1. Field of the Invention
The present invention relates to an apparatus and a method for simulating optical amplifying characteristics of an optical amplifier applied to an optical transmission system, and in particular, to an optical amplification characteristics simulation apparatus and an optical amplification characteristics simulation method considering the gain fluctuation due to a gain spectral hole burning phenomenon.
2. Description of the Related Art
As shown in a basic configuration diagram of
Heretofore, as shown in
In recent years, there has been promoted the introduction of a WDM optical transmission system provided with nodes as shown in
In such a WDM optical transmission system, when a failure, such as the transmission path breakage or the like, occurs, measures are taken in which the line switching is made for suppressing the degradation of the service quality so that the interruption of signal transmission is suppressed to a minimum. To be specific, in the above system shown in
However, it is understood that it is hard to maintain the flatness of the gain wavelength characteristics or the output power wavelength characteristics by the conventional optical amplifier applied with the automatic gain control, and as one of the reasons thereof, it is considered a gain spectral hole burning (GSHB) phenomenon of rare-earth ions. The gain spectral hole burning phenomenon means the spectral hole burning caused by an amplification phenomenon due to the stimulated emission. For example, for the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon of an erbium-doped fiber amplifier (EDFA), it has been reported that, by controlling a pumping light for holding a gain of a signal light of 1560 nm constant, the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon can be markedly observed (refer to literature 1: M. Nishihara, Y Sugaya and E. Ishikawa, in Proceedings of Optical Amplifiers and Their Applications, OAA2003, Tud.3 (2003)).
Spectrums in the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon can be obtained by getting a difference between gain spectral which are measured by the wavelength sweep of a probe light of lower power after entering a saturating signal light (a signal light by which the gain is saturated) and the probe light into the optical amplifier and gain spectrums which are measured by the wavelength sweep of the probe light of lower power after entering only the probe light. In the difference spectrums, as shown in
For example, in the case of a C-band (conventional band) of the EDFA, the second hole in the vicinity of 1530 nm does not depend on the wavelengths of the saturating signal light to appear at 1530 nm, and the hole-width and hole-depth thereof does not depend on the wavelengths of the saturating signal light. On the other hand, the main hole has characteristics in which the hole-width thereof is approximately constant without depending on the wavelengths of the saturating signal light whereas the hole-depth thereof becomes deeper as the wavelength of the saturating signal light becomes shorter (refer to
Thus, as a result that the observation of the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon has been promoted, it becomes possible to perform the simulation of the optical amplification characteristics using the calculation model thereof, and accordingly, a proposal has been made on a simulation apparatus for appropriately restricting an amplified wavelength range, an input/output power range and a gain setting range and for setting a calculating parameter, so that not only experimental results of one wave amplification characteristics but also experimental results of wavelength division multiplexing amplification characteristics can be traced (refer to literature 2: International Patent Publication 2005/002009 pamphlet).
Usually, in the optical amplifier, the length of the amplification medium and an optical circuit configuration are determined in accordance with the required specification, such as the amplification band, the input/output power range, noise characteristics and the like. Therefore, for the calculation model used in the above conventional simulation apparatus, it is also necessary to prepare the calculating parameter for the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon for each required specification.
However, in the conventional simulation apparatus, in the case where the calculating parameter setting does not meet conditions which has been set when the calculation model for the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon is constructed, a calculation result thereof does not always trace actual characteristics. In particular, in the case where the wavelength band, the temperature and the input power range are changed, it is difficult to apply the existing calculation model. Namely, the conventional simulation apparatus has disadvantages in that the calculation model without the versatility is used.
In order to enhance the versatility of the calculation model, to be specific, in order to enable the optical amplification characteristics simulation considering the gain fluctuation due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon even in arbitrary amplified wavelength ranges, the arbitrary wavelength numbers and wavelength allocation, arbitrary input/output power ranges, arbitrary gain ranges and arbitrary temperature ranges, it is necessary to construct a new calculation model based on a physical phenomenon. Ideally, it is desired to realize a calculation model in which the gain fluctuation due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon can be simulated based on a calculating parameter on the basis of the property and structure of the amplification medium.
Further, in the WDM optical transmission system as shown in
However, generally, it takes several milliseconds or several ten milliseconds until the variable optical attenuator to be utilized for the automatic level control is operated. The above described output power fluctuation which occurs until the automatic level control is effectively performed is accumulated in each optical amplifier disposed on the system, and an accumulative amount thereof is increased as the disposed number of optical amplifiers is increased. Therefore, it is anticipated that the transmission quality is degraded due to the optical output power fluctuation or the optical signal-to-noise (SN) ratio fluctuation.
Thus, in order to ensure the reliability of the optical transmission system, it is necessary to consider the optical output power fluctuation and the optical SN ratio fluctuation. However, there is a problem in that the analysis or the cause clarification has not been sufficiently performed on a phenomenon called the above output power deviation and the accumulation thereof. Namely, heretofore, only the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon of the optical amplifier has been noticed as the cause of the output power deviation, and accordingly, for the simulation thereof, the above described problem is not still solved. In particular, in the conventional simulation apparatus, the detailed design information, such as the optical circuit configuration of the optical amplifier, the pumping control method and the like, is required. Optical parts configuring the optical amplifier are often provided from external parts manufacturer. In such a case, it is difficult for a system designer to obtain the detailed design information of the optical amplifier, and consequently, it becomes hard to make a design considering the optical output power fluctuation and the optical SN ratio fluctuation on the total optical transmission system.
The present invention has been accomplished in view of the above problems, and has an object to provide an apparatus and a method capable of constructing a high versatile calculation model for the gain fluctuation due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon based on a physical phenomenon to thereby simulate with high precision optical amplification characteristics of an amplification medium under arbitrary conditions. Further, the present invention has an object to apply the above calculation model, to thereby enable the precise simulation of transmission characteristics of a WDM optical transmission system.
In order to achieve the above objects, an optical amplification characteristics simulation apparatus of the present invention is for supplying a pumping light to an amplification medium which is doped with rare-earth ions, and simulating optical amplification characteristics of the amplification medium, which amplifies a signal light input thereto due to a stimulated emission phenomenon of the pumped rare-earth ions to output the amplified signal light. This optical amplification characteristics simulation apparatus comprises: an input section that receives information relating to the signal light input to the amplification medium; a storage section that stores therein information relating to at least characteristics of the amplification medium; a computation section that uses the information input to the input section and the information stored in the storage section, to calculate gain wavelength characteristics, inclusive of a gain fluctuation portion due to a gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, of the amplification medium, in accordance with a previously set calculating formula, and obtains the power of the signal light output from the amplification medium based on the calculated gain wavelength characteristics, to thereby simulate the optical amplification characteristics of the amplification medium; and an output section that outputs the simulation result in the computation section. Further, the calculating formula used in the computation section is characterized to have a parameter corresponding to the gain fluctuation portion due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, and this parameter is characterized to be defined with a function obtained by modeling a physical phenomenon in which a population inversion rate is reduced due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, based on that, in an energy level structure of the amplification medium having Stark levels which are split into J+½ or 2J+1 relative to the total quantum numbers J due to Coulomb interactions, the spin-orbit interaction and the Stark effect, electron occupation numbers of each Stark level on the end level side are increased.
According to an optical amplification characteristics simulation method of the present invention, for an optical amplifier which supplies a pumping light to an amplification medium doped with rare-earth ions and amplifies a signal light input to the amplification medium due to a stimulated emission phenomenon of the pumped rare-earth ions to output the amplified signal light, gain wavelength characteristics, inclusive of a gain fluctuation portion due to a gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, of the optical amplifier are calculated, in accordance with a previously set calculating formula using information relating to the signal light input to the optical amplifier and information relating to characteristics of the amplification medium, or a gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon which occurs at the optical amplification time in previously set wavelength numbers and the previously set wavelength allocation is obtained by previously measuring characteristics of the optical amplifier, to calculate optical amplification characteristics of the optical amplifier based on the calculated or obtained gain wavelength characteristics. In this optical amplification characteristics simulation method, the calculating formula used for the calculation of the gain wavelength characteristics of the optical amplifier is characterized to have a parameter corresponding to the gain fluctuation portion due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, and this parameter is characterized to be defined with a function obtained by modeling a physical phenomenon in which a population inversion rate is reduced due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, based on that, in an energy level structure of the amplification medium having Stark levels which are split into J+½ or 2J+1 relative to the total quantum numbers J due to the Stark effect, electron occupation numbers of each Stark level on the end level side are increased.
In the optical amplification characteristics simulation apparatus and the optical amplification characteristics simulation method as described above, the gain wavelength characteristics of the amplification medium are calculated in accordance with the previously set calculating formula, using the information relating to the signal light input to the amplification medium of the optical amplifier and the information relating to the characteristics of the amplification medium. For the calculating formula used at this time, a new calculation model for the gain fluctuation due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon is applied. This calculation model is obtained by modeling the physical phenomenon in which the population inversion rate is reduced due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, based on that, in the energy level structure of the amplification medium having Stark levels which are split into J+½ or 2J+1 relative to the total quantum numbers J due to Coulomb interactions, the spin-orbit interaction and the Stark effect, the electron occupation numbers of each Stark level on the end level side are increased, and the parameter defined by the function corresponding thereto is incorporated into the calculating formula. Then, based on the calculated gain wavelength characteristics of the amplification medium, the power of the signal light output from the amplification medium is obtained, so that the optical amplification characteristics of the optical amplifier are simulated.
Further, the present invention also provides an apparatus for simulating transmission characteristics of a wavelength division multiplexing optical transmission system in which a plurality of devices each having a wavelength routing function and a plurality of optical amplifiers are arranged on a transmission path. This transmission characteristics simulation apparatus comprises: an input section that receives information relating to a configuration of the wavelength division multiplexing optical transmission system and information relating to a signal light transmitted through the wavelength division multiplexing optical transmission system; a storage section that stores therein information relating to characteristics of amplification mediums of the optical amplifiers, loss wavelength characteristics relating to the transmission path and filter characteristics of the devices each having the wavelength routing function; a computation section that, for an optical amplifier set on a simulation starting point, uses the information input to the input section and the information stored in the storage section to calculate gain wavelength characteristics of the optical amplifier, inclusive of a gain fluctuation portion due to a gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, in accordance with a previously set calculating formula, or obtains a gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon which occurs at the amplification time in previously set wavelength numbers and the previously set wavelength allocation by previously measuring characteristics of the optical amplifier, and after obtaining the power of the signal light output from the optical amplifier based on the calculated or obtained gain wavelength characteristics, repetitively executes, a series of computation processing of calculating the power of the signal light input to the next stage optical amplifier according to the loss wavelength characteristics of the transmission path or the filter characteristics of the device having the wavelength routing function which are connected to the latter stage of the optical amplifier, up to the optical amplifier connected to a reception end, to thereby simulate transmission characteristics of the signal light which reaches the reception end; and an output section that outputs the simulation result of the computation section. Further, the calculating formula used for the calculation of the gain wavelength characteristics of the optical amplifier in the computation section is characterized to have a parameter corresponding to the gain fluctuation portion due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, and this parameter is characterized to be defined with a function obtained by modeling a physical phenomenon in which a population inversion rate is reduced due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, based on that, in an energy level structure of the amplification medium having Stark levels which are split into J+½ or 2J+1 relative to the total quantum numbers J due to Coulomb interactions, the spin-orbit interaction and the Stark effect, electron occupation numbers of each Stark level on the end level side are increased.
In the above transmission characteristics simulation apparatus as described above, similarly to the above optical amplification characteristics simulation apparatus for the optical amplifier, the signal light output power of each optical amplifier arranged on the transmission path of the wavelength division multiplexing optical transmission system is calculated in accordance with the calculating formula applied with the new calculation model for the gain fluctuation due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon. At this time, for the signal light input to the next stage optical amplifier from the former stage optical amplifier via the transmission path or the device having the wavelength routine function, the input power thereof is calculated according to the loss wavelength characteristics of the transmission path or the filter characteristics of the device having the wavelength routing function. Such computation processing is repetitively executed on the optical amplifier set on the simulation starting point up to the optical amplifier connected to a receiver, so that the transmission characteristics of the signal light reaching the reception end can be simulated.
According to the optical amplification characteristics simulation apparatus and the optical amplification characteristics simulation method of the present invention as described in the above, since the gain wavelength characteristics of the amplification medium are calculated for the gain fluctuation due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon by applying the high versatile calculation model based on the physical phenomenon, it becomes possible to simulate with high precision the optical amplification characteristics considering the gain fluctuation due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon under arbitrary conditions. Further, by applying the above calculation model to the simulation of the transmission characteristics of the WDM optical transmission system, it is possible to calculate with high precision the output power deviation of the optical amplifier which occurs due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon and the like and the accumulation of the output power deviation. Therefore, it becomes possible to precisely simulate the transmission characteristics of the WDM optical transmission system. Furthermore, by previously measuring the gain fluctuation portion due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon of the optical amplifier, it becomes possible to simulate the transmission characteristics of the WDM optical transmission system which uses optical amplifiers of unspecified optical circuit configurations.
The other objects, features, advantages and various aspects of the present invention will become more apparent from the ensuing description of preferred embodiments with reference to the accompanying drawings.
There will be described embodiments for implementing the present invention, with reference to the accompanying drawings. The same reference numerals denote the same or equivalent parts in all drawings.
In
Here, there will be described in detail the calculation model of the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, which is to be applied to the present optical amplification characteristics simulation apparatus 1.
In order to solve the problems relating to the conventional optical amplification characteristics simulation apparatus as described in the above, it is necessary to seek origins of the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon to thereby perform the research going back to a physical phenomenon. By physically clarifying the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, it becomes possible to clear up a causal relation between the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, and property and structure parameters of the amplification medium, to thereby solve the problems in the conventional technology.
It is known that, in the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, the hole-width is changed depending on the temperature. By observing the gain spectral hole burning at the low temperature, it is possible to reveal the gain spectral hole burning which eliminates an influence by the heat fluctuation.
Trivalent rare-earth ions form an energy level structure with Coulomb interactions, the spin-orbit interaction, and an absorption property and an emission property appear due to the electron transitions between energy levels of the energy level structure. Further, it is known that the respective levels have Stark levels which are split into J+½ for the case where 4f electron numbers are odd numbers and into 2J+1 for the case where the 4f electron numbers are even numbers, due to the Stark effect. Note, J indicates the total quantum numbers. As a specific example,
The emission property of trivalent rare-earth ions and the absorption property thereof are basically determined with the overlap of the transitions between Stark levels. It is considered that, at the low temperature such as 77K, about 80% of the electrons pumped into a starting level occupies a first level and a second level (a first and a second from the bottom in Stark level are called the first level and the second level, respectively) in accordance with Boltzmann distribution. Therefore, the emission spectrums are observed due to the transitions from the first and second levels of the starting level (4I13/2 in
In accordance with the above model, it is possible to deem the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon shown in
It is possible to judge whether the reduction of the population inversion rate is caused by the decrease of the electron occupation numbers in the starting level or by the increase of the electron occupation numbers in the end level, by observing a change in the hole-depth due to a difference between doped amounts of the rare-earth ions as shown in
Briefly explaining the above covering mechanism using a conceptual diagram of
Accordingly, the present invention applies to the calculation model the consideration in that the reduction of the population inversion rate between Stark levels, which is deemed to be the physical cause of the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, is caused by the increase of the electron occupation numbers in the end level.
Further, for the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, as shown in a measurement result at 77K shown in
Namely, as shown in
Accordingly, the present invention applies to the calculation model the consideration in that the number of holes formed due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon is determined by the combinations of the transitions between Stark levels which are occupied by the electrons on the starting level side and Stark levels on the end level side, as shown in
Furthermore, for the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, as shown in
To be specific, the dependence on the input power has a characteristic such that as the input power becomes higher, the contribution rate to the hole forming becomes higher, as shown in
The dependence on the rare-earth ion concentration has a characteristic such that as the rare-earth ion concentration becomes higher, the contribution rate to the hole forming becomes lower, as shown in
Furthermore, for the dependence on the propagation mode of the signal light in the amplification medium, as the power of the signal light incident per one rare-earth ion in the amplification medium becomes higher or as an integral value of the signal light power in a region doped with the rare-earth ions in the amplification medium becomes higher, the contribution rate to the hole forming tends to become higher.
Moreover, for the gain spectral hole burning observed in a state where the population inversion rate is not formed, it has been reported that the hole-width follows T1.73 (T: temperature) (refer to the literature 3: E. Desurvire et al., IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, vol. 2, No. 4 (1990) pp. 246 to 248). In this literature 3, the hole-width is in proportional to T1.73 in a temperature range of 20 to 77K. Contrary to this, the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon observed in a state where the population inversion rate is formed has a characteristic such that a change amount of the hole-width due to the temperature becomes smaller compared with the dependence (T1.73-law) of the hole-width in the state where the population inversion rate is not formed, as shown in
Consequently, the present invention applies to the calculation model the consideration in that in addition to the dependence of the hole-width of the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon on the temperature, the contribution rate to the hole forming depends on at least one of the input power, the total population inversion rate, the rare-earth ion concentration and the propagation mode of the signal light in the amplification medium.
Next, there will be specifically described a simulation method of the optical amplification characteristics using the calculation model based on the above considerations.
For example, considering a unit length Δz of the amplification medium doped with the rare-earth ions with a longitudinal direction of the amplification medium as a z-axis direction (refer to
P(z+Δz)=P(z)+G(n+ΔnGSHB)×P(z) (1)
Note, n in the above formula (1) is the population inversion rate in the coordinate z of the amplification medium, P(z) is the signal light power in the coordinate z of the amplification medium, and G(n) is a gain of the amplification medium in the case of the population inversion rate n.
A propagation equation of the signal light which is propagated through the amplification medium can be expressed by the next formula (2).
dP(z,λ)/dz={(g(λ)+α(λ))(n(z)+ΔnGSHB)−(α(λ)+l(λ))}×P(z,λ) (2)
In the above formula (2), the population inversion rate n is a function n(z) according to the coordinate z in the longitudinal direction of the amplification medium. Further, g(λ) in the above formula (2) is a gain coefficient in the amplification medium, α(λ) is an absorption coefficient, l(λ) is a loss, which are previously given as functions according to a wavelength λ of the signal light. Incidentally, herein, data relating to g(λ), α(λ) and l(λ) is compiled in a database in the storage section 12 as a characteristic parameter for the amplification medium.
Based on the above formula (2), a minimum change amount dP(z)/dz of the signal light power in the coordinate z of the amplification medium can be obtained by obtaining the signal light power P(z) and n(z)+ΔnGSHB in the coordinate z. Based on the signal light power P(z) in the coordinate z of the amplification medium, n(z) can be obtained by a known calculating formula (refer to the formula (14) in the literature 4: C. R. Giles, et al., “Modeling Erbium Doped Fiber Amplifiers”, IEEE Journal of Lightwave Technology., pp. 271 to 283, vol. 9, no. 2, February 1991).
In the present invention, the calculation model based on the physical cause of the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon is applied to ΔnGSHB which is the parameter corresponding to a gain fluctuation portion due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon in the formula (2). To be specific, ΔnGSHB is expressed by the next formula (3).
Note, in the above formula (3), λ is the wavelength of the signal light, t is the total population inversion rate, P is the input power of the signal light, and Nt is the concentration of the rare-earth ions. Further, Cm(λ, t, P, Nt) is the ratio of the rare-earth ions contributing to the gain spectral hole burning, l(T) is the hole-intensity expressed as a function of the temperature, W(T) is the hole-width expressed as a function of the temperature, and f(λ, W(T)) is a function of the wavelength and the hole-width. Incidentally, as f(λ, W(T)), it is possible to apply any one of Gaussian function, Lorentz function and Voigt function.
The formula (3) includes relations shown in the next formulas (4) to (7), and corresponds to the above considerations of the calculation model. Namely, the relation of the formula (4) corresponds to the consideration in that the number of holes shown in
Accordingly, from the relations of the formulas (2) and (3), based on the power P(0) at the time when the signal light is input to the amplification medium, a value of ΔnGSHB in the formula (3) is calculated together with n(0), and the calculated ΔnGSHB is used in the formula (2), so that a minimum change in the signal light power for when the signal light is propagated through a position of the unit length Δz on a signal light input end of the amplification medium can be calculated.
Further, it is possible to add the calculated minimum change in the signal light power to the input signal light power P(0), to thereby obtain the signal light power P(Δz) propagated through the position of the unit length Δz. As a result, similarly to the above, it is also possible to calculate an optical power change in the case where the signal light is further propagated by the unit length Δz from the coordinate z=Δz in the longitudinal direction of the amplification medium.
Thus, by repetitively executing the above calculation, it becomes possible to calculate the optical power change in the case where the signal light is propagated by the unit length Δz from the coordinate z between the signal light input end (z=0) of the amplification medium and an output end (z=L) thereof, so that the optical power at the time when the signal light is finally output from the output end of the amplification medium can be calculated.
The above described simulation processing of the optical amplification characteristics is executed by the computation section 13 in accordance with the program which incorporates therein the above calculation model stored in the storage section 12 shown in
Here, there will be described a specific calculation example executed by the present optical amplification characteristics simulation apparatus 1. However, the present invention is not limited to the following calculation example.
Herein, as shown in
In the optical amplification characteristics simulation of the EDF as described above, the next formula (3)′ can be applied as a specific function of ΔnGSHB shown in the formula (3).
In the above formula (3)′, a parameter λm indicates a wavelength corresponding to the transitions between the respective Stark levels in the starting and end levels. This parameter λm is a physical parameter of the EDF 101, which is determined by a field around the rare-earth ions. A parameter ΔL is the gain hole line width at the low temperature. TL is the measured temperature obtained by measuring the parameter ΔL, and herein is the nitrogen temperature (for example, 77K). T is the room temperature (for example, 293K). Further, for the hole in the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, it is provided that, with the temperature rise, the hole-depth is reduced, and the hole-width is increased, and also, the hole area is fixed. Furthermore, the hole shape is a model having Gaussian curve. In addition, for the input power dependence, an empiric formula is used herein.
At the low temperature as described in the above, since the hole-width in the gain spectral hole burning becomes relatively narrower, it is considered that the gain reduction due to the gain spectral hole burning does not occur in the vicinity of this wavelength even in the case where an automatic gain control is performed at a wavelength (herein, 1570 nm) between the sub-holes, and accordingly, it is possible to obtain the spectrums in the pure gain spectral hole burning by the measurement. On the other hand, at the room temperature, the hole-width in the gain spectral hole burning becomes broader, and the sub-holes are overlapped with each other, so that the gain reduction due to the gain spectral hole burning occurs also in the vicinity of a reference wavelength in the automatic gain control. Therefore, it becomes hard to obtain the spectrums in the pure gain spectral hole burning by the measurement.
To be specific,
Thus, in the case of the room temperature at which the hole-width is broadened, it is hard to obtain the spectrums in the pure gain spectral hole burning by the measurement. However, according to the simulation using the calculation model of the formula (3)′, it s possible to obtain the spectrums in the pure gain spectral hole burning by the calculation.
As described in the above, by incorporating the calculation model of the formula (3)′ into the simulation program, also for the case where the gain fluctuation occurs due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, it becomes possible to simulate with high precision the optical amplification characteristics of the EDFA shown in
The calculation results shown in
Consequently, by using the calculation model according to the present invention based on the transitions between Stark levels, it becomes also possible to simulate with high precision the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon occurring in the vicinity of 1580 nm, similarly to the C-band region. Thus, according to the present simulation apparatus 1, it becomes also possible to predict the optical amplification characteristics for a new wavelength range or a new input/output power range.
By feeding the simulation result of the optical amplification characteristics according to the present invention back to the designing of the optical amplifier such as the EDFA, it becomes possible to perform the review for suppressing the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon in view of materials, the review for suppressing the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon by optimizing a structural parameter of the optical fiber used for the amplification medium, and the like. Further, in the conventional calculation model for the gain spectral hole burning, it is necessary to obtain the calculation model for each optical amplifier. However, according to the present simulation apparatus, it becomes possible to perform the simulation of the optical amplification characteristics considering the gain fluctuation due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, for arbitrary amplification wavelength ranges, arbitrary wavelength numbers and arbitrary wavelength allocation, arbitrary input/output power ranges, arbitrary gain ranges, and arbitrary temperature ranges. Therefore, it is possible to make the efficient design on the optical amplifier.
Next, there will be described another embodiment of the optical amplification characteristics simulation apparatus according to the present invention.
In the simulation apparatus in the above embodiment, as the database for simulating the optical amplification characteristics, it is necessary to store in the storage section 12 the information relating to the configuration of the optical amplifier (for example, the pumping wavelength, the length of the amplification medium, the loss in the constituent optical part, the pumping light control method, and the like) and the characteristic parameters for the amplification medium (for example, the rare-earth ion concentration, the glass composition of the fiber, and the like). Contrary to this, in the following embodiment, there will be described an application example in which the optical amplification characteristics can be simulated without the necessity of the information relating to the configuration of the optical amplifier.
In
To be specific, in the storage section 12′, an average gain GAVE corresponding to a set gain of the automatically gain controlled optical amplifier, the gain deviation ΔG indicating a difference between the average gain GAVE and a gain of each wavelength, a gain fluctuation amount ΔGGSHB (λ) and the characteristic parameters for the amplification medium are stored as a database, together with a simulation program.
Here, there will be described in detail the output power deviation occurring in the optical amplifier when the wavelength numbers are changed from M waves to N waves shown in
When the wavelength numbers of the signal light and the wavelength allocation thereof are significantly changed due to the wavelength routing in the OADM nodes and the like in an optical transmission system, one of the causes of the output power deviation which occurs after an optical surge caused in the optical amplifier is suppressed by the high-speed AGC is the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon and another cause is the gain deviation which is the difference between the gain of each wavelength and the average gain which is set to be constant irrespectively of the wavelength numbers of the signal light and the wavelength allocation thereof.
Regarding the output power deviation due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, as already described in detail, the physical cause of the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon is regarded to be the reduction of the population inversion rate between Stark levels caused by the increase of the electron occupation numbers in the end level, and therefore, it is possible to simulate with high precision the optical amplification characteristics using the calculation model shown in the formula (3) or the formula (3)′. However, in order to calculate the gain difference ΔGGSHB (λ) in the gain spectral hole burning of the optical amplifier, the configuration of the optical amplifier is needed. In order to obtain ΔGGSHB (λ) without the necessity of the configuration of the optical amplifier, there is the following method for example.
The optical amplifier is operated at maximum wavelength numbers, thereby performing the automatic gain control. Further, in order to measure ΔGGSHB (λ) at desired wavelength numbers and the desired wavelength allocation, the signal light of the desired wavelength numbers and desired wavelength allocation and one wave of the longest wavelength are incident on the optical amplifier, and the optical amplifier is operated so that a gain of the longest wavelength at the time becomes same as a gain of the longest wavelength for when the automatic gain control is performed at the maximum wavelength numbers. Then, by calculating a difference between gain wavelength characteristics which are measured when the optical amplifier is operated at the maximum wavelength numbers and gain wavelength characteristics which are measured when the optical amplifier is operated at the desired wavelength numbers and the desired wavelength allocation and also the one wave of the longest wavelength, it is possible to obtain ΔGGSHB (λ).
In the above method, ΔGGSHB (λ) is obtained by previously measuring the characteristics of the optical amplifier. However, in the case where the configuration of the optical amplifier is already known, ΔGGSHB (λ) may be surely calculated using the calculation model shown in the formula (3) or the formula (3)′.
Most of optical amplifiers applied to a WDM optical transmission system is each subjected to the automatic gain control by which an input/output power ratio thereof is held constant considering an optical noise portion. In the optical amplifier which is automatically gain controlled, in the case where the gain thereof is reduced due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, a gain working point being a dominant factor of the wavelength characteristics of the amplification medium is shifted and the pumping light power is controlled so that the average gain reaches a desired value. For example, in the case of the wavelength allocation in which the main holes in the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon are formed collectively on the shorter wavelength side, further deep holes are formed. In the automatic gain control, the pumping light power is increased so as to compensate for the gain reduction due to the deeper holes, thereby shifting the gain working point. A shift amount of the gain working point at the time is increased, compared with a shift amount in the case of the wavelength allocation of the signal light in which the holes are formed collectively on the longer wavelength side at which the hole-depth becomes relatively shallow. When the shift amount of the gain working point is increased, since the change in gain wavelength characteristics is increased, the output power deviation is also increased. Further, the hole-depth is increased as the wavelength spacing of the adjacent signal lights is narrower or as the wavelength numbers are less. Therefore, also in such a case, the shift amount of the gain working point is increased and accordingly, the output power deviation is increased.
Further, explaining the output power deviation due to the gain deviation which is the difference between the average gain and the gain of each wavelength, as shown in
In considering the cause by which the output power deviation occurs due to such gain deviation, herein as shown in
In the first state, paying attention to the signal light of longest wavelength α which is remained in the second state after the change in the wavelength numbers, this signal light has a gain higher than the average gain GAVE (=the set gain). Then, in the second state where only the signal light of longest wavelength is remained and other signal lights are all extracted, the pumping light power is controlled by the automatic gain control, so that the gain at the longest wavelength α reaches the predetermined set gain. Namely, by shifting from the first state to the second state, for the signal light of wavelength α, the gain, that is, the output power, is fluctuated by ΔGSHIFT in the figure, so that the output power deviation occurs.
In the optical amplifier which is automatically gain controlled as described in the above, the gain working point is shifted due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon and the gain deviation, and the shift of the gain working point causes the output power deviation. In order to simulate such output power deviation, conventionally, using the calculation model which needs the detailed information relating to the optical amplifier configuration, the optical amplification characteristics have been calculated. Contrary to this, in the simulation apparatus 1′ in the present embodiment, as described hereunder, the optical amplification characteristics can be calculated without the necessity of the detailed information relating to the optical amplifier configuration.
To be specific, in the present simulation apparatus 1′, as the information relating to the signal light input to the optical amplifier which is the simulation objective, input spectrums PIN(λ) containing the information relating to the wavelength numbers of the signal light and the wavelength allocation thereof, and the information relating to a noise light are input via the input section 11. By using the input information and the database stored in the storage section 12′, the optical amplification characteristics corresponding to the signal light of desired wavelength numbers and of the desired wavelength allocation are simulated in the computation section 13, and as the simulation result, output spectrums POUT (λ) containing the information relating to wavelength numbers of an output light and the wavelength allocation thereof, and also the information relating to the noise light are output from the output section 14.
As the database used for the optical amplification characteristics simulation in the computation section 13, as described in the above, there are used the average gain GAVE in the reference wavelength numbers and the reference wavelength allocation, the gain deviation ΔG (λ) indicating the difference between the average gain GAVE and the gain of each wavelength, the gain fluctuation amount ΔGGSHB (λ) due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon in the optical amplifier and the characteristic parameters (the wavelength dependence of the absorption coefficient and the wavelength dependence of the gain coefficient) for the amplification medium. Otherwise, in the case where the configuration of the optical amplifier is already known, in accordance with the optical circuit configuration thereof and the pumping method, the computation section 13 applies the calculation model shown in the formula (3) or the formula (3)′ to obtain the gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon in the optical amplifier, which occurs at the optical amplification time in the reference wavelength numbers and the reference wavelength allocation, and the gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon in the optical amplifier, which occurs at the optical amplification time in the desired wavelength numbers and the desired wavelength allocation, to thereby calculate the difference value ΔGGSHB (λ) thereof.
To be specific, considering a state where the signal light of 40 waves (the maximum wavelength numbers) is allocated at 100 GHz in equal spacing as the reference wavelength numbers and the reference wavelength allocation, and also, considering a state where the signal light of 32 waves is allocated at 100 GHz in equal spacing as the desired wavelength numbers and the desired wavelength allocation, data as shown in
By using the average gain GAVE, the gain deviation ΔG (λ) and the difference value ΔGGSHB (λ) of the gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon as shown in
G(λ)=GAVE+ΔG(λ)+ΔGGSHB(λ)+ΔGSHIFT(λ) (8)
By using the gain G (λ) calculated in accordance with the formula (8) and the input spectrums PIN (λ) supplied from the input section 11, the output spectrums POUT (λ) of the EDFA which is operated at 32 waves after the wavelength numbers change can be calculated in accordance with the next formula (9).
POUT(λ)=PIN(λ)+G(λ) (9)
Thus, in the simulation apparatus 1′ of the present embodiment, the optical amplification characteristics simulation is performed using the model formula which regards the optical amplifier as a so-called black box, without the necessity of the information relating to the optical amplifier configuration, such as the pumping wavelength for the optical amplifier, the length of the amplification medium, the loss in the constituent optical part, the pumping light control method.
Here, there will be described a specific example of the computation processing executed by the computation section 13 in the present simulation apparatus 1′. In the following description, provided that the state before the changes of the wavelength numbers and the wavelength allocation is the first state and the state after the changes thereof is the second state, the computation of the output spectrums is performed for each state.
In one specific example of the computation processing in the computation section 13, in the calculation processing of the output spectrums in the first state, there are used, as a database, the average gain GAVE and the gain deviation ΔG1 (λ) indicating the difference between the average gain GAVE and the gain of each wavelength in the first state. Gain G1 (λ) of each wavelength in the first state is expressed by G1 (λ)=GAVE+ΔG1 (λ) using the above database. Thus, output spectrums POUT1 (λ) in the first state are calculated by POUT1 (λ)=PIN1 (λ)+G1 (λ), using input spectrums PIN1 (λ) and the gain G1 (λ) which correspond to the first state.
On the other hand, in the calculation processing of the output spectrums in the second state, there are used, as a database, the average gain GAVE and the gain deviation ΔG1 (λ) which are same as those in the first state, and the difference value ΔGGSHB (λ) of the gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning which occurs when the wavelength numbers and the wavelength allocation are changed from the first state to the second state. Gain G2 (λ) of each wavelength in the second state is expressed by G2 (λ)=GAVE+ΔG1 (λ)+ΔGGSHB (λ)+ΔGSHIFT (λ) using the above database and using, as a calculating parameter, the gain fluctuation ΔGSHIFT (λ) in each wavelength which occurs due to the gain working point shift with the change from the first state to the second state. Thus, output spectrums POUT2 (λ) in the second state are calculated by POUT2 (λ)=PIN2 (λ)+G2 (λ), using input spectrums PIN2 (λ) and the gain G2 (λ) which correspond to the second state.
Further, in the case of calculating the characteristics fluctuation around the change from the first state to the second state, the optical output power fluctuation is obtained by subtracting POUT1 (λ) from POUT2 (λ). Furthermore, the optical SN ratio fluctuation is obtained by separating signal components from noise components in each of POUT1 (λ) and POUT2 (λ) to obtain a ratio OSNR1 (λ) between the signal component and the noise component in the first state and a ratio OSNR2 (λ) between the signal component and the noise component in the second state, to thereby subtract the ratio OSNR1 (λ) from OSNR2 (λ).
In connection with the above specific example of the computation processing in the computation section 13, there will be additionally described another specific example of which versatility is further improved.
In such another example, in the calculation processing of the output spectrums in the first state, there are used as a database, the average gain GAVE, the gain deviation ΔG (λ) indicating the difference between the average gain GAVE and the gain of each wavelength in a state where the amplification is performed in the reference wavelength numbers and the reference wavelength allocation (to be referred to as a reference state hereunder), and a difference value ΔGGSHB1 (λ) of the gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning which occurs when the wavelength numbers and the wavelength allocation are changed from the reference state to the first state. The gain G1 (λ) of each wavelength in the first state is expressed by G1 (λ)=GAVE+ΔG (λ)+ΔGGSHB1 (λ)+ΔGSHIFT1 (λ) using the above database and using, as a calculating parameter, the gain fluctuation ΔGSHIFT1 (λ) in each wavelength, which occurs due to the gain working point shift with the change from the reference state to the first state. Thus, the output spectrums POUT1 (λ) in the first state are calculated by POUT1 (λ)=PIN1 (λ)+G1 (λ), using the input spectrums PIN1 (λ) and the gain G1 (λ) which correspond to the first state.
On the other hand, in the calculation processing of the output spectrums in the second state, there are used, as a database, the average gain GAVE and the gain deviation ΔG (λ) which are same as those in the first state, and a difference value ΔGGSHB2 (λ) of the gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning which occurs when the wavelength numbers and the wavelength allocation are changed from the first state to the second state. The gain G2 (λ) of each wavelength in the second state is expressed by G2 (λ)=GAVE+ΔG (λ)+ΔGGSHB2 (λ)+ΔGSHIFT2 (λ) using the above database and using, as a calculating parameter, the gain fluctuation ΔGSHIFT2 (λ) in each wavelength, which occurs due to the gain working point shift with the change from the first state to the second state. Thus, the output spectrums POUT2 (λ) in the second state are calculated by POUT2 (λ)=PIN2 (λ)+G2 (λ) using the input spectrums PIN2 (λ) and the gain G2 (λ) which correspond to the second state.
Further, in the case of calculating the characteristics fluctuation around the change from the first state to the second state, it is possible to obtain the optical output power fluctuation and the optical SN ratio variation by a calculating method similar to that in the above described specific example.
As described in the above, in the specific example of the computation processing, the first state is made to be a reference and the gain characteristics in the second state are calculated as the difference from those in the first state. Contrary to this, in another specific example of the computation processing described in the above, the reference state is set differently from the first and second states, and the gain characteristics in the first and second states are calculated as the differences from those in the reference state. If for example a state which corresponds to the maximum wavelength numbers capable of being amplified by the optical amplifier is set as the reference value, sometimes, such an optical amplifier is not operated at the maximum wavelength numbers, depending on the optical transmission system to which such optical amplifiers are applied, and accordingly, in the above specific example of the computation processing, it is necessary to prepare ΔGGSHB (λ) which is individually calculated according to operation states of the optical transmission system. However, in another specific example of the computation processing described above, since the operation state at the maximum wavelength numbers can be made to be the reference state, it is no longer necessary to individually prepare data according to the system operation states, and therefore, it is possible to improve the versatility.
Further, in the above simulation apparatus 1′, it is desirable that the difference value ΔGGSHB (λ) of the gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon is the data reflecting characteristics of the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon in which the gain change amount in the case where the saturating signal light is allocated in concentrative on the shorter wavelength side is increased compared with the gain change amount in the case where the saturating signal light is allocated in concentrative on the longer wavelength side. Specifically explaining the characteristics of the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon in relation to the wavelength allocation of the saturating signal light, the gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon which occurs when the optical amplifier which has been operated at the maximum wavelength numbers of 40 waves is operated at 8 waves becomes larger than the gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon which occurs when the optical amplifier is operated at 8 waves on the longer wavelength side.
Next, there will be described the case where transmission characteristics of the optical transmission system using the optical amplifiers are simulated by applying the optical amplification characteristics simulation technology as described above.
According to the above described optical amplification characteristics simulation apparatuses 1 and 1′ for the optical amplifier, by constructing the new calculation models for the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon and also, considering the model which regards the optical amplifier as the black box, it becomes possible to simulate with high precision the optical amplification characteristics without the necessity of the detailed design information relating to the optical amplifier configuration. In the case where the transmission characteristics of the optical transmission system using the optical amplifiers is simulated by applying this simulation technology for the optical amplifier, it becomes necessary not only to simulate the optical amplification characteristics of a single optical amplifier but also to calculate the transmission characteristics of the entire system considering characteristics of a transmission path connected to the optical amplifier and the like. Therefore, in an embodiment of the simulation apparatus corresponding to the optical transmission system as shown in below, assuming a situation where the WDM optical transmission system as shown in
As factors of the output power deviation of the signal light in the WDM optical transmission system applying the automatically gain controlled optical amplifiers, there can be considered the fluctuation of the stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) occurring in the transmission path or a dispersion compensation fiber, around the changes of the wavelength numbers of the transmitted signal light and of the wavelength allocation thereof, in addition to the above described gain working point shift due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon and the gain deviation. Therefore, it is necessary to apply the calculation model which regards the automatically gain controlled optical amplifier as the black box as in the above simulation apparatus 1′ and also, to construct a calculation model corresponding to optical output power characteristics in the transmission path and a wavelength routing device which are connected to the latter stage of the optical amplifier, to thereby perform the transmission characteristics simulation in the entire system. To be specific, from the output wavelength characteristics (the output spectrums) of the single optical amplifier which are calculated by the above simulation apparatus 1′, loss wavelength characteristics considering an influence by the stimulated Raman scattering in the transmission path and the wavelength routing device which are connected to the latter stage of such an optical amplifier is subtracted, so that wavelength characteristics (the input spectrums) of the signal light input to the next stage optical amplifier is derived, and a series of this calculation processing is repetitively executed in successive up to the reception end, thereby simulating the transmission characteristics of the entire system.
In
The storage section 12″ stores therein, together with a simulation program, as a database, the loss wavelength characteristics of the transmission path and the dispersion compensation fiber and power fluctuation amounts due to the stimulated Raman scattering in the transmission path and the dispersion compensation fiber, and field characteristics (for example, transmission wavelength characteristics or loss wavelength characteristics) of each OADM node, in addition to the average gain GAVE, the gain deviation ΔG (λ), the gain change amount ΔGGSHB (λ) due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon and the characteristic parameters for the amplification medium, which are similar to those in the above simulation apparatus 1′.
The computation section 13 is made up by a CPU (Central Processing Unit) and the like, and executes the computation processing corresponding to the simulation model shown in
Here, there will be described the computation processing executed by the computation section 13. Similarly to the above described embodiments, the description will be made provided that a state (stationary state) before the changes in the wavelength numbers of the signal light and the wavelength allocation thereof is a first state and a state (failed state) after the changes is a second state.
Firstly, showing a correspondence relation between the configuration of the WDM optical transmission system shown in
In the first stage, to the post-amplifier 21 of the unit 20-1, the signal light of M+N waves is input, and the input spectrums PIN (λ) corresponding to the wavelength numbers of the signal light and the wavelength allocation thereof are supplied to the computation section 13 via the input section 11. Similarly to the case in the simulation apparatus 1′, the computation section 13 refers to the average gain GAVE and the gain deviation ΔG (λ) which correspond to the post-amplifier 21 from the database of the storage section 12″, and also uses the calculation model shown in the formula (3) or the formula (3)′ to calculate the difference value ΔGGSHB of the gain change amount due to the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon, to thereby calculate the output spectrums of the post-amplifier 21.
Next, the computation section 13 refers to the loss wavelength characteristics in the transmission path subsequent to the post-amplifier 21, and subtracts the loss in the transmission path from the output spectrums of the post-amplifier 21, to thereby calculate the wavelength characteristics of the signal light output from the fiber section 22. At this time, in the case where the power of the signal light input from the post-amplifier 21 to the transmission path is equal to or larger than an occurrence threshold of the stimulated Raman scattering, the output spectrums of the post-amplifier 21 is subtracted by the loss in the transmission path, and also, is added with the power fluctuation amounts due to the stimulated Raman scattering.
The calculation result of the output wavelength characteristics of the fiber section 22 is made to be the input spectrums to the pre-amplifier 23, and the calculation of the output spectrums of the pre-amplifier 23 is executed in the same way as that for the post-amplifier 21. Then, when the output spectrums of the pre-amplifier 23 are calculated, the data relating to the filter characteristics of the latter-stage wavelength routing device is referred to, a loss of each wavelength in the wavelength routing device is obtained based on a relation between an output power level of the pre-amplifier 23 and a set value of an output power level of the wavelength routing device, and the loss wavelength characteristics of the wavelength routing device are subtracted from the output spectrums of the pre-amplifier 23, thereby calculating the output spectrums of the OADM section 24.
When the transmission characteristics in the unit 20-1 are calculated as described in the above, the computation processing similar to the above is repetitively executed in successive on the units 20-2 to 20-n. Then, the output spectrums POUT (λ) from the pre-amplifier 23 of the unit 20-n are calculated as the spectrums of the signal light input to the receiver 25 in the first state.
Next, there is performed the computation processing of the input spectrums to the receiver 25 in the second state after the wavelength numbers of the signal light and the wavelength allocation thereof are significantly changed due to the failure or the like. In the computation processing in the second state, the output spectrums of the post-amplifier 21 of the unit 20-1 are calculated using the input spectrums PIN (λ) after the changes in the wavelength numbers and the wavelength allocation, and thereafter, similarly to the computation processing for the first state, the calculation processing of the transmission characteristics is repetitively executed in successive on the units 20-1 to 20-n, so that the output spectrums POUT (λ) from the pre-amplifier 23 of the unit 20-n are calculated as the spectrums of the signal light input to the receiver 25 in the second state.
Then, by obtaining a difference between the input spectrums to the receiver 25 in the first state and those in the second state, a level fluctuation amount of the signal light input to the receiver 25 around the change from the first state to the second state is calculated. Further, in the case where the optical SN ratio fluctuation of the input spectrums to the receiver 25 is calculated, the signal component and the noise component in the input spectrums to the receiver 25 in each of the first state and the second state are separated from each other, to obtain ratios between the signal components and the noise components in the respective states, and a difference between the ratios is obtained so that the optical SN ratio fluctuation is calculated.
As described in the above, according to the simulation apparatus 1″ in the present embodiment, it becomes possible to simulate with high precision the transmission characteristics of the WDM optical transmission system to which automatically gain controlled optical amplifiers are applied.
In the above embodiment, the configuration is such that the output spectrums of the post-amplifier 21 and the pre-amplifier 23 of each unit are calculated using the calculation model similar to that in the simulation apparatus 1′. However, differently from the case where the optical amplification characteristics of the single optical amplifier is simulated, in the simulation of the transmission characteristics of the optical transmission system, since the output power fluctuation in the plural optical amplifiers is accumulated to be transmitted to the latter-stage optical amplifier, it is predicted that the signal light having the power outside of an input dynamic range of the optical amplifier is input to the post-amplifier 21 or the pre-amplifier 23. In order to perform the simulation corresponding to such a case, it is desirable to prepare, in the database, ΔGGSHB (λ) corresponding to a broad input power range which is obtained by extending the input dynamic range of the single optical amplifier.
Further, there is also a possibility that the accumulated amount of noise light (ASE) generated in the optical amplifiers is increased due to the increase of OADM node numbers or the insertion of repeating nodes on the optical transmission system, and accordingly, the gain spectral hole burning phenomenon which occurs due to the accumulated noise light cannot be neglected. In order to perform the simulation corresponding to such a situation, the configuration may be such that, for example, the noise light power integrated in the fixed band-width around the signal light wavelength is contained in the input spectrums to the latter-stage node, and ΔGSHB (λ) obtained according to the power obtained by summing up the signal light power and the noise light power of the fixed region is prepared in the database.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2005-134415 | May 2005 | JP | national |
This application is a continuation of PCT/JP2005/020184, filed on Nov. 2, 2005.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
5309530 | Bergano et al. | May 1994 | A |
5309535 | Bergano et al. | May 1994 | A |
5406410 | Hanna et al. | Apr 1995 | A |
5861981 | Jabr | Jan 1999 | A |
6339495 | Cowle et al. | Jan 2002 | B1 |
6620748 | Sugimoto et al. | Sep 2003 | B1 |
7076138 | Rupasov et al. | Jul 2006 | B2 |
7212335 | Nishihara et al. | May 2007 | B2 |
20050254119 | Nishihara et al. | Nov 2005 | A1 |
20080304138 | Krummrich | Dec 2008 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2005002009 | Jan 2005 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20080088915 A1 | Apr 2008 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | PCT/JP2005/020184 | Nov 2005 | US |
Child | 11979370 | US |