Paper sorting system

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6250472
  • Patent Number
    6,250,472
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, April 29, 1999
    25 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, June 26, 2001
    23 years ago
Abstract
The present invention includes devices and methods for handling and sorting paper. Devices for accelerating and spreading paper from a paper input to a sensor are disclosed. Operably thin layers of paper are passed through a sensor at cost effective feed rates. One embodiment of the invention includes a spreader positioned to receive paper from the input and an inclined feed section downstream of the spreader. The inclined feed section includes first and second inclined conveyors to further accelerate and spread the paper. A feed accelerator is operably positioned to receive paper from the second inclined conveyor. The feed accelerator further accelerates and separates the paper. The feed accelerator feeds the paper to the sensor which is operably connected to an ejector downstream of the sensor. Targeted paper is ejected from the paper stream and product paper continues downstream to a product conveyor.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates to paper handling. Select embodiments of the invention are particularly well-suited for use in the waste paper recycling industry.




Environmental campaigns and recycling in many offices have generated a supply of recyclable waste paper. However, waste paper sorting is still currently performed almost entirely by manual sorting. This is time consuming and expensive. Thus, heretofore it has generally been more economical to use raw paper material than sort and process recyclable waste paper.




Numerous automated waste separation techniques are known. However these systems are designed for recovery of non-ferrous metals, aerospace alloys, municipal waste, mixed recyclables and plastic containers. Paper sorting presents unique problems not overcome by prior art separation techniques.




The unique problems encountered when attempting to sort waste paper is due to the relatively light weight and flexible nature of pieces of paper. These characteristics make it difficult to supply paper to a sorting sensor. Even when waste paper has been supplied to a sensor, it has not been supplied at a sufficient feed rate, e. g. pieces per hour (PPH), to be cost effective. Prior art sensors operate on the basis of an eddy current created by the waste stream as it passes through the sensor, diffusion of light transmission through the waste e. g. transparent glass, and the like. These techniques are inapplicable to sorting waste paper because the paper has no metallic components and the paper is opaque to light. Thus, not only must an effective paper sorting sensor be designed, an effective paper handling system must be designed to supply waste paper in sufficient feed rates to the effective paper sorting sensor. Prior art paper handling techniques have been unsatisfactory in overcoming these obstacles.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The present invention relates to paper handling and sorting methods and devices.




One embodiment of the present invention is for a paper handling system for handling paper fed to the system. The system includes a paper input adapted to receive paper and the system includes a product output. Operably positioned between the paper input and the product output is an acceleration means for distributing and accelerating the paper.




Another embodiment of the present invention is a paper handler adapted for use with a sorting machine which includes a sensor for sorting paper. The handler includes a paper input for receiving the paper and a product output positioned downstream of the paper input. The handler also includes a feed accelerator having an acceleration conveyor operably positioned to feed the paper through the sensor.




Another embodiment of the present invention is a paper sorting machine comprising a paper input and a spreader positioned to receive paper from the paper input. An inclined feed section is downstream of the spreader. The inclined feed section includes a first and a second inclined conveyor. The second inclined conveyor is downstream of the first inclined conveyor. A feed accelerator is operably positioned to receive paper from the second inclined conveyor. The feed accelerator includes an accelerator conveyor having a sensor end. A sensor is operably positioned to sense paper passing over the accelerator conveyor sensor end. An ejector is positioned downstream of the sensor. A product conveyor is downstream of the ejector and a product output is downstream of the product conveyor.




Accordingly, the present invention includes methods of handling paper which include distributing clumps of paper into operably thin layers of paper. Preferably the methods include accelerating the paper as the paper is transported downstream. In some embodiments this is accomplished by progressively increasing the speed at which the paper is transported downstream until the paper is passed through a sensor, or other operative component sensing or performing an operation on the paper.




Accordingly an object of the present invention is to provide means and methods for achieving a cost effective recycled machine grade paper fraction from a paper waste stream.




Another object of the present invention is to provide means for achieving automated sortation on a cost effective basis.




Another object of the present invention is to provide means for achieving improved consistency and repeatability in the quality of recycled waste paper.




Another object is to reduce labor requirements for sorting waste paper.




Another object of the present invention is to provide means and methods to accelerate and spread paper to operably thin layers to achieve an effective sort.




A further object of the present invention is to perform the sort at high speeds.




An object of the present invention is to incorporate automated sortation into a paper handling system to achieve consistent grades of premium paper from waste paper.




Other and further objects, features and advantages of the invention will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art upon a review of the following disclosure when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

shows an elevational side view of a paper sorting system according to the present invention.





FIG. 2

depicts the system shown in

FIG. 1

receiving clumps of paper, ejecting targeted paper, and delivering product.





FIG. 3

depicts an elevated side view the spreader included in

FIG. 1. A

paper input is shown on the right and discharge chutes depend from the spreader.

FIG. 3

shows the spreader in its preferred inclined orientation.





FIG. 4

shows a simplified schematic plan view of the spreader shown in

FIG. 3

with the paper input removed. A plurality of rotatable shafts including a plurality of discs on each shaft is depicted. The discs are oriented at zero degrees and forty-five degrees on alternating shafts.





FIG. 5

depicts an elevated side view of a rubber tipped disc. The disc is shown oriented at zero degrees.





FIG. 6

depicts a plan view of the spreader shown in

FIG. 4

wherein three sets of the rotatable shafts are rotated at progressively increasing speeds. Clumps of paper are shown being fed and accelerated on the rotatable shafts.





FIG. 7

shows a somewhat schematic elevated side view of the spreader shown in FIG.


3


.

FIG. 7

shows the spreader in an optional non-inclined orientation. Clumps of paper are shown being fed into the product input and accelerated downstream. An end-on view of three sets of rotatable shafts, which are rotating at increasing speeds, is shown.





FIG. 8

shows an enlarged view of the two inclined conveyors included in FIG.


1


. The first inclined conveyor is positioned to feed into the second inclined conveyor.





FIG. 9

shows a simplified enlarged view of the first inclined conveyor shown in FIG.


8


. The first inclined conveyor is shown accelerating underlying layers of paper and feeding the paper to the second inclined conveyor. Air supplied through a set of louvers pins the paper to the inclined conveyor belt and fluffs, and further spreads, the paper as it cascades off of the end of the first inclined conveyor.





FIG. 10

depicts an enlarged view of the acceleration conveyor, sensor and product conveyor shown in FIG.


1


.





FIG. 11

depicts the acceleration conveyor of

FIG. 10

without the sensor and without the product conveyor.





FIG. 12

shows a schematic view of the structure shown in FIG.


10


. Paper is shown pinned to the acceleration belt to feed the paper through the sensor at a predetermined speed substantially equal to the belt speed. Targeted paper is shown being ejected from the system and product paper is shown being conveyed away.





FIG. 13

shows an enlarged view of a product removal apparatus of the paper handler shown in FIG.


1


. The product removal apparatus is shown downstream of the sensor and acceleration belt.





FIG. 14

depicts a schematic view of the product removal apparatus shown in FIG.


13


. Paper is shown being pulled through the product removal conveyor and pinned to the product conveyor by an air flow generated by an air-assist means. An airlock including a rotating seal is shown de-entraining product.





FIG. 15

schematically depicts the air flow system used with the paper sorting system of FIG.


1


and the sorting system itself is shown in elevated side view.











DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS




The present invention relates to methods and apparatus for handling, in particular sorting, paper. The invention will be best understood by reference to the attached drawings wherein like reference numerals refer to like components.





FIG. 1

shows an elevated side view of one embodiment of the present invention for a paper handling or sorting system


10


. Referring to

FIG. 2

, the paper handling system


10


is adapted to handle paper


12


fed into the system. The system


10


, in the embodiment shown in

FIG. 2

, comprises a paper input


14


adapted to receive the paper


12


, and a product output


16


. The system


10


includes acceleration means


18


for distributing and accelerating the paper


12


. The acceleration means


18


is operably positioned between the paper input


14


and the product output


16


. As is further explained below, the acceleration means


18


includes several separate components including spreader


24


, inclined conveyors


50


and


52


, and acceleration conveyor


84


.




In some embodiments, the system


10


comprises an ejection output


20


between the paper input


14


and the product output


16


. A sensor means


22


for determining whether paper should be routed to the ejection output


20


or the product output


16


is included in the system


10


shown in FIG.


2


. Generally the acceleration means


18


accelerates the paper


12


from a first speed proximate the paper input


14


to a second higher speed proximate sensor means


22


.




In some embodiments the paper


12


is fed from a pit conveyor (not shown) to the paper input


14


at a rate of ten to thirty feet per minute. This may be via a lift conveyor (not shown) which transfers mixed waste paper from the pit conveyor to the paper input


14


.




In order to effectively eject sensed target paper, it is important that the paper


12


pass through the sensor means


22


at a predetermined speed. The sensor means


22


includes a sensor


23


. In some embodiments the predetermined speed at which the paper


12


passes through the sensor


23


is 1000 or 1200 feet per minute. One goal is to accelerate the paper


12


from a first speed at which it enters the system


10


to a greater speed and pass it through the sensor at the greater speed. Thus, the paper may be accelerated from 10 ft./min. to 1200 ft./min.




Another goal is to spread and separate the paper in order to achieve a more effective and efficient sort. Thus, in one embodiment the acceleration means includes the spreading means or spreader


24


for distributing and spreading paper


12


. The paper


12


generally enters the system in clumps at the paper input


14


.




THE SPREADER





FIG. 3

shows an elevated side view of the spreader


24


shown in FIG.


2


.

FIG. 4

shows a simplified or schematic plan view of the spreader


24


shown in FIG.


3


. In the embodiment of

FIG. 3

, the spreader


24


is shown in its preferred inclined orientation with the frame and thus the paper flow path being at an angle


25


which is in the range of 10° to 20°, and is preferably in the range of 14° to 16°. The spreader


24


includes a plurality of rotatable shafts


28


. Each rotatable shaft


28


includes a plurality of discs


30


.





FIG. 5

shows an elevated side view of a disc


30


. In the embodiment shown in

FIG. 5

the disc


30


is a bulged triangular disc which includes rubber tips or edges


32


. Other effective disc configurations will be apparent to those with skill in the art. The rubber tip


32


, which is urethane in one preferred embodiment, helps grip the paper


12


and accelerate paper


12


which is contacting the discs


30


ahead of other paper


12


not yet contacting the discs


30


. Other disc friction enhancing embodiments will be apparent to those with skill in the art.




As noted,

FIGS. 4

,


6


and


7


are somewhat schematic illustrations of the arrangement of the disc


30


.

FIG. 7

illustrates an alternative orientation of spreader


24


in a non-inclined position. Although the spreader


24


will operate successfully in the non-inclined position of

FIG. 7

, it has been found to be preferable to incline spreader


24


as shown in FIG.


3


. The inclination of the spreader aids in the separation and spreading of the paper, as it allows top layers to slide back over bottom layers.




In actual construction, the discs


30


are typically formed from one-quarter inch thick urethane sheet material. Adjacent discs are typically separated by a spacer plate (not shown) having a thickness on the order of one to two inches.





FIGS. 6 and 7

show plan and elevated side views, respectively, of the spreader


24


in which paper


12


is spread and accelerated by the rotatable shafts


28


and discs


30


.




The plurality of rotatable shafts


28


comprise bulged triangular discs


30


. The bulged triangular discs


30


are rotated 45 degrees relative to the remainder of the bulged triangular discs


30


. As shown in

FIG. 6

every other shaft includes a point of the disc


30


projecting out of the page. This is shown in

FIG. 7

as well.





FIG. 6

shows paper


12


flowing downstream in the direction of arrows


31


from the paper input


14


toward the product output


16


. Downstream is defined as the direction from the paper input


14


toward the product output


16


. As shown in

FIG. 6

, the plurality of rotatable shafts


28


are generally transverse to the flow of paper


12


.




The triangular shaped discs


30


function to vibrate and undulate the paper stream as it flows across discs


30


. This is accomplished by the tips of the discs


30


impacting the paper stream at regular time intervals between impacts as the paper travels downstream.





FIG. 7

shows an elevated side view of the spreader


24


. The plurality of shafts


28


comprises at least two sets of shafts including a first set of shafts


34


operating at a first speed


36


. The first speed


36


is indicated by the rotation arrows shown in

FIGS. 6 and 7

. The plurality of shafts


28


also includes a second set of shafts


38


operating at a second speed


40


. As shown in

FIGS. 6 and 7

, the second speed


40


is higher than the first speed


36


. This is indicated by use of an increased number of rotation arrows for increased speeds. Also depicted in

FIGS. 6 and 7

is a third set of shafts


42


operating at a third speed


44


.




In one embodiment the first


34


, the second


38


, and the third


42


set of shafts rotate at progressively increasing speeds. In one embodiment the first set of rotatable shafts


34


rotates at a tip speed of approximately 155 feet per minute; the second set of rotatable shafts


38


rotate at a tip speed of approximately 280 feet per minute; and the third set of rotatable shafts


42


operate at a tip speed of approximately 386 feet per minute.




These progressively increasing speeds of the first, second and third sets of shafts are accomplished by a drive means


43


including a drive motor


47


driving a gear box


49


which in turn is drivingly connected to one of the shafts


28


(see FIG.


3


). The various shafts each carry two sprockets (not shown) on their outer ends, and the sprockets of adjacent shafts are connected by drive chains (not shown). The desired relative speeds of the various shafts are controlled by the selection of the size of the sprockets attached to each shaft. Thus if it is desired to double the speed of one shaft relative to the adjacent shaft, the two shafts carry sprockets one of which has twice the number of teeth as the other, the two sprockets being connected by a chain.




Undersized material will fall between the shafts


28


and discs


30


. Removable canvas chutes


45


direct this undersized material to bins (not shown). Thus, the spreader


24


also functions as a trommel, or a sifter.




THE INCLINED CONVEYORS




Referring to

FIG. 2

the acceleration means


18


includes a plurality of inclined conveyors


50


and


52


located downstream of the spreader


24


.





FIG. 9

shows a schematic enlarged view of the inclined conveyors


50


and


52


. In

FIG. 9

the first inclined conveyor


50


operates at a first inclined conveyor speed


54


. The second inclined conveyor


52


operates at a second inclined conveyor speed


56


. Preferably the second inclined conveyor speed


56


is higher than the first inclined conveyor speed


54


. The increase in speed from one conveyor to another facilitates spreading, thinning, and acceleration of the paper


12


.





FIG. 7

shows an embodiment wherein the spreader


24


comprises a spreader output


58


. Proximate to the spreader output


58


, the spreader


24


operates at an output speed


60


. Preferably the first inclined conveyor speed


54


is higher than the spreader output speed


60


. The speed at which the paper travels downstream is thus progressively increased.




Typically the first and second inclined conveyors


50


and


52


are inclined, relative to a horizontal floor


62


, at an angle


64


in the range of ten degrees to thirty-five degrees (10° to 35°). The incline of the conveyors provides means for top layers of paper


66


to slide off of bottom layers of paper


68


. This further spreads the paper into thinner layers. Preferably the inclination angle


64


of first and second inclined conveyors


50


and


52


is about twenty-five degrees (25°).




Preferably the conveyor


50


comprises a belt


70


including rough top material


72


. In some embodiments, the conveyor belting is vulcanized seamless rough top rubber material. The rough top material


72


helps grip the bottom layers of paper


68


and accelerate them to a speed substantially equivalent to the speed of the inclined conveyor belt. The material further helps to spread the bottom layers of paper


68


apart from the top layers of paper


66


. The bottom layers of paper


68


are being pulled or carried along the belt


70


at a greater speed than the top layers of paper


66


, while the top layers of paper


66


slide down off of the bottom layers of paper


68


due to gravity. Other conventional belting material to effectuate objectives of the present invention will be apparent to those of skill in the art.




In some embodiments the inclined conveyor


50


comprises a belt


70


and assist means


74


. The assist means


74


is for pinning the paper


12


to the belt


70


. In the embodiment shown in

FIG. 9

, air


76


flows through a set of louvers


78


positioned above the belt


70


. The air flows downward against paper


68


to assist in pinning paper


68


to belt


70


. The louvers


78


may be adjusted, opened, closed, or oriented, by a louver handle


80


. They may be automatically adjusted as well as manually adjusted. The air


76


is controlled through an air knife


82


.




Also the air assist means


74


provides a means for fluffing the paper as it cascades off the first inclined conveyor


50


onto the second inclined conveyor


52


.




Any paper which adheres to of conveyor


50


and carries over the discharge end thereof will be directed to canvas chute


83


which transfers material from a drop-out opening to container on the floor. It is noted that each of the conveyors described herein has close fitting sidewalls enclosing it on each side, so that paper cannot fall off the side of the conveyor.




In some embodiments the inclined conveyors will have variable frequency drives.




Provisions may be made for a portion of sidewalls of a conveyor to be removable for replacement of the belting. Access ports for cleaning out jams that might occur at transfer points between conveyors may be incorporated. Viewing windows may be provided to allow material flow to be observed during operations.




In some embodiments a uniform, metered feed stream of waste paper will be accepted from a typical input feed system. Multiple stages of high-speed rough-top inclined conveyors may be positioned in series to accelerate and distribute the in feed waste paper as it is being transported to an automated sensing/ejection system.




It is important to note that components of the paper handling system need not be aligned in a straight line as shown in FIG.


2


. It will be apparent to those with skill in the art that bends and angles may be incorporated where appropriate. Intermediate transport or delivery conveyors may be incorporated where appropriate as well.




THE ACCELERATION CONVEYOR AND PRODUCT CONVEYOR




The system


10


shown in

FIG. 2

comprises an acceleration conveyor


84


, which may also be referred to as a feed means


84


for feeding the paper


12


at a predetermined speed to the sensor means


22


. The acceleration conveyor


84


is positioned downstream of the inclined conveyors


50


and


52


.

FIG. 10

shows an enlarged elevated side view of the feed means


84


. In one embodiment the second conveyor


52


operates at an inclined conveyor speed which is slower than the predetermined speed at which the paper


12


is fed to the sensor


23


.





FIG. 11

shows an embodiment in which the acceleration conveyor


84


comprises an acceleration belt


86


. Referring to

FIG. 12

, the acceleration belt


86


accelerates the paper


88


to a predetermined speed at which it passes through the sensor


23


. The sensor


23


shown in

FIG. 12

comprises a light source


90


under which the paper


88


passes. Downstream of the sensor


23


is an ejector


92


. Preferably the paper


88


passes through the sensor


23


at the predetermined speed so that the ejector


92


may be operated to eject the selected paper. The velocity at which the paper travels and the distance to the sensor determines when the ejector


92


must emit a burst of air to remove the target paper from the waste stream. In one preferred embodiment the ejector


92


includes a plurality of high compression air jets.




Any paper which adheres to the acceleration belt


86


and carries over the discharge end thereof will be directed to a canvas chute


89


which transfers that material to a waste container (not shown).




The system


10


includes a mechanical pinning means


94


for pinning the paper


88


to the acceleration belt


86


. The pinning means


94


is a rotary feeder


96


positioned above and contacting the acceleration belt


86


. In some preferred embodiments, the acceleration belt


86


comprises standard PVC material. In some preferred embodiments the rotary feeder


96


is flexible and in contact with the acceleration belt


86


. In one embodiment the rotary feeder


96


includes a plurality of flexible bristles


98


extending radially.





FIG. 2

shows a product removal apparatus


100


downstream of the sensor


23


. The ejector


92


, shown more clearly in

FIG. 12

, is positioned between the sensor


23


and the product removal apparatus


100


.




The product removal apparatus


100


shown in

FIG. 12

comprises a product conveyor


102


below and downstream of the acceleration belt


86


. Product


104


is carried downstream by the product conveyor


102


. The product conveyor


102


will take non-targeted paper (also referred to as product


104


) away from the sensing area


118


. In some embodiments it will operate at a fixed speed of approximately 600 feet per minute. The conveyor belting may be vulcanized seamless rubber.




Ejected paper


106


(also referred to as targeted paper


106


) is ejected by the ejector


92


. Preferably the amount of material selected for ejection is smaller than the amount of product going to product conveyor


102


. The precision air-jet ejection system may be mounted on the infeed of the product take-away conveyor (also referred to as product conveyor


102


). The ejector


92


uses signals received from the sensor


23


to selectively eject targeted materials using an array of high-pressure compressed air nozzles.




Any paper which adheres to product conveyor


102


and carries over the discharge end thereof is directed through a drop-out opening to a canvas chute


105


to transfer the waste paper material to a container on the floor.





FIG. 13

shows an enlarged view of the product removal apparatus


100


shown in FIG.


2


. The product removal apparatus


100


shown in

FIG. 13

includes a sort conveyor


108


and an airlock


110


. The sort conveyor


108


will take the paper fraction that passes through the system without being ejected and deliver it to a baler (not shown). The sort conveyor


108


will be operated in some embodiments at a fixed speed of 100 feet per minute. The sort conveyor


108


includes the product output


16


and the airlock


110


. The airlock


110


is proximate the product output


16


. The airlock


110


is used to de-entrain paper, or product,


104


. The airlock


110


acts as an air seal on the sort conveyor


108


to allow paper


104


to exit while restricting the discharge of air. Rotating tips


122


have a tip speed


123


. The tip speed


123


may be fixed, in some embodiments, to match the speed of the sort conveyor


108


. In some embodiments the tip speed


123


is 100 ft./min.; and the sort conveyor


108


operates at 100 ft./min. In some applications the airlock


110


may be replaced by a system of rubber flaps.




The acceleration conveyor


84


may also be described as a paper handler


130


(an embodiment of which is shown in

FIG. 12

) adapted for use with a sorting machine including a sensor


23


for sorting paper. In the embodiment shown in

FIG. 12

the handler


130


comprises a paper input


132


for receiving the paper


12


. A product output (not shown in

FIG. 12

) is downstream of the paper input


132


. The paper handler


130


also includes a feed accelerator


134


including an acceleration conveyor


136


operably positioned to feed paper


12


(also shown as paper


88


) through the sensor


23


.




The paper handler


130


may further comprise the plurality of inclined conveyors


50


and


52


positioned upstream of the acceleration conveyor


136


, as shown in FIG.


2


. In one embodiment of the paper handler


130


, the first inclined conveyor


50


includes a belt substantially similar to the belt


70


shown in

FIG. 9

, operating at a first inclined conveyor speed


54


. The paper handler


130


also includes a second inclined conveyor


52


including a belt


55


operating at a second inclined conveyor speed


56


. In one preferred embodiment the second inclined conveyor speed


56


is greater than the first inclined conveyor speed


54


. The accelerator conveyor


136


operates at an accelerator conveyor speed


124


(also referred to herein as acceleration belt speed) greater than the second inclined conveyor speed


56


.




In one preferred embodiment the first inclined conveyor speed is approximately four hundred fifty feet per minute (450 ft./min.); the second inclined conveyor speed is approximately seven hundred fifty feet per minute (750 ft./min.); and the accelerator conveyor speed is approximately twelve hundred feet per minute (1200 ft./min.).




In the embodiment of the paper handler


130


shown in

FIG. 2

the first inclined conveyor


50


is operably positioned to receive paper


12


from the spreader


24


which in turn is operably positioned to receive paper


12


from the paper input


14


.




Referring to

FIGS. 2 and 6

, one embodiment of the paper handler


130


comprises rotatable shafts


28


positioned transversely relative to a stream of paper in the spreader


24


. The rotatable shafts


42


closer to the first inclined conveyor


50


rotate faster than the rotatable shafts


34


closer to the paper input


14


. In

FIG. 6

, the paper input


14


and the first inclined conveyor


50


are not shown. However, the product input


14


would be nearer to the first set of shafts


34


, and the first inclined conveyor


50


would be located closer to the third set of rotatable shafts


42


.




In some embodiments the acceleration conveyor


136


will include a high-speed belt


86


(operating at approximately 1200 ft./min.) to deliver a thin layer of mixed paper beneath the paper-sort sensor


23


(also referred to herein simply as sensor). The conveyor will have a variable frequency drive and preferably vulcanized seamless belting. Provisions may be incorporated into the design of the belt to minimize carry-over of paper, and ease access for removal of materials which become entrapped. A drop-out chute


89


may be incorporated into the under pan


91


beneath the acceleration conveyor


136


to allow materials which enter beneath the belting to drop free without being moved to the tail section of the conveyor. A small rotary brush (not shown) may be positioned at the discharge end of the conveyor (proximate an end


138


of conveyor


136


nearest sensor


23


) to assist with discharge of paper. It may be driven from a head-pulley of the acceleration conveyor. A large rotary brush


98


may be mounted on the acceleration conveyor to “pin” paper to the belt prior to entering the sensor area (


118


). The rotary brush


98


may have a fixed tip speed of approximately 800 feet per minute.




It is desirable to avoid unwanted disturbances to the paper flow by avoiding large speed differentials between the acceleration belt


86


,


136


and rotating pinning device


96


. This can be accomplished by rotating the pinning device so that the tips of its flexible bristles


98


have a tip speed approximately two-thirds of the speed at which the acceleration belt


86


,


136


operates.




The flexible bristles


98


further reduce damage to the rotatable pinning apparatus


96


if bulky materials are carried through by the acceleration belt


86


,


136


. The flexible bristles


98


can flex to allow the bulky materials to pass.




As previously noted, the speed of the acceleration belt


86


adjacent the sensor


22


may be as high as approximately twelve hundred feet per minute. Such a high speed of the acceleration belt


86


is sufficient to create a suction phenomena such that once paper such as


88


is pinned to the belt


86


, such as by means of the rotary pinning device


96


, the suction phenomena serves to further pin the paper to the belt


86


so that the paper moves at substantially the same speed as the acceleration belt


86


.




As best seen in

FIG. 10

, at the input end


132


of the paper handler


130


there is located a catching structure


150


including a downwardly inclined catching plate


152


to facilitate delivery of paper to the acceleration belt


86


,


136


. Paper slides off of catching plate


152


onto acceleration belt


86


,


136


. The catching structure


150


further includes a plurality of rods such as


154


projecting downwardly in a general direction toward the catching plate


152


and the acceleration belt


86


,


136


.




Thus, as seen in

FIG. 10

, paper which is cascading off the end of the second inclined conveyor


52


is directed by rods


154


and catching plate


152


onto the upper surface of the acceleration conveyor


86


,


136


.




The paper impacts the plurality of rods


154


thus allowing the paper to separate as it falls onto the catching plate


152


and the conveyor belt


86


,


136


.




As best seen in

FIG. 12

, when the paper


88


reaches the left hand end or output end of acceleration conveyor


84


after it has passed under the sensor


23


, it passes through a transition zone


156


. As the paper passes through the transition zone


156


it is still moving at substantially the same speed at which it was travelling on the acceleration conveyor


86


,


136


. This continued motion is in part assisted by the air flow through the system.




As the paper passes through the transition zone


156


, if it has been targeted by the sensor for ejection, a rapid burst of air from ejector


92


will blow the paper downward causing it to become targeted or ejected paper


106


. If the paper crossing through transition zone


156


is not impacted by air jets from ejector


92


, it will continue to flow generally horizontally and fall downward upon the product conveyor


102


.




The transition zone


156


which communicates the acceleration conveyor


86


,


136


with the product conveyor


102


can be described as including a separation region adjacent the acceleration conveyor


86


,


136


at which the paper separates from the acceleration conveyor


86


,


136


. The transition zone


156


may also be described as including a reception region adjacent and immediately above the transition plate


158


of product conveyor


102


wherein the product conveyor


102


receives a majority of the paper crossing through the transition zone


156


.




The transition zone


156


may also be described with reference to an imaginary transition plane


160


seen in

FIG. 12

which extends from the top of the acceleration conveyor


86


,


136


and extends to that portion of the product conveyor


102


wherein the top surface thereof becomes generally horizontal and upon which the product paper will fall downstream of the transition plate


158


.




The transition plane


160


may be described as lying at an angle


162


relative to the horizontal, where the angle


162


lies in the range of from 15° to 60°. The transition angle


162


is preferably approximately 30°.




THE SENSOR AND EJECTOR SYSTEM




The sensor


23


is preferably a linear array of sensors spread across the width of the acceleration belt


86


in a direction normal to the plane of FIG.


12


. For example, for a forty-eight inch wide acceleration belt


86


, an array of approximately thirty-two sensors spaced across the width of the acceleration belt would be utilized.




The ejector


92


also comprises a linear array of ejectors spaced across the width of the transition zone


156


between acceleration belt


86


and product conveyor


102


.




In general the sensors


23


operate to identify bright white paper by searching for fluorescing additives in the individual sheets of paper. This type of paper has a higher value of fluorescence than paper without the additives.




The sensors illuminate the paper with a constant light source having a wave length of 360 nanometers. An elliptical mirror is used to focus light onto a region above the conveyor belt at approximately ten inches from the optic system. When paper with the fluorescing additives is illuminated with the light source, light is re-radiated in the 400 to 550 nanometer range. The sensor has a second light source that emits light in the 480 nanometer range. This light source is used to determine if any type of paper is present on the conveyor belt. It is turned on momentarily every three milliseconds and a reflected light measurement is made to determine if paper is present on the conveyor belt.




The details of construction of the sensor


23


are set forth in U.S. Patent Application, Ser. No. 69/301,715, of Bruner et al. filed concurrently herewith, entitled “SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR SENSING WHITE PAPER”, and assigned to the Assignee of the present invention, the details of which are incorporated herein by reference.




The sensor system


22


will sense whether there is a piece of white paper on the acceleration belt


86


, and it will sense the location of that paper upon the belt. Since the paper is moving at a predetermined fixed speed, the time at which the paper passes through the transition zone


156


can be calculated by the computer associated with sensor


23


. This computerized control system will in turn actuate the appropriate number of the array of jets


92


at the appropriate time so as to blow any reject paper downward through the transition zone


156


.




THE AIR CIRCULATION SYSTEM





FIG. 15

shows an overall schematic view of an air circulation system


200


of the paper handling system


10


. Details of the air circulation system


200


are seen in

FIGS. 13

,


15


,


2


and


9


.




With reference to

FIG. 15

, it can be seen that air is circulated through the system


200


by a blower


202


. Pressurized air from blower


202


enters a discharge duct


204


which splits into a supply duct


206


and a filter duct


208


.




The supply duct


206


splits into first and second supply duct arms


210


and


212


, respectively which are directed to the housings immediately above the first and second inclined conveyor belts


50


and


52


respectively.




Air knives


82


and


214


are disposed in the first and second supply duct arms


210


and


212


, respectively, adjacent their inlets to the housings surrounding the first and second inclined conveyors


50


and


52


, in order to control the flow of air into the housings adjacent the conveyors, and particularly to their louvers such as the louvers


78


associated with first inclined conveyor


50


. The first and second supply duct arms


210


and


212


may also include iris-type flow controls adjacent the air knives


82


and


214


.




It will be appreciated from the views previously described of the several components, that the inclined conveyors


50


and


52


, the acceleration conveyor


84


, and the product conveyor


102


all have associated therewith substantially enclosed housings so that the air which is provided through air supply duct arms


210


and


212


to the housings adjacent inclined conveyors


50


and


52


is directed through the housings of conveyors


50


and


52


, then through the housings surrounding acceleration conveyor


84


then through the sensing area


118


across the product conveyor


102


.




A portion of this air circulation system can be described as an air assist means


112


which is part of the product removal apparatus


100


and which assists in maintaining the predetermined speed of the paper


88


through the sensor


23


. In one preferred embodiment the air assist means


112


includes a vacuum


114


, which may also be described as a low pressure area


114


, downstream of the sensor


23


as is illustrated in FIG.


13


.




The vacuum or low pressure area


114


forms within a plenum chamber


116


defined adjacent the left hand end of product conveyor


102


in FIG.


13


.




An air recycle duct


216


is connected to the suction inlet


218


of blower


202


in order to pull air from the plenum chamber


116


thus creating the low pressure zone


114


therein. A screen may be utilized adjacent return duct


216


to prevent carry over of paper to the blower


202


.




The filter duct


208


leads to a plenum


220


and air flow thereto can be controlled by a motorized damper


222


. Plenum


220


is connected to a plurality of filter bags


224


. The filter bags


224


are used to remove dust from the air system prior to releasing it to the atmosphere.




In one embodiment, the blower


202


is a 6000 CFM blower, which is a variable speed blower for controlling the speed of the air drawn through the sensor area


118


. In a typical system, 2000 CFM would be directed to the filter duct


208


, with 4000 CFM flowing through supply duct


206


which in turn splits into two streams of 2000 CFM each in supply duct arms


210


and


212


which are directed to the inclined conveyors


50


and


52


.




It is noted that in

FIG. 12

the area between the product conveyor


102


and the acceleration belt


86


is shown open at the bottom for clarity. In practice this area will be closed in order to facilitate control of air flow through the system.




The air circulating through the system illustrated in

FIG. 15

provides several functions.




When the air first flows in through the louvers such as


78


of the first and second inclined conveyors


50


and


52


, that air flow functions to help pin the paper onto the inclined conveyors so as to help accelerate the paper speed up to the conveyor speed.




The air also aids in fluffing the paper as it cascades off the ends of the inclined conveyors.




The air also assists in the downstream movement of the paper through the system.




Particularly, the air assists in the movement of the paper through the sensing area


118


across the gap between acceleration belt


86


and product belt


102


.




The plenum chamber


116


adjacent the downstream end of the product conveyor


102


may be utilized to reduce the air flow to a speed below two hundred feet per minute in order to allow the paper to settle out on the product conveyor


102


.




The housing which defines the plenum


116


has a much larger area at plenum


116


than it does upstream near the transition zone


156


, so that the air speed is much higher near the transition zone


156


than it is downstream adjacent the plenum


116


.




The right hand end of the product conveyor


102


may generally be described as a transition end thereof. A transition plate


158


is located immediately above the transition end of the product conveyor


102


. The transition plate


158


is curved to conform to the general shape of the curved end of the product conveyor


102


, and functions to prevent paper from falling back off the transition end of the product conveyor


102


.




METHODS




The present invention also includes various methods for handling paper. One method comprises the steps of distributing clumps of paper


140


(see

FIG. 2

) into operably thin layers of paper


142


(see FIG.


12


). Operably thin is defined to be thin enough to accomplish the goal for which the paper is being handled. In one preferred embodiment the goal is to sense the paper by passing it through a sensor. To accomplish this goal the paper should be thin enough that the sensor may adequately sense and distinguish pieces of paper. The paper may then be sorted by an ejector. The method of handling paper also comprises accelerating the paper. The step of accelerating the paper includes progressively increasing the speed at which the paper is transported downstream.




One embodiment of this method comprises the steps of breaking up clumps of paper


42


in a spreader


24


. An apparatus for accomplishing this is shown in FIG.


6


. The method may also comprise rotating rotatable shafts


28


in the spreader


26


to progressively increase the speed at which the paper travels. The paper is also generally referred to herein by designation


12


. Another method of the invention comprises the step of feeding the paper


12


into a plurality of inclined conveyors


50


and


52


. This is shown in

FIGS. 2 and 9

. The respective plurality of inclined conveyor belts catch underlying layers of paper


68


. The underlying layers of paper


68


are also referred to as bottom layers of paper


68


. The method includes accelerating the underlying layers of paper


68


up to speeds approximating speeds at which the respective plurality of inclined conveyor belts operate.




One preferred embodiment of the invention comprises the step of inclining the inclined conveyors between fifteen degrees and thirty-five degrees (15°-35°). This is the optimal range for paper to adhere to and travel up the conveyor while paper on the top slides off the bottom paper due to gravity. Generally, layers of paper will begin to slide over lower layers of paper due to gravity at an incline of 15°. Beyond 35° the paper will not adhere to the belt as easily. This takes advantage of paper's friction co-efficient. The method includes allowing paper


66


above the underlying layers


68


to slide down the incline and become new underlying layers. A new underlying layer


144


is shown in FIG.


9


. The method then includes catching the new underlying layers


144


with the respective plurality of inclined conveyor belts and accelerating the new underlying layers


144


of paper


12


up to speeds approximating the speeds at which the respective plurality of inclined conveyor belts operate.




In some embodiments the method comprises the step of pinning the underlying layers of paper


68


to the respective plurality of inclined belts with air


76


and


126


. This is shown in

FIG. 9

in which air-assist means


74


pins and fluffs the paper


12


. Accordingly, one method comprises the step of fluffing the paper


12


as it cascades off respective ends of the respective plurality of inclined conveyors. In

FIG. 9

one respective end is designated as


146


on inclined conveyor


50


.




It is desirable to adjust volumes of air flow


76


with air knives


82


and direct air


76


(also shown as direction of air


126


) with respective sets of louvers


78


in the inclined conveyors


50


and


52


.




Preferably inclined conveyors downstream are operated at higher speeds than inclined conveyors upstream. Referring to

FIGS. 2 and 12

, it will be apparent that the present invention also includes the method of catching


20


underlying layers of paper


68


on an acceleration belt


86


. The underlying paper


68


is accelerated to a predetermined speed. The paper (referred to in

FIG. 12

by designation number


88


) is allowed to pass through a sensor


23


at the predetermined speed.




In one preferred embodiment a rotary feeder


96


is rotated above the acceleration belt


86


to pin the paper


88


to the acceleration belt


86


. The method also includes contacting the paper


88


and pinning the paper


88


to the acceleration belt


86


as the paper


88


passes between the acceleration belt


86


and the rotary feeder


96


. Preferably damage to the rotary feeder


96


is prevented by allowing the rotary feeder


96


to flex. In some embodiments the rotary feeder operates at a speed less than the acceleration belt


86


. In one embodiment the rotary feeder rotates at speeds of eight hundred feet per minute (800 ft./min.) and the acceleration belt operates at speeds approximating twelve hundred feet per minute (1200 ft./min.). More generally, a preferred embodiment in the present invention includes the step of rotating the rotary feeder


96


at approximately two-thirds of the speed at which the acceleration belt


86


operates. This prevents the pinning device from being bent up by a large speed differential when the pinning device contacts the high velocity acceleration belt


86


. This also reduces the likelihood that the paper


88


will be turned up at its end as it is caught between a stationary pinning device and a high velocity belt.




Another method of the present invention comprises the steps of allowing the paper


88


to pass through a sensor


23


and ejecting paper


106


(also referred to as targeted paper) selected for ejection (See FIG.


12


). The method also includes allowing non-selected paper, also referred to herein as product,


104


to continue downstream to a product conveyor


102


. Preferably the predetermined speed of the paper


88


is maintained through the sensor


23


with air-assistance


112


(not shown in FIG.


12


).




Another embodiment of handling paper comprises drawing the paper


88


with a vacuum


114


downstream of the ejector


92


, and matching a vacuum speed at which the vacuum


114


draws to a belt speed at which the acceleration belt


86


operates. The acceleration belt


86


accelerates paper


88


through the sensor


23


at a sensor speed (not shown) substantially equal to the acceleration belt speed


124


at which the acceleration belt


86


operates. Sensor speed as used here refers to the rate at which the sensor may sense material passing through it.




In some embodiments the method comprises the steps of adhering the paper


104


to the product conveyor belt


102


with the vacuum


114


.




Other methods of the invention comprise spreading and accelerating the paper in a spreader


26


, and transporting and accelerating the paper


12


up a first inclined conveyor


50


. The paper


12


is accelerated with the first inclined conveyor. The method also includes transporting and accelerating the paper


12


up a second inclined conveyor


52


and then accelerating the paper through a sensor


23


at a predetermined feed. In some embodiments the paper is pinned with a rotary feeder


96


proximate the sensor


23


. It is desirable in some embodiments to maintain paper flow through the sensor


23


with a vacuum


114


. The method also comprises ejecting selected paper


106


.




Thus, although there have been described particular embodiments of the present invention of a new and useful PAPER SORTING SYSTEM, it is not intended that such references be construed as limitations upon the scope of this invention except as set forth in the following claims.



Claims
  • 1. A paper sorting machine comprising:a paper input; a spreader positioned to receive paper from the paper input; an inclined feed section downstream of the spreader, wherein the inclined feed section includes a first and a second inclined conveyor, and wherein the second inclined conveyor is downstream of the first inclined conveyor; a feed accelerator operably positioned to receive paper from the second inclined conveyor, wherein the feed accelerator includes an accelerator conveyor having a sensor end; a sensor operably positioned to sense paper passing over the accelerator conveyor sensor end; an ejector downstream of the sensor; a product conveyor downstream of the ejector; and a product output downstream of the product conveyor.
  • 2. The sorting machine of claim 1, wherein:the paper input receives paper at a first speed; the spreader accelerates the paper to a second speed, wherein the second speed is greater than the first speed; the inclined feed section accelerates the paper to a third speed, wherein the third speed is greater than the second speed; and the feed accelerator accelerates the paper to a fourth speed, wherein the fourth speed is greater than the third speed.
  • 3. The sorting machine of claim 2, wherein the fourth speed is a predetermined speed and the paper passes through the sensor at the predetermined speed.
  • 4. The sorter of claim 1, wherein the feed accelerator comprises a rotary feeder proximate to and upstream of the sensor and above the accelerator conveyor.
  • 5. The sorter of claim 4, wherein the rotary feeder is flexible and contacting the accelerator conveyor.
  • 6. The sorter of claim 1, comprising an air-assist device for maintaining the paper at a predetermined speed through the sensor.
  • 7. The sorter of claim 1, comprising a sort conveyor downstream of the product conveyor, wherein the sort conveyor comprises an air-lock proximate the product output.
  • 8. The sorting machine of claim 1, wherein the spreader comprises three sets of rotatable shafts, each shaft including a plurality of bulged triangular discs, wherein the rotatable shafts closer to the inclined feed section rotate faster than the rotatable shafts closer to the paper input.
  • 9. The sorting machine of claim 8, wherein a portion of the bulged triangular discs are rotated 45° relative to a remainder of the bulged triangular discs.
  • 10. A paper sorting machine comprising:a paper input; a spreader positioned to receive paper from the paper input; a first inclined belt conveyor downstream of the spreader; a feed accelerator operably positioned to receive paper from the inclined belt conveyor, wherein the feed accelerator includes an accelerator belt conveyor having a sensor end; a sensor operably positioned to sense paper passing over the accelerator belt conveyor sensor end; an ejector downstream of the sensor; a product conveyor downstream of the ejector; and a product output downstream of the product conveyor.
  • 11. The sorting machine of claim 10, wherein:the paper input receives paper at a first speed; the spreader accelerates the paper to a second speed, wherein the second speed is greater than the first speed; the inclined belt conveyor accelerates the paper to a third speed, wherein the third speed is greater than the second speed; and the feed accelerator accelerates the paper to a fourth speed, wherein the fourth speed is greater than the third speed.
  • 12. The sorting machine of claim 11, wherein the fourth speed is a predetermined speed and the paper passes through the sensor at the predetermined speed.
  • 13. The sorting machine of claim 10, wherein the feed accelerator comprises a rotary feeder proximate to and upstream of the sensor and above the accelerator belt conveyor.
  • 14. The sorting machine of claim 13, wherein the rotary feeder is flexible and contacting the accelerator conveyor.
  • 15. The sorting machine of claim 10, comprising an air-assist device for maintaining the paper at a predetermined speed through the sensor.
  • 16. The sorting machine of claim 10, comprising a sort conveyor downstream of the product conveyor, wherein the sort conveyor comprises an air-lock proximate the product output.
  • 17. The sorting machine of claim 10, further comprising:a second inclined belt conveyor located between the first inclined belt conveyor and the acceleration belt conveyor; and wherein the second inclined belt conveyor operates at a speed greater than the first inclined belt conveyor and less than the accelerator belt conveyor.
  • 18. A method of handling paper comprising the steps of:(a) breaking up clumps of paper in a spreader; (b) feeding the paper from the spreader onto a first inclined belt conveyor; (c) accelerating underlying layers of paper with the first inclined belt conveyor up to a speed approaching a speed at which the first inclined belt conveyor operates; (d) allowing paper above the underlying layers to slide down the first inclined belt conveyor and become new underlying layers; (e) catching the paper on a generally horizontal acceleration belt conveyor; (f) accelerating the paper on the acceleration belt conveyor to a predetermined speed greater than the speed of the first inclined belt conveyor; (g) allowing the paper to pass through a sensor at the predetermined speed; (h) ejecting paper selected for ejection; and (i) allowing non-selected paper to continue downstream to a product conveyor.
  • 19. The method of claim 18, further comprising:between steps (d) and (e), accelerating the paper with a second inclined belt conveyor operating at a speed greater than the speed of the first inclined belt conveyor.
  • 20. The method of claim 18, further comprising:rotating a rotary pinning device above the acceleration belt conveyor; and contacting the paper and pinning the paper to the acceleration belt conveyor as the paper passes between the acceleration belt conveyor and the rotary pinning device.
  • 21. The method of claim 20, wherein the rotating step further includes rotating the rotary pinning device at a speed less than the acceleration belt conveyor speed.
US Referenced Citations (116)
Number Name Date Kind
1035345 Heess Aug 1912
1547743 Fowler Jul 1925
1847263 Sandberg Mar 1932
1847265 Sandberg Mar 1932
2242409 Anderson May 1941
2897952 Buccicone Aug 1959
3101832 Wyle et al. Aug 1963
3185286 Koplin May 1965
3198352 Puechberty Aug 1965
3227263 Kastenbein Jan 1966
3352404 Settembrini Nov 1967
3471013 Haver Oct 1969
3603645 Hardy Sep 1971
3650369 Vergobbi Mar 1972
3747755 Senturia et al. Jul 1973
3800936 Anfossi Apr 1974
3870627 Herkes Mar 1975
3908814 Hieronymus Sep 1975
4069145 Sommer, Jr. et al. Jan 1978
4093062 Sjögren Jun 1978
4094772 Hillekamp et al. Jun 1978
4102056 Angelo et al. Jul 1978
4124168 Bialski et al. Nov 1978
4131540 Husome et al. Dec 1978
4176750 Holmes Dec 1979
4207177 Block Jun 1980
4225427 Schnell Sep 1980
4231526 Ortner et al. Nov 1980
4352430 Maier et al. Oct 1982
4440284 DeWoolfson Apr 1984
4505371 Krueger et al. Mar 1985
4533053 Kenny et al. Aug 1985
4533054 Sommer, Jr. et al. Aug 1985
4541530 Kenny et al. Sep 1985
4542689 Trolle Sep 1985
4609108 Hristozov et al. Sep 1986
4632320 Holz et al. Dec 1986
4657144 Martin et al. Apr 1987
4699510 Alguard Oct 1987
4718559 Kenny et al. Jan 1988
4760925 Stehle et al. Aug 1988
4844351 Holloway Jul 1989
4909930 Cole Mar 1990
4919534 Reed Apr 1990
4929342 Johnston May 1990
5022644 Burge Jun 1991
5024335 Lundell Jun 1991
5048674 Wilbur et al. Sep 1991
5060870 Trezek et al. Oct 1991
5085325 Jones et al. Feb 1992
5091077 Williams Feb 1992
5092526 Takata Mar 1992
5100005 Noble et al. Mar 1992
5100537 Krause Mar 1992
5101977 Roman Apr 1992
5111927 Schulze, Jr. May 1992
5115144 Konishi et al. May 1992
5115987 Mithal May 1992
5143308 Hally et al. Sep 1992
5150307 McCourt et al. Sep 1992
5165676 Blessing et al. Nov 1992
5169588 Estepp Dec 1992
5183251 Sardella Feb 1993
5190165 Garfield, Jr. Mar 1993
5201921 Luttermann et al. Apr 1993
5209355 Mindermann May 1993
5257577 Clark Nov 1993
5297667 Hoffman et al. Mar 1994
5299693 Ubaidi et al. Apr 1994
5301816 Weber et al. Apr 1994
5314072 Frankel et al. May 1994
5315384 Heffington et al. May 1994
5318172 Kenny et al. Jun 1994
5322152 Tommila et al. Jun 1994
5333739 Stete Aug 1994
5333797 Becker et al. Aug 1994
5335791 Eason Aug 1994
5339962 Sommer, Jr. et al. Aug 1994
5339963 Tao Aug 1994
5344026 Booth et al. Sep 1994
5348136 Kenny et al. Sep 1994
5348162 Wrobewski Sep 1994
5361909 Gemmer Nov 1994
5361913 Melchionna Nov 1994
5398818 McGarvey Mar 1995
5402264 Wilbur et al. Mar 1995
5419438 Squyres et al. May 1995
5440127 Squyres Aug 1995
5443164 Walsh et al. Aug 1995
5460271 Kenny et al. Oct 1995
5464981 Squyres et al. Nov 1995
5469973 Booth et al. Nov 1995
5481864 Wright Jan 1996
5497871 Ciolkevich Mar 1996
5501344 Kaiser et al. Mar 1996
5512758 Kobayashi et al. Apr 1996
5531331 Barnett Jul 1996
5533628 Tao Jul 1996
5555984 Sommer, Jr. et al. Sep 1996
5632381 Thust et al. May 1997
5675416 Campbell et al. Oct 1997
5695035 Fukushima et al. Dec 1997
5789741 Kinter et al. Aug 1998
5794788 Massen Aug 1998
5797327 Gieser et al. Aug 1998
5799105 Tao Aug 1998
5813542 Cohn Sep 1998
5848706 Harris Dec 1998
5862919 Eason Jan 1999
5884775 Campbell Mar 1999
5901856 Brantley, Jr. et al. Apr 1999
5954206 Mallon et al. Sep 1999
5966217 Roe et al. Oct 1999
5979240 Rix et al. Nov 1999
6022017 Cummings et al. Feb 2000
6060677 Ulrichsen et al. Sep 2000
Foreign Referenced Citations (13)
Number Date Country
2109021 Apr 1994 CA
3615644A1 Nov 1987 DE
3828067A1 Feb 1990 DE
3926641 Feb 1991 DE
3926641A1 Feb 1991 DE
4125045A1 Feb 1993 DE
4135394A1 Apr 1993 DE
4305006A1 Sep 1993 DE
4241990C2 Jun 1994 DE
WO 9606690 Mar 1996 DE
291 959 A2 Nov 1988 EP
0873797 Oct 1998 EP
1411228 Jul 1988 RU
Non-Patent Literature Citations (5)
Entry
Catalog of Magnetic Separation Systems, Inc. entitled “Systems For Separation And Sensing”(undated, but admitted to be prior art).
Brochure entitled “MSS Pen Binary Bottlesort®” (Undated, but admitted to be prior art).
Brochure entitled “MSS Plasticsort™”(Undated, but admitted to be prior art).
Brochure entitled “Machinefabriek Lubo® Mobile Systems” (Undated, but admitted to be prior art) discloses a screening unit having rotating discs on parallel shafts.
Brochure entitled “Machinefabriek Lubo® Projects” (Undated, but admitted to be prior art) discloses a screening unit having rotating discs on parallel shafts.