The invention relates to communication systems and, in particular, to a method and apparatus for inter-module communication.
Communication systems designed to communicate data between remotely located stations that utilize electrical or optical signals have been widely implemented throughout the world. The stations may comprise communication modules designed to demodulate the data, or repeaters, provided to span long distances between remote locations.
It may be desirable to enable system level communication between remotely located stations to exchange communication system data in addition to the network data, thereby improving the transfer of network data between the stations. For example, it is contemplated that analysis could occur on the network data in an attempt to optimize operation of the communication system and that this optimization may be transmitted to another station in the communication system.
Prior art solutions for exchanging system data between remote stations suffer from numerous problems and drawbacks. One prior art solution comprises forcing the communication system to cease transmission of network data so that system data can be exchanged. This is extremely undesirable because it forces the communication system to stop the transmission of network data. This undesirably interrupts operation of the communication system and reduces the overall transmission rate of the communication system for network data.
As an alternative, it has been proposed to insert the system data into the network data, such as by padding the system data bits onto the network data. This, too, is highly undesirable, as it increases the necessary transmit rate in order to accommodate the additional bit. Moreover, it may require that the network data be demodulated, and then re-modulated with the additional system data. This requires additional hardware in each station. In addition, inclusion of system data into the network data stream may cause operation of the communication system to fall outside of the communication standard under which the communication system is operating. This in turn may require non-standard communication hardware or software to accommodate these changes.
As a result, there exists a need for an efficient, cost-effective, and accurate method and apparatus to achieve communication of system data between stations.
To address the need in the art for an efficient and low-complexity inter-station signaling system, a system is disclosed herein for jitter modulating secondary data onto the transmission of network data. The term secondary data is used interchangeably with the term system data and as used herein is defined to have the same meaning. In one embodiment, this system comprises a phase lock loop circuit configured to receive a clock signal and a filter configured to filter the output of the phase lock loop circuit to create a filtered signal. A voltage controlled oscillator is provided to generate an output signal based on the voltage of the filtered signal for use in controlling the phase lock loop circuit. Also part of this system is a variable delay that is configured to introduce an amount of delay into the output signal to create a modified output signal and the amount of delay may be controlled by secondary data. A multiplexer is also provided and is configured to receive network data in a parallel format and output the network data from the multiplexer in a serial format such that the timing of the outputting of the network data from the multiplexer is controlled by the modified output signal.
In one embodiment, the modified output signal represents the secondary data. In one embodiment, the system further comprises a frequency control module configured to modify the frequency of the output signal passing from the voltage controlled oscillator to the phase lock loop. In one such embodiment the system data is thus frequency modulated by time-varying the phase modulation. In another embodiment, the system further comprises an encoder configured to encode the secondary data prior to the secondary data being provided to the variable delay. It is contemplated that the encoder may utilize an orthogonal code.
In another embodiment, a system is provided for modulating secondary data onto a network data signal in a communication device. This device comprises an input for receiving a timing control signal and a timing control system configured to receive the timing control signal, re-time the timing control signal based on the secondary data to create a re-timed control signal, and output the re-timed control signal. The system also includes a switching device that is configured to receive the re-timed control signal and network data and selectively output network data at a time determined by the re-timed control signal.
In one variation to this system, the step of selectively outputting network data based on the re-timed control signal jitter modulates the secondary data onto the network data. In one embodiment, the secondary data comprises system data configured to control operation of a communication device. It is contemplated that the timing control system may comprise a variable delay. As disclosed herein, it is contemplated that the system may further comprise an encoder configured to encode the secondary data, which in turn affects the retiming of the timing control signal. This encoder may utilize an orthogonal code to encode the secondary data.
Also disclosed herein is a method for combining secondary data with network data to allow transmission of the system data with the network data over an optic fiber. In one embodiment, this method comprises the steps of receiving network data and secondary data. The system next generates a transmit timing signal configured to control transmit timing of the network data and introduces a delay into the transmit timing signal to create a re-timed transmit timing signal. The amount of delay may be controlled by the secondary data. Also performed as part of this method is the step of providing the re-timed transmit timing signal and the network data to a processing device configured to control, based on the re-timed transmit timing signal, when the network data is output or transmitted. Thus, the method outputs the network data from the processing device at a time controlled by the re-timed transmit timing signal.
In various embodiments, the processing device may comprise a parallel to serial converter and the delay caused by the re-timed transmit timing signal may introduce low frequency jitter into transmission of the network data. It is also contemplated that the system data or secondary data may control at least one aspect of operation of a remote communication device. In at least one embodiment, this method further comprises encoding the secondary data utilizing an orthogonal code to create encoded secondary data such that the delay is controlled by the encoded secondary data. An orthogonal code may be utilized to create the encoded secondary data. Due to loop bandwidth limitations, in one embodiment the transmission rate of the secondary data may be less than the transmission rate of the network data.
Also disclosed herein is a method for jitter modulating system data with network data to allow transmission of the system data with the network data. In one embodiment, this method comprises receiving network data and receiving system data for transmission with the network data. After reception, the system processes the network data to control the transmit timing of the network data such that the transmit timing is controlled by the system data. In one embodiment, system data provides information to a remote station regarding one or more aspects of operation of a communication system.
After transmission, it is necessary to recover the jitter modulated secondary data. Accordingly, also disclosed herein is a detector for use in a communication system configured to recover secondary data from a received signal. In one embodiment, the detector comprises a network data recovery system configured to recover network data from the received signal, wherein as part of the recovery of network data a loop signal is generated. A voltage detector is included and configured to process the loop signal to determine a change in voltage in the loop signal and is further configured with an output configured to output secondary data from the voltage detector. In one embodiment, the secondary data is related to the change in voltage in the loop signal. Devices other than a voltage detector may be utilized to isolate the secondary data.
It is contemplated that the network data recovery system may comprise a phase detector and a voltage controlled oscillator. In one embodiment, the detector further comprises a decoder configured to perform decoding of the loop signal to thereby recover the secondary data. The decoder may utilize an orthogonal code. It is further contemplated that secondary data may comprise system data configured to provide information regarding one or more aspects of operation of the communication system.
A method for recovering secondary data from network data having secondary data jitter modulated thereon after reception of the network data at a receiving communication device is also disclosed. In one embodiment, this method comprises receiving an input signal comprising network data that has been jitter modulated to contain secondary data. Thereafter, the method processes the input signal with a phase detector to recover the network data and generates a loop signal as part of phase detector operation. This method of operation filters the loop signal to generate a filtered loop signal and processes the filtered loop signal with the voltage detector to recover the secondary data.
In one embodiment, processing the filtered loop signal comprises detecting the changes in voltage in the filtered loop signal to obtain the secondary data. For example, the changes in voltage may correspond to low frequency jitter. It may be necessary, as part of the processing of the filtered loop signal, to decode the filtered loop signal to obtain the secondary data. One form of decoding may comprise multiplying the filtered loop signal with a spreading code.
Other systems, methods, features and advantages of the invention will be or will become apparent to one with skill in the art upon examination of the following figures and detailed description. It is intended that all such additional systems, methods, features and advantages be included within this description, be within the scope of the invention, and be protected by the accompanying claims.
The invention can be better understood with reference to the following figures. The components in the figures are not necessarily to scale, emphasis instead being placed upon illustrating the principles of the invention. Moreover, in the figures, like reference numerals designate corresponding parts throughout the different views.
It is further contemplated that, in addition to network data, it may also be desired to exchange system data between the first station 104 and the second station 108, any of the stations and a repeater, or between repeaters. As discussed above, the term network data comprises data that is exchanged over the network such as customer data, voice data, computer data, or any other data or information. The term system data comprises data that is used by the communication system to achieve or improve the exchange of network data.
By exchanging system data between communication devices, collectively, repeaters, stations, or any other apparatus configured to aid in or enable communication, one or more aspects of the communication system may be monitored, adjusted, or exchanged. For example, one or more aspects of communication can be monitored and steps can be taken to modify some aspect of the communication to optimize the communication. Those of ordinary skill in the art may contemplate other additional uses for the method and apparatus described herein, and hence the claims that follow should not be construed as being limited to the example environments or example implementation set forth herein. Utilizing the method and apparatus described herein, any type of system data may be exchanged between communication devices for any purpose.
In one example embodiment, a low frequency signaling channel utilizing jitter modulation is established to exchange data between communication devices. Through use of low frequency signaling, system data may be exchanged to optimize, control, or otherwise monitor or manipulate communication system operation. Use of the low frequency signaling utilizing jitter modulation is discussed below in more detail.
The receiver portion 208 and the transmitter portion 224 may comprise any receiver system and transmitter system that is capable of achieving the functionality described herein. The functionality of both of the receiver portion 208 and the transmitter portion 224 is explained below in conjunction with several example embodiments.
In operation, the receiver portion 208 receives incoming network data and system data via path 204. In one embodiment, the system data is jitter modulated onto the network data. In one exemplary embodiment, the path 204 comprises a fiber optic cable configured to provide the data to the receiver portion 208 in a serial format. The receiver 208 processes that data and provides the network data to the processing device 212, and provides the low frequency system data to the transmitter 224 via path 220.
In one embodiment, the processing device 212 comprises an ASIC type processing device, but it is contemplated that in other embodiments the processing device may comprise any apparatus capable of analyzing and/or manipulating the network data. The output of the processing device 212 returns the network data to the transmitter 224 wherein the transmitter may recombine the network data with the system data for retransmission over output path 228. It is contemplated that the transmitter portion 224 may jitter modulate the system data onto the network data. Separation and combination of the network data signal and the system data signal is discussed below in more detail.
As optional inputs 330A, 330B to the transmitters 316A, 316B, are inputs 330A, 330B that are provided for system data so that system data may be processed within or by the transmitters. This may allow the system data to be transmitted over the channel(s) 304 with the network data. In one embodiment, this data is jitter modulated with the network data. Similarly, the receivers 312A, 312B have output ports 340A, 340B configured to provide system data that was recovered or separated from the signal transmitted over channel 304.
To overcome the drawbacks of the prior art, the method and apparatus disclosed herein enables communication between stations utilizing jitter modulation of the network data. By selectively controlling the jitter of the network data, the system data is encoded onto the network data signal. In this manner, the system data is transmitted concurrent with the network data and in a manner that does not corrupt the network data and that does not result in the system data being lost as the combined signal passes through repeater stages or one or more additional stations.
Signal plot 420, which is shown with bold line, is now discussed. Signal plot 420 comprises a network data signal that has been jitter modulated to thereby have a phase offset as compared to other reference signals 428. Thus, at a period P1, the signal plot 420 is shifted to the left hand side of the figure to a greater degree than are reference signals 428. This indicates a phase shift, which can be detected at a receiver to recover system data. Similarly, signal plot 424, at a time period P2, is shifted slightly to the left as compared to other signal plots at time period P2. These shifts in jitter of the transmitted signal are introduced into the transmitted signal to represent the system data. Upon reception, the phase shifts of the jitter modulation can be detected and the system data recovered.
The slight introduction of jitter, which represents the system data in the transmitted signal, can be detected at a receiving station. In one embodiment, the jitter modulation is decoded in relation to a reference clock to allow for decoding, which may also occur in relation to a reference clock. In one embodiment, a clock data recovery circuit is utilized to recover the data.
As an advantage to this method of system data encoding the transmission, the regeneration of the signal, such as for example by repeaters, does not saturate or corrupt the jitter modulated system data. Communication based on amplitude modulation suffers from system data loss when repeaters enter saturation, thereby compressing the amplitude-modulated data. In addition, use of jitter modulation does not force the driver circuits or the optical signal emitting device in an optic system to output higher power levels than would be required if jitter modulation were not occurring. This is not true of amplitude modulation, which may decrease the lifespan of the optical signal-emitting device.
Yet another advantage of the method and apparatus described herein is that it is capable of utilizing existing components that are already utilized within modern communication devices. The method and apparatus described herein does not require additional de-modulators, modulators, or other such hardware. Thus the cost, complexity, power consumption, and heat generation as part of implementing the invention is minimized. Moreover, processing of the system data may be done at low frequencies, thereby minimizing system complexity.
Turning now to
The loop is defined as the loop created by elements 504, 508, 512, and 516. The loop is assumed to have a loop bandwidth defined by the maximum rate of change of the loop in tracking changes in the signal passing through the loop. For signals having a rate of change that is greater than the loop bandwidth, the loop is able to track such changes. Conversely, the loop is able to track signals having a rate of change that is less than the loop bandwidth. In prior art systems, the loop signal is utilized to control the timing of transmission.
The present invention, however, provides the output of the VCO 512 to a variable delay 520, and the output of the variable delay 520 feeds into a multiplexer 524 or other switching device. The variable delay 512 may comprise any device capable of introducing a controllable delay into the signal provided to the multiplexer 524. In one embodiment, the variable delay comprises one or more buffers, registers, or flip-flops. In this embodiment, the output of the variable delay 520 serves as the clock that controls the timing of the multiplexer 524. Any type of multiplexer 524 or switch system that operates in accordance with the method described herein may be utilized.
In this embodiment, the VCO output is modified by the variable delay 520 prior to serving as the clock for the multiplexer 524. A control signal input 528 provides a control signal to the variable delay 520 to thereby control the amount of delay that is introduced into the multiplexer timing signal.
The multiplexer 524 receives the multiplexer control signal 524 and one or more inputs from a data source via inputs 532. In one embodiment, the data source outputs carry network data that is to be transmitted by the transmitter. It is contemplated that the data source outputs may be part of any data source, such as a switch, processor, data base, memory, or any other device. In one embodiment, the signal from the VCO 512, that passes through the variable delay 520, controls the output timing of the data source signals, received over inputs 532, from the multiplexer 524. In one embodiment the control signal input 528 that is provided to the variable delay comprises secondary data, and in one embodiment the secondary data comprises system data.
In one example method of operation, network data is provided to the multiplexer 524 via inputs 532 for transmission over a transmission line or path. In one embodiment, the multiplexer 524 is configured to convert the network data received over inputs 532 in a parallel format to a serial format for transmission. In one embodiment, the transmission of network data occurs at a high data rate over an optic channel, but processing of the data, such as in stations or repeaters, occurs at a lower rate, and is hence reformatted to a parallel format for processing. The output timing of the multiplexer is controlled by the output of the variable delay. By controlling the timing of the multiplexer control signal, i.e., through use of the variable delay 520 or other equivalent device, the timing of transmission can be precisely controlled. The amount of variable delay can be directly related to the secondary data, such as the system data, to thereby jitter modulate the system data into the network data. In this manner, the system data may be transmitted to other stations or repeaters concurrent with the transmission of network data. In this manner, jitter modulation may occur to control the timing of the transmission of the network data and thereby encode secondary data, such as for example, system data.
As a result of the processing occurring in conjunction with the system of
A first output of the phase detector 604 connects to a de-multiplexer 608, while another output of the phase detector connects to a filter 612. The de-multiplexer 608 is configured to convert the network data arriving in a serial format into a parallel format on outputs 610. Operation of the phase detector 604 is generally understood by one of ordinary skill in the art and hence is not described in detail herein.
A second output from the phase detector 604 provides a loop signal to a filter 612. The filter 612 comprises a band pass filter configured to output a select frequency band of the received loop signal to a VCO 616 and an output port 620. The output of the VCO 616 completes the loop by connecting to the phase detector 604 to create a loop as discussed above. It is contemplated that this loop has a loop bandwidth defined by the maximum rate of change that can be tracked by the loop. In some embodiments, this loop is commonly known as a CDR loop.
As discussed above, the output from the phase detector 604 that connects to the de-multiplexer 608 carries the network data signal. This signal has been retimed and unwanted jitter aspects have been removed. The de-multiplexer 608 converts the serial stream of data to a parallel format as shown.
The loop defined by elements 604, 612, and 616 generates a loop signal. Variations in the loop signal that occur at a rate above the loop bandwidth are unable to be tracked by the loop. However, the loop is able to track signal variations that occur at a rate that is below the loop bandwidth. As a result, the loop, being unable to track high frequency jitter, removes the unwanted high frequency jitter from the loop signal to accurately track the network data. The low frequency secondary data jitter is below the loop bandwidth, and hence the loop tracks this jitter. The signal that passes within the loop will track the phase changes caused by the timing variation from the variable delay in the transmitter that encoded the secondary data onto the network data. Consequently, the data port 620 can be monitored to obtain the secondary data.
In the embodiment of
Of interest in
In one embodiment, the encoder 708 is configured to perform code division multiple access (CDMA) type encoding on the secondary data. Those of ordinary skill in the art are familiar with CDMA type encoding, and hence the particulars of CDMA encoding are not discussed in detail herein beyond the following. In one embodiment, the encoder 708 receives a code and the secondary data. In one embodiment, the code comprises an orthogonal code. The encoder processes the code and the secondary data to generate an encoded secondary data signal, which is in turn provided to the variable delay. As a result of the encoding, the introduction of delay and the amount of delay is controlled by the encoded secondary signal. In one embodiment, the secondary data is multiplied by an orthogonal code that comprises a spreading code. Thus, secondary data is spread over the orthogonal code. To recover the secondary signal at a receiver, decoding is performed as is discussed below.
One advantage to orthogonal spreading code encoding is that the amount of delay introduced into the transmitted network data is reduced. This in turn can increase the accuracy of network data recovery, since less low frequency jitter is introduced into the transmitted signal. Use of the orthogonal spreading code does suffer from the drawback of reducing the effective data transmit rate for the secondary data, since the amount of encoded data is increased due to the encoding processing.
In one embodiment, the code received by the decoder is an orthogonal code that may be identical to the orthogonal code utilized to encode the data. As an advantage to utilizing encoded secondary data, the encoding can reduce the amount of jitter that the variable delay introduces into the network data signal, thereby opening the eye of the eye diagram and reducing the BER.
As discussed above, the received signal comprises the network data with a low frequency jitter component (JLF) comprising the secondary data, and a high frequency jitter component (JHF). The high frequency jitter (JHF) is considered to be undesirable noise, but it is inherent in communication system transmission. Because the frequency of the JHF is above the loop bandwidth, the loop does not track the high frequency jitter. The loop does track the JLF, however, and hence the secondary data can be recovered.
In a non-encoded system, the JHF can interfere with a receiver's ability to isolate, and hence recover, the secondary data (SDj) and the network data. In some instances, it is helpful to increase the amount of delay that is introduced into the network data transmission using the variable delay to more greatly accentuate the phase difference of the jitter modulated secondary data. However, by increasing the jitter used to represent the secondary data (JLF), the BER for the network data can increase, because increasing the JLF also closes the eye of the eye diagram. By encoding the secondary data, these problems can be overcome because with encoded data, the amount of phase jitter that must be introduced into the network data is reduced. In one embodiment, a spread spectrum encoding scheme is utilized. In such an embodiment, orthogonal codes may be utilized to spread the JLF representing the secondary data over a longer transmit period while reducing the amount of jitter that is introduced. Upon reception, the encoded secondary data may be recovered, yet the BER is minimized due to the minimal amount of low frequency jitter introduced by the spreading of the secondary data.
The output of the junction 912 feeds into a voltage controlled oscillator (VCO) 916. The output of the VCO 916 comprises a signal that controls the timing of the transmitted data, although it is contemplated that the transmit signal may undergo additional processing prior to controlling of the transmission of data, such as customer or network data, over a channel. The output of the VCO 916 is also provided to a divider 920, the output of which is the feedback signal provided to the phase detector 904.
In one example embodiment, the phase detector 904 generates a signal proportional to the phase difference between the reference clock signal and the clock that is fed back from the VCO 916. The feedback signal is divided down in frequency from the VCO output because the average frequency of the VCO 916 may be the same as that of the optical signal while the frequency of the reference clock may be (but not necessarily) much lower in frequency. The phase detector circuit may generate high frequency components which must be filtered out by the loop filter 908. In this embodiment the secondary data signal is added, by the junction 912, to the output of the loop filter 908 to modulate the phase of the VCO output. One implementation first passes the data through a scrambler; otherwise, the modulation could have a nonzero mean which could cause problems in the receiver. It is also possible to employ forward error and/or spread spectrum to reduce the transmit power level requirements. This is important because the distortion in optical channels is, in general, nonlinear. As a result, low frequency signal components may result in higher frequency harmonics which can interfere with the payload.
As shown, a reference clock signal is provided to a phase detector 1004, which also receives a feedback signal from a frequency modification device 1020 or frequency control module, in this embodiment a divider. The output of the phase detector 1004 connects to a loop filter 1008, which in turn provides its output to a voltage controlled oscillator (VCO) 1016. The output of the loop filter 1008 also comprises the received secondary signal data. In one embodiment this comprises the error term of the loop. The VCO 1016 modifies the signal in accordance with it operation, which is generally understood, to provide an output to the divider 1020 as shown. The divider 1020 modifies the frequency of the signal and provides its output as a feedback signal to the phase detector 1004.
In operation, it is contemplated that the processing of the receive signal may be shown to have complementary functions for those in the transmitter. In addition, if the loop filter is not sufficiently narrowband, it may be beneficial to process the received signal with a noise reduction filter. The bandwidth of the loop filter is driven by the requirements of the PLL and the system and it may not be possible to have the bandwidth be adjusted to the requirements of the secondary signal.
A CDR circuit 1132 receives the output of the limiting amplifier 1128. Operation of the CDR circuit 1132 is discussed above in detail in conjunction with
On the transmit side of the transmit module, the ASIC 1108 connects to a multiplexer 1140. The multiplexer 1140 may also be configured to receive incoming secondary data that is to be combined with the outgoing network data. The multiplexer 1140 may output network data in a serial format after having received it in parallel format. The multiplexer 1140 has an output connected to a PLL circuit 1144, which may also receive the secondary data via path 1156. In this embodiment, the PLL circuit 1144, in conjunction with the multiplexer 1140, combines the secondary data into the network data. In one embodiment, this occurs utilizing a jitter modulation of the secondary data onto the network data. In one embodiment, the secondary data is encoded prior to modulation onto the network data. The PLL 1144 is described above in conjunction with
The output of the PLL circuit 1144 feeds into a driver amplifier 1148 configured to provide a driver signal to an optical emitter 1152. The optical emitter generates an optical signal representative of the driver amplifier output. In one embodiment, the optical emitter comprises a laser or light emitting diode. The optical emitter 1152 transmits the network data with secondary data jitter modulated over an optic fiber 1116.
While various embodiments of the invention have been described, it will be apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art that many more embodiments and implementations are possible that are within the scope of this invention.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4534064 | Giacometti et al. | Aug 1985 | A |
5019769 | Levinson | May 1991 | A |
5313173 | Lampe | May 1994 | A |
5383046 | Tomofuji et al. | Jan 1995 | A |
5383208 | Queniat et al. | Jan 1995 | A |
5394416 | Ries | Feb 1995 | A |
5396059 | Yeates | Mar 1995 | A |
5488627 | Hardin et al. | Jan 1996 | A |
5594748 | Jabr | Jan 1997 | A |
5636254 | Hase et al. | Jun 1997 | A |
5812572 | King et al. | Sep 1998 | A |
5844928 | Shastri et al. | Dec 1998 | A |
5900959 | Noda et al. | May 1999 | A |
5956168 | Levinson et al. | Sep 1999 | A |
6108113 | Fee | Aug 2000 | A |
6111687 | Tammela | Aug 2000 | A |
6259293 | Hayase et al. | Jul 2001 | B1 |
6282017 | Kinoshita | Aug 2001 | B1 |
6366373 | MacKinnon et al. | Apr 2002 | B1 |
6452719 | Kinoshita | Sep 2002 | B2 |
6473418 | Laroia et al. | Oct 2002 | B1 |
6494370 | Sanchez | Dec 2002 | B1 |
6556601 | Nagata | Apr 2003 | B2 |
6570944 | Best et al. | May 2003 | B2 |
6580328 | Tan et al. | Jun 2003 | B2 |
6661940 | Kim | Dec 2003 | B2 |
6707600 | Dijaili et al. | Mar 2004 | B1 |
6740864 | Dries | May 2004 | B1 |
6788743 | Pfeil | Sep 2004 | B1 |
6801555 | Dijaili et al. | Oct 2004 | B1 |
6837625 | Schott et al. | Jan 2005 | B2 |
6852966 | Douma et al. | Feb 2005 | B1 |
6868104 | Stewart et al. | Mar 2005 | B2 |
6888123 | Douma et al. | May 2005 | B2 |
6934307 | DeCusatis et al. | Aug 2005 | B2 |
6941077 | Aronson et al. | Sep 2005 | B2 |
6952531 | Aronson et al. | Oct 2005 | B2 |
6956643 | Farr et al. | Oct 2005 | B2 |
6957021 | Aronson et al. | Oct 2005 | B2 |
6967320 | Chieng et al. | Nov 2005 | B2 |
7031574 | Huang et al. | Apr 2006 | B2 |
7039082 | Stewart et al. | May 2006 | B2 |
7046721 | Grohn | May 2006 | B2 |
7050720 | Aronson et al. | May 2006 | B2 |
7058310 | Aronson et al. | Jun 2006 | B2 |
7066746 | Togami et al. | Jun 2006 | B1 |
7079775 | Aronson et al. | Jul 2006 | B2 |
7123665 | Brown et al. | Oct 2006 | B2 |
7227913 | Hein et al. | Jun 2007 | B1 |
20040047635 | Aronson et al. | Mar 2004 | A1 |
20040136727 | Androni et al. | Jul 2004 | A1 |
20050215090 | Harwood | Sep 2005 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20050135501 A1 | Jun 2005 | US |