The present invention relates to fine needle aspiration biopsies and, more particularly, to identifying and aspirating desired tissue to be biopsied.
Fine needle aspiration (“FNA”) biopsy (“FNAB”) is the standard evaluation of a thyroid nodule of a patient. Ultrasound guidance has been used to image the target tissue and guide the needle of a syringe to the tissue to be biopsied. Once the needle is guided to the tissue to be biopsied, a plunger of the syringe is moved to create a vacuum that aspirates the tissue. Diagnostic determination of the tissue requires a certain number of cells. If insufficient cells are aspirated, the biopsy procedure must be performed again, usually 2-6 months later.
It is estimated that more than 600,000 FNAB procedures are performed each year in the United States. The number of biopsies that yield insufficient cells to make a diagnostic determination ranges from 7 to 17%. Even in an elite academic thyroid center using ultrasound guidance, insufficient FNA biopsies occurred in 17% of 3,589 nodules biopsied.
Even if the needle is disposed in a position to aspirate the desired cells at the beginning of aspiration, manual manipulation of the device is required for aspiration and typically results in axial movement of the needle. This axial movement can result in insufficient biopsies and/or cells being aspirated from non-desired tissue.
The American Thyroid Association, as well as most endocrinologists and endocrine surgeons, recommend a total or near-total thyroidectomy for well-differentiated thyroid cancer. A total thyroidectomy allows for better use of Iodine-131 (131I) for postsurgical treatment because of a statistically significant improved overall survival and decreased recurrence rate. Because patients with “indeterminate” thyroid nodules are not known to have the certain diagnosis of cancer preoperatively, clinical decision making incorporates surgical judgment. Most surgeons prefer to treat patients with indeterminate nodules as though they did in fact have a cancer. A total or near-total thyroidectomy is performed as the initial operation in these situations, which subjects these patients to all of the risks of thyroidectomy. These risks include permanent bilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve injury which requires a permanent tracheotomy and permanent hyperparathyroidism which requires calcium supplementation, having clinical consequences, as well as the need for life-long thyroid-hormone replacement treatments. The present invention is directed to solving these and other problems.
In accordance with one embodiment, a device for performing fine-needle aspiration of tissue includes a syringe and a holder. The syringe includes a fiber optic probe, a plunger, and a needle. The fiber optic probe is configured to move within a lumen of the needle. The fiber optic probe is guided into the needle by a fiber optic channel. The plunger is configured to create a vacuum in the needle. The holder includes a coupling mechanism, a first actuator, and a second actuator. The coupling mechanism coupling the syringe in a fixed position relative to the holder. The first actuator being configured to extend the fiber optic probe into the needle and to retract the fiber optic probe from the needle. The second actuator is configured to extend the plunger thereby creating a vacuum within the needle.
In accordance with another embodiment, a method for performing fine-needle aspiration of tissue includes the steps of inserting a needle having a fiber optic probe disposed therein into tissue of a patient including tissue to be biopsied, generating an optical spectrum of tissue disposed proximate to a distal end of the needle, determining a spectral signature of the proximate tissue using the optical spectrum, removing the fiber optic probe from the needle, and aspirating the proximate tissue by moving a plunger to create vacuum in the needle.
In accordance with yet another embodiment, a device for performing fine-needle aspiration of tissue includes a syringe and a holder. The syringe includes a fiber optic channel, a barrel, and a needle. The fiber optic channel has a fiber optic probe disposed for movement therein. The barrel has a plunger disposed for movement therein. The needle has a lumen extending from a distal end to a proximal end of the needle. The proximal end of the lumen is operatively connected to both the fiber optic channel and the barrel. The lumen is configured to receive the fiber optic probe. The holder is configured to receive the syringe and includes a first actuator and a second actuator. The first actuator configured to extend the fiber optic probe from the fiber optic channel and into the lumen, and further configured to retract the fiber optic probe from the lumen. The second actuator is configured to slide the plunger, thereby causing material to move from the distal end of the lumen toward the barrel.
In accordance with still yet another embodiment, a device for performing fine-needle aspiration of tissue includes a biopsy needle, a fiber optic probe, and an actuator. The biopsy needle has a hollow core and is mounted to a handle. The biopsy needle includes a distal end adapted for insertion into tissue and a proximal end adapted for coupling to the handle. The biopsy needle is coupled to a vacuum source whereby vacuum can be selectively applied to the biopsy needle. The fiber optic is probe coupled to the biopsy needle and adapted to translate through the hollow core of the biopsy needle to the distal end and to be retracted from the biopsy needle. The actuator is coupled to the fiber optic probe to move the fiber optic probe through the hollow core of the biopsy needle and retract the fiber optic probe from the hollow core of the biopsy needle.
The invention may best be understood by reference to the following description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:
Although the invention will be described in connection with certain preferred embodiments, it will be understood that the invention is not limited to those particular embodiments. On the contrary, the invention is intended to cover all alternatives, modifications, and equivalent arrangements as may be included within the spirit and scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims.
It has been determined that one common reason for cellular insufficiency during an FNA thyroid biopsy is cystic degeneration of the nodule. Cystic degeneration results in a fibrous nodule with small pockets that have degenerated into fluid. This fluid volume may be in pockets that are sub-millimeter in size. At this size, the resolution of the ultrasound machine is too coarse to distinguish the difference between the tissue and the fluid pockets. Thus, even when the FNAB device is guided by real-time ultrasound imaging, the FNAB device may be sampling fluid rather than tissue.
Optical tissue diagnosis mediated by fiber-optic probes can be used to perform noninvasive or minimally invasive real time assessment of tissue pathology in situ. One method of performing this assessment can include the use of elastic scattering spectroscopy (“ESS”). ESS provides a point spectroscopic measurement of subcellular micromorphology and cellular composition of a tissue, using electromagnetic radiation in a broad wavelength range (e.g., 320-900 nm in one example system). Markers include size and hyperchromaticity of cell nuclei, chromatin granularity, nuclear crowding, and changes in the size and/or density of mitochondria and other cellular organelles. ESS spectra derive from the wavelength-dependent optical scattering efficiency and the effects of changes in the scattering phase function (e.g., the angular probability distribution for scattering), caused by the optical index gradients (e.g., due to cellular and subcellular structures). Normal and abnormal tissues generate different scattering spectral signatures as a result of changes in nuclear size, density, granularity of the chromatin, mitochondrial swelling, and other subcellular structural changes. These different scattering spectral signatures represent the optical-spectroscopy equivalent of histological appearances. The ESS method senses those morphology differences in a semi-quantitative manner, without actually imaging the microscopic structure. An important advantage of ESS is that it may provide a real-time objective and semi-quantitative assessment of tissue pathology that may not require on-site special expertise and/or subjective image interpretation as in conventional histopathology. ESS is also convenient: the unit used is lightweight and mobile, and the ESS probe can fit through a conventional 21-23 gauge needle for a minimally invasive diagnosis. A measurement is rendered in less than 250 ms and can be triggered by, for example, a simple foot pedal. Examples of ESS systems capable of performing this assessment are described in papers and publications listed in the ESS References section below, which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety.
Advantageously, an FNAB device incorporating an ESS probe disposed near the tip of the needle is able to report whether the needle tip is sensing fluid or solid tissue. For example, the probe can be guided to a nodule using ultrasound imaging, record optical spectra, and be repositioned within the nodule until the returned optical spectrum indicates solid tissue disposed proximate to the needle tip.
The fiber optic probe 106 can move within the lumen of the needle 104. The slide mechanism 112 is coupled to the fiber optic probe 106 and is configured to slide the distal end of the fiber optic probe between a deployed position and a retracted position. Fine needle aspiration (FNA) needles typically range from 23 gauge to 27 gauge. More preferably, the needle 104 is 25 gauge. The fiber optic probe 106 is flexible and includes fiber optic cable. In order for the fiber optic probe 106 to move within the lumen of the needle, the outer diameter of the fiber optic probe 106 must be less than the inner diameter of the needle, but should not be so small that binding occurs when the fiber optic probe 106 is pushed from the proximate end. For example, a fiber optic probe 106 with an outer diameter of 346 μm can be used with a 23 gauge needle having an inner diameter of 370 μm.
As used herein, “distal end” refers generally to a portion of the object nearer to a patient while in use and “proximal end” refers generally to a portion of the object nearer to a practitioner, unless otherwise specified. For example, a distal end of a needle is the end that pierces a patient's skin and a proximal end of the needle is the end that connects to the barrel of a syringe.
When in the deployed position, the distal end of the fiber optic probe 106 is disposed near the tip 114. When in the retracted position, the fiber optic probe 106 is disposed such that material near the tip 114 may be aspirated through the needle 104. In the illustrated embodiment, the fiber optic probe 106 is disposed in the deployed position.
The plunger 108 slides within a plunger chamber (
The aspiration channel 204 is between the needle 104 and a plunger chamber 208. Movement of the plunger 108 creates negative or positive pressure in the plunger chamber 208 because of the airtight seal between the plunger 108 and plunger chamber 208. The aspiration channel 204 communicates these pressures to the needle 104. Thus, outward movement of the plunger 108 creates negative pressure in the plunger chamber 208, which creates negative pressure at the tip 114. The negative pressure at the tip 114 results in a vacuum that aspirates material disposed proximate to the tip 114. The plunger 108 includes a spring 210 that biases the plunger 108 outward. The plunger 108 also includes a locking channel 212 that is selectively engaged by locking mechanism 110. When engaged, locking channel 212 prevents both inward and outward movement of the plunger 108.
The FNAB device 100 is configured to be held and operated substantially with a single hand. The device 100 can be gripped with a “pencil grip” where the barrel 102 is grasped generally between the practitioner's thumb, index finger, and middle finger. Advantageously, the pencil grip and single-handed operation minimizes accidental movement of the tip 114. In the illustrated embodiment, the device 100 is designed to be grasped in the practitioner's right hand. The locking mechanism 110 is disposed in a location where it can be easily actuated from the engaged position to the disengaged position by the thumb of the practitioner. Additionally, accidental axial movement of the tip 114 occurs when the practitioner has to manually move the plunger 108. This is typically accomplished by the practitioner grasping the barrel 102 with one hand and the plunger 108 with the other, then moving the hands in opposite directions. The forces exerted by each hand fluctuate, leading to accidental axial movement of the tip 114. Use of the spring 210 to move the plunger 108 decreases the accidental axial movement of the tip 114 during aspiration because the force exerted is internal to the device 100 and evenly placed.
When a desired spectrum is obtained, the fiber optic probe 106 is fully retracted to the retracted position at step 414. The desired tissue is then aspirated at step 416. The plunger 108 is moved outwardly, creating negative pressure in the plunger chamber 208. The negative pressure aspirates tissue disposed proximate the tip 114 into the plunger chamber through the needle 104 and aspiration channel 204. After the sample is taken, the device is removed from the tissue and the sample of aspirated tissue is subjected to diagnostic tests.
Actuator-control buttons 508a, b are used to control an actuator or actuators that move the fiber optic probe 106 and/or the plunger 108. In the illustrated embodiment, the forward button 508a controls motion of both the fiber optic probe 106 and the plunger 108 toward the tip 114 and the rearward button 508b controls motion of both the fiber optic probe 106 and the plunger 108 away from the tip 114. In this embodiment, the plunger 108 and the fiber optic probe 106 are operatively coupled in order to prevent the fiber optic probe 106 and the plunger 108 from interfering with each other. Beneficially, the sequential process of the technique allows for automatic rejection of inadvertent actuations of the buttons 508a,b, 510 and provides both visual and auditory feedback to the practitioner for the mistaken button press. Alternatively, four buttons may be provided where the first and the second control the inward and outward movement of the fiber optic probe 106 and the third and the fourth control inward and outward movement of the plunger 108.
The syringe 500b is coupled to the holder 500a by placing the syringe 500b within the bore 504 of the holder. The syringe 500b is placed such that the threading 620 of the plunger half-nut 614 and the probe half-nut 618 engage the threading 610 of the lead screw 608. The plunger half-nut 614 engages the lead screw 608 and moves laterally along a line parallel to the axis of the lead screw 608. The probe half-nut 618 engages the lead screw 608 and moves laterally along a line parallel to the axis of the lead screw 608 that is rotated about 90° from the line of the plunger half-nut 614. The line of the probe half-nut 618 is rotated from the line of the plunger half-nut 614 so that movement of the fiber optic probe 106 does not interfere with movement of the plunger 108. The holder 500b is closed by pivoting about hinges 622. When closed, a friction-fit is formed between the syringe 500a and the holder 500b that prevents movement of the barrel 502 relative to the bore 504. It is contemplated that other forms of actuation may be used. In some embodiments, the fiber optic probe 106 is driven by a first actuator and the plunger 108 is driven by a second actuator, separate from the first.
With reference to
In one example device, the fiber optic probe included fiber optic cables with approximately 125 μm center-to-center separation. The illumination cable was approximately 150 μm in diameter and the collection cable was approximately 100 μm in diameter. The probe is sensitive to both scattering and absorption properties in the tissue because of the small separation of the fiber optic cables. An example UV-visible spectroscopic system used a pulsed broadband Xenon arc lamp as the light source. The light source resulted in a useful system response that covered a spectral range of about 320 nm to about 800 nm. Five measurements were taken on each specific site in the thyroid gland during ultrasound-guided FNAB. The five measurements were then averaged to represent the ESS spectrum for that site. The procedure was repeated in 3 to 6 sites in the gland; however, the cells were aspired only from the last site, which was used to correlate ESS measurements with the cytological assessment. Measurements were taken in the presence of ambient room illumination with background subtraction. The spectral response of each system was calibrated by recording a reference spectrum from a spectrally-flat diffuse reflector SPECTRALON® (Labsphere, Inc., North Sutton, N.H.). Thus, the displayed spectra were calculated according to:
In some embodiments, optical techniques other than ESS are employed to distinguish whether desired tissue to be aspirated is disposed near the tip. Nonlimiting examples of these techniques include use of optical spectroscopy such as fluorescence spectroscopy, Raman spectroscopy, and other forms of diffuse reflectance spectroscopy.
Surprisingly, integration of an ESS probe with FNA device yielded a very low rate of insufficient biopsies. In one example, 92 biopsies resulted in only 3 insufficient biopsies. This equates to an insufficiency rate of 3.3%, which is lower than any insufficiency rate in any published series.
Advantageously, systems, methods, and devices in accord with the disclosed concepts can reduce the number of insufficient biopsies. An insufficient biopsy is estimated to occur in more than 100,000 individuals each year. The reduced insufficiency rate would result in an estimated savings of $50 million annually.
In some embodiments, devices in accord with the present concepts are completely disposable. In some embodiments, the holder is reusable and the syringe is disposable, including the fiber optic probe. Beneficially, this combination lowers cost per use because the circuitry and components of the holder are typically too costly to be disposable while the syringe can be produced relatively inexpensively. In this embodiment, the holder can be easily disinfected between procedures without substantial disassembly. Additionally, the disposable nature of the syringe eliminates the need for on-site sterilization leading to safer procedures and increased clinical acceptability.
In some embodiments, the device does not include a plunger. In these embodiments, negative pressure and aspiration are created by a vacuum pump. The vacuum can be actuated by, for example, a foot pedal provided to the practitioner or a button incorporated on the device.
While the concepts disclosed herein have been described with reference to thyroid nodules, it is contemplated that devices and techniques can be beneficial in analyzing liver cancer, probing pulmonary lymph nodes, identifying the parathyroid during laparoscopic surgery, analyzing other solid organ pathologies.
It will be evident to those skilled in the art that the invention is not limited to the details of the foregoing illustrated embodiment and that the present invention may be embodied in other specific forms without departing from the spirit or essential attributes thereof. The present embodiment is therefore to be considered in all respects as illustrative and not restrictive, the scope of the invention being indicated by the appended claims rather than by the foregoing description, and all changes which come within the meaning and range of equivalency of the claims are therefore intended to be embraced therein.
This application claims benefit under 35 U.S.C. §119(e) of the U.S. Provisional Application No. 61/759,748, filed Feb. 1, 2013, the content of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/US14/13804 | 1/30/2014 | WO | 00 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61759748 | Feb 2013 | US |