The invention generally relates to methods of increasing formability of a palm sheath material, methods of producing a palm sheath-based product, and palm sheath foodware produced thereby.
The negative effects of plastics on the environment are well-documented, with single-use plastic products being of particular concern as a result of being disposed at a far higher rate than other reusable plastic products and therefore having a more profoundly negative effect on the environment. Single-use plastics dominate the foodware/packaging industrial sector, which is itself the largest sector of plastic products. Post-consumption and/or post-use, single-use foodware products are dumped into landfills and oceans, adversely impacting public health, contaminating groundwater resources, and damaging the environment. Furthermore, single-use plastics have seen increased consumption in the recent pandemic and post-pandemic environment, being driven by increased demand for plastic bags, take-out food packaging, bottled water, and personal protective equipment (PPE). As a result, renewed efforts and innovations have been made towards finding environmentally friendly materials and sustainable, low-impact manufacturing processes to meet the aforementioned consumer demands, specifically those related to foodware and packaging.
Pulp-based (paper) foodware provide certain environmental advantages when compared to plastic foodware. Though largely biodegradable, pulp-based foodware require the use of additives or fillers, often as high as 30% of the mass of the product. The pulping and forming processes are energy-intensive, requiring emission-producing manufacturing processes that have additional negative environmental impacts. Additionally, pulp-based products often require the cutting of whole trees for their wood, contributing to deforestation and wide-scale environmental impacts. Finally, pulp-based foodware do not provide the same water retention capabilities as plastic foodware products. As a result, despite its reduced (though still measurable) environmental impacts, pulp-based foodware products remain non-ideal as a long-term solution to the environmental problems produced by single-use foodware products.
Areca catechu, commonly known as betel palm, areca-nut palm, or areca palm (hereinafter simply referred to as areca palm), is a species of palm tree which has been cultivated in India, Southeast Asia, East Asia, East Africa, Hawaii, and Oceania. The areca palm is primarily grown and cultivated for its nuts.
Areca palm sheaths have been found to be suitable for use as a substitute for plastics, including the single-step manufacturing of foodware such as shown in
Deformation, the process by which palm sheaths are formed into foodware (or some other useful shape) without any intermediate treatment, pulping, drying, or processing steps, is very much analogous to the forming of sheet metal by stretching or punching using dies and is neither water- nor energy-intensive. In contrast to pulp-based (paper) foodware production, the stretch-forming approach of palm sheath foodware production avoids the use of filler materials or additives. The sheath material is capable of biodegrading in about sixty days, compared to hundreds of years for plastics. Finally, the sheath material is raw waste material and can be renewably harvested from the same tree over many seasons, unlike bamboo or pulp-based foodware which typically involve cutting down whole trees to obtain raw material. This use of raw waste material, coupled with the very small energy of the forming process, highlights another key advantage of processing palm sheaths-producing products with low embodied energy.
Palm sheath foodware has been recorded up to two hundred years ago, and is currently commonly manufactured in emerging and developing economies of Asia. Palm sheath foodware is typically manufactured in small sheds with low-cost press equipment and an artisanal workforce with limited research and technological resources. As a result, current manufacturers rely on empiricism and intuitive understanding of material behavior for designing products and improving methods of manufacture. Currently, the sheath is often hydrated for several hours, sometimes up to twelve hours, in water before forming, ostensibly to induce more ductile behavior in the sheaths. The duration of this hydration treatment does not appear to be fixed or controlled by the manufacturer in any manner beyond that stipulated by empiricism and intuition. Using the aforementioned hydration method, moderate tensile strain limits similar to those of ductile aluminum and copper alloy sheet metal have been obtained.
Current manufacturing techniques have been limited in the shape, utility, and variety of products they may produce. Specifically, current palm sheath foodware products typically have a height to diameter aspect ratio of no more than about 0.2, which is relatively shallower than common foodware. The limiting factor has primarily been the formability of the sheath, which is not capable of withstanding the forming strains required to undergo shape changes with higher aspect ratios, which are often necessary to form palm sheaths into a wider variety of utensils. Therefore, there is broad interest from manufacturers in increasing palm sheath formability.
In light of the above, it would be advantageous if methods were available by which the formability of areca palm sheath material could be increased, thereby making it suitable for a wider variety of foodware products and utensils. Any enhancement of the formability beyond that achieved by pure hydration treatments would be of value not only for improving the current stretch-forming process for palm sheath foodware, but also for expanding the capability to produce high-aspect ratio, palm sheath products. In order to maintain and confer environmental advantages associated with existing areca palm sheath foodware, such methods would necessarily be neither energy- nor water-intensive and would result in products with low embodied energy. By providing such a method and, by extension, providing palm sheath foodware of greater variety and utility, palm sheath foodware production would provide wide scale advantages in the environmental impact of foodware use and disposal.
The intent of this section of the specification is to briefly indicate the nature and substance of the invention, as opposed to an exhaustive statement of all subject matter and aspects of the invention. Therefore, while this section identifies subject matter recited in the claims, additional subject matter and aspects relating to the invention are set forth in other sections of the specification, particularly the detailed description, as well as any drawings.
The present invention provides, but is not limited to, methods of increasing formability of a palm sheath material, methods of producing a palm sheath-based product, and palm sheath foodware produced thereby.
According to a nonlimiting aspect of the invention, a method of increasing formability of a palm sheath material includes treating the palm sheath material with a fluid substance that weakens bonds between cellulose fibers of the palm sheath material by partially eliminating lignin and hemicellulose of the palm sheath material without inducing large-scale structural damage that promotes fracture.
According to another nonlimiting aspect of the invention, a method of producing a palm sheath-based product includes producing a treated palm sheath material by the method described above, and deforming the treated palm sheath material into a shape to produce a product.
Other nonlimiting aspects of the invention include palm sheath foodware produced by the method described above. The product may include at least one of a cup, a bowl, a plate, a utensil, a tumbler, and packaging.
Technical aspects of methods as described above preferably include the ability to increase the formability of a palm sheath material, resulting in the material be being better suited for a wider variety of products, including but not limited to foodware products and utensils with relatively high height-to-diameter aspect ratios (e.g., exceeding 0.2).
These and other aspects, arrangements, features, and/or technical effects will become apparent upon detailed inspection of the figures and the following description.
The intended purpose of the following detailed description of the invention and the phraseology and terminology employed therein is to describe what is shown in the drawings, which depict and/or relate to one or more nonlimiting embodiments of the invention, and to describe certain but not all aspects of the embodiment(s) depicted in the drawings. The following detailed description also identifies certain but not all alternatives of the embodiment(s) depicted in the drawings. As nonlimiting examples, the invention encompasses additional or alternative embodiments in which one or more features or aspects shown and/or described as part of a particular embodiment could be eliminated, and also encompasses additional or alternative embodiments that combine two or more features or aspects shown and/or described as part of different embodiments. Therefore, the appended provisional claims, and not the detailed description, are intended to particularly point out subject matter regarded to be aspects of the invention, including certain but not necessarily all of the aspects and alternatives described in the detailed description.
According to some nonlimiting aspects of the invention, a palm sheath material, for example, a sheath of an areca palm, can be treated with a fluid substance that weakens bonds between cellulose fibers of the palm sheath material by partially eliminating lignin and hemicellulose of the palm sheath material prior to undergoing a forming operation to increase its formability. Particular but nonlimiting examples of suitable fluid substances include ethylene glycol, hot water (liquid), water vapor, and aqueous (liquid) solutions containing one or more hydroxides (which release OH− groups that aid in the partial elimination of lignin) and sulfites, such as sodium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide, calcium hydroxide, magnesium hydroxide, ammonium hydroxide, potassium sulfite, calcium sulfite, magnesium sulfite, and ammonium sulfite. Further nonlimiting examples of suitable fluid substances are believed to include methanol, formic acid, acetic acid, chlorite, and tetrahydrofuran. In investigations leading to the present invention, tests were performed evidencing the efficacy of sodium hydroxide, ethylene glycol, sodium sulfite, and hot water or boiling water. Some of the investigations using aqueous sodium hydroxide (NaOH) solutions as the fluid substance to treat areca palm sheaths are described below.
Though NaOH is known to soften wood to increase its bendability and to increase the densification of natural wood by compression, the action of a NaOH solution in all of these cases is to weaken the bonding between cellulose fibers in natural wood by partially removing hemi-cellulose and lignin. An advantageous increase in the formability of a palm sheath due to a NaOH treatment was not expected given that palm sheaths have a structure intermediate that of wood and a plant leaf.
Formability conferred by NaOH treatments to palm sheaths was investigated using a limiting dome height (LDH) test, an illustrative example of which is shown in
A series of LDH experiments was carried out with areca sheaths under dry (original untreated), hydrated, and aqueous NaOH treatment conditions to assess sheath formability with specific relevance to foodware manufacturing. The sheaths were obtained in a raw condition, meaning that they had not undergone any previous treatments that would alter their structures or microstructures. The LDH test samples were cut from central regions of the sheaths to each have a size of about 40 mm×40 mm×3 mm (thickness). Sheath formability was assessed in terms of maximum punch displacement and maximum strain (forming limit) developed at the bottommost point of the punch (inside surface of the resulting cup) at failure, as well as the forming force.
All hydrated test samples were hydrated by immersion in water (0% NaOH) for two hours. Aqueous NaOH solutions at different NaOH concentrations were used to treat the NaOH-treated samples. NaOH concentrations evaluated were 2%, 5%, 10%, and 15% by weight in a solution of water, and all NaOH-treated samples at each concentration were treated by immersion in the solution for a duration of one, two, six, or twelve hours. Forming limit strains were obtained with five tests performed at each set of parameter conditions.
Formability was assessed in terms of the capacity for shape change (limit strain, ε) and the forming force to produce a given shape change. Results for dry samples, hydrated samples treated with water for two hours, and samples treated with 5% NaOH for two hours are plotted in
Concurrent with the increased capacity for shape change, there was a corresponding large reduction in the forming force due to the hydration and NaOH treatments. For example, the maximum load, which occurs almost at the failure limit (h about 3.8 mm), was about 350 Newtons (N) in the dry sample, whereas the corresponding load at the same penetration depth of 3.8 mm with the hydrated sample was just less than 50 N, an approximately 85% load decrease. This failure limit load was even further lowered with the NaOH treated samples relative to the hydrated samples—about 130 N vs about 410 N—a nearly 70% reduction in the forming force with the NaOH treatment. The large forming force reduction was concluded to be another manifestation of the significantly increased formability due to hydration and even more so due to the NaOH treatment. Such reductions in forming force confer advantages in energy requirements when forming foodware as well as other products from areca palm sheath materials, and therefore reduces the embodied energy of such products.
Areca sheath samples subjected to aqueous NAOH solution treatments at 2%, 5%, 10%, and 15% concentrations for durations of one, two, six, and twelve hours also underwent a series of LDH tests, the results of which are depicted in
SEM analysis of the sheath samples subjected to the 5% and 15% NaOH treatments (two-hour exposures) suggested that the observed forming limit changes were a consequence of microstructure modifications resulting from the treatments.
Mass measurements and FTIR analysis on dry (untreated) sheath samples and sheath samples subjected to the 15% NaOH treatment confirmed and reinforced the SEM observations of the structural changes in the sheath samples seen in
In light of the above, a preferred embodiment is believed to entail the treatment of palm sheath, particularly an areca palm sheath, with an aqueous NaOH solution in which the NaOH concentration is about 2% to less than 10%, for example, about 5%, with treatments of no greater than twelve hours, preferably greater than one hour and up to about six hours. Particularly suitable treatments are believed to use a 5% NaOH concentration and a treatment duration of about one to about six hours. Palm sheaths treated in this manner are believed to be suitable for producing products through a deformation process, as nonlimiting examples, foodware, food packaging, and/or cooking and eating utensils.
The cutting and forming processes of the present aspect of the invention are roughly analogous to sheet metal cutting and forming and processes known to those skilled in the art. Specifically, the shape of a finished product can be determined by the shape cut into the sheet of material, in this case a palm sheath, and by the depth of deformation. In a nonlimiting embodiment of the present invention, the forming process can be achieved by deforming the sheath by stretching, punching, or pressing it, as nonlimiting examples, mechanical pressing, stretching, twisting, bending, punching, rolling, piercing, cutting, or some combination thereof between two shaping dies. The process may further involve heating the deformed sheath material, possibly by heating the die once it is formed into a desired shape. In certain embodiments, the dies may be heated for about three minutes, which is believed in many cases to be capable of locking in the desired shape by removing excess moisture without causing structural damage to the sheath material.
The LDH force-displacement curves described above can also be used to estimate the specific energy for the forming process, an important measure of product sustainability. The specific energy is the energy required to form a given unit mass of the material, and can be estimated as the area under a load-displacement curve (e.g.,
As previously noted above, though the foregoing detailed description describes certain aspects of one or more particular embodiments of the invention, alternatives could be adopted by one skilled in the art. For example, any number of tools, products, or utensils could be produced with the method provided by the present invention, especially as the capabilities of palm sheath materials are fully explored by those skilled in the art. Such utensils may expand to include cups, bowls, tumblers, and shell-type packaging. Additionally, those skilled in the art may expand upon the method of the present invention in terms of scaling and improved efficiency, thereby increasing production rates and reducing manufacturing costs. Finally, the LDH test used as empirical validation in the present invention could therefore explore the viability of employing the method of the present invention on similar plan materials, beyond areca palm sheath materials specifically. As such, and again as was previously noted, it should be understood that the invention is not necessarily limited to any particular embodiment described herein or illustrated in the drawings.
This application claims the benefit of provisional U.S. Patent Application No. 63/495,922 filed Apr. 13, 2023, the contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63495922 | Apr 2023 | US |