Patent Application
20230149426
The present invention relates to a composition comprising β-hydroxy-β-methylbutyrate (HMB) and Vitamin D, and methods of using a combination of HMB and Vitamin D to improve muscle mass, strength, or functionality.
Lean body mass (LBM) decreases at a rate of about 8% per decade after the age of 40 and accelerates to about 15% per decade after the age of 70. Decreasing lean mass typically reflects a loss of muscle mass and is accompanied by reduced muscular strength and physical function. These losses have serious, wide-ranging implications for older adults. Lean body mass and strength are inversely associated with loss of independence, fall risk, morbidity, and mortality. Thus, attenuating the age-related losses of muscle mass and function has great potential to improve health and quality of life.
Several strategies have been proposed to slow age-related muscle loss, but to date, only resistance training, alone or in combination with nutritional interventions, has been consistently shown to be effective. However, nutritional interventions alone are generally only effective in cases of restricted food intake or overt malnutrition. Insufficient protein intake (less than the recommended daily allowance [RDA] of 0.8 g per kg per day) is associated with reduced LBM and physical performance. While protein insufficiency affects relatively few older adults (˜10%), increasing protein intake above the RDA increases muscle mass but does not improve muscle strength or global physical functioning. Similarly, pharmacologic interventions, primarily using anabolic agents, have been less convincing with some studies showing beneficial and others showing adverse outcomes. Additionally, the use of anabolic hormones have been associated with significant morbidities limiting their utility in the general population.
HMB
The only product of leucine metabolism is ketoisocaproate (KIC). A minor product of KIC metabolism is β-hydroxy-β-methylbutyrate (HMB). HMB has been found to be useful within the context of a variety of applications. Specifically, in U.S. Pat. No. 5,360,613 (Nissen), HMB is described as useful for reducing blood levels of total cholesterol and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol. In U.S. Pat. No. 5,348,979 (Nissen et al.), HMB is described as useful for promoting nitrogen retention in humans. U.S. Pat. No. 5,028,440 (Nissen) discusses the usefulness of HMB to increase lean tissue development in animals. Also, in U.S. Pat. No. 4,992,470 (Nissen), HMB is described as effective in enhancing the immune response of mammals. U.S. Pat. No. 6,031,000 (Nissen et al.) describes use of HMB and at least one amino acid to treat disease-associated wasting.
It has previously been observed that HMB alone or in combination with other amino acids is an effective supplement for restoring muscle strength and function in young athletes. Further, it has been observed that HMB in combination with two amino acids, glutamine and lysine, is effective in increasing muscle mass in elderly persons.
It has been shown that HMB has beneficial effects on muscle mass, muscle strength, muscle function, and protein kinetics in older and young adults. In a year-long study by Baler et al., daily supplementation with HMB/Arg/Lys significantly improved LBM in supplemented older adults but showed no improvements in muscle strength or function.
HMB is an active metabolite of the amino acid leucine. The use of HMB to suppress proteolysis originates from the observations that leucine has protein-sparing characteristics (1-4). The essential amino acid leucine can either be used for protein synthesis or transaminated to the α-ketoacid (α-ketoisocaproate, KIC)(1, 3). In one pathway, KIC can be oxidized to HMB. Approximately 5% of leucine oxidation proceeds via the second pathway (5). HMB is superior to leucine in enhancing muscle mass and strength. The optimal effects of HMB can be achieved at 3.0 grams per day, or 0.38 g/kg of body weight per day, while those of leucine require over 30.0 grams per day (3).
Once produced or ingested, HMB appears to have two fates. The first fate is simple excretion in urine. After HMB is fed, urine concentrations increase, resulting in an approximate 20-50% loss of HMB to urine (4, 6). Another fate relates to the activation of HMB to HMB-CoA (7-16). Once converted to HMB-CoA, further metabolism may occur, either dehydration of HMB-CoA to MC-CoA, or a direct conversion of HMB-CoA to HMG-CoA (17), which provides substrates for intracellular cholesterol synthesis. Several studies have shown that HMB is incorporated into the cholesterol synthetic pathway (12, 16, 18-20) and could be a source for new cell membranes that are used for the regeneration of damaged cell membranes (3). Human studies have shown that muscle damage following intense exercise, measured by elevated plasma CPK (creatine phosphokinase), is reduced with HMB supplementation within the first 48 hrs. The protective effect of HMB lasts up to three weeks with continued daily use (21-23).
In vitro studies in isolated rat muscle show that HMB is a potent inhibitor of muscle proteolysis (24) especially during periods of stress. These findings have been confirmed in humans; for example, HMB inhibits muscle proteolysis in subjects engaging in resistance training (4). The results have been duplicated in many studies (25) (21-23, 26-28).
The molecular mechanisms by which HMB decreases protein breakdown and increases protein synthesis have recently been reported (29-31, 31-33). In mice bearing the MAC16 cachexia-inducing tumor, HMB attenuated protein degradation through the down-regulation of key activators of the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway (30). Furthermore, HMB attenuated proteolysis-inducing factor (PIF) activation and increased gene expression of the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway in murine myotubes, thereby reducing protein degradation (31). PIF inhibits protein synthesis in murine myotubes by 50% and HMB attenuates this depression in protein synthesis (29). Eley et al demonstrated that HMB increases protein synthesis by a number of mechanisms, including the down-regulation of eukaryotic initiation factor 2 (eIF2) phosphorylation through an effect on dsRNA-dependant protein kinase (PKR) and upregulation of the mammalian target of rapamycin/70-kDa ribosomal S6 kinase (mTOR/p70S6k) pathway. The net result is increased phosphorylation of 4E-binding protein (4E-BP1) and an increase in the active eIF4GeIF4E complex. Leucine shares many of these mechanisms with HMB, but HMB appears to be more potent in stimulating protein synthesis (29).
HMB can also increase protein synthesis by attenuating the common pathway that mediates the effects of other catabolic factors such as lipopolysaccharide (LPS), tumor necrosis factor-α/interferon-γ (TNF-α/IFN-γ), and angiotensin II (Ang II) (32, 33). HMB acts by attenuating the activation of caspases-3 and -8, and the subsequent attenuation of the activation of PKR and reactive oxygen species (ROS) formation via down-regulation of p38 mitogen activated protein kinase (p38MAPK). Increased ROS formation is known to induce protein degradation through the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway. HMB accomplishes this attenuation through the autophosphorylation PKR and the subsequent phosphorylation of eIF2a, and in part, through the activation of the mTOR pathway.
Numerous studies have shown an effective dose of HMB to be 3.0 grams per day as CaHMB (˜38 mg/kg body weight-day−1). This dosage increases muscle mass and strength gains associated with resistance training, while minimizing muscle damage associated with strenuous exercise (34) (4, 23, 26). HMB has been tested for safety, showing no side effects in healthy young or old adults (35-37). HMB in combination with L-arginine and L-glutamine has also been shown to be safe when supplemented to AIDS and cancer patients (38).
Studies in humans have also shown that dietary supplementation with 3 grams of CaHMB per day plus amino acids attenuates the loss of muscle mass in various conditions such as cancer and AIDS. (3, 4, 26, 34, 39, 40) A meta-analysis of supplements to increase lean mass and strength with weight training showed HMB to be one of only 2 dietary supplements that increase lean mass and strength with exercise (34). More recently it was shown that HMB and the amino acids arginine and lysine increased lean mass in a non-exercising, elderly population over a year-long study.
Vitamin D
Vitamin D has classically been associated with calcium and phosphorous metabolism and bone strength. Until recently, an adequate Vitamin D level has been defined using the Vitamin D deficiency disease rickets. While 1,25OH2-VitD3 is the active metabolite of Vitamin D, a measure of Vitamin D status widely accepted is serum (blood) circulating 25OH-VitD3. A circulating blood level between 10 and 15 ng 25OH-VitD3/mL will cause rickets in young children and has been accepted as the deficiency level for Vitamin D. Vitamin D can be synthesized by humans with adequate sun exposure or can be obtained through the diet and through supplements to the diet. Many factors influence the amount and effectiveness of Vitamin D found in the body. These factors include dietary intake, sun exposure, Vitamin D receptor number (VDR), conversion rate from cholecalciferol to 25OH-VitD3 and finally the conversion of 25OH-VitD3 to 1,25OH2-VitD3.
Most of the population in northern latitudes (most of the United States) do not produce Vitamin D in the winter regardless of sun exposure because the sun's ultraviolet B rays do not reach the earth during that time and therefore the only source of Vitamin D is dietary (42). As the 25 hydroxylation occurs in the liver and the 1 hydroxylation occurs primarily in the kidney, these two organs play a large role in determining the circulating levels of Vitamin D, and the functioning of these organs and thus Vitamin D status tends to decrease with age (42).
In a recent review, Holick details research showing that circulating levels of 25OH-VitD3 must reach as high as 30-40 ng/mL before parathyroid hormone (PTH) levels begin to plateau (43). Other researchers have found that increasing 25OH-VitD3 from 20 to 32 ng/mL increased intestinal calcium transport (44). Both of these criteria would point to a 25OH-VitD3 level of 30 ng/mL or greater being required for optimal regulation of calcium metabolism in the body. A recent review by Heaney describes the optimal level of 25OH-VitD3 to be 32 ng/mL or greater for optimal health which takes into account a number of aspects other than bone health and calcium metabolism (45). By these standards, from 40 to 100% of independent elderly men and women are Vitamin D deficient (43).
The 1-alpha, 25-Vitamin D hydroxylase in the kidney has been considered the primary source for synthesis of the circulating active metabolite of Vitamin D, 1,25OH2-VitD3. The activity of this enzyme is regulated on a whole body level by parathyroid hormone (PTH). Regulating 1,25OH2-VitD3 on a whole body level probably does not provide for optimal levels of the active vitamin for all body tissues at one time. Relatively recently tissue specific 1-alpha, 25-Vitamin D hydroxylases have been identified and are thought to mediate autocrine responses of Vitamin D at the tissue specific level (46, 47). Human vascular smooth muscle has 1-alpha, 25-Vitamin D hydroxylase activity with a Km of 25 ng/mL. This means that the enzyme is operating at one half maximal capacity at a 25OH-VitD3 concentration of 25 ng/mL (48). Therefore serum levels of >25 ng/mL may be necessary for optimal active Vitamin D for vascular smooth muscle cells.
Muscle strength declines with age and a recently characterized deficiency symptom of Vitamin D is skeletal muscle weakness (43). Deficiency of Vitamin D and its hormonal effect on muscle mass and strength (sarcopenia) has been described as a risk factor in falls and bone fractures in the elderly (49). Loss of muscle strength has been correlated with a loss of Vitamin D receptors (VDR) in muscle cells (50). Supplemental Vitamin D of at least 800 IU per day may result in a clinically significant increase in VDR in muscle cells which may be in part be the mechanism whereby other studies have shown improvement in body-sway, muscle strength and falling risk were seen with Vitamin D supplementation at this level (51). While this muscular weakness associated with Vitamin D may not be surprising at classical Vitamin D deficiency levels (blood 25OH-VitD3 of <15 ng/mL), Bischoff-Ferrari et al continued to see improvement in lower extremity function up to and beyond 40 ng 25OH-VitD3/mL which are levels well above what previously might have been thought necessary for maximal benefit (52). This observation has been confirmed by other researchers that in fact minimal Vitamin D levels necessary to prevent rickets do not allow for maximal physical performance (53). A recent editorial in American Journal of Clinical Nutrition stated that all the literature available would indicate a 25OH-VitD3 level of at least 30 ng/mL is most optimal for health and disease (54).
While the exact mechanism is still unclear, it is clear that both the active metabolite, 1,25OH2-VitD3 and its precursor, 25OH-VitD3, play a significant role in normal functioning of muscle. Muscle contains VDRs for 1,25OH2-VitD3, found in both the nucleus and at the cell membrane (55-57) and these are also involved in non-specific binding 25OH-VitD3 as well (58). Studies by Haddad and Birge, published in the 1970s, show that feeding D3 to vitamin D deficient rats 7 hours prior to measurement increased protein synthesis as measured by 3H-leucine incorporation into muscle cell proteins. However, when the muscles were removed from the Vitamin D deficient rats and studied, only 25-OH Vit D3 acts directly in the muscles (58-60).
Early clinical evidence pointed to a reversible myopathy associated with Vitamin D deficiency (61). Vitamin D receptors were discovered in muscle tissue, thus providing direct evidence of Vitamin D's effect on muscle function (51, 62). Muscle biopsies in adults with Vitamin D deficiency exhibit mainly type II muscle fiber atrophy (63). Type II fibers are important because they are the first initiated to prevent a fall. A recent randomized controlled study found that daily supplementation of 1,000 IU of Vitamin D2 in elderly stroke survivors resulted in an increase in mean type II fiber diameter and in percentage of type II fibers (64). There was also a correlation between serum 25OH-VitD3 level and type II fiber diameter.
Vitamin D conveys its action by binding to VDR. VDR is expressed in particular stages of differentiation from myoblast to myotubes (55, 65, 66). Two different VDRs have been described. One is located at the nucleus and acts as a nuclear receptor and the other is located at the cell membrane and acts as a cellular receptor. VDR knockout mice are characterized by a reduction in both body weight and size as well as impaired motor coordination (67). The nuclear VDR is a ligand-dependent nuclear transcription factor that belongs to the steroid-thyroid hormone receptor gene superfamily (68). Bischoff et al (69) reported the first in situ detection of VDR in human muscle tissue with significant associated intranuclear staining for VDR. Once 1,25OH2-VitD3 binds to its nuclear receptor, it causes changes in mRNA transcription and subsequent protein synthesis (70). The genomic pathway has been known to influence muscle calcium uptake, phosphate transport across the cell membrane, phospholipid metabolism, and muscle cell proliferation and differentiation. 1,25OH-VitD3 regulates muscle calcium uptake by modulating the activity of calcium pumps in sacroplasmic reticulum and sacrolemma (61). Modifications of calcium levels impact muscle function (71). In vitro experiments support these findings by demonstrating an increased uptake of 45Ca in cells exposed to physiological levels of 1,25OH2-VitD3 (72). The calcium binding protein calbindin D-9K is synthesized as a result of activation of nuclear VDR (62). 1,25OH2-VitD3 plays a role in regulating phosphate metabolism in myoblasts by accelerating phosphate uptake and accumulation in cells. 1,25OH2-VitD3 acts rapidly, presumably through cell membrane VDRs (56, 57). While binding to these receptors, there is an activation of second-messenger pathways (G-proteins, cAMP, inositol triphosphate, arachidonic acid) (73-75) or the phosphorylation of intracellular proteins. These would in turn activate protein kinase C (PKC), leading to release of calcium into muscle cells, and ultimately resulting in active transport of Ca into the sacroplasmic reticulum by Ca-ATPase. This process is important for muscle contraction. Additionally, PKC affects enhancements of protein synthesis in muscle cells (76). Recent data (77) indicate that 1,25OH-VitD3 has a fast activation of mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) signaling pathways, which in turn forward signals to their intracellular targets that effect the initiation of myogenesis, cell proliferation, differentiation, or apoptosis.
Vitamin D may also regulate formation and regeneration of tight junctions and neuromuscular junctions. In vitro studies that found that Vitamin D regulates expression of VDR and the neural growth factor (NGF) in Schwann cells (78). Recent studies have shown that Vitamin D enhances glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) in rats and that this may have beneficial effects in neurodegenerative disease (79). Therefore, Vitamin D could act through several mechanisms of cellular function and neural interaction to improve overall muscle strength and function.
A need exists for a composition and methods to increase muscle mass and improve function and strength. The present invention comprises a composition and methods of using a combination of Vitamin D and HMB that results in such an increase in muscle mass and improvements in strength and function. The present invention comprises a composition and methods of using a combination of HMB and Vitamin D to control progressive loss of lean muscle mass, including loss of muscle mass due to aging.
One object of the present invention is to provide a composition for increasing muscle mass, strength, or functionality.
Another object of the present invention is to provide methods of administering a composition for increasing muscle mass, strength or functionality.
A further object of the present invention is to provide methods of optimizing the efficacy of HMB for increasing muscle mass, and improving strength and muscle function by raising a mammal's blood serum levels of vitamin D to at least 25 ng/ml.
An additional object of the present invention is to provide methods of optimizing the efficacy of HMB for increasing muscle mass, and improving strength and muscle function by raising a mammal's blood serum levels of vitamin D to at least 30 ng/ml.
Another object of the present invention is to provide a composition and methods of use of the composition for increasing muscle mass, improving muscle function, improving physical function and/or improving strength without requiring exercise.
These and other objects of the present invention will become apparent to those skilled in the art upon reference to the following specification, drawings, and claims.
The present invention intends to overcome the difficulties encountered heretofore. To that end, a composition comprising HMB and Vitamin D is provided. The composition is administered to a subject in need thereof to increase muscle mass, strength and functionality. All methods comprise administering to the animal HMB and Vitamin D.
The present invention comprises a combination of HMB and Vitamin D that has a synergistic effect and improves overall muscle strength and function. The combination of HMB and Vitamin D results in significant enhancements in overall muscle mass, function and strength. This combination can be used on all age groups seeking enhancement in overall muscle mass, function and strength. The following methods describe and show increased overall muscle mass, function and strength even in non-exercising animals.
The present invention comprises a combination of HMB and Vitamin D. Vitamin D is administered with HMB to optimize the efficacy of HMB, as it has been unexpectedly and surprisingly discovered that optimal effectiveness of HMB for increasing muscle mass, and improving muscle function and/or muscle strength occurs when a mammal has blood serum levels of Vitamin D of at least about 25 ng/ml, including 26 ng/ml, 27 ng/ml, 28 ng/ml, 29 ng/ml, 30 ng/ml, 31 ng/ml and higher.
One specific use HMB and Vitamin D is in the older or elderly population. Current estimates place a large portion of the older population at risk for falls with potential significant associated morbidities. The combination of HMB and Vitamin D specifically targets muscle mass, strength and function and consequently may produce significant improvement in health, quality of life, and in particular, decreased falls and injury in this group. The strength and functionality tests and indices described herein, including but not limited to the hand grip test, the timed get up and go test and the get up test are correlated with improved quality of life, including the ability to carry out daily activities such as climbing stairs and carrying groceries. Improved muscle function and/or strength results in increased energy.
The younger population also benefits from the administration of HMB and Vitamin D, in part due to the widespread occurrence of Vitamin D deficiency. Women also benefit from the administration of HMB and Vitamin D as women are prone to Vitamin D deficiency.
Newborn babies and children twelve months and younger can benefit from the administration of HMB and Vitamin D. Baby formula is Vitamin D fortified, and the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends that all infants, children and adolescents take in enough Vitamin D through supplements, formula or cow's milk to prevent complications from deficiency of this vitamin.
An additional specific use of HMB and vitamin D is in non-human animals, including but not limited to pets such as dogs, cats, and horses.
The present invention provides a composition comprising HMB and Vitamin D. The composition is administered to an animal in need of improvement in overall muscle mass, strength or function. As used herein, muscle function includes muscle performance, muscle strength, physical performance and physical functionality.
The composition of HMB and Vitamin D is administered to an animal in any suitable manner. Acceptable forms include, but are not limited to, solids, such as tablets or capsules, and liquids, such as enteral or intravenous solutions. Also, the composition can be administered utilizing any pharmaceutically acceptable carrier. Pharmaceutically acceptable carriers are well known in the art and examples of such carriers include various starches and saline solutions. In the preferred embodiment, the composition is administered in an edible form.
The composition of HMB and Vitamin D includes administration of the composition as baby formula and nutrition drinks for all ages.
B-hydroxy-β-methylbutyric acid, or β-hydroxy-isovaleric acid, can be represented in its free acid form as (CH3)2(OH)CCH2COOH. The term “HMB” refers to the compound having the foregoing chemical formula, in both its free acid and salt forms, and derivatives thereof. While any form of HMB can be used within the context of the present invention, preferably HMB is selected from the group comprising a free acid, a salt, an ester, and a lactone. HMB esters include methyl and ethyl esters. HMB lactones include isovalaryl lactone. HMB salts include sodium salt, potassium salt, chromium salt, calcium salt, magnesium salt, alkali metal salts, and earth metal salts.
Methods for producing HMB and its derivatives are well-known in the art. For example, HMB can be synthesized by oxidation of diacetone alcohol. One suitable procedure is described by Coffman et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 80: 2882-2887 (1958). As described therein, HMB is synthesized by an alkaline sodium hypochlorite oxidation of diacetone alcohol. The product is recovered in free acid form, which can be converted to a salt. For example, HMB can be prepared as its calcium salt by a procedure similar to that of Coffman et al. in which the free acid of HMB is neutralized with calcium hydroxide and recovered by crystallization from an aqueous ethanol solution. The calcium salt of HMB is commercially available from Metabolic Technologies, Ames, Iowa.
CaHMB has historically been the preferred delivery form of HMB. Previously, numerous obstacles existed to both extensive testing and commercial utilization of the free acid form of HMB, and since it was thought there was no difference between the two forms from a pharmacokinetic perspective, the calcium salt was adopted as a commercial source of HMB. Until recently packaging and, in particular, distribution of dietary supplements has been better suited to handle nutrients in a powdered form and therefore the calcium salt of HMB was widely accepted. HMB-acid is a liquid and much more difficult to deliver or incorporate into products.
Currently, the manufacturing process for HMB has allowed for HMB free acid to be produced in a purity that allows for oral ingestion of the HMB free acid. Besides having a commercial source that is pure enough for oral ingestion, the HMB-acid needs to be buffered for oral ingestion, a process which only recently was determined due to the factors listed above which precluded previous use of HMB-acid.
It was assumed that ingestion of CaHMB would result in a rather quick dissociation of HMB from the calcium salt form. However, a recent study and corresponding patent application (U.S. App. Publication No. 20120053240) has shown that HMB in the free acid form has rather unique pharmacokinetic effects when compared to CaHMB ingestion. Use of HMB free acid (also called HMB-acid) improves HMB availability to tissues and thus provides a more rapid and efficient method to get HMB to the tissues than administration of CaHMB.
Vitamin D is present in the composition in any form. In the preferred embodiment, Vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol) is administered, but the invention is not limited to that form of Vitamin D. While Vitamin D3 is the synthesized and preferred form of Vitamin D for mammals, mammals can also use supplemental Vitamin D2. Vitamin D2 may be less potent than Vitamin D3, hence additional D2 may be required in order to raise blood levels of 25-OH VitD2.
When the composition is administered orally in an edible form, the composition is preferably in the form of a foodstuff or pharmaceutical medium, more preferably in the form of a foodstuff. Any suitable foodstuff comprising the composition can be utilized within the context of the present invention. In order to prepare the composition as a foodstuff, the composition will normally be blended with the appropriate foodstuff in such a way that the composition is substantially uniformly distributed in the foodstuff. Alternatively, the composition can be dissolved in a liquid, such as water. The composition can be incorporated into emulsions, such as a liquid or slurry containing protein, fats, vitamins, and/or minerals, etc. The composition can also be incorporated into a substantially clear liquid containing protein, fats, vitamins, and/or minerals, etc. The composition can be a powder, tablet, gelcap, capsule, etc. Although any suitable pharmaceutical medium comprising the composition can be utilized within the context of the present invention, preferably, the composition is blended with a suitable pharmaceutical carrier, such as dextrose or sucrose, and is subsequently tabulated or encapsulated as described above.
Furthermore, the composition can be intravenously administered in any suitable manner. For administration via intravenous infusion, the composition is preferably in a water-soluble non-toxic form. Intravenous administration is particularly suitable for hospitalized patients that are undergoing intravenous (IV) therapy. For example, the composition can be dissolved in an IV solution (e.g., a saline or glucose solution) being administered to the patient. Also, the composition can be added to nutritional IV solutions, which may include amino acids and/or lipids. The amounts of the composition to be administered intravenously can be similar to levels used in oral administration. Intravenous infusion may be more controlled and accurate than oral administration.
The HMB itself can be present in any form. For example, CaHMB is typically a powder that can be incorporated into any delivery form, while HMB-acid is typically a liquid or gel that can be incorporated into any delivery form. Non-limiting examples of delivery forms include pills, tablets, capsules, gelcaps, liquids, beverages, solids and gels. For animals such as companion animals, HMB and vitamin D can be incorporated into feed, including commercial pet food, chews, and/or treats, along with the previously listed delivery forms.
Methods of calculating the frequency by which the composition is administered are well-known in the art and any suitable frequency of administration can be used within the context of the present invention (e.g., one 6 g dose per day or two 3 g doses per day) and over any suitable time period (e.g., a single dose can be administered over a five minute time period or over a one hour time period, or, alternatively, multiple doses can be administered over an eight week time period). The combination of HMB and Vitamin D can be administered over an extended period of time, such as months or years.
It will be understood by one of ordinary skill in the art that HMB and Vitamin D do not have to be administered in the same composition to perform the claimed methods. Stated another way, separate capsules, pills, mixtures, etc. of Vitamin D and of HMB may be administered to a subject to carry out the claimed methods. In the instance of non-human animals such as dogs and cats, where commercial food sources have the animal's total daily requirement of vitamin D, supplementation with a separate source of HMB, such as HMB in the form of a treat, chew, pill, capsule, tablet, etc. without vitamin D is within the scope of the present invention.
Any suitable dose of HMB can be used within the context of the present invention. Methods of calculating proper doses are well known in the art. The dosage amount of HMB can be expressed in terms of corresponding mole amount of Ca-HMB. The dosage range within which HMB may be administered orally or intravenously is within the range from 0.01 to 0.2 grams HMB (Ca-HMB) per kilogram of body weight per 24 hours. For adults, assuming body weights of from about 100 to 200 lbs., the dosage amount orally or intravenously of HMB (Ca-HMB basis) can range from 0.5 to 30 grams per subject per 24 hours. For animals such as dogs and cats, the dosage range within which HMB may be administered is within the range from 10-160 mg/kg body weight per day, although there is no need to limit the amount to below 160 mg/kg. An optimal amount of HMB for dogs is around 38 mg/kg, while an optimal amount of HMB for cats is around 80 mg/kg. It is understood that HMB may be administered across the entire range described herein within the scope of the invention.
The amount of Vitamin D in the composition can be selecting an amount of Vitamin D within the range of greater than 500 IU, as the below examples indicate that 500 IU is the lower threshold for an effective amount in individuals with inadequate levels of Vitamin D in the bloodstream, yet not too much Vitamin D as to be toxic. While the examples indicate a threshold of 500 IU, lower amounts such as 400 IU, may be appropriate, in some individuals, to raise blood Vitamin D levels to an appropriate amount. In another embodiment, the amount of Vitamin D in the composition can be selecting an amount of Vitamin D within the range of greater than 400 IU, yet not too much Vitamin D as to be toxic. The toxic level of vitamin D is a person-specific amount and depends on a person's blood level of vitamin D. For example, administration of 100,000 IU of vitamin D may be toxic for healthy individuals, but not toxic for a person suffering from rickets. One of skill in the art will recognize toxicity levels for an individual. Further, the composition may include Vitamin D in amounts sufficient to raise blood levels of Vitamin D to at least around 25 ng/ml.
In the preferred embodiment, the composition comprises HMB in the form of its calcium salt, and Vitamin D in the form of 25-OH Vit D3. Preferably, a composition in accordance with the present invention comprises HMB in an amount from about 0.5 g to about 30 g and Vitamin D in an amount greater than 500 IU, but not in an amount high enough to be toxic. One range of Vitamin D in accordance with this invention is around 1000 IU to around 4000 IU. For examples, 1001 IU, 1002 IU, 1003 IU . . . 1995 IU, 1996 IU, 1997 IU, 1998 IU, 1999 IU, 2000 IU, 2001 IU, 2002 IU, 2003 IU, 2004 IU, 2005 IU . . . 0.3997 IU, 3998 IU, 3999 IU, and all numbers between around 1000 IU and 4000 iU and not otherwise stated.
In another example, a range of Vitamin D in accordance with this invention is around 400 IU to around 100,000 IU. The specific amount of vitamin D that is appropriate to administer to a particular individual routinely varies. A healthy individual likely requires supplementation with vitamin D in an amount lower than an individual with certain disease conditions. For example, it would be appropriate in some circumstances to administer vitamin D to an individual with rickets in an amount of 100,000 IU daily. One of skill in the art is able to readily determine the amount of vitamin D that should be given to a particular individual without causing toxicity.
The amount of vitamin D used in the present invention depends on the individual's vitamin D status. In some individuals, around 400-500 IU of vitamin D is all that would be required to achieve a serum blood level of around 25 ng/ml. In others, 2,000, 4,000 or even 100,000 IU of vitamin D may be required. For example, 400 IU, 40 IU, 405 IU, 450 IU, 500 IU, 550 IU, 1000 IU, 1001 IU, 2000 IU, 5000 IU, 10,000 IU, 20,000 IU, 50,000 IU, 75,000 IU and 100,000 IU and all numbers around and between 400 IU and 100,000 IU that have not been otherwise stated are included in this invention.
The Food and Nutrition Board at the Institute of Medicine of The National Academies has developed intake reference values for Vitamin D and other nutrients. These values include the Recommended Dietary Allowance (“RDA”), which is defined as the average daily level of intake sufficient to meet the nutrient requirements of nearly all (97%-98%) healthy people; and Adequate Intake (“AI”), which is established when evidence is insufficient to develop an RDA and is set at a level assumed to ensure nutritional adequacy. The RDA for Vitamin D is currently set at 600 IU, or 15 mcg, for males and females ages 1-70. For people over the age of 70, the RDA is set at 800 IU of vitamin D (20 mcg). For babies from 0-12 months, an AI has been established of 400 IU (10 mcg).
Daily Values (DVs) are established by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and are used on food and dietary supplement labels. DVs suggest how much of a nutrient serving of the food or supplement provides in the context of a total daily diet. DVs are presented on food and supplement labels as a percentage. The Daily Value for Vitamin D, based on a caloric intake of 2,000 calories, for adults and children age 4 years or more, is 400 IU. The Daily Value for Vitamin D is also 400 IU for infants, children less than 4 years old, and pregnant and lactating women.
These amounts are determined such that a large percentage of the population taking these amounts will have sufficient Vitamin D levels. Heaney et al. have determined that a dose of 400 IU per day will elevate serum 25(OH)D3 levels by 7.0 nmol/L (or 2.8 ng/mL) (99).
In one example of the present invention, the amount of vitamin D used can be expressed in terms of the Recommended Dietary Allowance (RDA), Adequate Intake (AI), and/or Daily Value (DV). For example, the present invention includes compositions of HMB and Vitamin D in an amount around at least as much as the Recommended Daily Allowance of RDA; compositions of HMB and Vitamin D in an amount around at least as much as the Daily Value; and compositions of HMB and Vitamin D in an amount around at least as much as the Adequate Intake.
The amount of vitamin D needed to reach appropriate blood serum levels of vitamin D in accordance with the present invention may routinely vary from person to person, and determination of the optimum amount in each instance can be readily obtained by routine procedures. “Person” is defined to include non-human animals, as well as humans.
The National Research Council has established recommended vitamin intake amounts for eats and dogs. Requirements expressed relative to dry matter change with the energy density of the diet. In addition, nutritional requirements can change, with body weight. The following table illustrates the vitamin D requirement of a mature dog of normal activity.
Similarly, the National Research Council has also published vitamin D recommendations for cats, as shown in Table 3.
Further, vitamin D adequacy in canines is similar to the level considered adequate for humans. For example, the prevalence of cancer in dogs has been found to be significantly increased if the serum blood levels of Vitamin D are below 40 ng/ml, which correlates with research in humans indicating an increased risk for many cancers in individuals with Vitamin D levels below 40 ng/ml. With respect to adequacy as it relates to the present invention and as described for humans, adequacy for companion animals, including dogs, as included in this invention, is a circulating blood level of Vitamin D of at least about 25 ng/ml.
Additionally, adequate amounts of Vitamin D in canines and felines can be determined based on the Recommended Daily Allowance, for Vitamin D in humans, which is 600 IU per day. In the United States the average human is approximately 81 kg, therefore the recommended human dosage would be approximately 7.41 IU of vitamin D per kg body weight. The National Research Council (NRC) daily recommended intake for vitamin D in dogs is based upon the formula 0.45 μg*Body weight0.75. For dogs, vitamin D may be supplemented from about 5 IU to about 20 IU/kg body weight. For cats, vitamin D may be supplemented from about 1.9 to 7.6 kg/body weight. Vitamin D may be included in any amount sufficient to raise circulating blood levels of Vitamin D to at least about 25 ng/ml.
In an additional embodiment, the composition in accordance with the present invention comprises HMB in an amount from about 0.5 g to about 30 g and Vitamin D in an amount sufficient to increase circulating blood levels of 25OH-VitD3 or 25-OH VitD2, depending on the form supplemented, to at least about 25 ng/ml.
In general, an amount of HMB and vitamin D in the levels sufficient to improve overall muscle strength, function, and overall mass is administered for an effective period of time.
The invention provides a method of administering a composition of HMB and Vitamin D to an animal such that the animal's muscle mass increases. The animal may or may not engage in exercise. Exercising in conjunction with the administration of HMB and Vitamin D results in an even greater improvement in strength and muscle function, but exercise is not necessary to improve strength and muscle function. The amount of HMB and Vitamin D in the composition administered that are effective for increasing the animal's muscle mass can be determined in accordance with methods well-known in the art. In one embodiment, the effective amount of HMB in the composition may be from about 0.5 g to about 30 g and the effective amount of Vitamin D in the composition may be from greater than about 500 IU per 24 hour period. In another embodiment, the effective amount of HMB is the same, and the effective amount of Vitamin D is that which is sufficient to increase blood levels of Vitamin D to at least about 25 ng/ml.
The invention provides a method of administering a composition of HMB and Vitamin D to an animal such that the animal's strength increases. The animal may or may not engage in exercise. The amount of HMB and Vitamin D in the composition administered that are effective for increasing the animal's muscle mass can be determined in accordance with methods well-known in the art. In one embodiment, the effective amount of HMB in the composition may be from about 0.5 g to about 30 g and the effective amount of Vitamin D in the composition may be from greater than about 500 IU per 24 hour period. In another embodiment, the effective amount of HMB is the same, and the effective amount of Vitamin D is that which is sufficient to increase blood levels of Vitamin D to at least about 25 ng/ml.
The invention further comprises a method of administering a composition of HMB and Vitamin D in an effective amount for improving muscle function. The amount of HMB and Vitamin D in the composition administered that are effective for increasing the animal's muscle mass can be determined in accordance with methods well-known in the art. In one embodiment, the effective amount of HMB in the composition may be from about 0.5 g to about 30 g and the effective amount of Vitamin D in the composition may be from greater than about 500 IU. In another embodiment, the effective amount of HMB is the same, and the effective amount of Vitamin D is that which is sufficient to increase blood levels of Vitamin D to at least about 25 ng/ml, 26 ng/ml, 27 ng/ml, 28 ng/ml, 29 ng/ml, 30 ng/ml, 31 ng/ml and/or higher.
The following examples further illustrate the invention but should not be construed as in any way limiting its scope. For example, the amounts of HMB and Vitamin D administered and the duration of the supplementation are not limited to what is described in the examples. The amount of Vitamin D used in certain experimental examples was 2000 IU per day. This amount of Vitamin D was used to quickly raise blood serum levels of Vitamin D to at least around 25 ng/mL, but the invention is not limited to this amount. Any amount of Vitamin D sufficient to raise blood serum levels to at least around 25 ng/mL, including at least around 30 ng/L, is within the scope of the invention. Amounts of Vitamin D included in this invention include 500 IU per day, 2000 IU per day, 4000 IU per day, and any amount of Vitamin D per day between 500 IU per day and 4000 IU per day.
These examples demonstrate the surprising result that the combination of vitamin D and HMB improves strength and muscle function. It was previously known that HMB supplementation increases muscle mass, but no corresponding improvement in strength and muscle function was seen with HMB alone. The examples demonstrate that when serum levels of Vitamin D reach appropriate levels, most typically through supplementation, muscle strength and function improve. The increases in strength, muscle mass, and improved muscle function described and observed in the examples below demonstrate that HMB and Vitamin D are synergistic; when vitamin D levels reach an adequate amount, administration of HMB works better, more effectively or more efficiently than HMB when administered without adequate vitamin D levels. A composition containing HMB and Vitamin D in sufficient amounts will be more efficient and more effective than a composition containing HMB that does not also include adequate amounts of Vitamin D. The studies below examine the effects of vitamin D levels on the efficacy of HMB as related to muscle function, strength and muscle mass, but the improved efficacy of HMB as described in this invention includes all known uses of HMB, including but not limited to the use of HMB for disease associated wasting, aging, cachexia, and nitrogen retention. Further, the efficacy of HMB as related to immune function and lowering cholesterol are also within the scope of this agreement.
It is known that administration of HMB and amino acids, specifically arginine and lysine, administered to the non-exercising population results in significant increases in lean mass and improvement in protein turnover. Due to the increases in lean mass and improvement in protein turnover, it would be expected that administration of HMB and amino acids would also improve strength and function. Administration of HMB and amino acids alone, however, does not result in improvement in strength, function, or both. Instead, a gradual loss of handgrip and leg strength is observed. The following example demonstrates that the amount of Vitamin D in the bloodstream affects whether administration of HMB shows improvement in muscle strength and/or function. The data demonstrate that administration of HMB, arginine, and lysine (HMB/ARG/LYS) and Vitamin D is superior to administration of either HMB/ARG/LYS alone or Vitamin D alone. These results show a synergistic effect between HMB and Vitamin D for improving muscle strength and function.
Methods
The effects of HMB, arginine, and lysine (HMB/ARG/LYS) on strength and muscle function in the elderly was studied in both elderly men (n=38) and women (n=39) with an average age of 76.0±1.6 years (80). Subjects were randomly assigned to either treatment with HMB/ARG/LYS (n=40) or to an isonitrogenous control group (n=37) for a one year study. Supplements were taken once per day in the morning with breakfast and all supplements supplied 0.1 g ascorbic acid per day. The HMB/ARG/LYS contained 2 g CaHMB, 5 g arginine, and 1.5 g lysine. The control contained 5.6 g alanine, 0.9 g glutamic acid, 3.1 g glycine, and 2.2 g serine. The supplements were supplied as a ready to mix orange-flavored powder. Subjects weighing more than 68 kg were given supplements containing 1.5 times the dosage above to maintain close to 38 mg/kg body weight per day CaHMB intake as this has been shown to be an effective intake of HMB per day. Lean tissue mass was measured using two independent methods, bioelectrical-impedance analysis (BIA) and dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA). Strength was measured in the upper and lower extremities.
The retrospective analysis of serum 25OH-VitD3 in the same cohort was performed and the data were stratified based upon the Vitamin D status of the subjects within each original treatment group. An “adequate Vitamin D status” was defined as serum 25OH-VitD3 level of >30 ng/mL (82-84). Consequently four cohorts were identified: (1) control-subjects with a 25OH-VitD3 level <30 ng/mL (n=25); (2) HMB/ARG/LYS subjects with a 25OH-VitD3 level <30 ng/mL (n=29); (3) control subjects with a 25OH-VitD3 level >30 ng/mL (n=12); and (4) HMB/ARG/LYS subjects with a 25OH-VitD3 level >30 ng/mL (n=11).
Statistics
The data, means and changes in means over the 12-month period, were analyzed using a mixed models procedure of the Statistical Analysis System for Windows (Release 8.02, SAS Institute, Cary, N.C.). A repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) that included the initial time 0 values for the variable measured as a covariate and main effects of site, gender, and treatment. Lean body mass was analyzed using linear and quadratic time by treatment contrasts.
Results and Analysis
Supplementation with HMB/ARG/LYS resulted in statistically significant increases in muscle mass irrespective of the Vitamin D status (
Taken together, these results suggest a synergistic effect between the HMB-supplemented cocktail and Vitamin D. Although HMB/ARG/LYS supplementation increased muscle mass (fat-free-mass) regardless of Vitamin D status, strength was only increased with HMB/ARG/LYS supplementation when subjects had adequate Vitamin D status.
The combination of HMB/ARG/LYS and adequate Vitamin D status is necessary for and superior to either HMB/ARG/LYS alone or adequate Vitamin D alone based upon the controls with adequate Vitamin D in improving the strength and functionality of muscle. These results show a synergistic effect between HMB and Vitamin D for improving muscle strength and function.
Prior studies examining the effect of HMB on increasing muscle mass were not significantly improved in all study designs (published and unpublished). It is believed that Vitamin D status may not have been adequate to maximize muscle mass gains in these earlier studies in the HMB-supplemented subjects. This may be especially true in populations where low vitamin D status due to age, geographical location, dietary intake, or disease was in question. Consequently, supplementation with a combination of HMB and Vitamin D may not only increase muscle strength and functionality but also restore or increase muscle mass compared to supplementation of HMB alone.
In this example, subjects were administered a combination of HMB and vitamin supplements.
Materials and Methods: Elderly women (n=30) and men (n=16) were recruited into a double-blinded controlled study. The older adults were recruited from two locations in South Dakota: Brookings and Sioux Falls. The subjects underwent an initial screening and were randomized to treatments. Testing consisted of an initial (0 weeks) and follow-up testing at 4, 8 and 12 weeks over the course of the 12-week study.
Prior to the start of the experimental period, we randomly assigned nutritional supplements to each subject using computer-generated random numbers in a double-blind fashion. Treatments were arranged in a 2×2 factorial design with two levels of HMB (0 & 3.0 g/d) and two levels of Vitamin D (0 & 2,000 IU/d). We assigned subjects to one of the following four treatments:
(1) Control
(2) HMB (calcium salt), 3.0 g/day
(3) 2,000 IU Vitamin D/day
(4) HMB, 3.0 g/day+2,000 IU Vitamin D.
The treatments were supplied in capsules of equal size and color and contained equal amounts of calcium and phosphorus. The subjects were instructed to take three capsules two times a day. Each subject was supplied with a one-week supply of the supplement, allocated by subject number and returned each week for an additional 1-week supply.
The exercise testing and training session was supervised by trained research associates. Resting heart rate and blood pressure measurements were obtained prior to strength measurements. Enrolled individuals participated in an exercise training program consisting of strength training exercises with Theraband® stretch cords (resistance training) and jumping. The equipment consisted of items that can easily be used at home. Exercise sessions were 3 times a week for 12 weeks. Each exercise session was about 45-60 minutes. Testing sessions were performed at 0, 4, 8, and 12 weeks. Each testing session lasted ˜60 minutes.
The strength program incorporated the following exercises: bicep curls, triceps extensions, chair squats, calf raises, ankle dorsiflexion, shoulder front raises and lateral raises, latissimus dorsi pull-down, chest press, seated row, knee flexion and extension, and hip flexion. For each of the 12 exercises, the participants completed 3 sets of isotonic movement, 2 sets of 20 repetitions, and a final set to failure. When the 3rd set could be performed for 20 repetitions in good form, the resistance was increased by moving to the next color of the resistance band. Between each set, participants performed a set of hops or small jumps. Initially, 5 hops/jumps were performed following each set. The number of hops/jumps was increased by 5 every 3 weeks until 25 hops/jumps were achieved. Subjects remained at 25 hops/jumps between sets for the remainder of the study. The number of hops/jumps was reduced or omitted if there are any complaints regarding joint pain. The resistance bands had been shown to safely increase strength and functionality when used in an older adult population (87-90).
Body composition measurements were obtained at 0, 4, 8, and 12 weeks. Measurements of strengths of quadriceps (extension/flexion) and elbows (extension/flexion) were obtained using the BIODEX Isokinetic Dynamometer. Handgrip strength was measured using a handgrip dynamometer. Peak torque for knee extension and flexion was measured at 60, 90 and 120°/sec. Peak torque for elbow extension and flexion was measured at 60 and 120°/sec.
Functionality tests included: “Get-up-and-Go” performance (speed and gate), and “Get-up” performance. The “Get-up-and-Go” test consisted of timed measurements of the subject's starting from a seated position, standing, walking forward 3 meters, turning around, walking back to the chair, and sitting down. The “Get-up” test consisted of the subject standing upright from a seated position as many times as possible within 30 seconds. The complete descriptions and standardization of the tests are outlined in the Physical Dimensions of Aging by Waneen W. Spirduso (Human Kinetics, 1995).
A muscular performance index was calculated by summing the percentage change from baseline for Get-up-and-Go, Get-up, handgrip, peak torque for knee extension and flexion (60, 90 and 120°/sec) and peak torque for elbow extension and flexion (60°/sec).
At 0, 4, 8, and 12 weeks blood samples were taken from a superficial arm vein into Vacutainers™ (Becton Dickinson, Vacutainer Systems, Rutherford, N.J.) after an overnight fast. Serum was collected and used to measure 25OH-VitD3 using a fully automated antibody-based chemiluminescence assay (DiaSorin Inc., Stillwater, Minn.).
Least Squares Mean±SEM were calculated strength and functionality changes in each variable over the 12-week period. The mixed models procedure of the Statistical Analysis System for Windows (Release 9.1, SAS Institute, Cary, N.C.) was used to analyze the data. Analysis of Covariance was used with main effects of HMB, Vitamin D and the HMB*Vitamin D interaction. Data were adjusted using the initial serum 25OH-VitD3 concentration as the covariate. The hypothesize was that the combination of HMB and Vitamin D supplementation will result in a greater improvements in strength and functionality as compared to control, HMB, or Vitamin D-treated subjects. This synergistic effect was tested with pre-planned one-tail t-test in a post-hoc analysis. Statistical significance was determined for p<0.05 and a trend was determined for 0.05<p<0.10.
Results and Discussion: A total of 43 subjects completed the 12-week and one subject completed the 8-weeks of the study and was included in the analysis. Two subjects dropped from the study prior to the 4-week follow-up visit and were not used in the analysis. The subjects that dropped from the study did so because of the demanding commitment of a 12-week training study and not due to any adverse events. The subject characteristics of the 44 subjects used in the analysis are presented in Table 1.
The average 25OH-VitD3 concentration at wk 0 was 26.5 ng/ml. Subjects treated with 2000 IU of Vitamin D per day increased their serum 25OH-VitD3 level by 10.7 ng/mL (
The effects of the combination of HMB and Vitamin D on knee extension strength (peak torque, 60°/sec is presented in
Although not significant the performance index tends supports these observations (see
This experimental example demonstrates the synergistic effect of HMB and Vitamin D on muscle when Vitamin D was supplemented at approximately 24 IU/kg of body weight (2000 IU daily in an average 82.3 kg human). A similar effect of supplemental vitamin D on the muscles of dogs and cats occurs at similar supplemental rates over the minimal required vitamin D dosage.
Implications: These data from a prospective study in older adults support the hypothesis that the combination of HMB and Vitamin D supplementation is synergistic, and resulted in significant improvements in knee muscle strength and overall performance index. These data support the observation from the retrospective study in an elderly population supplemented with HMB, Arginine, and Lysine. Muscular strength increases only occur with HMB, Arginine, and Lysine in older adults with adequate Vitamin D. In conclusion, the combination HMB and Vitamin D is superior to either HMB or Vitamin D alone and is therefore synergistic. These findings are important as the Vitamin D status in approximately 66% of the elderly population is low and leads to a decrease in muscular strength and function. The loss of strength and function leads to an increase in falls and fractures, poor quality of life and will ultimately impact health care costs.
In this example, cell culture studies were performed to analyze the effects of HMB and vitamin D on protein, DNA and protein turnover in muscle cell cultures.
Recent in vitro studies have shown that HMB decreases protein breakdown. In one study HMB attenuated proteolysis-inducing factor (PIF) activation and increased gene expression of the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway in murine myotubes, thereby reducing protein degradation (91). Other studies also suggest HMB may influence protein synthesis through the mTOR pathway (92). Early studies have also suggested that vitamin D affects protein metabolism (93). Vitamin D also binds a VDR found in the nucleus of muscle cells and regulates gene expression (94). We hypothesize that HMB and vitamin D both have effects on muscle cells and that if they act through independent mechanisms there could be a synergistic effect on either protein, DNA or protein turnover in the cells.
Methods
Mouse C2C12 skeletal muscle cell myoblasts were grown in culture under standard conditions and fused into myotubes following the methods of Menconi et al. (95). Four separate studies were conducted during different weeks. The first 3 studies consisted of 4 replicate dishes per treatment and the fourth study consisted of 6 replicate dishes per treatment. The treatments were applied to the cells during the 24 h measurement period. Treatments applied were control, 25OH-VitD3 (200 ng/mL), HMB (200 μM HMB as Ca(HMB)2, and the combination of HMB and 25OH-VitD3. Dexamethasone (100 nM) was added to the culture medium during the treatment/measurement period to stimulate protein degradation. Calcium in the form of calcium chloride was added to the control and 25OH-VitD3 treatments so that all the treatments were balanced for calcium. For measurement of protein degradation during the treatment period, leucine free medium was obtained to which [5,5,5]2H3-leucine was added so that the isotopes of leucine (natural leucine and [1-13C]-leucine) could be measured as they were released into the medium through the protein degradation process. The measurement medium was sampled at 2 and 24 h and samples stored at −80° C. until analyzed. The samples were analyzed for leucine using a gas chromatography (model 6890, Hewlett Packard, Palo, Calif.) mass spectrometry (model 5973, Hewlett Packard, Palo, Calif.) and the gas chromatography column used for the analysis was a Zebron ZB-5. (Phenomenex, Torrence, Calif.). Natural leucine, [1-13C]-leucine, and [5,5,52H3]-leucine were monitored at 302, 303, and 305 AMU, respectively. Corrections for sampling at 2 h and for leucine utilization from the measurement media were made. The amount of the leucine isotopes released was also corrected for utilization (transamination and/or protein synthesis) (96). Concentrations of proteins were analyzed following the microplate assay instructions using a Pierce BCA protein assay kit (Thermo Scientific, Rockford, Ill.). DNA was measured flourometrically using the Quant-iT™ dsDNA assay kit from Invitrogen (Carlsbad, Calif.).
Statistics
Each cell culture dish was considered an experimental unit for analysis. Data presented are least square means and data were analyzed using General Linear Models in the Statistical Analysis System for Windows (Release 8.02, SAS Institute, Cary, N.C.). Main effects of experiment, HMB, vitamin D, and the interaction of HMB and vitamin D were included in the model. Post-hoc least square means analysis was performed for individual treatment means.
Results and Analysis
After the 24 h treatment period there were no treatment main effects on total protein content in the culture dishes. There were no significant treatment main effects for DNA content. Protein:DNA ratio with the combination of HMB and 25OH-VitD3 (
The amount of Vitamin D administered with HMB must be in an effective amount to raise the blood level of Vitamin D. In this example, it is demonstrated that 500 IU of Vitamin D does not sufficiently raise the blood level of Vitamin D; this finding however, is based on the subjects in this study. As stated hereinabove, the amount of Vitamin D necessary to raise blood serum levels of Vitamin D to an adequate amount depends on the individual's Vitamin D status; in some instances, as little as 400 IU of Vitamin D is an appropriate amount to raise blood levels to around at least 25 ng/ml.
Subjects with adequate Vitamin D (plasma 25OH-VitD3 levels >30 ng/ml) manifested significant improvements in muscle function, while those with biochemical evidence of Vitamin D deficiency (25OH-VitD3 levels <30 ng/ml) failed to show improvements in muscle strength and functionality. While muscular weakness associated with Vitamin D may not be surprising at classical Vitamin D deficiency levels (blood 25OH-VitD3 of <15 ng/mL), Bischoff-Ferrari et al continued to see improvement in lower extremity function up to and beyond 40 ng 25OH-VitD3/mL which are levels well above what previously might have been thought necessary for maximal benefit (11). Therefore, supplementation Vitamin D should be adequate to raise 25OH-VitD3.
This 12-month clinical trial employed a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled 2×2 factorial design. The experiment was double-blind with respect to calcium HMB plus Vitamin D3 (HMB+D) and control supplementation. Participants were stratified by sex and assigned to one of four treatment arms using computer-generated random numbers. The treatment arms consisted of: (a) Control+no exercise; (b) HMB+D+no exercise; (c) Control+exercise, and (d) HMB+D+exercise. The clinical trial consisted of multiple measurements over the 12 months. Assessments (except for dual energy x-ray absorptiometry, DXA) were performed at baseline and again at 3, 6, 9, and 12 months. This study was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT02043171).
Participants: Men and women ≥60 years of age with insufficient, but not clinically deficient 25-hydroxy-vitamin D (25OH-D) levels (baseline concentration between 15 and 30 ng/mL) were recruited for this study. Volunteers were solicited from a willing recruitment list, electronic mailings, USPS mailings, and flyers for the study. Participants had a starting BMI of <40 kg/m2, were free of liver and kidney diseases or other serious medical illnesses, had no evidence of uncontrolled hypertension; did not have osteoporosis or a bone density T-score <−2.0 or chronic diseases affecting calcium or bone metabolism; had no history of blood clots and/or the use of blood thinning medications; were able and willing to participate in 3-day-a-week monitored strength-training program; had no major surgery in the previous six weeks, and did not have any restrictions placed on physical exercise by their primary care physician. If at follow-up, a participant had a 25OH-D<12 ng/ml or T-Score<−2.5, the participant was referred to a physician and was dropped from the study.
Nutritional supplements: Supplements consisted of either a placebo (calcium lactate) in the no supplement (control) group or the combination of calcium HMB (3.0 g/day) plus Vitamin D3 (2,000 IU/day) in the supplemented (HMB+D) group. The HMB dosing strategy (3 g/d, split into 2 doses) has been utilized in the majority of previous studies examining the effects of HMB on body composition and physical and function performance in older adults. Vitamin D doses ranging from 800-2000 IU per day have been recommended to achieve a minimum serum 25OH-D of 30 ng/ml at 3 months. The Vitamin D3 dosing strategy (2,000 IU/day, split into 2 doses) was utilized in this study to rapidly increase circulating levels of 25OH-D3 to be within the sufficient range (25-100 ng/ml) where HMB has been previously shown to be efficacious for muscle strength improvements. Both nutritional supplements were provided in capsules of equal size, color, and taste and were produced in a cGMP facility and obtained through TSI Innovative Products Division (Missoula, Mont.). The purity of calcium HMB used in the capsules was determined by the manufacturer using high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) to be greater than 98%. The calcium HMB and Vitamin D3 concentrations of the capsules were verified throughout the study (Heartland Assays, Ames, Iowa). Capsules were consumed twice daily with the morning and evening meals. Both supplements contained equal amounts of calcium (102 mg), phosphorus (26 mg), and potassium (49 mg). Prior to enrollment in the study, participants were instructed to discontinue any supplements containing HMB or vitamin D, but a multivitamin was allowed; this was maintained throughout the study period.
The non-exercises were instructed not to perform resistance exercise during the study period.
Measurements
Body weight and composition: Body weight was measured without shoes following an overnight fast. DXA (Hologic Discovery v.12.3) was used to assess regional body composition (lean and fat mass) and bone density data at 0, 6, and 12 months only. Bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA; BIA-101S, RJL Systems, Clinton Township, Mich.) and air displacement plethysmography (ADP; BOD POD®, LMI, Concord Calif.) (35) were used to measure body composition at all timepoints. BIA data were analyzed using the Fluid & Nutrition Analysis Software, version 3.1b (RJL Systems) (36) and ADP calculations were performed using the Ski equation (37). Previous publications have shown a high correlation between ADP, BIA, and DXA measurements (38).
Muscle Strength: Muscle strength was assessed via isokinetic dynamometry. Bilateral knee and elbow extension/flexion peak torque were measured at multiple speeds (knee: 60, 90, and 180°/sec; elbow: 60 and 120°/sec) using the BIODEX Isokinetic Dynamometer (System 3 Quickset, Shirley, N.Y.). Peak torque generation for each movement and speed were also analyzed independently. Additionally, a total lower composite extremity strength index was calculated to examine the effect of the intervention on overall lower extremity muscle function. Lower Extremity Strength Index=(left leg extension peak torque at 60°/sec+90°/sec+180°/sec)+(right leg extension peak torque at 60°/sec+90°/sec+180°/sec)+(left leg flexion peak torque at 60°/sec+90°/sec+180°/sec)+(right leg flexion peak torque at 60°/sec+90°/sec+180°/sec).
Physical Function: The “Timed Up-and-Go” and “Get-up” tests were used to assess physical function. The “Up-and-Go” test requires the subject to, starting from a seated position, stand, walk forward 3 meters, turn around, walk back to the chair, and sit down as quickly as possible without running (39); three “Up-and-Go” trials were performed, and the average time was recorded. The “Get-up” test (30 second sit to stand) requires the subject to stand up from a seated position as many times as possible within 30 seconds (39). Handgrip strength was measured using a handgrip dynamometer (Lafayette Instrument Co., Lafayette, Ind.); three trials were completed per side, the average for each side was recorded, and the sum of left and right handgrip was used for analysis. A composite functional index was developed to assess improvement across multiple muscle groups and has transitional properties that captures changing improvement in functional status. The index of changes (Composite Functional Index) was calculated as the sum of fractional changes in all functionality measures [left handgrip+right handgrip+Get Up+(−Get Up and Go)].
Dietary Assessment: Food recalls (3 days) were used to estimate vitamin D and nutrient intake at all timepoints. Records were analyzed using the Food Processor (ESHA Research, Salem Oreg.).
Questionnaires: A health form questionnaire, quality of life questionnaire (SF-36 Health Survey) (40), and Circumplex effect questionnaire were completed by participants at each visit. Each participant also maintained a falls calendar.
Compliance: Compliance to the supplement protocol was monitored using participant logs, capsule counts, and by measuring serum 25OH-VitD concentrations.
Results
A total of 591 older adults were screened for this study. Of these, 238 participants were enrolled. A total of 117 participants completed the study and were included in the per-protocol analysis. There were no differences in capsule supplementation and exercise compliance between groups. The average group capsule compliance based on capsule count was 96.0±0.4%.
Vitamin D Status: As designed, HMB+D supplementation resulted in significant increases in circulating total 25OH-D levels, which were maintained throughout the study period (
Body Composition
HMB+D supplementation alone had a significant benefit on lean body mass within the non-exercise group at 6 months (0.44±0.27 in HMB+D vs. −0.33±0.28 in control, p<0.05, d=0.55), which was attributed to improvements in trunk lean mass (Trt main effect, p<0.05). See
A composite functional index was developed to assess improvements across multiple muscle groups [left handgrip+right handgrip+Get Up+(−Get Up and Go)]. The effect of HMB+D supplementation on the functional index was prominent in the non-exercise group. HMB+D supplementation alone resulted in a larger increase in composite functional index than was observed in the control group at 3 months (p=0.03, d=0.58); even greater increases were observed at 6 months (p=0.04, d=0.70) and 12 months (p=0.04, d=0.67), as shown in
The non-exercising, non-supplemented control group generally showed little to no improvement.
In addition, when the supplemented groups (exercise and non-exercise) were combined and compared to the control groups, older adults supplemented with HMB and Vitamin D exhibited a significant treatment functional index overall increase at three, six and twelve months, p<0.05. The Main Treatment Effect probabilities are as follows: 3-month, p=0.03; 6-month p=0.04; 12-month p=0.04. See
The Get Up test was the number of repetitions a participant can stand from a sitting position in a chair in thirty seconds. The GU test results in all participants supplemented with HMB and Vitamin D compared to control are shown in
For the Get Up test in the non-exercise groups, there was a tendency for a main effect of a HMB+D supplementation at 3 months (p=0.065). HMB+D supplementation alone tended to improve performance at 6 months (p=0.071, d=0.49) and significantly improved performance at 12 months (increase of 4.5±0.9 reps in HMB+D vs. 1.7±0.9 reps in control, p=0.03, d=0.61) in non-exercisers. See
The Get Up & Go test is the time (in seconds) that is required for participant stand from a sitting position in a chair, walk forward 3 meters, turn around, return to the chair, and sit down. For this test, a decrease represents an improvement in function. Times were numerically shorter in the CaHMB+VitD group (exercise/non-exercise combined (
In non-exercisers, improvement in knee extension peak torque (60°/sec) was significantly greater in HMB+D supplemented participants than in non-supplemented group at 3 months (10.9±5.7 Nm vs. −5.2±5.9 Nm, respectively, p=0.04) (
In the combined HMB+Vitamin D groups compared to control groups, there tended to be a Treatment effect at 3-months, p=0.06 for knee extension strength (peak torque), as shown in
HMB+D supplementation tended to improve lower extremity strength index values among non-exercisers at 3 months (p=0.10, d=0.45). This tendency persisted at 9 and 12 months (p=0.10 and 0.07, respectively) as shown in
In the combined group, right and left knee extension and flexion index (sum of fractional change) was calculated as follows: =left leg extension strength at 60°/sec+90°/sec+180°/sec+right leg extension strength at 60°/sec+90°/sec+180°/sec+left leg flexion strength at 60°/sec+90°/sec+180°/sec+right leg flexion strength at 60°/sec+90°/sec+180°/sec. There tended to be a treatment effect after 3 months of CaHMB+VitD supplementation compared to the control supplemented subjects (
High activation as measured by the Circumplex questionnaire increased significantly from baseline to 6, 9, and 12 months only in HMB+D-supplemented participants. High activation is described by the following words: aroused, astonished, stimulated, surprised, active, intense. High activation is interpreted as increased feelings of energy, a sign of improved muscle function.
Combined supplementation with HMB and Vitamin D for 12 months was safe and increased circulating levels of 25OH-D to within the sufficient range (25-100 ng/ml) previously shown to support a beneficial effect of HMB on lower body strength. A main finding of this study was that co-supplementation with HMB and Vitamin D to healthy older adults improved the composite functional strength index. These findings underscore the potent effects of supplementation with HMB on improving functionality in healthy older adults with Vitamin D sufficiency, even in the absence of exercise. Further, these findings demonstrate that the effectiveness of HMB is independent of the additional amino acids often included in the nutritional supplement formulas previously shown to be efficacious in older adults.
Skeletal muscle loss and decreased functionality are hallmarks of aging, and if left unattended can result in sarcopenia and loss of essential daily functions necessary for mobility and quality of life. It is well established that sarcopenia is a universal prelude for worsening of multiple chronic diseases and for the development of frailty. Assessment of functionality in this aging population can be quite complex and is one of the greatest challenges to healthcare professionals. The loss of functional status that leads to physical frailty is associated with adverse health outcomes, long-term institutionalization, and mortality. The present study utilized a functional composite index to represent the primary end point of estimating changes in strength and physical function over the one-year period. This index incorporated several tests (Get Up test, the Get Up & Go test, and the handgrip strength test) frequently used to evaluate deficits in common daily function related to muscle strength and/or muscle function. Among the individual functional tests, the largest relative improvement was observed for the Get Up test, which evaluates a common critical function (getting up from a chair); its performance requires muscle strength, power, and balance. There is extensive evidence that exercise training, including both aerobic and resistance exercise, results in improved skeletal muscle strength and mass and balance in older adults; unfortunately, a significant portion of older adults are either unable or unwilling to exercise regularly. In contrast, the evidence for nutritional interventions is at best modest even when combined with exercise, in the presence or absence of sarcopenia. The data supporting the present invention demonstrates that supplementation with both HMB and Vitamin D is crucial for the enhancement of muscle function in non-exercising older adults.
Supplementation with HMB+D resulted in significant improvements in the emotion of “High Activation” on the Circumplex questionnaire. The findings in the current study are related to the improvements in the functional composite index, representing an enhanced state of functional reserve. Such an increase in functional reserve would lessen the relative effort of daily activities (e.g. climbing stairs, carrying groceries), resulting in feeling more energetic. These effects represent another potential cross talk between the improvements in muscle function and the brain, as those seen with exercise, with a consequent beneficial effect by reducing depression-like symptoms. This positive effect has been ascribed to the enhancement in rmuscular expression of the enzyme kynurenine aminotransferase (KAT), which converts neurotoxic KYN into neuroprotective kynurenic acid (KYNA).
The positive long-term effects on functional composite index observed in the supplemented, but non-exercising older adults, are primarily attributed to the benefits of HMB that are fully realized in Vitamin D sufficiency.
This study demonstrates the benefits of co-supplementation with HMB and Vitamin D to enhance physical functionality and muscle strength in adults, even in individuals not engaged in an exercise training program. The combined supplementation with HMB and Vitamin D provides a unique protective effect for the substantial population of older adults who are unable or unwilling to exercise. Supplementation with HMB and vitamin D improves physical performance, including muscle function, even in the absence of exercise. The benefits of HMB+D are valuable in sarcopenic/pre-sarcopenic individuals given their lower baseline functional status. This combination can provide protection against developing sarcopenia in those at risk, including those who are vitamin D deficient. Older people with vitamin D deficiency are extremely exposed to develop sarcopenia, thus providing a further indication for supplementation with HMB and vitamin D.
The foregoing examples demonstrate the use of HMB and Vitamin D to increase muscle mass and/or improve strength and/or improve physical (muscle) function. Vitamin D is supplemented with HMB to optimize and/or maximize the effects of HMB. Vitamin D is supplemented to raise blood serum vitamin D levels to at least 25-30 ng/ml and sustain blood serum levels in a sufficient amount.
The foregoing description and drawings comprise illustrative embodiments of the present inventions. The foregoing embodiments and the methods described herein may vary based on the ability, experience, and preference of those skilled in the art. Merely listing the steps of the method in a certain order does not constitute any limitation on the order of the steps of the method. The foregoing description and drawings merely explain and illustrate the invention, and the invention is not limited thereto, except insofar as the claims are so limited. Those skilled in the art who have the disclosure before them will be able to make modifications and variations therein without departing from the scope of the invention.
This application is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 16/897,945, filed Jun. 10, 2020, which is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 16/903,843, filed Jun. 17, 2020, which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 16/230,375, filed Dec. 21, 2018, which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/648,911, filed Jul. 13, 2017, which is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/869,533, filed Sep. 29, 2015, which is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/861,728, filed Sep. 22, 2015, which is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 14/219,522, filed Mar. 19, 2014, which is a continuation-in-part of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 12/634,507, filed Dec. 9, 2009, which claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/121,065, filed Dec. 9, 2008, and herein incorporates U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/121,065 by reference.
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 61121065 | Dec 2008 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 16230375 | Dec 2018 | US |
| Child | 16897945 | US | |
| Parent | 15648911 | Jul 2017 | US |
| Child | 16230375 | US | |
| Parent | 14869533 | Sep 2015 | US |
| Child | 15648911 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 16897945 | Jun 2020 | US |
| Child | 18095314 | US | |
| Parent | 14861728 | Sep 2015 | US |
| Child | 14869533 | US | |
| Parent | 14219522 | Mar 2014 | US |
| Child | 14861728 | US | |
| Parent | 12634507 | Dec 2009 | US |
| Child | 14219522 | US |
