A spaceplate is a photonic device that miniaturizes optical systems. Free-space between the components of an optical system takes by far the most volume of an optical system. A spaceplate has the same optical functionality as free-space over a distance d, e.g., as expressed by the transfer function of free space, while having a thickness less than distance d. A spaceplate may be placed anywhere in the optical path of an optical system to reduce the space between the components of the system.
To date, there is no spaceplate design to miniaturize optical devices in the visible region of the electromagnetic spectrum. Rather, existing spaceplate designs compress free-space within a limited bandwidth. Hence, these are effectively monochromatic spaceplates.
The operating bandwidth of a spaceplate is constrained by strict physical bounds underlying generic space compression mechanisms. The fundamental trade-off between compression ratio and bandwidth, inherent in the optics of spaceplates, suggests that drastic space compression over the entire visible range is fundamentally challenging and far from feasible in practice, as it would require transparent materials with a large refractive index (e.g., a refractive index on the order of three to achieve a compression ratio of four). These physical bounds, however, only apply to spaceplates operating over continuous bandwidths, suggesting a possible strategy to bypass these issues.
Based on this insight, in this work we disclose “multi-color” spaceplates, embodiments of which operate at three distinct color channels over the visible spectrum to replace and compress free-space in color imaging systems. In embodiments, the space compression effect is based on the guided-mode resonances in dispersion-engineered coupled planar FP cavities made of amorphous TiO2 and SiO2 layers.
Embodiments of the disclosed multi-color spaceplates have high transmission efficiency and an achromatic response at three wavelengths with space compression ratios as high as ˜4.6, using dielectric materials with a refractive index less than ˜2.6.
Embodiments disclosed herein include a multi-wavelength spaceplate that achromatically compresses space for light propagation at three distinct color channels over the visible spectrum. The multi-wavelength spaceplate may include monochromatic (i.e., single-color) spaceplates. Analytic and simulation results confirm that a particular integration of monochromatic spaceplates forms a multi-wavelength spaceplate with an achromatic response at three wavelengths.
Compared to most previous designs of multilayer spaceplates, which were based on optimization methods, the disclosed spaceplates are designed through a rational approach rooted in the physics of wave propagation in FP cavities, which enables the design of scalable spaceplates with no limits on the number of layers. Conversely, design approaches based on standard brute-force optimization methods are not scalable in practice because the number of layers is significantly limited by trade-offs between the performance of the optimization algorithms and the number of degrees of freedom. More importantly, it is highly non-trivial to design a multi-color spaceplate with achromatic performance at three distinct colors.
Designing spaceplates with broadband or multi-band response has not been possible so far by relying on brute-force optimization. Simplifying the structural complexity required for high-performance space compression, making it amenable to rational design solutions, is in our opinion a significant strength of the disclosed approach.
In a first aspect, a multi-color spaceplate includes a first component spaceplate and a second component spaceplate cascaded with the first component spaceplate. The first component spaceplate has an on-resonance compression ratio C11 at a first resonance wavelength and, at a second resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C21, that is less than the on-resonance compression ratio C11. The second component spaceplate has an on-resonance compression ratio C22 at the second resonance wavelength and, at the first resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C12 that is less than the on-resonance compression ratio C22. The multi-color spaceplate may also include a third component spaceplate cascaded with the first component spaceplate and the second component spaceplate. The third component spaceplate has (i) an on-resonance compression ratio C33 at a third resonance wavelength, (ii) at the first resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C13 that is less than the on-resonance compression ratio C33, and (iii) at the second resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C23 that is less than the on-resonance compression ratio C33.
Embodiments of multi-color spaceplate 100 may be integrated into, and decrease the size of, imaging systems such as cameras, AR/VR headsets, night-vision goggles, telescopes, and microscopes. Realizing space compression in the visible spectrum may lead to a new generation of ultra-thin optical systems, making the use of complex optical systems even more widespread in our daily lives. Even an embodiment of multi-color spaceplate 100 that has a compression ratio as low as two (twofold size reduction) for multiple color channels over the visible spectrum would still make a significant impact toward the miniaturization of many optical devices. AR/VR headsets, night-vision goggles, telescopes, microscopes, and cameras are among the many optical devices that may be made thinner and lighter in weight through the use of multi-color spaceplate 100.
Multi-color spaceplate 200 may be configured to be substantially transparent in at least two of a first spectral range that includes resonance wavelength 201, a second spectral range that includes resonance wavelength 202, and a third spectral range that includes resonance wavelength 203. The bandwidth of each of the first, second, and third spectral ranges may be at least ten nanometers or at least twenty nanometers. Herein, examples of “substantially transparent” include transmittance values of at least 75%. For example, the transmittance may be at least 80%, 85%, or 90%, between 75% and 100%, or within any subrange therein.
In embodiments, multi-color spaceplate 200 also includes a component spaceplate 230 that is cascaded with component spaceplate 210 and component spaceplate 220. Component spaceplate 230 has (i) an on-resonance compression ratio 233 (C33) at a resonance wavelength 203, (ii) at resonance wavelength 201, an off-resonance compression ratio 213 (C13) that is less than on-resonance compression ratio 233, and (iii) at resonance wavelength 202, an off-resonance compression ratio 223 (C23) that is less than on-resonance compression ratio 233. In such embodiments, (i) component spaceplate 210 has an off-resonance compression ratio 231 (C31), that is less than on-resonance compression ratio 211, and (ii) component spaceplate 220 has an off-resonance compression ratio 232 (C32), that is less than on-resonance compression ratio 222.
Equation (1) defines s compression tensor C characterizing multi-color spaceplate 200. Compression tensor C includes the aforementioned compression ratios Cij, where the first index i denotes the wavelength of incident light and the second index j denotes the resonance wavelength of component spaceplate 210 (j=1), 220 (j=2), or 230
Resonance wavelength 201 may be less than resonance wavelength 202, which may be less than resonance wavelength 203. Each of resonance wavelengths 201-203 may be in the range of 450 nm and 800 nm, or any subrange within this range. In embodiments, resonance wavelength 201 is between 380 nm and 490 nm, resonance wavelength 202 is between 490 nm and 560 nm, and resonance wavelength 203 is between 570 nm and 750 nm. Herein, resonance wavelengths 201, 202, and 203 are also denoted by λ1, λ2, and λ3, respectively. Similarly, subscript k equals one of integers 1, 2, or 3, such that λk is one of resonance wavelengths 201-203.
One or more of on-resonance compression ratios 211, 222, and 233 may be greater than two, such that each component spaceplate of multi-color spaceplate 200 functions as a space plate at on-resonance wavelengths. One or more of off-resonance compression ratios 221, 231, 212, 232, 213, and 223 may be less or equal to one such that each component spaceplate of multi-color spaceplate 200 does not compress incident light incident having off-resonance wavelengths. For example, each of the off-resonance compression ratios may be less than or equal to 0.7.
In embodiments, component spaceplates 210, 220, and 230 include material layers 217, material layers 227, and material layers 237, respectively. Herein, where nmax1, nmax2, and nmax3 denote the maximum refractive index of the material layers 217, 227, and 237, respectively. In embodiments, we have found that these maximum refractive indices impose a lower limit on the values of off-resonance compression ratios. Hence, in embodiments, at least one of (i) off-resonance compression ratio C21 exceeds 1/nmax1 and (ii) off-resonance compression ratio C12 exceeds 1/nmax2. When multi-color spaceplate 200 includes component spaceplate 230, at least one (i) off-resonance compression ratio C13 exceeds 1/nmax3, (iii) off-resonance compression ratio C23 exceeds 1/nmax3.
Candidate materials for quarter-wave layers 311 and 312 include silicon dioxide and titanium dioxide. In embodiments, one of quarter-wave layers 311 and 312 may be a silicon dioxide layer while the other of quarter-wave layers 311 and 312 is a titanium dioxide layer.
Along direction D1, cavity layer 320 has a thickness 329 that defines a distance between DBRs 310(1) and 310(2). Thickness 329 is a geometric thickness. Thickness 329 equal to mkλk/2n320(λk), where n320(λk) is the refractive index of cavity layer 320 at wavelength λk, and mk is a positive integer. Optical cavity 300 has a length 308, which may be a distance between an exterior-facing surface 319(1) of DBR 310(1) and an exterior-facing surface 319(2) of DBR 310(2).
Component spaceplate 410 includes N1 cascaded optical cavities 412 each having a resonance at resonance wavelength 201. Component spaceplate 420 includes N2 cascaded optical cavities 422 each having a resonance at resonance wavelength 202. Component spaceplate 430 includes N3 cascaded optical cavities 432 each having a resonance at resonance wavelength 203. Each of optical cavities 412, 422, and 432 is an example of optical cavity 300. Each of N1, N2, and N3 is a positive integer.
Each optical cavity 412, 422, and 432 is an example of optical cavity 300, and hence has a cavity layer 320 having thickness 329. For cavities 412, 422, and 432, thickness 329 equals m1λ1/2n320(λ1), m2Δ2/2n320(λ2), and m3λ3/2n320(λ3), respectively.
Embodiments of multi-color spaceplate 400 with specific values of m1, m2, and m3, and/or relationships among these quantities, have distinctively superior performance. Each of m1, m2, and m3 is a design parameter used in designing multi-color spaceplates. These parameters may be selected in a way that monochromatic spaceplate components perform space compression near one specified wavelength and function as a high-transmission filter at other wavelengths.
In a first embodiment, one of m1, m2, and m3 equals one, and the remaining two of m1, m2, and m3 equaling two. In a second embodiment, m1 equals one and resonance wavelength 201 is less than each of resonance wavelength 202 and resonance wavelength 203. In the second embodiment, m2 and m3 may equal two as in the first embodiment. In a third embodiments, each of m1, m2, and m3 equals one.
Embodiments of multi-color spaceplate 400 with specific values of N1, N2, and N3, and/or relationships among these quantities, have distinctively superior performance In a fourth embodiment, N2 equals 5N1/6 and N3 equals N2. In a fifth embodiment, N1 equals thirty, N2 equals thirteen, and N3 equals five. Embodiments of multi-color spaceplate 400 may qualify as more than one of the above-mentioned first through fifth embodiments.
Along direction D1, optical cavities 412, 422, and 432 have respective lengths 418, 428, and 438, each of which is an example of length 308 of optical cavity 300. Also along direction D1, component spaceplate 410, component spaceplate 420, and component spaceplate 430 have respective lengths 419, 429, and 439, herein also denoted as L1, L2, and L3. Lengths 419, 429, and 439 are equal to, respectively: N1 times length 418, N2 times length 428, and N3 times length 438.
As respective examples of component spaceplates 210, 220, and 230, component spaceplates 410, 420, and 430 have are characterized by compression ratios Cij or compression tensor C, equation (1). Component spaceplates 410, 420, and 430 have respective focal-point shifts F1, F2, and F3 defined by equations (2.1), (2.2), and (2.3).
In embodiments, integers N1 and N2 minimize a differences between focal-point shifts F1 and F2. When multi-color spaceplate 400 includes component spaceplate 430, integers N1, N2, and N3 may minimize differences between focal-point shifts F1, F2, and F3.
In the following sections, we first present a strategy to design monochromatic spaceplates with high transmission amplitudes and high compression factors at any visible wavelength. These monochromatic spaceplates are the building blocks of the disclosed multi-color spaceplates. Next, we demonstrate that such monochromatic spaceplates with tailored transmission responses may be coupled in a dispersion-engineered manner to create multi-color spaceplates that achromatically compress free-space at three visible wavelengths while maintaining high performance. Trivial combinations/cascades of monochromatic spaceplates would instead lead to drastic aberrations. The presented theoretical and computational results confirm the high performance of the disclosed spaceplates over the visible spectrum, in terms of transmission efficiency, usable angular range, and compression ratio. These findings may lead to the experimental demonstration of strong space-compression effects for visible light, a goal that has so far remained elusive.
A nonlocal structure can perform space compression by implementing an angle-dependent transmission phase that matches the phase shift acquired by light propagating in free-space over a distance that exceeds the spaceplate's physical thickness. Existing spaceplate designs in the literature have been mainly based on photonic crystal slabs or multilayered thin films made of transparent materials with relatively high refractive indices, such as Si, which are common for infrared operation, but become highly lossy and dispersive in the visible range. Among the dielectric materials with a transparency window in the visible spectrum, amorphous TiO2 (refractive-index nTiO
As indicated by Eq. (3), the space compression effect of an FP structure is mainly determined by the reflectance of mirrors, with a higher reflectance offering a higher space compression ratio. We also note that the angular range and bandwidth over which this structure actually works as a spaceplate, approximating the response of free-space, inversely scale with the compression ratio and may be very narrow for a single resonator18. Such fundamental tradeoff may be relaxed by increasing the number of resonances. Based on these ideas, realizing a spaceplate in the visible spectrum requires the use of high-reflectance mirrors made of relatively low-index materials, with virtually zero loss, and the suitable combination and coupling of multiple resonances.
Here, we propose a design where the reflective mirrors of a planar FP cavity are implemented as dielectric distributed Bragg reflectors (DBRs) composed of TiO2 and SiO2 layers. The constructive interference of reflected light from multiple layers of a DBR creates high overall reflectance within a wavelength range known as stop band. For normal incidence of light at a wavelength λ, the highest reflectance occurs when each layer of the DBR is a quarter-wavelength thick, λ/4n, where n is to the refractive index of the layer. The number of layers in the DBR determines its reflectance and, consequently, the compression ratio of the FP cavity. Increasing the number of layers results in higher compression ratios, but reduces the usable bandwidth and angular range.
To demonstrate the performance of the disclosed structure for monochromatic space compression over the visible spectrum, we designed three spaceplates operating near the FP-like resonances at wavelengths: λr=405 nm (violet), 535 nm (green), and 700 nm (red). The DBRs implemented in each FP cavity are composed of seven alternating layers of quarter-wavelength thick TiO2 and SiO2, and ten FP cavities are coupled to form a spaceplate at each wavelength.
To achieve space compression over the widest possible angular range, the operating wavelength (λ0) of spaceplates 600(1-3) is chosen to be slightly off-resonance at normal incidence (at the edge of the bright line), where transmission amplitude is still high and the phase shift has an approximately quadratic response vs. incident angle, matching that of free-space.
Spaceplate 600(1), when operating at λ0=404.4 nm, replaces a free-space length of ˜88.97 μm with a thickness of ˜9.32 μm, corresponding to a compression ratio of 9.5 over NA=0.16. Spaceplate 600(2), when operating at λ0=533.6 nm, replaces a free-space length of ˜72.04 μm with a thickness of ˜12.73 μm, corresponding to a compression ratio of 5.6 over NA=0.20. Spaceplate 600(3), when operating at λ0=697.6 nm, replaces a free-space length of ˜80.22 μm with a thickness of ˜16.87 μm, corresponding to a compression ratio of 4.8 over NA=0.22.
Each of optical beams 1040, 1050, and 1060 is a TE polarized Gaussian beam (NA=0.14) propagating in vacuum and has respective free-space wavelengths λ0=404.4 nm, λ0=533.6 nm, and λ0=697.6 nm. Each of spaceplates 1010, 1020, and 1030 includes three coupled FP cavities with seven TiO2/SiO2 layer pairs in their DBRs and have respective thicknesses of approximately 2.79 μm, 3.81 μm, and 5.05 μm.
Plots 1000a-1000c denotes a free-space focal planes 1009a-1000c and 1005a-1005c, which are separated by respective space compressions 1004a-1004c, each of which are examples of space compression 104 introduced in
As shown in
The fractional bandwidth of spaceplates 600, 1010, 1010, 1020, and 1030 is on the order of 1%. Such a limited bandwidth would be a major barrier to the miniaturization of many optical devices in the visible wavelength range, such as color imaging systems. While strong compression of free-space over the full visible spectrum appears to be fundamentally difficult as discussed above, a multi-color spaceplate operating at three (or more) distinct color channels over the visible spectrum, and not over a continuous bandwidth, is a promising alternative solution to miniaturize color imaging systems without incurring in the fundamental bandwidth tradeoffs. However, as further discussed in the following, it is highly non-trivial to design a single spaceplate with achromatic performance, in terms of transmission efficiency, compression ratio, and angular range, at different wavelengths.
Embodiments of multi-color spaceplates disclosed here are based on a combination of monochromatic spaceplates, where each monochromatic element is designed to perform space compression near one specified wavelength and function as a high-transmission filter at other wavelengths. Based on this concept, we developed a multi-color spaceplate operating near λr=405, 535, and 700 nm.
Crucial for the performance of a multi-color spaceplate, monochromatic spaceplate 1210 transmits light with high efficiencies at the two other wavelengths, λ=535 and 700 nm (
To do that, we define a compression tensor C, whose elements Ci,j correspond to the compression ratios of the monochromatic spaceplate resonating at λr=j nm when light with λ=i nm wavelength passes through it. For the monochromatic spaceplates described above, the compression tensor is:
While each monochromatic spaceplate 1210-1230 performs space compression near its resonance wavelength (Ci,j>1, for i=J), refraction of light in a high-transmission filter introduces a counter space-compression effect (Ci,j<1, for i≠j). This is attributed to the refractive indices of the layers being higher than the refractive index of free-space, nTio
Embodiments of multi-color spaceplate 200, such as multi-color spaceplate 1200, achromatically compresses free-space at three wavelengths. For example, multi-color spaceplate 200 may be designed using a dispersion-engineered composition of monochromatic spaceplates that achieve the same compression factor at each wavelength, taking into account the “space expansion” effect of the other cascaded spaceplates:
In Eq. (4), Lj is the thickness of the monochromatic spaceplate resonating at λr=j nm. The overall achromatic compression ratio of the multi-color spaceplate is then simply given by any of the sums in Eq. (4) divided by the total length. The achromatic condition specified by Eq. (4) may be met by adjusting the Lj factors through the number of FP cavities (Nj) implemented in each monochromatic spaceplate. For the case considered here, we found that the combination of N405=6, N535=5, N700=5 elements nearly satisfies the condition for multi-color spaceplate 1200 to have an achromatic response at the selected wavelengths.
The layout of multi-color spaceplate 1200 is schematically illustrated in
Due to the modularity of the disclosed multi-color spaceplate designs, a longer length of free-space may be replaced (with the same compression ratio) by simply increasing the number of FP cavities in component spaceplates 210, 220, and 230. However, in embodiments, to preserve its achromatic response, as the number of FP cavities increases the composition ratio of N405=6: N535=5: N700=5 is maintained when the same component waveplates are used. As an example,
In embodiments or multi-color spaceplate 1200, its thickness is ˜22.47 μm and the spaceplate replaces a free-space length of ˜66.7 μm at λ=404.5 nm, ˜65.7 μm at λ=534.3 nm, and ˜67.1 μm at λ=698.8 nm, corresponding to almost identical compression ratios of C ˜3.0, 2.9, and 3.0, respectively. These results highlight the achromatic performance of multi-color spaceplate 1200 at these three wavelengths.
In embodiments, the overall achromatic compression factor of a multi-color spaceplate 200 is lower than that of its component monochromatic spaceplates 210, 220, and 230 operating individually at each wavelength. This is due to the counter space-compression effect introduced by the refraction of light in the rest of the structure, as discussed above. A stronger overall compression effect, however, may be realized by using monochromatic spaceplates with higher individual compression ratios at their resonance wavelengths, while redesigning the stack of layers to maintain achromaticity and high transmission.
Monochromatic spaceplate 1910 includes thirty FP cavities 1912 each having seven TiO2/SiO2 layer pairs in its DBRs, designed at a resonance wavelength λr=400 nm, at which monochromatic spaceplate 1910 has a compression ratio C=9.6. Monochromatic spaceplate 1920 includes thirteen FP cavities 1922 each having nine TiO2/SiO2 layer pairs in its DBRs, designed at a resonance wavelength λr=533 nm, at which monochromatic spaceplate 1920 has a compression ratio C=12.3. Monochromatic spaceplate 1930 includes five FP cavities 1932 each having eleven TiO2/SiO2 layer pairs in its DBRs, designed at a resonance wavelength λr=700 nm, at which monochromatic spaceplate 1910 has a compression ratio C=19.9. FP cavities 1912, 1922, 1932 are respective examples of optical cavities 412, 422, and 432.
The transmission responses presented in
A spaceplate has the same optical function as the free-space but with a shorter thickness. The light transmitting through a spaceplate of thickness L effectively experiences a propagation length of Leff>L in free-space, and C=Leff/L determines the compression ratio of the spaceplate.
Based on the Fourier optics analysis, during the propagation between two points separated by Leff along the z-axis, each plane-wave component of the optical field acquires an angle-dependent phase in free-space:
where k0, λ, kt, and θ are the wavenumber in free-space, the wavelength of light in free-space, the transverse wavenumber, and the angle of incidence relative to the z-axis, respectively. The right hand side of Eq. (5) is the Taylor series expansion of phase for small incident angles. This angle-dependent phase response on Fourier components of the field is known as a “nonlocal” response. In this regard, a nonlocal metasurface with a thinner structure L<Leff and a transmission phase matching the angle-dependent phase response of free-space realizes the space compression.
The Fabry-Pérot (FP) cavity is a simple planar structure transmitting light at selected wavelengths with a nonlocal phase shift. The complex transmission coefficient of the FP cavity made of two similar semi-transparent mirrors with reflectance R, spaced by a distance L is1
where nc and θc correspond to refractive index of medium and angle of incident inside the cavity, respectively. The complex transmission coefficient can be written as t=|t|e−iφ where the phase shift of the transmitted field is:
Near the transmission peak at resonance, where δ=7, the Taylor series expansion of the phase is:
where higher-order terms are neglected. Substituting δ from Eq. (6) into Eq. (8), the transmission phase is:
For small incident angles, the transmission phase is approximately:
According to Eq. (10), the transmission phase of the FP cavity near the resonance has the same nonlocal kt-dependence as the free-space propagation in Eq. (5). Comparing the coefficients of kt-dependent terms in Eq. (5) and Eq. (10) indicates phase response of propagation over a distance of Leff may be realized through an FP cavity with a thickness of L. Therefore, the compression ratio of the FP cavity is:
Thus, the compression factor of the FP structure is mainly determined by the reflectance of mirrors and the refractive index of the medium between mirrors.
In an FP cavity, the quadratic term in Eq. (10) that approximates the response of a free-space volume is bounded in the range
Thus, a quantitative trade-off between the compression factor and the maximum NA over which an FP cavity performs space compression is:
As Eq. (11) and Eq. (12) indicate, FP cavities composed of mirrors with higher reflectance have a narrower angular window of space compression. According to Eq. (12) the distance between the two mirrors (L) also determines the angular range of space compression. An FP cavity with a larger space between the two mirrors has a smaller maximum NA to perform space compression.
The transverse-invariant structure of FP cavities leads to polarization-insensitive spaceplates.
Increasing the number of layers in distributed Bragg reflectors (DBRs) implemented in FP cavities leads to higher compression ratios. As an illustration, λr=700 nm, we increased the number of DBR layers in monochromatic spaceplate 600 from seven to nine layers.
Monochromatic spaceplates with significantly higher compression factors are attainable. As an example, we used fifteen layers of TiO2 and SiO2 in DBRs of the FP cavity resonating at λr=405 nm.
The spaceplate of
The presented strategy for designing monochromatic spaceplates is general and may be applied across various wavelength ranges by selecting suitable materials for that specific range. In the near-infrared range, implementing amorphous Si and SiO2 layers would result in relatively high space compression effects.
In embodiments, spaceplate 2600 has a thickness of ˜24.6 μm. In such embodiments, spaceplate 2600 replaces free-space length of ˜509.4 μm, corresponding to compression ratio of C ˜20.7 over NA=0.13.
For space compression at wavelength λ, the separation space L between the DBRs may be determined by L=mλ/2nc, where nc is the refractive index of the medium filling the cavity and m is a positive integer that specifies orders of resonance in the FP cavity. For designing a multi-color spaceplate with high transmission efficiencies it is advantageous to couple monochromatic spaceplates that are transparent at each of the colors that the space compression is performed. To design the multi-color spaceplates with high transmission efficiencies (e.g., multi-color spaceplate 1200), resonance orders of FP cavities (corresponding to different lengths L) may be used as an additional degree of freedom to control the transmission efficiency of the monochromatic spaceplates over the visible range.
Spaceplates 2900a and 2900b perform space compression in the first and second orders of resonance at λ=700 nm, respectively. Spaceplate 2900a, with 700 nm/2nSiO
Multi-color spaceplate 1200 performs space compression at three wavelengths, achromatically. Embodiments of multi-color spaceplates that cover a longer range of free-space may be realized by increasing the number of the FP cavities in the constituent monochromatic spaceplates. In embodiments, for an achromatic response at three wavelengths, the composition ratio of N405=6: N535=5: N700=5 is maintained as the number of FP cavities increases.
a-c show a Transmission response of TE polarized light incident on multi-color spaceplate 3000.
The transfer-matrix method is a general method to analyze the transmission and reflection response of multilayer structures1,
where matrix M is obtained by multiplying transition matrices Tj,j+1 and propagation matrices Pj in sequence. The transition matrix between layer nj and
where tj,j+1 and ri,j+1 are the Fresnel transmission and reflection coefficients between the two layers, respectively. For layer nj with dj thickness, the propagation matrix is
Once matrix M is obtained, the transmission (t) and reflection (r) coefficients of the multilayer structure are calculated:
Propagating of light in the presence of a spaceplate can be analyzed by using the scalar diffraction theory. For a focusing beam of light with a Gaussian amplitude distribution G(x, y) and phase profile of φ(x, y), the electric field is expressed as:
The angular spectrum of the electric field is calculated through a Fourier transform:
During the propagation through the spaceplate structure, the angular transmission coefficient of the spaceplate t(kx, ky), calculated from transfer-matrix analysis, is applied to the corresponding (kx, ky) components of Fourier coefficient of the electric field f(kx, ky):
The spatial distribution of the electric field at the outer surface of the spaceplate is then obtained through the inverse Fourier transform:
The electric field profile at any plane, which is many wavelengths away from the outer surface of the spaceplate, is calculated based on the Rayleigh-Sommerfeld diffraction formula:
indicating the Eout(u, v) is the superposition of the diverging spherical waves originating from point sources on the outer surface of the spaceplate, where r is the distance between point (u,v) on the projection plane and (x,y) on spaceplate, and θ is the angle between vector r and spaceplate outer surface normal. Finally, the intensity distribution is:
The feasibility of fabricating the disclosed spaceplate structures was investigated by considering an embodiment of monochromatic spaceplate 600 designed at λr=700 nm. This spaceplate includes ten coupled FP cavities, where the DBRs in each FP cavity are composed of seven alternating layers of quarter-wavelength thick TiO2 and SiO2.
These results show space-compression performance close to that of monochromatic spaceplate 600. This level of accuracy (±0.5 nm) in the fabrication of layers can be afforded through the Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) method. However, the low deposition rate of layers in ALD (˜0.02˜0.06 nm/cycle) is the main challenge in realizing spaceplates with a large number of layers.
To address this problem, we note that one of the main features of the spaceplate designs presented in this work is that the structure is scalable to many layers by just cascading FP cavities with identical structures. Based on this notion, a large number of FP cavities with identical structures may be fabricated simultaneously inside the ALD chamber and then bonded together to form a spaceplate composed of many layers.
Feasibility of fabricating the spaceplates designed based on the presented approach was investigated. We found that the performance of spaceplates is significantly compromised through the random fabrication errors in the thickness of layers. This is due to the fact that these errors randomly shift the resonance frequency of the Fabry-Pérot (FP) cavities in the spaceplate which disrupts the desired coupling at resonance for space compression.
One of the main features of the spaceplate design presented in this work is cascading FP cavities with similar structures. Based on this notion, a large number of FP cavities with identical structures may be fabricated simultaneously and then bonded together to form a spaceplate. The main advantage of this approach is that the resonance wavelength of the FP cavities may be measured before bonding, and only those within a certain bandwidth (depending on the spaceplate design) are bonded together to form a high performance spaceplate. In this way, we are able to mitigate the effect of random fabrication errors on performance of the spaceplate.
Depending on the materials used in layers of the spaceplate, deposition methods such as atomic layer deposition (ALD), plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD), electron beam evaporation, and sputtering may be utilized to fabricate FP cavities.
After measuring the resonance wavelength of the FP cavities, those with similar resonance wavelengths are bonded together to yield a spaceplate 3390, which is an example of component spaceplate 410, 420, and 430. Then the carrier substrate is released by removing the sacrificial layer. These bonding and de-bonding steps are repeated to achieve the spaceplate with the desired number of FP cavities. Therefore, spaceplates with a large number of layers may be fabricated through this method.
For deposition processes with low temperatures (<200° C.), such as ALD, a positive tone photoresist such as PMMA may be used as the sacrificial layer. This sacrificial layer is removed by UV exposure. Other UV-release polymers such as BrewerBond705 can also be used as the sacrificial layer for deposition processes with higher temperatures (<400° C.). These photoresists and polymers are transparent in visible and NIR spectrum with a refractive index close to SiO2. A transparent sacrificial layer is crucial for measuring the resonance wavelength of individual FP cavities.
Polymeric bonds are also a low-temperature and low-cost bonding method. Positive tone photoresists such as ZEP520A-2 (60 nm @2000 rpm) or 495 PMMA A2 (65 nm @3000 rpm) might be used as the bonding layer between the FP cavities. Absorption loss of sacrificial layer and materials such as TiO2 and Si within layers of FP cavity protects the bonding resist from exposure during UV release of the sacrificial layer. Other types of thin-film adhesive polymers such as mr-I 9020 XP are also reported for wafer-level bonding.
Higher quality of bonding may be achieved through direct bonding methods (no intermediate layer) such as surface-activated bonding. This bonding method is performed at room temperature and is compatible with the use of positive tone photoresist and other types of polymers in the sacrificial layer.
Fusion bonding is another direct bonding technique performed at high temperatures (˜550° C.) for SiO2: SiO2 bonding of the FP cavities. Regarding the high temperature required for this type of boding, polymeric sacrificial layers cannot be used. We suggest indium tin oxide (ITO) as the sacrificial layer. Thin layers of ITO are deposited on a glass substrate using the sputtering technique. ITO is transparent in the visible spectrum which is crucial for measuring the resonance wavelength of FP cavities before the bonding step. ITO is removed using the etchant TE-100 (Transene, Inc.) at 30˜40° C. temperature with high selectivity to SiO2, TiO2, or Si layers.
For spaceplates composed of Si and SiO2 layers, designed to operate at near-infrared, anodic bonding can also be used for Si:SiO2 bonding of FP cavities. Anodic bonding is usually performed at ˜400° C.. We suggest germanium (Ge) as the sacrificial layer for the fabrication of this type of spaceplates. Thin layers of Ge are deposited on a glass substrate using the sputtering technique which is relatively transparent in near-infrared range. Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) is a well-known etchant for Ge with high selectivity to SiO2 and Si layers.
Features described above, as well as those claimed below, may be combined in various ways without departing from the scope hereof. The following enumerated examples illustrate some possible, non-limiting combinations.
Embodiment 1. A multi-color spaceplate includes a first component spaceplate and a second component spaceplate cascaded with the first component spaceplate. The first component spaceplate has an on-resonance compression ratio C11 at a first resonance wavelength and, at a second resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C21, that is less than the on-resonance compression ratio C11. The second component spaceplate has an on-resonance compression ratio C22 at the second resonance wavelength and, at the first resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C12 that is less than the on-resonance compression ratio C22.
Embodiment 2. The multi-color spaceplate of embodiment 1, each of the on-resonance compression ratios C11 and C22 being greater than two.
Embodiment 3. The multi-color spaceplate of embodiment 1, each of the off-resonance compression ratios C21 and C12 being less than or equal to one.
Embodiment 4. The multi-color spaceplate of any one of embodiments 1˜3, further comprising: a third component spaceplate cascaded with the first component spaceplate and the second component spaceplate, and having (i) an on-resonance compression ratio C33 at a third resonance wavelength, (ii) at the first resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C13 that is less than the on-resonance compression ratio C33, and (iii) at the second resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C23 that is less than the on-resonance compression ratio C33.
Embodiment 5. The multi-color spaceplate of embodiment 4, the on-resonance compression ratio C33 being greater than two.
Embodiment 6. The multi-color spaceplate of either one of embodiments 4 or 5, each of the off-resonance compression ratios C13 and C23 being less than or equal to one.
Embodiment 7. The multi-color spaceplate of any one of embodiments 1-6, the first component spaceplate including N1 cascaded optical cavities each having a resonance at the first resonance wavelength, each optical cavity including a pair of first distributed Bragg reflectors (DBR) separated by a first cavity layer having a thickness equal to m1λ1/2n1, where λ1 is the first resonance wavelength, n1 is the refractive index of the first cavity layer at the first resonance wavelength, and both N1 and m1 are integers; and the second component spaceplate including N2 cascaded optical cavities each having a resonance at the second resonance wavelength, each optical cavity including a pair of second DBRs separated by a second cavity layer having a thickness equal to m2λ2/2n2, where λ2 is the second resonance wavelength, n2 is the refractive index of the second cavity layer at the second resonance wavelength, and both N2 and m2 are integers.
Embodiment 8. The multi-color spaceplate of embodiment 7, further comprising: a third component spaceplate having (i) an on-resonance compression ratio C33 at a third resonance wavelength, (ii) at the first resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C13 that is less than the compression ratio C33, and (iii) at the second resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C23 that is less than the compression ratio C33, and the third component spaceplate including N3 cascaded optical cavities each having a resonance at the third resonance wavelength, each optical cavity including a pair of third DBRs separated by a third cavity layer having a length (e.g. a geometric length) or thickness equal to m3λ3/2n3, where λ3 is the third resonance wavelength, n3 is the refractive index of the third cavity layer at the third resonance wavelength, and both N3 and m3 are integers.
Embodiment 9. The multi-color spaceplate of embodiment 8, one of m1, m2, and m3 equaling one, and the remaining two of m1, m2, and m3 equaling two.
Embodiment 10. The multi-color spaceplate of embodiment 8, m1 equaling 1, and the first resonance wavelength being less than each of the second resonance wavelength and the third resonance wavelength.
Embodiment 11. The multi-color spaceplate of embodiment 8, wherein each of m1, m2, and m3 equals one.
Embodiment 12. The multi-color spaceplate of any one of embodiments 8-11, the first resonance wavelength being between 380 nm and 490 nm, the second resonance wavelength being between 490 nm and 560 nm, and the third resonance wavelength being between 570 nm and 750 nm.
Embodiment 13. The multi-color spaceplate of any one of embodiments 8-11, wherein and N2 equals 5N1/6 and N3 equals N2.
Embodiment 14. The multi-color spaceplate of any one of embodiments 8-11, wherein N1 equals thirty, N2 equals thirteen, and N3 equals five.
Embodiment 15. The multi-color spaceplate of any one of embodiments 7-14, the first and second component spaceplates having respective lengths (e.g. a geometric length or thickness) L1 and L2, and respective focal-point shifts F1 and F2, where F1=L1(C11+C12+C13) and F2=L2(C21+C22+C23), lengths L1 and L2 are determined in part by N1 and N2, respectively, and N1 and N2 are integers that minimize a differences between focal-point shifts F1 and F2.
Embodiment 16. The multi-color spaceplate of any one of embodiments 8˜15, the first, second, and third component spaceplates having respective lengths (e.g. a geometric length or thickness) L1, L2, and L3 and respective focal-point shifts F1, F2, and F3, where F1=L1(C11+C12+C13), F2=L2(C21+C22+C23), and F3=L3(C31+C32+C33), lengths L1, L2, and L3 are determined in part by N1, N2, and N3, respectively, and N1, N2, and N3 are integers that minimize differences between focal-point shifts F1, F2, and F3.
Embodiment 17. The multi-color spaceplate of any one of embodiments 7-16, each of the first DBR and the second DBR including multiple alternating layers of silicon dioxide and titanium dioxide.
Embodiment 18. The multi-color spaceplate of any one of embodiments 1-17, the first component spaceplate including a first plurality of material layers, the off-resonance compression ratio C21 exceeding 1/nmax1, where nmax1 is the maximum refractive index of the first plurality of material layers; and the second component spaceplate including a second plurality of material layers, the off-resonance compression ratio C12 exceeding 1/nmax2, where nmax2 is the maximum refractive index of the second plurality of material layers.
Embodiment 19. The multi-color spaceplate of any one of embodiments 8-18, the first component spaceplate having, at the third resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C31 that is less than the on-resonance compression ratio C11; and the second component spaceplate having, at the third resonance wavelength, an off-resonance compression ratio C32 that is less than the on-resonance compression ratio C22.
Embodiment 20. The multi-color spaceplate of embodiment 19, the first component spaceplate including a first plurality of material layers, each of the off-resonance compression ratios C21 and C31 exceeding 1/nmax1, where nmax1 is the maximum refractive index of the first plurality of material layers; the second component spaceplate including a second plurality of material layers, each of the off-resonance compression ratios C12 and C32 exceeding 1/nmax2, where nmax2 is the maximum refractive index of the second plurality of material layers, and the third component spaceplate including a third plurality of material layers, each of the off-resonance compression ratios C13 and C23 exceeding 1/nmax3, where nmax3 is the maximum refractive index of the third plurality of material layers.
Changes may be made in the above methods and systems without departing from the scope of the present embodiments. It should thus be noted that the matter contained in the above description or shown in the accompanying drawings should be interpreted as illustrative and not in a limiting sense. Herein, and unless otherwise indicated the phrase “in embodiments” is equivalent to the phrase “in certain embodiments,” and does not refer to all embodiments.
Regarding instances of the terms “and/or” and “at least one of,” for example, in the cases of “A and/or B,” “at least one of A and B,” and “at least one of A or B,” such phrasing encompasses the selection of (i) A only, or (ii) B only, or (iii) both A and B. In the cases of “A, B, and/or C,” “at least one of A, B, and C,” and “at least one of A, B, or C,” such phrasing encompasses the selection of (i) A only, or (ii) B only, or (iii) C only, or (iv) A and B only, or (v) A and C only, or (vi) B and C only, or (vii) each of A and B and C. This may be extended for as many items as are listed.
The following claims are intended to cover all generic and specific features described herein, as well as all statements of the scope of the present method and system, which, as a matter of language, might be said to fall therebetween.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 63/542,235, filed on Oct. 3, 2023, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
This invention was made with government support under Grant No. FA9550-22-1-0204 awarded by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research. The government has certain rights in the invention.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63542235 | Oct 2023 | US |