
20110050228 | Levitt et al. | Mar 2011 | A1 |
Entry |
---|
L.B. Becerra, G.J. Gerfen, R.J. Temkin, D.J. Singel + R.G. Griffin, “Dynamic Nuclear-Polarization with a Cyclotron-Resonance Maser at 5-T”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 3561-3564 (1993). |
M.J. Prandolini, V.P. Denysenkov, M. Gafurov, B. Endeward + T.F. Prisner, “High-field dynamic nuclear polarization in aqueous solutions”, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 131, 6090-2 (2009). |
J.H.Ardenkjaer-Larsen, B.Fridlund, A.Gram, G.Hansson, L.Hansson, M.H.Lerche, R.Servin, M.Thaning + K. Golman, “Increase in signal-to-noise ratio of >10,000 times in liquid-state NMR”, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci.100, 10158-10163 (2003). |
M. Carravetta, O.G. Johannessen + M.H. Levitt, “Beyond the T1 limit: Singlet nuclear spin states in low magnetic fields”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 153003 (2004). |
P. Ahuja, R. Sarkar, P.R. Vasos + G. Bodenhausen “Molecular Properties Determined from the Relaxation of Long-Lived Spin States”, J. Chem. Phys. 127, 134112 (2007). |
M. Carravetta + M.H. Levitt, “Long-lived nuclear spin states in high-field solution NMR”, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 126, 6228-6229 (2004). |
G.Pileio, M. Concistré, M.Carravetta + M.H. Levitt, “Long-lived nuclear spin states in the solution NMR of four-spin systems”, J. Magn. Reson. 182, 353-347 (2006). |
G. Pileio + M.H. Levitt, “J-Stabilisation of singlet states in the solution NMR of multiple-spin systems”, J. Magn. Reson. 187, 141-145 (2007). |
E.Vinogradov + A.K.Grant, “Long-lived states in solution NMR: Selection rules for instramolecular dipolar relaxation in low magnetic fields”, J. Magn. Reson. 188, 176-182 (2007). |
E.Vinogradov + A.K. Grant, “Hyperpolarized long-lived states in solution NMR: Three-spin case study in low field”, J. Magn. Reson. 194, 46-57 (2008). |
D.Canet, S.Bouguet-Bonnet, C.Aroulanda + F.Reineri, “About long-lived nuclear spin states involved in para-hydrogenated molecules”, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 129, 1445-9(2007). |
P.Ahuja, R. Sarkar, P.R. Vasos + G.Bodenhausen, “Long lived states in multiple-spin systems”, Chemphyschem, 10, 2217-2220 (2009). |
S.Cavadini, J.Dittmer, S.Antonijevic + G.Bodenhausen, “Slow diffusion by singlet state NMR spectroscopy”, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 127, 15744-15748 (2005). |
S.Cavadini + P.R. Vasos, “Singlet states open the way to longer time-scales in the measurement of diffusion by NMR spectroscopy”, Concepts Magn. Reson. 32A, 68-78 (2008). |
R.Sarkar, P.Ahuja, P.R. Vasos + G.Bodenhausen, “Measurement of Slow Diffusion Coefficients of Molecules with Arbitrary Scalar couplings via Long-Lived Spin States”, ChePhysChem 9, 2414-2419 (2008). |
R.Sarkar, P.R.Vasos + G.Bodenhausen, “Singlet-State Exchange NMR Spectroscopy for the Study of Very Slow Dynamic Processes”, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 129, 328-334 (2007). |
W.S.Warren, E. Jenista, R.T.Branca + X.Chen, “Increasing Hyperpolarized Spin Lifetimes Through True Singlet Eigenstates”, Science 323, 1711-1714 (2009). |
G.Golman, J.H.Ardenaer-Larsen, J.S.Petersson, S.Mansson + I.Leunbach, “Molecular imging with endogenous substances”, Proc.Nat. Acad. Sci. 100, 10435-10439 (2002). |
A.Comment, B.Van Den Brandt, K.Uffmann, F.Kurdzesau, S.Jannin, J.A.Konter, P.Hautle, W.T.H.Wenckebach, R.Gruetter + J.J.Van Der Klink, “Design and performance of a DNP prepolarizer coupled to a rodent MRI scanner”, Concepts Magn. Reson. 318,255-269 (2007). |
R.Sarkar, P.Ahuja, D.Moskau, P.R.Vasos + G.Bodenhausen, “Extending the scope of singlet-state spectroscopy”, ChemPhysChem 8, 2652-2656 (2007). |
D.P.Burum + R.R.Ernst, “Net Polarization Transfer Via a J-Ordered State for Signal Enhancement of Low-Sensitivity Nuclei”, J. Magn. Reson. 39, 163-168 (1980). |
G.A.Morris + R.Freeman, “Enhancement of Nuclear Magnetic-Resonance Signals by Polarization Transfer”, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 101, 760-762 (1979). |
P.Ahuja, R.Sarkar, P.R.Vasos + G.Bodenhausen, “Diffusion Coefficients of Biomolecules Using Long-Lived Spin States”, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 131, 7498-7499 (2009). |
Chekmenev, Eduard, Y. et al., “Hyperpolarized (1)H NMR Employing Low gamma Nucleus for Spin Polarization Storage”, Journal of the American Chemical Society, Mar. 11, 2009, vol. 131, No. 9, pp. 3164-3165. |
Vasos, P.R. et al., “Long-lived states to sustain hyperpolarized magnetization”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, Nov. 3, 2009, vol. 106, No. 44, pp. 18469-18473. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20110001475 A1 | Jan 2011 | US |