This invention relates generally to energetically reactive compositions, and more specifically relates to the preparation of metastable nano-composite materials by arrested reactive milling.
A very high reaction enthalpy is an advantage of composite energetic formulations employing metallic fuels and solid oxidizers. However, the rates of reaction of such formulations are limited by condensed phase transport processes and are much lower than the reaction rates of mono-molecular energetic formulations, e.g., TNT, HMX, RDX, etc. Current research on composite energetics aims to reduce the length scales limiting mass transfer rates and to approach the reaction kinetics achievable for monomolecular formulations. Significant efforts have been made to produce metal fuel powders with nano-sized particles, see e.g., [D. P. Dufaux, R. L Axelbaum, Combustion and Flame 100 (1995) 350-358; L. J. Rosen, Z. Sun, R. L. Axelbaum, Chemical and Physical Processes in Combustion Combustion Institute, Raleigh, N.C., 1999, pp. 164-167]. Faster burning rates have been demonstrated with nano-sized metal powders for several applications, however difficulties in handling such powders and their incorporation into existing formulations have also been reported [P. Brousseau, J. C. Anderson, Propellants, Explosives, Pyrotechnics 27(5) (2002) 300-306]. To benefit fully from the small length scale and large specific surface of nano-sized metal particles, such particles should be intimately mixed with similarly sized oxidizer particles. Progress in this direction has been reported and nanopowders of metals and metal oxides have been mixed in organic solvents forming so-called Metastable Intermolecular Composites (MIC) [N. Bockmon, S. F. Son, B. W. Asay, J. R. Busse, J. T. Mang, P. D. Peterson, M. Pantoya, CPIA Publication 712 (38th JANNAF Combustion Subcommittee Meeting) (2002) 613-624]. Sol-gel processing has also been developed to produce nano-structured matrices of oxidizer materials that can be filled with metallic nano-sized fuels [T. M. Tillotson.; A. E. Gash, R. L. Simpson, L. W. Hrubesh, J. H. Satcher, J. F. Poco, Journal of Non-Crystalline Solids 285(1-3) (2001) 338-345].
In all of the current approaches, metal nanopowders have to be synthesized in a separate process and then mixed with the oxidizer. Handling of the highly reactive nano-sized fuel particles in close contact with oxidizer is needed and some passivation is always required. In order to reduce ignition sensitivity of metal nano-powders, protective coatings are used [D. Y Maeng, C. K Rhee, W. W. Kim, K. H Kim, Y. A. Kotov, Journal of Metastable and Nanocrystalline Materials 15-16 (2003) 491-494], which typically reduce the overall enthalpy of the fuel. Nano-sized ingredient powders also make it difficult to achieve the desired high density of the final energetic formulations. In addition, the costs of synthesis, passivation, and handling of the fuel and oxidizer nanopowders are currently prohibitively high.
Now in accordance with the present invention, nano-structured composite energetic materials are provided by use of arrested reactive milling of powdered mixture of metals and oxidizers for the metals, or by such milling of mixtures of reactive metals. The resulting materials are micron-sized powders, which can be handled using conventional processing techniques. Each particle comprises a fully dense mixture of the reagents with a three-dimensional nanosized structure. The components can be a fuel and oxidizer, e.g., thermite compositions, or highly reactive combinations of metals, e.g., B—Ti, B—Zr or others. Fresh metal surface is produced during synthesis but most of it is never exposed to oxidizing environment, unlike the fresh metal surface of the nanosized metal powders. The interface between the reactants is formed at low temperatures and therefore, the passivating layers are not produced on the fresh metal surfaces to the same degree as for blends of nanometer sized powders or layered nanocomposites produced at elevated temperatures by sputter deposition [K. J. Blobaum, M. E. Reiss, J. M. Plitzko Lawrence, and T. P Weihs, Journal of Applied Physics 94(5) 2003 2915-2922].
Reactive Milling has been observed to trigger spontaneous combustion-like reactions in a number of reactive systems. Such a spontaneous reaction is likely if the adiabatic reaction temperature of the components exceeds 1800° K [L. Takacs, Progress in Materials Science 47: 355-414 (2002) Z. A Munir, U. Aselmi-Tamburini, Materials Science Reports, 3(7-8) (1989) 277-365]. Such spontaneous reactions show very high reaction rates desirable for many applications of energetic materials. In the present invention reactive milling is adapted to prepare highly reactive composites. Such materials are obtained just before the spontaneous reaction would have occurred during milling so that the reaction can be controllably initiated later. In order to prepare such materials, the time of spontaneous initiation must be known as accurately as possible. Current theoretical treatment of the milling process is not sufficiently advanced to predict initiation reliably. Therefore, in the process of the invention a parametric experimental investigation establishes the conditions leading to the spontaneous reaction for each composition of interest.
Thus in accordance with the invention, a method is disclosed for producing an energetic metastable nano-composite material. Under pre-selected milling conditions a mixture of powdered components are reactively milled. These components will spontaneously react after a known time duration specific for the pre-selected milling conditions. The milling is stopped at a time at which the components have been compositionally homogenized to produce nanocomposite particles, but prior to said known duration, and thereby before the spontaneous reaction occurs. The milled powder is recovered as a highly reactive nanostructured composite for subsequent use by controllably initiating destabilization thereof. During recovery and handling, only the external surface of the particles is exposed to oxygenated environment and passivated by oxidation. Most of the freshly produced reactive metal interfaces remain within the nanocomposite material and retains its high reactivity.
In a preferred procedure for practicing the invention the milling is effected in a ball mill, where the pre-selected conditions include the number of balls; the ball diameter and ball material; the ratio between the ball diameter and initial volume of the components being milled; the ratio between the mass of balls and the mass of the said components; the material, size, and shape of the milling container; the presence or absence of milling aids such as surfactants; and the mill operating parameters used during the milling operation, which for example in a vibratory ball mill would include oscillating rate and amplitude. On the other hand, in a stirred mill such as the “Attritor”, rotational speed of the stirrer is such an operating parameter. Similarly, in a planetary mill rotational speed of the milling vial is such an operating parameter.
The invention is further illustrated in the Figures appended hereto, in which:
The invention is further illustrated in the following Examples, which however are to be considered as exemplary and not definitive of the invention.
A SPEX 8000 shaker mill has been used extensively in current research on reactive milling and mechanical alloying [C. Suryanarayana, Progress in Materials Science, 46 (2001) 1-184; Y. L. Shoshin, R. S. Mudryy, E. L. Dreizin, Comb. Flame 128 (2002) 259-269; M. Schoenitz, E. L. Dreizin, E. Shtessel, J. of Prop. and Power 19(3) (2003) 405-412] and was also used in this and the other Examples. The SPEX shaker mill is a vibratory mill; its vial is agitated at high frequency in a complex cycle that involves motion in three orthogonal directions. The reciprocating velocity of the vial in the SPEX 8000 series shaker mill is directly proportional to the motor's rotational speed. Under various loading conditions, the rotational speed of the actuator input shaft was measured with a stroboscope. The nominal rotational speed was 1054 RPM, which translates to an oscillation frequency of 17.6 Hz. The vial speed was not varied in the present Examples, but it offers additional means of control over the milling process as the vial speed directly influences the impact velocity and frequency of collisions, and hence the energy transferred to the powder from the plastic deformation. Steel milling vials and balls were used in this and the remaining Examples. Milling media with higher or lower densities can also be used to afford control over the collision energy between the media.
A thermistor was mounted on the milling vial and connected to a PC-based data logger to monitor its temperature. The spontaneous reaction registered as a sharp temperature spike. Times of initiation were determined for varying milling parameters for each material. No process control agent was used. The diameters of the balls used were 2.36, 3.16, 4.76, and 9.52 mm. The materials were milled under argon. The ball-to-powder weight ratio (charge ratio, CR) was set to 2.5, 5, and 10.
Starting materials were Al (98%, 10-14 μm), Fe2O3 (99.5%, −325 mesh), and MoO3 (99.95%, −325 mesh) from Alfa Aesar. The total amount of material was 5 g in the case of Al—Fe2O3, and 2 g for Al—MoO3. At a given CR, this changes the number of balls used, and therefore the milling times required to initiate the spontaneous reaction for different materials are not immediately comparable. The amount of the Al—MoO3 mixture loaded in a single run did not exceed 2 g to avoid damaging the milling vial because of the high local temperatures caused by the reaction.
After initiation times were determined, samples of metastable composite materials were prepared using Arrested Reactive Milling (ARM) by halting the milling just before the initiation of the reaction. Stoichiometric Samples of Al—Fe2O3 and Al—MoO3 were prepared with varying milling times. The respective reproducibility of the initiation under identical milling conditions was found to be about 10% (see below). Therefore, samples arrested at approximately 90% of the time of spontaneous initiation are designated as “fully milled” for reference. Partially milled samples were obtained at approximately 50% initiation time.
Materials Characterization
Powder x-ray diffraction was performed using a Philips X'pert MRD X-ray diffractometer. The surface morphology of individual particles as well as the internal structure of cross-sectioned particles was investigated using a LEO 1530 Field Emission Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM). Cross sections were prepared by embedding small quantities of composite powders in epoxy resin. The particles were embedded under vacuum to eliminate trapped gasses and avoid formation of bubbles. The mounts were then polished by hand using successively finer SiC polishing paper up to 1200 grit.
Particle size distributions for starting materials, mechanical alloys and their combustion products were determined by Low-Angle Laser Light Scattering (LALLS) using a Coulter LS230 particle size analyzer.
Combustion Testing
Several preliminary tests were carried out to assess changes in the ignition and combustion behavior of the nano-composite thermite materials produced by ARM. Schematic diagrams of the experimental setups are shown in
Ignition of the ARM-prepared powders was studied using an electrically heated filament (
In another test, reaction rates were compared for nano-composite powders prepared using ARM and blended initial component powders. In these tests, the thermite powder was placed on a ceramic support inside a closed pressure vessel equipped with a pressure transducer (
Linear burning rates of different powders were measured in the test illustrated in
Results and Discussion
Synthesis of the Reactive Nano-Composite Powders
Observed times of spontaneous initiation during milling of Al—MoO3 and Al—Fe2O3 are shown in Table 1. The values and errors shown are the results of 2 -4 repetitions under identical conditions. The reproducibility is found to be on the order of ±10%. Milling times generally decrease with increasing charge ratio CR.
Recently, it has been suggested that the progress of mechanical alloying or reactive milling can be described using the specific milling dose, Dm, introduced as
where I is the milling intensity, ncoll is the frequency of ball-ball collisions, Ecoll the averaged energy per collisions, t the milling time, and mp the powder mass [F. Delogu, R. Orrhu, G. Cao, Chemical Engineering Science 58 (2003) 815-821]. It was assumed that the value of Dm, determines the state of the milled material, and that ignition is triggered at a specific degree of grain refinement. Further simplifying assumptions can be made, i.e., Ecoll˜mb, where mb is the mass of a single ball, and ncoll˜nb, where nb is the number of balls. With the time of the initiation, tinit, this leads to a constant milling dose, Dm* corresponding to a certain degree of grain refinement:
The product of the measured milling times leading to initiation and the charge ratios, CRtinit, is plotted as a function of the ball diameter in
Based on the good reproducibility of the experiments with balls of 4.76 mm diameter, reactive composites were prepared for further analysis with these balls and with CR=5. “Fully milled” materials were milled for 11 and 19 min for the Al—MoO3 and Al—Fe2O3 mixtures, respectively. “Partially milled” materials were milled for about half the maximum time, 6 and 10 min, respectively. In addition, fully reactive B—Ti nano-composite powders were prepared by milling elemental B and Ti powders in steel vials for 150 min using steel balls with diameters of 4.76 mm and a CR of 5. Thermite powder blends were prepared by manually homogenizing the starting materials under acetone for reference tests.
Materials Properties
SEM images of the fully milled nano-composite particles and particle cross-sections are shown in
Preliminary Ignition and Combustion Testing
Ignition temperatures measured at different heating rates for the three types of fully reactive nanocomposite materials prepared using ARM are shown in Table 2. These data, processed using an isoconversion method [M. J. Starink, Thermochimica Acta 288 (1996) 97-104] to estimate the ignition activation energy, are plotted in
Pressure traces measured in the constant volume explosion vessel for combustion of different charges of thermite powders are shown in
The combustion products collected from the pressure vessel were analyzed by SEM and XRD. A representative backscattered electron image is shown in
The same pressure vessel has recently been used for constant volume aerosol explosion tests carried out in air with different mechanically alloyed powders [M. Schoenitz, E. L. Dreizin, E. Shtessel, J. of Prop. and Power 19(3) (2003) 405-412]. Nano-composites prepared using boron and titanium powders using ARM were made and compared with the respective powder blends. Higher rates of pressure rise were reported for the nano-composite powders and a higher degree of conversion of the metallic powders to oxides was observed. Interestingly, some borides (e.g., TiB or TiB2) were detected in the combustion products of B—Ti powder blends but no borides were found in the combustion products of the ARM-prepared B—Ti nano-composite powders. More details on these experiments are available elsewhere [Schoenitz, Dreizin and Shtessel, op. cit.].
The results of the linear burn measurements for Al—Fe2O3 nano-composites prepared using ARM with different milling times as well as for the blended Al and Fe2O3 powders are shown in
The foregoing demonstrates that the reactive milling of powders with very high reaction enthalpies can be reproducibly arrested to produce novel energetic material powders with particles in the 1-100 μm size range. Individual particles of these powders are fully dense. The composition of each particle is identical to the bulk powder composition. The components are intimately mixed in three-dimensional nano-structures and ready to react upon initiation. An experimental parametric study of the arrested reactive milling established that for a range of sizes of the grinding balls used, a concept of a milling dose proportional to the product of the milling time and charge ratio can be used to approximately predict the time necessary to prepare the metastable nano-composites. Ignition temperatures of the prepared materials were measured and their activation energies of ignition were evaluated. The activation energy obtained from these experiments for the Al—Fe2O3 nano-composite is consistent with the known activation energy of the Al—Fe2O3 thermite reaction. Higher reaction rates were observed in combustion tests conducted in a constant volume pressure vessel in argon for the ARM-prepared nano-composites of both Al—Fe2O3 and Al—MoO3 as compared to the respective blends of initial powders and partially milled powders. Linear burning rates were observed to increase for the ARM-prepared powders as the time when the reactive milling was arrested approached the expected time of the spontaneous reaction in the milling vial.
While the present invention has been described in terms of specific embodiments thereof, it will be understood in view of the present disclosure, that numerous variations upon the invention are now enabled to those skilled in the art, which variations yet reside within the scope of the present teaching. Accordingly, the invention is to be broadly construed, and limited only by the scope and spirit of the claims now appended hereto.
This application claims priority from U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 60/524,712, filed Nov. 24, 2003.
The United States government may hold license and/or other rights in this invention as a result of financial support provided by governmental agencies in the development of aspects of the invention.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60524712 | Nov 2003 | US |