1. Field of the Invention
The present invention relates to a multi-polar rotary machine, and more particularly, to a typical hybrid type stepping motor capable of increasing an output and reducing cogging torque for use in an office automation (OA) apparatus or a fully automatic (FA) equipment.
2. Description of the Prior Art
A variable•reluctance (VR) type stepping motor having a rotor using no permanent magnet, a permanent magnet (PM) type stepping motor having a rotor composed of a permanent magnet, and a hybrid (HB) type stepping motor formed by mixing the variable•reluctance type stepping motor and the permanent magnet type stepping motor have been proposed. The permanent magnet type stepping motor and the hybrid type stepping motor are capable of reducing in size and accordingly are used in a relatively small industrial machine. Especially, the hybrid type stepping motor is high in precision and torque and is small in step angle, and accordingly such motor is used widely. However, it is required for the motor to reduce in size and to increase in torque further.
In order to increase a torque, it is effective to increase magnetic flux interlinkaging a winding and a turn number of the winding. A stepping motor capable of increasing the magnetic flux interlinkaging the winding without reducing the resolution or the rotor tooth number is disclosed in the Japanese Patent Application Laid-Open No. 12856/81.
A reference numeral 8 denotes an annular groove formed on a peripheral surface at a central portion of the stator element 4, 9 denotes an annular groove formed on a peripheral surface at a central portion of the stator element 5, 12 denotes an exciting winding arranged in the annular groove 8, and 13 denotes an exciting winding arranged in the annular groove 9.
A reference numeral 10 denotes a cylindrical rotor supported rotatably by the shaft 1 through bearings 11 and 11 and covers 2 and 2′. An inner peripheral surface of the rotor 10 faces to an outer peripheral surface of the stator 6 with an air gap therebetween, and has a plurality of small rotor teeth similar in number to the small stator teeth of the stator element 4 or 5.
As shown in
In the above case, the small stator teeth A, B, Ā, and
A current flow of the magnetic flux will now be explained. As shown in
The magnetic fluxes φA, φĀ, φB and φ
φA=ΦA(1+k cos θ) (1)
φĀ=ΦĀ(1−k′ cos θ) (2)
φB=ΦB(1+k sin θ) (3)
φ
Here, θ denotes an electrical angle of the rotation of rotor 10, ΦA, ΦĀ, ΦB and Φ
As shown in the Formulas 1 to 4, the magnetic fluxes φA, φB, φĀ and φ
The generated torque is analyzed as follows.
As shown in
A torque TA and a torque TB can be expressed by Formulas 7 and 8.
TA=eAi/ωM=niΦkp sin θ (7)
TB=eBi/ωM=niΦkp cos θ (8)
Here, ωM denotes a mechanical angular velocity and is ω/p, and p denotes a pole pair number, that is, a number of the small stator teeth or small rotor teeth.
It is appreciated that a mean magnetic flux Φ interlinkaging the winding and a rate of variation k must be increased in order to increase the torque if the number of windings and the number of the small teeth are constant.
In general, each of the rotor and the stator of the motor is formed by laminating a plurality of silicon steel plates, and each silicon steel plate is coated with an anti-corrosion film, so that a gap is formed between laminated silicon steel plates unavoidably. In the conventional motor, many paths of magnetic flux are formed in the axial direction of the motor, and the permeance of iron core is reduced by the gap between the laminated plates, so that the magnetic flux interlinkaging the winding is reduced. Especially, in the motor as shown in
Accordingly, an object of the present invention is to provide a motor wherein an output of the motor is increased by reducing the magnetic reluctance of the paths in the axial direction of the motor, and balancing magnetic paths of A, Ā,
Another object of the present invention is to provide a multi-polar rotary machine comprising a stator; and a cylindrical outer rotor arranged concentrically with the stator and with an air gap therebetween; said stator having two splitted stator elements and a ring shaped permanent magnet held between the stator elements and magnetized so as to form N and S poles in the axial direction of the stator, a plurality of small stator teeth A and Ā separated in the axial direction of the stator from each other and formed on the outer peripheral surface of one of the splitted stator elements, a plurality of small stator teeth
Further object of the present invention is to provide a multi-polar rotary machine comprising a stator; and a cylindrical outer rotor arranged concentrically with the stator and with an air gap therebetween; said stator having two splitted stator elements and a ring shaped permanent magnet held between the stator elements and magnetized so as to form N and S poles in the axial direction of the stator, a plurality of small stator teeth A and Ā separated in the axial direction of the stator from each other and formed on the outer peripheral surface of one of the splitted stator elements, a plurality of small stator teeth
A further object of the present invention is to provide a multi-polar rotary machine comprising an inner rotor; and a cylindrical stator arranged concentrically with the rotor and with an air gap therebetween; said stator having two splitted stator elements and a ring shaped permanent magnet held between the stator elements and magnetized so as to form N and S poles in the axial direction of the stator, a plurality of small stator teeth A and Ā separated in the axial direction of the stator from each other and formed on the inner peripheral surface of one of the splitted stator elements, a plurality of small stator teeth
Yet further object of the present invention is to provide a multi-polar rotary machine comprising an inner rotor; and a cylindrical stator arranged concentrically with the rotor and with an air gap therebetween; said stator having two splitted stator elements and a ring shaped permanent magnet held between the stator elements and magnetized so as to form N and S poles in the axial direction of the stator, a plurality of small stator teeth A and Ā separated in the axial direction of the stator from each other and formed on the inner peripheral surface of one of the splitted stator elements, a plurality of small stator teeth
Still further object of the present invention is to provide a multi-polar rotary machine comprising an inner rotor; and a cylindrical stator arranged concentrically with the rotor and with an air gap therebetween; said rotor having two splitted rotor elements and a ring shaped permanent magnet held between the rotor elements and magnetized so as to form N and S poles in the axial direction of the rotor; said stator having two splitted stator elements and a plurality of small stator teeth A and Ā separated in the axial direction of the stator from each other and formed on the inner peripheral surface of one of the splitted stator elements, a plurality of small stator teeth
The other object of the present invention is to provide a multi-polar rotary machine comprising an inner rotor; and a cylindrical stator arranged concentrically with the rotor and with an air gap therebetween; said rotor having two splitted rotor elements and a ring shaped permanent magnet held between the rotor elements and magnetized so as to form N and S poles in the axial direction of the rotor; said stator having two splitted stator elements and a plurality of small stator teeth A and Ā separated in the axial direction of the stator from each other and formed on the inner peripheral surface of one of the splitted stator elements, a plurality of small stator teeth
A ratio of a thickness of the small stator teeth Ā in the axial direction of the stator to a thickness of the small stator teeth A in the axial direction of the stator is set to a value smaller than 1 so as to equalize substantially in mean permeance both small stator teeth A and Ā to each other, and wherein a ratio of a thickness of the small stator teeth
A ratio of a thickness of the small stator teeth Ā or
A ratio of a stator tooth width to a rotor tooth width is set to 35% to 45% with respect to the standard small teeth pitch.
These and other aspects and objects of the present invention will be better appreciated and understood when considered in conjunction with the following description and the accompanying drawings. It should be understood, however, that the following description, while indicating preferred embodiments of the present invention, is given by way of illustration and not of limitation. Many changes and modifications may be made within the scope of the present invention without departing from the spirit thereof, and the invention includes all such modifications.
A hybrid stepping motor of a first embodiment according to the present invention will be explained. Parts of the motor which are similar to corresponding parts of the conventional motor shown in
As shown in
Said stator 6 has two splitted stator elements 4,5 and a ring shaped permanent magnet 3 held between the stator elements 4, 5 and magnetized so as to form N and S poles in the axial direction of the stator 6, a plurality of small stator teeth A and Ā separated in the axial direction of the stator 6 from each other and formed on the outer peripheral surface of one of the splitted stator elements 4, a plurality of small stator teeth
Said rotor 10 has a plurality of small rotor teeth formed on the inner peripheral surface thereof similar in number to the small stator teeth. Said small stator teeth A, Ā,
In order to certify the effect of the motor according to the present invention, the magnetic field analysis using the three-dimensional finite element method is applied to a motor having a rotor of 35 mm in outer diameter, a stator of 28 mm in axial length, a magnet of 2 mm in thickness, and each of windings of 6 mm in thickness.
It is apparent that the cogging torque s of the motor according to the present invention is reduced to about ⅕ of the cogging torque r of the conventional motor, of which stator and rotor are formed by laminated silicon steel plates.
The powder of soft magnetic material itself is high in electric resistance, so that the eddy current loss in the motor can be reduced, and accordingly it is effective to use for the higher speed motor. In a second embodiment of the present invention, a ratio C of a thickness of the small stator teeth Ā in the axial direction of the stator to a thickness of the small stator teeth A in the axial direction of the stator (stack ratio) is set to a value smaller than 1, preferably 0.5 to 0.8 so as to equalize substantially in mean permeance both small stator teeth A and Ā to each other, and a ratio C of a thickness of the small stator teeth
According to the present invention, the cogging torque Tc can be reduced without reducing the counter electromotive force e as shown in
In a third embodiment of the present invention, the small rotor teeth of the rotor 10 are arranged with vernier pitch different from the regular pitch of 7.2°, that is 360°/50 in case that the number of the small rotor teeth is 50, for example. The small rotor teeth of the vernier pitch are divided into two, for example, and a gap is formed between divided small rotor teeth so that the divided small rotor teeth are arranged axisymmetrically, in order to eliminate an unbalance magnetic attractive force in the radial direction of the rotor.
In this case, the small stator teeth A, Ā, B and
Further, in the other embodiment of present invention, the same effect can be obtained by arranging the small stator teeth of the stator with vernier pitch, instead of the small rotor teeth of the rotor.
(Equivalent Magnetic Circuit of Motor)
In order to clarify the present invention, the equivalent magnetic circuit theory is applied to the motor.
It is considered that the total permeance of the small stator teeth A and Ā, and B and
Accordingly, if it is assumed that a half of the magnetomotive force of the magnet is applied equally on each of the small stator teeth of the A phase and B phase, the magnetic circuit can be converted into an equivalent magnetic circuit shown in
Magnetic flux φi of i phase in
In this case, PiC is a larger value with respect to the variable air gap permeance Pig.
However, it is assumed that 1/(1+Pig/PiC) is constant substantially with respect to the rotation for the shake of simplicity and expressed by Formula 10.
Accordingly, Formula 9 can be expressed by Formula 11.
φi=kiFM Pig (11)
Pig has a phase difference of 90° in electrical angle in each phase as shown in
Here, a reference character hi denotes an effective length in the axial direction of the small stator teeth of each phase, ρig1 denotes a permeance per unit axial length, ρn denotes a coefficient of n th harmonic component, ζi denotes an electrical angle of i th phase, and θe denotes an electrical angle of rotation.
(Effective Magnetic Flux and Electric Current Torque)
In the stepping motor of the present invention, torques TA and TB are generated by the mutual action of the magnetic fluxes φA and φB interlinkaging the winding of each phase and the electric currents iA and iB passing through the windings. If the numbers of the windings of A phase and B phase are the same and the number is nA, Formula 14 can be obtained.
Taking only the fundamental wave occupying a large component of the torque into consideration with the magnetic flux and the relation of Formulas 11 to 13, Formula 15 and Formula 16 can be obtained.
φA=kAFMhA(ρ0+ρ1 cos θc), φB=kAFMhA(ρ0+ρ1 cos(θe−π/2)) (15)
The torque can be expressed by Formula 17.
TA=iAnAkAFMhAρ1n sin θe, TB=iBnAkAFMhAρ1n sin(θe−π/2) (17)
Electric currents similar in phase to the counter electromotive force expressed by formula 18 are considered.
A=IA sin θe, iB=IA sin(θe−π/2) (18)
A torque T expressed by Formula 19 is obtained.
T=TA+TB=√{square root over (2)}IAnAkAFMhAρ1≡√{square root over (2)} IAnAΔφA (19)
Here, ΔφA=kAFMhAρ1 is an amplitude of variable component of the magnetic flux in Formula 15.
It is understood that ΔφA is essential to increase the torque at the magnetic circuit side, because the electric current torque (or torque constant) is in proportion to the amplitude ΔφA of the variable component of the magnetic flux. It is understood further that the ampereturn IAnA must be maintained at the winding side according to Formula 19.
In the stepping motor, other than the electric current torque which is an effective torque the cogging torque causing a vibration is generated, so that the cogging torque must be reduced.
(Cogging Torque)
The magnetic energy in the air gap occupying a large portion of the magnetic energy in the equivalent magnetic circuit shown in
The cogging torque Tc is given by the angle differentiation of magnetic energy, and expressed by Formula 21 in case of the two-phase motor.
Here, a reference character N denotes a number of small rotor tooth, and θe denotes an electrical angle. It is assumed that ki is not varied by the rotary angle. Formula 22 can be obtained.
(Relation Between the Harmonic Component and the Cogging Torque)
Table 1 shows harmonic components of air gap permeance in each phase. A coefficient (ki2hi)ρn of each phase is omitted for the sake of simplicity.
(ki2hi)ρn is equal between A and B, and Ā and
(Improvement by Small Teeth Arrangement)
A method of eliminating specific harmonic components, that is, the quaternary harmonic components by the arrangement of the small teeth utilizing the fact that the air gap permeace Pig consists of the total of each small tooth permeance will be examined.
(Total of Small Teeth Permeances)
The air gap permeance Pig in each phase can be considered as the total of the permeances Pik (here, i is a phase number, and k is small tooth number) between small teeth, as shown in Formula 23.
In this examination, therefore, the permeance is culculated in accordance with each small tooth, and the premeance of the winding pole is obtained by a sum of the calculated premeances.
The assumed magnetic path method is adpted for calculation of the permeance, and an example of the magnetic path of one small tooth portion is shown in
Here, μ0 denotes the space permeability, dS denotes a differential opposed area, and l denotes a magnetic path length. The permeance is varied bisymmetrically according to the even function as shown in
The total permeance of all phases can be obtained by totalizing presences of N pieces of small tooth. In case of the motor shown in
(Principle of Improvement by Small Teeth Arrangement)
It is expected that the waveform of the permeance becomes smooth by the arrangement of the small teeth shifted slightly from the pole pitch, respectively, and the cogging torque is reduced. Here, the principle is considered. In order to remove specific n th harmonic components by the combinationation of the small teeth permeances Formula 25 must be satisfied. In case that the cogging torque of the two-phase motor is reduced, n is 4.
Here, m is a number of groups of small teeth, and Q is a number of small tooth in one group and N=mQ. ρ1kn is a n th harmonic component of unit length permeance of k th small tooth, and can be specified in the form of complex vectors used a deviation from the reference angle (small tooth permeance vectors), as shown in Formula 26.
ρ1 kn=ρ1 knεj n p θ
Here, ρ1kn is an amplitude of n th harmonic component of small tooth permeance, p is a number of magnetic pole pairs and equal to the number N of the small tooth in the motor of the present invention shown in
The position θk can be expressed by using a deviation angle δθk from an angle (reference angle) θk0 in case that the small teeth are arranged by magnetic pole pair pitch, as shown in Formula 27.
θk=θk0+δθk=2π(k−1)+δθk (27)
Because εjnpθk0=εj2πnp(k−1)=1, Formula 26 becomes in the same form in case that the deviation angle δθk is used instead of the position θk. The condition for reducing the cogging torque can be expresed by Formula 28 using Formula 25 similarly.
The deviation angle δθk can be expressed by an angle from zero position, because the reference angle θk0 is always zero angle. In such condition, if permmeance vectors of small teeth are shown on a harmonic vector plane expressed by electrical angle, a vector sum of the permeance vectors becomes zero. Each vector is rotated while maintaining the relative positions, so that the balance is maintained always during the rotation and the cogging torque is minimized.
(Removal of Quaternary Harmonic Component)
A method of reducing the cogging torque is considered utilizing the above conception. It is necessary to arrange the small teeth axisymmetrically in order to avoid the unbalance in the radial direction. In case that the number of the small tooth is 50, the small teeth are divided into two groups and arrange axisymmetrically.
In case that only the quaternary harmonic component which has a large relation to the cogging torque is removed, the vernier system wherein the pitch of the small tooth is varied is preferable.
In case that the small teeth in one group are arranged at regular pitch, the deviation angle δθk is equal with respect to each small tooth, so that it is necessary to arrange Q pieces of vector ρ1knεjnpδθ
In this case, the deviation angle δθk is expressed by Formula 29.
In the motor of the present invention shown in
It is apparent that the displacements of negative side and positive side have the same effect with each other, as described with respect to Formula 25 to Formula 29.
(Elimination of Two Kinds Harmonic Waves)
As stated above, it is not necessary to arrange the small teeth in the regular pitch and it is possible to arrange arbitrary in order to satisfy Formula 25. However, the axisymmetric construction is preferable as stated above. It is required to obtain positive effects, such as the removal of the two kinds of harmonic waves in the irregular pitch arrangement.
Further, it is considered to remove not only the quaternary harmonic wave having a large relation to the generation of the cogging torque, but also the tertiary harmonic wave. In this case, the 50 pieces of small tooth are divided into two groups so as to satisfy the axisymmetericality, and one group is divided further into five subgroups in consideration of the factors. The tertiary harmonic component is removed from each subgroup and the quaternary harmonic wave is removed among five subgroups. In this case, Q is 5, so that the deviation angle δθ can be expressed by Formula 29 as following.
In each subgroup, δθ is 0.48° (elimination of the tertiary harmonic wave).
Among five subgroups, δθ is 0.36° (elimination of the quaternary harmonic wave).
In
In each subgroup, a distance between small teeth is (7.2°−0.48°=6.72°). An angle among the groups, that is among lines θ1, θ2, θ3, θ4, and θ5 is (7.2°×5−0.36°=35.64°).
In the above case, the change of the small teeth arrangement is carried out about the rotor side, however, the change can be carried out about the stator side instead of the rotor side.
In case that two kinds of harmonic waves, such as quaternary and tertiary harmonic waves are removed, a small rotor tooth pitch (distance) is set to (7.2°−360/(4×50×25)=7.128°), and a small stator tooth pitch is set to (7.2°−360/(3×50×25)=7.104°) as shown in
(Improvement of Balance of Odd Number Harmonic Components)
In Table 1, the permeance variations are totalized on the assumption that the coefficient (ki2hi)ρn is equal with respect to each phase. In case of the odd number harmonic waves (fundamental wave and the tertiary wave), Σρ can not be set to zero unless (ki2hi) is equal with respect to A phase and Ā phase.
kA and kĀ are expressed by Formula 30 according to Formula 10.
The same Formula can be obtained with respect to B phase.
The magnetic path of the A phase is longer by a length of iron core between the A and Ā phases than that of the Ā phase. Accordingly, PAC<P
That is, the small teeth length of A phase in the axial direction must be longer than that of Ā phase.
The magnetic flux φA of A phase and the amplitude ΔφA of the variable component thereof are reduced by the magnetic reluctance of the magnetic path, and the electric current torque is reduced. The electric machine using laminated steel plates has small air gaps between the laminated steel pates, so that the magnetic reluctance is increased. Accordingly, it is preferable to use thicker steel plate and to reduce the number of the laminated steel plate. Further, it is preferable to use an iron core made of insulating powder, because the relative difference between kA and kĀ becomes small.
(Study by Three-Dimensional FEM Magnetic Field Analysis)
The amplitude φCM of the magnetic flux variation which affects on the torque generation and the cogging torque which effects on the vibration are calculated under many conditions by using a magnetic field analyzing program of the three-dimensional finite element method which is actually used for the hybrid type stepping motor.
(Iron Core Material and Stack Ratio)
Effects of ki when the length hi of the small stator teeth in the axial direction is varied are studied about the laminated silicon steel plates and the pressed powder magnetic core in order to correct the effects of ki which are different in the positive phases A and B and the negative phases Ā and
The motor to be tested has a rotor of 35.4 mm in outer diameter, 29.6 mm in inner diameter and 7.128° in small rotor tooth pitch, a stator of 7.2° in small stator tooth pitch, a magnet of 27.6 mm in outer diameter, 20 mm in inner diameter and 2 mm in thickness, and a winding of 6 mm in axial length. An air gap between the inner peripheral surface of the rotor and the outer peripheral surface of the stator is 0.1 mm. The tooth width and groove depth of each of the rotor and the stator are 0.7 mm, respectively. The calculation is carried out by varying the stack ratio so that the sum of the lengths in the axial direction of the small stator teeth of the positive and negative phases is set to 6 mm.
The results of calculation of the cogging torque and the effective magnetic flux in case that the stack ratio (1/C) of the positive and negative phases is varied are shown in
As apparent from
As apparent from
As stated above, it is understood that the pressed powder iron core is the best for the effective magnetic flux. In
The variable magnetic flux in both phases contributing the torque generation is small and 40% or more. However, it is considered that the interlinkaging magnetic flux is larger than that in the normal structure, because the magnet is large and the number of winding in each phase is 1.
(Effect of Vernier Pitch)
(Affection of Tooth Width)
(Embodiment of Teeth Divided into Four Groups)
In case that the number of small tooth is 50, it is considered that the small teeth are divided into two groups each having 25 pieces of small tooth, as shown in
In case that the number of small tooth is 48, it is possible to divide the small teeth into four groups as shown in
(Embodiment of Inner Rotor Type Motor)
The present invention can be applied on a motor having an inner rotor as shown in
In the motor shown in
(Effect of the Tooth Width Ratio at the Optimum Stack Ratio)
According to the magnetic field analysis, it is considered that the cogging torque becomes zero in case that the stack ratio is 1.6 (the small teeth length of positive phase is 3.7 mm and the small teeth length of negative phase is 2.3 mm).
The relation of the tooth width and the cogging torque is shown in
The other power transistors 29 to 32 and the winding 13 are actuated similarly.
In the two-phase brushless motor as mentioned above, the number of the power transistor can be reduced to four, if the bifilar winding is used for each winding. It is preferable to reduce the magnetic pole pair number, that is, the number of small tooth is reduced compared with that in the normal hybrid type motor, in order to make easy the mounting precision of the Hall elements for detecting the rotor position.
The above brushless motor is simple in construction, low in cost, small in size, and high in torque, and can be used widely, because the control circuit is two-phase.
According to the stepping motor of the present invention, following effects can be obtained.
(1) It is possible to improve the permeance of the main magnetic flux path, and increase the counter electromotive force, torque and output, by using synthetic powder soft magnetic material, though a cylindrical winding of small turn number is used.
(2) It is possible to minimize the cogging torque without reducing the counter electromotive force, by selecting the stack ratio of the small teeth of two phases.
(3) It is possible to widen the freedom of design, and reduce the loss of the magnetic material due to the punching and the manufacturing cost, because the stator and the rotor can be made of the pressed powder soft magnetic material.
(4) The iron loss of the motor at the high speed rotation thereof can be reduced, so that the motor efficiency can be increased.
(5) The present invention can be applied to not only stepping motor, but also brushless motor, synchronous motor or generator.
(6) The cogging torque and the vibration of the motor can be reduced remarkably, because the numbers of rotor and stator small teeth are the same with each other, the small teeth of one of the motor and stator being arranged axisymmetrically with vernier pitch.
(7) The conventional motor shown in the Japanese Patent Application Laid-Open No. 12856/81, for example, is low in cost, because the winding can be carried out easily, however, the counter electromotive force, the output torque are small and the cogging torque is large, so that the utility is small. According to the present invention, however, the above defects can be obviated by using powder soft magnetic material.
(8) The multi-polar rotary machine of the present invention can be used widely for the office automation (OA) apparatus which require no vibration, or the full automation (FA) equipment which is operated at a high speed. The present invention can also be applied similarly to the inner rotor type motor, brushless motor, synchronous motor or generator.
While the invention has been particularly shown and described with reference to the preferred embodiments thereof, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes in form and details may be made therein without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2003-330338 | Sep 2003 | JP | national |
2004-197226 | Jul 2004 | JP | national |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4206374 | Goddijn | Jun 1980 | A |
4306164 | Itoh et al. | Dec 1981 | A |
4327299 | Goddijn | Apr 1982 | A |
4488069 | Field, II et al. | Dec 1984 | A |
4899072 | Ohta et al. | Feb 1990 | A |
5719452 | Sugiura | Feb 1998 | A |
5723921 | Sugiura | Mar 1998 | A |
5834865 | Sugiura | Nov 1998 | A |
5856714 | Sugiura | Jan 1999 | A |
6441530 | Petersen | Aug 2002 | B1 |
20010038249 | Ohnishi et al. | Nov 2001 | A1 |
20020079749 | Ohnishi et al. | Jun 2002 | A1 |
20050062348 | Ohnishi et al. | Mar 2005 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
0568347 | Nov 1993 | EP |
0812054 | Dec 1997 | EP |
1289102 | Mar 2003 | EP |
54084207 | Jul 1979 | JP |
56-012856 | Feb 1981 | JP |
56012856 | Feb 1981 | JP |
57-208854 | Dec 1982 | JP |
60-070958 | Apr 1985 | JP |
03-112356 | May 1991 | JP |
04-140056 | May 1992 | JP |
06-165468 | Jun 1994 | JP |
09-056137 | Feb 1997 | JP |
09-233801 | Sep 1997 | JP |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20050062348 A1 | Mar 2005 | US |