The present invention relates to methods of determining the liquid water content of a cloud.
The liquid water content (LWC) of a cloud varies based on cloud type and can be linked to different cloud formations and weather events. In addition, clouds having different LWCs and associated water droplet size distributions can present different risks of ice formation on aircraft exteriors, such as wings. Therefore, knowing the LWC of a cloud can be important for aviation safety. The LWC of a cloud can be estimated in various ways. Several existing methods, for example, merely assume an effective droplet diameter based on prior research investigating droplet size distributions of clouds. Such assumptions, however, can introduce significant error in the LWC estimate. More accurate estimates of LWC can be achieved through the use of multiple sensing apparatus working in conjunction with one another to provide the requisite parameters for estimating LWC. While more accurate, the use of multiple sensors is often expensive with a concomitant increase in system complexity.
In one aspect, methods of estimating the LWC of a cloud are described herein. In some embodiments, LWC of a cloud is derived from the size distribution of water droplets in the cloud. Therefore, in another aspect, methods of determining a size distribution of water droplets in a cloud are described herein.
In some embodiments, a method of determining a size distribution of water droplets in a cloud comprises sampling a depth of the cloud with a beam of electromagnetic radiation, measuring echo intensities of the electromagnetic radiation returned from the cloud with a detector, determining a measured optical extinction coefficient from the measured echo intensities, determining a measured backscatter coefficient from the measured echo intensities and determining a lidar ratio from the measured optical extinction coefficient and the measured backscatter coefficient. A value pair comprising a shape parameter (μ) and median volume diameter (DMVD) of the water droplets is determined from the lidar ratio, and a size distribution of the water droplets (n(D)) is determined using the value pair (μ, DMVD). The size distribution of the water droplets is used to determine the effective droplet diameter (Deff), and the LWC of the cloud is then determined using the Deff.
In some embodiments, a plurality of value pairs (μ, DMVD) are determined from the lidar ratio and a plurality of water droplet size distributions are determined using the value pairs.
In some embodiments, wherein a plurality of water droplet size distributions are determined, a method described herein further comprises providing a plurality of calculated optical extinction coefficients from the plurality of droplet size distributions and comparing the calculated optical extinction coefficients to the measured optical extinction coefficient. The water droplet size distribution associated with the calculated optical extinction coefficient most closely approximating the measured optical extinction coefficient, in some embodiments, is selected and the effective droplet diameter (Deff) is determined from this selected droplet size distribution. The LWC of the cloud is then determined using the Deff.
In some embodiments wherein a plurality of water droplet size distributions are determined, a method described herein further comprises providing a plurality of calculated backscatter coefficients from the plurality of droplet size distributions and comparing the calculated backscatter coefficients to the measured backscatter coefficient. The water droplet size distribution associated with the calculated backscatter coefficient most closely approximating the measured backscatter coefficient, in some embodiments, is selected and the effective droplet diameter (Deff) is determined from this selected droplet size distribution. The LWC of the cloud is then determined using the Deff.
These and other embodiments are described in greater detail in the detailed description which follows.
Embodiments described herein can be understood more readily by reference to the following detailed description and drawings. Elements, apparatus, and methods described herein, however, are not limited to the specific embodiments presented in the detailed description and drawings. It should be recognized that these embodiments are merely illustrative of the principles of the present invention. Numerous modifications and adaptations will be readily apparent to those of skill in the art without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.
In one aspect, methods of estimating the LWC of a cloud are described herein. In some embodiments, LWC of a cloud is derived from the size distribution of water droplets in the cloud. Therefore, in another aspect, methods of determining a size distribution of water droplets in a cloud are described herein.
In some embodiments, a method of determining a size distribution of water droplets in a cloud comprises sampling a depth of a cloud with a beam of electromagnetic radiation, measuring echo intensities of the electromagnetic radiation returned from the cloud with a detector, determining a measured optical extinction coefficient from the measured echo intensities, determining a measured backscatter coefficient from the measured echo intensities and determining a lidar ratio from the measured optical extinction coefficient and the measured backscatter coefficient. A value pair comprising a shape parameter (μ) and median volume diameter (DMVD) of the water droplets is determined from the lidar ratio, and a size distribution of the water droplets is determined using the value pair (μ, DMVD). The size distribution of the water droplets is used to determine the effective droplet diameter ((Deff), and the LWC of the cloud is then determined using the Deff.
In some embodiments, a plurality of value pairs (μ, DMVD) are determined from the lidar ratio and a plurality of water droplet size distributions are determined using the value pairs.
In some embodiments, wherein a plurality of water droplet size distributions are determined, a method described herein further comprises providing a plurality of calculated optical extinction coefficients from the plurality of droplet size distributions and comparing the calculated optical extinction coefficients to the measured optical extinction coefficient. The water droplet size distribution associated with the calculated optical extinction coefficient most closely approximating the measured optical extinction coefficient, in some embodiments, is selected and Deff is determined from this selected droplet size distribution. The LWC of the cloud is then determined using the Deff.
In some embodiments wherein a plurality of water droplet size distributions are determined, a method described herein further comprises providing a plurality of calculated backscatter coefficients from the plurality of droplet size distributions and comparing the calculated backscatter coefficients to the measured backscatter coefficient. The water droplet size distribution associated with the calculated backscatter coefficient most closely approximating the measured backscatter coefficient, in some embodiments, is selected and Deff is determined from this selected droplet size distribution. The LWC of the cloud is then determined using the Deff.
Turning now to specific steps of methods described herein, a method described herein comprises sampling a depth of a cloud with electromagnetic radiation. A cloud can be sampled with electromagnetic radiation to any depth not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, the cloud is sampled to a depth no greater than the distance over which the cloud is homogeneous or substantially homogeneous. In some embodiments, the cloud is sampled to a depth of up to about 30 meters (m). In some embodiments, the cloud is sampled to a depth of up to about 20 m.
The beam of electromagnetic radiation can comprise any beam not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, the beam of electromagnetic radiation comprises a beam emitted from a laser. In some embodiments, the laser beam is polarized. In some embodiments, the laser beam is circularly polarized. In some embodiments, the laser beam comprises a pulsed laser beam or a continuous wave laser beam. In some embodiments, the continuous wave laser beam is chopped. Moreover, in some embodiments, the beam of electromagnetic radiation is emitted from a light emitting diode.
The beam of electromagnetic radiation can comprise any wavelength distribution not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, for example, the beam is a monochromatic or substantially monochromatic beam. In some embodiments, the beam of electromagnetic radiation has a wavelength in the infrared (IR) region of the electromagnetic spectrum. In some embodiments, the beam of electromagnetic radiation has a wavelength in the near infrared (NIR) region of the spectrum. In some embodiments, the beam of electromagnetic radiation has a wavelength in the visible region of the spectrum. In some embodiments, the beam of electromagnetic radiation has a wavelength in the ultraviolet (UV) region of the spectrum. The beam of electromagnetic radiation, in some embodiments, has a wavelength not absorbed or substantially absorbed by water. In some embodiments, the beam of electromagnetic radiation has one or more wavelengths falling in an optical window not absorbed by water. In some embodiments, for example, the beam of electromagnetic radiation has a wavelength of about 905 nm.
Moreover, the beam of electromagnetic radiation can have any power not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, the beam of electromagnetic radiation has an intensity of mW to tens of mW.
In some embodiments, the beam of electromagnetic radiation comprises a calibrated beam. A calibrated beam, in some embodiments, has sufficiently known and/or stable characteristics to permit the measurement of calibrated echo intensities. Calibrated echo intensities, in some embodiments, refer to echo intensities measured in radiometric units, such as W/cm2, as opposed to dimensionless units (e.g., relative to another measurement). Calibration of the beam of electromagnetic radiation and measurement of calibrated echo intensities can be dependent on one or more considerations, including intensity of the beam, transmission efficiency of the entire optical train (both transmit and receive), detector sensitivity and transmission characteristics of the external window of the housing in which the beam source is disposed.
As described herein, echo intensities of the electromagnetic radiation retuned from the cloud are measured with a detector. Any detector not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention may be used in the measurement of the echo intensities. In some embodiments, the detector comprises a solid state photodetector. In some embodiments, the detector comprises a photodiode, such as a photodiode array. The photodiode, in some embodiments, comprises one or more of silicon (Si), germanium (Ge), indium gallium arsenide (InGaxAs1-x), lead (II) sulfide (PbS), and combinations thereof. In some embodiments, the detector comprises at least one photosensitive element and one or more circuits for processing the output of the at least photosensitive element. The one or more circuits, in some embodiments, comprise filtering circuits and/or amplification circuits. In some embodiments, a detector is calibrated for the measurement of calibrated echo intensities.
Measuring the echo intensities of the electromagnetic radiation returned from the cloud with a detector can be executed in any manner not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, for example, the echo intensities are parsed into range resolved slices. The range resolved slices can have any thickness not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, the range resolved slices have a thickness of about 5 m or less. In some embodiments, the range resolved slices have a thickness of about 1 m or less.
In some embodiments, the echo intensities received from range R can be described according to the equation:
P(R)=K·G(R)·β·e−2αR, (1)
wherein K is a constant dependent on instrumental parameters (such as aperture size of the beam source, beam intensity, and transmission efficiency of the optics of the beam source), G(R) is the geometric form function of the detector, β is the backscatter coefficient (in units of m−1 sr−1), and α is the optical extinction coefficient (in units of m−1).
In some embodiments, sampling a depth of the cloud and measuring the echo intensities is conducted with a single apparatus. In some embodiments, an apparatus used for sampling a depth of a cloud and measuring echo intensities is coupled to an aircraft. In some embodiments, sampling the depth of a cloud and measuring the echo intensities is conducted while the aircraft is in-flight.
In some embodiments, a suitable apparatus for sampling a depth of a cloud and measuring echo intensities as described herein is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 7,986,408, the entirety of which is hereby incorporated by reference. In some embodiments, sampling the depth of a cloud and measuring the echo intensities is conducted with more than one apparatus. One or more apparatuses used to sample the depth of the cloud and measure the echo intensities, in some embodiments, can be used to obtain other information about the cloud, in addition to determining the droplet size distribution and/or LWC of the cloud.
Methods described herein comprise determining a measured optical extinction coefficient (α) from the measured echo intensities. Determining a measured optical extinction coefficient can be conducted in any manner not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, the measured echo intensities display time dependent decay. Therefore, determining a measured optical extinction coefficient from the measured echo intensities can comprise fitting the measured echo intensities to a known decay curve. The decay curve, in some embodiments, is an exponential decay curve.
Moreover, methods described herein comprise determining a measured backscatter coefficient from the measured echo intensities. Determining a measured backscatter coefficient can be conducted in any manner not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, for example, the measured backscatter coefficient is determined from normalized, range corrected echo intensities. The normalized, range corrected echo intensities can be described according to the following equation derived from equation (1) above:
N(R)=P(R)/[K·G(R)]=β·e−2αR, (2)
with the result that the backscatter coefficient can be described by the following equation:
β=N(R)e2αR. (3)
wherein α is the measured optical extinction coefficient. In some embodiments described above, the cloud is sampled over a depth wherein the composition of the cloud is considered to be homogeneous. As a result, α and β are not regarded as functions of R as in the cases of space-based and terrestrial lidars performing large-scale cloud sounding. In some embodiments, a plurality of measured backscatter coefficients are determined from the echo intensities of the range resolved slices and averaged to provide an average measured backscatter coefficient and corresponding standard deviation of the measured backscatter coefficient. In some embodiments, the plurality of measured backscatter coefficients are determined from equation (3), wherein N(R) represents the echo intensities of a range resolved slice.
Once the measured optical extinction coefficient and measured backscatter coefficient have been determined, a lidar ratio (S) is calculated according to the equation:
α/β=S (4)
In some embodiments, β is a single measured value or an averaged measured value.
A value pair comprising a shape parameter (μ) and a median volume diameter of the water droplets (DMVD) is determined from the lidar ratio. Determination of a value pair (μ, DMVD) can be carried out in any manner not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, determining a value pair comprises using a look-up table. In some embodiments, the look-up table comprises a table and/or a graph. The table and/or graph, in some embodiments, comprises a curve of the theoretical lidar ratio as a function of median volume diameter for a gamma distribution of droplet sizes with a chosen value of the shape parameter (μ). Such plots are described, for example, in O'Connor, E. J.; Illingworth, A. J.; and Hogan, R. J., “A technique for autocalibration of cloud lidar,” Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology, 2004, 21 (5), pp. 777-786, the entirety of which is hereby incorporated by reference.
In some embodiments, a non-graphical look-up table can be derived from a graph, such as the graph illustrated in
Determination of a value pair (μ, DMVD) permits determination of a size distribution n(D) for the water droplets of the cloud. In some embodiments of methods described herein, the water droplet size distribution is determined according to the equation:
wherein n0 is a droplet number concentration per unit of droplet diameter in m−3 μm−1. In some embodiments, n0 is measured. In some embodiments, n0 is determined according to the equation:
n
0=4.35·10(6-4μ)(DMVD)μe7.05μ. (6)
In some embodiments, a method described herein further comprises determining the effective droplet diameter (Deff) using n(D). In some embodiments, Deff is determined according to the equation:
wherein n(D) is the droplet size distribution.
Methods described herein further comprise determining the liquid water content of the cloud. In some embodiments, the LWC of the cloud is determined using Deff. In some embodiments, for example, LWC is determined according to the equation:
LWC=3ραDeff, (8)
wherein ρ is the density of water and α is the optical extinction coefficient.
Methods described herein of determining a size distribution of water droplets in a cloud are not limited to determining a single value pair or a single size distribution. In some embodiments, a method described herein comprises determining a plurality of value pairs (μ, DMVD) from the lidar ratio and determining a plurality of water droplet size distributions using the value pairs (μ, DMVD). The plurality of value pairs can be determined in a manner consistent with that described herein for a single value pair using a look-up table comprising a table and/or graph.
Moreover, in some embodiments, a plurality of value pairs can be provided with a single curve of a graph.
In some embodiments, a non-graphical look-up table can be derived from a graph, such as the graph illustrated in
A plurality of water droplet size distributions n(D) can be determined using the value pairs in any manner not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, the water droplet size distributions n(D) are determined according to equation (5). In some embodiments, n0 of equation (5) is measured. In some embodiments, n0 is determined according to equation (6).
In some embodiments, methods described herein further comprise providing a plurality of calculated optical extinction coefficients from the plurality of water droplet size distributions n(D) determined using the value pairs. The calculated optical extinction coefficients can be provided in any manner not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, the calculated optical extinction coefficients (α) are provided according to the equation:
wherein Qext is determined from Mie theory for spherical water droplets having the same index of refraction.
In some embodiments, methods described herein further comprise comparing the calculated optical extinction coefficients to the measured optical extinction coefficient and selecting the water droplet size distribution n(D) associated with the calculated optical extinction coefficient most closely approximating the measured optical extinction coefficient. The selected n(D) is subsequently used to determine Deff and the LWC of the cloud. In some embodiments, Deff and LWC are determined according to equations (7) and (8) herein.
The measured optical extinction coefficient (α) is determined from the measured echo intensities P(R), and the normalized, range-corrected signal N(R) is then obtained from P(R) according to equation (2). The measured backscatter coefficient (β) is obtained using the measured optical extinction coefficient (α) and N(R) according to equation (3). In some embodiments, a measured backscatter coefficient is determined for each of the range resolved slices, and the backscatter coefficients are averaged to obtain an averaged measured backscatter coefficient and associated standard deviation for use in subsequent steps of the method.
After determining values for the measured optical extinction coefficient and measured backscatter coefficient (α and β, respectively), the lidar ratio (S) is determined by equation (4). This determined lidar ratio (S) is later used in conjunction with a look-up table to identify value pairs (μ, DMVD) as described herein. Upon identification of the value pairs (μ, DMVD), a corresponding droplet number concentration n0 is determined for each value pair according to equation (6) to provide a value triplet (μ, DMVD, n0). A calculated water droplet size distribution n(D) is then determined for each value triplet according to equation (5). From each calculated droplet size distribution n(D), a calculated optical extinction coefficient (α) is determined according to one equation (9).
The calculated optical extinction coefficients are compared to the measured optical extinction coefficient, and the calculated optical extinction coefficient most closely approximating the measured optical extinction coefficient is identified. The water droplet size distribution n(D) associated with the calculated optical extinction coefficient most closely approximating the measured optical extinction coefficient is selected and used to calculate Deff according to equation (7). The LWC of the cloud is then determined according to equation (8).
In some embodiments, methods described herein further comprise providing a plurality of calculated backscatter coefficients from the plurality of water droplet size distributions n(D) determined using the value pairs (μ, DMVD). The calculated backscatter coefficients can be provided in any manner not inconsistent with the objectives of the present invention. In some embodiments, the calculated backscatter coefficients (β) are provided according to the equation:
wherein (dQscat(λ,D)/dΩ)Ω=π is determined from Mie theory for spherical water droplets having the same index of refraction.
In some embodiments, methods described herein further comprise comparing the calculated backscatter coefficients to the measured backscatter coefficient and selecting the water droplet size distribution n(D) associated with the calculated backscatter coefficient most closely approximating the measured backscatter coefficient. The selected n(D) is subsequently used to determine Deff and the LWC of the cloud. In some embodiments, Deff and LWC are determined according to equations (7) and (8) herein.
The measured optical extinction coefficient (α) is determined from the measured echo intensities P(R), and the normalized, range-corrected signal N(R) is then obtained from P(R) according to equation (2). The measured backscatter coefficient (β) is obtained using the measured optical extinction coefficient (α) and N(R) to equation (3). In some embodiments, a measured backscatter coefficient is determined for each of the range resolved slices, and the measured backscatter coefficients are averaged to obtain an averaged measured backscatter coefficient and associated standard deviation for use in subsequent steps of the method.
After determining values for the measured optical extinction coefficient and measured backscatter coefficient (α and β, respectively), the lidar ratio (S) is determined by equation (4). This determined lidar ratio (S) is later used in conjunction with a look-up table to identify value pairs (μ, DMVD) as described herein. Upon identification of the value pairs (μ, DMVD), a corresponding droplet number concentration n0 is determined for each value pair according to equation (6) to provide a value triplet (μ, DMVD, n0). A calculated water droplet size distribution n(D) is then determined for each value triplet according to equation (5). From each calculated droplet size distribution n(D), a calculated backscatter coefficient (β) is determined according to one equation (10).
The calculated backscatter coefficients are compared to the measured backscatter coefficient, and the calculated backscatter coefficient most closely approximating the measured backscatter coefficient is identified. The water droplet size distribution n(D) associated with the calculated backscatter coefficient most closely approximating the measured backscatter coefficient is selected and used to calculate the effective droplet diameter (Deff) according to equation (7). The LWC of the cloud is then determined according to equation (8).
It is contemplated that methods described herein can be at least in part executed and/or implemented on computer or processor-based systems. In some embodiments, the computer or processor-based systems are part of an aircraft operating system.
Various embodiments of the invention have been described in fulfillment of the various objects of the invention. It should be recognized that these embodiments are merely illustrative of the principles of the present invention. Numerous modifications and adaptations thereof will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.