The present invention relates to systems for internal cleaning of containers, and in particular to techniques for monitoring the operation of such cleaning systems.
In many processing applications, e.g. for production of chemicals, foodstuffs and pharmaceutical compounds, containers or tanks are used for storing or processing various ingredients. These containers need to be cleaned from time to time. The need for cleaning may be controlled by many different factors, depending on industry and type of processing, e.g. to avoid cross contamination, adulteration and avoidable carryover, to prepare the container for processing of another batch, to remove or at least avoid build up of contamination layers such as bio-film, dried foam, precipitate or sediments, to comply with legal requirements, to prepare the container for human entry, to remove hazardous or explosive atmospheres, or to protect the processing equipment against corrosion or other degradation.
Such a need for internal cleaning of containers arises in all types of industries, including the fields of pharmaceutics, food processing, textiles, pulp and paper, paint, petrochemical processing, plastics, mining, etc. It is desirable to clean the containers as fast and efficient as possible, preferably without having to dismantle and clean the containers manually. There is also a general desire to reduce the consumption of water, chemicals and energy. To achieve one or more of these goals, so-called Cleaning-In-Place (CIP) systems have been developed. The CIP systems operate to supply a fluid inside the tank for cleaning purposes and may be either static or rotary.
A static CIP system may use a static spray ball inside the container to spray a chemical detergent onto the interior of the container, whereby the mechanical action of falling film acts to remove contaminations.
A rotary or dynamic CIP system may operate a rotary nozzle head to rotate slowly inside the container so as to generate and displace one or more fluid jets or sprays across the inner surfaces of the container, whereby the impact of the fluid at least partly acts to remove contaminations. In one type of rotary CIP system, the nozzle head is configured to generate confined liquid jets that are rotated both around a vertical axis in the container and a second axis with respect to the nozzle head, e.g. as disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,333,630 and U.S. Pat. No. 5,715,852. Such a nozzle head is known as a “rotary jet head” (RJH) and operates to move the jet in mutually displaced loops on the inside the container, such that the loops collectively form a full pattern with desired coverage. In another type of rotary CIP system of simpler design, the nozzle head is configured to generate one or more sprays of fan-shaped flat type which are rotated around a vertical axis in the container, e.g. as disclosed in US2003/137895. Such a nozzle head is known as a “rotary spray head” (RSH).
Typically, CIP systems are highly automated, and there is a need to ensure proper cleaning of the container. For verification that the container is properly cleaned, the interior of the container may be physically inspected. This is however a labor intensive and expensive process.
A commercially available system for monitoring of an RJH CIP system is denoted “Rotacheck system” and provided by Alfa Laval. The Rotacheck system may be used for e.g. automatically estimating whether the interior of the container has been properly cleaned or not. The system includes a sensor which is installed in the roof of the container and has a small circular sensor diaphragm that generates a signal pulse when hit by a jet released by the rotary jet head. By evaluating the timing of signal pulses, the system is able to verify proper rotation of the rotary jet head. Since the RJH CIP system moves the jet slowly in mutually displaced loops, the time interval between signal pulses generated by the sensor for a particular jet may be significant, e.g. on the order of minutes, or even longer. Apart from causing an undesired delay in detecting e.g. malfunctions in the RJH CIP system, the long time interval between signal pulses causes an undesirable trade-off between response time and accuracy in detecting malfunctions. A fast response time may require a potential malfunction to be detected based on a single or a few signal pulses for a particular jet, resulting in a low accuracy and a risk for errors. The long time intervals also make the monitoring system vulnerable to interferences, e.g. caused by liquid splashes, measurement noise, and instabilities in the level of signal pulses, etc.
The prior art also comprises JP08-192125, which discloses a rotary CIP system that operates to rotate a spray ball around a vertical axis inside a tank, while the ball ejects a liquid through a series of holes to generate a 360° spray in a vertical plane. Poor rotation of the spray ball is detected based on signals from two spaced apart circular sensors arranged in the roof of the tank to measure pH, temperature or electric conductivity. This monitoring technique is sensitive to wetting of the sensors, splashes, etc.
JP2008-290003 discloses a rotary CIP system that comprises a rotary jet generation element which is suspended from the roof of a tank to generate a rotating jet of liquid. A conductivity sensor is suspended from the roof in parallel to the jet generation element so as to be intermittently hit by the rotating jet. A rotation failure may be detected by correlating the rotation of the jet generation element with the output signal of the conductivity sensor. This monitoring technique is sensitive to wetting of the sensor, splashes, etc. The use of a projecting sensor may limit the installation to certain types of tanks or applications, and may also lead to undesired accumulation of contaminations on the sensor itself.
It is an objective of the invention to at least partly overcome one or more limitations of the prior art.
Another objective is to provide an improved technique for monitoring of rotary CIP systems for the purpose of identifying operation failure and/or verifying proper cleaning.
A further objective is to enable a faster and/or more accurate detection of operation failure in a rotary CIP system.
Yet another objective is to provide a monitoring technique which is simple to install in containers and/or combine with rotary CIP systems.
A still further objective is to provide a monitoring technique capable of providing increased information about the cleaning process inside the container.
One or more of these objects, as well as further objects that may appear from the description below, are at least partly achieved by means of a monitoring arrangement, a cleaning system, method of monitoring the operation of a cleaning system, and a computer program product according to the independent claims, embodiments thereof being defined by the dependent claims.
A first aspect of the invention is a monitoring arrangement for a cleaning system installed in a container, the cleaning system comprising a pipe configured to extend into the container through a wall portion of the container, a nozzle head connected for rotation at an end of the pipe inside the container so as to eject a liquid, and a drive member operable to impart a rotation to the nozzle head around a first axis such that the liquid is ejected into the container in a predetermined pattern. The monitoring arrangement comprises a sensor unit for mounting at the wall portion of the container, the sensor unit comprising a sensing surface responsive to liquid impact for enabling the sensor unit to emit a sensor signal indicative of the liquid impact; and a processing unit configured to obtain the sensor signal from the sensor unit and process the sensor signal for monitoring the operation of the cleaning system. According to the first aspect, the sensing surface is elongated and configured to extend along a perimeter of the pipe when the sensor unit is mounted at the wall portion of the container. By “elongated” means that the sensing surface has a greater dimension (surface extension) in one direction across the sensing surface than another dimension (surface extension) in another direction across the sensing surface. By “sensing surface” means the surface of the sensor unit that is responsive to liquid impact, i.e. the sensor unit emits a signal when liquid impact on the sensing surface.
The inventive configuration of the sensor unit allows the sensing surface to be selectively extended in a direction that coincides with one or more movement trajectories for the ejected liquid in the predetermined pattern. For example, the sensing surface may be extended to approximately coincide with the direction of movement of the nozzle head around the first axis. The elongated extent of the sensing surface may thereby cause the ejected liquid, be it a confined jet or a flat-fan spray, to move across the sensing surface during a longer time period when it impinges on the sensor unit during the cleaning process. Generally, the longer duration provides an improved ability of tracking the ejected liquid as a function of time. The longer duration of liquid impact may be used to improve the accuracy of the monitoring. For example, the longer duration may be converted into a more consistent signal pulse in the sensor signal and/or or be used for suppressing the influence of fluctuating interferences such as splatter. If the sensor unit is made sensitive to the location of liquid impact within the elongated sensing surface, the first aspect may also enable time-resolved monitoring of the ejected liquid while it is moved across the sensing surface, as well as two-dimensional monitoring of the distribution of liquid impact across the sensing surface. This may enable determination of novel monitoring parameters, such as the width (footprint) of the ejected liquid, which may provide additional information about the cleaning process.
When the ejected liquid is a confined jet that is rotated both around the first axis and a second axis defined in relation to the nozzle head, e.g. as described above for so-called RJH CIP systems, the extended sensing surface may increase the frequency by which the jets impinge on the effective sensing area. This will reduce the time interval between liquid impact on the sensor unit, and thereby enable a faster and/or more accurate detection of operation failure. The reduced time interval may also result in an increased amount of information about the cleaning process, e.g. by an increased time-resolution of a monitoring parameter.
The sensor unit may be configured for installation in any container, since it need not (but may) project into the container. The sensor unit is simple to install since it may be arranged in a through hole or a blind hole in the wall portion. The sensor unit may also be combined with the cleaning system, e.g. by arranging the sensor unit in a mounting flange attached to the pipe, where the mounting flange is configured to be fitted in sealing engagement with an opening in the wall portion of the container.
In certain cleaning systems, the first axis may be arranged to co-extend with the longitudinal axis of the pipe, or even coincide with a longitudinal center axis of the pipe. In other cleaning systems, the first axis may have an inclination with respect to the longitudinal axis, e.g. in the range of approximately ±20° or ±10°.
According to the first aspect, the sensing surface is elongated to extend along the perimeter of the pipe, which denotes the outer contour of the pipe. This is merely intended to indicate that the sensing surface spans along at least a portion of the outer contour of the pipe, with or without a spacing to the outer contour.
In one embodiment, the sensing surface is configured to extend along at least 25%, 50% or 75% of the perimeter of the pipe. This corresponds to a span of at least 90°, 180° or 270° of the outer contour of the pipe. It is currently believed that an increased span yields improved performance in terms of accuracy, and may also improve the ability of extracting novel monitoring parameters.
In one embodiment, the sensing surface is configured to surround the pipe when the sensor unit is mounted at the wall portion of the container. Thereby, the sensing surface spans 360° of the outer contour of the pipe. The shape of the sensing surface that surrounds the pipe may be optimized depending to the cleaning system and/or the monitoring parameters to the extracted from the sensor signal. Thus, the shape of the sensing surface may but need not conform to the outer contour of the pipe.
In one embodiment, the sensing surface is annular, with any desired shape of the annulus, including circular, elliptical, and polygonal.
In one embodiment, the sensing surface is configured to extend along an essentially circular path around the pipe when the sensor unit is mounted at the wall portion of the container. The use of a circular path may, at least for certain cleaning systems, optimize the duration of liquid impact on the sensing surface, and may also facilitate the interpretation of the sensor signal.
The sensing surface may be configured as a coherent surface, which is thus responsive to liquid impact across its entire extent.
In a variant, the sensing surface may be formed as an aggregation of individual sensing segments, which are individually responsive to liquid impact. The sensor signal may thus comprise sub-signals indicative of the liquid impact on the respective segments. The sensing segments may be arranged to form a coherent surface, or they may be arranged with a mutual spacing along the elongated extent of the surface portion. This means that the sensing surface may include surface portions that are not responsive to liquid impact. It should be understood that even if it includes non-responsive surface portions, the sensing surface may still be continuous or coherent with respect to the impinging liquid, provided that the non-responsive surface portions have an extent that is less than a relevant dimension of the impinging liquid on the sensor unit, e.g. the minimum diameter of a confined jet or the width of a flat-fan spray as it impinges on the sensor unit. This enables the sensor unit to be responsive to impact from the ejected liquid across the entire sensing surface.
In one embodiment, the processing unit is configured to process the sensor signal so as to identify occurrences of liquid impact on the sensing surface and match the occurrences to the predetermined pattern. This enables the monitoring arrangement to verify proper functioning of the cleaning system and to identify malfunctions, e.g. in the rotation of the nozzle head, or the operation of a specific nozzle.
In one embodiment, the sensor unit is configured to be responsive to the location of liquid impact within the sensing surface, and the processing unit is configured to process the sensor signal to determine a distribution of liquid impact on the sensing surface. This enables the monitoring arrangement to track the movement of the ejected liquid and/or to determine novel monitoring parameters, such as width or pressure of the ejected liquid.
In one embodiment, the nozzle head of the cleaning system is configured to rotate at least two jets of liquid around the first axis and around a second axis of the nozzle head, and the processing unit is configured to monitor at least one of: a dimension of each jet, the number of jets, a pressure of each jet, the rotation of the jets around the first axis, and the rotation of the jets around the second axis.
In another embodiment, the nozzle head of the cleaning system is configured to rotate at least one beam of liquid around the first axis, and the processing unit is configured to monitor at least one of: a dimension of said at least one beam of liquid, the rotation of said at least one beam of liquid around the first axis, and a pressure of said at least one beam of liquid. The cleaning system may be configured to generate the beam of liquid in the form of a collimated jet or an expanding beam, also known as a fan beam, which may or may not be of a flat type.
In one embodiment, the processing unit is configured to process the sensor signal for determination of a value of at least one monitoring parameter indicative of the ejected liquid, evaluate the value of said at least one monitoring parameter for detection of a malfunction in the cleaning system, and issue a warning signal indicative of the malfunction.
In one embodiment, the processing unit is configured to record data representative of the predetermined pattern based on the sensing signal, and to generate a validation report based on the recorded data.
A second aspect of the invention is a cleaning system for installation in a container, wherein the cleaning system comprises a pipe extending into the container through a wall portion of the container, a nozzle head connected for rotation at an end of the pipe inside the container so as to eject a liquid into the container, and at least one drive member operable to impart a rotation to the nozzle head around a first axis such that the liquid is ejected into the container in a predetermined pattern, the cleaning system further comprising the monitoring arrangement of the first aspect.
A third aspect of the invention is a method of monitoring the operation of a cleaning system which comprises a pipe extending into a container through a wall portion of the container, a nozzle head connected for rotation at an end of the pipe inside the container so as to eject a liquid, and a drive member operable to impart a rotation to the nozzle head around a first axis such that the liquid is ejected into the container in a predetermined pattern. The method of the third aspect comprises the steps of: obtaining a sensor signal from a sensor unit which comprises an elongated sensing surface that is responsive to liquid impact, said sensor unit being mounted at the wall portion of the container such that the elongated sensing surface extends along a perimeter of the pipe; and processing the sensor signal for monitoring the operation of the cleaning system.
A fourth aspect of the invention is a computer program product comprising computer code which, when executed on a data-processing system, is adapted to carry out the method of the third aspect.
Any one of the embodiments of the first aspect can be combined with the second to fourth aspects to attain the corresponding technical effects or advantages.
Still other objectives, features, aspects and advantages of the present invention will appear from the following detailed description, from the attached claims as well as from the drawings.
Embodiments of the invention will now be described in more detail with reference to the accompanying schematic drawings.
Embodiments of the present invention relate to techniques for remote monitoring of a cleaning process performed by a rotary CIP system inside a container. In the following, examples are given with respect to a rotary CIP system of RJH type (rotary jet head) as well as a CIP system of RSH type (rotary spray head). Corresponding elements are designated by the same reference numerals.
In the illustrated example, the distributor 100 has a pipe 101 that extends into the container 40 via an opening in the top wall 43 of the container 40. The distributor 100 has a mounting flange 102 that provides a secure connection as well as a tight seal to the container 40. An upper part of the pipe 101 that is outside the container 40 has an inlet 103 for receiving a liquid L. A lower part of the pipe 101 that extends into the container 40 has at its end a connection flange 105 to which a rotary head 106 is connected. The rotary head 106 comprises a housing 107 that is rotatable around a first axis A1 that is parallel to the pipe 101. A first bearing 108 is arranged in between the connection flange 105 and an inlet end of the housing 107 that faces the connection flange 105, such that the housing 107 is rotatable relative the connection flange 105. The rotary head 106 also comprises a rotary hub or nozzle head 110 on which a number of liquid ejection nozzles 112 are arranged. In the illustrated embodiment, four nozzles are symmetrically arranged on the rotary hub 110 even though it is possible to have any number of nozzles, e.g. only one nozzle, on the rotary hub 110. A second bearing 111 is arranged in between the rotary hub 110 and an outlet end of the housing 107 that faces the rotary hub 110, such that the rotary hub 110 is rotatable relative the housing 107. The second bearing 111 allows the rotary hub 110 to rotate about a second axis A2 that is typically offset from the first axis A1 by an angle of 80-100° (90° in the illustrated embodiment). Thus, the rotary hub 110 and the nozzles 112 are able to rotate in a first direction R1 about the first axis A1 and in a second direction R2 about the second axis A2. In certain embodiments, not shown, the first axis A1 may be inclined with respect to the axis of the pipe 101.
The inlet 103 and the pipe 101 each have the principal shape of a conventional pipe and are capable of transporting liquid L to be ejected into the container 40. Liquid L enters the inlet 103, is conveyed into the pipe 101 and towards the rotary head 106. Liquid L then enters the housing 107 of the rotary head 106 at its connection to the connection flange 105 and exits the housing 107 at its connection to the rotary hub 110. The rotary hub 110 receives liquid from the housing 107 and distributes liquid L further to the nozzles 112, which eject the liquid L into the container 40 such that liquid L hits the inner walls 41-43 of the container 40.
The rotation in the first direction R1 about the first axis A1 is accomplished via a transmission shaft 104 that extends from an upper end of the pipe 101 and to the rotary head 106 where it is connected to the housing 107. The shaft 104 has a diameter that is smaller than both an inner diameter of the pipe 101, an inner diameter of the connection flange 105 and a diameter of an opening at the inlet end of the housing 107. This allows liquid L to flow past the shaft 104. When the shaft 104 is rotated, the housing 107 and thereby the rotary head 106 are rotated in the first direction R1. The pipe 101 is connected to a connection piece 23 and a gearbox 22 is connected to the connection piece 23. The shaft 104 is connected to the gearbox 22, which in turn is connected to a drive member 21. The drive member 21 is here a conventional electrical motor 21, but other types of motors such as a pneumatic motor may be used just as well. When the motor 21 is activated, it generates a rotation of the shaft 104 and thereby a rotation of the rotary head 106 in the first direction R1.
To accomplish the rotation in the second direction R2, a drive member 109 in form of an impeller 109 is arranged inside the housing 107. A rotation of the impeller 109 is induced by a flow of liquid L that passes through the housing 107, from the inlet end to the outlet end of the housing 107. When the impeller 109 rotates, its rotational movement is used for generating a rotation of the rotary head 106, or more specifically, for generating a rotation of the rotary hub 110 in the second direction R2.
Thus, in the example of
In
In
Reverting to the example in
As shown in further detail in
In many implementations, only the exact hits will result in sufficiently reliable and consistent signal pulses, which means that proper operation of the nozzles may only be verified once for every full pattern, e.g. once every 7 minutes, using the conventional sensor P. On the other hand, as indicated in
As indicated in
The sensor unit 33 may be based on any suitable sensor technology capable of sensing a liquid impact. Such sensor technology includes sensors for direct impact detection, such as various types of pressure sensors, as well as sensors for indirect impact detection, including electric conductivity sensors, liquid detection sensors, pH sensors, and temperature sensors. Pressure sensors may be based on any available technology, such as piezoresistive strain gauges, piezoelectric materials, capacitive detection, electromagnetic detection, optical detection, etc. It is also conceivable that sensing surface 34 is formed by a commercially available pressure sensitive film, e.g. of plastic material, of the type that is used in touch pads for computers.
The sensor ring 34 may define a unitary detection surface, such that the ring sensor 34 generates a signal pulse irrespective of the location of the impact on the sensing surface 34 (zero-dimensional detection). Such a ring sensor 34 may e.g. generate the train of signal pulses as shown in
It is realized that, depending on the implementation of the ring sensor 34, a number of different monitoring parameters may be determined in step S2, including:
In one implementation, step S3 processes the current value of the monitoring parameter(s) generated in step S2 for detection of malfunctions in the cleaning system 2, e.g. by comparing the current value to a corresponding reference value that represents the predetermined pattern. The reference value have may been obtained by mathematical modeling of the cleaning system for the specific container, or it may be obtained in a dedicated calibration procedure (see below). To reduce the impact of the current value, step S3 may instead operate to detect the malfunction based on a time average, optionally weighted, of the most recent values of the monitoring parameter. The malfunction may include an impaired rotation (or lack of rotation) of the rotary head 106 or the rotary hub 110, a complete or partial clogging of one or more nozzles 112, and an inability of the pump 61 to supply an adequate amount of liquid to the cleaning system 2. In one example, the impaired rotation may be detected based on one of the monitoring parameters: ti, Δsi, δti, si, Δn and Δti, or a combination thereof. In another example, a complete or partial clogging of a nozzle may be detected based on one of the monitoring parameters: ti, Δsi, δti, si, Δn, Δti and pi, or a combination thereof. A failure of the pump 61 may be monitored by aggregating (e.g. summing) pi for consecutive jets from different nozzles 112 and monitoring the aggregated value as a function of time. In the event that step S3 detects a malfunction, it may issue an audible alarm and/or a visual signal to alert the operator of the cleaning system, e.g. via the user interface 38 (
In another implementation, step S3 processes the current value of the monitoring parameter(s) to verify that the container has been properly cleaned. This implementation is fully equivalent to the above-described detection of malfunction.
In another implementation, step S3 processes the monitoring parameter(s) to analyze the movement pattern of the jets inside the container. In one example, the monitoring parameter(s) are analyzed for the purpose of validating a cleaning process for a specific container. In another example, the monitoring parameter(s) are analyzed for the purpose of validating or improving a mathematical model of the cleaning process in the container. In yet another example, the monitoring parameter(s) are analyzed for determining their functional dependence on various control or design parameters, such as the pressure of the liquid, the type of liquid, the number of nozzles, the type of nozzles, the rotation speed of the rotary head 106 and/or the rotary hub 110, the size and configuration of the container, the placement of the cleaning system etc, for example for the purpose of optimizing the cleaning process.
In another implementation, step S3 stores the monitoring parameter(s) in electronic memory (e.g. 32 in
In yet another implementation, step S3 is operated to generate the above-mentioned reference values during a calibration procedure and store the reference values in an electronic memory for subsequent access by the processing unit. The reference values may be given by monitoring parameter values that are computed during a cleaning process at well-controlled conditions in the container, or they may be given in by monitoring parameter values computed in a preceding cleaning process that was completed without any malfunctions.
The sensing surface 34 of the sensor unit 33 may be configured in many different ways while retaining at least some of the advantages of the ring sensor in
The embodiment in
The embodiment in
The embodiment in
The embodiment of
It is realized that any of the embodiment in
Generally, the monitoring process according to the various embodiments disclosed herein may be implemented by a data processing device, such as the processing unit 30, which is connected to sample or otherwise acquire measurement values from the sensor unit 33. With reference to
The device 30′ may be implemented by special-purpose software (or firmware) run on one or more general-purpose or special-purpose computing devices. In this context, it is to be understood that each “element” or “means” of such a computing device refers to a conceptual equivalent of a method step; there is not always a one-to-one correspondence between elements/means and particular pieces of hardware or software routines. One piece of hardware sometimes comprises different means/elements. For example, a processing unit may serve as one element/means when executing one instruction, but serve as another element/means when executing another instruction. In addition, one element/means may be implemented by one instruction in some cases, but by a plurality of instructions in some other cases. Naturally, it is conceivable that one or more elements (means) are implemented entirely by analog hardware components.
The software controlled device 30′ may include one or more processing units (cf. 31 in
While the invention has been described in connection with what is presently considered to be the most practical and preferred embodiments, it is to be understood that the invention is not to be limited to the disclosed embodiments, but on the contrary, is intended to cover various modifications and equivalent arrangements included within the spirit and the scope of the appended claims.
For example, the cleaning system may be mounted in an opening in any wall portion of the container to be cleaned, and the pipe may thus extend into the container in any desired direction. Further, the sensor unit need not be mounted on the cleaning system (e.g. in the mounting flange 102), but may instead be mounted directly in a wall portion of the container. It is also possible to use other types of RSH and RJH nozzle heads than those exemplified herein.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
12155043 | Feb 2012 | EP | regional |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2013/052769 | 2/12/2013 | WO | 00 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2013/120841 | 8/22/2013 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2035962 | Hock | Mar 1936 | A |
5333630 | Jepsen et al. | Aug 1994 | A |
5715852 | Jepsen | Feb 1998 | A |
20030137895 | Hummer | Jul 2003 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
1615429 | May 2005 | CN |
10 2006 034882 | Oct 2007 | DE |
1 882 914 | Jan 2008 | EP |
8-192125 | Jul 1996 | JP |
2008-290003 | Dec 2008 | JP |
03089883 | Oct 2003 | WO |
Entry |
---|
English Machine Translation of EP 1882914 A2. |
“Instruction Manual, Toftejorg Sanitary Rotacheck System, Ex for Toftejorg TJ20G/TZ-74/TZ-79/TZ-89” TIM-TE91A661-EN032, (Alfa Laval Toftejorg), month and year of publication unknown (publication obtained before Feb. 2012), pp. 1-4. |
Troy R. Humphries, “Transportation, Storage, and Process”, Tank Cleaning Technology, Version: 456B, (May 30, 2006), pp. 1-19. |
International Search Report (PCT/ISA/210) dated Mar. 5, 2013, by the European Patent Office as the International Searching Authority for International Application No. PCT/EP2013/052769. |
Written Opinion (PCT/ISA/237) dated Mar. 5, 2013, by the European Patent Office as the International Searching Authority for International Application No. PCT/EP2013/052769. |
Search Report dated Aug. 1, 2012, by the European Patent Office for Application No. 12155043.8. |
Anonymous: “Edelstahl-Reinigungstechnik [7. Auflage]: CIP-Monitoring System (CIPMon SC)”, Armaturenwerk Hötensleben catalogue, Nov. 2006, pp. 1, 98-100, XP002680355, retrieved from the internet: URL:http://www.awh.de/pdf/deutsch/AWH-RT7-1106-dt.pdf. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20160008859 A1 | Jan 2016 | US |