This application claims priority to European Patent Application number 07301224.7, filed Jul. 11, 2007, titled “Microfluidic Devices and Methods for Immiscible Liquid-Liquid Reactions.”
A principal problem of a reaction in which the reactants comprise or are dissolved in two or more immiscible liquids is achieving the desired amounts or rates of mass transfer between the phases. The present invention relates to microstructured fluidic or microfluidic devices and methods for facilitating such immiscible liquid-liquid reactions.
In the chemical production environment, immiscible liquid/liquid reactions face scale-up issues, particularly where large quantities of reactants are to be processed. Since batch tank volume is typically large, delivering the quantity or density of energy required to create and sustain an emulsion during the needed process period becomes a significant limitation. Maximum achievable baffle speeds limit the deliverable quantity or density of energy. There are two general approaches to overcome this problem.
One general approach is to use additional chemicals as one or more phase transfer catalysts. The disadvantage of use of a phase transfer catalyst (defined herein as including a large molecule with a polar end, like tetraamine salts or sulfonatic acid salts, and a hydrophobic part, typically having long alkyl chains) is the typical necessity of adding the catalyst compound to one of the reactive liquid phases, which, after the reactions are complete, complicates the work-up procedure, which is in general a phase separation.
Another general approach is to achieve a high surface to volume ratio of the liquids within the reactor used for the reaction.
One way to achieve a high surface to volume ratio is to create a stable emulsion. But a stable emulsion also causes difficulties in the following work-up procedures.
A temporary high surface to volume ratio (or unstable emulsion) may be obtained by the injection of droplets. This method has the disadvantage of generally needing a large ratio between the volumes of the injected and host liquids, which typically requires the use of excess liquid.
Other possibilities for making an unstable emulsion are rotor-stators and ultrasonification, both of which have the drawback that they generally have to be specifically adapted to the size of the batch, which becomes more difficult with increasing batch size.
Among other options for creating unstable emulsions, static mixers are often cited in the literature and applied in practice. To enhance emulsification beyond that provided by a single static mixing device, the length of static mixing is increased by placing multiple static mixing devices in series. This configuration is meant to enhance emulsification by adding length to the static mixing zone inside the tubing where the liquids flow. Mixing capacity may be increased over a single static mixer device by use of a parallel configuration of multiple static mixers as in a multitubular reactor.
The present inventors and/or their colleagues have previously developed various microfluidic devices of the general form shown in
Note that the terms “horizontal” and “vertical,” as used in this document are relative terms only and indicative of a general relative orientation only, and do not necessarily indicate perpendicularity, and are also used for convenience to refer to orientations used in the figures, which orientations are used as a matter of convention only and not intended as characteristic of the devices shown. The present invention and the embodiments thereof to be described herein may be used in any desired orientation, and horizontal and vertical walls need generally only be intersecting walls, and need not be perpendicular.
A reactant passage 26, partial detail of which is shown in prior art
For reactions where increased thermal control is desirable, the present inventors and/or their colleagues have also developed microfluidic devices of the type shown in prior art
The device shown in
Although good performance has been obtained with devices of the types shown above in
High surface to volume ratios of immiscible fluids are sometimes obtained by the use of micro channels in the size range of, e.g., 0.25 mm×0.1 mm, in which the reactants move in a laminar flow. The disadvantage is that such small reaction channels have a small volume, even relative to the devices of
According to one embodiment of one aspect of the present invention, methods of contacting two or more immiscible liquids comprise (1) providing a unitary thermally-tempered microstructured fluidic device comprising a reactant passage therein with characteristic cross-sectional diameter in the 0.2 millimeter to 15 millimeter range, having, in order along a length thereof, two or more inlets for entry of reactants, an initial mixer passage portion characterized by having a form or structure that induces a degree of mixing in fluids passing therethrough, an initial dwell time passage portion characterized by having a volume of at least 0.1 milliliter and a generally smooth and continuous form or structure and one or more additional mixer passage portions, each additional mixer passage portion followed immediately by a corresponding respective additional dwell time passage portion; and (2) flowing the two or more immiscible fluids through the reactant passage, wherein the two or more immiscible fluids are flowed into the two or more inlets such that the total flow of the two or more immiscible fluids flows through the initial mixer passage portion.
According to embodiments of another aspect of the present invention, unitary devices in which the method may be performed are also disclosed.
One such embodiment comprises a unitary thermally tempered microstructured fluidic device having a reactant passage therein with characteristic cross-sectional diameter in the 0.2 millimeter to 15 millimeter range and having in order along a length of the reactant passage: (1) two or more inlets for entry of reactants (2) an initial mixer passage portion characterized by having a form or structure that induces a degree of mixing in fluids passing therethrough (3) an initial dwell time passage portion characterized by having a volume of at least 0.1 milliliter and a generally smooth and continuous form or structure that generally maximizes the available volume within the passage relative to the available volume within the device and (4) one or more respective stabilizer passage portions, each stabilizer passage portion characterized by having a form or structure that induces a degree of mixing in fluids passing therethrough, each stabilizer passage portion followed immediately by a corresponding respective additional dwell time passage portion.
Another such embodiment comprises a unitary thermally tempered microstructured fluidic device having a reactant passage therein with characteristic cross-sectional diameter in the 0.2 millimeter to 15 millimeter range, the passage having, in order along a length thereof: (1) two or more inlets for entry of reactants (2) an initial mixing passage portion characterized by having a form or structure that induces a degree of mixing and a first degree of pressure drop in fluids passing therethrough (3) an initial dwell time passage portion characterized by having a volume of at least 0.1 milliliter and a generally smooth and continuous form or structure that generally maximizes the available volume within the passage relative to the available volume within the device (4) one or more respective stabilizer passage portions, each stabilizer passage portion characterized by having a form or structure that induces a degree of mixing and a second degree of pressure drop in fluids passing therethrough, the second degree of pressure drop being less than the first degree, each stabilizer passage portion followed immediately by a corresponding respective additional dwell time passage portion.
Additional features and advantages of the invention will be set forth in the detailed description which follows, and in part will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art from that description or recognized by practicing the invention as described herein, including the detailed description which follows, the claims, as well as the appended drawings.
It is to be understood that both the foregoing general description and the following detailed description present embodiments of the invention, and are intended to provide an overview or framework for understanding the nature and character of the invention as it is claimed. The accompanying drawings are included to provide a further understanding of the invention, and are incorporated into and constitute a part of this specification. The drawings illustrate various embodiments of the invention, and together with the description serve to explain the principles and operations of the invention.
Reference will now be made in detail to the presently preferred embodiments of the invention, examples of which are illustrated in the accompanying drawings. Whenever possible, the same reference numerals will be used throughout the drawings to refer to the same or like parts.
By “unitary” is understood herein a device that is structured and arranged such that the device is generally not understood to be capable of non-destructive disassembly. Some examples include glass, glass-ceramic, and ceramic microstructured devices prepared according to the methods developed by the present inventors and/or their colleagues and disclosed for example in U.S. Pat. No. 7,007,709, G. Guzman et al., 2006. Such materials and methods are useful in the context of the present invention.
The method and the microstructured fluidic device represented by
The alternation of mixer or emulsification zones and dwell time or reaction zones provides the volume needed for the reaction time, which is generally not the case in a microstructure that contains only a long, narrow and tortuous emulsification zone. Such a long emulsification zone has the disadvantage of a small volume, which represents a short reaction time.
It will be appreciated that methods represented by the diagram of
Almost for all micromixer designs, the higher the flowrate, the better the quality of the emulsion is obtained. The devices of the present invention have the advantage of using high flowrate while still keeping the residence time compatible with the reaction time required by the reaction kinetics.
One presently preferred embodiment of a device according to the present invention is shown in
As in the schematic diagram of
The method and the microstructured fluidic device represented by
In the device of
In contrast with the structure of
The self-sustaining oscillating jet stabilizers 44 of
An amidation reaction was used as test reaction. The test procedure was the following: 1.682 g (0.01 mol) of 2-phenylacetic chloride (1) was dissolved in 1 L of dry ethyl acetate or toluene. 1-phenylethylamin (1.212 g, 0.01 mol) was dissolved in 1 L of 0.1 N sodium hydroxide solution. The two immiscible solutions were pumped with a constant ratio of 1:1 through the reactor with various flow rates at room temperature. The reaction was quenched at the exit of the reactor by collecting the liquids in a beaker containing a 1N acid chloride solution. The organic phase was separated, dried and injected into a gas chromatograph for analysis.
The order of injection was not important; switching the inlets used for organic and aqueous phases did not have an impact on the yield. One reactant was injected at the inlet A of test a structure like that shown in
Trace 50 shows the yield results from the a device like that of
To give an illustration of how the design principles and methods described herein can be used and adapted to a specific chemical reaction case, we propose the following simple analysis of a reaction system, without intending to be bound thereby. The optimal number N of total mixing and/or emulsification elements is considered as the variable for the analysis and calculated to find the trade-off between (i) pressure drop, (ii) total volume of the reactor to provide sufficient reaction time and (iii) the maximum diameter of the droplet in the dispersed phase of the emulsion.
The notations used are the following: γ interfacial tension, ρ density of the mixture, S solubility of the dispersed phase in the continuous medium, D diffusion coefficient, R gas molar constant, T temperature, V total volume of the reactor, Vm volume of one emulsification element, VDT volume of one straight segment, ΔPm the pressure drop in one emulsification element, and Q total volumetric flowrate.
The emulsion is created by shear stress in each emulsification element and we can take the following equation to assess the energy dissipated Em in this process for the entire reactor, which is independent of the number of emulsification elements but depends only on the design of one single unit:
The maximum diameter dmax of the droplets in the dispersed phase can then be assessed by:
Once this diameter has been assessed, the time of stability of the emulsion can be evaluated to give an order of magnitude for the desirable volume of the straight channels. For the simplicity of the demonstration, we can assume that destabilization of the emulsion follows a maturing process (although other mechanisms could be envisaged, such as coalescence). For such a process, the radiuses of the droplets scale as:
r
4
=r
0
4
+kt (3)
where k is a constant defined by the mixture properties:
The radius of the droplet at the outlet of one emulsification element can be taken as dmax/2, if we want to minimize the size of the droplets in the reactor. The pressure drop created in the reactor may be written
ΔP=N(ΔPm+ΔPDT) (5)
and total volume may be written V=N(Vm+VDT), which is approximately equal to V=N·VDT if the volume of the emulsification element is neglected. This enables us to calculate the total residence time τ=V/Q.
For given reaction and process conditions, the flowrate Q and the total residence time needed r are set. If we also assume the design of an emulsification element is defined, then all parameters are set except the number of these elements N. This number will be defined by addressing the two following criteria: (i) the radiuses at the entrance of any emulsification element should be minimized (i.e., at the outlet of the previous straight channel) (ii) pressure drop should be minimized. Such a condition allows us to write, following the preceding equations (r0, k, τ, ΔPm and ΔPDT being constant for a given optimization case):
where both r and ΔP have to be minimized with respect to N.
We have chosen the two systems taken in the reported data for the numerical example, namely ethyl-acetate (C4H802)-water and toluene (C7H8)-water systems:
We take the following assumptions for the reactor and reaction/process conditions:
Q=150 ml/min
ΔPm=0.3 bar (dependent on solvent viscosity, but kept constant here for simplicity)
ΔPDT=0.15 bar (dependent on solvent viscosity, but kept constant here for simplicity)
τ=20 s
This leads to the following result:
Values reported above are large and correspond to poor stability of the emulsion, which is why we need to implement our invention in this case.
Another simple estimation of orders of magnitude will show that the inventive integrated approach described in this invention disclosure leads to efficient prevention of coalescence. In shear driven coalescence of droplets in a viscous continuous phase, the value for the maximum radius R of coalesced droplets can be assessed with several models; one of these models (Immobile Interface approach) gives:
with hc the critical film thickness for drainage between two droplets, τ the shear rate, ηm the dynamic viscosity of the continuous liquid phase.
For a cylindrical tube of diameter D, the shear stress τ at radius r is given by:
Hence, the volume fraction of liquid under a shear rate leading to a maximum coalescence radius Rc is given by:
This number is clearly highly dependent on internal diameter of the tube and therefore explains why achieving small dimensions between two stabilizers is of prime importance.
The same analysis can be done with a channel with rectangular cross-section. It is demonstrated that the aspect ratio is the key factor to provide sufficient shear for a given volume of microchannel. The details for the calculation of the shear rate can be found in P.-S. Lee & S. V. Garimella, Thermally developing flow and heat transfer in rectangular microchannels of different aspect ratios, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, vol. 49, pp. 3060-3067, 2006.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
07301224.7 | Jul 2007 | EP | regional |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/US2008/008538 | 7/11/2008 | WO | 00 | 5/14/2010 |