The present invention relates to a method for measuring perfusion in tissue, by which method a diffusionally permeable reservoir comprising a tracer is placed in or on the surface of the tissue, a diffusionally permeable detector chamber for detection of the tracer is placed in or on the surface of the tissue in a distance from the reservoir, tracer is supplied to the reservoir, and the presence of tracer in the detection chamber is measured. The invention further relates to a sensor for measuring tissue perfusion comprising a diffusionally permeable reservoir and at least two diffusionally permeable detector chambers.
Tissue perfusion is a measure of the volume of blood that passes through an amount of tissue per time unit and is often measured in the unit milliliter blood/(100 gram tissue)/minute. Supply of nutrients and excretion of waste products in all tissue take place by diffusion between the tissue cells and the blood, and perfusion in a tissue is therefore an extremely important factor in the health and survival of a tissue. A method for measuring the perfusion of a tissue is therefore very relevant for instance for monitoring tissue during and after surgery and transplantation. Also monitoring of threatened tissue, for instance muscle tissue where the blood supply is threatened by increasing pressure inside the fascia of the muscle, is very relevant as an indicator of when a pressure-releasing operation should be initiated. Likewise, monitoring of the internal perfusion, which is caused by the formation of oedema in the heart, e.g. when the heart has been stopped during surgery, can give important information regarding the need for artificial nutrition for the heart tissue. Furthermore, perfusion is an important parameter in medical research.
A method for determining the perfusion of a tissue using 133Xenon is described by Larsen, O. A., N. A. Lassen, and F. Quaade. 1966 (Blood Flow through Human Adipose Tissue Determined with Radioactive Xenon. Acta physiol. scand. 66:337-345). The method comprises injection of 133Xe in the tissue to be investigated and measuring the disappearance rate of the radioactivity. With this technique the temporal resolution is approximately ½ hour, which is inadequate in many acute situations, and the place of the injection is not very precisely defined relative to where the radioactivity is measured.
Another method for measuring perfusion consists of continuous infusion of ethanol during micro dialysis. In micro dialysis a fluid is pumped very slowly through a fiber placed in the tissue of the patient. The ethanol concentration of the fluid in the fiber equilibrates with the surrounding tissue as the fiber is diffusionally permeable and the fluid is collected through a return fiber. Also this method has a very long temporal resolution.
There are patented optical and acoustic techniques (e.g. Laser-Doppler) that measure the movement of blood cells. These methods do not measure the transport of compounds between the tissue cells and the bloodstream but only the velocity of the blood cells. Furthermore the geometry of the measurements is limited to either very local measurements or to measurements in a very limited depth below the surface of a tissue. Other optical techniques include NMR imaging, which require that the patient is immobilized relative to the NMR-scanner.
WO 97/46853 describes a method and a microsensor, which is capable of measuring tissue perfusion, but the measurements of this microsensor are confined to a very limited spatial localization, and heterogeneities in the tissue will make average measurements of the perfusion very complicated. A precise placement and fixation of the microsensor is necessary, which makes it very difficult to use the method on living organisms.
WO 01/24692 describes a method and a sensor for measuring tissue perfusion using tracers that are simultaneously released from and detected by the sensor. This sensor comprises one diffusionally permeable reservoir for releasing the tracer and one diffusionally permeable detector chamber, which makes the response time relatively long and which gives a very complicated signal evaluation.
To avoid the disadvantages of the prior art for measuring tissue perfusion the purpose of the present invention is to provide a method, which is faster and more precise than the prior art for measuring tissue perfusion.
The purpose is furthermore to provide a sensor, the physical construction of which enables the application on tissue of patients that are not fully immobilized.
Furthermore, it is a purpose to provide a sensor to be used for measurements of skin perfusion through the surface of the skin or perfusion in other organs through the surface of these.
Furthermore, methods will be described that enable the interpretation of the signals of such a sensor with the purpose of calculating the tissue perfusion based on the signals.
Compared to the previously mentioned patent application WO 01/24692 it is possible with the present invention to provide a complete picture of the tracer distribution in the tissue, which can be used to make a relatively easy perfusion rate calculation using only a blood tissue partition coefficient as will be explained below.
In a first aspect, the present invention relates to a method for measuring tissue perfusion by which method a diffusionally permeable reservoir containing a tracer is placed in or on the surface of a tissue, a diffusionally permeable detector chamber for the tracer is placed in or on the surface of a tissue in a distance from the reservoir, tracer is supplied to the reservoir, and the presence of tracer in the detector chamber is measured, in which method at least one additional diffusionally permeable detector chamber for detecting the tracer is placed in or on the surface of the tissue, that the presence of the tracer is measured in each detector chamber separately, and that the measurements are converted to a measure of the tissue perfusion.
In a second aspect, the present invention relates to a sensor for measuring tissue perfusion comprising a diffusionally permeable reservoir and at least two diffusionally permeable detector chambers, wherein at least two diffusionally permeable detector chambers are located in different distances from the reservoir either on the same side of the reservoir or on both sides of the reservoir.
The invention is explained in detail below with reference to the drawing(s), in which
The invention is substantially based on the following basic elements: 1) at least one compartment, which in one particular embodiment is a longitudinally elongated compartment, in the following termed “reservoir”, with diffusionally permeable side-walls containing at least one detectable substance like a liquid or a gas, in the following termed “tracer”, 2) a source for providing the at least one reservoir with tracer(s), 3) a number of compartments, in the following termed “detector chambers”, particularly longitudinally elongated compartments, wherein the tracer(s) can be detected after diffusing out of the reservoir and through the adjacent tissue and into the detector chambers.
In the context of the present invention, “diffusionally permeable” is defined as having the property that the tracer molecules in question can penetrate the material by molecular diffusion, in the absence of holes in the material where mass flow can take place.
In general the principle of the sensor according to the invention is based on having at least one source of a tracer, e.g. a gas, supplied to a reservoir, particularly a longitudinally elongated reservoir, having diffusion permeable side walls through which side walls the tracer will diffuse into the surrounding tissue. Some of the tracer molecules will enter into the blood stream and be carried away while other tracer molecules will move by molecular diffusion and reach one of the at least two detection chambers, which detection chambers in a particular embodiment are longitudinally elongated detection chambers, preferably placed parallel to each other and to the reservoir. The reservoir could in one embodiment be placed in the middle of several detection chambers, where two or more detection chambers are located in increasing distance from the reservoir on each side. In one particular embodiment more than 5 to 20 detection chambers are located on each side of the reservoir. Also it is possible to combine more than one reservoir with the above described embodiments in such a way as to form repeated units of reservoirs interspaced by several (e.g. 10-40) detection chambers. In a further embodiment one reservoir is located at one side having two or more detection chambers in increasing distance on the other side.
In one embodiment the sensor comprises at least 4 detector chambers, particularly at least 5, more particularly at least 8, even more particularly at least 10.
Preferably the at least one reservoir and the detector chambers are fixed in a position parallel to each other. The elongated structures are in one embodiment fixed by tracer-impermeable spacer structures 3, 14 (see
Alternatively one could imagine other arrangements like e.g. having a central reservoir surrounded by a number of detection chambers forming concentric circles around the reservoir and located in increasing distance from the reservoir.
Many more combinations would of course be imaginable by the skilled person and as long as these possible embodiments enables the detection of the tracer in separate compartments in increasing distance from a given reservoir, such embodiments will fall within the scope of the present invention.
The embodiment of the sensor according to the invention shown in
Instead of separate spacers 3, which form connections between the reservoir 2 and the detector chambers 1, the sensor can be made in one part, for instance by extrusion of a plastic material, e.g. polyethylene or polypropylene, or by photolithography in silicone.
When applying the embodiment shown in
When the sensor is placed in the tissue, tracer(s) in the form of a gas or a liquid is/are supplied in one embodiment in an intermittent fashion to the reservoir. The tracer(s) are supplied through the opening 8 to the reservoir 2 as indicated by the arrow in
Tracers that have left the reservoir as part of such a mass flow can either be collected for later disposal or led directly into the atmosphere if the tracer(s) are not harmful.
In one embodiment of the invention only one tracer is supplied to the reservoir and in another embodiment at least two different tracers are supplied to the reservoir.
The tracer(s) will typically consist of a mixture of noble gasses, for instance He, Ne, Ar, Kr, Xe and other non-toxic gasses, for instance H2, SF6 and CFC-gasses. The particular application of the sensor according to the invention determines the choice of tracer gas. The molecular weigh of a gas is negatively correlated to its diffusion coefficient, such that a small molecular weight has a high diffusion coefficient and vice versa. For fast response and overall high signal, a gas having a small molecular weight is selected, however, to achieve a more pronounced signal change in response to perfusion changes, a more heavy molecular weight tracer gas should be selected. If a tracer is very soluble in the tissue components (cells and intercellular material), the signal response to changes in perfusion is less than for a tracer with a low solubility. The solubility of a tracer relies on its polarity. So the tracer(s) should be selected with a polarity that is as different as the general polarity of the tissue components as possible in order to get the strongest signal(s). To take advantage of the improved signal interpretation from two or more signals, a range of tracers that differ significantly with respect to the total effect of molecular weight and polarity on the signal should be selected. Slow diffusing tracer(s) will, if all other parameters are equal, arrive at the detector chamber(s) in smaller amounts than fast tracers. The amount of tracer(s) should reflect the molecular weight such that a slow tracer is represented in larger amounts in the reservoir, to avoid that the resulting signal gets too low to get an acceptable signal-to-noise ratio.
The tracers are in one embodiment supplied to separate reservoirs. In another embodiment the tracers are supplied simultaneously to each reservoir.
When the reservoir 2 contains tracers, part of the tracer molecules will diffuse through the wall of the reservoir 2 and into the surrounding tissue as indicated by the dashed arrows 9 in
Each of the detector chambers 5 are as mentioned in connection with a detection device via the proximal open end 7. The detection device measures the tracer concentration inside the detection chamber or the amount of tracer that enters the detection chamber per time unit. An example of a technology that measures concentration is optical detection, where a detection device measures the concentration of tracer molecules without consuming these. An example of a technology that measures the amount of tracer that is transported into the detection chamber per time unit is a quadrupol mass spectrometer, which, by keeping a very low pressure inside the mass spectrometer measuring unit, causes a movement of the tracer molecules from the detection chamber of the sensor to the detection mechanism of the mass spectrometer and yields a signal which is proportional to the number of tracer molecules that pass into the measuring chamber per time unit. Another technology that measures the tracer transport by measuring and at the same time removing the tracer is electrochemical oxidation or reduction of the tracer.
In an implementation of the sensor with the simultaneous use of several tracer compounds it is an advantage to use a detection device, which can easily detect several compounds almost simultaneously, for instance the above mentioned quadrupol mass spectrometer, which can measure the signal from several tracers within a few seconds. Each separate detection chamber does not have to have its own detection device. Instead multiplexing can be performed between these chambers, i.e. by using valves or other switching mechanism, the connection between detection chamber and detection device is changed sequentially, such that the detection device measures each detection chamber for a limited time period.
Signal Interpretation.
After the detection of tracer gas in each detection chamber, these data have to be converted to a measure for the tissue perfusion. This signal interpretation is in turn dependent on the mode of supply of the tracer(s) to the reservoir(s). Either the supply can be in the form of a sequential or intermittent supply or it can be continuous.
In the case of intermittent supply, in one embodiment the tracer gas is supplied for 1-500 seconds, then the supply of tracer(s) to the reservoir is abruptly interrupted and replaced by a flow of gas or liquid containing none or a different mix of different tracer substances. The length of the supply period is chosen such that within this period and the following detection period only an insignificant part of the tracer has diffused further away from the reservoir than the most distant detection chamber, and this time depends on the type and physiological state of the tissue, the diffusion coefficient of the tracer(s), and the distance between the reservoir and the most remote detection chamber. In practice the end of the supply period is chosen when the tracer has been detected in the detection chamber closest to half way between the reservoir and the detection chamber most distant to the reservoir. The detection period extends from this point to the time when tracer is detected in the most distant detection chamber. After this detection period, there is a resting period until 95-99% of the total tracer amount has been completely removed by diffusion and perfusion, before a new supply period is initiated.
As long as tracer(s) is/are supplied to the reservoir, there will be a net diffusion of tracer(s) in the tissue radially away from the reservoir. The concentration distribution of tracer(s) in the tissue can be monitored by the tracer detection in each detection chamber as mentioned above. The signal from each detection chamber represents the tracer concentration in a distance from the reservoir which is equal to the distance between the reservoir and the detection chamber in question. If the detection chambers are spaced sufficiently finely, the total amount of tracer in the tissue between the reservoir and the outermost detection chamber can thus at any time be approximated as the sum of the concentration detected by each detection chamber times the tissue volume which, is represented by the detector chamber. This can be written for equally spaced detection chambers as:
where Trtot is the to total amount of tracer in the tissue, Cn is the concentration at the n'th detection chamber, rn is the the distance from the reservoir to the n'th detection chamber, dr is the distance between two neighboring detection chambers, and l is the length of the sensor.
When the tracer(s) in the reservoir(s) is abruptly removed and exchanged with none or different tracer(s), the reduction over time of this total amount of tracer in the tissue will be due to the removal by perfusion. If equilibration between the amount dissolved in the cells and interstitial material and the amount dissolved in the blood vessels is assumed, the perfusion can be calculated as:
Perfusion=d(ln(Trtot))/dt·λ·100
The partition coefficient λ has been investigated for a number of gases in different tissues and can be looked up in the literature (e.g. Bülow, J., Jelnes, R., Astrup, A., Madsen, J., and Vilmann, P. 1987. Tissue/blood partition coefficients for xenon in various adipose tissue depots in man. Scand J Clin Lab Invest 47:1-3). When the perfusion is calculated with the above formula with a known partition coefficient for a gas, the partition coefficient of other gases that are used simultaneously can be determined using the same formula for the signal for the gas with unknown partition coefficient, but now with the partition coefficient as the only unknown parameter. In this fashion, the unknown partition coefficient for a gases can be determined and the signal of this gas may be useful for perfusion measurements under conditions for which the gas with the known partition coefficient is not suited, for instance due to substantial changes in the perfusion rate.
Alternatively to the above method with abrupt changes in tracer supply, a continuous tracer supply can be used, but this requires a more complex signal interpretation.
With a continuous supply of tracer(s), the sensor according to the invention indirectly measures the concentration of tracer in the tissue immediately outside each detection chamber by detecting the resulting concentration inside the detection chamber or the resulting transport of tracers into the detection chamber. The concentration of the tracer(s) immediately outside each detection chamber is a function of
If the diffusion of a tracer from the reservoir out into a surrounding tissue without perfusion is considered, such diffusion can be described as a cylindrical diffusion system, where the concentration C of the tracer as a function of the diffusion coefficient D, the distance to the reservoir r and the time t can be formulates as:
A given perfusion, which is evenly distributed in the tissue, will remove a constant fraction, ki of the tracer concentration per time unit. If this removal is incorporated into the model, the result will be the following equation:
This mathematical model assumes that the presence of the detector chambers do not significantly influence the diffusion of the tracer molecules, which can be assumed with a relatively low error margin, provided that the tracer permeability in the wall of the detector chambers is low and if the diffusion coefficient and solubility of a given tracer is the same in the reservoir wall as in the tissue. However, the tissue and the reservoir wall are not likely to have the same solubility and diffusion coefficient for a given tracer as they consist of different materials. For this reason the mathematical model should be expanded to comprise several layers in a cylindrical geometry. This can be done analytically, but such an analytical model cannot handle situations with variable perfusion over time.
It is therefore useful to employ a computer model, which implements the reservoir wall and tissue as a cylindrical diffusion-consumption system. The system is divided into layers and the computer model moves amounts of a tracer between neighboring layers as a function of the concentration difference between them and of the tracer diffusion coefficient and solubility in each layer. The amount moved is determined using a discrete version of the above equation. A similar model system can be implemented for a detection chamber wall, and by combining these two systems, a complete model of the signal is for a detection chamber can be constructed. To use the model to model the perfusion rate in the tissue, it is necessary to have values for the above-mentioned parameters under 1)-6). If these values are known, the actual signals can be modeled by an iterative procedure where the perfusion rate is found as the one that gives the model the best fit to the signals. If the values for diffusion coefficients and solubility are not known beforehand, they can also be variable parameters in the model that are adjusted to give the model the best fit to the signals, but with the difference that they can be assumed to be constant during the measurement.
By using two or more tracers simultaneously, the model can be consolidated, as the tracers share the same perfusion rate and the number of unknown parameters per tracer in the model is thus reduced. For instance helium and krypton, that have very different diffusion coefficients, can be used simultaneously.
A simpler way to interpret the signal in the case of continuous tracer supply is a qualitative evaluation. If the perfusion of the tissue increases, the tracer concentration—and thus the sensor signal—will decrease. If the signal is monitored continuously, it will thus be possible to monitor changes in perfusion qualitatively, as all other parameters under 2) to 6) above can be assumed to be constant for each tracer for a given tissue for a given person on a given day.
The sensor can be formed with different geometries and of different materials, such that the sensitivity of the sensor and other properties are suited for different measuring situations. By increasing the distance from the reservoir to the most distant detector chamber the sensitivity of the sensor for low perfusion rates is increased, but this has the disadvantage that the sensor width is increased and thus the risk of discomfort or irritation of the tissue is increased. Conversely, the tissue can be less damaged by using a slimmer version of the sensor, but at the expense of the sensitivity at low perfusion rates. Inner and outer diameter of the reservoir can be increased, whereby the tracer will reach tissue in a larger circumference relative to the sensor and the measurement will thus integrate over a larger tissue section, but this increase is at the expense of the sensitivity at low perfusion rates. The tracer permeability of the walls of both reservoir and detector chambers can be varied by changing material (e.g. increasing the permeability by changing from Teflon to polyethylene, from polyethylene to polypropylene, or from polyethylene to Mylar) or making a different wall thickness. An increase of the permeability will increase the absolute size of the signal and thus the signal-to-noise ratio, but it will also result in that the naturally occurring tissue gases like oxygen and carbon dioxide will diffuse into the reservoir and/or the detector chambers to a higher degree whereby the physiological state of the tissue may be affected.
In
The plate can be fastened to the tissue surface by mechanical means (e.g. straps) or by suction in specialized channels in the underside of the plate.
In addition to tracer molecules, also naturally occurring tissue gases (e.g. oxygen, carbon dioxide) can diffuse into the detector chambers. If the detection device is sensitive to these gases, as is for instance a quadrupol mass spectrometer, these gases can be measured almost simultaneously with the tracer(s) and thus further important information about the state of the tissue is obtained.
Above, several embodiments are described. It is understood that these are only a few of many possible embodiments of the described principle, as it is defined in the accompanying set of claims and that other embodiments can be conceived by a person skilled in the art. For instance, the reservoir and detector chambers in the embodiment in
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PA 2001 01950 | Dec 2001 | DK | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/DK02/00889 | 12/20/2002 | WO |