This disclosure relates to improving thermal stability of superhard bonded diamond cutting elements used for wear, drilling, drawing and other downhole tools where superhard properties are required. More specifically, this disclosure relates generally to systems and methods of hard-facing and brazing fully or partially encapsulated thermally stable bonded diamond to downhole tool components.
A wide variety of bonded diamond compacts (BDCs) can be used in downhole tool components. Usually BDCs are used in drill string mud motor bearings, push the bit pads and drill bit cutting elements. Generally, these prior BDC devices do not incorporate a thermally stable element in the region adjacent to the cutting surface, therefore prior BDC devices tend to have a mismatch in thermal expansion that can cause the interstitial metal to exert a high stress on the diamond lattice, which in turn can lead to fracture of the diamond-to-diamond bonds and shorten the operating life of the compact. Further, prior BDC devices tend to incorporate a non-thermally stable element that readily dissolves carbon from the diamond surface at elevated temperatures, thereby, leading to the conversion of diamond to graphite, which in turn leads to the shortened operating life of the compact.
Common BDCs are formed by subjecting diamond or other superhard particles (such as cubic boron nitride (CBN) and the like) to high-temperatures and high pressure in the presence of a metallic catalyst to form a polycrystalline matrix of inter-bonded particles. This bonding process is typically referred to as “sintering.” The metallic catalyst typically remains in the polycrystalline diamond matrix. Well known polycrystalline diamond (PCD) elements typically consist of a facing table of polycrystalline diamond integrally bonded to a substrate of a less hard material, such as cemented tungsten carbide. This material is often referred to as a polycrystalline diamond compact (PDC). PDC is commonly used in downhole tools, such as downhole drill bit assemblies (including drag bits, also called fixed cutter bits; percussion bits; and rolling cone bits, also called rock bits), reamers, stabilizers and tool joints.
Thermal stability in a PDC is desirable in hard rock drilling applications. High temperatures are generated at the leading edge of the PDC tool while cutting rock. These high temperatures can cause degradation of the tool via several mechanisms, two of which are graphitization of the polycrystalline diamond in contact with the interstitial metallic catalyst and thermal expansion of the interstitial metallic catalyst. In the graphitization mechanism, carbon readily dissolved from the diamond surface as the temperature of the cutting tip increases above about 450° C. This dissolving of the carbon is due to the increased saturation level of carbon in the metallic catalyst with increasing temperature. The dissolved carbon takes the form of graphite since the PDC tool operates outside of the thermodynamic stability region of diamond. In the thermal expansion mechanism, this thermal expansion of the metallic catalyst is several times greater than that of diamond for a given increase in temperature. The mismatch in thermal expansion causes the interstitial metal to exert a high stress on the diamond lattice. These stresses can lead to a fracture of diamond-to-diamond bonds at or above about 700° C. and a shortened operating life of the compact.
When BDCs are disposed in plugs located in the outer surface of downhole tool components, a process known as hard-facing is used. Typical hard-facing and induction brazing temperatures for mud motor bearings, push the bit pads and drill bits are over 800° C. The high temperatures can impact seating and lead to significant thermal degradation of the BDC.
Embodiments of the present disclosure relate to encapsulating superhard compact materials, such as bonded diamond powder or bonded cubic boron nitride powder, with an encapsulation layer to improve thermal stability. The combination of the encapsulation layer and the bonded compact yields a bonded compact construct that can more readily be attached to mud motor bearings, push the bit pad assemblies and drill bit assemblies. In some embodiments, the bonded compact construct may be formed of a bonded diamond compact (BDC). In some embodiments, the bonded compact construct may be formed of a bonded cubic boron nitride compact.
The encapsulation layer 106 includes an outer surface 106a, as illustrated. In one or more embodiments, the encapsulation layer 106 may have a thickness T1 of about 1.0 mm to 1.5 mm. In one or more embodiments, the thickness T1 may range from about 0.5 mm to about 2.0 mm. In one or more embodiments, the thickness T1 may scale to a dimension of the BDC construct 102, such as ranging from about 10% to about 25% of one of a length L1, width W1, or height H1 of the BDC construct 102, as illustrated. In one or more embodiments, the thickness T1 may vary over the outer surface 104a. In one or more embodiments, a portion of the encapsulation layer 106 adjacent an edge 104b may be thinner than portions of the encapsulation layer 106 adjacent edges 104c and 104d. In one or more embodiments, the encapsulation layer 106 may be thicker on one side of the BDC construct 102 compared to an opposing side of the BDC construct 102.
In one or more embodiments, the outer surface 204a includes a surface feature to increase surface area contact between the outer surface 204a and the encapsulation layer 206. The surface feature may include, without limitation, a pattern, texture, topography, surface finish, or surface chemistry. In one or more embodiments, the surface feature may improve bonding of the encapsulation layer 206 to the outer surface 204a and help secure the encapsulation layer 206 to the outer surface 204a. Thus, an interface is formed between the outer surface 204a and the encapsulation layer 206 with improved bonding compared to a flat outer surface 204a without the surface feature. In one or more embodiments, the surface feature may include a physical roughness or other topographical feature to increase surface area contact, one or more notches, a surface chemistry, or a combination thereof. In one or more embodiments, the surface chemistry may form at least one of an ionic, covalent, or metallic bond between the outer surface 204a and the encapsulation layer 206. In one or more embodiments, the BDC construct 202 may have a cylindrical shape. Although the BDC construct 202 is shown as having a cylindrical shape having a diameter D1, it will be appreciated that the BDC construct 202 can be manufactured and/or processed to have a variety of shapes, including but not limited to ovals, spheres, cylinders, trapezoids, rectangles and squares. The encapsulation layer 206 may have a thickness T2, and the outer surface 206a may have an outer diameter D2. In one or more embodiments, the thickness T2 of the encapsulation layer 206 along a longitudinal central axis may be nonuniform. In other embodiments, the thickness T2 along a radial axis may be nonuniform.
In one or more embodiments, as shown in
In the embodiment shown in
Referring again to
Utilizing the cloth-based batch processing procedure described above with reference to
Other hardfacing processes may be employed to bind the BDC constructs 202 to the push the bit pad 504 while hardfacing the first surface 506a. For example, laser, rope and rod hardfacing, induction brazing and infiltration processes may be employed.
In a laser hardfacing process, a laser beam may be focused to a particular spot size on the first surface 506a. A hard metal powder, e.g. a WC powder, may be carried to the focused spot in a stream of inert gas to be deposited through nozzles onto the first surface 506a. The laser beam and the nozzles may be moved across the first surface 506a in any particular pattern intersecting the constructs 202 in the plugs 508. The energy of the laser binds the powder to itself, the constructs 202 and the first surface 506a of the pad 504.
In a rope hardfacing process, a rope constructed with a metallic wire as a core and an exterior skin material comprising a hardfacing mixture of tungsten carbide particles, alloying and binder materials. The first surface 506a and the BDC constructs 202 may be hardfaced by progressively melting the rope and allowing the melted material to solidify. An oxyacetylene torch may be used to heat the rope, pad 504 and constructs 202. In a rod hardfacing process, the hardfacing materials may be supplied in the form of an elongate rod. The hardfacing materials may be deposited onto the pad 504 by brazing or welding. For example, in some embodiments, the rod may be used as an electrode in an arc welding process in which an electric arc is induced between the rod and the pad 504 to provide heat to melt and bind the hardfacing materials to the pad.
In an induction brazing process, an induction coil may be employed to provide an electormagnetic field without contacting the pad 504. The electromagnetic field may heat ferrous material in binder matrix applied to the first surface 506a and the constructs 202. In an infiltration process, a mold may be formed around the pad 504, and a hardfacing powder may be placed into a cavity defined between the pad and a mold. Thereafter, a molten binder may be permitted to flow into the mold to bind the hardfacing powder to the first surface 506a and the constructs 202. In other embodiments, a spray and fuse process maybe employed as described below.
In
Silicon carbide bonded diamond (ScD) as a BDC material offers several advantages over other materials. Although ScD elements offers good thermal stability compared to PCI) elements, ScD elements may be sensitive to temperature degradation when subjected to the very high temperatures required for hard-facing. Using the disclosed process, BDC constructs 202 can now be attached using induction brazing without causing material degradation onto wear surfaces of downhole tools. Furthermore, the packing density of BDC constructs 202 can be improved to increase tool component wear resistance. Moreover, the disclosed process allows BDC constructs 202 to be used in spray and fuse applications and in plasma transferred arc processes. Although the compacts primarily described herein have been formed using bonded diamond powder or bonded cubic boron nitride powder, it will be appreciated that the disclosure need not be limited to such compacts and includes bonded compacts formed of superhard materials.
In one or more embodiments, the hard-facing process may be automated, and/or performed using batch/hulk processing. For example, the BDC constructs 202 may be arranged in a prearranged pattern, after which thermal spray may be applied over the BDC constructs 202. The process may subsequently incorporate a furnace brazing step in a batch process without concerns for heat damage.
In any event, the BDC constructs 702a-d are shown as having a proximal end 718 and a distal end 720 having a face 722 formed at the distal end 720. BDC constructs 702a and 702c are each illustrated as having a generally flat face 722, while BDC constructs 702b and 702d are illustrated as having a shaped face, such as the illustrated domed faces.
As stated above, the degree of partial encapsulation of BDC elements 704a-d may vary, with only the upper or distal most portions of BDC constructs 702a-d (relative to the proximal end 718) having BDC elements 704a-d exposed. It will be appreciated that the exposed portions may be a least likely portion to be affected by temperatures applied adjacent the proximal end 718 of the BDC constructs 702a-d during attachment to the wear surface 714. Thus, encapsulation layer 706 is shown encapsulating BDC elements 704a-d at the proximal end 718 of the BDC constructs 702a-d and extending at least partially along the length of the BDC elements 704a-d towards the distal end 720 of the BDC constructs 702a-d. In BDC construct 702a, encapsulation layer 706 extends around approximately 50% of the length of BDC element 704a, while on BDC construct 702b, encapsulation layer 706 extends around approximately 90% of the length of BDC element 704b. On BDC construct 702c, encapsulation layer 706 encapsulates or covers all but the face 722 of BDC construct 702c. Finally, on BDC construct 702d, encapsulation layer 706 encapsulates or covers all of the body of BDC element 704d and a portion of the face 722 of BDC construct 702d, leaving a portion of the face exposed and not covered by encapsulation layer 706.
It is desirable to provide improved thermal stability in BDCs. It is particularly desirable to provide such improved stability by incorporating in the design of the BDC construct an encapsulation layer including a thermally stable metal element, the encapsulation layer surrounding an outer surface of the BDC, encapsulating the BDC, and forming a chemically bonded interface. In some embodiments, the BDC is fully encapsulated, while in other embodiments, the BDC is sufficiently encapsulated so as to prevent heat damage to the BDC during attachment of the BDC to a downhole tool wear component such as onto mud motor bearings, push the bit pads, and drill bit cutting faces.
Typically, downhole tool components incorporate wear or cutting elements hard-faced on various parts that push against the formation. These parts may include pads or pistons. One challenge is that the abrasive wear on these parts can be extreme, therefore requiring a very effective hard-facing. Technologies utilizing laser cladding and spray & fuse (or PTA) applied tungsten-carbide (WC) tiles suffer from accelerated wear. Other hard materials (such as silicon carbide (SiC) bonded diamond, polycrystalline diamond) may provide excellent wear properties but suffer from a variety of issues such braze wettability as well as temperature sensitivity. For example, thermal damage to a PDC during hard-facing procedures is common and can result in the diamond matrix cracking and losing integrity under thermal stress.
Moreover, BDCs can be difficult to attach to downhole tool components. It is often necessary to employ multiple attachment techniques. For example, the silicon carbon bonded diamond (ScD) may employ Ni-coating, CVD based tungsten coatings, nanostructured W-WC coatings, Ti coating, foil wrap, carbide shoe encapsulation, etc. Most of these techniques either perform inadequately during brazing/hard-facing or have field issues as a result of lack of interfacial strength. For example, a mud motor bearing may include embedded wear elements. A mud motor bearing typically requires bearings that possess superior wear resistance, thermal stability, and a low dynamic friction coefficient in order to extend useful wear life. Current WC tile-based or laser cladded bearings suffer heat damage, accelerated wear and relatively high dynamic friction coefficients. Thus, mud motor wear surfaces may experience failures due to the lack of adequate interfacial strength. Where WC tiles are used to create a wear surface on a bearing, the wear tile may crack under thermal stress during the hard-facing process or thermal damage under operation as a result of higher dynamic friction coefficients between WC based mating surfaces. BDCs on the other hand can provide much better thermal stability and much improved dynamic friction coefficients. However, they are difficult to attach, weld, and/or braze as a result of either lack of electrical conductivity and/or wettability.
Illustrative embodiments disclose a method to process these hard materials, such as BDCs, with encapsulating material using a high isostatic pressure process. In one or more embodiments, encapsulating the BDCs generates an effective thermal barrier to heat damage either during hard-facing or during brazing.
In one or more embodiments, the high isostatic pressure process provides significantly better interfacial strength between the BDC and encapsulating material over current encapsulation techniques that use either a low strength brazing or an ineffective nickel or titanium plating. In addition, the disclosed encapsulated BDC constructs offers improved interfacial strength when compared to a foil, coated, or carbide shoe techniques commonly used. The encapsulation process also increases weldability and braze-ability with a fully customizable chemistry in the encapsulation layer.
In one or more embodiments, the dynamic friction coefficient for mud motor bearing applications is increased as a result of incorporating the BDC constructs on the bearing surfaces.
In one or more embodiments, encapsulation of the BDC construct greatly improves shaping ability. BDCs can be very difficult to grind and experience cracking failures during grinding. BDCs can also be very difficult to electrostatically shape and electrostatically finish due to the limited electrical conductivity. Encapsulation can be optimized to have a required thermal stability to facilitate grinding and electrostatic shaping/finishing since the encapsulation layer is customizable. The embodiments illustrated herein show various encapsulation options, where the encapsulation layer fully or partially envelopes the BDC. As used herein, “full” encapsulation refers to a BDC that is completely enclosed within the encapsulation layer, while “partial” encapsulation refers to a BDC where the encapsulation layer encloses at least that portion of the BDC most susceptible to thermal degradation during attachment to a substrate. For example, a base or proximal end of the BDC may be encased in the encapsulation layer and the encapsulation layer may extend up and around the BDC with only a portion of the top or distal most end or face of the BDC exposed. The encapsulation of the BDC could be symmetrically disposed about the outer surface of the BDC along the central longitudinal axis of the BDC compact. In one or more embodiments, the encapsulation layer could be disposed asymmetrically on the outer surface of the BDC along the central longitudinal axis of the BDC. In one or more embodiments, the encapsulation layer could be disposed symmetrically on the outer surface of the BDC along the central longitudinal axis of the BDC and asymmetrically along the transverse axis of the BDC.
The above specific example embodiments are not intended to limit the scope of the claims. The example embodiments may be modified by including, excluding, or combining one or more features or functions described in the disclosure.
Thus, a wear component for a downhole tool has been described. The downhole tool may be a drill bit assembly, and include a drill bit, a plug section located within an outer surface of the drill bit or push the bit pad; a diamond material compact; a substrate located on said bonded diamond material compact; an encapsulation material bonded to said substrate using a high isostatic pressure, wherein the encapsulation material fully envelopes the bonded diamond material compact; and the fully enveloped diamond material compact is disposed within the plug section of the drill bit or a push the bit pad. The downhole tool may be a drill bit assembly, and include a drill bit, a plug section located within an outer surface of the drill bit or push the bit pad; a diamond material compact; a substrate located on said bonded diamond material compact; an encapsulation material bonded to said substrate using a high isostatic pressure, wherein the encapsulation material at least partially envelopes the bonded diamond material compact; and the at least partially enveloped diamond material compact is disposed within the plug section of the drill bit or a push the bit pad. In other embodiments, the downhole tool may be a mud motor assembly having a mud motor bearing; a plug section located within an outer surface of the mud motor bearing; a diamond material compact; a substrate located on said bonded diamond material compact; an encapsulation material bonded to said substrate using a high isostatic pressure, wherein the encapsulation material fully envelopes the bonded diamond material compact; and the fully enveloped diamond material compact is disposed within the plug section of the mud motor bearing. In other embodiments, the downhole tool may be a mud motor assembly having a mud motor bearing; a plug section located within an outer surface of the mud motor bearing; a diamond material compact; a substrate located on said bonded diamond material compact; an encapsulation material bonded to said substrate using a high isostatic pressure, wherein the encapsulation material at least partially envelopes the bonded diamond material compact; and the at least partially enveloped diamond material compact is disposed within the plug section of the mud motor bearing. In other embodiments, the downhole tool may be a mud motor assembly having a mud motor bearing; a plug section located within an outer surface of the mud motor bearing; a bonded material compact; a substrate located on said bonded material compact; an encapsulation material bonded to said substrate using a high isostatic pressure, wherein the encapsulation material at least partially envelopes the bonded material compact; and the at least partially enveloped bonded material compact is disposed within the plug section of the mud motor bearing. The downhole tool may be a drill bit assembly, and include a drill bit or push pad, a plug section located within an outer surface of the drill bit or push the bit pad; a superhard material compact; a substrate located on said superhard material compact; an encapsulation material bonded to said substrate using a high isostatic pressure, wherein the encapsulation material fully or partially envelopes the superhard material compact; and the fully or partially enveloped superhard material compact is disposed within the plug section of the drill bit or a push the bit pad. The downhole tool may an apparatus for drilling a subterranean formation, the apparatus including a plug section located within an outer surface of the apparatus; a superhard material compact; a substrate located on said superhard material compact; an encapsulation material bonded to said substrate using a high isostatic pressure, wherein the encapsulation material fully or partially envelopes the superhard material compact; and the fully or partially enveloped superhard material compact is disposed within the plug section of the outer surface of the apparatus.
Any one or more of the above-described downhole tool embodiments may include any one or more of the following elements, alone or in combination:
Likewise, a method for making a diamond construct for attachment to a downhole tool component has been described. In one or more embodiments, the method may include the steps of sintering a diamond matrix powder forming a bonded diamond compact; fully or partially encapsulating the bonded diamond compact with a metallic material; binding the encapsulation material to the bonded diamond compact using a high isostatic pressure forming a diamond construct; inserting the diamond construct into a plug section on the outer of the downhole tool component; and hard-facing and/or brazing the downhole tool component. In other embodiments, the method may include the steps of providing a bonded diamond compact; fully or partially encapsulating the bonded diamond compact with a metallic material; binding the encapsulation material to the bonded diamond compact for form a diamond construct; inserting the diamond construct into a plug section of the downhole tool component; and attaching the diamond construct to the downhole tool component. In other embodiments, the method may include the steps of providing a bonded compact of superhard material; fully or partially encapsulating the bonded compact with a metallic material; binding the encapsulation material to the bonded compact for form a construct; inserting the construct into a plug section of the downhole tool component; and attaching the construct to the downhole tool component.
Any one or more of the above-described method embodiments may include any one or more of the following, alone or in combination:
This application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Application No. 62/812,064 filed Feb. 28, 2019, entitled “Methods to Attach Highly Wear Resistant Materials to Downhole Wear Components,” the disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
8056650 | Middlemiss et al. | Nov 2011 | B2 |
8069935 | Miess et al. | Dec 2011 | B1 |
8517125 | Lockwood | Aug 2013 | B2 |
20110220348 | Jin | Sep 2011 | A1 |
20120067652 | Bellin | Mar 2012 | A1 |
20170107768 | Saini | Apr 2017 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
1958688 | Aug 2008 | EP |
Entry |
---|
Korean Intellectual Property Office, International Search Report and Written Opinion, dated Apr. 22, 2020, 13 pages. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20200277825 A1 | Sep 2020 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62812064 | Feb 2019 | US |