The present invention relates to percutaneous valve replacement devices and, in particular, to percutaneous valve replacement devices that provide optimal anchoring and sealing when the device is seated within the cone-shaped space created by the annulus and leaflets.
The mitral valve is a complex structure whose competence relies on the precise interaction of annulus, leaflets, chordae, papillary muscles and the left ventricle (LV). Pathologic changes in any of these structures can lead to mitral regurgitation (MR). Ischemic mitral regurgitation (IMR) occurs when a structurally normal mitral valve (MV) is rendered incompetent as a result of LV remodelling induced by myocardial infarction (MI).
IMR affects 2.4 million Americans and is present in some degree in over 50% of patients with reduced LV ejection fraction undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG). The magnitude of this clinical problem is significant and expected to grow substantially as the population ages. IMR increases mortality even when mild, with a strongly graded relationship between severity and reduced survival. Currently, IMR can be treated with either mitral valve repair or replacement. Mitral valve repair with undersized ring annuloplasty, typically performed in conjunction with CABG, has become the preferred treatment. However, this therapeutic approach is associated with a 30% recurrence rate of IMR at 6 months after surgery with recurrence approaching 60% at 3 to 5 years. This lack of durability has likely contributed to the difficulty in demonstrating a survival advantage of MV repair compared with either medical management, or with revascularization alone. These reports have generated much discussion in the cardiac surgery world regarding repair versus replacement in the treatment of IMR.
Regardless of the surgical debate, it should be understood that the vast majority of patients with moderate to severe IMR and associated congestive heart failure (CHF) are never treated surgically. It is estimated that less than 2% of the 2.4 million IMR patients in the US receive surgical correction. IMR can intermittently and unexpectedly destabilize the heart failure patient requiring increased medication and repeated hospitalizations. While it is still unclear from scientific investigation whether restoring mitral valve function in these patients will improve survival, there is general consensus that it would make the care of many of them more effective and less costly. Despite this understanding, the risk of surgery for these patients is deemed prohibitive because of the need for a relatively large incision and the morbidity of cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB).
This large unmet clinical need drove the development of several transcatheter mitral valve repair techniques during the early part of the 2000s. Despite early optimism, a number of issues have proven problematic with all these devices including inability to demonstrate effective proof of concept and clinical efficacy. The major reason for these failures is likely due to the fact that all transcatheter repair techniques are only partial approximation of open surgical repair which in itself has been shown to be less efficacious than thought only a decade ago.
In contrast to the failure of catheter based valve repair techniques, catheter based heart valve replacement technology has been successful enough to produce the initiation of a major paradigm shift in valve therapy. Improvements in imaging, catheter technology, and stent design have combined to make transcatheter replacement of the aortic and pulmonic valves clinical realities. These valves can be placed via a peripheral blood vessel or by a tiny thoracotomy without the need for CPB. These successes combined with the growing understanding of the inadequacies of mitral valve repair have piqued interest in the development of transcatheter mitral valve replacement technologies.
Three groups have published the results of their attempts to develop a feasible approach to TMVR in animal models. All have reported limited success and identified similar difficulties. The first obstacle is the lack of adequate echocardiographic visualization or fluoroscopic landmarks of the mitral valve apparatus for device deployment. The second barrier is related to the left ventricular out flow (LVOT) obstruction which results from the exclusive use of radial force to anchor a valved stent inside the mitral annulus. The next two impediments to success are related to the anatomy of the mitral valve apparatus. The complex annular and leaflet geometry makes perivalvular seal a significant challenge while the presence of chordae tendineae can interfere with complete expansion, accurate positioning, and anchorage. The fifth challenge is that the mitral valve must anchor and seal against the highest pressures in the circulation. Thus, the complex anatomy of the mitral valve and the high pressures it is exposed to have prevented the application of the current aortic and pulmonic replacement technologies to the treatment of mitral valve disease.
A transcatheter approach to mitral valve replacement (TMVR) would represent a major advance in the treatment of valvular heart disease since approximately 2.4 million Americans suffer from moderate to severe ischemic mitral regurgitation (IMR) with the vast majority being deemed too sick or debilitated to tolerate open-heart surgery. Successful TMVR requires (1) a sutureless anchoring mechanism, (2) a perivalvular sealing strategy, and (3) foldability. In PCT Application No. PCT/US2010/055645 filed Nov. 5, 2010, the present inventors demonstrated a successful TMVR design that can anchor and seal robustly in large animal models. It is desired in accordance with the present invention to optimize the design of such a TMVR device to maximize device foldability and delivery without compromising valve fixation and seal. The goal of the invention is thus to further hone the design of the TMVR device to increase the device's flexibility which will facilitate transcatheter deliverability and enhance perivalvular seal while maintaining anchoring strength. Such a TMVR device is believed to have the potential to provide an improved treatment strategy for hundreds of thousands of patients annually.
The present inventors have addressed the above needs in the art by developing an improved anchoring and sealing mechanism for TMVR. The exemplary embodiments include a self-expanding valved stent constructed from a polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) covered nitinol wire frame. Anchoring is facilitated by arms emanating from the ventricular end of the device which are designed to atraumatically insinuate themselves around chordae and leaflets. The sealing mechanism relies on the flexibility of the stent, which allows the device to be slightly oversized, thereby permitting it to conform snuggly to the annulus and leaflet cone.
The valve prosthesis of the invention is described by way of exemplary embodiments with and without an annuloplasty ring. In a first embodiment, the valve prosthesis includes an at least partially self-expanding stent comprising a wire framework defining outer and interior surfaces and an anchoring arm. The stent has an unexpanded and an expanded state. The anchoring arm has an elbow region and a hook that clamps around mitral tissue of the patient when seated. An elastic fabric/cloth made of, for example, PTFE material, is wrapped circumferentially around the wire framework. The wire framework itself traverses the circumference of the stent with a pitch may extend a portion of the length of the stent or may extend the entire length of the stent 4-10 times. A valve comprising at least one leaflet is fixedly attached to the interior surface of the stent. In exemplary embodiments, the number of anchoring arms is minimized and preferably the stent has no more than 12 anchoring arms. The length of the anchoring arms is also minimized and preferably the anchoring arms have lengths that are 40% of the length of the stent. The anchoring arms may alternatively flare circumferentially outward.
In a second embodiment, a failed mitral valve repair is treated using an annuloplasty ring. This embodiment makes stent replacement of the valve much easier and the anchoring arms are not needed to anchor the valve prosthesis. In this embodiment, the valve prosthesis includes an at least partially self-expanding stent comprising a wire framework defining outer and interior surfaces and the stent has an unexpanded and an expanded state. However, the anchoring arms are optional in this embodiment. An elastic fabric/cloth made of, for example, PTFE material, is wrapped circumferentially around the wire framework and a valve having at least one leaflet is fixedly attached to the interior surface of the stent. However, in this embodiment, an annuloplasty ring is provided into which the stent is inserted prior to expansion. The stent is adapted to be expanded to be held in place by radial pressure against the annuloplasty ring. The annuloplasty ring and/or the stent also may have a magnet and/or a detent incorporated therein such that the expanded stent does not move relative to the annuloplasty ring.
The various novel aspects of the invention will be apparent from the following detailed description of the invention taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, of which:
The invention will be described in detail below with reference to
The inventors have found that optimal anchoring and seal occurs when the mitral valve replacement device is seated completely within the cone-shaped space created by the annulus and leaflets. Positioning within the leaflet cone is influenced by arm length of the anchoring arms that function to gather tissue centrally to the body of the stent device so as to aid in anchoring and sealing in the mitral opening. If the anchoring arms are too long, the device can be held partially beneath the leaflets causing left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) obstruction and an ineffective seal. On the other hand, if the anchoring arms are too short, anchoring strength is diminished. The optimal length and number of anchoring arms necessary to anchor and seal the device are described herein. Different designs for use with and without an annuloplasty ring are described.
To determine the optimal number of anchoring arms, prototypes were constructed with four different numbers of arms (20, 16, 12 and 8). Anchoring arm length was kept the same in each (0.75 arm length to stent length ratio—ASR). A pericardial valve was fitted to each and the device was inserted into sheep (80 kg). Because anchoring arm design influences the design of the delivery system, standard cardiac surgical techniques were used. After placement, the valve seal was assessed echocardiographically for stability and perivalvular seal. If function was satisfactory, the valve was reassessed after a month. The design with the fewest number of anchoring arms was further constructed with varying arm lengths (0.6, 0.4, 0.3, 0.2 ASR) and tested in animals. In the testing paradigm, each arm number was tested in 5 animals.
Embodiments of two types of steerable, coaxial, delivery, deployment and retrieval systems will be described below. The first system is designed to allow placement of the valve through a small thoracotomy and atrial purse string. The second system allows for valve placement via a transfemoral vein/transatrial septum approach to the mitral valve. Both systems are tailored to accommodate the determined optimized anchoring arm design of the TMVR device. For each system, the length, width, radius of curvature, release mechanism, and docking station characteristics are defined.
A mini thoracotomy delivery is used and the folding technology is honed to permit percutaneous device placement in a beating heart with or without the use of percutaneous placement catheters. Once placement was achieved reproducibly, a TMVR in accordance with the invention was placed in 5 animals, and the animals were reevaluated by echocardiography after about one month. A transfemoral vein delivery device may also be used.
The present invention is directed to a mitral valve prosthesis with a design that overcomes many of the obstacles noted in the background section above. For example, the present inventors have developed the design illustrated in
The device of
Additionally, the device of
The device shown in
In order to enhance foldability and perivalvular seal, the inventors have developed the embodiments shown in
The devices of
Also, the device of
In extensive animal work with the nitinol wire weave design of prior art
The successful nitinol weave prototypes for the device of
The inventors note that there are varying combinations of arm number and length that may work optimally. Because arm number influences folding and anchoring most significantly, the arm number is optimized first by constructing PTFE-nitinol prototypes with dimensions specified above and a varying number of arms (20, 16, 12 and 8) of the same length (0.75 arm length to stent length ratio). Each device was fitted with a custom designed trileaflet pericardial valve and optionally included a polyester skirt. The leaflets were designed for optimal opening and closing during the cardiac cycle and were cut from bovine pericardium with a thickness ranging from 0.23 mm to 0.28 mm. The skirt provided attachment for the leaflets and acted as an interface between the leaflets and the stent. The entire assembly was sutured together using a size 6-0 Tevdek II white braided PTFE impregnated polyester fiber suture.
Human-sized sheep (80 kg) were anesthetized and a left anterior thoracotomy performed. The pericardium was opened to expose the heart and an epicardial rt-3DE evaluation of the mitral valve was performed. The animal was then placed on CPB using standard cannulation techniques. Using standard open heart techniques, the mitral valve was exposed through a left atriotomy. A custom made applicator was then used to place the devices of
Arm length was optimized by using the successful device with the fewest arms (as determined above) with varying arm lengths (0.6, 0.4, 0.3, 0.2 ASR). Each device was fitted with a pericardial valve as previously described. Each arm length was evaluated in 5 animals. The same iterative evaluation, imaging techniques and surgical procedures were used as in the above example. The 0.6 ASR prototypes were assessed first with sequentially shorter arms being tested subsequently. The successful prototype was that which functioned adequately with the shortest and fewest arms.
It is the inventors' belief that the added flexibility of the PTFE design not only makes it more foldable for delivery purposes but its flexibility has been found to make it more adherent to the leaflet cone. This added adherence makes it more efficient in perivalvular sealing with fewer and shorter arms than used in the nitinol wire weave designs such as in
Two types of steerable, coaxial, delivery, deployment and retrieval systems may be used to deliver the device to the mitral valve position. The first system is designed to allow placement of the valve through a small thoracotomy and purse string controlled atriotomy (i.e., a minimally invasive surgical procedure: MIS). The second system allows for valve placement via a trans-femoral vein/trans-atrial septum approach to the mitral valve. Both systems are tailored to accommodate the arm design of the TMVR device optimized above. For each system, the length, width, radius of curvature, release mechanism, and docking station characteristics are defined.
The essentials of a first embodiment of a delivery system design are shown in
Using standard surgical techniques, a sterile left 3 cm anterior thoracotomy is performed and the left atrium exposed (unlike the human the left atrium is more easily reached via a small left thoracotomy rather than a right in a sheep). An atrial purse string is placed, through which an angiographic catheter is introduced across the MV annulus into the LV. A stiff 0.035″ guidewire is introduced and looped in the LV apex. The TMVR device is loaded into the delivery catheter and then introduced through the purse string, over the wire, into the atrial chamber, and across the MV annulus.
Given the dynamic nature of the MV annulus in the beating heart, visualization of the annular plane, leaflets, and submitral apparatus are essential for accurate transcatheter deployment of the TMVR device. A combination of angiography, and intracardiac echocardiography (ICE), and rt-3DE is used for localization of the important mitral valve components. Once appropriate positioning is confirmed via these imaging modalities, the TMVR device is deployed. Follow up rt-3DE and angiography are used to assess TMVR device position, function, and stability. The delivery system is withdrawn once stable position is established. The atrial purse string and thoracotomy are repaired in the standard fashion.
The general folding, imaging and delivery strategy is the same as developed for the MIS procedure. Catheter steerability is needed for percutaneous placement. As shown in
Not shown in
Due to the longer route to the left atrium, there is some necessary optimization of catheter length, width, and radius of curvature. However, the release mechanism and docking station characteristics are the same as for the MIS delivery device. As in the experiments described above, appropriate visualization is critical to successful TMVR deployment, and so an imaging protocol is used.
The inventors have previously demonstrated the feasibility of mitral valve replacement in the beating heart using the systemic venous circulation and transatrial septal puncture. This work was done in animals with pre-existing annuloplasty rings—the so-called valved stent-in-ring (VIR) procedure as shown in
In the embodiment of
Once the proper device position is confirmed using ICE, rt-3DE, and/or angiography, the TMVR device is deployed, released, and assessed for location and stability. In particular, the stent of the TMVR device in this embodiment is expanded until it is held in place by radial pressure against said annuloplasty ring. In exemplary embodiments, the annuloplasty ring and/or the stent may have a magnet and/or a detent incorporated therein such that the expanded stent does not move relative to the annuloplasty ring due to magnetic force retention and/or interaction with the detent. The delivery system is withdrawn once stable position is established. The ASD is closed via standard transcatheter techniques.
For testing of the devices described herein, the inventors have developed and extensively studied a sheep model of IMR which mimics the human disease very precisely. The model is produced by ligating the second and third branches of the circumflex artery. Twenty to 25 percent of the posterior basal LV myocardium is reliably infarcted and 3 to 4+MR develops over 8 weeks. The inventors have quantitatively characterized this IMR model using rt-3DE and analysis software. Using an extensive library of quantitative rt-3DE images, the size and the geometry of the leaflet cone in sheep with IMR is assessed. This data is then used to optimize the size of the device for IMR sheep. These prototypes are then placed using both the MIS and TMVR delivery systems described above.
Those skilled in the art will also appreciate that the invention may be applied to other applications and may be modified without departing from the scope of the invention. For example, those skilled in the art will appreciate that the devices and techniques of the invention may be used to replace the tricuspid valve as well as the mitral valve. Also, those skilled in the art will appreciate that the device may be made of stainless steel of varying thickness instead of nitinol. Accordingly, the scope of the invention is not intended to be limited to the exemplary embodiments described above, but only by the appended claims.
The present patent application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 61/565,958 filed Dec. 1, 2011. The content of that patent application is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/US12/67339 | 11/30/2012 | WO | 00 | 5/29/2014 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
61565958 | Dec 2011 | US |