The present invention relates to flocculation of oil sands fine tailings and dewatering of same using a flocculating polymer and dynamic mixing.
Oil sands are basically a combination of clay, sand, water and bitumen. Oil sands are mined by open pit mining and the bitumen is extracted from the mined oil sand using variations of the Clark Hot Water Process, where water is added to the mined oil sand to produce an oil sand slurry. The oil sand slurry is further processed to separate the bitumen from the rest of the components. The remaining solids, known as tailings, are sent to large ponds where the tailings separate into three primary layers: a top layer which is primarily water that is recycled back to the extraction process; a bottom layer primarily comprised of sand, which easily settles to the bottom; and a middle layer comprised of water, fine clays and hydrocarbons. The middle layer does not settle very quickly, as the clays essentially remain in suspension. Over time, the middle layer creates mature fine tailings or fluid fine tailings (FFT), which have an average solids content of about 30-40 wt %.
As mentioned above, the main issue with FFT is that it will not separate in a reasonable amount of time. In fact, it may take decades for FFT to thicken and dewater. Thus, containment of FFT in a large area is required. Hence, it is desirable to be able to dewater or solidify the FFT so as to be able to more economically dispose of or reclaim the fine tailings.
One recent method for dewatering FFT is disclosed in PCT application WO 2011/032258, which describes in-line addition of a flocculant solution into the flow of oil sands fine tailings, including FFT, through a conduit such as a pipeline. A pipeline reactor is disclosed comprising a co-annular injection device for in-line injection of the flocculating liquid within the oil sands fine tailings. Once the flocculant is dispersed into the oil sands fine tailings, the flocculant and fine tailings continue to mix as it travels through the pipeline and the dispersed fine clays bind together (flocculate) to form larger structures (flocs) that can be efficiently separated from the water when ultimately deposited in a deposition area.
In-line dispersion and mixing is commonly referred to as static mixing and the degree of mixing and shearing is dependent upon the flow rate of the materials through the pipeline. Thus, any changes in the fluid properties or flow rate of the oil sands fine tailings may have an effect on both mixing and shearing and ultimately flocculation. As stated in WO 2011/032258, shear conditioning is managed by adjusting the length of the pipeline through which the flocculated oil sands fine tailings travel prior to deposition. Thus, if one has a static length of pipe, it would be difficult to control flocculation because of the difficulty in independently controlling both the shear rate and residence time simply by changing the flow rate.
Other prior art (e.g., Canadian Patent Application No. 2,512,324) suggest addition of water-soluble polymers to oil sands fine tailings during the transfer of the tailings as a fluid to a deposition area, for example, while the tailings are being transferred through a pipeline or conduit to a deposition site. However, once again, proper mixing of polymer flocculant with tailings is difficult to control due to changes in the flow rate and fluid properties of the tailings material through the pipeline.
It is desirable to have a process which is readily controllable in order to accommodate differing oil sands fine tailings properties and differing flocculant solution properties while still maintaining good mixing and floc structure preservation.
It has been discovered that proper mixing of a flocculant such as a high molecular weight nonionic, anionic, or cationic polymer with oil sands fine tailings such as FFT is critical to creating the right floc structure that will dewater the tailings rapidly. It is contemplated that the present invention can be used in conjunction with centrifugation of the flocculated fine tailings in, for example, decanter centrifuges; thickening of the flocculated fine tailings in thickeners known in the art; accelerated dewatering, or rim ditching, in specially constructed dewatering cells; and “thin lift” operations, where the flocculated fine tailings are spread over an area in a thin layer for rapid dewatering, followed by additional layering and dewatering of flocculated fine tailings.
It has been discovered that using a stirred tank reactor, which is commonly referred to as a dynamic mixer, to continuously mix oil sands fine tailings with a water-soluble flocculating polymer results in a more consistent production of well-defined floc structures which results in good dewatering. In one embodiment, the water-soluble polymer is used as an aqueous solution. Some advantages of using a dynamic mixer include the ability to control the mixing energy input independent of the feed flow rate; it is a more reliable operation; and it results in more robust flocculation performance (i.e., more robust flocs). The ability to control the energy input allows one to obtain the optimal operation regime for floc formation, as above or below the optimal operation regime could result in over-shearing or under-mixing of the mixture of FFT and flocculant solution, both of which result in poor water release.
Further, use of a stirred tank reactor allows the operator to control the mixing time (i.e., residence time) of the flocculant to more readily ensure a more robust flocculation performance without over-shearing or under-mixing.
It is understood that oil sands fine tailings means tailings that are derived from oil sands extraction operations which contain a fines fraction. Fines are generally defined as solids having a diameter less than 44 microns. An example of fines tailings useful in the present invention are mature fine tailings or fluid fine tailings (FFT) from tailings ponds. However, any fine tailings that are obtained from ongoing extraction operations may be used in the present invention. For example, the fine tailings can be obtained from a hydrocyclone. In one embodiment, fine tailings may be combined with coarse particles such as sand prior to treatment in a dynamic mixer.
In one aspect of the invention, a process for flocculating oil sands fine tailings is provided, comprising:
This was discovered that impeller tip speed and mixing time are critical for mixing polymeric flocculant and oil sands fine tailings to produce optimum floc structures for maximum oil sands fine tailings dewatering.
In one embodiment, the removed flocculated oil sands fine tailings are added to at least one centrifuge to dewater the oil sands fine tailings and form a high solids cake and a low solids centrate.
In another embodiment, the removed flocculated oil sands fine tailings are added to a thickener to dewater the oil sands fine tailings and produce thickened oil sands fine tailings and clarified water.
In another embodiment, the removed flocculated oil sands fine tailings are transported to at least one deposition cell for dewatering.
In another embodiment, the removed flocculated oil sands fine tailings are spread as a thin layer onto a deposition site.
The oil sands fine tailings can have a solids content of about 10% to about 70%, more specifically, about 15% to about 45%, in particular when the oil sands fine tailings are fluid fine tailings (FFT). In one embodiment, the FFT are diluted to about 20% solids content.
In one embodiment, the polymeric flocculant is a water soluble polymer having a moderate to high molecular and an intrinsic viscosity of at least about 3 dl/g (measured in 1M NaCl at 25° C.). The polymeric flocculant may be cationic, non-ionic, amphoteric, or anionic. The polymeric flocculant can be in an aqueous solution at a concentration of about between 0.05 and 5% by weight of polymeric flocculant. Typically, the polymeric flocculant solution will be used at a concentration of about 1 g/L to about 5 g/L.
Suitable doses of polymeric flocculant can range from 10 grams to 10,000 grams per tonne of oil sands fine tailings. Preferred doses range from about 400 to about 1,000 grams per tonne of oil sands fine tailings.
In one embodiment, the stirred tank reactor can be either a single stage mixer or a multistage mixer.
a is a photograph of flocculated FFT removed from a dynamic mixer where the impeller speed was 73 RPM.
b is a photograph of flocculated FFT removed from a dynamic mixer where the impeller speed was 112 RPM.
a shows one of sample of treated FFT, where the flocculated FFT showed strong flocs and had a yield stress of 45 Pa and a Capillary Suction Time of 100.6 sec.
b shows another sample of treated FFT, where the flocculated FFT showed much weaker flocs and had a yield stress of only 15.3 Pa and a Capillary Suction Time of 283 sec.
a, 15b and 15c are simulations of FFT and polymer in a dynamic mixer at impeller speeds of low RPM, medium RPM and high RPM, respectively.
a is a plot of yield stress versus post-flocculant shear time when using flocculant SNF 3335 for three different mixing powers per unit volume of slurry.
b is a plot of yield stress versus post-flocculant shear time when using flocculant SNF 3338 for two different mixing powers per unit volume of slurry.
a is a plot of CST (sec) versus post-flocculant shear time when using flocculant SNF 3335 for three different mixing powers per unit volume of slurry.
b is a plot of CST (sec) versus post-flocculant shear time when using flocculant SNF 3338 for three different mixing powers per unit volume of slurry.
The detailed description set forth below in connection with the appended drawings is intended as a description of various embodiments of the present invention and is not intended to represent the only embodiments contemplated by the inventor. The detailed description includes specific details for the purpose of providing a comprehensive understanding of the present invention. However, it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the present invention may be practiced without these specific details.
The present invention relates generally to a process for dewatering oil sands tailings. As used herein, the term “tailings” means tailings derived from oil sands extraction operations and containing a fines fraction. The term is meant to include fluid fine tailings (FFT) from tailings ponds and fine tailings from ongoing extraction operations (for example, thickener underflow or froth treatment tailings) which may bypass a tailings pond.
In one embodiment of the process of the present invention, the oil sands fine tailings are primarily FFT obtained from tailings ponds. The raw FFT will generally have a solids content of around 30 to 40 wt % and may be diluted to about 20-25 wt % with water for use in the present process. However, any oil sands fine tailings having a solids content ranging from about 10 wt % to about 70 wt % or higher can be used.
Useful flocculating polymers or “flocculants” include charged or uncharged polyacrylamides such as a high molecular weight polyacrylamide-sodium polyacrylate co-polymer with about 25-35% anionicity. The polyacrylamide-sodium polyacrylate co-polymers may be branched or linear and have molecular weights which can exceed 20 million.
As used herein, the term “flocculant” refers to a reagent which bridges the neutralized or coagulated particles into larger agglomerates, resulting in more efficient settling. Preferably, the polymeric flocculants are characterized by molecular weights ranging between about 1,000 kD to about 50,000 kD. Natural polymeric flocculants may also be used, for example, polysaccharides such as dextran, starch or guar gum.
Other useful polymeric flocculants can be made by the polymerization of (meth)acryamide, N-vinyl pyrrolidone, N-vinyl formamide, N,N dimethylacrylamide, N-vinyl acetamide, N-vinylpyridine, N-vinylimidazole, isopropyl acrylamide and polyethylene glycol methacrylate, and one or more anionic monomer(s) such as acrylic acid, methacrylic acid, 2-acrylamido-2-methylpropane sulphonic acid (ATBS) and salts thereof, or one or more cationic monomer(s) such as dimethylaminoethyl acrylate (ADAME), dimethylaminoethyl methacrylate (MADAME), dimethydiallylammonium chloride (DADMAC), acrylamido propyltrimethyl ammonium chloride (APTAC) and/or methacrylamido propyltrimethyl ammonium chloride (MAPTAC).
A schematic of four embodiments, A, B, C and D, of the present invention is shown in
A flocculating polymer, such as an aqueous solution of an acrylamide-acrylate copolymer, is added via line 26 to Point X of the dynamic mixer 18. Generally, the polymer inlet and the FFT inlet are separated spatially, both vertically and horizontally (see
In one embodiment (B) shown in
In another embodiment (A), the flocculated FFT is removed and transferred to a thin lift deposition site having a slope of about 2 to 4% to allow water drainage. This water drainage allows the material to dry at a more rapid rate and reach trafficability levels sooner. Additional layers can be added and allowed to drain accordingly.
In a further embodiment (C), the flocculated FFT is removed and placed in a thickener 32, which thickener 32 may comprise rakes 34, to produce clarified water and thickened tailings for further disposal.
In yet a further embodiment (D), the flocculated FFT is removed from the dynamic mixer 18 and deposited at a controlled rate via pipe 37 into an accelerated dewatering cell 36, which acts as a fluid containment structure. The water released is removed using pumps 38 and exits via pipe 39. The deposit fill rate is such that maximum water is released during deposition.
In the following Example, dynamic mixer 118 was connected to a Lynx™ 60 Decanter Centrifuge as shown in embodiment B of
In each run, process conditions were first set and the system stabilized for about 30 minutes before collecting samples. As previously mentioned, when the dynamic mixer was connected to a centrifuge during testing, samples of the flocculated FFT were taken a few meters before the centrifuge. The polymer used in these experiments was a diluted solution (0.2 wt %) of a medium-high molecular weight (i.e., 14-20 million), branched chain anionic polymer (Polymer A) having approximately 25-30% charge density (an acrylamide/acrylate copolymer) and the polymer dosage ranged from about 750-850 g/tonne dry weight of tailings, unless otherwise noted. The flow rate of the FFT into the dynamic mixer was varied from 30-55 m3/hr during the testing.
One of the objectives of the following tests was to determine conditions under which (1) strong flocs were formed and (2) enhanced dewatering occurred.
In this test run, FFT, which had been diluted to about 20 wt % solids, and 750-850 g/tonne of Polymer A were added to a dynamic mixer as shown in
It can be seen from
a and 5b show the floc structure for the same material at an impeller speed of 73 RPM and at a higher impeller speed of 112 RPM, respectively. It can be seen in
The vane yield stress and the dewaterability of the flocs formed in the dynamic mixer were also determined. Vane yield stress of the flocculated FFT was measured using a Brookfield, R/S Plus-Soft Solids Tester rheometer, which measures the stress required before the flocculated material starts to yield, and the dewatering ability of the flocculated FFT was measured using a Triton Electronics Ltd. Capillary Suction Time testers. Dewaterability is thus measured as a function of how long it takes for water to be suctioned through a filter and low values indicate rapid dewatering whereas high values indicate slow dewatering ability. Thus, a low CST number indicates good dewatering. Dewatering ability is hereinafter referred to as CST.
The dynamic mixer performance, as indicated by Fines Capture in the centrifuge cake, was plotted as a function of CST value and yield stress, which is shown in
The preferred dosage of Polymer A, in grams of polymer per tonne of dry tailings, was determined by operating the dynamic mixer at the near optimal impeller speed of 73 RPM and adding between 500 to 875 g/tonne polymer to diluted FFT having a solids concentration of about 20 wt %. The flocculation performance was determined by measuring the fines capture in the cake formed in the Lynx 60 centrifuge. It can be seen in
The flocculation process was further examined using two different FFT samples; one having a solids content of 35.8 wt % and one having a solids content of 20 wt %. In this Example, samples of FFT were taken from a dynamic mixer at various time periods (in minutes) post flocculant polymer addition. The torque, which is a measure of the turning force on the impeller, was plotted against time (in minutes) over the entire period of the test. The yield stress and CST were also measured at various time intervals after about 3.5 minutes of mixing of polymer and FFT.
Thus, it would appear that the optimal operating window would be between about 3.5 and 4.2 minutes or about 3.0 to about 3.7 minutes post flocculant injection. As mentioned, the decrease in yield stress and increase in CST is likely due to excessive shear post-flocculant injection. This is in keeping with the theory that in the initial period post-injection of flocculant, the FFT is forming a gel-like structure. After a certain degree of shearing or conditioning of the gel-like structure, large flocs are formed allowing for maximum water release. However, after about 3.7 minutes, the shearing starts having a negative effect and the large flocs are irreversibly broken down and fines are released.
Similar results were obtained with 35.8 wt % FFT, as shown in
Based on the fluid properties of flocculated FFT obtained in the above tests, it was possible to determine a modified Reynolds number (e.g., Metzler Reed Reynolds number) for various flocculated FFT. A correlation of Power number (NP) and Reynolds number (Re′) is shown in
A simulation of the mixing behavior of FFT and polymer is shown in
The above tests show that a dynamic mixer of the proper design can be used to mix FFT with a polymer to produce a well floccutated structure. A key aspect is that the shear imparted by the impeller must be in the right range as to provide adequate mixing without overshearing the flocs. Based on the above test work, this requires that the impeller diameter and height of fluid above the impeller both be about 0.6-0.7 times the tank diameter. The impeller speed must also be kept below a certain rpm depending on polymer dosage and FFT solids content to avoid overshearing of the flocs. This will usually result in the impeller operating in a transitional flow regime. Given the unique rheological properties of flocculated FFT, operation of a dynamic mixer outside of the above ranges resulted in poor dewatering. In addition, the dynamic mixer should be placed in close proximity to the dewatering stage.
In the following tests, the tank 219 had a diameter (T) of 315-mm, the baffle clearance (BC) to the tank wall was about 10 mm, the clearance between the turbine 220 and the tank bottom (C) was 65 mm, and the width of the baffles (WB) was about 6 mm. It was discovered that if the ratio of slurry height (H) to tank (mixer) diameter (H/T) is too large (e.g., 1.2), the slurry load is too high and the slurry is hard to be homogeneously mixed. If the H/T is too low (e.g., 0.4), the floc structures that are formed in the mixer could be easily oversheared. Similarly, if the impeller diameter (D) to tank (mixer) diameter (D/T) is too small (e.g., 0.4), the slurry is not homogeneously mixed and if the D/T is too large (e.g., 0.8), the flocculated material could be easily oversheared.
Tests were done using two high molecular weight polymers, an linear anionic acrylamide/acrylate polymer (SNF 3335) having approximately 25-30% charge density and a branched anionic acrylamide/acrylate polymer (SNF 3338) having approximately 25-30% charge density. The FFT feed solids content was 20%, H/T 0.6, D/T 0.6 or 0.7, SNF 3335 flocculant concentration 0.17% and dosage 920 g/t, SNF 3338 flocculant concentration 0.4% and dosage 800 g/t, flocculant injection/mixing time of 3.5 minutes, and ambient temperature of 20° C. Three different power input per unit volume of slurry (P/V) were used, namely, 4 hp/kgal, 7 hp/kgal and 11 hp/kgal. Power input is related to the cube of the impellers' rotational speed. Power input per unit volume of slurry (P/V) can be calculated as follows:
a and 17b show that, after mixing the flocculant with the tailings for a duration of 3.5 minutes, continued application of power (i.e., continued mixing) resulted in a decrease in yireld stress. In particular,
Additional tests using the reaction tank as shown in
A second test was performed using branched anionic acrylamide/acrylate polymer SNF 3338 at a concentration of 0.4% and dosage of 800 g/t and a higher mixer power (PN) of 11 hp/kgal. The FFT feed solids content was 20%, H/T 0.6, D/T 0.7, and ambient temperature of 20° C. The effects of flocculant injection/mixing time on yield stresses, CST and centrate solids content at different post-flocculant shear time are shown in
Polymer dosages were tested using the reactor tank of Example 2. Polymeric flocculant dosage is an important variable for high density FFT flocculation. For this series of tests, both SNF 3335 and SNF 3338 dosages were tested. The fixed test conditions are as follows: FFT feed solids content 20%, H/T 0.6 before flocculant addition, FBT impeller D/T 0.7, PN 7 hp/kgallon, flocculant injection/mixing time 3.5 minutes, and temperature ambient at 20° C.
The CST and centrate solids contents in
The CST and centrate solids contents in
Impeller tip speed can be calculated as follows:
Impeller tip speed is important because it is at this part of the impeller (i.e., tip) where maximum shearing is occurring. Thus, impeller tip speed is directly proportional to the maximum shear rate. Hence, if the feed rate changes or the size of the tank changes, thereby changing the number of turnovers, the impeller tip speed can be adjusted to compensate for these changes and still provide proper conditions for optimum flocculation. As can be seen in
By way of a hypothetical example, if at a lower flow rate (flow through) of FFT feed into a 60 liter reactor tank the # of turnovers of the FFT is 50, then the tip speed should be about 4 msec in order to achieve a tip speed times number of turnovers of about 200. However, if the flow through into the 60 liter reactor tank of the FFT is increased (i.e., high flow through), the # of turnovers of the FFT may be only 25. Thus, to achieve a tip speed times number of turnovers of about 200, the tip speed would have to be increased to 8 msec. Thus, regardless of the size of the tank or flow rate into the tank, good flocculation and dewatering can be controlled by changing the tip speed accordingly.
Tests were performed using the above parameters to produce a well flocculated material (using FFT) with good dewatering capabilities (i.e., material having a relatively high yield stress and relatively low CST). The well-flocculated material was then transported through a pipeline to determine whether the well-flocculated material could be transported through a pipe to its final deposition treatment without excessive break-down, i.e., shearing of the flocs.
The reactor tank of Example 2 was scaled up for a pilot test and was operated on a continuous basis using FFT fed at a feed rate of 30 msec. A Lynx 60 centrifuge has connected to the reactor tank and the centrifuge centrate solids % and fines capture % determined. A range of tip speeds, m/s, were tested. As can be seen in
In one specific embodiment, a 0.5 m3 multi staged mixing tank with eight compartments and eight flat blade turbine impellers was used to produce a proper flocculated material when fed with 16 wt % FFT. The mixer was attached to a decanter centrifuge that was able to produce a 55 wt % cake at less than 1 wt % solids in the centrate. The mixer was run at 800 RPM and the polymer was injected half way up the vessel at nominally 800 g/tonne. Each impeller diameter was 0.6-0.7 times the tank diameter. The flocculation process in a multi-staged mixer also works on the principal of the impeller tip speed time the number of times the mixtures interacts with the impeller. As the material flows through the vessel it interacts with each impeller as it moves from compartment to compartment. The total experience of the material is the sum of all experiences in each individual compartment.
From the foregoing description, one skilled in the art can easily ascertain the essential characteristics of this invention, and without departing from the spirit and scope thereof, can make various changes and modifications of the invention to adapt it to various usages and conditions. Thus, the present invention is not intended to be limited to the embodiments shown herein, but is to be accorded the full scope consistent with the claims, wherein reference to an element in the singular, such as by use of the article “a” or “an” is not intended to mean “one and only one” unless specifically so stated, but rather “one or more”. All structural and functional equivalents to the elements of the various embodiments described throughout the disclosure that are known or later come to be known to those of ordinary skill in the art are intended to be encompassed by the elements of the claims. Moreover, nothing disclosed herein is intended to be dedicated to the public regardless of whether such disclosure is explicitly recited in the claims.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61535862 | Sep 2011 | US |