Patent Grant
10258581
The invention relates to organosulfur compounds that can be used to prevent or treat neurodegenerative diseases. More specifically, a class of lipophilic mercaptans are disclosed which can be used to decrease the formation of aldehyde-protein adducts, protein carbonylation, protein aggregates, and the resulting neuroinflammation. Examples of use include the treatment of diseases and conditions such as Alzheimer's disease, senile dementia, Parkinson's disease, multiple sclerosis, Lewy body disease, peripheral neuropathy, spinal cord injury, stroke and cerebral ischemia.
Note: Unless otherwise stated, all amino acids mentioned within the specification or the claims are of the L-isomer.
Acrolien: The smallest and most reactive alpha,beta-unsaturated aldehyde; chemical formula (also see
Administration of a compound: Causing a compound to enter into the body of an animal, either orally, by injection, or by any other means.
Allicin; (diallyl thiosulfinate): The principal thiosulfinate that is formed when garlic is crushed; chemical formula (also see
Allyl mercaptan; (also represented chemically as AllylSH), chemical name AllylThiol; chemical formula (also see
CH2═CH—CH2—SH
In the present exposition allyl-mercaptan is the model lipophilic mercaptan (preferring a lipid environment to an aqueous environment). In general, a compound is referred to herein as a “model” compound when it is representative of a more general class of compounds defined herein.
Allylmercapto radical: allyl mercaptan without the terminal hydrogen atom of the SH group, resulting in an unpaired electron on the sulfur atom which is available for covalent bonding to the remainder of a larger molecule; chemical formula:
CH2═CH—CH2—S*
Amphiphilic molecule: A molecule having a more polar, water-soluble group attached to a less polar, lipid-soluble organic group.
Biothiol: Any thiol that is commonly found in biological systems. Common biothiols are cysteine, glutathione, several types of antioxidants (such as the dithiol form of lipoic acid), and several types of vitamins (such as the thiol form of thiamine).
Diallyl Disulfide; DADS, (also represented chemically as AllylSSAllyl or ASSA): the disulfide formed from two AllylMercapto radicals bonded together. Equivalent to deoxygenated allicin. In the present exposition diallyl disulfide is the model disulfide compound. See also
Glutathione: A tripeptide composed of the amino acids glutamate, cysteine, and glycine (ARB52:711). Glutathione is present in biological systems in a variety of forms, the most important of which are reduced glutathione (GSH), the anion of reduced glutathione (GS−), the glutathiyl free radical (GS*), glutathione disulfide (GSSG), mixed glutathione disulfides (GSSR), and protein-glutathione mixed disulfides (PSSG).
The term “glutathione” used by itself can be used to refer to the sum of GSH and GS−. The term “oxidized glutathione” usually refers to GSSG (the typical end product of oxidation, even though GS* is usually the initial oxidation product). The term “total glutathione” refers to the sum of all of these.
4-hydroxy-2-nonenal; 4-HNE, HNE: An alpha,beta-unsaturated aldehyde that has been extensively researched, See also
Lipophilic molecule: Attracted to lipids. A molecule is lipophilic if it preferentially partitions into the oily side of an oil and water system. For example, allyl mercaptan has a partition coefficient (Log P) of 1.51, which indicates that its concentration on the oily side is approximately 30 times its concentration on the aqueous side of an oil and water system.
Metabolism: The entire set of chemical reactions that can occur within a living organism. This includes anabolism (the formation of more complex molecules from simple ones), catabolism (the break down of complex molecules from complex molecules to make simpler ones) and also simpler reactions, such as thiol-disulfide exchange reactions.
Mercaptan: A small molecule with the general formula RSH where R is any radical. Mercaptans are the subset of thiols which are small molecules and only have one terminal sulfhydryl (SH). Mercaptans are typically volatile and very smelly.
Mitigate: To make less severe or less intense.
Molecular Mass: The mass of a molecule expressed in units of 1/12 of the weight of one atom of the isotope carbon-12.
Neuropathy: A disease or abnormality of the nervous system.
Nutraceutical: A food to which a substance has been added to promote health.
Prodrug: An inert drug that becomes active only after it is transformed or metabolized by the body.
Prophylactic treatment: Acting to defend against or prevent a disease.
Propyl mercaptan; n-Propyl Mercaptan, PropylSH, chemical name 1-PropaneThiol; chemical formula:
CH3—CH2—CH2—SH
Protein-aldehyde adduct: a protein that has been modified by the attachment of an aldehyde.
Protein carbonylation: The net addition of a carbonyl group onto a protein, including protein carbonyls that are formed by the addition of an aldehyde.
Radical; R: A group of atoms which behaves as a unit and has one or more unpaired electrons.
Reactive Oxygen Species; ROS: oxygen containing molecules that are capable of producing oxidative damage to other molecules. Many, but not all, ROS are free radicals. Examples include: H2O2 (hydrogen peroxide), *O2− (superoxide radical), *OH (hydroxyl radical), HOCl (hypoclorus acid), ONOO− (peroxynitrite), O21 (singlet oxygen), O3 (ozone), *NO (nitric oxide), and *NO2 (nitrogen dioxide).
S-allylmercapto-N-acetylcysteine; SAMNAC: The mixed disulfide formed from allyl mercaptan and N-acetylcysteine; chemical formula (see also
S-propylmercapto-N-acetylcysteine; SPMNAC: The mixed disulfide formed from propyl mercaptan and N-acetylcysteine; chemical formula:
Sulfur Amino Acids; SAA: typically the sum of cysteine, cystine, methionine (constituents of proteins), and other sulfur containing amino acid molecules such as homocysteine, cysteamine, and N-acetylcysteine. Because they are amino acids (which are zwitterons with ionized amino and carboxyl groups), these molecules are too polar to be able to freely diffuse through biological membranes.
Thiol: Any molecule that includes one or more terminal sulfhydryl (SE). Mercaptans (RSH) are the subset of thiols which are small molecules and only have one terminal sulfhydryl (SH).
Trans-adduction: The transfer of an adduct from one molecule to another. For example, the transfer of a protein-aldehyde adduct from a protein molecule to a mercaptan molecule, repairing the protein and forming a mercaptan-aldehyde conjugate molecule.
Treatment: The willful administration of a therapeutic agent with the intent of preventing or mitigating a disease or an abnormal condition.
For articles contained in books, the first listing (typically by Dewey decimal number or ISBN number) contains identification information for the book and the actual reference(s) are the listings for the article(s) or pages that follow.
3.1 New Knowledge about the Causes of Neurological Diseases
Modern methods greatly increase the amount of physiological detail which can be measured or observed, and in some cases causing revisions to long-held beliefs. This is especially true now that genetic information is available for the entire human genome.
Diseases associated with gross genetic defects have been known for decades, but only a small minority of the population inherit a genetic defect which, in and of itself, produces a disease. Most genetic diseases are now known to be associated with a combination of genetic alleles (none of which can individually cause the disease), or the combination of one or more genetic alleles with environmental factors.
Because Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases are both the most prevalent and the most researched of the neurodegenerative diseases, the description below will concentrate on these diseases.
3.2 Examples
3.2.1 Alzheimer's Disease
3.2.1.1 the Effect of APOE Allele Type on Alzheimer's Disease Risk
The new techniques allow the influence of genetic alleles to be accurately determined, which can provide deep insights into the disease process itself. A good example is that of apolipoprotein E (APOE) which has three major human isoforms which are designated e2, e3, and e4. The e4 allele of APOE is associated with an increased risk of developing Alzheimer's disease (NBA32:655); while the e2 allele of APOE decreased the risk relative to the e3 allele (which is considered “normal” because the e3 allele is found in the majority of the population of the world).
The alleles of APOE vary at only two codons, with the e4 allele coding for an arginine at both 130Arg and 176Arg, the e3 allele coding for a cysteine at position 130Cys and an arginine at position 176Arg, and the e2 allele coding for cysteines at both positions 130Cys and 176Cys (BMCBBF2:13). For those with two copies of the e4 allele, their likelihood for developing early onset Alzheimer's disease is over 6 times as great as for those with two copies of the e3 allele, and over 11 times as great at that for those who have one copy of the e3 allele and one copy of the e2 allele (there were no e2/e2 patients within the population surveyed) (BMCBBF2:13).
These statistics are very close (over 6 vs. almost 7) to the relative frequency of strongly reactive amyloid-beta-immunoreactive plaques found in the hippocampus of autopsied patients with late-onset sporadic Alzheimer's disease, which is observed to be almost 7 times greater for APOE4/4 patients than for APOE3/3 patients (two copies of e4 vs. two copies of e3) (PNAS90:9649).
One reason for the observed relationship between the number of cysteines in each APOE allele and the the prevalence of amyloid-beta plaques found in the autopsied brains is explained in the paper “Evidence that amyloid-beta-peptide-induced lipid peroxidation and its sequelae in Alzheimer's disease brain contribute to neuronal death” (NBA23:655). Briefly stated, in the order from observed result to ultimate cause:
As dramatically shown by
3.2.1.2 Mutations to Amyloid Precursor Protein (APP)
The first mutations discovered in familial Alzheimer's disease were missense mutations in APP which have the effect of increasing the production of amyloid-beta and its progressive accululation in the brain. This led to the “amyloid hypothesis” of Alzheimer's disease progression. However, most cases of early onset Alzheimer's disease do not have a mutation in APP.
3.2.1.3 Mutations in Presenilin-1 and Presinilin-2
Mutations in the presenilins account for the majority of familial Alzheimer's disease cases. These mutations increase the level of amyloid-beta peptide that is produced in the brain. Mice mutated to express human amyloid precursor protein and mutated human PS-1P264L genes develop significantly elevated lipid peroxidation (as indicated by protein-bound HNE) and protein oxidation (as indicated by protein carbonyls). By age 1 month, the levels of protein-bound HNE and protein carbonyl levels in the brain have both increased by 40% compared to controls. Furthermore, the early progression and regional distribution of amyloid-beta deposits (e.g. in the frontal cortex) match those of Alzheimer's disease (FRBM45:1420).
3.2.2 Parkinson's Disease
3.2.2.1 Gene Mutations Linked to Familial Early Onset Parkinson's Disease.
Alpha-synuclein is a small protein that is expressed in many parts of the brain. Mutations in the alpha-synuclein gene (PARK1) are a very rare cause of Parkinson's disease. Although the clinical features associated with alpha-synuclein mutations are the same as those of ideopathic Parkinson's disease, including the formation of Lewy bodies and the development of cognitive impairment, the age of onset is lower and the rate of disease progression is more rapid.
Mutations to the parkin gene (PARK2) and the “PTEN-induced putative kinase 1” (PINK1) gene produce clinical symptoms similar to ideopathic Parkinson's disease, including substantial loss of dopaminergic neurons in the substantia nigra region of the brain, but there is a lack of Lewy body formation.
The physiological role of parkin is the ubiqiunation of proteins destined to be catabolized. PINK1 works with parkin to maintain mitochondrial integrity. Mitochondria exposed to oxidative stress are normally cleared from the cell via mitophagy, but mutated PARK2 or PINK1 reduce the efficiency of this process. Because mitophagy is the only way that mitochondria are recycled, in its absence defective mitochindria accumulate in the cell (PLONE6:E16746).
Mutations to the DJ-1 gene at the PARK7 locus can also cause familial early onset Parkinson's disease. Wild type DJ-1 can prevent dopaminergic cell death by two different protection mechanisms (JBC280:43150). First, during oxidative stress, expression of DJ-1 increases glutathione synthesis by increasing both the transcription and enzymatic activity of the rate-limiting enzyme, glutamine-cysteine ligase (GCL). Secondly, in response to alpha-synuclein overexpression, wild type DJ-1 activated the molecular chaperon protein Hsp70, which blocks alpha-synuclein aggregation and toxicity. The loss of either of these functions due to DJ-1 mutations would increase vulnerability to the development of Parkinson's disease.
3.3 Evidence for Inflammatory Positive Feedback in Alzheimer's and Parkinson's Diseases
3.3.1 Alzheimer's Disease
The gene mutations described above that are associated with Alzheimer's disease and Parkinson's disease all relate to protein aggregation, defective clearance of protein aggregates, and the oxidative stress which leads to protein aggregation. Furthermore, the protein aggregates typically induce an immune response that produces oxidative stress, and that oxidative stress causes lipid peroxidation. Lipid peroxidation products in turn produce cross links between proteins, which then cause inflammation and more oxidative stress.
Activated astrocytes and microglia play a major role in the inflammation observed in Alzheimer's disease as well as many other neurological diseases. In Alzheimer's disease, amyloid plaques are surrounded by astrocytes and activated microglia which release inflammatory cytokines such as Interleukin-1 IL-1), Interleukin-6 (IL-6), and tumor necrosis factor (TNF) alpha (JALHZD4:193). These in turn activate cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2), Nuclear Factor kappa B (NFkB), iNOS expression (inducible nitric oxide synthase) and the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) such as hydrogen peroxide and peryoxinitrite (JBC275:7918).
The activation of NFkB appears to also directly increase the production of Amyloid Precursor Protein (APP), because the APP gene has a binding site for the NFkB transcription factor in its 5′-regulatory region (JJP82:85).
Conversion from diffuse non-neuritc plaques to the neuritic plaques is diagnostic of Alzheimer's disease. The fibrillar state of amyloid beta is a requirement for IL-1 beta release (NATIMMU9:857). Furthermore, amyloid beta phagocytosis by microglia is necessary for that pathway. Once amyloid beta is phagocytosed by microglial cells, lysosomes that contain amyloid beta adopt a swollen morphology, structural damage, and loss of membrane integrity. This is because microglia are incapable of efficiently degrading fribular amyloid beta, even over a period of weeks after its internalization. The uncontrolled release of lysosomal components into the cytoplasm is proinflammatory. For example, the cathepsin B released from the lysosomes induces microglial IL-1 beta release (NATIMMU9:857).
It is interesting to note that cross-linked protein aggregates are also resistant to the digestive system. Formaldehyde (an aldehyde that forms protein cross-links) is prohibited by law from use as a food preservative because formaldehyde-modified proteins are not digestible (QD3.A5#159:577). Similarly, collagen that is treated with formaldehyde is inert towards proteolytic enzymes (QP801.A33S3:13). Furthermore, aldehydes, especially alpha,beta-desaturated aldehydes, inhibit the enzymes of digestion (QP801.A33S3:15)
3.3.2 Parkinson's Disease
Neuroinflammation and alpha-synuclein aggregation potentiate each other, driving chronic progression of neurodegeneration in a mouse model of Parkinson's disease. A new mouse model of Parkinson's disease uses a single lipopolysaccarhde infusion to trigger a Parkinsonian disease which more closely mimics the human disease than other available animal models (EHP119:807):
This demonstrates the “neuroinflammation to protein aggregation to more inflammation loop” is in action, in the best available animal model for Parkinson's disease.
3.3.3 Oxidative Stress, Lipid Peroxidation, and Aldehydes in the Inflammatory Positive Feedback Loop
Although a wide variety of aldehydes (including simple aldehydes such as formaldehyde) can form protein cross-links, the alpha,beta-unsaturated aldehydes contain one (or more) carbonyls and one (or more) carbon-to-carbon double bonds which can readily react with the protein side groups of cysteine, lysine or histidine. Among the aldehydes that are produced in vivo, acrolein is the most reactive (pure acrolein is self-explosive!) but HNE (4-hydroxy-2-nonenal) seems to be the most researched.
These aldehydes readily form reversible protein adducts 23 with the cysteine, lysine or histidine amino acids of proteins. Although the adducted proteins may lose their function, the adduction is reversible, perhaps allowing the protein to be repaired by the removal of the aldehyde (which can occur spontaneously). But when exposed to reactive oxygen species (ROS), further reactions can occur, including the formation of irreversible protein-aldehyde adducts 24 (CRT11:247). The irreversible adducts can permanently prevent the protein from performing its functions, impairing the performance of the cell until the damaged protein is replaced.
The irreversible adducts, when further exposed to ROS, can form irreversible cross-links between proteins. The resulting protein aggregation 25 is proinflammatory and can activate microglia, resulting in inflammation 21. This feedback loop can be self-sustaining, leading to the progressive degeneration that is seen in Alzheimer's and various other neurodegenerative diseases.
A primary goal of the invention is to break the feedback loop of inflammation leading to damaged molecules which can then lead to further inflammation and tissue damage. By decreasing the formation of the protein-aldehyde adducts that can produce protein aggregates, unnecessary inflammation is prevented. Lipophilic mercaptan molecules can detoxify aldehydes by rapidly conjugating with them, thereby protecting proteins and other biomolecules such as DNA from damage. Lipophilic mercaptan molecules can also repair damaged protein residues by participating in exchange reactions that remove the aldehyde adducts from the proteins.
This process is illustrated in
Should lipid peroxidation occur (for any reason), the peroxide degradation products will include aldehydes. These aldehydes will encounter lipophilic mercaptans close to their source of origin (i.e. within the lipid membrane itself), reacting with the lipophilic mercaptans to form less toxic scavenged aldehydes 37. The scavenging of the aldehydes prevents the formation of reversible protein-aldehyde adducts 33.
Should reversible protein aldehyde adducts form (for any reason), the lipophilic mercaptans can repair the protein by trans-adduction, thereby repairing the protein 38.
Alternatively, lipophilic mercaptans can prevent the formation of an irreversible protein-aldehyde adducts by scavenging ROS molecules 39 before they can convert a protein adduct from a reversible to an irreversible one.
Thus, lipophilic mercaptans can break the feedback loop at several steps within the loop. Note that among antioxidants, only mercaptans (or other thiols) can detoxify aldehydes or repair adducted proteins by trans-adduction. And only mercaptans that are located within the lipid membranes of the cell can detoxify aldehydes at their source and protect (or repair) proteins that are located in membranes.
The lipophilic mercaptans are preferably administered in the novel form of a mixed disulfide with N-acetylcysteine, which releases the lipophilic mercaptans in the body via thiol-disulfide exchange reactions. These molecules could be developed and deployed as drugs. But because the mixed disulfide has much lower objectionable smell and taste than the lipophilic mercaptan itself, in some cases it can be suitable for administration as a dietary supplement or as a nutraceutical food.
The specific mixed disulfides include S-allyl-N-acetylcysteine and S-propyl-N-acetylcysteine which incorporate organosulfur groups that are found in natural crushed garlic and the steam distilled products of crushed garlic and onions. These form allyl mercaptan and propyl mercaptan in the body, which are lipophilic compounds that are already FDA approved for use in food.
Other aspects, advantages, and novel features of the invention are described below or will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art from the following specifications and drawings of illustrative embodiments.
6.1 Detoxification Pathways
6.1.1 In Biological Systems, Aldehydes Preferentially Attack Sulfhydryl Groups
This is a good place to start the detailed description, because whenever free SH groups are available, they are first in line for being attacked by aldehydes. For example, although HNE will readily react with the amino groups of proteins (see
Although the alpha,beta-unsaturated aldehydes have two sites that are reactive with cysteine, the Michael addition reaction at the C═C site is preferred (QP801.A33S3:5), with the cysteine eliminating the C═C double bond of the aldehyde (similar to the reaction of
6.1.2 Small Molecular Weight Thiols Effectively Protect Protein Thiols from Aldehydes
In general, aldehydes are more reactive with the SH groups of small molecular thiols that with any other type of molecule found in biological systems. This is true even in comparison with the SH groups of proteins.
For intracellular concentrations of HPE up to 0.6 mM, the low molecular weight thiols become depleted, but there is no effect on protein sulfhydryls or enzyme activities. Only after the low molecular weight thiols are more than 80% depleted do the protein sulfhydryls even start to become affected. Only after 100% of the low molecular weight thiols are depleted and 30% of the protein sulfhydryls have been depleted (blocked) does enzyme activity become affected.
The authors' primary explanation for this is that:
But I think that the real reason is that there is a continuous transfer of aldehydes from whatever protein adducts that do form to the low molecular weight thiols that are floating around within the cytosol of the cell. This “trans-adduction” process that I propose is analogous to the “transglycation” process that has been shown to transfer the glucose moiety of protein-glucose conjugates to free cysteine molecules, thereby repairing glycated proteins (U.S. Pat. No. 7,678,833).
Note that when the low molecular weight thiols are not depleted, the protein SH groups are essentially fully protected from modification by the aldehyde. But when the small molecular weight thiols become depleted, the protein SH groups are essentially completely unprotected.
6.1.3 Other Types of Antioxidants do not Protect Proteins from Aldehydes, and in Fact can Make Things Worse
Although “SH” based antioxidants such as cysteine and glutathione are protective, other commonly used antioxidants such as Vitamin A, Vitamin C, and Vitamin E provide no protection, and can actually make things worse.
Although vitamin C and glutathione in many ways work together and vitamin C can partially substitute for glutathione as an antioxidant, excessive vitamin C consumption has been shown to significantly decrease the glutathione content of cells. This effect has been utilized in a clinical trial where the goal was to increase the cytotoxicity of the chemotherapeutic drug arsenic trioxide (which is normally detoxified by glutathione within cells) against the cancer multiple myeloma (CCR8:3658). A daily dosage of 1000 mg of vitamin C caused significant glutathione depletion, resulting in a mean percentage decrease of 60% among the patients.
Vitamin A and other carotenoids can also cause depletion of glutathione and other thiols. The main antioxidant property of the carotenoids is the quenching of singlet oxygen, with each caroteniod molecule able to do this approximately 1000 times before it breaks down and forms a very reactive aldehyde molecule. These break down products form adducts with SH groups that are not reversible. Carotenoid breakdown products are otherwise long lived and can travel far before they encounter (for example) an SH sensitive enzyme, producing a cumulative inhibition of SH enzymes in the body. Carotenoid levels, especially beta-carotene in blood and various tissues are dependent on the carotenoid content of food and may exceed the levels that were used in these enzyme inhibition studies (RB170.H36:235).
Note that this apparently little-known toxicity of carotenoids may explain the poor results from the “beta-Carotene and Retinol Efficacy Trial”, which showed that carotenoid supplementation significantly increases cancer risk and overall mortality (CBEP12:350).
6.1.4 Reactions Between Aldehydes and Thiols Also Occur in Hydrophobic Environments
The aldehydes that are formed as lipid peroxide degradation products are sufficiently water soluble to enter the cytosol of the cell and diffuse to diverse targets (including nuclear DNA). This has led most researchers to conduct their in vitro experiments in aqueous systems instead of non-polar oils or solvents. They have firmly-established that aldehydes rapidly react with thiols in water, but leave the question of whether such reactions also can occur in nonpolar, aprotic environments such as within lipid-based membranes.
However there is experimental evidence that aldehydes can participate in Michael addition reactions with both cysteine and lysine residues of proteins in hydrophobic environments within cells and also in a model system using an nonpolar aprotic solvent (hexane). The enzyme fructose-1,6-bisphosphatse is inactivated by the aldehyde o-phthalaldehyde which creates an irreversible intra-protein cross-link between a cysteine residue and a nearby lysine residue. Because the “molar transition energy” can be used to determine the degree of polarity in the microenvironment of the cysteine and lysine residues participating in the reaction, the molar transition energy of the adduct (121 kJ/mol) was well matched to that which was obtained from an analogous model reaction performed in hexame (121 kJ/mol), indicating that the environment within the protein where the reaction occurs must be a hydrophobic environment (BBRC150:1088).
Note: Amyloid beta, alpha-syneuclein and APOE all are proteins which preferentially locate within membranes.
6.1.5 Aldehyde Adduct Formation with Protein Lysine Residues
In the absence of low molecular weight thiols, adducts can readily form between aldehydes and protein lysine residues (PrNH2) by a Michael addition reaction, as shown in
The aldehyde HNE (52 of
6.1.6 Most Protein-Aldehyde Adducts are Protein Carbonyls
As shown in 53 of
Elevation in the total level of protein carbonyls has been documented in both Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases (JBC279:13256). In particular, the protein “Ubiquitin Carboxyl-terminal Hydrolase L1” which is associated with mutations of the UCH-L1 gene in a rare familial form of Parkinson's disease, is also seen to be significantly carbonylated in the idopathic versions of both diseases. These oxidative modifications may cause irreversible alteration to the catalytic activity (e.g. the clearance of damaged proteins via ubiquination and subsequent proteolysis) and have a deleterious effect on neuronal function and survival (JBC279:13256).
6.1.7 Protein Repair by Low Molecular Weight Thiols (e.g. Mercaptans)
Mercaptans are low molecular weight thiols that are well suited for repairing adducted proteins via trans-adduction.
The reaction that is being called “trans-adduction” here is similar to the well known nucleophilic substitution reaction (where the more “electron rich” nuclophile attacks a molecule that contains a less electron rich nucleophile (which when it leaves is called the “leaving group”). In this case the attack comes from both the “S” and the “H” of the mercaptan which both attach to the aldehyde, and the leaving group is the entire protein.
6.1.8 Further Evidence that Low Molecular Weight Thiols (e.g. Mercaptans) can Protect Proteins in Membranes from Aldehydes
Glutathione Ethyl Ester (GEE) is a glutathione analog that is formed by adding an ethyl group to the C-terminus carboxyl group of glutathione, thereby converting glutathione into an electrically neutral molecule. This allows GEE to enter cells by diffusion through the cell membrane (ABB239:538).
Pretreatment of synaptosomal membranes with GEE significantly reduces the amount of protein carbonlys that are observed after acrolein treatment (
But the really interesting result is that the “GEE” column (positive control) has an 85% lower concentration of carbonyls in the synaptosomal membrane than the “Control” column.
The authors state that:
If so, this shows that membrane was protected from carbonyl formation by the GEE in the membrane.
But perhaps that is not the only thing going on. These results could also indicate that the GEE can remove previously formed carbonyls from the proteins in the membrane (trans-adduction of protein-aldehyde adducts). The dramatic reduction in carbonyls seems to exceed the amount that would normally be expected from only 3 hours of oxygen exposure (the duration of GEE pretreatment in the experiments).
6.1.9 Irreversible Adduct Formation has a Low Probability but a High Toxicity
The reactions that produce reversible protein-aldehyde adducts include Michael additions to protein cysteine, lysine, and histidine and also Shiff base additions to lysine. These addition reactions are all spontaneously reversible at a low rate. They are also rapidly reversed by trans-adduction reactions with mercaptans.
Although this disclosure has emphasized (and will continue to emphasize) the formation of irreversible protein cross-links, their formation is relatively rare compared to the rate of reversible adduct formation (and reversal) within any biological system that includes a significant level of mercaptans. This is not to say that the short-term formation of adducts is without effect. For example, many (probably most) enzymes include one or more cysteines whose blockage by aldehyde adduct formation will impair the function of the enzyme. But because this blockage is reversible, the effect is temporary and is unlikely to kill the cell.
Of the irreversible cross-links that are seen in detergent insoluble protein aggregates, lysine is almost always involved. Furthermore, the fluorescent “signature” of a wide variety of these aggregates show evidence of the formation of a pyrrole ring (a 5-sided ring of 4 carbons and one nitrogen with attached side groups). In particular, the pyrolle-based cross link shown in
The formation of the pyrole-based cross link requires a relatively long and specific sequence of steps (presented in detail in CRT11:247, and summarized in
For example, the very first step is the formation of a Schiff base between an aldehyde 62 and a lysine of a protein “PrNH2” to form a reversible protein-aldehyde adduct 63 (as shown in
To reiterate, the molecule shown as 65 could easily be reversed, as could the molecule shown as 66, as could the molecule shown as 67, if mercaptans are present in the system.
Although reversals occur all the time, with a sufficiently long time a significant level of cross-linked proteins can eventually accumulate, and these can become easily observable (e.g. as age spots in the skin of old people).
However, as illustrated by
If the “system” is located in a lipid membrane, it is lipophilic mercaptans located in the membrane that are needed for the efficient reversal of the initially formed protein-aldehyde adducts (before they can become irreversible).
6.1.10 Cysteine Deficiency
In U.S. Pat. No. 7,678,833 I spend several pages making the case that there is probably a significant cysteine deficiency associated with current dietary practices, which I won't repeat here. But one point is directly relevant.
In 2001, it was reported that the current recommendation for daily dietary sulfur amino acid consumption were low by almost a factor of two (13 mg/kg instead of 25 mg/kg) due to an arithmetic error when the requirements were determined experimentally in 1955 (AJCN74:756). Therefore, a 70 kg person should actually be consuming 1750 mg of sulfur amino acids per day (of which approximately ½ will be cysteine and ½ will be methionine). Another problem with the way that the dietary sulfur amino acid requirements were determined is that the experiments were based on “nitrogen balance” which only measures the amount of the amino acid that is needed for protein formation (weight maintenance) and does not take into account other biological requirements for cysteine (such as the synthesis of glutathione, taurine, and sulfate).
Therefore, even if someone is consuming the amount of cysteine that is currently officially recommended, this may actually be less than half of their actual dietary needs.
6.2 Pharmacological Intervention Options
6.2.1 Mercaptans Themselves are Poorly Suited for Direct Administration
For one thing, they are extremely smelly. In U.S. Pat. No. 7,678,833 compositions are disclosed that utilize a dietary protein (whey protein) with allyl mercaptan disulfide bonded to the cysteine residues of the protein as a lower taste and smell way of administering allyl mercaptan: The allyl mercaptan is only released from the protein when the protein is digested. But because the amount of cysteine in the protein is only 2% of the protein by weight, the amount of allyl mercaptan that can be contained in the capsule is limited by the bulk of the protein. What is needed in order to improve upon this is something closer to a 1:1 ratio between the allyl mercaptan and the non-volatile molecule that it is disulfide bonded to.
N-acetylcysteine is my current molecule of choice for this purpose. It is a nontoxic prodrug for cysteine which has been used at high dosages for the treatment of acetaminophen poisoning (BMCCC6:155), and it is used as a dietary supplement. (Cysteine itself is considered toxic when used in high doses.)
6.2.2 Synthesis of S-Allylmercapto-N-Acetylcysteine (SAMNAC)
Thiosulfinates react rapidly with mercaptans to form mixed disulfides (U.S. Pat. No. 8,217,084). The thiosulfinate “allicin” can react with a molecule of N-actylcysteine to form a molecule of SAMNAC plus a sulfenic acid that contains an allylmercapto group. This sulfenic acid molecule reacts rapidly with a second molecule of N-acetylcysteine to yield a second molecule of SAMNAC plus a molecule of water. These reactions between thiosulfinates and mercaptans are well known and are very rapid, and therefore were expected by the applicant to produce SAMNAC molecules with a high yield.
Synthesis of SAMNAC was performed for the applicant as work for hire by Larry D. Lawson, Ph.D, Research Director of Silliker Inc. Utah Laboratory, using the following procedure:
Dr. Jeff Conroy of Authentix Corporation confirmed that the NRM spectrum obtained by proton NMR from the dehydrated SAMNAC is consistent with the synthesized compound being authentic SAMNAC. The NMR spectrum is:
1H NMR (CD3OD, ppm): 1.99 (s, 3H), 2.99 (m, 1H), 3.31 (m, 1H), 3.36 (d, 2H), 4.44 (m, 1H), 5.091-5.21 (m, 2H), 5.79-5.93 (m, 1H).
6.2.2.2 Confirmation that SAMNAC Contains an Allyl Mercapto Group.
Analysis of SAMNAC to confirm that the compound contains an allyl mercapto group was performed as work for hire by Dr. Lawson. Starting with some of the SAMNAC produced above, treatment with the reducing agent tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphate (TCEP) produces allyl mercaptan, as verified by HPLC.
6.2.2.3 Confirmation that SAMNAC Contains an N-Acetylcysteinyl Group.
Analysis of SAMNAC to confirm that the compound contains an N-acetylcysteinyl group was performed as work for hire by Dr. Lawson. Starting with some of the SAMNAC produced above, treatment with the reducing agent tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphate (TCEP) produces N-acetylcysteine, as verified by HPLC.
6.2.3 Examples of Compositions
6.2.3.1 A “garlic” dietary supplement capsule
A dietary supplement capsule containing SAMNAC was produced by the following method:
1. Start with 5 bulbs of fresh garlic (330 g). This should produce approximately 1300 mg of allicin when pulverized, because the allicin yield from crushed garlic is approximately 4 mg/g (RM666.G15K6313:42).
2. Grate the garlic with a food processor (I used a KitchenAid food processor).
3. Transfer the “mash” to a blender (I used an Osterizer), add 200 mL of water, and blend for 10 minutes to completely pulverize the garlic.
4. Add 15 mL of N-acetylcysteine powder (11.5 g) and blend for a few seconds to mix.
5. Add sufficient potassium bicarbonate to raise the pH to approximately 4 (3.75 mL raised the pH to 4.3) and blend for a few seconds to mix.
6. Filter the fluid from the mixture by squeezing the mixture through a fine cloth. Above a cup, spoon some of the mixture onto the cloth, raise the sides of the cloth to surround the mixture, and twist the cloth to squeeze the mixture, allowing the fluid to pass through the cloth into the cup. Approximately 350 mL of liquid is obtained. The (now dry) pulverized garlic remains weigh approximately 107 g.
7. Let the fluid stand for a day at room temperature.
8. Use a food dehydrator (trays with hot air blown across them—normally used for drying fruit, vegetables, or beef jerky) to dry the fluid (I used an Excalibur). I used multiple 18-well silicone nonstick miniature donut baking molds (by Freshware) to hold the fluid, with ½ teaspoon of fluid in each well (approximately 140 wells total). Drying time is approximately 24 hours at 95 degrees F., followed by 24 hours at 155 degrees F.
9. Remove the “crystalized” product from the wells of the molds (approximately 83 g total).
10. Grind the crystalized product using a hand cheese grater (I used a Zyliss) to make a powder.
11. Fill size 00 capsules with the powder (I used the Cap-M-Quik manual capsule filler). Makes 115 capsules, each with an estimated 35 mg of SAMNAC (11 mg of allyl mercapto groups) and an estimated 75 mg of “excess” N-acetylcysteine.
I have taken these capsules at 6 per day for a month with no noticeable side effects.
6.2.3.2 an “Onion” Dietary Supplement Capsule
Just as crushing garlic produces the thiosulfinate allicin (diallyl thiosulfinate), crushing onions produces dipropenyl thiosulfinate (QK475.A43B56:150), although yellow onions only have approximately 10% of the thiosulfinate yield from garlic (approximately 0.4 mg/g). Dipropenyl thiosulfinate contains propenyl mercapto groups (analogous to the allyl mercapto groups of allicin) and has the same reaction properties. Therefore, the reaction product S-propenyl-N-acetylcysteine (analogous to S-allyl-N-acetyloysteine, SAMNAC) rapidly can be formed from the mixture of dipropenyl thiosulfinate with N-acetylcysteine at a pH of approximately 4.
A dietary supplement capsule containing S-propenyl-N-acetylcysteine was produced by the following method:
1. Start with two large fresh yellow onions (637 g, which should produce approximately 250 mg of dipropenyl thiosulfinate when pulverized).
2. Grate the onion with a food processor (I used a KitchenAid food processor).
3. Transfer the “mash” to a blender (I used an Osterizer), add 200 mL of water, and blend for 10 minutes to completely pulverize the onion.
4. Add 15 mL of N-acetylcysteine powder (11.5 g) and blend for a few seconds to mix.
5. Add sufficient potassium bicarbonate to raise the pH to approximately 4 (3.75 mL raised the pH to 4.5) and blend for a few seconds to mix.
6. Filter the fluid from the mixture by squeezing the mixture through a fine cloth. Above a cup, spoon some of the mixture onto the cloth, raise the sides of the cloth to surround the mixture, and twist the cloth to squeeze the mixture, allowing the fluid to pass through the cloth into the cup. Approximately 600 mL of liquid is obtained. The (now dry) pulverized onion remains weigh approximately 180 g.
7. Let the fluid stand for a day at room temperature.
8. Use a food dehydrator (trays with hot air blown across them—normally used for drying fruit, vegetables, or beef jerky) to dry the fluid (I used an Excalibur). I used multiple 18-well silicone nonstick miniature donut baking molds (by Freshware) to hold the fluid, with one teaspoon of fluid in each well (approximately 120 wells total). Drying time is approximately 24 hours at 95 degrees F., followed by 24 hours at 155 degrees F.
9. Remove the “crystalized” product from the wells of the molds (approximately 47 g total).
10. Grind the crystalized product using a hand cheese grater (I used a Zyliss) to make a powder.
11. Fill size 0 capsules with the powder (I used the Cap-M-Quik manual capsule filler). Makes 90 capsules, each with an estimated 8.5 mg of S-propenylmercapto-N-acetylcysteine (2.7 mg of propenyl mercapto groups) and an estimated 120 mg of “excess” N-acetylcysteine.
I have taken these capsules at 6 per day for a week with no noticeable side effects.
6.2.3.3 A Nutraceutical Food (Garlicky Potatoes with Bacon)
Garlicky potatoes with bacon (a nutraceutical food) was prepared in two stages. First a “SAMNAC garlic powder” was produced, which was then used in the preparation of the food.
To make the SAMNAC garlic powder:
1. Start with 210 mL of garlic powder (100 g), which should produce approximately 290 mg of allicin when mixed with water, given that the average allicin yield from garlic powder is 2.9 mg/g (RM666.G15K6313:93).
2. Add 15 mL of N-acetylcysteine powder (11.5 g) and blend for a few seconds to mix.
3. Add sufficient potassium bicarbonate to raise the pH to approximately 4 (3.75 mL raised the pH to 4.5) and blend for a few seconds to mix.
4. Let the mixture stand for a day at room temperature.
8. Use a food dehydrator (trays with hot air blown across them—normally used for drying fruit, vegetables, or beef jerky) to dry the fluid (I used an Excalibur). I used multiple 18-well silicone nonstick miniature donut baking molds (by Freshware) to hold the fluid, with one teaspoon of fluid in each well (approximately 65 wells total). Drying time is approximately 24 hours at 95 degrees F., followed by 36 hours at 155 degrees F.
5. Remove the “crystalized” product from the wells of the molds (approximately 102 g total).
6. Grind the crystalized product using a hand cheese grater (I used a Zyliss) to make a powder.
11. Each gram of the powder has an estimated 9.2 mg of SAMNAC (2.9 mg of allyl mercapto groups) and an estimated 110 mg of “excess” N-acetylcysteine.
To make the garlicky potatoes with bacon:
1. Cut three medium size russet potatoes into small cubes, approximately 1 cm on each side.
2. Put the cut potatoes in a pot with enough water to cover them.
3. Add one teaspoon (5 ml, 3 g) of the SAMNAC garlic powder to the pot.
4. Heat the pot to a gentle boil and cook until the potato cubes are done.
5. Cut 5 slices of bacon into pieces of approximately 1 cm by the width of the bacon slice.
6. Fry the bacon at 350 degrees F. until done.
7. Drain the potatoes.
8. Add the potatoes to the bacon in the frying pan.
9. Mix and fry until the excess water on the surface of the potato cubes is gone.
10. Serves two. The potatoes have a strong bacon flavor and a moderate garlic flavor. Each serving has up to an estimated 13 mg of SAMNAC and up to an estimated 165 mg of N-acetylcysteine.
6.2.3.4 A Nutraceutical Beverage
Garlicky tomato juice can be made by:
1. To 8 ounces of tomato juice, add one teaspoon (5 ml, 3 g) of SAMNAC garlic powder.
2. Refrigerate overnight.
3. The garlicky tomato juice has a strong tomato flavor and a moderate garlic flavor. Each serving has an estimated 27 mg of SAMNAC and an estimated 230 mg of N-acetylcysteine.
6.2.3.5 Experiments with Other Starting Ingredients
The above experiments were performed by the applicant at home using “kitchen chemistry” and naturally available sources for the thiosulfinate ingredients. Although it is not necessary for patentability to have developed a commercial scale manufacturing process (and the methods described above are sufficient for patentability), the disclosure and examples in this section illustrate experiments with some other commercially available starting ingredients that could be used for the development of a commercial scale manufacturing process.
6.2.3.5.1 Starting with Mercaptans
A mercaptan such as allyl mercaptan could be used with N-acetylcysteine to produce the mixed disulfide S-allylmercapto-N-acetylcysteine (SAMNAC). This would require the use of an oxidizing agent to induce disulfide formation. One traditional means for doing this is by bubbling air through the reaction mixture.
Allyl mercaptan is commercially available (including food grade, which is intended for human consumption in foods) and I have used it for experiments in the past.
Allyl mercaptan is moderately dissolvable in water (5 g/L), but dissolves freely in oil, indicating that it is a lipophilic molecule. When initially added to water, it tends to float on top or cling to glassware rather than rapidly dissolving (U.S. Pat. No. 8,217,084).
Allyl mercaptan is lipophillic and will preferentially partition into the lipids of a lipid and aqueous system. The Material Safety Data Sheet for allyl mercaptan (e.g. as published by GuideChem) states that allyl mercaptan is soluble in water and also that it has a partition coefficient (Log P) of 1.51 (e.g. it equilibrates to a 30 to 1 higher concentration in the oil than in the water side of a system with both oil and water).
Propyl mercaptan has a partition coefficient (Log P) of 1.95 (e.g. it equilibrates to an almost 100 to 1 higher concentration in the oil than in the water side of a system with both oil and water).
Although allyl mercaptan (and diallyl disulfide) have lower solubility in water than in lipids, experiments have shown that their concentrations in both the membranes and the cytosol of cells in sufficient to provide biologically significant activity (U.S. Pat. No. 8,217,084).
Even a very small concentration of a mercaptan in the air is objectionable, as was evidenced in the past by the appearance of a mysterious strong odor in Manhattan on Jan. 8, 2007 that nauseated many people. Even a few well dispersed ounces of (for example) ethyl mercaptan could be enough to stink up all of Manhattan (NYTIMES2001:0121A). Although the source of the odor was not was not found, it was described as having a mercaptan-like smell and may have been a natural product produced by micro-organisms in the coastal marshes (NYTIMES2001:0121B).
Even the thought experiment of using allyl mercaptan in a bubbling mixture was enough to prevent actually doing this (in consideration of my wife and neighbors).
But for designing an industrial production process, there should be known oxidizing-agents that can be used to induce disulfide formation (hydrogen peroxide comes to mind). But for my actual experiments, there is no advantage to starting with a mercaptan instead of starting with a thiosulfinate (as described in the previous sections) or a disulfide (as described below).
6.2.3.5.2 Starting with Disulfides
An initial attempt to make SAMNAC powder starting with diallyl disulfide (DADS,
A mixture of DADS and N-acetylcysteine in water produces a solution with a pH near 2, which is much to acidic for thiol-disulfide reactions to occur at a reasonable rate. An acceptable reaction rate (e.g. a speedup of 1000 times or more compared to pH=2) could be obtained at a pH of 5 or more.
The low pKa of N-acetylcysteine is due to the carboxyl group (COOH), which is normally ionized (COO−) at any pH over 2. For normal cysteine, the ionized carboxyl group is “canceled out” by its ionized amino group (NH3+) to produce a net pH near 0.7 when dissolved, but in N-acetylcysteine, this amino group is acetylated so its ionization is unavailable.
By adding sufficient potassium bicarbonate to the mixture (which reacts with H+ to produce H3O and K+) the pH can be adjusted to approximately 7. (A target pH of 7 was desired because at this pH the amount of K+ will be equal to the amount of SAMNAC− that is formed, which will simplify the formation of a 1:1 salt between them when the mixture is later dried.)
Note that the formed SAMNAC will be an anion in solution (the carboxyl group will remain ionized) and would be expected to form a salt with the added potassium when dried (unless the potassium is removed before drying). In this case, it is probably beneficial for the potassium to remain in the product, because potassium is safe and the potassium consumption of most people is lower than the current recommendations.
In the initial mixture, the DADS floats on the surface, but as it combines with the N-acetylcysteine, the surface layer disappears. Continuous mixing speeds up this process.
A size 0 capsule that contained the equivalent of 40 mg of allyl mercaptan and 400 mg of N-acetylcysteine (and metabolized to something near this) would have a desirable dosage of both of these ingredients. The hope was that although SAMNAC naturally is a liquid, starting with 10× N-acetylcysteine would result in 9× excess N-acetylcysteine (normally a solid), so the combination could perhaps form a solid suitable for grinding into a powder (for putting into gelatin capsules).
Because the ratio of thiols to disulfides is not changed from thiol-disulfide exchange reactions, starting with a 10× excess of N-acetylcysteine over the DADS concentration (of allyl mercaptan equivalents, with each DADS molecule counting as 2 allyl mercaptan equivalents), could be expected to produce approximately 90% retained N-acetylcysteine, 9% SAMNAC, 1% allyl mercaptan and 0.1% retained DADS (the same 10× ratio of thiols to disulfides). In practice the observation that the oily surface layer disappears implies that essentially all of the DADS and allyl mercaptan have combined with the N-acetylcysteine.
After the DADS had disappeared (not appearing on the surface of the mixture after the mixing is stopped and the mixture is allowed to settle), the mixture was dried and then ground into a powder. The result seemed to be a success.
But subsequent HPLC analysis performed as work for hire by Dr. Lawson showed that this powder did not contain a significant amount SAMNAC.
An experiment by Dr. Lawson showed the reason why. As shown in
In hindsight, the molecular structure of allyl mercaptan can explain this. The initial thiol-disulfide exchange reactions are rapid and complete within an hour. But there is still approximately 9× excess N-acetylcysteine in the mixture. The retained C═C double bond from the allyl mercaptan is vulnerable to a Michael addition reaction which could proceed to modify the SAMNAC molecules, decreasing the SAMNAC yield as shown.
Dr. Lawson's main conclusions were:
Note: An easy way to lower the pH would be to use less N-acetylcysteine as a starting material (e.g. 2× excess instead of 10×), balance the pH for this amount of anion (which would take only ⅕ as much cation to do), and to then add N-acetylcysteine at the appropriate time (e.g. after one hour).
A subsequent experiment using dipropyl disulfide (which is similar to DADS but has a C—C single bond instead of the C═C double bond of DADS) was only partially successful.
The resulting mixture was slow to dry, and after drying soon became soft and sticky (presumably due to moisture absorption from air). Before grinding could be completed, the grinder became stuck. Also, the pile of “ground” powder “melted” together too soon to allow it to be put into capsules. So the S-propylmercapto-N-acetylcysteine salt that I made (
In hindsight, this may be due to the known fact that potassium salts are “highly hygroscopic” and readily absorb moisture from the atmosphere (RS403.H33:393).
Therefore, although SAMNAC could be produced from DADS and N-acetylcysteine by stopping the reaction at the appropriate point, and SPMNAC could be produced from dipropyl disulfide and N-acetylcysteine, they do not form solids when dried and would need to be used in the form of a gel capsule (with a liquid inside) to produce a dietary supplement in the form of a capsule.
6.3 Examples of Use
6.3.1 Experimental Use
It is expected that those at risk of development of a neurological disease would consume these compositions on a daily basis, either as a dietary supplement or in nutraceutical foods. Those who have developed a neurological disease are likely to consume a larger quantity as recommended or prescribed by their doctor.
Myself, some friends, and relatives have consumed these and related compounds for several years without any apparent negative effects.
In the future, similar compositions could also become available in the form of FDA approved drugs with proven safety and effectiveness for the treatment of specific diseases.
I have experimentally consumed 240 mg/day of allyl mercaptan for several weeks without any apparent negative effects (except for taste and smell unpleasantness when taking each dose!). The results of a standard comprehensive blood test at the end of the experiment were essentially normal.
6.3.2 Dosages
The anticipated viable dosage range is from a minimum of 1 mg to a maximum of 2 grams of the lipophillic mercaptan (within the composition, e.g. the mass of the lipophilic mercapto redicals within the mixed disulfide) per day. The lower end of this range encompasses unit dosages (e.g. in nutraceuticals), taking into account that multiple servings (e.g. multiple types of these nutraceuticals) could be consumed each day (e.g. for an accumulated dosage of up to 2 grams/day).
Experience with similar mercaptans has shown a dose-dependent effectiveness range of, for example, a total of 30 mg to 60 mg per day (e.g. for the treatment of chronic arsenicosis, as disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 7,678,833). For this example, the unit dose (per capsule) was 10 mg, so the daily consumption was 3 to 6 capsules. Because arsenicosis is an extreme case, most other conditions are likely be responsive to daily dosages well below this.
The upper limit of the range is based on the dosages of mercaptans (or disulfides that metabolize to form mercaptans) that have been used in animal studies. For example, in a study of the prevention of acetaminophen poisoning in mice (PHYRES3:50), the dosage of S-allylmercaptocysteine used was up to 200 mg/kg, which would correspond to a dosage of 5000 mg of S-allylmercaptocysteine (which contains approximately 2000 mg of allyl mercaptan) for a 70 kg adult human.
The most preferred unit dosage is 25 mg of lipophilic mercaptan per unit dosage (e.g. per capsule, or per serving of a nutreceutical). Less preferred is a unit dosage within the range of 5 to 25 mg. Also less preferred is a unit dosage within the range of 25 mg to 200 mg. Even less preferred is a unit dosage within the range of 1 mg to 5 mg, or a unit dosage within the range of 200 mg to 2000 mg.
The most preferred daily dosage for healthy adults is 50 mg of lipophilic mercaptan per unit dosage (e.g. two unit doses of 25 mg each). Less preferred is a daily dosage within the range of 10 to 50 mg. Also less preferred is a daily dosage within the range of 50 mg to 200 mg. Even less preferred is a daily dosage within the range of 1 mg to 10 mg, or a daily dosage within the range of 200 mg to 2000 mg.
The most preferred daily dosage for children over age 10 is one half of the daily dosage for adults (e.g. one unit dose of 25 mg per day).
6.4 Other Lipophilic Mercaptans
The examples above have emphasized the use of lipophilic mercaptans which are present naturally in foods such as garlic, onions, and cabbage or are produced from these during normal food preparation and consumption. In particular, both allyl mercaptan and propyl mercaptan are already approved as food ingredients by the FDA. In addition, garlic oil, diallyl disulfide, onion oil, and dipropyl disulfide (which are all FDA approved for use in foods) metabolize during digestion to form allyl mercaptan or propyl mercaptan. In addition to their natural consumption by populations for millennia, these compounds have been used experimentally without apparent toxicity in animals at dosages up to 100 mg/kg, which would correspond to a dosage of 7,000 mg for a 70 kg adult human.
Because allyl mercaptan has a partition coefficient (Log P) of 1.51 (e.g. it equilibrates to a 30 to 1 higher concentration in the oil side than in the water of a system with both oil and water), the most desirable partition coefficient is approximately 1.51 (e.g. the range of 1.3 to 1.7). Propyl mercaptan has a partition coefficient (Log P) of 1.95 (e.g. it equilibrates to an almost 100 to 1 higher concentration in the oil side than in the water of a system with both oil and water) therefore a less desirable partition coefficient range is from 1.7 to 2.3 (the range which encompasses propyl mercaptan). A still less desirable partition coefficient range is from 1.0 to 1.3 (encompassing some slightly less lipophillic mercaptans) or above 2.3 (encompassing the more lipophillic mercaptans).
Therefore, the present invention is not limited to compounds where the lipophilic mercaptan component is either allyl mercaptan or propyl mercaptan. Other lipophilic mercaptans are likely to also be safe and beneficial. In particular, some control of the depth of the SH group within a lipid could be obtained by varying the carbon chain length, which may prove to be of benefit.
Because the lipophilic mercaptans can be expected to occasionally form mixed disulfides with glutathione, it is desirable to limit their molecular mass to 200 g/mol or less. This is because if the molecular mass was greater than this, there could be the possibility that these “glutathione conjugates” would be excreted from the cell by a “multidrug resistance protein” (MRP).
Multidrug resistance proteins are also known as the “GS-X pump” because it will pump any compound “X” out of the cell provided that the “X” becomes conjugated with glutathione and provided that “X” exceeds a molecular mass of approximately 250. The GS-X pump has been extensively studied due to its role in the detoxification of various anti-tumor chemotherapeutic drugs, such as Cisplatin (whose molecular mass is 301 g/mol), thereby reducing their effectiveness (QP606.G59G59:199). Tumor cells with increased expression of the GS-X pump are termed “multidrug resistant”.
Another consideration is that many molecular receptors respond selectively to various organic ring structures. In order to avoid the unintentional recognition of the lipophilic mercaptan by some type of receptor (e.g. an untended side effect), it is desirable to not include any ring structures in the structure of the lipophilic mercaptan.
The most preferred lipophilic mercaptans are allyl mercaptan and propyl mercapan, because both of these (and their respective disulfides) are already approved by the FDA for use in foods. Because they both have a carbon backbone of 3 carbon atoms, the most preferred number of carbon atoms is 3. Carbon backbones in the range of 1 to 2 are less preferred. Carbon backbones in the range of 4 to 5 are also less preferred. Carbon backbones of length 6 and above are even less preferred. In general, any lipophilic mercaptans of the invention should be an organic molecule (i.e. include a backbone of carbon and also include hydrogen atoms along with the other atoms in the molecule), the carbon backbone can be branched, but it cannot have any rings. In other words, the molecule must have a single SH group, optionally have other groups attached to the carbon backbone (branching is not excluded), and have a molecular mass of 200 g/mol or less.
6.5 Other Neurodegenerative Diseases
Although this disclosure has focused on Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases, those skilled in the art will recognize that various other neurodegenerative diseases share the features of neuroinflammation, lipid peroxidation, increased levels of protein carbonyls, and in many cases various types of protein aggregation. These are all indicators that aldehydes are being formed as lipid peroxidation products, and that there are protein-aldehyde adducts being formed. One of skill in the art will recognize that the present invention will be useful in limiting disease progression for all of the diseases that share these characteristics.
6.5.1 Lewy Body Disease
Lewy body disease is very similar to Parkinson's disease and is sometimes considered to be a less advanced form of Parkinson's disease. In particular, it exhibits excessive formation of Lewy bodies (protein aggregates composed largely of alpha syneuclein, as described in the disclosure above). The present invention can be used to decrease the formation of Lewy bodies for this disease, just as it can for Parkinson's disease.
6.5.2 Tauopathys
Taupathies are a class of neurodegenerative diseases associated with the pathological aggregation of tau protein in the human brain. The current invention can decrease the amount of protein aggregation in the neurofibrillary tangles of tauopathies, just as it can in Alzheimer's disease.
6.5.3 Multiple Sclerosis
In mice with Experimental Autoimmune Enchephalomyelitis (EAE, an animal model for multiple sclerosis) the autoinflammation induced demyelination of the myelin sheath of neurons can be decreased by 80% by treatment with the aldehyde scavenger hydralazine (NEURO173:150). This treatment also delayed the age of onset of the disease by 30% and reduced the “EAE behavioral score” by 50%. These results indicate that aldehyde scavenging by lipophilic mercaptans will protect against the development and progression of multiple sclerosis.
Note: Hydralazine is a small molecule with an exposed amino group that can “compete” with the amino groups of proteins for damage from acrolein. (Each hydralazine-aldehyde adduct is “a protein-aldehyde adduct that didn't happen”.) In order to be effective, it needs to be used in a high concentration (the competition between the amino groups of hydalazine and those of proteins is in a level playing field). At these concentrations, hydalazine has toxic side effects, so it hasn't been used for this purpose in humans. Still, the experimental results in mice indicate that lipophilic mercaptans will work in humans.
6.5.4 Polyneuropathy
Polyneuropathy also involves the destruction of the myelin sheath of neurons, most commonly due to an autoimmune response. In this respect it is even more similar to EAE than Multiple Sclerosis, so the results reported for suppression of EAE in mice (NEURO173:150, described in the previous section) indicate that lipophilic mercaptans will protect against the development and progression of polyneuropathy.
6.5.5 Spinal Cord Injury
It is well established that the overall pathophysiology of spinal cord injure consists on an initial primary insult, which is characterized by mechanical injury, as well as a number of secondary injuries, which are largely mediated by biochemical mechanisms and oxidative stress. The spinal cord continues to degenerate following the initial insult, and the lesion spreads to adjacent, otherwise uninjured tissues. A study using guinea pigs has shown that subsequent to the injury, the level of protein-acrolein adducts increases by almost 500%. This could induce a feedback cycle involving neuroinflammation which then drives the spreading of the lesion.
6.5.6 Ischemia
It is also well established that most of the neurotoxicity from ischemia cones not from the period of deprivation of oxygen, but rather from the reperfusion and subsequent persistent neuroinflammation.
Evidence for such a feed back loop is the involvement of NFkB activation and the protective effect of its inhibition (FOLIABIOL53:164).
Further evidence for the involvement of an inflammation to aldehyde to inflammation feedback loop is elevation of HNE that occurs, and the protective effect of treatment with edaravone (STROKE36:2220).
These results indicate that lipophilic mercaptans should be effective for the treatment of ischemia.
6.5.7 Stroke
Because stroke is primarily involves ischemia in its pathogenesis, stroke treatment would also benefit from the suppression of the inflammatory feedback loop.
Therefore, lipophilic mercaptans should be effective for the treatment of stroke.
The unsuccessful attempts to form a solid composition containing SAMNAC or SPMNAC that could be ground into a powder for use in dietary supplements (described in section 6.2.3.5.2 above) have been also described in the parent application (Ser. No. 13/373,878 which was filed on Dec. 5, 2011). Subsequent to the filing of the parent application, the applicant has discovered ways to make the desired compositions, as disclosed and taught below.
7.1 A Successful Dietary Supplement Capsule Composition
By using calcium carbonate to adjust the pH (instead of potassium bicarbonate), a calcium salt is formed (instead of a potassium salt), which forms a solid which can easily be ground into a powder suitable for use in a capsule.
The procedure I used is:
Each capsule has an estimated to have a maximum of 63 mg of S-propylmercapto-N-acetylcysteine (which gives 20 mg of propylmercapto groups) and approximately 140 mg of “excess” N-acetylcysteine.
7.2 Additional Compositions
7.2.1 A Higher Dosage Capsule
Each capsule has an estimated to have a maximum of 160 mg of S-allylmercapto-N-acetylcysteine (which gives 50 mg of allyl mercapto groups) and 50 mg of excess N-acetylcysteine. This formulation is optimized to have close to a 1 to 1 ratio between the number of allylmercapto groups and the number of N-acetylcysteine molecules in the ingredients, producing a higher dosage of lipophillic mercaptan (i.e. 50 mg) in each capsule.
7.2.2 A Whey Protein Based Capsule
Each capsule has an estimated to have a maximum of 80 mg of S-allylmercapto-N-acetylcysteine (which gives 25 mg of allyl mercapto groups) and 25 mg of excess N-acetylcysteine. This formulation is optimized to have close to a 1 to 1 ratio between the number of allylmercapto groups and the number of N-acetylcysteine molecules in the ingredients, to include a higher amount of magnesium (a mineral which is commonly deficient in modern diets), and to include whey protein.
7.2.3 A Rice Protein Based Capsule
Each capsule has an estimated to have a maximum of 80 mg of S-allylmercapto-N-acetylcysteine (which gives 25 mg of allyl mercapto groups) and 25 mg of excess N-acetylcysteine. This formulation is optimized to have close to a 1 to 1 ratio between the number of allylmercapto groups, the number of N-acetylcysteine molecules, and divalent magnesium bonds available for salt formation in the ingredients, to include a higher amount of magnesium (a mineral which is commonly deficient in modern diets), and to use rice protein (because some people avoid whey protein).
These examples are illustrative and the invention is not intended to be limited to these examples.
This application is a divisional application of U.S. application Ser. No. 13/694,447, filed Dec. 3, 2012, which is a continuation in part of U.S. application Ser. No. 13/373,878, filed on Dec. 5, 2011, each of which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7678833 | Ott | Mar 2010 | B2 |
| 8217084 | Ott | Jul 2012 | B2 |
| 8455552 | Savion | Jun 2013 | B2 |
| 20130143967 | Ott | Jun 2013 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 2139465 | Sep 2012 | EP |
| 62063517 | Sep 2012 | JP |
| 2008135984 | Nov 2008 | WO |
| Entry |
|---|
| Barber et al. Dementia with Lewy bodies: diagnosis and management: International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 2001; 16: S12-S18. |
| McKeith et al. Dementia with Lewy bodies. The Lancet, Neurology, vol. 3, Jan. 2004. |
| McKeith et al. Lewy Body Dementia—Diagnosis and Treatment. British Journal of Psychiatry, 1995, 167, 709-717. |
| Quarles RH, et al. Myelin Formation, Structure and Biochemistry. In: Siegel GJ, Agranoff BW, Albers RW, et al., ?. . . ditors. Basic Neurochemistry: Molecular, Cellular and Medical Aspects. 6th edition. Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven; 1999. Chapter 4. |
| Cygan, Adduction of Cholesterol 5,6-Secosterol Aldehyde to Membrane-Bound Myelin Basic Protein Exposes an immunodominant Epitope, Biochemistry, 2011, pp. 2092-2100, vol. 50. |
| Leung, Anti-Acrolein Treatment Improves Behavioral Outcome and Alleviates Myelin Damage in Experimental Autoimmune Enchephalomyelitis Mouse, Neuroscience, 2011, pp. 150-155, vol. 173. |
| Hamilton, Elevated Protein Carbonyloation, and Misfolding in Sciatic Nerve from dbldb and Soc1-/-Mice: Plausible ink between Oxidative Stress and Demyelination, Jun. 2013, 10 pgs, vol. 8, Issue 6. |
| Nie, Amyloid-like aggregates of neuronal tau induced by formaldehyde promote apoptosis of neuronal cells, BMC Neuroscience, Jan. 23, 2007, 16 pgs. |
| Chen, Potential implications of endogenous aldehydes in B-amyloid misfolding, oligomerization and fibrillogenesis, Journal of Neurochemistry, 2006, pp. 1413-1424, vol. 99. |
| Venere, Findings suggest new cause, possible treatment for multiple sclerosis, Nov. 23, 2010, 3 pgs, downloaded from: http://www.purdue_edu/newsroom/research/2010/101123ShiAcrolein_html. |
| O'Mullan et al. Sniffing out the truth; New York Times Jan. 21, 2007. |
| Turin, What you can't smell will kill you; New York Times Jan. 21, 2007. |
| Anderson, et al. Glutathione monoethyl ester: preparation, uptake by tissues, and conversion to glutathione; Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics, 1985, pp. 538-548, vol. 239, No. 2. |
| Di Buono et al., Total sulfur amino acid requirement in young men as determined by indicator amino acid oxidation; American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2001, pp. 756-760, vol. 74, No. 6. |
| Meister, Glutathione; Anual Review of Biochemistry, 1983, pp. 711-760, vol. 52. |
| Zuo et al., Variation in APOE and STH loci and Alzheimer's disease; Behavioral and Brain Functions, 2005, pp. 13, vol. 52. |
| Gyamlan I et al., Acetaminophen toxicity: suicidal vs accidental; Critical Care, 2002, pp. 155, vol. 6. |
| Neuhouser et al., Fruits and Vegetables Are Associated with Lower Lung Cancer Risk Only in the Placebo Arm of the β-Carotene and Retinol Efficacy Trial (CARET); Cancer Epidemiology; Biomarkers & Prevention, 2003, pp. 350-358, vol. 12, No. 4. |
| Bahlis et al., Feasibility and Correlates of Arsenic Trioxide Combined with Ascorbic Acid-mediated Depletion of Intracellular Glutathione for the Treatment of Relapsed/Refractory Multiple Myeloma; Clinical Cancer Research, 2002, pp. 3658-3668, vol. 8, No. 2. |
| Xu et al., Structural Characterization of a 4-Hydroxy-2-alkenal-Derived Fluorophore That Contributes to Lipoperoxidation-Dependent Protein Cross-Linking in Aging and Degenerative Disease; Chemical Research in Toxicology, 1998, pp. 247-251, vol. 11, No. 4. |
| Gao et al., Neuroinflammation and α-Synuclein Dysfunction Potentiate Each Other, Driving Chronic Progression of Neurodegeneration in a Mouse Model of Parkinson's Disease; Environmental Health Perspectives, 2011, pp. 807-814, vol. 119, No. 6. |
| Abdul et al., Oxidative damage in brain from human mutant APP/PS-1 double knock-in mice as a function of age; Free Radicals in Biology and Medicine, 2008, pp. 1420-1425-. vol. 45, No. 10. |
| Izgov et al., S-allylmercapto-N-acetylcysteine up-regulates cellular glutathione and protects vascular endothelial cells from oxidative stress; Free Radicals in Biology and Medicine, 2011, pp. 1131-1139, vol. 50, No. 9. |
| Akama et al., Beta-amyloid stimulation of inducible nitric-oxide synthase in astrocytes is interleukin-1beta- and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNFalpha)-dependent, and involves a TNFalpha receptor-associated factor- and NFkappaB-inducing kinase-dependent signaling mechanism; Journal of Biological Chemistry, 2000, pp. 7918-7924, vol. 75, No. 11. |
| Choi et al., Oxidative modifications and down-regulation of ubiquitin carboxyl-terminal hydrolase L1 associated with idiopathic Parkinson's and Alzheimer's diseases; Journal of Biological Chemistry, 2004, pp. 13256, vol. 279, No. 13. |
| Zhou et al., DJ-1 up-regulates glutathione synthesis during oxidative stress and inhibits A53T alpha-synuclein toxicity; Journal of Biological Chemistry, 2005, pp. 43150-43158, vol. 280. |
| Qin et al., Effect of 4-hydroxy-2-nonenal modification on alpha synuclein aggregation; Journal of Biological Chemistry, 2007, pp. 5862-5870, vol. 282, No. 8. |
| Sugaya et al., New anti-inflammatory treatment stretegy in Alzheimer's disease; Japanese Journal of Pharmacology, 2000, pp. 85-94, vol. 82, No. 2. |
| Halle et al., The NALP3 inflammasome is involved in the innate immune response to amyloid-beta; Nature Immunology, 2008, pp. 857-865, vol. 9, No. 8. |
| Butterfield et al., Evidence that amyloid beta-peptide-induced lipid peroxidation and its sequeale in Alzheimer's disease brain contribute to neuronal death; Neurobiology of Aging, 2002, pp. 655-664, vol. 23, No. 5. |
| Pocernich et al., Glutathione elevation and its protective role in acrolein-induced protein damage in synaptosomal membranes: relevance to brain lipid peroxidation in neurodegenerative disease; Neurochemistry International; 2001, pp. 141-149, Vol. 39, No. 2. |
| Leung et al., Anti-acrolein treatment improves behavioral outcome and alleviates myelin damage in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis mouse; Neuroscuence, 2011, pp. 150-155, vol. 173. |
| Rakovac et al., Mutations in PINK1 andParkin impair ubiquination of Mitofusins in human fibroblasts; PLoS ONE, 2011,6:E16746. |
| Schmechl et al., Increased amyloid beta-peptide deposition in cerebral cortex as a consequence of apolipoprotein E; Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 1993, pp. 9649-9653, vol. 90, No. 20. |
| Block, Garlic and other Alliums; p. 150; RSC Publishing, Cambridge UK, 2010. |
| Vermeulen et al., Glutathione S-Transferases; pp. 199-211; Taylor and Francis Ltd, London, 1996. |
| Schauenstein et al., Aldehydes in Biological Systems; pp. 66-69; Pion Limited, London, 1977. |
| Cadenas et al., Handbook of Antioxidants; pp. 235-249; Marcel Decker, NY, 2001. |
| Koch et al., Garlic; pp. 42 and 93; Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, MD, 1996. |
| Beyer et al., Molecular Pathology of Lewy Body Diseases; Int. J. Mol. Sci., 2009, pp. 724-745, vol. 10. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20170100349 A1 | Apr 2017 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 13694447 | Dec 2012 | US |
| Child | 15387181 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 13373878 | Dec 2011 | US |
| Child | 13694447 | US |
