Conventional nuclear batteries, nuclear capacitors, or similar nuclear power generation systems rely upon nuclear fission induced by the collision of two subatomic particles. Generally, a subatomic particle, typically a neutron, is absorbed by the nucleus of a fissile material that fissions into two lighter elements and additional neutrons along with releases of thermal energy and prompt gamma rays. The fissile material in some cases can be a material such as uranium-235. Conventional and prior art systems, however, fail to capture the energy of other particles and prompt gamma ray released during fission. The current disclosure describes methods and systems for the effective absorption or capture of isotope-emitted beta particles and high energy photons to maximize the power output. The methods and systems disclosed herein result in a more efficient means to produce power as effective absorption or capture of these high energy subatomic particles and high energy photons that determine more power density of energy conversion systems.
Prior art energy systems include nuclear batteries described in U.S. Pat. No. 10,269,463, hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety. Methods and systems disclosed herein improve the energy conversion, production, and efficiency of Nuclear Thermionic Avalanche Cell (NTAC) related systems. Prior art energy systems using a NTAC are described in U.S. Pat. No. 10,269,463, the contents of which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety. The novel configuration and design of the NTAC disclosed herein takes advantage of an isotope's multiple internal interactions via a uniquely designed multiple layered structure of the NTAC. The unique design disclosed herein results in an energy conversion and power generation system with extremely high power density output. The systems and methods disclosed herein would only require refueling every three to four decades (depending on the application and activity rate of fission) or perhaps longer. Such functionality could be attractive in applications where the energy-using device is very remote from energy refueling sources or where there are operational benefits associated with minimal refueling. Potential applications include use in drones, high altitude aircraft, public utility-scale electric power generation facilities, electric propulsion for automobiles and airplanes, power for remote and rural communities, nodal power without transmission lines, marine electric-propulsion onboard nautical vessels, spacecraft, and satellites.
The present systems and methods disclosed herein are directed to nuclear thermionic avalanche cell (NTAC) system that may include a radioisotope core that may be configured to emit high energy photons and energetic beta particles and the radioisotope core may be substantially cylindrical-shaped or rod-shaped. In some examples, the avalanche electron emitter layer may surround an outer portion of the radioisotope core and a plurality of NTAC layers may surround the radioisotope core. In other examples, the plurality of NTAC layers may be substantially cylindrical-shaped and the plurality of NTAC layers may further include a collector, an insulator, and an emitter. In still other examples, the emitter layer encapsulating a radioisotope core and the NTAC layer emitter may be positioned across a thermionic vacuum gap to face the collector. In some examples, the collector may be positioned across a thermionic vacuum gap, and the collector, the insulator, and the emitter may be integrated with each other. In still other examples, the collector may be configured on an interior of the insulator and the insulator may be configured on an interior of the emitter. In yet other examples, the plurality of NTAC layers may form a coaxially arranged and multilayered NTAC, and the emitter encapsulating or surrounding a radioisotope core and the NTAC emitter layers may be configured to capture the photons from the radioisotope core, and by the captured photons free up a large number of electrons in an avalanche process from deep and intra-band of atoms. In another example, the large number of avalanche electrons that are emitted from the emitter may pass through the thermionic vacuum gap and arrive at the collector to output a high density avalanche cell current through a photo-ionic or thermionic process of the freed up electrons.
In other examples, the radioisotope core may have a diameter and a height that are dependent on the design of the NTAC system according to power requirement. In another example, the photons may be X-rays, gamma rays, or visible UV light and the radioisotope core may be Cobalt-60, Sodium-22, or Cesium-137. In yet another example, a required number of NTAC layers may be determined by the complete absorption and exhaustion of high energy photons undergoing the electron avalanche process through each of the plurality of NTAC layers.
A certain amount of the photons is absorbed by a single layer of NTAC and the rest of the photons goes to and couples with the next layer of NTAC. Any left-over of photons that pass through prior NTAC layers keep progressing to and interacting with the next NTAC layer for power generation. The photon energy determines the mean-free-path. How far a photon penetrates into a material is explained by the mean-free-path. The mean-free-path is determined by the photon energy and normally atomic number. The higher the photon energy is, the longer the mean-free-path is. And higher the atomic number is, the shorter the mean-free-path is. Therefore, the required number of NTAC layers is determined by the photon energy and the atomic numbers of materials for the emitter, the collector, and the insulator.
In another example, the emitter may comprise a nanostructured surface of a high Z material and the emitter may capture photons from the radioisotope core, and the collectors may be configured to capture avalanche electrons from the emitters and lead avalanche electrons to a power circuit.
In still other examples, the collector may comprise a low or mid Z material. In one example, the emitter may have a thickness from about 1 mm to about 3 mm. In another example, the emitter may have a thickness of at least 1 mm. In yet another example, the photons from x-rays, gamma rays, or visible UV light may be absorbed by the emitters and collectors and may be converted into thermal energy through inelastic collisions and scattering, and/or the avalanche electrons may undergo multiple Coulomb collisions with neighboring electrons generating thermal energy. In still other examples, a thermoelectric generator may be configured to receive the thermal energy and output thermoelectric power.
Another embodiment disclosed herein is a method of capturing high energy photons to generate power that may include receiving high energy photons emitted from a radioisotope core integrated with a nuclear thermionic avalanche cell (NTAC), in which the NTAC may comprise a plurality of NTAC layers configured to receive the photons, and the NTAC layer may include an emitter, a thermionic vacuum gap, and a collector, In some examples, the emitter may be positioned between the radioisotope core and the collector. The method, in other examples, may include outputting the liberated avalanche electrons using the received photons, guiding the avalanche electrons to cross over a vacuum gap to a collector, harnessing a load from the electrons at the collector via a power circuit, and generating an electrical current.
In some examples, the radioisotope core of the method may further include an emitter layer, a thermionic vacuum gap, and a collector layer. In other examples, the high-energy photons may be X-rays, gamma rays, or visible UV light. In some example methods, the radioisotope core may be Cobalt-60, Sodium-22, or Cesium-137. In yet other example methods, the emitter may have a thickness from about 1 mm to about 3 mm, and the radioisotope emitter may have a thickness about 1 mm. In another example, the emitter may have a thickness of at least 3 mm. In still other example methods, the emitter may include a nanostructured surface of a high Z material. In still other example methods, the collector may comprise a low or mid Z material.
Yet another embodiment disclosed herein is an energy conversion system comprising a radioisotope core configured to emit high energy photons, and the radioisotope core may comprise Cobalt-60, Sodium-22, or Cesium-137. In other examples, a nuclear thermionic avalanche cell may comprise a plurality of NTAC layers integrated with the radioisotope core and configured to receive the photons from the radioisotope core and by the received photons free up a large number of electrons in an avalanche process from deep and intra-bands of an atom to output a high density avalanche cell current through a photo-ionic or thermionic process of the freed up electrons, and the avalanche current may be fed through power circuit. In some examples, the plurality of NTAC layers may comprise a nanostructured surface of a high Z material, the plurality of NTAC layers may comprise a combination of a collector in which the collector may be at least 1 mm thick, an insulator that may be at least 3 mm thick, and an emitter that may be at least 3 mm thick. In one particular example, a thermoelectric generator may be configured to receive the thermal energy, and the thermal energy may be radiatively conducted axially and radially, and the thermoelectric generator may output thermoelectric power. In other examples, the thermoelectric generator may surround the plurality of NTAC layers and the radioisotope core.
These and other features, advantages, and objects of the present approach will be further understood and appreciated by those skilled in the art by reference to the following specification, claims, and appended drawings.
The patent or application file contains at least one drawing executed in color. Copies of this patent or patent application publication with color drawings will be provided by the Office upon request and payment of the necessary fee.
It is to be understood that the systems and methods disclosed herein may assume various alternative orientations and step sequences, except where expressly specified to the contrary. It is also to be understood that the specific devices and processes illustrated in the attached drawings, and described in the following specification, are simply exemplary embodiments of the inventive concepts defined in the appended claims. Hence, specific dimensions and other physical characteristics relating to the embodiments disclosed herein are not to be considered as limiting, unless the claims expressly state otherwise.
The systems and methods disclosed herein relate a system, and related methods of generating power, constructed with multilayers of nuclear thermionic avalanche cells (NTAC). The multilayer structure of NTAC systems offers effective recoverable means to capture and harness huge quantities of energy from gamma photons for useful purposes, such as a power source for deep space exploration.
High energy photons have well-defined interactions with the electrons and the nucleus of an atom, such as photoelectric (pe), photonuclear (pn), Compton scattering (Cs), and electron/positron pair production (pp). Large number of electrons in the intra-band of atom can be liberated through bound-to-free transition when coupled with high energy photons. If a power conversion system or process effectively utilizes these liberated electrons in an avalanche form through a power conversion circuit, the power output will be drastically increased. As such, the power density of the system can be multiplied by the rate of high energy photon absorption. Long mean free-paths of high energy photons, however, experience some attenuation of light travelling through the materials by absorption and scattering. Enhancing the coupling effect or absorption of high energy photons requires a thicker material than the mean free-path, or a sufficient number of layer structures of energy conversion devices must be implemented to capture the flux of high energy photons.
NTAC systems (see e.g., U.S. Pat. No. 10,269,463 titled “Nuclear Thermionic Avalanche Cells with Thermoelectric (NTAC-TE) Generator in Tandem Mode”) employ high-energy gamma rays (tens of keV to MeV) to liberate or free a large number of intra-band, inner shell electrons from atoms for power generation through the primary interactions of photoelectric, Compton scattering, photonuclear, and electron/positron pair production processes ad illustrated in
In a collision of a gamma ray of energy E with an electron, the gamma ray energy E′, after scattering through angle θ, is given by:
For very small scattering angles, the gamma ray energy does not change much since the factor (1−cos θ) is approximately zero, and the denominator of the above equation is nearly unity. The above equation for E=500 keV γ-photon yields the electron with 160 keV and photon with 340 keV energies after Compton scattering with a 45° collision angle [4]. Based upon this result, it is observed that the scattered Compton γ-ray carries substantial photon energy, which has similar effects of photoelectric, Compton scattering, photonuclear, and electron/positron pair production processes as the primary γ-photons as depicted in
The removing K-band edge electron of high-Z materials requires less than 140 keV [2]. Photoelectron or Compton electron, therefore, after an interaction with a photon with a higher than K-band edge gains substantial energy due to the difference between photon energy and K-band edge. For example, a γ-ray photon of Cs-137 (662 keV) on rhenium, the photoelectron or Compton electron gains 590 keV by (photon 662 keV−K-band edge 71.676 keV). A study based on the Monte Carlo method shows that the photoelectron carries 300 keV after interacting with γ-photon=600 keV [5]. As shown in
As depicted in
For photons with high photon energy (i.e., several MeV scale and higher), pair production eventually becomes the dominant mode of photon interactions with matter. As shown in
Exothermic nuclear reactions, through decay and fission, generate keV to MeV X-ray and γ-ray photons which are suitable for NTAC applications. A half-life of the decay process can be a tens of years or more. Thus, a single NTAC charge can run for decades without refueling. Further, nuclear waste refinement can provide a stable, ready supply of γ-ray emitting materials. For example, Cs-137 is an abundant component (6%) of nuclear waste, with a 30.23 year half-life and strong emissions at 662 keV; Co-60 is readily produced in a nuclear reactor by bombarding Co-59 with thermal neutrons. Na-22 requires a cyclotron collision process of proton to magnesium or aluminum target to generate Na-22. From the current stockpile of radioactive materials, the supply of gamma ray sources for NTAC devices does not pose any significant issue.
Through the photoelectric (pe) and photonuclear (pn) effects, Compton scattering (Cs), and electron/positron pair production (pp) the absorbed energy is proportional to the absorption cross-section (σt=σC+σpe+σpn+σpp), the atomic number of matter (Z), and the thickness of the materials in the primary interaction. As shown in
As an example, the number of lanthanum (La) atoms per gram is 4.33×1021/g or 2.67×1022/cm3. Assuming that 29 of 57 La electrons are stripped off as avalanche electrons, the energy required to strip off 29 out of La atom would be less than 17.641 keV for L-edge and 38.925 keV for K-edge electrons [2]. Thus, the number of available electrons per cm3 is 7.74×1023/cm3, or 124,042 C/cm3 (≈105 C/cm3 or ≈107 C/kg), 5 orders of magnitude higher in energy density than conventional systems based on free or dopant density-dependent valence band electrons only. As shown and described in
The high energy photon-enhanced thermalized avalanche electron emissions can be estimated by considering the flux of photo-excited, Coulomb collision, and photo-thermalized electrons that have sufficient energy to escape the material surface. The flux of electrons is the collection of electrons freed up and undergone free-to-free transition from the deep level and intra-band photo excitations by a MeV level photon energy. The electron population in the conduction-band is distributed by the quasi-Fermi level in the aftermath of the level transitions from the deep and intra-bands impacted by high energy photon fluxes.
The Fermi energy of number of electrons is expressed [7] by
where EF is the Fermi level, Ei, j is the Fermi level of intra-band under ith excitation mechanism, ni, j is the total freed-up electron concentration in the conduction band from an intra-band at ith excitation mechanism, neq is the equilibrium concentration without photoexcitation, and TC is the cathode temperature. From the above expression, it is obvious that the photoexcitation by gamma ray abundantly multiplies electron concentration at the conduction-band additively from the valence band and intra-bands, ΣΣEi, j. The third term of Eq. (1) represents the thermionic emission of electrons at surface temperature (TC). The fourth term represents the photo-excited energetic electrons at the conduction band. Eq. (1) is also applicable to the primary, secondary, tertiary, etc., interactions for determining the Fermi energy of the number of electrons in emission from the emitter material.
Assuming the freed-up electrons are collected by the collector cathode, the total current density can be expressed by
where EC is the energy at the conduction-band minimum, χ the electron free-to-free transition in average, e the electron charge, vx the electron velocity perpendicular to the material surface, ΣiΣjNi(Ej) the density of states, ΣiΣjfi(Ej) the Fermi distribution, and m* the effective mass. The expression on the right hand side of Eq. (2) assumes that the density of states in the conduction band is parabolic and approximates the Fermi function by the Boltzmann distribution because the work function is much larger than κTC. If the effective mass is isotropic, then under both the thermalization and the photoexcitation processes of electrons above the conduction-band minimum, electrons gain an excessive degree of freedom with kinetic variation, such as Ei, j−EC=m*[v2]i, j/2, where [v2]i, j=[vx2+vy2+vz2]i, j. The integral can then be rewritten in terms of electron velocities:
where vvac=√{square root over (2χ/m*)} is the minimum velocity necessary to emit into vacuum. The excitation and thermalization processes of electrons require substantially more energy than the bandgap energy (EgI . . . EgM) for even deep level transitions, as shown in
Significantly, Eq. (3) above yields a result that is identical to the Richardson-Dushman equation for thermionic current, except that the energy barrier in the exponent is relative to the quasi-Fermi level instead of the equilibrium Fermi level:
where A is the Richardson-Dushman constant, 1202 mA/mm2K2. However, it is not clear whether a single value of the work function can be representative for this complex emission process. Since the second (level transition) and fourth terms (thermalization) are dominant contributors in Eq. (1), it is not obvious how these two terms should be presented in a closed form. The work function for both emission cases due to level transition and thermalization may not be a fixed value, but the density states in level transitions and thermalization may determine the work function. The expression on the right hand side of Eq. (4) explicitly shows that the effect of photo-illumination on semiconductor thermionic emission is to lower the energy barrier by the difference between the quasi-Fermi level with photoexcitation and the Fermi level without photoexcitation. Such an effect exists for deeper Fermi levels as expressed in Eqs. (1) and (4). Rewriting Eq. (4) in terms of the electron density in the conduction band, n, and average velocity perpendicular to the surface, <vx>, leads to
Eq. (5) illustrates the number of electrons excited by the photo-coupling process and secondary, tertiary, etc. means which increases conduction-band electron concentration ΣiΣjni, j over the equilibrium value neq, whereas the thermal energy determines the rate at which electrons emit over the electron free-to-free transition in average, χ. The current density shown in Eq. 5 represents a number of electrons emitted from emitter surface after the primary interaction. This process of estimation can be repeated over the secondary, tertiary, and so forth according to the use of photon energy.
The attenuation of high energy photons through a material usually follows the Beer-Lambert law. The transmittance of photons through a medium is described by
T=e
−σ·ρ·z
where σ is the attenuation cross-section of a medium, ρ the density of a medium, and z the path length of the beam of light through a medium. The transmittance of high energy photons can be lowered as the cross-section of a material is large, or density is high or the path length is long, or by all factors working together. However, the cross section and density are determined by morphological formation of material. The only control parameter for the absorption of high energy photons is the thickness of material.
Specifically for the NTAC applications, the thickness of selected material cannot be increased only to improve the absorption of high energy photons. If the thickness of material is made too thick in order to absorb more high energy photons, the electrons liberated from the intra-band of atoms located deep inside material by high energy photons cannot be readily emitted out of the domain of material due to the loss of energy through multiple scatterings through Coulomb collisions.
The left graph shown in
Preliminary laboratory experiments were conducted for several electron emitter materials using a vacuum UV (VUV, 6˜20 eV deuterium lamp) and a 320 keV X-ray source. The test result for lanthanum with VUV shows that the number of electrons extracted by VUV was 3.12 times more than electrons in the valence band alone. As shown in
Based upon the cross section calculation using the NIST XCOM database [8], the primary interaction of selected samples with γ-rays is estimated. Below, Table I shows how many NTAC layers required for the rhenium- or gold-based NTAC with performance based on the thickness of materials illustrated
Theoretical analyses of an NTAC device can be carried out using MCNP-6 and GEANT-4 codes to set the definition and criteria for optimized NTAC device design parameters by mapping the emission potentials of high Z materials, density state analysis of intra-band electron transitions, and cross section analysis. Experimental analysis is essential to characterize and validate NTAC device design parameters and high-Z materials as emitters and low-Z materials for collector and insulator materials using 300 keV photons. Results can be used to define NTAC layers and to design a prototype NTAC for Cs-137 and Co-60.
The study performed for determining required NTAC layers with only primary interactions shows how many layers of NTAC are necessary to use the incident γ-ray without allowing any leaks (see Table II). The thicknesses of emitter, collector, and insulator used for the estimation of a number of layers required, without allowing the leak of γ-rays, are shown in
The design study of all power scale NTAC devices can be made with the results obtained from theoretical and experimental analyses as disclosed herein. Along with selected γ-radiation sources, NTAC design definitions and rules are established and implemented for the design of small-to-large scale NTAC systems. Design and performance analyses of a prototype NTAC device (1-kWe level) can be made within a year to set for fabrication ready. Relatively low photon energy sources (<1 MeV) require fewer NTAC layers with high Z material for emitters like that shown in
As shown in
As also shown in
Specific elements of any of the foregoing embodiments or examples can be combined or substituted for elements in other embodiments or examples. Furthermore, while advantages associated with certain embodiments and examples of the disclosure have been described in the context of these embodiments, other embodiments and examples may also exhibit such advantages, and not all embodiments need necessarily exhibit such advantages to fall within the scope of the disclosure.
[1] U.S. Pat. No. 10,269,463.
[2] McMaster, W. H., Kerr Del Grande, N., Mallett, J. H., and Hubbell, J. H., “Compilation of X-ray Cross Sections”, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory Report UCRL-50174 Section II Rev. I, 1969.
[3] Oakley, W. S, “Resolving the Electron-Positron Mass Annihilation Mystery”, Int J of Sci Rep. Vol. 1, No. 6, pp. 250-252, 2015.
[4] “Energies of a photon at 500 keV and an electron after Compton scattering”, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compton_scattering
[5] Johns, H. E., Till, J. E., and Cormack, D. V., “Electron Energy Distributions Produced by Gamma-Rays”, Table 2a, Nucleonics, Vol. 12, No. 10, pp. 40-46, October, 1954.
[6] McMullan G, Faruqi A R, Henderson R, Guerrini N, Turchetta R, Jacobs A, van Hoften G, “Experimental observation of the improvement in MTF from backthinning a CMOS direct electron detector”, Ultramicroscopy, 109 (9-3), pp. 1144-1147, August 2009.
[7] Sze, S. M. and Ng, K. K., Physics of Semiconductor Devices, 3rd Ed., Wiley Interscience, ISBN-13: 978-0-471-14323-9, p. 154, 2007.
[8] Berger, M. J., Hubbell, J. H., Seltzer, S. M., Chang, J., Coursey, J. S., Sukumar, R., Zucker, D. S., and Olsen, K., “XCOM: Photon Cross Sections Database”, NIST Standard Reference Database 8 (XGAM), 1998.
This patent application claims the benefit of and priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 62/850,624, filed on May 21, 2019, the contents of which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety.
The invention described herein was made by employees of the United States Government and may be manufactured and used by or for the Government of the United States of America for governmental purposes without the payment of any royalties thereon or therefore.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62850624 | May 2019 | US |