The invention refers to a method for controlling an optical amplifier and an amplifier arrangement
Optical amplifiers are employed in the field of optical transmission technology for amplifying the optical signals transmitted in an optical network. The optical signals in many cases propagate over long links measuring several hundred kilometers and more in an optical fiber, being attenuated in the process. It is therefore necessary to amplify the optical signals when they have been transmitted over a long distance.
Optical links and networks of this type frequently employ Wavelength Division Multiplexing (WDM), a technique whereby a plurality of channels is transmitted in an optical fiber simultaneously at various wavelengths.
Erbium-doped fiber amplifiers (EDFAs) are largely employed in WDM transmission systems. An EDFA operates using an erbium-doped fiber into which the light from an optical pump, for example a laser diode, is coupled. The optical signal launched into the doped fiber is therein amplified by means of stimulated photon emission.
Addition and removal of individual channels of the WDM signal being transmitted on the fiber, component failures, fiber breaks or protection switching result in abrupt changes in power at the input of the amplifier. The pumping power of the optical pump has to be quickly matched to different input powers. The amplifier gain (defined as the output power/input power) would otherwise change and the output power of the individual signals would increase or decrease, as a consequence of which bit errors may occur at the receiver. Particularly in the case of multistage amplifiers, the deviations in gain in the individual stages can accumulate so that bit errors can very readily occur. A critical factor in the development of an optical amplifier is hence to maintain as constant as possible an amplifier gain even when large abrupt changes in power occur at the amplifier input.
a-2d show the operation of a conventional amplifier stage 10 of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario and in particular the overshoot 23 and 24 which occurs immediately after a switching operation in the output signal Pout and in the gain G of an amplifier stage 10.
A large number of methods are known from the prior art whereby the amplifier gain can be kept substantially constant when there is a change in input power. One known method, for example, includes the use of a feedforward controller which measures the change in input power and, as a function thereof, calculates a new pumping power that will be set on the pump immediately thereafter. But there are typically some inaccuracies leading to permanent deviation from the target gain of the amplifier. The main difficulty with this lies in calculating the new pumping power correctly so that the amplifier gain will remain substantially constant. The pumping power is dependent not only on the amplifier's input power but also on the other channels' wavelength after the switching operation, and on other influencing variables. Basing the calculation of the pumping power requiring to be newly set solely on the change in power at the input is thus relatively imprecise.
Other known methods combine the feedforward controller with a feedback controller, which introduces over a longer period of time small modifications to the pump power level and thus helps to recover the original gain of the amplifier over time.
However, variations (overshooting or undershooting) in the amplifier gain will also occur after a switching operation even when the pumping power is optimally matched to a changed input power (which is to say is changed to the correct value in a single step). Said variations are due to the memory effect of the doping element in the fiber. The electrons in the doping element (erbium, for example) are, by means of optical pumps, first raised to a third higher energy level from which they drop, in a non-emitting state transition, to a lower metastable energy level. There will always still be many electrons at the third higher energy level when the pumping power is reduced abruptly, and these will later contribute to (undesired) intermediate gain variations. In particular, when using optical pumps with an emission wavelength around 980 nm, there is a theoretical limit for the minimum achievable deviations due to population of the third higher energy level. These intermediate gain variations can be detected as overshoots in the output power which, especially in the case of multistage amplifiers, can result in bit errors at the receiver through accumulation.
Based upon the above discussions, it is concluded that there is a need in the art, for an improved system and method for controlling an optical amplifier gain. The improved system and method should be capable of controlling an optical pump in such a fashion that the intermediate gain variations due to the memory effect of the doping element in the fiber are strongly reduced.
In order to overcome the above-described need in the art, the present invention discloses a method for controlling a variation in gain of an optical amplifier, the optical amplifier including a pumping device, the method comprising: determining a change in an input power of the optical amplifier, adjusting a pumping power of the pumping device to a first power level Ppump|zero for a predetermined period of time (Δtzero, Δtoptzero, Δtoptzero|(i)), adjusting the pumping power of the pumping device to a second power level Ppump|after, the second power level being able to drive the amplifier gain to a predetermined gain value G|after after that the change in the input power occurred.
It is also an embodiment, that the predetermined gain value G|after is essentially equal to a first gain value G|before, the first gain value G|before being the gain of the amplifier before that the change in the input power occurred.
In a further embodiment, the method comprises the step of determining the second power level Ppump|after.
In a next embodiment, the method comprises the step of determining a third power level Ppump|before which keeps the gain of the amplifier at the first gain value G|before.
It is also an embodiment, that the change in the input power of the optical amplifier occurs abruptly.
In a further embodiment, the method comprises the step of determining the predetermined period of time Δtoptzero based on the equation:
wherein τ3 stands for the lifetime of the pump level, αfit is a parameter including the density of the erbium ions, Ppumpeff|before is given by the equation
Ppump|before being the third power level and Ppumpeff|after is given by the following equation
Ppump|after being the second power level and P0ESA being the characteristic power.
According to another embodiment, the change in the input power of the optical amplifier occurs approximately linearly with the time.
In a further embodiment, the method comprises the step of adjusting successively and alternatively the pumping power of the pumping device at intermediate power levels Ppump|(i) and at the first power level Ppump|zero for predetermined periods of time Δtoptzero|(i).
In a next embodiment, the method comprises the step of determining the intermediate power levels Ppump|(i) by using means for measuring or means for calculating, said means for measuring or means for calculating including digital signal processors;
In a next embodiment, the step of determining the intermediate power levels Ppump|(i) further includes calculating the effective power levels Ppumpeff|(i).
It is also an embodiment, that the determination of the intermediate power levels Ppump|(i) and Ppumpeff|(i) occurs with a sampling rate of approximately 1 MHz;
In a further embodiment, the method comprises the step of determining the predetermined periods of time Δtoptzero|(i) based on the iterative equation:
wherein τ3 stands for the lifetime of the pump level and αfit is a parameter including the density of the erbium ions.
According to another embodiment, the change in the input power of the optical amplifier is based upon one or more events selected from the group consisting of: removing a channel of the WDM signal transmitted, fiber break, protection switching, and component failures.
In a next embodiment, the first power level Ppump|zero is lower than the second power level Ppump|after.
It is also an embodiment that the first power level Ppump|zero is approximately zero.
In a further embodiment, the change in the input power of the optical amplifier is based upon adding a channel of the WDM signal transmitted
In a next embodiment, the second power level Ppump|after is lower than the first power level Ppump|zero.
In embodiments of the present invention, the optical amplifier is a single stage amplifier.
In other embodiments of the present invention, the optical amplifier is a stage of a multistage amplifier.
The problem stated above is also solved by an optical amplifier for amplifying a Wavelength Division Multiplexing signal, comprising a pumping device for providing pumping power, a control unit for determining a change in an input power of the optical amplifier, wherein, when a change in the input power of the optical amplifier occurs, the control unit is operable to adjust a pumping power of the pumping device to a first power level Ppump|zero for a predetermined period of time (Δtzero, Δtoptzero, Δtoptzero|(i)) and later to a second power level Ppump|after, the second power level being able to drive the amplifier gain to a predetermined gain value G|after after that the change in the input power occurred.
In embodiments of the present invention, the control unit is adjustable to operate a feedforward control.
In other embodiments of the present invention, the control unit is adjustable to operate a feedforward and a feedback control.
The invention is explained by way of example in more detail below with the aid of the attached drawings.
a is an illustration of the curve of the input power of an optical signal applied to the input of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario;
b is an illustration of the curve of the pumping power of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario;
c is an illustration of the curve of the total signal output power of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario;
d is an illustration of the curve of the gain of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario;
a is an illustration of the curve of the input power of an optical signal applied to the input of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario according to a first embodiment of the invention;
b is an illustration of the curve of the pumping power of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario according to a first embodiment of the invention;
c is an illustration of the curve of the total signal output power of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario according to a first embodiment of the invention;
d is an illustration of the curve of the gain of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario according to a first embodiment of the invention;
e is an illustration of the curve of the gain of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario according to a second embodiment of the invention;
a is an illustration of the curve of the input power of an optical signal applied to the input of an optical amplifier in a channel adding scenario according to a third embodiment of the invention;
b is an illustration of the curve of the pumping power of an optical amplifier in a channel adding scenario according to a third embodiment of the invention;
c is an illustration of the curve of the total signal output power of an optical amplifier in a channel adding scenario according to a third embodiment of the invention;
d is an illustration of the curve of the gain of an optical amplifier in a channel adding scenario according to a third embodiment of the invention;
e is an illustration of the curve of the gain of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario according to a fourth embodiment of the invention;
a is an illustration of a simulation which shows the curves of gain variation of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario for different durations of the “zero period” according to an embodiment of the invention;
b is an illustration of a simulation which shows the curves of the pump power of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario for five different durations of the “zero period” according to an embodiment of the invention;
As regards the description of
Illustrative embodiments will now be described with reference to the accompanying drawings to disclose the teachings of the present invention. While the present invention is described herein with reference to illustrative embodiments for particular applications, it should be understood that the invention is not limited thereto. Those having ordinary skill in the art and access to the teachings provided herein will recognize additional modifications, applications, and embodiments within the scope thereof and additional fields in which the present invention would be of significant utility.
a-4e show the operation of the amplifier stage 34 with feedforward control circuit FFCC 32 according to a first embodiment of the invention. In particular,
a shows the curve of the input power Pin of an optical signal having, for example, 80 channels of equal power with a spacing of 50 GHz (0.4 nm) in the conventional wavelength band (C-band) that is being applied to the input of the amplifier stage. For example, at the instant t0, 79 of the 80 channels are removed from the amplifier, as a result of which the power at the input Pin abruptly drops 40. This situation may also occur as a consequence of a fiber break, a component failure or a protection switching. In this abrupt drop scenario may be also included the situation in which a change in the input power of the optical amplifier occurs within 1 μs.
b shows the curve of the pumping power Ppump and in particular how the pumping device 33, controlled by the feedforward control circuit FFCC 32, operates according to a first embodiment of the invention. Ppump|before 49 is the value which keeps the gain G at a constant level G|before (45, 451) before the removal of the channels (which occurs at the instant t0), and Ppump|after 46 is the value which keeps the gain G at a constant level G|after (48, 481) after the removal of the channels on steady-state conditions. Once the control unit 35 determines a change in the input power, the feedforward control circuit FFCC 32 of the present invention first adjusts the pumping power of the pumping device 33 to a first power level (Ppump|zero) 41 for a predetermined period of time (Δtzero) 47 and then adjusts the pumping power of the pumping device to a second power level (Ppump|after) 46. In the abrupt channel drop scenario described in
c shows the total signal output power Pout of the amplifier stage 34 according to an embodiment of the invention, which displays an abrupt change 42 approximately at the instant t0, which total signal output power Pout contains a strongly reduced overshoot 43 compared with conventional optical amplifiers.
d shows the gain G of the amplifier stage 34, which gain is kept at a constant level before G|before 45, and after G|after 48 the drop and contains a strongly reduced overshoot 44 compared with conventional optical amplifiers. In the embodiment of
e shows the gain G of the amplifier stage 34 according to an alternative embodiment of the invention, which gain is kept at a constant level before G|before 451, and after G|after 481 the drop and contains a strongly reduced overshoot 441 compared with conventional optical amplifiers. In the alternative embodiment of
a-5e shows the operation of the amplifier stage 34 with feedforward control circuit FFCC 32 according to another embodiment of the invention. In particular,
a shows the curve of the input power Pin of an optical signal having, for example, 1 channel that is being applied to the input of the amplifier stage. For example, at the instant t0, 79 channels are added to the amplifier, as a result of which the power at the input Pin abruptly rises 50.
b shows the curve of the pumping power Ppump and in particular how the pumping device 33, controlled by the feedforward control circuit FFCC 32, operates according to a another embodiment of the invention. Ppump|before 59 is the value which keeps the gain G at a constant level G|before (55, 551) before the adding of the channels (which occurs at the instant t0), and Ppump|after 56 is the value which keeps the gain G at a constant level G|after (58, 581) on steady-state conditions. Once the control unit 35 determines a change in the input power the feedforward control circuit FFCC 32 of the present invention first adjusts the pumping power of the pumping device 33 to a first power level (Ppump|zero) 51 for a predetermined period of time (Δtzero) 57 and then adjusts the pumping power of the pumping device to a second power level (Ppump|after) 56. In the channel adding scenario described in
c shows the total signal output power Pout of the amplifier stage 34 according to another embodiment of the invention, which displays a change 52 approximately at the instant t0, which total signal output power Pout contains a strongly reduced undershoot 53 compared with conventional optical amplifiers. When the predetermined period of time (Δtzero) is set to its optimum value Δtoptzero (“optimum zero period”), the undershoots of the gain of the amplifier stage 34 are minimized.
d shows the gain G of the amplifier stage 34 according to another embodiment of the invention, which gain is kept at a constant level before G|before 55, and after G|after 58 the drop and contains a strongly reduced undershoot 54 compared with conventional optical amplifiers. In the embodiment of
e shows the gain G of the amplifier stage 34 according to an alternative embodiment of the invention, which gain is kept at a constant level before G|before 551, and after G|after 581 the drop and contains a strongly reduced overshoot 541 compared with conventional optical amplifiers. In the alternative embodiment of
a is an illustration of a simulation which shows the curves of the gain variation ΔG 71 of an optical amplifier in an abrupt channel drop scenario for different durations of the Δtzero (“zero period”) according to an embodiment of the invention. For example, 80 channels of equal power are applied to the input of the amplifier stage 34 and at the instant t=0, 79 of the 80 channels are removed from the amplifier. The gain variation ΔG 71 (in dB) of the surviving channel at 1531.9 nm versus time t 72 (in μs) is shown as a result of a simulation for five different durations. In particular the curve 73 corresponds to a duration of the “zero period” of 18.5 μs, the curve 74 corresponds to a duration of the “zero period” of 15.0 μs, the curve 75 corresponds to a duration of the “zero period” of 10.0 μs, the curve 76 corresponds to a duration of the “zero period” of 5.0 μs and the curve 77 corresponds to a duration of the “zero period” of 0.0 μs. If the method disclosed by the present invention is employed, the maximum amplitude of overshoots, i.e. gain deviations to larger values, decreases by more than a factor of two and there is an even significantly larger reduction of the duration of the overshoots with respect to conventional methods. If the duration of the “zero period” Δtzero is set to its optimum value (Δtoptzero=18.5 μs), the overshooting is minimized and only a small needle remains.
b is an illustration of a simulation which shows the curves of the pump power Ppump of an optical amplifier in the same scenario described in
If the parameter Δtzero exceeds its optimum value (Δtoptzero=“optimum zero period”) which in this example is 18.5 μs, undershoots are induced.
Maximum gain variation (Max ΔG 91) is indicated versus duration of the “zero period” Δtzero 92. In particular, maximum positive gain variations 95 (maximum value of the overshoots), maximum negative gain variations 93 (maximum value of the undershoots), maximum value of both deviations 94 (maximum overall deviation) are shown. Gain variations to positive values decrease approximately linearly with increasing value of the “zero period” Δtzero 92 until a minimum value of the overshoots is reached. In the chosen example, overshoots are minimum for Δtzero≧11.0 μs. It becomes also apparent that there are undershoots that increase approximately linearly with the duration of the zero period for Δtzero≧18.5 μs. Therefore, the maximum magnitude of overshoots and undershoots is minimum for approximately 11.0 μs≦Δtzero≦18.5 μs.
The curve 103 in
Deeper insight into the transient behaviour of EDFAs can be gained considering basic equations describing the amplification provided by optical amplifiers. In logarithmic units, the gain of an EDFA is given by
where σe* and σa* denote the Giles parameters for emission and absorption, respectively. Both parameters are wavelength dependent. The parameter Lfiber stands for the length of the doped fiber while
where variations of the population probabilities of involved energy levels according to the equations
Δ
Δ
have been introduced. The gain of a single surviving channel at wavelength λsurv may not be altered by the variation of the input power if the relation
[σe*(λsurv)+σa*(λsurv)]Δ
is fulfilled. In other words, a linear relation between the variations of the two involved population probabilities may be required to keep the gain of a single surviving channel constant.
However, the increase of Δ
Other embodiments of the present invention may also include a drop scenario according to which channels other than the surviving channel are no longer suppressed completely but reduced in power by a factor called drop factor Ddrop that is varied during the investigations.
with the characteristic power P0ESA. With this result, the expression:
allows to determine the required duration of the zero period, where τ3 stands for the lifetime of the pump level and αfit is a parameter derived from different constants such as the density of the erbium ions. When added to
In particular, setting the duration of the zero period Δtzero to values giving minimum overshoots results in the curve 144. Aiming for minimum undershoots at maximum duration of the zero period leads to the grey dashed curve 146. The dashed curve 145 shows the maximum magnitude of gain variations for settings of the duration of the “zero period” Δtzero which lead to minimum variation of the population probability in the pump level. Curve 143 shows the maximum gain variations for conventional feedforward controls with “zero period” Δtzero=0. For drop factors Ddrop 142 smaller than 0.2, all shown settings of the duration different to zero (curves 144,145 and 146) give identical results that are significantly better as compared with the case without “zero period” Δtzero (curve 143). At larger values of the drop factor, settings according to equation (7) lead to variations that are smaller or only marginally larger than the results “zero period” Δtzero (curve 143). Nevertheless, the gain variations could be reduced by choosing slightly smaller durations. In conclusion, setting the duration of the “zero period” Δtzero according to equation (7), i.e. Δtzero=Δtoptzero, gives significant improvement of transient performance for the most important scenarios. Furthermore, the implementation of the technique is very easy.
The duration from the start of the drop until the final value has been reached is called transition time ttrans. Evolution of the input power versus time is shown in
The simulations include the effect of “spectral hole burning”. It is assumed that a digital signal processor (DSP) capable of calculating updates of the required pump power every 1 μs is used. Thus, pump powers Ppumpeff|(i) 169b may be calculated. Using equation (7), the corresponding durations of the zero period Δtoptzero|(i) 169a can be calculated. The sum of these durations gives
This means that the durations Δtoptzero|(i) 169a calculated successively sum up to the duration that is calculated for a immediate drop to the final value. Although these mathematical calculations are exact, some further corrections may be required. Due to the use of a digital signal processor DSP, the minimum duration of a zero period is approximately 1 μs and it may be favourable to sum up the small durations until the sum equals at least 0.5 μs before setting the pump power to zero and to set the pump power to the same pump power level as a standard feedforward control would do. Setting the pump power to a slightly reduced power level different from zero may also introduce a reduction of the population probability of the pump level. This has to be taken into account by a different correction factor. Results of the simulations indicate that equation (7) may overestimate the optimum duration of the zero period for small values. Since the zero periods calculated step by step can be quite small, some scaling may help to improve transient performance.
An algorithm can be implemented according to the following considerations.
First, a variable Δtoptzero|memory representing the accumulated values Δtoptzero|(i) 169a that have not been taken into account by a zero period can be introduced. At the beginning, the variable may be set to zero. Successively, the following steps may be repeated continuously.
1) The appropriate pump power according to the rules used for a standard feedforward control is calculated and the effective pump power is derived by making use of equation (6);
2) The corresponding duration of the zero period is determined following equation (7) which is scaled according to
where Δtoptzero|ref is a constant value that takes into account that equation (7) can overestimate the optimum duration for small values. A typical value of this constant may be in the range from 1 μs to 10 μs. Finally, the result can be added to the variable Δtoptzero|memory. It should be noted that this step can be considered optional.
3) The pump power can be set to zero if Δtoptzero|memory≧0.5 Δtsamp and Δtoptzero|memory can be reduced by the duration of one sampling period Δtsamp, i.e. the time interval between two samples of the signals. Otherwise, the pump power may be set to the value of a standard feedforward control and the equation:
can be applied in order to take into account the effect on the population of the pump level.
The above described implementation according to one embodiment of the invention provides a significant reduction of overshoots, especially for transition times up to 1 ms.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
09 175 269 | Nov 2009 | EP | regional |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/EP2010/066944 | 11/5/2010 | WO | 00 | 5/7/2012 |