The present invention relates to a composite slip adapted for engagement with an internal surface of a metal tubular.
Composite slips are used in downhole zonal isolation tools to hold the tool in place during stimulation and service work. For example, the zonal isolation tool is a bridge plug, frac plug, or packer for bridging a hole or gap of a metal tubular such as a well casing.
The zonal isolation tool has an internal elongated mandrel and a circular array of slips mounted on the mandrel at each end of the tool. Each slip has an outer surface adapted for engagement with the internal surface of the well casing. Each slip also has an inclined inner surface. Each array of slips is disposed next to a respective conical ring mounted on the mandrel for sliding under the inclined inner surfaces of the slips in the array. In the middle of the zonal isolation tool, rings of elastomeric sealing material are mounted on the mandrel between the conical rings. When a setting tool pulls the mandrel in the longitudinal direction, the rings of sealing material expand outward in the radial direction to seal the well casing. In addition, the conical rings slide under the slips and force the slips outward in the radial direction into engagement with the well casing. The slips lock the zonal isolation tool in place inside the well casing in such a way that the rings of sealing material remain in compression for sealing the well casing when the setting tool is removed.
The zonal isolation tool can be designed to be retrievable and reusable after it has been set in the well casing. However, the zonal isolation tool is most economical to manufacture when it has been constructed to become permanently set in the well casing so that it must be drilled out destructively to unseal the well casing. Traditionally, such a drillable zonal isolation tool has been made of a cast iron mandrel and cast iron slips.
A number of downhole tool makers have replaced the cast iron components of the zonal isolation tools with composite components of epoxy fiberglass. The composite components can be drilled out faster than cast iron, and the drilled-out chips of composite material are lighter than cast iron chips so that the composite chips are more easily flushed out of the tubular member with drilling fluid. The composite downhole tools are also lighter than the cast iron downhole tools and can be used in both high and low pH environments. Details of construction of such composite zonal isolation tools are found, for example, in Turley et al. U.S. Pat. No. 6,712,153, issued Mar. 30, 2004, incorporated herein by reference, and in Sutton et al., U.S. Pat. No. 6,976,534 issued Dec. 20, 2005, incorporated herein by reference.
As evident from the Turley et al. U.S. Pat. No. 6,712,153 and the Sutton et al. U.S. Pat. No. 6,976,534, there has been a problem when the metal slips of a zonal isolation tool have been replaced with composite slips. As shown in
It is desired to increase the gripping capability of a composite slip adapted for engagement with an internal surface of a metal tubular. It is also desired to provide a more economical manufacturing process resulting in a composite slip having more uniform and desirable characteristics.
The gripping capability of the composite slip has been limited by the holding capability of the ceramic inserts and the coefficient of friction between the outer surface of the composite slip and the inner wall of the well casing. The ceramic inserts are limited in number and in strength. The ceramic inserts are of a brittle nature, subject to chipping and cracking. The ceramic inserts are inserted in cavities in the composite slip, and these cavities are weak regions where the composite material may break and lose contact with the inner wall of the casing. In practice, the ceramic inserts deform and penetrate the casing so that the outer surface of the slip is in load-bearing contact with the inner wall of the casing. Yet the coefficient of friction between the composite material and the metal of the casing is relatively low, especially in the wet environment of a well bore.
In accordance with one aspect, the invention provides a composite slip. The composite slip includes a body of composite material. The body has an outer surface adapted for engagement with an internal surface of a metal tubular. The composite slip also includes high friction material that is secured to the body and disposed at and distributed over the outer surface of the body for gripping the internal surface of the metal tubular.
In accordance with another aspect, the invention provides a composite slip. The composite slip includes a body of composite material including glass or ceramic fiber in a matrix of thermoset polymer. The body has an outer surface adapted for engagement with an internal surface of a metal tubular. The composite slip further includes granular abrasive that is secured to the body, disposed at the outer surface of the body, and distributed over the outer surface of the body in rows for gripping the internal surface of the metal tubular.
In accordance with yet another aspect, the invention provides a composite slip. The composite slip includes a body of epoxy-fiberglass material. The body has an outer surface adapted for engagement with an internal surface of a metal tubular. The body has spaced grooves in the outer surface. The composite slip also includes ceramic or metal/ceramic composite inserts disposed in cavities in the body and protruding from the outer surface of the body for penetration of the internal surface of the metal tubular. The composite slip further includes granular abrasive disposed in the spaced grooves and protruding from the outer surface of the body. The granular abrasive is bonded to the body by epoxy adhesive in the grooves, and the granular abrasive is distributed in rows over the outer surface of the body between and around the inserts.
The high friction material, for example, is granular abrasive such as steel particles, crushed ceramic, or crushed crystalline material. The granular abrasive, for example, is aluminum oxide, zirconium oxide, tungsten carbide, silicon carbide, silicon dioxide, or crushed granite. The granular abrasive, for example, is bonded to the composite material of the composite slip by being embedded in the composite material, or by being bonded to the composite material by a bonding agent such as epoxy adhesive or rubber.
Preferably the high friction material is very well sorted (i.e., phi under 0.35) coarse or very coarse (i.e., grain size of from 0.5 mm to 2.0 mm) granular aluminum oxide abrasive arranged in circumferential rows on the outer surface of the composite slip. For example, the granular abrasive is disposed in rows by forming the composite material with circumferential grooves in the outer surface of the slip, filling the grooves with bonding agent, and then pouring the granular abrasive over the outer surface of the slip, so that the granular abrasive that falls in the grooves becomes bonded to the composite slip. Alternatively, a mold for the composite slip has a wall defining the outer surface of the composite slip, the wall is formed with circumferential grooves, and the granular abrasive is laid up in the grooves of the mold prior to molding of the composite slip so that the granular abrasive becomes imbedded in and bonded to the composite material in ridges on the outer surface of the composite slip during the molding of the composite material.
By forming cavities for the ceramic inserts during the molding process, the weak regions around the cavities are much stronger than if the cavities were machined after the molding process. Machining of the cavities would sever the fibers of the composite material precisely at the regions of high stress where continuous fiber is needed. By charging the mold with a glass-epoxy pre-mix sheet molding compound, it is possible to mold a suitable composite slip that requires no machining other than removal of flashing at the mold piece parting line.
An unexpected benefit of the high friction material on the surface of the composite slip is that it holds the composite slip surface in engagement with the well casing wall even if the slip would break up at the weak regions around the ceramic insert cavities.
Additional features and advantages of the invention will be described below with reference to the drawings, in which:
While the invention is susceptible to various modifications and alternative forms, specific embodiments thereof have been shown in the drawings and will be described in detail. It should be understood, however, that it is not intended to limit the invention to the particular forms shown, but on the contrary, the intention is to cover all modifications, equivalents, and alternatives falling within the scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims.
With reference to
The bridge plug tool 20 has an internal elongated mandrel 25 and a respective circular array of slips 26, 27 mounted on the mandrel at each end of the bridge plug tool. Each slip has an outer surface adapted for engagement with the internal surface of the well casing 22. Each slip also has an inclined inner surface. Each array of slips 26, 27 is disposed next to a respective conical ring 28, 29 mounted on the mandrel 25 for sliding under the inclined inner surfaces of the slips in the array. In the middle of the sealing tool, rings 30, 31, 32 of elastomeric sealing material are mounted on the mandrel between the conical rings 28, 29.
Once the bridge plug tool 20 has been aligned with the perforation 24, the setting tool 21 is activated. For example, the setting tool 21 has a cylinder 33 and a piston 34 driven by fluid 35 under pressure, such as hydraulic fluid or gas generated by a pyrotechnic charge. The piston 34 has a shaft 36 coupled by a shear pin 37 to the mandrel 35 for pulling the mandrel in the longitudinal direction.
As shown in
If later it is desired to remove the bridge plug tool 20 from the well casing 22, then the bridge plug tool is drilled out destructively. For fast drill-out, light weight, and tolerance of high and low pH environments, the bridge plug tool 20 is comprised of composite material such as epoxy fiberglass. For example, the epoxy resin is a 50:50 blend by weight of a cycloaliphatic epoxy resin and an epoxy resin of bisphenol A and epichlorohydrin.
For enhanced gripping of the inner wall of the well casing, the outer surface of the slip body 42 includes high friction material in addition to the ceramic or metal/ceramic buttons 46, 47, 48. Preferably this high friction material includes granular abrasive distributed around and between the buttons 46, 47, 49 and arranged in circumferential rows 51, 52. Thus, the rows granular abrasive are perpendicular to the longitudinal force applied to the mandrel by the setting tool, so that the composite material of the slip body 42 is most effective in applying this longitudinal force to the granular abrasive particles when the granular abrasive engages the inner wall of the well casing.
In practice, the ceramic and metal/ceramic buttons 46, 47, 48 deform and penetrate the inner wall of the casing so that the outer surface of the slip is in load-bearing contact with the inner wall of the casing. If the well casing has normal properties so that it is deformed by the ceramic and metal/ceramic buttons, then the outer surface of the slip including the abrasive material is pressed into the inner wall of the well casing with about 6,000 to 8000 psi. Therefore it is possible to significantly increase the holding capability of the slip under normal conditions. Under abnormal conditions, such as a fracture of the ceramic buttons or a fracture of the weak area of the composite slip around the buttons, the pressing of the abrasive material into the inner wall of the well casing may prevent a failure of setting of the zonal isolation tool that would require considerable service downtime to drill-out the defective tool from the well casing and insert a new tool.
For example, the slip body 42 has a size of about 1.3 inches by 1.85 inches by 0.6 inches, and ten rows of abrasive particles are disposed on the outer face of the slip between the arcuate grooves 43, 44, so that the center-to-center spacing between adjacent rows is about 0.12 inches. Preferably the abrasive grains are very well sorted (under 0.35 phi, i.e., the base two logarithm of the ratio of the standard deviation of grain size to the mean grain size is less than 0.35). Preferably the abrasive grains are coarse or very coarse (i.e., grain size of from 0.5 mm to 2.0 mm). Preferably the abrasive grains are comprised primarily of aluminum oxide. For example, the abrasive grains are obtained by sorting very coarse crushed aluminum oxide industrial abrasive (generally known as “brown aluminum oxide”) with a U.S. Standard Sieve Mesh No. 18 to remove any particles with a size less than 1.0 mm, and then sorting the remaining grains with a U.S. Standard Sieve Mesh No. 16 to obtain grains with a size between 1.0 mm and 1.2 mm. The larger grains are crushed and sorted again.
As shown in
The granular abrasive can be disposed in rows at the outer surface of the composite body of the slip after the composite body of the slip is molded, or during the molding of the composite body of the slip. The most convenient method is to form circumferential grooves in the composite body of the slip during molding of the composite body of the slip, and after the composite body of the slip has been molded, then filling the circumferential grooves with a bonding agent, and then pouring the granular abrasive over the outer surface of the slip body so that granular abrasive that falls in the grooves becomes bonded to the composite slip. The less convenient method is to embed the granular abrasive into the composite body of the slip when the composite slip is molded.
The molded LYTEX 9063 sheet molding compound is sufficiently compliant that there is no need for the adhesive 73, 74 to be compliant or toughened. If the composite slip body were made of a relatively non-compliant material such as a glass phenolic composite, then it may be desirable to use a compliant or toughened adhesive, or incorporate a near-surface layer of compliant material in the composite slip body, in order to ensure substantially uniform pressing of the granular abrasive into the inner wall of the well casing. For example, epoxy adhesive can be toughened by incorporating ground rubber powder into the adhesive.
Once strips 85, 96 for all the granular abrasive are laid over and aligned with the circumferential grooves in the mold piece 82, a roll 87 of sheet molding compound is laid over the strips and while being partially stuffed into the cavity of other mold piece 87, and then the mold pieces are brought together, and the part is compression molded.
In view of the above, the gripping capability of a composite slip is enhanced by providing high friction material to the outer surface of the composite slip in addition to the ceramic and metallic/ceramic composite inserts that are typically used in composite slips. Preferably the high friction material is granular abrasive arranged in circumferential rows on the outer surface of the composite slip. The high friction material is especially useful if the ceramic inserts fracture or there is a fracture of the relatively weak and highly stressed region of the composite slip near the metallic/ceramic composite insert. Granular abrasive is particular effective for engagement with the inner wall of a metal tubular that does not deform in the fashion typical of well casing or that has a surface hardness greater than the surface hardness typical of well casing so that the ceramic or metallic/ceramic composite inserts would be ineffective for setting of the zonal isolation tool.
The composite slip including the high friction material is easily formed body. It is also possible to embed the granular abrasive into the composite material of the slip when the composite slip is molded.