1. Technical Field of Invention
The present invention relates, generally, to power regulation systems and, in particular, to providing precisely regulated power to a microelectronic device such as a microprocessor. Improved power regulation is accomplished with an Active Transient Response Circuit that detects multiple threshold levels and provides multiple levels of gain.
2. Background of the Invention
Regulated power supplies or voltage regulators are typically required to provide the voltage and current supply to microelectronic devices. The regulator is designed to deliver power from a primary source to an electrical load at the specified current, voltage, and power efficiency. Switching power converters (SPC) also referred to as Buck regulators are commonly used voltage regulators due to their high efficiency, high current capability, and topology flexibility. In addition, they can be designed to provide very precise voltage and current characteristics required by devices such as microprocessors, microcontrollers, memory devices, and the like.
Power requirements for emerging leading edge technology microprocessors have become very difficult to satisfy. As the speed and integration of microprocessors increases, the demands on the power regulation system increase. In particular, as gate counts increase, the power regulation current demand increases, the operating voltage decreases and transient events (e.g. relatively large voltage spikes or droops at the load) typically increase in both magnitude and frequency. Some emerging microprocessors are expected to run on less than 1.3 volts and more than 100 amperes.
SPC's utilizing step-down multi-phase Buck converters have been the preferred topology to meet the low voltage and high current requirements of microprocessors. With the advent of increasingly complex power regulation topologies, digital techniques for power converter control, specifically in multiphase designs, can improve precision and reduce the system's total parts count while also supporting multiple applications in the same power system through digitally programmable feedback control.
Existing feedback controls have taken voltage measurements from the load, as well as from the individual output phases. The feedback information has been used to adjust the duty cycle, i.e. width of the pulses produced by each of the phases of a multi-phase buck regulator system to bring the supplied voltage and current within the load line tolerances specified by the microprocessor manufacturer. Such a multi-phase pulse width modulated (PWM) voltage regulator system has been disclosed in the patent applications cross-referenced hereinabove and the details of those disclosures are incorporated herein by reference. In particular, the co-pending patent application entitled: DIGITAL CALIBRATION WITH LOSSLESS SENSING IN A MULTIPHASE SWITCHED POWER CONVERTER, Ser. No. 10/884,840, filed Jul. 2, 2004, inventors: Southwell et al, of which an inventor of this application is a co-inventor, teaches a novel lossless technique for sensing current at the load that is provided in a feedback loop to bring the supplied voltage and current within the specified load line tolerances.
Active Transient Response (ATR) has been used for high frequency response to rapidly changing power requirements at the load by quickly activating multiple phases to supply or drain (as the case required) more current to or from the load, thereby temporarily over riding the generally slower overall voltage regulator system response. Such power regulation systems utilizing ATR have been disclosed in detail in the patent applications cross-referenced hereinabove and the details of those disclosures are incorporated herein by reference. In particular, the co-pending patent application entitled: SYSTEM, DEVICE AND METHOD FOR PROVIDING VOLTAGE REGULATION TO A MICROELECTRONIC DEVICE, Ser. No. 10/103,980, filed Mar. 22, 2002, inventors: Duffy et al, of which an inventor of this application is a co-inventor, discloses a power regulation system having an active transient response (ATR) circuit.
The use of ATR enables voltage regulator systems to be designed with lower overall output capacitance while maintaining equivalent dynamic performance. An ATR circuit includes a window comparator that compares the output supply voltage at the load to the reference voltage, as determined by the specified load line. As long as the output voltage remains within a specified tolerance range (i.e. window) above or below the specified load line, the ATR circuit provides no input signal to the PWM, which proceeds to provide power to the load in a conventional manner. On the other hand, as soon as the voltage is outside the “window”, the ATR circuit signals the PWM to modify its operation. For example, if the voltage drops below the specified voltage range, all low side power switches in the multi-phase system are turned off and then, after a short delay, all high side power switches are turned on, causing the normally staggered inductor charging to occur in parallel.
Thus, when the voltage at the load increases above a specified voltage, the window comparator signals an ATRL (Active Transient Response Low) event. Such an ATRL event requires a rapid lowering of the voltage at the load. This is accomplished by turning on additional low side FETs and blocking the high side from providing the normal synchronous phase pulses. This effectively is a compensation operation that reduces the output voltage. Conversely, when the voltage at the load decreases above a specified voltage, the window comparator signals an ATRH (Active Transient Response High) event. Such an ATRH event causes the high side FETs to increase their duty cycle. This effectively is a compensation operation that increases the output voltage back to within the specified window. This technique of compensating for transients causing over voltage and under voltage conditions is enhanced by adjusting the window comparator to a specified load line. By using AVP (Adaptive Voltage Positioning) as a reference “target voltage”, correction of under voltage and over voltage excursions is improved.
However, as the power regulation needs of load devices such as microprocessors and the like become even more demanding, even more precise ATR techniques than those disclosed in the aforementioned Duffy et al application, are desired. In particular, it is desired to more precisely detect and compensate the magnitude of the voltage excursion from the target voltage.
Accordingly, the present application describes ATR techniques for more accurately detecting voltage excursions from the specified load line (i.e. the target voltage). In particular, the present invention discloses a multi-level sensing technique that detects not only the fact that the voltage excursion requires an active transient response but also detects the amplitude of the excursion. In accordance with the invention, it has been found highly desirable to sense multiple thresholds, particularly multiple ATRH thresholds.
In particular, the invention provides multiple threshold based detection of under voltage that determines how many high-side phases need to be activated to maximize output current slew rate. For example, if the transient is slight, only one phase will respond. If the transient is severe, up to three additional phases (e.g. in the case of a system with four or more phases) can respond. Thus, a plurality of asynchronous pulses is provided on one or more of those phases asynchronously. As previously noted, by the presently disclosed method, the number of thresholds exceeded by the voltage excursion is detected. In short, the number of correction pulses provided is a function of the number of voltage thresholds that are exceeded. In this way, the multi-threshold sensing scheme allows variable gain to be applied by the ATR circuit by varying the number of ATR pulses that are generated so that the correction to the ATR event is in proportion to the magnitude of the sudden voltage excursion, i.e. transient.
In accordance with the invention, the multi-threshold sensing technique can be programmed to detect the amplitude of the excursion within desired parameters. The detected excursion is then used to provide an adjustment to the supply voltage that is more precise than would be possible with a less precisely detected excursion. The capability for such rapid enhanced response to transients allows a reduction in the bulk of output capacitors used in Buck regulators.
In accordance with the invention, an Adaptive Voltage Positioning (AVP) circuit determines the voltage/current requirements to track the specified load line, which in combination with the multi-threshold multi-gain ATR provides voltage regulator with enhanced performance. In this case, the target voltage is a variable voltage in accordance with the specified load line. Accordingly, the target voltage used as a reference for correcting for under voltage and over voltage conditions, combined with the multilevel sensing and multi-gain correction provide an improved response to transient excursions.
By way of further example, in case of an over voltage condition, the ATR circuit can activate additional low-side phases, in addition to blocking high-side pulses to maximize output current slew rate. As will become more apparent in the following more detailed description, the ATR circuit of this invention is asynchronous relative to the synchronous PWM pulse generation. However, as a further feature, the invention provides a method of selecting phases when the correction pulses are applied in accordance with a predetermined scheduled timing relative to the synchronous pulse width modulated pulses.
In accordance with another aspect of the invention, the AVP circuit includes a variable low pass filter that is adjusted in response to an ATR event. This resolves a conflict in the choice of AVP bandwidth. A low AVP bandwidth is desired to filter out current sense noise so that the AVP computation does not add a lot of noise to the output voltage. On the other hand, a high AVP bandwidth is desired for passing transients so that the transient response looks as close to an ideal voltage step as possible. By opening up the AVP bandwidth, the amount of overshoot associated with an ATRH event is reduced.
In accordance with a still further aspect of the invention, the AVP circuit is configured to receive pre-determined current values representing different threshold levels of an ATR event. A pre-positioning circuit receives these pre-determined current values from memory and provides them as an output when receiving a signal indicative of an ATRH event. The particular current value provided at the output depends on the degree of the ATRH event, i.e. ATRH1, ATRH2, or ATRH3. These pre-determined current values are added to the compensation voltage applied to the load at a time prior to the detection of current transients. The detection of transient current values at the load is delayed because the current must pass through an inductor.
These and other features of the invention will become more apparent in the following more detailed description and claims when considered in connection with the drawings where like reference numerals refer to similar elements throughout the Figures.
The present invention may be described herein in terms of various functional components and various processing steps. It should be appreciated that such functional components may be realized by any number of hardware or structural components configured to perform the specified functions. For example, the present invention may employ various integrated components comprised of various electrical devices, e.g. resistors, transistors, capacitors, inductors and the like, whose values may be suitably configured for various intended purposes. Any actual values provided for such components as well as applied voltage levels and currents are intended by way of example and not limitation.
In addition, the present invention may be practiced in any integrated circuit application. Such general applications and other details that will be apparent to those skilled in the art in light of the present disclosure are not described in detail herein. Further, it should be noted that while various components may be suitably coupled or connected to other components within exemplary circuits, such connections and couplings can be realized by direct connection between components, or by connection through other components and devices located therebetween.
Refer now to
Digital controller 10 receives a VID input at voltage control 12. VID is a digital number provided by the microprocessor manufacturer describing specific power requirements, in particular the set point, i.e. initial load line voltage at minimum current. Digital controller 10 can also have a reference voltage 14 that is applied to analog-to-digital converter 16 that also receives, as a second input, the voltage at load 80. The reference voltage from block 14 is used to calibrate the output of analog-to-digital converter ADC 16 to that reference voltage. The output of ADC 16 is a digital voltage value that is compared to the output of voltage control circuit 12 (the target voltage) in summer 17 and provided as a digital error voltage to digital compensator 18. Digital compensators such as digital compensator 18 that provide inputs to multi-phase pulse width modulators such as PWM 20 are well known and described for example in the above cross-referenced patent application, SYSTEM, DEVICE AND METHOD FOR PROVIDING VOLTAGE REGULATION TO A MICROELECTRONIC DEVICE, Ser. No. 10/103,980, filed Mar. 22, 2002, inventors: Duffy et al., of which an inventor in this application is a co-inventor. Digital compensator 18 then provides an input to PWM 20 in order to modify the width of the pulses provided to the drivers 30 and 30′, etc. of each of the two phases in the illustrated example, and other phases, when utilized. Phase 1 is driven by driver circuits 32 and 34. Circuit 32 drives the gate of FET 40 with a signal that is complementary to the output of circuit 34 that drives the gate of FET 50. FETs 40 and 50 have their drain-source paths connected in series, at a common point A, between a first potential source (+V) and a second potential source (ground). Since both FETs 40 and 50 are shown as N-channel devices, only one of the two transistors is on at any one time. Of course, if transistor 40 were to be replaced with a P-type transistor, then the same phase signal could be used to drive the gate of both transistors 40 and 50. In either case, there is never a direct current path between +V and ground.
The phase 2 output of PWM 20 is provided to circuits 36 and 38 during phase 2 time in the same way that circuits 32 and 34 receive the pulse width modulate signals during phase 1 time. Circuit 36 then drives the gate of FET 42 and circuit 38 drives the gate of FET 52. Note that although two phases are shown, any number of phases can be used. Larger number of phases provides smoother and more accurate power to the load.
In operation, during phase 1, while the pulse width modulated waveform turns high side FET 40 on, current flows through FET 40 into node A and through inductor 60 to charge capacitor 70 and provide power to load 80. On the other hand, when low side FET 50 is turned on, current flows through FET 50. High side FET 42 and low side FET 52, connected in common at node B operate in a similar manner during phase 2. The voltage from the load 80 is fed back to ADC 16 so that the voltage to the load can be adjusted to changing load conditions. It is desirable to also measure the voltage at node A and node B (and other corresponding nodes in systems with more phases) as an indication of the current being supplied to the load. The cross-referenced patent applications show how the measurements taken at nodes A and B are then used to better regulate the power provided to load 80. Although such a system operates satisfactorily, it has been found that for more rapid response to high speed variations in the power requirements of load 80, a second voltage adjustment technique is desired. In particular, when the voltage excursion from the load line exceeds a predetermined specified amount, then a secondary power adjustment is provided by active transient response (ATR) circuitry.
Refer now to
In the
ATR circuit 100 is coupled between the output stage, at load 80 and multi-phase PWM20 and is configured to detect the voltage level at the load. In case the transient voltage at the load deviates from the target voltage by one or more of the pre-set thresholds, ATR100 provides a signal to PWM20 that is a function of the amplitude of the deviation of the detected voltage from the target voltage. The ATR100 output will be one of: ATRL, ATRH1, ATRH2, or ATRH3.
ATR100 is also coupled between the output stage, at load 80, and AVP12 to provide one of the signals indicative of an ATR event, i.e. one of ATR signals (ATRL, ATRH1, ATRH2, or ATRH3) to AVP12. This enables AVP12 to provide an early, predictive change to summer 17. This predictive change can occur prior to the time that the sensed current change is received from ADC13 because the sensed load current change is delayed passing through inductors 60, 62, and other similar inductors in additional phases.
As long as the voltage at the load is maintained within predetermined limits, ATR circuit 100 is not activated and no output signals are provided by ATR circuit 100. However, when the changes in power demands by the load result in a voltage excursion at the load that exceeds the predetermined limits ATR circuit 100 provides ATRL, ATRH1, ATRH2, or ATRH3 signals to PWM generator 20 to correct the voltage deviation rapidly and with minimal noise generation. As shown in
Refer now to
Refer now to
In particular, for normal signals, it is desired that a digital filter, such as 208′, have a narrow bandwidth with filter coefficients set at FC1, for example to filter out ripple noise so that the AVP computation doesn't add a lot of noise to the output voltage. However, for high frequency transient signals a wide bandwidth filter with filter coefficients set at FC2, for example, is desired so that transient response looks as close to an ideal voltage step as possible. These coefficients are set by 2:1 multiplex circuit 212, as will now be described.
Circuit 212 receives a (FILTER_WIDE_BW) input when there is either an ATRL or an ATRH event. The second input (FILTER_NARROW_BW) is active when there is no ATR event. OR circuit 214 is also provided to provide an input to circuit 212 when either an ATRL1 or an ATRH1 event occurs. Circuit 212 will pass the FILTER_WIDE_BW signal when S=1, i.e. either ATRL1 or ATRH1 is up. Conversely circuit 212 will pass FILTER_NARROW_BW when S=0. Depending on which of these signals is inputted to digital filter 208′, it will operate with coefficient FC1 or FC2.
Pre-positioning circuit 216 receives pre-stored inputs (from memory not shown) representing current values corresponding to ATRH thresholds exceeded. For example, CUR_INJECT_ATRH1 could be preset at 25 amps. Then, CUR_INJECT_ATRH2 could be preset at 50 amps. CUR_INJECT_ATRH3 could be preset at 75 amps and so on for the N thresholds. Logic circuit 218 receives the inputs ATRH1, ATRH2 and ATRH3 from ATR circuit 100. Note that ATR circuit 100 receives a voltage sense input directly from the load 80. This voltage transient signal is received much more quickly than the current sense signal transient which must pass through an inductor, e.g. 60, 62, etc. In response to a voltage transient, ATR circuit 100 inputs to logic circuit 218, the ATRH threshold (if any) that has been triggered. In response, circuit 216 provides the pre-programmed values of CUR_INJECT to summing circuit 205. For example, the respective pre-programmed values of CUR_INJECT can be: 0 amps (no ATR), 25 amps (ATRH1 event), 50 amps (ATRH2 event), or 75 amps (ATRH3 event). In turn, summer 205 provides the sum of the currents ISUM+CUR_INJECT to multiplier 206. The output of circuit 206 is a voltage DELTA_AVP that is the product of RLOADLINE (the slope of the load line) and the current. It is the function of AVP low pass filter 208′ to filter this voltage. Filter 208′ receives a signal from circuit 212 and depending on that signal acts as a low pass filter either with coefficient FC1 or FC2 to provide the filtered output to summer 210. Summer 210 combined the VID_SET_POINT value with the filtered voltage value as the output of the AVP 12 circuit.
Refer now to
The ATRH comparator circuits 314, 316, and 318 are configured in the same way and operate in a manner similar to comparator circuit 310. Threshold setting circuit 304 sets the threshold voltage level ATRH1 for comparator 314. When the Vsense voltage deviates (in a negative direction in case of an ATRH event) to a greater value than the threshold voltage provided by block 304, comparator 314 provides a high level logic signal indicating an ATRH1 event. If the Vsense voltage deviates to a greater value than the threshold value provided by block 306, comparator 316 provides a signal indicating an ATRH2 event. If the Vsense voltage deviates to a greater value than the threshold value provided by block 308, comparator 318 provides a signal indicating an ATRH3 event.
Refer now to
The inputs Thresh_ATRL and Thresh_ATRH are programmable parameters stored in memory, which set the current DAC outputs. These programmable parameters are digital values permitting adjustment of ATRH1, ATRH2, and ATRH3 by simply modifying the value of the Thresh_ATRH input to current DAC 408. Similarly the ATRL threshold is programmable by simply adjusting the value of the Thresh_ATRL input to current DAC 406. Differential current outputs are used so that the current through FETs 402 and 404 are fixed independent of setting (i.e. the sum of the true and complement currents are a fixed value.)
In operation, the voltage at the common connection of R3 and R4 is applied as a first input to ATRL compare circuit 410. This voltage value is determined by: 1. the amplitude of the target voltage applied to the gate of FFT404, 2. the amplitude of the current supplied by DAC406 and 3. the value of the resistors in the voltage divider formed by R1, R2, R3, and R4. The voltage at the common connection of R8 and FET402 is applied to the second input to ATRL compare circuit 410. The voltage at this second input is determined by the amplitude of the sensed voltage applied at the gate of FET402. If the second input exceeds the first input, compare circuit 410 will signal an ATRL event (ATRL1) resulting in the blocking of high side FETs and turning on low side FETs.
Comparator circuits 412, 414, and 416 are configured and operate in a manner similar to just described circuit 410. Each of them receives a first input that is a function of the target voltage applied to the gate of FET404. Each of them receives a second input that is a function of the sensed voltage provided to the gate of FET402, the threshold setting current provided by current DAC 408 and the resistor values of R5, R6, R7, and R8. In particular, comparator circuit 412 receives the sensed input from the common connection between R7 and R8. In the event the voltage sensed at the common connection between R7 and R8 deviates from the target voltage by a value greater than the first threshold, then circuit 412 provides an output indicating an ATRH1 event. If the voltage at the common connection of R6 and R7 deviates from the target voltage by a value greater than the second threshold, as set in comparator circuit 414, then circuit 414 provides an output indicating an ATRH2 event. Lastly, if the voltage at the common connection of R5 and R6 deviates from the target voltage by a value greater than the third threshold, as set in comparator circuit 416, then circuit 416 provides an output indicating an ATRH3 event.
Thus, setting a single threshold at a voltage level in a positive direction (at a pre-determined voltage higher than the target voltage) permits detection of a deviation greater than the pre-determined voltage. The detection of such a deviation signals an ATRL event activating circuitry to rapidly reduce voltage at the load. On the other hand, setting multiple thresholds at voltage levels in a negative direction (at multiple voltage levels lower than the target voltage) permits detection of the size of the deviation from the target voltage. The detection of such multiple levels of deviation, i.e. transients, signals not only the existence of an ATRH event, but also the amplitude of the deviation, i.e. ATRH1, ATRH2, or ATRH3.
The operation of the ATR comparators and ATR circuit 400 will also be understood with reference to the waveform shown in
Under rapidly changing conditions, for example if the load suddenly requires far less current, the load at the voltage could exceed the AVP load line voltage by more than the pre-set ATRL threshold. This is an ATRL event that will cause the ATR circuit 100 to be activated to rapidly bring the load voltage towards the AVP load line. Similarly, if the load suddenly requires far more current, then the load voltage could decrease to an amount that would exceed one or more of the ATRH thresholds. This will be an ATRH event that will cause the ATR circuit 100 to be activated to rapidly bring the load voltage towards the AVP load line.
In accordance with the invention, it has been found highly desirable to have multiple thresholds, particularly multiple ATRH thresholds. All of the embodiments in this application disclose three ATRH thresholds, to wit, ATRH1, ATRH2 and ATRH3, which can be used to great advantage in PWM systems with 2-6 or more channels (phases). However, there is no practical reason why rather than 3 ATRH thresholds, 2, 4 or more ATRH thresholds could not be used. However, the use of multiple ATRH thresholds greatly improves circuit operation (as compared with a single ATRH threshold) and is more cost effective than 4 or more ATRH thresholds where the improved performance may reach the point of diminishing returns. The improvement in circuit operation is achieved by adjusting the magnitude of the ATR response to the magnitude of the excursion from the AVP load line.
The advantage of detecting multiple ATR thresholds is achieved by providing correction based on the magnitude of the excursion. This technique is shown in the waveform diagram of
With continued reference to
By way of further example, see
The multi-gain aspect is illustrated in greater detail in the schematic diagram of
Refer now to
The pulse trains with the illustrated timing of the ATRHX_PHASEX signals are generated by timing generator 701 in response to the CLK input pulse. Thus, as shown in
As previously noted, the three ATRH threshold level detection is useful not only in four phase systems but in a system with any number of phases. For example, see
By way of example, see
What has then been described is a multi-phase pulse width modulated voltage regulator in which voltage excursions or deviations that exceed the load line voltage by more than a pre-determined amount are detected by an ATR circuit and a correction signal is applied. The correction signal is in the form of asynchronous pulses and the number of such pulses is a function of the magnitude of the voltage excursion as determined by the number of thresholds that are exceeded.
The present invention has been described above with reference to various exemplary embodiments. However, those skilled in the art will recognize that changes and modifications may be made to the exemplary embodiments without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention. For example, the various components may be implemented in alternate ways, such as, for example, by providing other configurations of SPC's. By way of another example, the number of phases utilized is a matter of design choice. By way of a still further, the specific Pulse Width Modulator used to generate the PWM pulses is also a matter of design choice. Such changes or modifications are intended to be included within the spirit and scope of the present invention, as set forth in the following claims.
This application includes subject matter that is related to and claims priority from the following patent applications, commonly assigned to the assignee of the present application, that are hereby incorporated herein by reference: 1. SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR HIGHLY PHASED POWER REGULATION, Ser. No. 10/112,738 filed Apr. 1, 2002, inventors: Duffy, et al, now U.S. Pat. No. 6,563,294. 2. SYSTEM, DEVICE AND METHOD FOR PROVIDING VOLTAGE REGULATION TO A MICROELECTRONIC. DEVICE, Ser. No. 10/103,980, filed Mar. 22, 2002, inventors: Duffy et al. 3. SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR CURRENT HANDLING IN A DIGITALLY CONTROLLED POWER CONVERTER, Ser. No. 10/237,903, filed Sep. 9, 2002, inventors: Duffy et al. 4. SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR HIGHLY PHASED POWER REGULATION, Ser. No. 09/975,195, filed Oct. 10, 2001, inventors: Duffy et al. 5. SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR HIGHLY PHASED POWER REGULATION USING ADAPTIVE COMPENSATION CONTROL, Ser. No. 09/978,294, filed Oct. 15, 2001, inventors: Goodfellow et al. 6. SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR HIGHLY PHASED POWER REGULATION USING ADAPTIVE COMPENSATION CONTROL, Ser. No. 10/109,801, filed Oct. 15, 2001, inventors: Goodfellow et al. 7. DIGITAL CALIBRATION WITH LOSSLESS SENSING IN A MULTIPHASE SWITCHED POWER CONVERTER, Ser. No. 10/884,840, filed Jul. 2, 2004, inventors: Southwell et al
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
5635934 | Brown | Jun 1997 | A |
5987615 | Danstrom | Nov 1999 | A |
6157332 | Frank et al. | Dec 2000 | A |
6356063 | Brooks | Mar 2002 | B1 |
6472856 | Groom et al. | Oct 2002 | B2 |
6512353 | Sanzo et al. | Jan 2003 | B2 |
6563294 | Duffy et al. | May 2003 | B2 |
6667606 | Oglesbee et al. | Dec 2003 | B2 |
6696825 | Harris et al. | Feb 2004 | B2 |
6696882 | Markowski et al. | Feb 2004 | B1 |
6856121 | Chou et al. | Feb 2005 | B2 |
7007176 | Goodfellow et al. | Feb 2006 | B2 |
20020144163 | Goodfellow et al. | Oct 2002 | A1 |
20020171985 | Duffy et al. | Nov 2002 | A1 |
20020175747 | Tang et al. | Nov 2002 | A1 |
20030006650 | Tang et al. | Jan 2003 | A1 |
20030141858 | Caine et al. | Jul 2003 | A1 |
20060025892 | Leung et al. | Feb 2006 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20090261795 A1 | Oct 2009 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 10938031 | Sep 2004 | US |
Child | 12490071 | US |