Patent Grant
10906014
The invention generally relates to a mixing device.
Hypochlorous acid (HOCl) is a weak acid that is known to rapidly inactivate bacteria, algae, fungus, and other organics, making it an effective agent across a broad range of microorganisms. Additionally, since hypochlorous acid is a weak acid and since people naturally produce certain compounds that allow them to tolerate hypochlorous acid (e.g., the amino acid taurin), it is generally not harmful to people. Due to the combination of its biocide properties and its safety profile, hypochlorous acid has been found to have many beneficial uses across many different industries, such as the medical, foodservice, food retail, agricultural, wound care, laboratory, hospitality, dental, or floral industries.
Hypochlorous acid is formed when chlorine dissolves in water. One manufacturing method involves the electrochemical activation of a saturated salt solution (e.g., brine) to form HOCl. Another production method involves the disproportionation of chlorine gas in alkaline solutions.
A problem with hypochlorous acid produced by these methods is that it is highly unstable, and over a short period of time (e.g., a few hours to a couple of weeks) the hypochlorous acid will degrade. The distribution of chloric compounds in aqueous solution is known to be a function of pH. As the pH of a solution containing hypochlorous acid becomes more acidic (e.g., pH below 3), chlorine gas is formed. As the pH of a solution containing hypochlorous acid becomes more basic (e.g., pH above 8) hypochlorite anions (OCl—; i.e., bleach) are formed, which are also toxic to people. Thus, while being an effective biocide, the use of hypochlorous acid has been limited by the need for onsite generation and the challenge of maintaining storage stability.
The invention recognizes that aspects of the production process for making hypochlorous acid (HOCl) may contribute to the instability of the product. In this manner, the invention provides a mixing device that may be used for mixing based methods of producing hypochlorous acid that do not rely on electrolysis or use of chlorine gas. The device assists in producing a more stable form of hypochlorous acid that can be bottled and stored for a significant period of time (e.g., from at least a couple of months to 6 to 12 months or longer), eliminating the need for onsite generation and overcoming the challenges of maintaining storage stability.
In certain aspects, mixing devices of the invention include a fluidic inlet, a fluidic outlet, and a chamber, the chamber being configured to produce a plurality of fluidic vortexes within the chamber. Any chamber configuration that produces a plurality of vortices is includes with devices of the invention. In certain embodiments, the chamber includes a plurality of members, the members being spaced apart and fixed within the chamber perpendicular to the inlet and the outlet in order to form a plurality of sub-chambers. Each member includes at least one aperture that allows fluid to flow there through. The members are of a size such that they may be fixed to an interior wall within the chamber. In this manner, water cannot flow around the members and can only pass through the apertures in each member to move through mixing device.
With such a configuration, a fluidic vortex is produced within each sub-chamber. The apertures can be the same or different (e.g., size, shape, placement in the member, etc.) within a single member and may be the same or different across the plurality of members. In certain embodiments, the apertures all have the same diameter. In other embodiments, the apertures have different diameters. The size of the apertures will depend on the flow of water and the pressure in the system. Generally, the apertures will have a diameter from about 1 mm to about 1 cm. In particular embodiments, the diameter of the apertures is about 6 mm.
In devices of the invention, the inlet is configured to sealably mate with an inlet channel, and the outlet is configured to sealably mate with an outlet channel. Such features allows the mixing devices to be placed in-line with fluidic systems for an automated production process.
The basis of compositions and methods of the invention is the protonation of the hypochlorite ion (OCl−). Using HCl and NaOCl as an example, the protonation is accomplished by introducing an acid (e.g., HCl) to the solution, which results in the following reaction occurring:
HCl(aq)NaOCl(aq)↔HOCl(aq)+NaCl(aq).
The hypochlorous acid in aqueous solution partially dissociates into the anion hypochlorite (OCl−), thus in aqueous solution there is always an equilibrium between the hypochlorous acid and the anion (OCl−). This equilibrium is pH dependent and at higher pH the anion dominates. In aqueous solution, hypochlorous acid, is also in equilibrium with other chlorine species, in particular chlorine gas, Cl2, and various chlorine oxides. At acidic pH, chlorine gases become increasingly dominant while at neutral pH the different equilibria result in a solution dominated by hypochlorous acid. Thus, it is important to control exposure to air and pH in the production of hypochlorous acid.
Additionally, the concentration of protons (H+) affects the stability of the product. The invention recognizes that the proton concentration can be controlled by using an acid that has a lesser ability at a given pH to donate a proton (i.e., the acid can provide buffering capacity). For example, conducting the process with acetic acid instead of hydrochloric acid is optimal when the desired pH of the final solution is approximately the pKa of acetic acid. This can be achieved by mixing ratios in water of 250× or greater, meaning 1 part proton donor at 100% concentration (e.g., HCl or acetic acid) to 250 parts water.
The invention generally relates to methods of producing hypochlorous acid (HOCl). In certain embodiments, methods of the invention involve mixing together in water in an air-free environment, a compound that generates a proton (H+) in water and a compound that generates a hypochlorite anion (OC−) in water to thereby produce air-free hypochlorous acid. The water may be tap water or purified water, such as water purchased from a water purification company, such as Millipore (Billerica, Mass.). Generally, the pH of the water is maintained from about 4.5 to about 9 during the method, however the pH may go above and below this range during the production process. Conducting methods of the invention in an air-free environment prevents the build-up of chlorine gases during the production process. Further, conducting methods of the invention in an air-free environment further stabilizes the produced HOCl.
Any compound that produces a hypochlorite anion (OCl−) in water may be used with methods of the invention. Exemplary compounds include NaOCl and Ca(OCl)2. In particular embodiments, the compound is NaOCl. Any compound that produces a proton (H+) in water may be used with methods of the invention. Exemplary compounds are acids, such as acetic acid, HCl and H2SO4. In particular embodiments, the compound is HCl. In preferred embodiments, the compound is acetic acid because it is a weaker acid with a preferred pKa to HCl, meaning, it donates less protons during the reaction than HCl and able to maintain the preferred pH level better.
Methods of the invention can be conducted in any type of vessel or chamber or fluidic system. In certain embodiments, a fluidic system 100 as shown in
Pipes 101a-c generally have an inner diameter that ranges from about 5 mm to about 50 mm, more preferably from about 17 mm to about 21 mm. In specific embodiments, the pipes 101a-c have an inner diameter of about 21 mm. Pipes 101a-c generally have a length from about 10 cm to about 400 cm, more preferably from about 15 cm to about 350 cm. In certain embodiments, pipes 101a-c have the same length. In other embodiments, pipes 101a-c have different lengths. In specific embodiments, pipe 101a has a length of about 105 cm, pipe 101b has a length of about 40 cm, and pipe 101c has a length of about 200 cm.
The pipes and mixers can be made from any inert material such that material from the pipes and mixers does not become involved with the reaction occurring within the fluidic system. Exemplary materials include PVC-U. Pipes are commercially available from Georg Ficher AB. The pipes and mixers can be configured to have a linear arrangement such that the pipes and the mixers are arranged in a straight line. Alternatively, the pipes and mixers can have a non-linear arrangement, such that the water must flow through bends and curves throughout the process. System 100 shows a non-linear configuration of the pipes 101a-c and mixers 102 and 103.
Pipe 101a is an inlet pipe that receives the water that will flow through the system. Generally, the water in pipes 101a-c is under a pressure of at least about 0.1 bar, such as for example, 0.2 bar or greater, 0.3 bar or greater, 0.4 bar or greater, 0.5 bar or greater, 0.7 bar or greater, 0.9 bar or greater, 1.0 bar or greater, 1.2 bar or greater, 1.3 bar or greater, or 1.5 bar or greater. At such pressures, a turbulent water flow is produced, thus the reagents are introduced to a highly turbulent water flow which facilitates an initial mixing of the reagents with the water prior to further mixing in the mixing devices 102 and 103.
In order to control the pH during the production process, the incoming water should have a buffering capacity in the range of pH 3.5-9.0, more preferably from 6.0 and 8.0, to facilitate addition of the compounds that generates the proton and the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion. The dissolved salts and other molecules found in most tap waters gives the tap water a buffering capacity in the range of pH 5.5-9.0, and thus tap water is a suitable water to be used with methods of the invention.
In certain embodiments, deionized water with the addition of known buffering agents to produce a water having a buffering capacity in the range of pH 3.5-9.0 is used. On example of a buffer in this particular range is phosphate buffer. For greater process control and consistency, using a formulated deionized water may be preferable to using tap water because tap water can change between locations and also over time. Additionally, using deionized water with known additives also ensures a stable pH of the incoming water flow. This process is discussed in greater detail below.
In particular embodiments, an initial pH of the water prior to addition of either the compounds that generates the proton or the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion is at least about 8.0, including 8.1 or greater, 8.2 or greater, 8.3 or greater, 8.4 or greater, 8.5 or greater, 8.6 or greater, 8.7 or greater, 8.8 or greater, 8.9 or greater, 9.0 or greater, 9.5 or greater, 10.0 or greater, 10.5 or greater, or 10.8 or greater. In specific embodiments, the pH of the water prior to addition of either the compound that generates the proton or the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion is 8.4.
Methods of the invention include introducing to the water the compound that generates the proton and the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion in any order (e.g., simultaneously or sequentially) and in any manner (aqueous form, solid form, etc.). For example, the compound that generates the proton and the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion are each aqueous solutions and are introduced to the water sequentially, e.g., the compound that generates the proton may be introduced to the water first and the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion may be introduced to the water second. However, methods of the invention include other orders for sequential introduction of the compound that generates the proton and the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion.
System 100 is configured for sequential introduction of reagents to the water flow, and the process is described herein in which the compound that generates the proton is introduced to the water first and the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion is introduced to the water second. In certain embodiments, the compound that generates the proton and the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion are introduced to the water in small aliquots, e.g, from about 0.1 mL to about 0.6 mL. The iterative and minute titrations make it possible to control the pH in spite of additions of acid (compound that generates the proton) and alkali (the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion). In certain embodiments, no more than about 0.6 mL amount of compound that generates the proton is introduced to the water at a single point in time. In other embodiments, no more than about 0.6 mL amount of the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion is introduced to the water at a single point in time.
To introduce the reagents to the water, pipe 101a includes an injection port 104 and pipe 101b includes an injection port 105. The injection ports 104 and 105 allow for the introduction of reagents to the water flow. In this embodiments, aqueous compound that generates the proton is introduced to the water in pipe 101a via injection port 104. The compound that generates the proton is introduced by an infusion pump that is sealably connected to port 104. In this manner, the flow rate, and thus the amount, of compound that generates the proton introduced to the water at any given time is controlled. The infusion pump can be controlled automatically or manually. The rate of introduction of the compound that generates the proton to the water is based upon the incoming water quality (conductivity and pH level) and the pressure and the flow of the incoming water. In certain embodiments, the pump is configured to introduce about 6.5 liters per hour of hydrochloric acid into the water. The introducing can be a continuous infusion or in an intermittent manner. Since the water is flowing though the pipes in a turbulent manner, there is an initial mixing of the compound that generates the proton with the water upon introduction of the hydrochloric acid to the water.
Further mixing occurs when the water enters the first mixing device 102.
The mixing device 102 is configured to produce a plurality of fluidic vortexes within the device. An exemplary device configured in such a manner is shown in
Any number of members 109 may be fixed in the chamber 108, the number of members 109 fixed in the chamber 108 will depend on the amount of mixing desired.
A fluidic vortex is produced within each sub-chamber 110a-d. The vortices result from flow of the water through the apertures 111 in each member 109. Methods of the invention allow for any arrangement of the apertures 111 about each member 109.
In certain embodiments, apertures 111 in a member 110 have a first size and apertures 111 in a different member 110 have a different second size. In other embodiments, apertures 111 in at least two different members 110 have the same size. The size of the apertures will depend on the flow of water and the pressure in the system. Exemplary aperture diameters are from about 1 mm to about 1 cm. In specific embodiments, the apertures have a diameter of about 6 mm.
The solution enters mixing device 102 through inlet 106, which is sealably mated with pipe 101a. The solution enters the chamber 108 and turbulent mixing occurs in each of sub-chambers 110a-d as the solution pass through members 109a-d via the apertures 111 in each member 109a-d. After mixing in the final sub-chamber 110d, the water exits the chamber 108 via the fluidic outlet 107 which is sealably mated to pipe 101b.
The compound that generates the hypochlorite anion is next introduced to the solution that is flowing through pipe 101b via injection port 105. The compound that generates the hypochlorite anion is introduced by an infusion pump that is sealably connected to port 105. In this manner, the flow rate, and thus the amount, of compound that generates the hypochlorite anion introduced to the water at any given time is controlled. The infusion pump can be controlled automatically or manually. The rate of introduction of the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion to the water is based upon properties of the solution (conductivity and pH level) and the pressure and the flow of the solution. In certain embodiments, the pump is configured to introduce about 6.5 liters per hour of compound that generates the hypochlorite anion into the solution. The introducing can be a continuous infusion or in an intermittent manner. Since the solution is flowing though the pipes in a turbulent manner, there is an initial mixing of the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion with the solution upon introduction of the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion to the solution.
Further mixing occurs when the solution enters the second mixing device 103. Mixing device 103 includes all of the features discussed above with respect to mixing device 102. Mixing device 103 may be configured the same or differently than mixing device 102, e.g., same or different number of sub-chambers, same or different diameter of apertures, same or different sizes of sub-chambers, etc. However, like mixing device 102, mixing device 103 is configured to produce a fluidic vortex within each sub-chamber.
The solution enters mixing device 103 through an inlet in the device, which is sealably mated with pipe 101b. The solution enters the mixing chamber and turbulent mixing occurs in each sub-chamber of the mixing device as the solution pass through members in the chamber via the apertures in each member. After mixing in the final sub-chamber, the water exits the chamber via the fluidic outlet in the mixing device which is sealably mated to pipe 101c.
At this point, the reaction has been completed and the HOCl has been formed. The production is controlled in-line by measuring pH and conductivity. The pH is used in combination with conductivity based on a pre-calibrated relation between the conductivity and concentration of HOCl measured with spectrophotometry. The measured conductivity is a measure of the solvent's ability to conduct an electric current. Comparing the same matrix with different known concentrations of HOCl and OCl—, a calibration curve (
Pipe 101c can be connected to a switch valve 112 that switches between a waste line 113 and a product collection line 114. Shown in
The HOCl that has been produced in an air-free manner is collected and bottled in an air-free manner. Placing liquids into a bottle in an air-free manner is known in the art. An exemplary method includes placing an inflatable vessel (such as a balloon) into a bottle. The inflatable vessel is connected directly to the collection line 114 and the HOCl is pumped directed into the inflatable vessel in the bottle without ever being exposed to air. Another method involves filling the bottles under vacuum. Another air-free filling method involves filling the bottles in an environment of an inert gas that does not interact with the HOCl, such as an argon environment.
The produced hypochlorous acid is air-free and will have a pH from about 4.5 to about 7.5. However, the pH of the produced HOCl can be adjusted post production process by adding either acid (e.g., HCl) or alkali (e.g., NaOCl) to the produced hypochlorous acid. For example, a pH of between about 4.5 and about 7 is particularly suitable for the application of reprocessing heat sensitive medical instruments. Other applications, such as its use in non-medical environments, for example as in the processing of poultry and fish and general agricultural and petrochemical uses, the breaking down of bacterial biofilm and water treatment, may demand different pH levels.
The process can be performed manually or in an automated manner. Fluidic systems described herein can be operably connected to a computer that controls the production process. The computer may be a PCL-logic controller system. The computer opens and closes the valves for the water inlet, the waste water outlet, and the product outlet according to the feedback received from the sensors in the system (e.g., conductivity, pH, and concentration of product (ppm) being produced). The computer can also store the values for the water pressures and water amounts and can adjust these according to the feedback received from the sensors regarding the properties of the HOCl being produced. The computer can also control the infusion pumps that inject the reagents into the water for the production process.
The process can be performed iteratively in that pipe 101c can be attached to a second fluidic system and the produced HOCl is then flowed through the second system where the process described above is repeated with the starting solution being HOCl instead of water. In this manner, an increased yield of HOCl is produced. Any number of fluidic systems may be interconnected with methods of the invention.
In certain embodiments, further mixing of the water and buffer is performed prior to conducting the process of producing the HOCl. In those embodiments, further mixing occurs when the water with buffering agent enters the first mixing device 203. Mixing device 203 includes all of the features discussed above with respect to mixing device 102. Mixing device 203 may be configured the same or differently than mixing device 102, e.g., same or different number of sub-chambers, same or different diameter of apertures, same or different sizes of sub-chambers, etc. However, like mixing device 102, mixing device 203 is configured to produce a fluidic vortex within each sub-chamber.
The solution enters mixing device 203 through an inlet in the device, which is sealably mated with pipe 201a. The solution enters the mixing chamber and turbulent mixing occurs in each sub-chambers of the mixing device as the solution pass through members in the chamber via the apertures in each member. After mixing in the final sub-chamber, the water exits the chamber via the fluidic outlet in the mixing device which is sealably mated to pipe 202b. The water has a pH of at least about 8.0, preferably 8.4, and a buffering capacity of pH 5.5-9.0.
The process is now conducted as described above for producing HOCl. The compound that generates the proton is next introduced to the water that is flowing through pipe 201b via injection port 204. The compound that generates the proton is introduced by an infusion pump that is sealably connected to port 204. In this manner, the flow rate, and thus the amount, of compound that generates the proton introduced to the water at any given time is controlled. The infusion pump can be controlled automatically or manually. The rate of introduction of the compound that generates the proton to the water is based upon properties of the water (conductivity and pH level), the buffer composition, and the pressure and the flow of the water. In certain embodiments, the pump is configured to introduce from about 6.5 liters per hour to about 12 liters per hour of compound that generates the proton into the water. The introducing can be a continuous infusion or in an intermittent manner. Since the water is flowing though the pipes in a turbulent manner, there is an initial mixing of the compound that generates the proton with the water upon introduction of the hydrochloric acid to the water.
Further mixing occurs when the solution enters the second mixing device 205. Mixing device 205 includes all of the features discussed above with respect to mixing device 102. Mixing device 205 may be configured the same or differently than mixing device 203, e.g., same or different number of sub-chambers, same or different diameter of apertures, same or different sizes of sub-chambers, etc. However, like mixing device 203, mixing device 205 is configured to produce a fluidic vortex within each sub-chamber.
The solution enters mixing device 205 through an inlet in the device, which is sealably mated with pipe 201b. The solution enters the mixing chamber and turbulent mixing occurs in each sub-chambers of the mixing device as the solution pass through members in the chamber via the apertures in each member. After mixing in the final sub-chamber, the water exits the chamber via the fluidic outlet in the mixing device which is sealably mated to pipe 201c.
The compound that generates the hypochlorite anion is next introduced to the solution that is flowing through pipe 201c via injection port 206. The compound that generates the hypochlorite anion is introduced by an infusion pump that is sealably connected to port 206. In this manner, the flow rate, and thus the amount, of compound that generates the hypochlorite anion introduced to the water at any given time is controlled. The infusion pump can be controlled automatically or manually. The rate of introduction of the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion to the water is based upon properties of the solution (conductivity and pH level) and the pressure and the flow of the solution. In certain embodiments, the pump is configured to introduce about 6.5-12 liters per hour of compound that generates the hypochlorite anion into the solution. The amount introduced depends on the desired concentration of HOCl (ppm) and flow of water through the pipes. The introducing can be a continuous infusion or in an intermittent manner. Since the solution is flowing though the pipes in a turbulent manner, there is an initial mixing of the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion with the solution upon introduction of the compound that generates the hypochlorite anion to the solution.
Further mixing occurs when the solution enters the second mixing device 207. Mixing device 207 includes all of the features discussed above with respect to mixing device 102. Mixing device 207 may be configured the same or differently than mixing devices 205 or 203, e.g., same or different number of sub-chambers, same or different diameter of apertures, same or different sizes of sub-chambers, etc. However, like mixing devices 205 and 203, mixing device 207 is configured to produce a fluidic vortex within each sub-chamber.
The solution enters mixing device 207 through an inlet in the device, which is sealably mated with pipe 201c. The solution enters the mixing chamber and turbulent mixing occurs in each sub-chambers of the mixing device as the solution pass through members in the chamber via the apertures in each member. After mixing in the final sub-chamber, the water exits the chamber via the fluidic outlet in the mixing device which is sealably mated to pipe 201d.
At this point, the reaction has been completed and the HOCl has been formed. The produced HOCl can be measured and collected as described above. Pipe 201d can be connected to a switch valve that switches between a waste line and a product collection line. The valve includes a pH meter and a conductivity measuring device. These devices measure the concentration, purity, and pH of the HOCl being produced and provide feedback for altering such properties of the produced HOCl. Once the HOCl being produced in pipe 201d meets the required concentration, purity, and pH, the valve switches from the waste line to the product collection line to collect the desired product.
In another embodiment, a deionizer is placed in-line with incoming water. The deionizer deionizes the water and then a buffering agent is added to the deionized water. The production process is then conducted as described for embodiments of system 200 to produce water having a pH of at least about 8, for example 8.4, and a buffering capacity of pH 6-8.
The HOCl produced by the above process can be used in numerous different applications, for example medical, foodservice, food retail, agricultural, wound care, laboratory, hospitality, dental, delignification, or floral industries.
Any and all references and citations to other documents, such as patents, patent applications, patent publications, journals, books, papers, web contents, that have been made throughout this disclosure are hereby incorporated herein by reference in their entirety for all purposes.
The invention may be embodied in other specific forms without departing from the spirit or essential characteristics thereof. The foregoing embodiments are therefore to be considered in all respects illustrative rather than limiting on the invention described herein.
When spectrophotometry is expanded to also cover the visible range it is possible to detect colors. The gases generally produced during production of HOCl are ClO2, Cl2O and Cl2, all of which are detectable in the visible range as yellow or yellow-red. Tzanavaras et al. (Central European J. of Chemistry, 2007, 5(1)1-12). Data in
HOCl produced by the process described above was stored under heat stress at 40° C. in order to accelerate degradation using four different types of aqueous solutions: (1) reagent grade water (deionized water); (2) tap water; (3) reagent grade water with a phosphate buffer; and (4) tap water with a phosphate buffer. Characteristics of the HOCl product were monitored after the initial reaction (T=0); four weeks (T=4); eight weeks (T=8); and twelve weeks (T=12).
Using the above described process, HOCl was produced using hydrochloric acid (HCl) and acetic acid and thereafter stored under heat stress at 40C. The amount of HOCl initially produced was recorded (T=0) and then the amount of HOCl product remaining after twelve days was recorded. Three batches of each were produced. The data for the HCl produced HOCl is shown in Table 1. The data for the acetic acid produced HOCl is shown in Table 2.
The data show that using acetic acid provides greater product stability, most likely due to greater stability in the pH. Without being limited by any particular theory or mechanism of action, it is believed that the different protonation capacity of acetic acid as compared to hydrochloric acid, i.e., acetic acid donates fewer protons to a liquid than hydrochloric acid, results in greater HOCl stability over time.
The present application is a continuation of U.S. application Ser. No. 13/770,748, filed Feb. 19, 2013, which claims priority to and the benefit of U.S. provisional application Ser. No. 61/600,347, filed Feb. 17, 2012, the content of which is incorporated by reference herein in its entirety.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2118295 | Crawford | May 1938 | A |
| 2125245 | McCray | Jul 1938 | A |
| 2312639 | Gronemeyer | Mar 1943 | A |
| 2600733 | Clift | Jun 1952 | A |
| 2740616 | Walden | Apr 1956 | A |
| 2929248 | Sprenkle | Mar 1960 | A |
| 2965695 | Sleicher, Jr. | Dec 1960 | A |
| 3045984 | Cochran | Jul 1962 | A |
| 3089683 | Adams | May 1963 | A |
| 3526391 | Church, Jr. | Sep 1970 | A |
| 3545492 | Scheid, Jr. | Dec 1970 | A |
| 3582048 | Sarem | Jun 1971 | A |
| 3855368 | Prochazka | Dec 1974 | A |
| 3856270 | Hemker | Dec 1974 | A |
| 4068830 | Gray | Jan 1978 | A |
| 4201482 | Imhauser | May 1980 | A |
| 4301652 | Sohda | Nov 1981 | A |
| 4427030 | Jouwsma | Jan 1984 | A |
| 4514095 | Ehrfeld | Apr 1985 | A |
| 4684254 | Goudy, Jr. | Aug 1987 | A |
| 4729665 | Goudy, Jr. | Mar 1988 | A |
| 4755325 | Osgerby | Jul 1988 | A |
| 4869849 | Hirose | Sep 1989 | A |
| 4874248 | Luetzelschwab | Oct 1989 | A |
| 4874560 | Titmas | Oct 1989 | A |
| 5327941 | Bitsakis | Jul 1994 | A |
| 5388906 | Rao | Feb 1995 | A |
| 5425858 | Farmer | Jun 1995 | A |
| 5863587 | Badertscher | Jan 1999 | A |
| 5887977 | Morikawa | Mar 1999 | A |
| 5984519 | Onodera | Nov 1999 | A |
| 6114415 | Bertelo | Sep 2000 | A |
| 6145544 | Dutertre | Nov 2000 | A |
| 6186179 | Hill | Feb 2001 | B1 |
| 6227695 | Kubiak | May 2001 | B1 |
| 6305835 | Farrar | Oct 2001 | B1 |
| 6379035 | Kubo | Apr 2002 | B1 |
| 6447158 | Farkas | Sep 2002 | B1 |
| 6530684 | Kolb | Mar 2003 | B1 |
| 6536940 | Kolb | Mar 2003 | B1 |
| 6722780 | Stein | Apr 2004 | B2 |
| 6736376 | DeLisle | May 2004 | B1 |
| 7033499 | Cohee | Apr 2006 | B2 |
| 7175335 | Furukawa | Feb 2007 | B2 |
| 7303732 | Gillis | Dec 2007 | B2 |
| 7582324 | Blank | Sep 2009 | B2 |
| 7621670 | England | Nov 2009 | B1 |
| 7789108 | Lawson | Sep 2010 | B1 |
| 7857095 | Zhang | Dec 2010 | B2 |
| 7905653 | Wilmer | Mar 2011 | B2 |
| 8042989 | Gordon | Oct 2011 | B2 |
| 8641264 | Sawada | Feb 2014 | B2 |
| 8864367 | Hanada | Oct 2014 | B2 |
| 8894273 | Gordon | Nov 2014 | B2 |
| 9010994 | McQueen | Apr 2015 | B2 |
| 9302230 | Soukup | Apr 2016 | B2 |
| 9878293 | Almas | Jan 2018 | B2 |
| 10480668 | Baxter | Nov 2019 | B2 |
| 20020048213 | Wilmer | Apr 2002 | A1 |
| 20020193642 | Gillis | Dec 2002 | A1 |
| 20030007419 | Goebel | Jan 2003 | A1 |
| 20040057334 | Wilmer | Mar 2004 | A1 |
| 20040066703 | Sparey-Taylor | Apr 2004 | A1 |
| 20070070807 | Bracht | Mar 2007 | A1 |
| 20080062813 | Wilmer | Mar 2008 | A1 |
| 20100276820 | Mogami | Nov 2010 | A1 |
| 20110128814 | Hanada | Jun 2011 | A1 |
| 20120188842 | Smith | Jul 2012 | A1 |
| 20130021871 | Strahmann | Jan 2013 | A1 |
| 20140078859 | Lundberg | Mar 2014 | A1 |
| 20150191380 | Glass | Jul 2015 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 1222957 | Jul 2002 | EP |
| 1188516 | Apr 1970 | GB |
| WO-2008147050 | Dec 2008 | WO |
| Entry |
|---|
| Feng et al., 2007, Journal of Environmental Engineering and Science 6:277-84, 8 pages. |
| Tzanavaras et al., 2007, Central European Journal of Chemistry 5(1):1-12, 11 pages. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20180147548 A1 | May 2018 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 61600347 | Feb 2012 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 13770748 | Feb 2013 | US |
| Child | 15879953 | US |
