None.
Not applicable.
Not applicable.
Downhole tools and completion strings may use isolation devices and/or pressure barriers such as packers and others for isolating one zone from another or for isolating a plurality of zones. Some isolation tools are designed to maintain a pressure differential in one direction only, which may be referred to as unidirectional pressure barrier tools and/or unidirectional isolation tools. Other isolation tools are designed to maintain a pressure differential in both directions, which may be referred to as dual directional pressure barrier tools and/or dual directional isolation tools. Pressure on seals may be exerted by reservoir pressures, by pressure applied from the surface into an annulus, and by other pressure sources. Pressure may be exerted by liquids and/or gases. Some isolation devices and/or pressure barrier tools are designed to be deployed, to seal, to unseal, and to be retrieved from the wellbore, which may be referred to as retrievable tools.
Disclosed herein is a downhole retrievable dual directional isolation tool, comprising a mandrel, a compressor ring concentric with the mandrel, and a packing element concentric with the mandrel and having an outer surface defining a plurality of grooves.
Also disclosed herein is a downhole retrievable dual directional isolation tool, comprising a mandrel, a packing element concentric with the mandrel, a compressor ring concentric with the mandrel and having a first side wall proximate to a second side wall of the packing element, and a stop ring concentric with the mandrel having a third side wall proximate to a fourth side wall of the packing element, wherein the first side wall of the compressor ring or the third side wall of the stop ring have a circumferential land, whereby in a set state of the tool a contact area between the circumferential land and the second side wall of the packing element or the fourth side wall of the packing element achieves higher contact pressure.
Further disclosed herein is a downhole retrievable dual directional isolation tool, comprising a mandrel, a packing element having an outer surface defining a plurality of circumferential grooves, wherein the grooves are angled across an axial section of the packing element.
Further disclosed herein is a downhole retrievable dual directional isolation tool, comprising a mandrel, a packing element body concentric with the mandrel and comprising a first elastomeric material having a first hardness, and at least one sealing insert concentric with the mandrel and comprising a second elastomeric material having a second hardness, wherein the second hardness is less than the first hardness.
These and other features will be more clearly understood from the following detailed description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and claims.
For a more complete understanding of the present disclosure, reference is now made to the following brief description, taken in connection with the accompanying drawings and detailed description, wherein like reference numerals represent like parts.
It should be understood at the outset that although illustrative implementations of one or more embodiments are illustrated below, the disclosed systems and methods may be implemented using any number of techniques, whether currently known or in existence. The disclosure should in no way be limited to the illustrative implementations, drawings, and techniques illustrated below, but may be modified within the scope of the appended claims along with their full scope of equivalents.
Packing elements may be employed in a variety of wellbore servicing operations. Dual directional, removable isolation tools having one or more packing elements may be activated for sealing by compressing the packing element, for example by compressing the packing element between a stop ring and a compressor ring. In some contexts, the stop ring and the compressor ring may be referred to as an upper gauge ring and a lower gauge ring. Activating the packing element by delivering compression force to the packing element may be referred to in some contexts as pack-off. Under some conditions, upon completion of the packing element pack-off, a slight backlash or relaxation of the pack-off may occur. This backlash may reduce the sealing effectiveness of the packing element at one or both ends of the packing element. Under these circumstances, the packing element may seal positively when the fluid and/or gas pressure differential across the packing element has a first sense but may leak when the fluid and/or gas pressure differential across the packing element has an opposite sense. Under some conditions, the packing element may cool over time and shrink as a result of this cooling, again reducing the sealing effectiveness of the packing element. The present disclosure teaches profiling or shaping of packing element surfaces to provide increased surface contact pressure at selected points on the packing element and decreased surface contact pressure at other selected points on the packing element. Additionally or in combination with this concept, the disclosure further teaches providing packing elements having surface areas of restricted sealing or surface areas where sealing is limited. These concepts may also be combined with selective and/or designed flow of formation fluids and/or formation gases past a portion of the packing element surface to an inside diameter of the packing element to activate a different portion of the packing element surface to seal by operation of a pressure differential across a selected and/or designed portion of the packing element.
The sealing effectiveness of a packing element may be related to the contact area to which a contact force is applied. When a packing element is packed-off, the compression force causing the packing element to expand as its axial length (axial with reference to the axis of a mandrel over which the packing element is disposed) is reduced by compression causes the packing element outside diameter surface to apply a contact force to the interior wall of the wellbore and/or a casing. More force applied to the contact area between the packing element and a casing wall, for example, may increase the sealing effectiveness of the isolation tool. Applying the same amount of force but over a diminished contact area between the packing element and the casing wall, for example, may likewise increase the sealing effectiveness of the isolation tool. A packing element having a reduced contact area and/or areas is taught in the following disclosure. Depending on a surface geometry of a packing element, reducing the contact area of the packing element may be employed to restrict sealing over a specific area, that is to reduce the sealing effectiveness over the subject area.
In an embodiment, one or more circumferential insert may be set into a packing element, where the hardness of the circumferential insert is less hard (lower durometer) than the remaining packing element. The circumferential insert may provide increased sealing effectiveness while the harder packing element may at least partially surround and support the circumferential insert.
Turning now to
In an embodiment, the downhole tool 100 is retrievable by one of a wireline and an electrical line. Those skilled in the art appreciate that retrieving the downhole tool 100 using wireline or electrical line may impose structural limitations on the packing element 102. For example, a tool comprising a packing element 102 that is suitable for retrieving using jointed pipe may not be suitable for retrieving using wireline or electrical line. The packing element 102 is at least partially flexible and swells when compressed by the compressor ring 108 and resumes its former shape, at least partially, when compression forces are removed. In an embodiment, the packing element 102 may comprise rubber, but in other embodiments the packing element 102 may comprise other elastomeric material or materials.
In an embodiment, the packing element 102 comprises an elastomer or a plurality of elastomers. The elastomers may include any suitable elastomeric material that can melt, cool, and solidify onto a high density additive. In an embodiment, the elastomer may be a thermoplastic elastomer (TPE). Without limitation, examples of monomers suitable for use in forming TPEs include dienes such as butadiene, isoprene and hexadiene, and/or monoolefins such as ethylene, butenes, and 1-hexene. In an embodiment, the TPE includes polymers comprising aromatic hydrocarbon monomers and aliphatic dienes. Examples of suitable aromatic hydrocarbon monomers include without limitation styrene, alpha-methyl styrene, and vinyltoluene. In an embodiment, the TPE is a crosslinked or partially crosslinked material. The elastomer may have any particle size compatible with the needs of the process. For example, the particle size may be selected by one of ordinary skill in the art with the benefits of this disclosure to allow for easy passage through standard wellbore servicing devices such as for example pumping or downhole equipment. In an embodiment, the elastomer may have a median particle size, also termed D50, of greater than about 500 microns, alternatively of greater than about 550 microns, and a particle size distribution wherein about 90% of the particles pass through a 30 mesh sieve US series.
In an embodiment, packing element 102 may comprise a resilient material. Herein resilient materials may refer to materials that are able to reduce in volume when exposed to a compressive force and return back to about their normal volume (e.g., pre-compressive force volume) when the compressive force subsides. In an embodiment, the resilient material returns to about the normal volume (e.g., to about 100% of the normal volume) when the compressive force subsides. In an alternative embodiment, the resilient material returns to a high percentage of the normal volume when the compressive force subsides. A high percentage refers to a portion of the normal volume that may be from about 70% to about 99% of the normal volume, alternatively from about 70% to about 85% of the normal volume, and further alternatively from about 85% to about 99% of the normal volume. Such resilient materials may be solids, liquids or gases.
In an embodiment, the packing element 102 is intended to provide a dual directional seal. A dual directional seal, as this term is intended to be construed in this disclosure, is suitable for establishing a seal with a casing wall that blocks flow of either fluid or gases across the seal in either direction, independently of the sense of the pressure differential that may exist between an annulus formed between the tool 100 and the wellbore casing on a first side of the packing element 102 and the annulus on the opposite side of the packing element 102. In an embodiment, the packing element 102 is intended for use to seal in the presence of high gas pressure differentials with zero leakage or very little leakage.
Turning now to
With reference to
In an embodiment, the land 262 may be a circumferentially continuous ridge. As used herein, the term ‘land’ is used to refer to a surface structure of the packing element that projects above surrounding grooves or channels. The outside diameter of the packing element at the peak of the land may be substantially the same as the outside diameter of the packing element outside of the region of lands and grooves. Alternatively, in some embodiments, the outside diameter of the packing element at the peak of the land may be different from the outside diameter of the packing element outside the region of lands and grooves. In an embodiment, the groove 264 may be a circumferentially continuous groove or channel. The outside diameter of the packing element at the bottom of the groove is less than the outside diameter of the packing element at the peak of the land. The packing element 260 may be formed by cutting or milling the grooves 264 out of the outer circumferential surface of a smooth surfaced packing element. Alternatively, the packing element 260 may be formed by molding to have the pattern of lands 262 and grooves 264. In an embodiment, the packing element 260 may comprise an anti-extrusion mechanism 266, for example two circumferential anti-extrusion rings. In an embodiment, the anti-extrusion rings may expand with the expansion of the packing element 260 when compressed.
The force exerted on a surface can be related to a contact pressure and a contact surface area as
F∝PA (Eq 1)
P∝F/A (Eq 2)
where F is a force applied normally to the surface, A is the area of the contact, and P is the contact pressure exerted on the surface expressed as pressure per unit area. Eq 1 expresses force as directly proportional to both contact pressure and contact surface area. Eq 2 rearranges Eq 1 by a simple algebraic operation to express contact pressure as directly proportional to force and indirectly proportional to contact area. Worded alternatively, Eq 2 expresses pressure as directly proportional to both force and the reciprocal of contact area. It will be appreciated that the above proportional relations may be transformed to express equalities by use of an appropriate multiplicative constant of proportionality to account for units. In the SI system of units, no constant of proportionality is needed, or the constant is unity, provided force is expressed in units of Newtons, contact pressure is expressed in units of Pascals, and contact area is expressed in units of square meters.
A predetermined compression force may be applied to the packing element 260 by an isolation tool, for example the stop ring 106 and the compressor ring 108 of the tool 100. This predetermined compression force may be said to result in a predetermined force applied to the casing wall by the outer circumferential surface of the packing element 260, as the packing element 260 swells in response to the compression force. When a fixed or predetermined force is applied to a casing wall by the outer circumferential surface of the packing element 260, the contact pressure between the packing element and the casing wall may be said to increase with reference to a similar sized smooth surfaced packing element because the outer circumferential surface area of the packing element 260—term A in Eq 2 above—has been reduced with reference to the surface area of the smooth surfaced packing element by the grooves 264. It is known to those of skill in the art that increased contact pressure between a packing element and a casing wall may be associated with more effective sealing, for example sealing against flow of high pressure gas.
With reference to
With reference to
In an embodiment, the grooves 286, 292 and the lands 288, 290 slant towards the intermediate land 294 from an inner diameter to an outer diameter of the packing element 280. In some contexts, this disposition of lands 288, 290 and grooves 286, 292 may be referred to as a chevron pattern or a chevron configuration. Alternatively, in another embodiment, the grooves 286, 292 and the lands 288, 290 may slant away from the intermediate land 294. Alternatively, in still another embodiment, the grooves 286, 292 and the lands 288, 290 may all slant leftwards or may all slant rightwards. In an embodiment, the intermediate land 294 may define a form other than a rhomboid form in axial section.
As depicted in
While
With reference to
In some contexts, the first circumferential surface 308 may be referred to as a knurled surface or a roughened surface. In an embodiment, the first circumferential surface 308 may be formed not of intersecting striations of parallel grooves but instead may be formed of a plurality of scallops and/or cuts into the material of the packing element 300 that generally promote the reduction of contact area and decreased or limited sealing effectiveness. Alternatively, in an embodiment, the packing element 300 having such a first circumferential surface 308 may be fabricated by molding in a mold corresponding to the plurality of scallops and/or cuts.
With reference to
The outer surface embedded circumferential ridges, for example ridge 704, and the side wall embedded circumferential ridges, for example ridge 706, may be formed of a second elastomeric material having a second hardness, where the second hardness is less than or equal to the first hardness. In an embodiment, the first hardness may vary over the range from about 85 Durometer hardness to 100 Durometer hardness. In an embodiment, the second hardness may vary over the range from about 70 Durometer hardness to about 85 Durometer hardness. The greater hardness and/or greater resilience of the packing element body 702 may promote better recovery and anti-extrusion characteristics of the packing element. Additionally, the greater hardness of the packing element body 702 may provide increased support for the outer surface embedded ridges and the side wall embedded ridges. The outer surface embedded ridges and the side wall embedded ridges may promote improved sealing effectiveness. The outer surface embedded ridges and the side wall embedded ridges may be referred to as sealing inserts or inserts in some contexts. While illustrated in
With reference to
Turning now to
With reference to
Turning now to
The side walls 342, 344 comprise a plurality of circumferential lands 346 and define a plurality of circumferential grooves 348. While shown in
Turning now to
With reference to
The sub-component 370 is disposed concentric with the mandrel 104 of the downhole tool 100. In an embodiment, the first gauge ring 378 is disposed between the compressor ring 108 and the packing element 372, and the second gauge ring 382 is disposed between the stop ring 106 and the packing element 372. The stop ring 106 stops the second gauge ring 382, and the second gauge ring 382 stops the packing element 372. The compressor ring 108 applies force to the first gauge ring 378, and the first gauge ring 378 transfers the compression force to the packing element 372. Alternatively, in an embodiment, the first gauge ring 378 is the same device as the compressor ring 108 or provides the functionality of the compressor ring 108, and the second gauge ring 382 is the same device as the stop ring 106 or provides the functionality of the stop ring 106. The gauge rings 378, 382 may be fabricated from metal or non-metallic material. The faces of the ridges 380, 384 may be smooth, for example lapped and/or polished, to promote effective sealing and/or to avoid cutting the sidewalls 374, 376.
With reference to
With reference to
With reference to
With reference to
In a run in condition, the first side wall 506 and the third side wall 516 are separated by a gap 520. The first ridge 506 projects from the first side wall 504 by a distance substantially equal to the gap 520. The second groove 518 has a depth 522. The depth 522 is less than the gap 520. The sub-component further comprises a second gauge ring 524 comprising a fourth side wall 526 and defining a third circumferential groove 528. In the run in condition, the second side wall 508 and the fourth side wall 526 are separated by a gap substantially equal to the gap 520. The second ridge 510 projects from the second wall 508 by a distance substantially equal to the gap 520. The depth of the third groove 528 is substantially equal to the depth 522.
The first side wall 504 slopes towards the first gauge ring 514 and the second side wall 508 slopes towards the second gauge ring 524 from an inner diameter to an outer diameter of the packing element 502. The third side wall 516 and the fourth side wall 526 slope away from the packing element 502 from an inner diameter to an outer diameter of the gauge ring 514, 524, respectively. In the detail view, a portion of the sub-component 500 is shown in the compressed and/or deployed condition. The packing element 502 is shown to be expanded. In this condition, the second ridge 510 is compressed by an amount that depends on the difference between the gap 520 and the depth 522, thereby promoting increased sealing effectiveness. In some contexts, the ridges 506, 510 may be said to establish designed enhanced contact pressure zones when engaged with the grooves 518, 528. One skilled in the art will appreciate that much of the description of packing elements and gauge rings above applies substantially to the sub-component 500.
With reference to
Turning now to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
Referring to
In an embodiment, one or more of the controlled surface contact area features described above may be combined in the packing element 102. In an embodiment, one or more of the packing elements 260, 270, 280, 300, 320, 330, 340, 372, 402, 422, 452, 502, or 552 may comprise through holes and/or vent holes providing communication between the inner surface and the outer surface of the subject packing element. Other combinations of the many disclosed features are contemplated by the present disclosure. One or more of the controlled surface contact area features of the embodiments described above may be employed in packing elements 102 having asymmetrical design features. For example, a longitudinal center of the region of grooves and lands of the embodiments shown in
Turning now to
The servicing rig 1314 may be one of a drilling rig, a completion rig, a workover rig, a servicing rig, or other mast structure and supports a toolstring 1306 and a conveyance 1312 in the wellbore 1302, but in other embodiments a different structure may support the toolstring 1306 and the conveyance 1312, for example an injector head of a coiled tubing rigup. In an embodiment, the servicing rig 1314 may comprise a derrick with a rig floor through which the toolstring 1306 and conveyance 1312 extends downward from the servicing rig 1314 into the wellbore 1302. In some embodiments, such as in an off-shore location, the servicing rig 1314 may be supported by piers extending downwards to a seabed. Alternatively, in some embodiments, the servicing rig 1314 may be supported by columns sitting on hulls and/or pontoons that are ballasted below the water surface, which may be referred to as a semi-submersible platform or rig. In an off-shore location, a casing may extend from the servicing rig 1314 to exclude sea water and contain drilling fluid returns. It is understood that other mechanical mechanisms, not shown, may control the run-in and withdrawal of the toolstring 1306 and the conveyance 1312 in the wellbore 1302, for example a draw works coupled to a hoisting apparatus, a slickline unit or a wireline unit including a winching apparatus, another servicing vehicle, a coiled tubing unit, and/or other apparatus.
The toolstring 1306 may comprise one or more downhole tools, for example a retrievable bridge plug 1308 and a setting tool 1310. Alternatively, the toolstring 1306 may comprise a different downhole tool, for example a retrievable packer. In some contexts, the retrievable bridge plug 1308 may be referred to as a down hole dual directional isolation tool or a downhole wireline retrievable dual directional isolation tool, and having a lower end 1320. In some contexts, the lower end 1320 may be referred to as a bull plug. The conveyance 1312 may be any of a string of jointed pipes, a slickline, a coiled tubing, a wireline, and other conveyances for the toolstring 1306. In another embodiment, the toolstring 1306 may comprise additional downhole tools located above or below the retrievable bridge plug 1308. Additionally, the toolstring 1306 may not include the retrievable bridge plug 1308 but may include instead an alternate dual directional isolation tool. In an embodiment, the toolstring 1306 may include one or more of a retrievable packer assembly, a retrievable straddle packer assembly, and/or other packer assemblies or packer subassemblies. It is contemplated that any of these packers, bridge plugs, and/or zonal isolation plugs may comprise a packing element incorporating one or a combination of the novel packing element structures described in detail above.
The toolstring 1306 may be coupled to the conveyance 1312 at the surface and run into the wellbore casing 1303, for example a wireline unit coupled to the servicing rig 1314 may run the toolstring 1306 that is coupled to a wireline into the wellbore casing 1303. In an embodiment, the conveyance may be a wireline, an electrical line, a coiled tubing, or other conveyance. The toolstring 1306 may be run past the target depth and retrieved to approximately the target depth, for example to assure that the toolstring 1306 reaches target depth. At target depth, the setting tool 1310 may be activated to set the retrievable bridge plug 1308 in the wellbore casing 1303. The setting tool 1310 may activate in response to a signal sent from the surface and/or in response to the expiration of a timer incorporated into the setting tool 1310.
In an embodiment, the setting tool 1310 may capture or grip an inner mandrel of the retrievable bridge plug 1308 and apply compression force to a sleeve structure operable to slide over the inner mandrel, for example the compressor ring 108 of
After fully deploying the packing element 1324, continued application of compression force by the setting tool 1310 may cause a latching mechanism of the retrievable bridge plug 1308 to latch the compression forces loaded into the packing element 1324. For example, the compressor ring 108 of
The retrievable bridge plug 1308 may be placed in the wellbore casing 1303 to serve a variety of purposes. The retrievable bridge plug 1308 may be installed above the uppermost production zone to seal the upper end of the wellbore casing 1303, to temporarily stop ring production, in order to remove a wellhead, also referred to as a Christmas tree, to replace or service the wellhead. After reinstallation of the wellhead, the retrievable bridge plug 1308 may be retrieved from the wellbore casing 1303. The retrievable bridge plug 1308 may be placed in the wellbore casing 1303 to seal off non-producing formations below the lowermost production zone, thus isolating the lowermost production zone from the remaining wellbore 1302 below production. The retrievable bridge plug 1308 may be placed in the wellbore casing 1303 above the uppermost production zones to suspend production, for example temporary well abandonment. The retrievable bridge plug 1308 may be placed in the wellbore casing 1303 to test tubing. The retrievable bridge plug 1308 may be placed in the wellbore casing 1303 to promote setting of a completion packer. Those skilled in the art will appreciate that yet other applications of the retrievable bridge plug 1308 are contemplated by the present disclosure and may advantageously employ the packing element 102, 1324 taught by the present disclosure.
To retrieve the retrievable bridge plug 1308, a retrieval tool (not shown) may be run into the wellbore 1302 on the conveyance 1312 to the retrievable bridge plug 1308 where the retrieval tool may couple to the retrievable bridge plug 1308. The service rig 1314 may exert upwards force on the conveyance 1312 until a shear pin, shear screw, shear ring and/or other decoupling device in the retrievable bridge plug 1308 securing the latching mechanism shears or otherwise releases. With the latching mechanism thus released, the packing element 1324 relaxes and disengages from the wellbore casing 1303. After the release of the packing element 1324, further exertion of upwards force on the conveyance 1312 by the service rig 1314 may cause the slips 1322, that may be spring loaded to the retracted position, to retract, thereby releasing the retrievable bridge plug 1308 from the wellbore casing 1303. The retrievable bridge plug 1308 may then be retrieved completely from the wellbore 1302.
While several embodiments have been provided in the present disclosure, it should be understood that the disclosed systems and methods may be embodied in many other specific forms without departing from the spirit or scope of the present disclosure. The present examples are to be considered as illustrative and not restrictive, and the intention is not to be limited to the details given herein. For example, the various elements or components may be combined or integrated in another system or certain features may be omitted or not implemented.
Also, techniques, systems, subsystems, and methods described and illustrated in the various embodiments as discrete or separate may be combined or integrated with other systems, modules, techniques, or methods without departing from the scope of the present disclosure. Other items shown or discussed as directly coupled or communicating with each other may be indirectly coupled or communicating through some interface, device, or intermediate component, whether electrically, mechanically, or otherwise. Other examples of changes, substitutions, and alterations are ascertainable by one skilled in the art and could be made without departing from the spirit and scope disclosed herein.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2632514 | Fitzpatrick | Mar 1953 | A |
2988148 | Conrad et al. | Jun 1961 | A |
3036639 | Baker | May 1962 | A |
3233676 | Lynes | Feb 1966 | A |
3282346 | Claycomb | Nov 1966 | A |
3339637 | Holden | Sep 1967 | A |
3605886 | Cox et al. | Sep 1971 | A |
3631927 | Young | Jan 1972 | A |
4326588 | McStravick | Apr 1982 | A |
4427063 | Skinner | Jan 1984 | A |
4436150 | Barker | Mar 1984 | A |
4438933 | Zimmerman | Mar 1984 | A |
4441721 | Harris et al. | Apr 1984 | A |
4518037 | Youngblood et al. | May 1985 | A |
4548265 | Luke | Oct 1985 | A |
4611658 | Salerni et al. | Sep 1986 | A |
4730835 | Wilcox et al. | Mar 1988 | A |
4765404 | Bailey et al. | Aug 1988 | A |
4809989 | Kernal | Mar 1989 | A |
4862967 | Harris | Sep 1989 | A |
4898239 | Rosenthal | Feb 1990 | A |
5117913 | Themig | Jun 1992 | A |
5176217 | Luke et al. | Jan 1993 | A |
5226494 | Rubbo et al. | Jul 1993 | A |
5311938 | Hendrickson et al. | May 1994 | A |
5431412 | Reinhardt et al. | Jul 1995 | A |
5542473 | Pringle | Aug 1996 | A |
6044908 | Wyatt | Apr 2000 | A |
6446717 | White et al. | Sep 2002 | B1 |
6691788 | Dearing | Feb 2004 | B1 |
6843480 | Nelson et al. | Jan 2005 | B2 |
7210533 | Starr et al. | May 2007 | B2 |
7360590 | Kossa et al. | Apr 2008 | B2 |
7424909 | Roberts et al. | Sep 2008 | B2 |
7673693 | Standridge et al. | Mar 2010 | B2 |
7926581 | Marshall et al. | Apr 2011 | B2 |
8091640 | Saltel | Jan 2012 | B2 |
20020121743 | Crow et al. | Sep 2002 | A1 |
20030080515 | Milberger et al. | May 2003 | A1 |
20070056725 | Lucas et al. | Mar 2007 | A1 |
20080115928 | Cherewyk | May 2008 | A1 |
20080179055 | Baski | Jul 2008 | A1 |
20080190600 | Shkurti et al. | Aug 2008 | A1 |
20080196884 | Doane et al. | Aug 2008 | A1 |
20080230236 | Wright et al. | Sep 2008 | A1 |
20080290602 | Coronado | Nov 2008 | A1 |
20090242215 | Eatwell et al. | Oct 2009 | A1 |
20100243235 | Caldwell et al. | Sep 2010 | A1 |
20110186307 | Derby | Aug 2011 | A1 |
20110247835 | Crabb | Oct 2011 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2009058021 | May 2009 | WO |
Entry |
---|
Foreign communication from a related counterpart application—International Search Report and Written Opinion, PCT/US2011/030789, Sep. 29, 2011, 8 pages. |
Foreign communication from a related counterpart application—International Search Report and Written Opinion, PCT/US2011/040032, Feb. 9, 2012, 9 pages. |
Patent application entitled “Sequenced packing element system,” by James Crabb, filed Apr. 12, 2010 as U.S. Appl. No. 12/758,411. |
Office Action dated Apr. 30, 2012 (25 pages), U.S. Appl. No. 12/758,411, filed Apr. 12, 2010. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20120006530 A1 | Jan 2012 | US |