The invention relates to optically resonant sensing devices, and more particularly to devices for sensing rotation.
Gyroscopes are important for applications in navigation, guidance, and control. Many of these applications would benefit from miniaturization due to concerns with system cost, size, weight, and power. However, the possibilities for miniaturization are limited because the designs for conventional gyroscopes tend to exhibit better sensitivity and resolution at larger scales.
Consequently, there is a need for a new type of gyroscope that can be miniaturized with minimal to no impact on performance.
The inventors have developed a Sagnac effect-based optomechanical gyroscope (Sagnac OM gyroscope) for the sensing of rotation. This Sagnac OM gyroscope can be miniaturized with minimal to no impact on performance.
Rotation is detected through its effect on the mechanical angular frequency of a circulating optical resonator. Optomechanical oscillation arises because of the radiation pressure exerted on the circulating optical resonator by circulating light. Through the optomechanical spring effect, the mechanical angular frequency is sensitive to the optical flux within the circulating optical resonator. In turn, the optical flux depends on the amount of detuning between the circulating optical resonator and the optical frequency of the laser that drives it. The Sagnac effect provides the link between the amount of detuning and the externally imposed angular rotation of the circulating optical resonator.
The Sagnac effect is an interference phenomenon caused by rotation. A beam of light is split and one of the two resultant beams is injected into a circulating optical resonator that may be subject to rotation. In other embodiments, the two beams are both injected into the same circulating optical resonator, but in opposite directions. In yet other embodiments, the two beams are injected into two separate, but identical, circulating optical resonators, again in opposite directions. In each case, upon exiting the circulating optical resonator(s), the light beams are combined and undergo interference. The relative phases of the two beams, and thus the position of the interference fringes, are shifted according to the angular velocity of the circulating optical resonator(s). In operation, when the Sagnac OM gyroscope is irrotational, i.e., when the circulating optical resonator(s) is not rotating, the two beams travel at a constant speed and the position of the interference fringes does not change. However, when the Sagnac OM gyroscope is rotated, one beam will slow with respect to the other beam causing the position of the interference fringes to change.
Analysis of the Sagnac OM gyroscope has shown that reducing its size improves its sensitivity to rotation as measured by a scale factor equal to the ratio of the change in the mechanical angular frequency to the externally imposed angular rotation frequency.
Accordingly, the invention in a first embodiment relates to a method for detecting rotation. Input light is injected into a circulating optical resonator so as to excite an optical resonance within the resonator. “Circulating optical resonator” means a ring-shaped optical resonator, a disk-shaped optical resonator, or any other optical resonator in which the resonant optical field propagates around a closed curvilinear loop. The injected input light has a power level greater than a threshold for exciting optomechanical oscillation of the circulating optical resonator at a mechanical angular frequency.
Output light is taken from the circulating optical resonator and a modulation sideband, due to modulation of the input light at the mechanical angular frequency, is isolated, for example, by bandpass filtering of the output of a photodetector coupled so as to detect the output light. A measurement is made of the frequency shift of the modulation sideband from its frequency under irrotational conditions.
The invention in a second embodiment relates to a Sagnac OM gyroscope for detecting rotation. The Sagnac OM gyroscope includes a circulating optical resonator, a waveguide evanescently coupled to the resonator so as to provide an input path for input light to the resonator and an output path for output light from the resonator, a photodetector, and a signal-processing circuit.
The photodetector is coupled to the output path so as to receive at least a portion of the output light from the circulating optical resonator, and it is configured to provide an output detector signal in response to the coupled output light. The output detector signal includes the instantaneous mechanical angular frequency.
The signal-processing circuit is configured to determine the difference between the instantaneous mechanical angular frequency of the output detector signal and an irrotational mechanical angular frequency.
In other embodiments, the Sagnac OM gyroscope includes first and second circulating optical resonators, each having a respective input path for input light and a respective output path for output light, and each resonator being coupled through its respective output path to a respective photodetector. The light in the first circulating optical resonator circulates in the opposite direction of the light in the second circulating optical resonator. The signal-processing circuit is configured to determine the difference between the instantaneous mechanical angular frequencies of the two detector output signals.
In at least one embodiment, a respective bandpass filter is coupled to each of the photodetectors and configured to isolate an instantaneous mechanical angular frequency in the detector output signal before the detector output signal is provided to the signal-processing circuit.
In at least one embodiment, the signal-processing circuit is configured to mix the respective detector output signals so as to produce an output signal indicative of the difference between the instantaneous mechanical angular frequencies of the two detector output signals. For example, these operations may be provided by an analog phase detector with frequency mixing.
As illustrated in
For convenience, the geometrical configuration of the circulating optical resonator in the following discussion will be referred to as a “disk.” However, this terminology is to be understood as non-limiting, and as inclusive of any other suitable resonator geometries, including a ring and other closed curvilinear loop geometries.
Optomechanical oscillation is excited by driving the circulating optical resonator 120 with a laser 130 whose optical output power exceeds the threshold required to overcome intrinsic mechanical damping and whose output wavelength is blue-shifted relative to the unperturbed resonant peak wavelength of the resonator 120. See T. O. Rocheleau et al., “Enhancement of Mechanical Q for Low Phase Noise Optomechanical Oscillators,” IEEE 26th International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (2013), which is incorporated herein by reference. Unperturbed means absent a perturbation by externally imposed angular rotation, i.e., under irrotational conditions. Blue-shifted means shifted toward a higher energy or, equivalently, toward a shorter wavelength and corresponding higher frequency.
In the absence of noise and rotation, the optomechanical oscillation frequency will occur at a mechanical angular frequency Ωm0. This mechanical angular frequency Ωm0 is also referred to as the “irrotational mechanical angular frequency.” Due to modulation of the resonant wave by the vibrating circulating optical resonator 120, the spectral content of the output light will contain modulation sidebands displaced from the wavelength of the laser 130 by integer multiples of the mechanical angular frequency Ωm0.
Turning to
While
The change in the detuning, acting through the optomechanical spring effect, also causes a corresponding shift Ωm′ in the mechanical angular frequency. Referring again to
As those skilled in the art will appreciate, the frequency shift of the sidebands provides an indication of the externally imposed angular rotation frequency due to the Sagnac effect. In a sideband produced by an Nth-order harmonic (N being an integer ≥2), the rotation-induced frequency shift is multiplied by a factor of N. This can be especially advantageous when the harmonic sideband is stronger in power than the fundamental sideband. See F. Liu and M. Hossein-Zadeh, “On the Spectrum of Radiation Pressure Driven Optomechanical Oscillator and Its Application in Sensing,” Opt. Comm. Vol. 294, PP. 338-343 (2013), which is incorporated herein by reference.
The frequency shift can be measured by comparing the output light of the circulating optical resonator 120 with the output of a reference oscillator, for example, the frequency ω0 of laser 130. However, better measurements may be obtained by comparing the outputs of two circulating optical resonators that are respectively excited by input light injected in oppositely circulating directions. In this dual circulating optical resonator embodiment of the present invention, the output signal magnitude is doubled and common-mode noise is reduced relative to a single circulating optical resonator embodiment of the present invention.
As seen in
The force F on moveable mirror 320 due to radiation pressure is proportional to the photon flux impinging on the moveable mirror 320, and it is inversely proportional to the moveable mirror position x(t). The photon flux, in turn, is proportional to the energy in the optical field, divided by the round-trip propagation time τrt within the optical resonator 300, which is proportional to the (one-way) propagation distance L+x(t).
Accordingly, an optomechanical stiffness kdba induced by dynamical back-action can be found, where kdba is defined as ∂F/∂x. This linear optical resonator model thus shows that kdba is inversely proportional to L2. Applying this linear optical resonator model to a disk circulating optical resonator shows that kdba in a disk of radius R will be inversely proportional to R2. The mechanical angular frequency Ωm0 is given by the equation:
with meff being the effective mass of the circulating optical resonator. For disk-shaped circulating optical resonators, meff is proportional to R2, and Ωm0 is therefore proportional to 1/R.
In the presence of optomechanics, the instantaneous mechanical angular frequency is given by:
Back-substituting for each element's proportionality to R results in:
It will be seen from equation 4c that the shift Ωm′ in mechanical angular frequency due to the presence of the optical field is proportional to 1/R3 for a disk-shaped circulating optical resonator. This shows that the optomechanical spring effect is highly sensitive to radius.
One can calculate the optical resonant frequency of the rotating circulating optical resonator, ωc, by equating the round-trip phase to an integer multiple of 2π:
where m is a non-zero integer, c is the speed of light, and neff is the effective refractive index in the circulating optical resonator. Solving for the optical resonant frequency, one obtains:
ωc=ωc0+ω′ (6b)
The Sagnac-induced shift ω′ of the optical resonant frequency ωc0 due to rotation is then given by the following, where λc0 and ωc0 are respectively the optical resonant wavelength and frequency in the absence of rotation, and Ωrot is the externally imposed angular rotation rate:
The optomechanical stiffness kdba induced by dynamical back-action is given by:
where Pin is the input optical power, κex the external coupling rate to a waveguide [rad/sec], Δ is the laser detuning (Δ=ωc0−ω0), κ is the loaded optical linewidth, i.e., the full width at half maximum (FWHM, in angular frequency units) of the loaded circulating optical resonator, and Ωm0 is the mechanical angular frequency of the unperturbed resonator. The term outside the brackets is just the radiation pressure force multiplied by δωc/δR while the term inside the brackets is proportional to the Lorentzian line shape evaluated at the stokes and anti-stokes sideband frequencies.
Assuming that kdba is in the unresolved sideband regime (see T. Kippenberg and K. Vahala, “Cavity Opto-Mechanics,” Optics Express 15.25 (2007) 17172-17205, which is incorporated herein by reference), the optical linewidth and laser detuning are large compared to the mechanical angular frequency: κ, Δ>>Ωm0>>1. Setting Ωm0˜0 in equation (8) yields:
The shift in the mechanical angular frequency in the presence of radiation pressure and rotation based upon equation (3) is:
Expanding the laser detuning, A, and substituting equations (6b) and (7b) for the cavity resonant frequency, ωc, yields:
A Taylor expansion about RΩrot/c=0, as c >>RΩrot, simplifies equation (11) to:
Ω′m=Ω′m(dba)+Ω′m(Rot) (12b)
where Ω′m (dba) is the dynamical back-action contribution to the mechanical angular frequency and Δ0 is the laser detuning under irrotational conditions. Ω′m (Rot) is the correction to the mechanical angular frequency due purely to rotation, and is given by:
Looking at the scaling of equation (13) with respect to radius R, the unperturbed mechanical frequency, Ωm0, scales as 1/R and the effective mass, meff, scales with R2 for a disk-shaped circulating optical resonator. The loaded optical linewidth remains essentially constant for radius R values greater than about 40 μm for PSG and greater than about 10 μm for bulk silicon nitride circulating optical resonators. Assuming the radius R is kept above the critical radius at which the loaded optical linewidth begins to degrade, there is a 1/R2 pre-factor multiplying the terms in parentheses in equation (13). Thus, unlike traditional optical and MEMs gyroscopes, the signal is enhanced by reducing the radius in a Sagnac OM gyroscope in accordance with at least one embodiment of the present invention.
The scale factor in the unresolved sideband regime is then:
which results in the scale factor being proportional to 1/R2. Note that equation (14) was multiplied by a factor of two due to the differential output, described in reference below to
The optical quality factor QOpt is only weakly dependent on radius R for a bulk silicon nitride disk-shaped circulating optical resonator for R>10 μm and for a PSG disk-shaped resonator for R>40 Under the assumption that QOpt is independent of radius, the scale factor Ω′m(Rot)/Ωrot for the circulating optical resonator is expected to scale as 1/R2 in disk-shaped resonators and roughly as 1/R in ring-shaped resonators.
It will be understood from
Based upon above equation (14) for Ω′m(Rot)/Ωrot, it can be observed that the scale factor is highly sensitive to the loaded optical linewidth κ. As a consequence, a high optical quality factor QOpt is necessary.
Thermomechanical Brownian motion was considered in order to estimate a fundamental noise limit for a Sagnac OM gyroscope in accordance with at least one embodiment of the invention. Starting with the Sagnac OM gyroscope output as:
Output=KΩrot+Offset+Noise(t), (15)
with K being the scale factor defined above as Ω′m(Rot)/Ωrot. As long as the offset is repeatable, then it can be calibrated out. Since one cannot calibrate out the time varying noise, the Brownian-based noise limit can be defined as a noise equivalent rotation rate:
Ωnoise=Noise(t)/K. (16)
Turning next to the Schawlow-Townes equation for linewidth narrowing, in accordance with M. Hossein-Zadeh et al., “Characterization of a Radiation-pressure-driven Micromechanical Oscillator,” Phys. Rev. A, Vol. 74, No. 2, PP. 023813-1-023813-15 (2006), which is incorporated herein by reference, one finds:
in which kB is the Boltzmann constant, T is temperature, and x is the mechanical oscillation amplitude. Through numerical simulation of a disk-shaped circulating optical resonator, it was determined that δΩ has a 1/R3 dependence.
The Allan deviation σ(τ), which is a measure of frequency stability in an oscillator during an averaging time τ, is:
Back substituting in the Allan deviation found in equation (18) for each element's R dependence reveals:
σ(τ)∝1/√{square root over (R)} (19b)
Returning to equation (16) and the noise equivalent rotation rate:
Again, back substituting for each element's R dependence shows:
Ωnoise∝√{square root over (R)} (21b)
As the signal-to-noise ratio is inversely proportional to Ωnoise, the signal-to-noise ratio is therefore proportional to 1/√R. Consequently, and in contrast to a conventional resonant optical gyroscope, the angle random-walk-limited resolution in at least some embodiments of the present invention due to Brownian motion is expected to improve as the disk radius R decreases.
In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the photocurrents from the photodetectors 550A, 550B will be amplified by a gain factor G (exemplarily by transimpedance amplifiers, not illustrated) either before or after bandpass filtering by a respective bandpass filter 560A, 560B. The bandpass filters 560A, 560B are used to isolate the desired harmonic from the circulating optical resonator 540. When transimpedance amplifiers are employed, instead of filtered photocurrents IA and IB, the input signals to the signal-processing circuit 570 will be amplified and filtered photovoltages VA and VB.
In the single circulating optical resonator arrangement of
The output voltage signal represented in the figure by
is an example output signal produced by the signal-processing circuit 570 employing an analog phase detector that uses frequency mixing. The output of the frequency mixer is proportional to a phase difference, which is the frequency difference multiplied by time. In order to isolate the frequency difference, the frequency mixer output is differentiated with respect to time.
It will be understood that a signal-processing circuit 570 comprising an analog phase detector is a nonlimiting example, and that alternative signal processing methods are also suitable, including digital methods for frequency mixing and phase detection. To the extent a digital signal-processing circuit is employed, the analog output from the photodetectors 550A, 550B may be digitized by an analog-to-digital converter (ADC). Alternatively, to the extent a digital signal-processing circuit is employed, the analog output from the bandpass filters 560A, 560B may be digitized by an ADC. As yet another alternative, to the extent a digital signal-processing circuit is employed, the analog output from the transimpedance amplifiers, not illustrated, may be digitized by an ADC. It will also be understood that once the signal has been digitized, it may be bandpass filtered in the digital domain and/or it may undergo amplification in the digital domain. As the ADC may be placed at a number of different points within the electrical signal path, use of the term “electrically coupled” means coupled either directly or indirectly, i.e., via one or more intervening electrical elements.
In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the photocurrent from the photodetectors 650A, 650B will be amplified by a gain factor G (exemplarily by transimpedance amplifiers) either before or after bandpass filtering by a respective bandpass filter 660A, 660B. The bandpass filters 660A, 660B are used to isolate the desired harmonic from each circulating optical resonator 640A, 640B. When transimpedance amplifiers are employed, instead of filtered photocurrents IA and IB, the input signals to the signal-processing circuit 670 will be amplified and filtered photovoltages VA and VB.
In the dual circulating optical resonator arrangement of
The output voltage signal represented in the figure by
is an example output signal produced by the signal-processing circuit 670 employing an analog phase detector that uses frequency mixing. The output of the frequency mixer is proportional to a phase difference, which is the frequency difference multiplied by time. In order to isolate the frequency difference, the frequency mixer output is differentiated with respect to time.
It will be understood that a signal-processing circuit 670 comprising an analog phase detector is a nonlimiting example, and that alternative signal processing methods are also suitable, including digital methods for frequency mixing and phase detection. To the extent a digital signal-processing circuit is employed, the analog output from the photodetectors 650A, 650B may be digitized by an ADC. Alternatively, to the extent a digital signal-processing circuit is employed, the analog output from the bandpass filters 660A, 660B may be digitized by an ADC. As yet another alternative, to the extent a digital signal-processing circuit is employed, the analog output from the transimpedance amplifiers, not illustrated, may be digitized by an ADC. It will also be understood that once the signal has been digitized, it may be bandpass filtered in the digital domain and/or it may undergo amplification in the digital domain.
A typical ring 710 has a radius R in the range of 10-200 μm, though the radius R is preferably in the range of 10-30 μm for a ring 710 formed of PSG and in the range of 40-60 μm for a ring 710 formed of bulk SiN. Typical widths for the ring 710 are in the range of 3-10 while typical widths for the spokes 720 are in the range of 0.5-3 μm. An example material composition for the ring 710, as well as for the evanescently coupled waveguide, not illustrated, is PSG. An alternative composition is bulk SiN. Other compositions are considered to lie within from the scope of the invention.
It should be noted that the circulating optical resonator design of
In one alternative embodiment of the present invention, each anchor 730 includes a plurality of small holes. The small holes may be, for example, 1.5 μm wide and 3 μm deep. An advantage offered by such holes is that they are unlikely to be filled by photoresist that is spun onto the wafer at a typical rotational speed such as 3K rpm. As a consequence, the total amount of surface topography that is of account in subsequent lithographic processing can be reduced, i.e., these small holes eliminate the need for planarization that may be required for large anchors 730, as planarization is needed for good lithography during subsequent patterning.
It should also be noted that the spokes 720 are advantageous because they increase the mechanical quality factor QMech of the micro-ring circulating optical resonator 700. That is, propagation of acoustic waves into the anchor 730 is a loss mechanism. The spokes 720 reduce this loss because they offer only a thin channel for acoustic propagation toward the anchor 730.
Although narrower spokes 720 lead to less acoustic loss, there is a limit to how narrow they can be made. That is, if the spokes 720 are made too narrow, they will fail to support the ring 710 properly. For example, if stress is present in the ring 710, it may tend to curl up if it receives inadequate support from the spokes 720. Because stress tends to bend the ring 710 out of plane, the width of the spokes 720 should increase as the radius R increases in order to provide adequate support. By way of illustration, a design study on bulk silicon nitride rings showed that for a ring 710 having a radius R greater than 50 μm, it would be necessary to use spokes 720 wider than 2 μm. See S.-S. Li et al., “Micromechanical ‘Hollow-Disk’ Ring Resonators,” 17th IEEE International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (2004), which is incorporated herein by reference.
Any of following fabrication processes may be used to make Sagnac OM gyroscopes in accordance with the various embodiments of the invention as described herein.
PSG Timed Release Process with Pedestal.
As shown in
As shown in
PSG Process on SOI with Anchors.
As shown in
As shown in
A useful reference on PSG photonic integrated circuit platforms for optomechanical systems is K. E. Grater et al., “A Platform for On-Chip Silica Optomechanical Oscillators with Integrated Waveguides,” Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics 2012, OSA Technical Digest, paper CW1M.5, which is hereby incorporated herein by reference.
Bulk Silicon Nitride on Silicon Process with Anchors.
As shown in
The silicon wafer 1000 may optionally be planarized. Then, as shown in
The silicon wafer 1000 is then optionally planarized by depositing a thermal silicon dioxide layer, not illustrated, and subjecting the silicon wafer 1000 to a chemical-mechanical polish (CMP) process. A wet etch to remove the thermal silicon dioxide layer completes the planarization and exposes the SiN layer.
The SiN layer is then patterned and etched using, for example, a dry etch in an ME or inductively coupled plasma (ICP) tool. As shown in
As shown in
As shown in
As shown in
If integrated waveguides, not illustrated, are desired, the patterning of the hard mask layer 1080 and subsequent processing also includes the integrated waveguides. Alternatively, a tapered microfiber can be used for injecting light into the ring.
Bulk Silicon Nitride on Silicon Process with Pedestals.
The nitride layer 1120 is patterned and etched, exemplarily in an RIE or ICP tool, to define the waveguide features 1130, the ring features 1140, the anchor features 1150, and the spoke features 1160. These features are shown in
As shown in
As shown in
As shown in
If integrated waveguides are desired, the patterning of the polysilicon hard mask 1170 and subsequent processing also includes the integrate waveguides. Alternatively, a tapered microfiber can be used for injecting light into the ring features 1140.
Sagnac OM Gyroscopic Systems
Although the above discussion has provided details of the design and fabrication of an individual Sagnac OM gyroscope in accordance with various embodiments, it will be understood that a practical system for navigation will typically require three Sagnac OM gyroscopes, with each occupying a respective orthogonal plane. The design, fabrication, optical stimulation, and readout of each Sagnac OM gyroscope can be as described herein.
In the simplest method of readout, the laser that drives the circulating optical resonator is maintained at a fixed wavelength during operation. However, those skilled in the art will recognize that other readout techniques are available and may be preferred for particular applications. For example, in some applications the laser can be retuned to maintain peak optical resonance during operation. Such an approach can be more robust, but it would generally add to system cost and to power consumption. In another example approach, the laser wavelength is repeatedly swept through resonance while observing the mechanical angular frequency difference as a function of time.
The invention may be embodied in other specific forms without departing from its spirit or essential characteristics. The described embodiments are to be considered in all respects only as illustrative and not restrictive. The scope of the invention is, therefore, indicated by the appended claims rather than by the foregoing description. All changes which come within the meaning and range of equivalency of the claims are to be embraced within their scope.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 62/545,172, filed Aug. 14, 2017, which is incorporated herein by reference.
This invention was made with Government support under Contract No. DE-NA0003525 awarded by the United States Department of Energy/National Nuclear Security Administration. The Government has certain rights in the invention.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
5331404 | Moeller | Jul 1994 | A |
6370289 | Bennett | Apr 2002 | B1 |
20050035278 | Margalit | Feb 2005 | A1 |
20090244544 | Terrel | Oct 2009 | A1 |
20130088720 | Sorrentino | Apr 2013 | A1 |
20140283601 | Bhave | Sep 2014 | A1 |
20140369699 | Strandjord | Dec 2014 | A1 |
20160069686 | Lee | Mar 2016 | A1 |
20160164458 | Nguyen | Jun 2016 | A1 |
20160349283 | Bramhavar | Dec 2016 | A1 |
Entry |
---|
Grutter, K.E. et al., “A Platform for On-Chip Silica Optomechanical Oscillators with Integrated Waveguides”, Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics 2012 OSA Technical Digest (online) (Optical Society of America, 2012), paper CW1M.5 (//doi.org/10.1364/CLEO_SI.2012.CW1M.5), 2 pages. |
Hossein-Zadeh, M. et al., “Characterization of a radiation-pressure-driven micromechanical oscillator”, Physical Review A 74, 023813 (2006), pp. 023813-1-023813-15. |
Kippenberg, T.J. et al., “Cavity Opt-Mechanics”, Optics Express, vol. 15, No. 25 (2007), pp. 17172-17205. |
Li, S.-S. et al., “Micromechanical Hollow-Disk Ring Resonators”, Proceedings, 17th Int. IEEE Micro Electro Mechanical Systems Conf., Maastricht, The Netherlands, Jan. 25-29, 2004, pp. 821-824. |
Liang, W. et al., “Resonant microphotonic gyroscope”, Optica, vol. 4, No. 1 (2017), pp. 114-117. |
Liu, F. et al., “On the Spectrum of Radiation Pressure Driven Optomechanical Oscillator and Its Application in Sensing”, Optics Communications 294 (2013) pp. 338-343. |
Ma, H. et al., “Resonant Micro-optic Gyro Using a Short and High-finesse Fiber Ring Resonator”, Optics Letters, vol. 40, No. 24 (2015), pp. 5862-5865. |
Rocheleau, T.O. et al., Enhancement of mechanical Q for Low Phase Noise Optomechanical Oscillators, Jan. 20-24, 2013, 2013 IEEE 26th International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEMS), 4 pages. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62545172 | Aug 2017 | US |