Patent Grant
8901338
The present invention relates to phosphonium salts and their methods of preparation.
Phosphonium salts may be used in a wide range of applications, including: as surfactants; as a component in spinning finish agents for aromatic polyamide fibers (JP 11172577 A2, published Jun. 29, 1999); as antimicrobial agents (Kanazawa et al. (1994) Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, vol. 38(5), p. 945-952); and as polar solvents known as “ionic liquids” (for a recent review, see Thomas Welton (Chem. Rev. 1999, 99, 2071-2083)).
For many purposes, a phosphonium salt having a non-halide anion is desirable. Phosphonium non-halide salts can be prepared by a conventional two-step process, comprising the steps of (a) reacting a tertiary phosphine with an alkylhalide to obtain a quaternary phosphonium halide salt, and (b) exchanging the halide anion with a suitable anion (by ion exchange or metathesis) to generate a quaternary phosphonium salt having a non-halide anion.
However, this two-step process has several drawbacks. For example, the alkylhalides used to quaternize the tertiary phosphine are expensive and some are corrosive and difficult to prepare and use. Also, the tertiary phosphine may be expensive or difficult to make, the preparation thereof sometimes involving several steps and starting materials that are expensive and pyrophoric (see for example Kanazawa et al., supra, and Hugh R. Hays, J. Org. Chem. Vol. 31, pp. 3817-3820, which describe methods for preparing trimethylalkylphosphonium halides).
In addition, the two-step process generates large amounts of waste, as salt or acid by-products are usually removed by washing with water. Thus, the two-step process is inconvenient on an industrial scale.
Further, the end-product of the two-step process can be contaminated with residual halide ion, which may interfere with the intended utility of the phosphonium salt. For instance, halide ions such as chloride ions coordinate with group VII metals such as palladium and platinum and as a result, the presence of chloride ion can interfere with the activity of group VII metal catalysts. If a phosphonium salt is to be used in an environment where halide ions are unacceptable, even at low levels, halide salts should not be used in the starting materials or a further process must be used which ensures removal of halide ions from the phosphonium salt.
In one aspect, the present invention provides a method of preparing a phosphonium salt, the method comprising reacting a compound of formula I:
wherein R1 is hydrogen, R2 is hydrogen or hydrocarbyl, and R3 is hydrocarbyl,
wherein each of R4, R5, R6, R7, R8, R9, and R10 is independently hydrocarbyl,
wherein RQ is selected from R4 and R2 when R2 is hydrocarbyl, RX is selected from R4 and R3, each of RY and RZ is independently R4, and X− is
Some of the compounds of formula VII that can be prepared by the foregoing process are novel. Thus, in another aspect, the invention provides a compound of formula VII:
wherein each of RQ, RX, RY, and RZ is independently hydrocarbyl; and X− is
wherein each of R7, R8, and R9 is defined as above,
when X− is a phosphonate anion, then RQ, RX, RY, and RZ each has three or more carbon atoms;
when X− is a sulfate then the sum of carbon atoms in RQ, RX, RY, and RZ is greater than 4; and
when X− is methylsulfate, and one of RQ, RX, RY, and RZ is methyl, the other of RQ, RX, RY, and RZ cannot all be 2-cyanoethyl.
In general, a phosphonium salt of formula VII can be prepared by reacting a phosphine of formula I (hereinafter referred to as the “starting phosphine”) with an ester compound selected from the group consisting of: a phosphate triester of formula II; a phosphonate diester of formula III; a sulfate diester of formula IV; and a sulfonate ester of formula V. The overall reaction generates a quaternary phosphonium salt of formula VII and an acid counterpart of the ester (i.e. phosphoric acid, phosphonic acid, sulfuric acid, or sulfonic acid, respectively).
In one embodiment, the current method may be used for preparing a phosphonium of formula VII that has one or more methyl groups (i.e. one, two, three, or four methyl groups) attached to the phosphorus atom.
The current method may be especially suitable for preparing compounds of formula VII that are substantially free of halide ions.
In general, when the starting phosphine is a primary phosphine or a secondary phosphine, the ester is present in about three-fold or two-fold molar excess, respectively, relative to the starting phosphine, so as to provide roughly stoichiometric amounts of reagents. Specifically, when the starting phosphine is a primary phosphine (i.e. has a one hydrocarbyl group and two hydrogens attached to the phosphorus atom), the ester is present in about 3-fold molar excess of ester relative to starting phosphine. When the starting phosphine is a secondary phosphine (i.e. has two hydrocarbyl groups and one hydrogen attached to the phosphorus atom), the ester is present in about 2-fold molar excess of ester relative to starting phosphine. However in some cases, yields may be improved by using an excess of ester, for example in the range of about 1.05 to about 3.0 fold excess relative to the stoichiometry of the overall reaction and preferably about 1.1 to about 1.2 fold excess relative to the stoichiometric amount.
The temperature of the reaction is not critical and may range from about room temperature to about 260° C. or higher, although lower temperatures will result in longer reaction times. In general, the reaction proceeds readily at elevated temperature, say between about 80° C. to about 220° C., preferably in the range of 100-190° C., and is often complete in 8 hours at these temperatures.
However, as R4 groups on the ester increase in size (i.e. steric bulk), the reaction may become less efficient and higher temperatures or longer reaction times may be necessary to increase yield. Therefore, suitable values for R4 include but are not limited to: methyl, ethyl, n-propyl, isopropyl, n-butyl, iso-butyl, and tert-butyl. Certain esters, such as dimethyl-sulfate, are very active alkylating reagents and may be used for reactions carried out at moderate temperatures.
Also, the properties of the starting phosphine may affect the overall rate of the reaction. Secondary phosphines tend to be more reactive than primary phosphines. Thus, in general, reactions involving primary phosphine are carried out at higher temperatures or for longer times or both than are counterpart reactions involving secondary phosphines.
The starting phosphine can be added directly to an ester (a phosphate triester, a phosphonate diester, a sulfate diester, or a sulfonate ester), with stirring. However, the overall reaction is exothermic. Therefore, in order to control the temperature of the reaction mixture, it may be desirable to control the rate of addition in some cases and perhaps also to apply external cooling during the addition step. In addition, since alkylphosphines may be pyrophoric, it may be desirable to control the rate of addition of mono- or di-alkylphosphine so as to avoid having a large amount of unreacted mono- or di-alkylphosphine present in the reaction mixture, especially when the reaction is being carried out at elevated temperatures, for example over 100° C.
When the starting phosphine is a liquid at the temperature to be used for carrying out the reaction, the pressure of the reaction is not critical, and the reaction may be conveniently carried out at atmospheric pressure, under an inert atmosphere, such as nitrogen. Some primary and secondary phosphines that have short chain alkyl groups (such as dimethylphosphine) have low boiling points and may be gaseous and the temperature to be used for carrying out the reaction. When the starting phosphine is a gas at the temperature to be used for carrying out the reaction, the reaction is suitably carried out under pressure (e.g. in an autoclave) under an inert atmosphere, such as nitrogen.
The reaction can be carried out in the absence of solvent, in order to avoid a further step of purifying product away from solvent. However, the reaction may also be carried out in the presence of a solvent. In some cases, the presence of a solvent may be preferred as the solvent may enhance the rate at which the reaction proceeds.
If desired, any unreacted starting materials may be removed, for example, by evaporating under vacuum.
The method of the invention produces a mixture of phosphonium salt and acid which may be used directly, for example as a solvent for chemical reactions. Alternatively, the mixture of phosphonium salt and acid may be subjected to purification steps to isolate the phosphonium salt. For example, dimethylphosphoric acid and methyl hydrogen sulfate can be removed from the reaction mixture by evaporation, for example under vacuum at elevated temperatures (dimethylphosphoric acid decomposes at 172-176° C., and methyl hydrogen sulfate decomposes at 130-140° C.; see Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 57th Edition, CRC Press, Inc., copyright 1976, pages C-435 and C-508). Alternatively, the acid product can be removed by neutralizing the acid with a hydroxide of a Group II metal (i.e. an alkaline earth metal hydroxide, such as calcium hydroxide or barium hydroxide) to form a precipitate and recovering the precipitate by suitable means, such as filtration. Of note, calcium dimethylphosphate, a chemical that finds utility in polyester fibre processing (JP2001164461), can be prepared by the foregoing process. If the phosphonium salt forms a two-phase system when mixed with water, it may be possible to remove acid by washing the phosphonium salt with water. Other purification processes known in the art, such as chromatography, can also be used to purify the phosphonium salt from the reaction mixture.
Suitable hydrocarbyl groups for RQ, RX, RY, RZ, R2, R3, R4, R5, R6, R7, R8, R9, and R10 include: substituted or unsubstituted C1-C30 alkyl, substituted or unsubstituted C3-C8 cycloalkyl, substituted or unsubstituted C2-C30 alkenyl, substituted or unsubstituted C2-C30 alkynyl, substituted or unsubstituted C6-C18 aryl, or substituted or unsubstituted C7-C35 aralkyl, although hydrocarbyl groups with not more than 20 carbon atoms are preferred. R2 and R3 together with the phosphorus atom to which R2 and R3 are bonded can form a five- to eight-membered heterocycle or a heterobicycle, such as 9-phosphabicyclo[3.3.1]nonane. It is noted that R2 and R3 can be perfluoroalkyl. It is possible for the R groups (RQ, RX, RY, RZ, R2 and R3 when not perfluoroalkyl and R4 to R10) to bear substituents, or to include heteroatoms, provided that the substituents or heteroatoms do not interfere with the preparation of the compounds of the invention, and do not adversely affect the desired properties of the compound. Acceptable substituents may include alkoxy, halo, carboxy, and acetyl,and heteroatoms that may be acceptable include nitrogen, oxygen and sulphur. Substituents are likely to increase the cost of the compounds of the invention and as the compounds are often used in industrial applications (as solvents, surfactants, etc.), they are used in such volume that cost is a significant factor. Hence, it is contemplated that, for the most part, substituents will not be present, except for compounds in which one or more of R2 and R3 is perfluoroalkyl. If necessary, one of skill in the art can readily determine whether substituents or heteratoms of the hydrocarbyl groups interfere with preparation or desired properties of the compounds by routine experimentation that does not involve the exercise of any inventive faculty.
In many cases, RQ, RX, RY, RZ, R2, R3, R4, R5, R6, R7, R8, R9, and R10 will be substituted or unsubstituted alkyl groups of 1 to 20 carbon atoms. Thus, specific examples of values for RQ, RX, RY, RZ, R2, R3, R4, R5, R6, R7, R8, R9, and R10 include: methyl, ethyl, n-propyl, isopropyl, n-butyl, iso-butyl, tert-butyl, n-pentyl, cyclopentyl, iso-pentyl, n-hexyl, cyclohexyl, norbornyl, 3-methylphenyl (2,4,4′-trimethyl)pentyl, cyclooctyl, tetradecyl, etc. R2 and R3 can also be trifluoromethyl.
Mention is made of the following examples of values for R2 and R3: methyl, trifluoromethyl, ethyl, n-propyl, iso-propyl, n-butyl, iso-butyl, tert-butyl, cyclopentyl, cyclohexyl, and norbornyl, and the case where R2 and R3 together with the phosphorus atom to R2 and R3 are bonded form 9-phosphabicyclo[3.3.1]nonyl.
Mention is made of the following examples of values for R4, R5, R6, R7, R8, R9, and R10: methyl, ethyl, n-propyl, isopropyl, n-butyl, iso-butyl, and tert-butyl. It is noted that R10 can also be p-toluenyl. Examples of suitable esters for use in the inventive method include but are not limited to: trimethylphosphate, dimethylsulfate, dimethylmethanephosphonate, and methyltosylate.
Phosphonium cations in which RQ, RX, RY, and RZ are not identical are referred to as “asymmetric”. In some cases, it is desired that RQ, RX, RY, and RZ shall not be identical and in particular, that at least one of RQ, RX, RY, and RZ shall contain a significantly higher number of carbon atoms (for example 14 to 20 carbon atoms) than the others of RQ, RX, RY, and RZ.
For some applications, it is desired that at least one of RQ, RX, RY, and RZ shall contain a low number of carbon atoms (for example 1 to 3 carbon atoms, more preferably 2 carbon atoms, and even more preferably one carbon atom). For example, one, two, three or all of RQ, RX, RY, and RZ can be methyl. Phosphonium salts with a low carbon content, say between 5 to 12 carbon atoms, may find utility as ionic liquids or electrolytes in cases where a high ratio of charge to molecular weight is required.
Phosphonium salts that may be used as surfactants include those in which three of RQ, RX, RY, and RZ are each independently methyl or ethyl, preferably methyl, and the other is a saturated hydrocarbyl having an unbranched chain of a higher number of carbon atoms, say 12 to 30 carbon atoms, more preferably 12 to 20 carbon atoms. By a “surfactant” we mean a surface-active agent that reduces surface tension when dissolved in water or water solutions, or that reduces interfacial tension between two liquids, or between a liquid and a solid. Surfactants include detergents, wetting agents, and emulsifiers. Surfactants may form micelles. The hydrocarbyl chain on the phosphonium may bear substituents that do interfere with intended utility of the compound as a surfactant, including but not limited to fluoro.
In some cases, it is preferred that at least one of RQ, RX, RY, RZ or R5 to R10 contains a higher number of carbon atoms, for example 14 or more. For example, the presence of one or more long alkyl chains may increase the ability of a phosphonium salt to dissolve nonpolar organic compounds. In addition, the presence of one or more long alkyl chains may render the phosphonium salt “water immiscible”.
Compounds according to formula VII that are hydrophobic or “water immiscible” are preferred for some purposes. The term “water immiscible” is intended to describe compounds that form a two phase system when mixed with water but does not exclude compounds that dissolve in water nor compounds that will dissolve water, provided that the two phase system forms. Water immiscibility is a desirable feature of a phosphonium salt not only because it renders the compound useful as a solvent for biphasic reactions with an aqueous phase, but also because it facilitates purification and isolation of the phosphonium salt when prepared according to certain methods. By way of illustration, when the method of the invention produces a water-immiscible phosphonium salt and an acid, the acid can be removed from the reaction products by washing the phosphonium salt with water. Compounds of formula VII that have a large total number of carbons, say equal to or greater than 20 and in particular greater than 25 or 26, or have at least one aryl group are more hydrophobic. There is no critical upper limit on the total number of carbon atoms that may be present in a compound of formula VII. However, it is unlikely that the total will exceed 50.
If the compound of formula VII is intended for use as a solvent, then in general, it is preferred that the compound is a liquid below 100° C., more preferably below 50° C., and most preferably at or below room temperature. Values for RQ, RX, RY, RZ, R2, R3, R4, R5, R6, R7, R8, R9, and R10 can be selected to yield compounds that are liquid at room temperature. Increasing the total number of carbon atoms present in the hydrocarbyl groups RQ, RX, RY, RZ, and R2 to R10 will tend to increase the melting point, although this effect can be counteracted somewhat by asymmetry, branching of the hydrocarbyl groups RQ, RX, RY, RZ, and R2 to R10, and the tendency of sterically bulky ions to coordinate poorly. Specifically, the melting point tends to decrease as the degree of asymmetry around the phosphorus atom increases. Also, the melting point of the salt will tend to decrease as the degree of branching of the hydrocarbyl groups RQ, RX, RY, RZ, and R2 to R10 increases. Branching can occur at the alpha or omega carbon or at any intermediate point. In addition, the melting point of the salt will tend to decrease as steric bulk increases around either or both of the phosphorus atom of the cation and the central atom of the anion (the sulfur atom or phosphorus atom or carbon atom); for this reason, it may be preferred for one or more of R groups on either or both of the cation and anion (i.e. RQ, RX, RY, RZ, R5, R6, R7, R8, R9, and R10) to have three or more carbon atoms.
Thus, the current invention contemplates compounds of formula VII where properties may be modified by varying the values of the R groups present on either the anion or the cation. Selection of particular values for RQ, RX, RY, RZ, and R2 to R10 to achieve particular melting points, degrees of water immiscibility, or surfactant properties is within the competence of a person skilled in the art, although it may require some routine experimentation.
Compounds according to formula VII that have chirality provide a chiral environment for chemical reactions and may be especially suitable for certain purposes, such as a reaction having an asymmetric or chiral transition state that can be stabilized by interaction with a suitable solvent. Examples of chiral compounds of formula VII include compounds containing a phosphonium cation wherein RQ, RX, RY, and RZ, are all different or wherein one of RQ, RX, RY, and RZ, is an enantiomer, such as 2,4,4′-trimethylpentyl, which group has one chiral atom.
Mention is made of the following examples of compounds of formula VII:
cyclohexyltrimethylphosphonium dimethylphosphate;
dibutyldimethylphosphonium dimethylphosphate;
dicyclohexyldimethylphosphonium dimethylphosphate; and
diisobutyldimethylphosphonium dimethylphosphate.
Phosphonium salts described herein may find utility in a wide range of applications. For example, phosphonium salts in which three of RQ, RX, RY, and RZ are methyl and the other is a saturated or unsaturated hydrocarbyl having an unbranched chain of a higher number of carbon atoms, say 12 to 30 carbon atoms, may find utility as antimicrobial agents (Kanazawa, supra) or surfactants. Phosphonium phosphates may find utility as a component of spinning finish (JP11172577). The phosphonium salts of the current invention may also be used as polar solvents known as “ionic liquids” for chemical reactions such as Michael additions, aryl coupling, Diels-Alder, alkylation, biphasic catalysis, Heck reactions, hydrogenation, or for enzymatic reactions, for example lipase reactions (for a recent review of ionic liquids, see Thomas Welton (Chem. Rev. 1999, 99, 2071-2083)).
In the following examples, starting material phosphines are made by Cytec Canada, Inc. and their purity determined by gas chromatography (GC). The remaining starting materials were purchased from Aldrich and used as they were purchased. Structures were confirmed by NMR (nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometry) and by FAB MS (Fast Atom Bombardment mass spectrometry), as indicated.
Cyclohexylphosphine (14.5 g, 98%, 0.1255 mole) was added by dripping through an addition funnel over a period of 10 minutes to a flask containing trimethylphosphate (95 g, 97%, 0.6578 mole, b.p. 197° C.) preheated to 140° C. under nitrogen, with stirring. There was no sudden change in temperature associated with addition. The mixture was heated to reflux (about 165° C.).
As the reaction proceeded, the temperature of the mixture gradually increased to 210° C. and was maintained at this temperature with stirring for 15 minutes. The total reaction time was about 8 hours.
The reaction mixture was then cooled and decanted into a flask. Excess trimethylphosphate was removed from the reaction mixture by heating to 180° C. under vacuum 5 mm Hg.
The product was a glassy, colourless liquid with a pH of about 2-3 pH units. The presence of cyclohexyltrimethylphosphonium dimethylphosphate and dimethylphosphoric acid was confirmed by 1H (see
A 500 ml 2 neck round-bottomed flask fitted with a condenser was charged with 108.0 g (0.77 mole) trimethylphosphate and heated to 135° C. under nitrogen with stirring. Di-n-butylphosphine (93.2 g, 0.64 mole) was added to the flask over a period of 8 hours. The temperature of the contents of the flask increased to 155° C. during the addition of a first 6.6 g of the total 93.2 g of di-n-butylphosphine. The reaction was maintained at 150° C. for 2 hours.
Following the incubation period, unreacted trimethylphosphate was removed by evaporation for 6 hours at 100° C. under reduced pressure (20 mmHg).
A colourless and viscous liquid (180.7 g) was obtained. 31P, 13C and 1H NMR and FAB MS confirmed the presence of dibutylphosphonium dimethylphosphate and dimethylphosphoric acid. 1H-NMR (CDCl3, 300.13 Hz, δ) signals for the characteristic methyl groups are: 1.65 (d, J=13.8 Hz, P—CH3), 3.20 (d, J=10.6 Hz, O═P—O—CH3); 31P—NMR (CDCl3, 81.015 Hz, δ): 30.36 (F), 2.06 (O═P—O—CH3).
A round-bottomed flask fitted with a condenser was charged with 280.3 g (1.9 mole) trimethylphosphate and heated to 100° C. under nitrogen with stirring. Dicyclohexylphosphine (277.2 g, 1.4 mol) was gradually added to the flask over a period of 7.5 hour. The reaction was exothermic, with the temperature of the contents of the flask rising rapidly to 150-160° C. during the addition of dicyclohexylphosphine. The reaction mixture was maintained at a temperature of 150-160° C. for 2 hours, then cooled to room temperature.
Upon cooling to room temperature, the product crystallized into a clear, colourless solid. Unreacted trimethylphosphate was removed by evaporation under reduced pressure (5 mmHg) at 170° C. for 12 hour.
Analysis by 31P and 1H NMR and MS confirmed the presence of dicyclohexyldimethylphosphonium dimethylphosphate and dimethylphosphoric acid. 1H-NMR (CDCl3, 300.13 Hz, δ) signals for the characteristic methyl groups are: 1.76 (d, J=13. Hz, P—CH3), 3.39 (d, J=10.6 Hz, O═P—O—CH3); 31P—NMR (CDCl3, 81.015 Hz, δ): 34.48 (P+), 2.28 (O═P—O—CH3).
A round-bottomed flask was charged with 136.0 g (0.96 mole) trimethylphosphate and heated to 140° C. under nitrogen with stirring. While stirring vigorously, a solution of 70.3 g (0.48 mol) diisobutylphosphonium and 11.0 g of dimethylcarbonate were added to the flask over a period of 2.5 hours at 135° C. The reaction was exothermic during the addition of the phosphine. The reaction mixture was maintained at 135° C. for a total of 8 hours, then cooled room temperature. 31P, 1H, and 13C NMR analyses confirmed the presence of the diisobutyldimethylphosphonium dimethylphosphate and dimethylphosphoric acid.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2424215 | Mar 2003 | CA | national |
This application is a divisional application of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 12/899,097, filed Oct. 6, 2010 (now U.S. Pat. No. 8,748,668), which is a divisional of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 10/549,223, filed Feb. 8, 2007 (now U.S. Pat. No. 7,829,744), which is the U.S. National Phase application of International Application No. PCT/US2004/006961, filed Mar. 8, 2004, which claims benefit of priority from Canadian Patent Application No. 2,424,215, filed Mar. 31, 2003, each of which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. This application is also related to co-pending U.S. application Ser. No. 14/152,551, filed Jan. 10, 2014 (allowed).
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3976566 | Petrovich | Aug 1976 | A |
| 4017610 | Baker | Apr 1977 | A |
| 4837394 | Alexandrovich et al. | Jun 1989 | A |
| 4867790 | Jochum et al. | Sep 1989 | A |
| 20040106823 | Robertson et al. | Jun 2004 | A1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 029003 | Oct 1980 | EP |
| 0149480 | Jan 1985 | EP |
| 0161128 | Nov 1985 | EP |
| 0455257 | Nov 1991 | EP |
| 0640646 | Mar 1995 | EP |
| 0675130 | Oct 1995 | EP |
| 0895997 | Jan 1999 | EP |
| 1182197 | Aug 2000 | EP |
| 63119490 | May 1988 | JP |
| 11172577 | Jun 1999 | JP |
| 2001164461 | Jun 2001 | JP |
| 9723490 | Jul 1997 | WO |
| 0016902 | Mar 2000 | WO |
| 01-87900 | Nov 2001 | WO |
| 03-020843 | Feb 2003 | WO |
| 03051894 | Jun 2003 | WO |
| WO0016902 | Mar 2014 | WO |
| Entry |
|---|
| Christine J. Bradaric, et al.; “Industrial Preparation of Phosphonium Ionic Liquids,” Green Chemistry, 2003, 5, 143-152. |
| Welton, Chem. Rev. 99, pp. 2071-2083 (1999). |
| Kanazawa, Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, v. 38(5) pp. 945-952 (1994). |
| Hays, H., J. Org. Chem., 1966, v. 31(11), pp. 3817-3820. |
| Kanazawa, J. Polymer Sci., v. 31(6), pp. 1441-1447 (1993). |
| Ludley, P. et al. Tetrahedron Letters v. 42, No. 10, Mar. 4, 2001, pp. 2011-2014. |
| Comyns, C. et al., Catalysis Letters, v. 67, No. 2-4, Mar. 10, 2000, pp. 113-115. |
| Karodia, N. et al., Chemical Communications, No. 21, 1998, pp. 2341-2342. |
| Olivier, H., Nonaqueous Ionic Liquids (NAILS): Aqueous Phase Organometallic Catalysis, Concepts and Applications, May 28, 1998 pp. 555-563. |
| Abdallah, D.J. et al., J. Amer. Chem. Soc., v. 122(13), Apr. 5, 2000, pp. 3053-3062. |
| Esteruelas, M.A. et al., Organometallics, v. 16(21) Oct. 14, 1997, pp. 4572-4580. |
| Imrie, C. et al., J. Organic Chemistry, v. 58(21), 1993, pp. 5643-5649. |
| Dema, A. et al., Organometallics, v. 10(4) 1991, pp. 1197-1200. |
| Jones, R. A. et al., J. Chem. Soc., Perkin Transactions II, No. 1, 1980, pp. 117-120. |
| Cerichelli, G. et al., Langmuir, v. 16(1) Jan. 11, 2000, pp. 156-171. |
| Ogata, M. et al., J. of Applied Polymer Sci., v. 48(4), Apr. 20, 1993, pp. 583-601. |
| Yanmaele, L., Research Disclosure, No. 287, 1988, pp. 133-134. |
| Barraud, A. et al., Langmuir-Blodgett Film, v. 160(1), Jun. 1, 1988, pp. 81-85. |
| Adams, C. et al. Chemical Communications, No. 19, 1998, pp. 2097-2098. |
| Chauvin, Y. et al., Journal of the Chemical Society, Chemical Communications, No. 23, 1990, pp. 1715-1716. |
| Bohm, V. et al., Chemistry—A European Journal, v. 6(6) Mar. 17, 2000, pp. 1017-1025. |
| Chauvin, Y. et al., Catalytic Dimerization of Olefins by Nickle Complexes in Organochloroaluminate Molten Salts, v. 90(17), 1990, pp. 822-832. |
| Chauvin, Y. et al., Journal of Catalysis, v. 165, 1997, pp. 275-278. |
| Fischer, T. et al. Tetrahedron Letters, v. 40(4), Jan. 22, 1999, pp. 793-796. |
| Wessolowski, H. et al., J. Fluorine Chem., v. 80(2), 1996, pp. 149-152. |
| Sarbu, T. et al., Maromol. Chem. Phys., 2001, 202, pp. 3379-3397. |
| Haskin, B.A., et al., J. of Gen. Chem., v. 38(12), 1967, pp. 2652-2658. |
| Office Action Summary of Oct. 9, 2008 for copending U.S. Appl. No. 10/521,973. |
| Wasserscheid et al., 2002, CAS: 136:200188. |
| Holbrey et al., 2002, CAS: 138:338049. |
| Wasserscheid et al., 2002, CAS: 140:78757. |
| Office Action Summary of Jun. 17, 2009 for copending U.S. Appl. No. 10/521,973. |
| International Search Report for PCT/US2004/006961, date mailed Aug. 5, 2004. |
| Written Opinion of ISR for PCT/US2004/006961, dated mailed Aug. 5, 2004. |
| International Preliminary Report on Patentability for PCT/US2004/006961, date completed Aug. 18, 2005. |
| Oliver, H., Nanaqueous Ionic Liquids (NAILS): Aqueous Phase Organometallic Catalysis, Concepts and Applications, May 28, 1998, pp. 555-563. |
| Chauvin, V. et al., Catalytic Dimerization of Olefins by Nickle Complexes in Organochloroaluminate Molten Salts, v. 99(17), 1990, pp. 822-832. |
| Opposition paper for EP1387813, dated Mar. 4, 2008. |
| International Search Report for PCT/CA03/01189, mailed Jan. 2, 2004. |
| International Preliminary Examination Report for PCT/CA03/01189, completed Sep. 30, 2004. |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20140128630 A1 | May 2014 | US |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 12899097 | Oct 2010 | US |
| Child | 14152477 | US | |
| Parent | 10549223 | US | |
| Child | 12899097 | US |
