The disclosure relates to plant-expressed cocaine hydrolase variants of butyrylcholinesterase and methods of reducing cocaine-primed reinstatement.
Cocaine abuse is a global problem with major medical and societal consequences. Cocaine-use disorders include short- and long-term pathologies (for example, overdose, intractable addiction, and post-abstinence relapse) that affect millions of people worldwide with no available treatment to effectively reduce morbidity and mortality associated with such disorders. Patients suffering from acute toxicity (overdose) are only symptomatically treated and there is no effective FDA-approved treatment to decrease the likelihood of relapse in rehabilitated addicts. One therapeutic approach for counteracting the toxic and addictive psychoactive effects of cocaine is to accelerate the drug's metabolism, for example, using enzymes that can break down active cocaine molecules into inactive metabolites.
Butyrylcholinesterase (BChE) is a human serum enzyme that is capable of binding and/or hydrolyzing a diverse array of compounds including many natural and man-made toxicants of the central and peripheral nervous system, unlike the highly selective homologous enzyme acetylcholinesterase (AChE). BChE is capable of counteracting the toxicity of various anticholinesterases by binding to them before they reach their targets in the nervous system. BChE can detoxifying organophosphorous (OP) nerve agents like paraoxon, as well as acetylcholine receptor antagonists, and psychoactive plant alkaloids such as cocaine. Exogenously supplied BChE can augment the bioscavenging capacity of the endogenous enzyme and provide broad protection by sequestering the anticholinesterase agents.
In humans, BChE is responsible for the inactivation of cocaine, resulting in the transient nature of cocaine-induced euphoria. However, the limited hydrolytic capacity of this promiscuous enzyme toward (−)-cocaine, the psychoactive enantiomer of the drug, does not allow the enzyme to remove it rapidly enough from the human body in situations of overdose. Mutants of BChE have been rationally designed (for example, using molecular dynamics and modeling based on the atomically resolved structure of the enzyme (PDB 1P0P)) to create highly efficient recombinant cocaine hydrolases compared to the wild-type (WT) BChE (UniProt accession number P06276). The variants were designed to be an enzyme-based therapy to treat drug overdose and addiction.
One such cocaine hydrolase BChE variant (A199S/S287G/A328W/Y332G), when derived from mammalian expression systems, has been shown to accelerate cocaine metabolism in vivo and to fully protect mice and rats from respective lethal doses of cocaine. This enzyme has also been shown to be safe and effective in humans to accelerate cocaine metabolism in Phase I and Phase II clinical trials. In an effort to further improve the efficiency of cocaine hydrolysis, a pentavalent mutant (A199S/F227A/S287G/A328W/Y332G) was designed, and it was shown to be an even more effective cocaine hydrolase both in vitro and in vivo.
The catalytic activity of WT hBChE against cocaine is measurable, albeit slow, and provides one of the major detoxification pathways for the drug, generating non-psychoactive metabolites. When designing BChE-based cocaine hydrolase mutants, care was taken to ensure that their ability to hydrolyze the crucially important substrate, acetylcholine (ACh), was not significantly enhanced. While these highly efficient cocaine-metabolizing variants of BChE were designed with the goal of increasing catalytic efficiency of cocaine hydrolysis toward an anti-cocaine treatment, whether the newly introduced mutations can affect the role of BChE in interfering with the drug reinstatement neurological pathway remains unclear.
The disclosure relates to the use of a cocaine hydrolase variant of human serum butyrylcholinesterase (BChE, UniProt accession number P06276) to reduce cocaine-primed reinstatement of drug-seeking behavior in mammals having had prior exposure to cocaine or to treat acute cocaine toxicity. In one useful embodiment, the cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE is plant-expressed and a pentavalent mutant with a substitution mutation at residue 199, residue 227, residue 287, residue 328, and residue 332. In certain beneficial embodiments, the cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE have the following substitution mutations: A199S, F227A, S287G, A328W, and Y332G. In some aspects, the plant-expressed BChE is a tetramer and/or comprises a C-terminal 6x histidine tag.
In certain implementations, the cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE is administered parenterally, for example, intravenously, sublingually, subcutaneously, or transdermally. The cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE can also be administered via a pulmonary route. The amount of the cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE administered is typically at least 3 mg/kg body weight of the mammalian subject. In certain particular aspects, the amount of the cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE administered is 3 to 10 mg/kg body weight, e.g., about 3 mg/kg body weight of the mammalian subject.
The mammalian subject being treated has often had multiple self-induced exposures to cocaine. For example, the mammalian subject is an addict. As used herein, the term multiple exposures means more than once, e.g., at least 5 times, at least 10 times, etc. In other implementations, the mammalian subject may be administered multiple doses of cocaine by another party. The cocaine-seeking behavior of the mammalian subject, in certain embodiment, has been extinguished for at least one day, at least one week, or at least two weeks.
The patent or application file contains at least one drawing executed in color. Copies of this patent or patent application publication with color drawing(s) will be provided by the Office upon request and payment of the necessary fee.
WT hBChE, 100%=1.57±0.04 nmol/min, Equation (2), R2=0.98;
WT pBChE, 100%=1.21±0.07 nmol/min, Equation (2), R2=0.99;
pBChEv2, 100%=0.79±0.10 nmol/min, Equation (3), R2=0.83;
pBChEv3, 100%=0.96±0.01 nmol/min, Equation (3), R2=0.95;
pBChEv4, 100%=8.9±0.6 nmol/min, Equation (3), R2=0.95;
pBChEv5, 100%=8.1±0.3 nmol/min, Equation (3), R2=0.95
WT hBChE, 100%=0.97±0.04 nmol/min, Equation (2), R2=0.99;
WT pBChE, 100%=3.0±0.1 nmol/min, Equation (2), R2=1.00;
pBChEv2, 100%=4.7±0.1 nmol/min, Equation (2), R2=0.99;
pBChEv3, 100%=1.39±0.00 nmol/min, Equation (3), R2=0.98;
pBChEv4, 100%=2.6±0.1 nmol/min, Equation (1), R2=0.94;
pBChEv5, 100%=12.0±0.7 nmol/min, Equation (3), R2=0.99
In accordance with certain embodiments,
In accordance with certain embodiments,
In accordance with certain embodiments,
Detailed aspects and applications of the disclosure are described below in the following drawings and detailed description of the technology. Unless specifically noted, it is intended that the words and phrases in the specification and the claims be given their plain, ordinary, and accustomed meaning to those of ordinary skill in the applicable arts.
In the following description, and for the purposes of explanation, numerous specific details are set forth in order to provide a thorough understanding of the various aspects of the disclosure. It will be understood, however, by those skilled in the relevant arts, that embodiments of the technology disclosed herein may be practiced without these specific details. It should be noted that there are many different and alternative configurations, devices and technologies to which the disclosed technologies may be applied. The full scope of the technology disclosed herein is not limited to the examples that are described below.
The singular forms “a,” “an,” and “the” include plural referents unless the context clearly dictates otherwise. Thus, for example, reference to “a step” includes reference to one or more of such steps.
As used herein, the term “about” refers to a deviation up to but not more than 10% of the given value, for example a deviation of 10%, 7.5%, 5%, 4%, 3%, 2%, 1%, 0.5%, or 0.1% of the given value.
As used herein, the term “subject,” “mammalian subject,” or “addict,” refers to any mammalian subject or patient to which the methods of the invention can be applied. “Mammals” refers to human patients and non-human primates, as well as experimental animals such as rabbits, rats and mice, and other animals. The term “addict” also refers to a mammalian subject who has had multiple exposures to cocaine, whether self-induced or not self-induced. In particular embodiment, the term “addict” refers to a mammalian subject that is administered cocaine on a regular basis, whether self-administered or by another.
As used herein, the amino acid sequence of wild-type human serum butyrylcholinesterase (BChE) is set forth in UniProt accession number P06276.
As used herein, the term “cocaine hydrolase variants of butyrylcholinesterase” are BChEs altered to have cocaine hydrolase activity. Examples of such mutated BChE include BChE with the following combination of substitution mutations: F227A, S287G, A328W, and Y332A (also referred to herein as pBChEv2 when produced in plants); A199S, S287G, A328W, and Y332G (also referred to herein as pBChEv3 when produced in plants); A199S, F227A, S287G, A328W, and Y332G (also referred to herein as pBChEv4 or PCocSH (Plant-derived form of the Cocaine Super Hydrolase) when produced in plants); F227A, S287G, A328W, and Y332G (also referred to herein as pBChEv5 when produced in plants).
The term “plant-derived cocaine hydrolase variants of BChE” (pBChE, as opposed to the wild-type human serum BChE abbreviated as hBChE) as used herein, refers to any cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE that are produced from plants expressing a gene encoding a cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE. For example, the cocaine hydrolase variants of BChE are produced by a plant with its genome modified to express a synthetic gene encoding the cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE. In certain embodiments, the gene may be codon optimized for plant expression.
The disclosure relates to the discovery that the mutations at residue 119, residue 227, residue 287, residue 328, and residue 332 of BChE allosterically affect the catalytic triad not only within a single subunit but also propagate to neighboring subunits of the BChE oligomer (see, for example,
In some aspects, the mammalian subject having had prior exposure to cocaine has had multiple self-induced exposures to cocaine. For example, the mammalian subject that self-administers cocaine on a regular basis. In certain implementations, the mammalian subject having had prior exposure to cocaine is an addict.
In some embodiments, the cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE is a mutated BChE comprising at least one substitution mutation at residue 119, residue 227, residue 287, residue 328, or residue 332, for example, at least two substitution mutations, at least three substitutions, or at least for substitution mutations. In certain embodiments, the combinations of mutations in a cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE are substitution mutations at residues 227, 287, 328, and 332; at residues 199, 287, 328, and 332; at residues 199, 227, 287, 328, and 332; or substitution mutations at residues 227, 287, 328, and 332, for example, the cocaine hydrolase variants specified in Table 3. In a particular embodiment, the cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE is PCocSH.
In certain aspects, the genome of the plant from which the cocaine hydrolase variant of BChE is produced is modified by cloning the synthetic gene encoding the cocaine hydrolase variant of human serum BChE into a TMV-based MagnICON vector system. In some aspects, the pBChE administered is a tetramer. In some aspects, the pBChE administered comprises a C-terminal 6x histidine tag. In certain implementations, the pBChE administered is conjugated to polyethylene glycol, for example, PEGylated (see Geyer et al., PNAS 2010). In other implementations, the pBChE is administered in a composition comprising other ingredients that are known to enhance the half-life and bioavailability of an enzyme.
In certain implementations, the pBChE is administered parenterally. For example, the pBChE may be administered to the mammalian subject intravenously, sublingually, subcutaneously, and/or transdermally. The pBChE may also be administered with a pulmonary route, for example, in an aerosolized form. The amount of pBChE administered to the mammalian subject is between 2 and 15 mg/kg body weight, for example, between 2 and 10 mg/kg body weight, between 3 and 10 mg/kg body weight, about 2 mg/kg body weight, at least 3 mg/kg body weight, about 3 mg/kg body weight, about 4 mg/kg body weight, about 5 mg/kg body weight, about 6 mg/kg body weight, about 7 mg/kg body weight, about 8 mg/kg body weight, about 9 mg/kg body weight, or about 10 mg/kg body weight.
In particular implementations of reducing cocaine-primed reinstatement of drug-seeking behavior in a mammalian subject having had prior exposure to cocaine, the pBChE is administered no more than a day before an incident of cocaine exposure, for example, no more than 20 hours, 12 hours, 10 hours, about 8 hours, about 6 hours, about 5 hours, about 4 hours, about 3 hours, about 2 hours, about 1 hour, about 30 minutes, about 15 minutes, about 10 minutes, or about 5 minutes before an incident of cocaine exposure. The mammalian subject's prior exposure to cocaine may be, in certain embodiment, at least one day from the administration of pBChE. In some aspects, the prior exposure to cocaine was at least one week, at least two weeks, about one week, or about two weeks from the administration of pBChE. Thus, in certain implementations, pBChE is administered to the mammalian subject when the cocaine-behavior of the subject has been extinguished for at least one day, at least one week, at least two weeks, about one day, about one week, or about two weeks.
In some implementations of reducing cocaine-primed reinstatement of drug-seeking behavior in a mammalian subject having had prior exposure to cocaine, the pBChE is administered to the mammalian subject once daily, weekly, or monthly. In some aspects, the pBChE is administered continuously or on the aforementioned schedule using a pump-liked device. When pBChE is administered continuous, the amount of the enzyme administered is between 2 and 15 mg/kg body weight/day, for example, between 2 and 10 mg/kg body weight/day, between 3 and 10 mg/kg body weight/day, about 2 mg/kg body weight/day, at least 3 mg/kg body weight/day, about 3 mg/kg body weight/day, about 4 mg/kg body weight/day, about 5 mg/kg body weight/day, about 6 mg/kg body weight/day, about 7 mg/kg body weight/day, about 8 mg/kg body weight/day, about 9 mg/kg body weight/day, or about 10 mg/kg body weight/day. In another implementation where pBChE is administered continuously, the amount of the enzyme administered is between 2 and 15 mg/kg body weight/week or between 2 and 15 mg/kg body weight/month, for example, between 2 and 10 mg/kg body weight/week, between 3 and 10 mg/kg body weight/week, about 2 mg/kg body weight/week, at least 3 mg/kg body weight/week, about 3 mg/kg body weight/week, about 4 mg/kg body weight/week, about 5 mg/kg body weight/week, about 6 mg/kg body weight/week, about 7 mg/kg body weight/week, about 8 mg/kg body weight/week, about 9 mg/kg body weight/day, about 10 mg/kg body weight/week, between 2 and 10 mg/kg body weight/month, between 3 and 10 mg/kg body weight/month, about 2 mg/kg body weight/month, at least 3 mg/kg body weight/month, about 3 mg/kg body weight/month, about 4 mg/kg body weight/month, about 5 mg/kg body weight/month, about 6 mg/kg body weight/month, about 7 mg/kg body weight/month, about 8 mg/kg body weight/month, about 9 mg/kg body weight/month, or about 10 mg/kg body weight/month.
In particular implementations of treating acute cocaine toxicity, pBChE is administered within 10 minutes after the mammalian subject is exposed to cocaine. In some embodiments, the pBChE is administered within a minute of the mammalian subject developing symptoms of acute cocaine toxicity. Symptoms of acute cocaine toxicity include cocaine-induced seizures or tremors, decreased motor activity, dragging feet, dystaxia, knuckle walking, labored breathing, and decreased locomotion. Symptoms of acute cocaine toxicity also include decreased responsiveness to stimuli and dyspnea.
Illustrative, Non-Limiting Example in Accordance with Certain Embodiments
The disclosure is further illustrated by the following examples that should not be construed as limiting. The contents of all references, patents, and published patent applications cited throughout this application, as well as the Figures, are incorporated herein by reference in their entirety for all purposes.
1. Plant production of a recombinant cocaine-hydrolyzing human BChE variant.
A low-cost, sustainable, source of recombinant BChE must be readily available to produce clinically useful quantities of BChE mutants. Rapid and high-level transient expression of foreign proteins in plants is needed to efficiently screen copious number of mutant variants, while maintaining the ability to ramp up production greatly when mutants of particular interest have been established. Mammalian expression systems have been used to produce cocaine hydrolase variants of BChE, but such platforms can be difficult and expensive to scale up. Plant-based recombinant protein production systems, in particular transient expression systems that make use of viral vectors (
Several research groups have been working on rational re-design of BChE into a cocaine hydrolase. The group led by Zhan used hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) method-based predictions followed by validation through in vitro and in vivo experiments. This process provided evidence for a correlation between the measured catalytic efficiency of cocaine hydrolysis and the sum of the enzyme-substrate hydrogen-bonding distances within the first transition state. In successive papers Zhan et al. reported the further design of BChE variants with ever increasing catalytic efficiency.
Several of these variants (see Methods for a list of variants discussed here) have been produced using the deconstructed tobacco mosaic virus (TMV)-based expression system in plants (
The pBChEv4 was purified as previously reported for its WT counterpart. SDS-PAGE analysis of pBChEv4 revealed that it resolved with an apparent molecular mass of ˜65-70 kDa. This is similar to previously described plant-derived BChE variants and slightly smaller than the ˜85 kDa human BChE monomer, likely due to differences in glycosylation (
The plant-derived pBChEv4 was examined closely for its ability to hydrolyze cocaine (
In another experiment, PCocSH enzyme was transiently expressed in WT Nicotiana. benthamiana plants using the magnICON vector system based on deconstructed tobacco mosaic virus (
2. Cocaine hydrolase variants of BChE exhibit altered allosteric effects.
The specific residues changed to produce BChE-based cocaine hydrolases included those at the bottom of the catalytic gorge near the 7c-cation binding site (A328) and in the peripheral anionic site (Y332). Catalytic activity against (−)-cocaine was further improved through additional mutations to the oxyanion hole (A199), entrance to the gorge (S287) and non-active site residues participating in H-bonding (F227). Together, these changes result in increased catalytic efficiency against (−)-cocaine and potentially affect the enzyme's interactions with other substrates and ligands. Preliminary results with crude preparations revealed such effects. The following experiments were performed to determine whether there are other allosteric effects on the function of several plant-derived BChE variants.
To rule out artifacts from the plant expression system, WT human plasma-derived (hBChE) was compared with WT plant-derived BChE (pBChE). The Michaelis-Menten constant (KM) of WT hBChE and WT pBChE were determined with the substrate, butyrylthiocholine. Nonlinear regression analysis showed values of 16.8±2.9 μM and 14.6±1.4 μM respectively, similar to previous reports and essentially identical to each other (
Catalytic efficiency of pBChEv2, pBChEv3, and pBChEv4 toward BTC was reduced 100-, 37- and 5-fold, respectively, mostly due to a large reduction in the turnover number but also to small changes in the KM. An even larger drop (˜1000-fold) was observed in the catalytic efficiencies of pBChEv3 and pBChEv4 toward ATC, but not in the case of pBChEv2, which dropped only 3-fold. Of note, the catalytic efficiency of pBChEv5, toward both substrates remained equal to the WT enzyme (Table 1).
Human AChE and BChE exhibit characteristic allosteric effects due to low affinity substrate binding at the “peripheral site” (P-site) positioned near the entrance to the catalytic gorge. Despite the close homology between the two cholinesterases, their substrates exert opposite allosteric effects. AChE is inhibited by ACh concentrations above 5 mM, but BChE is stimulated by similar concentrations of ACh and BCh and their thioester analogues (ATC and BTC,
aWhen b > 1, enzyme is exhibiting substrate activation; when b < 1, enzyme is exhibiting substrate inhibition; if b = 1, the enzyme is following Michaelis-Menten kinetics.
bn and x represent the Hill coefficients. See Scheme 2 (FIG. 6B) and Equation 3 (see Methods section). Positive cooperativity is observed when either n > 1 or x > 1. Negative cooperativity is observed when n < or x < 1.
In striking contrast, hydrolysis of BTC by pBChEv3 and pBChEv4 revealed partial substrate inhibition (
Even more complex enzymatic behavior was exhibited by pBChEv2 and pBChEv5, which differ from each other only by, respectively, an alanine or a glycine residue at position 332 (
Hydrolysis of the smaller substrate ATC also revealed differences between the four variants. In all tested variants, ATC has much weaker inhibitory effect on its hydrolysis. In fact, pBChEv2 and pBChEv5, which were somewhat inhibited by high concentrations of BTC, were clearly activated by high ATC concentrations, as was the case of WT hBChE or WT pBChE (
The complex kinetic behavior of certain variants is reflected by the relatively poor fit between experimental data and the standard model for BChE and AChE's allosteric effects (Equation 2 (see Methods Sections) and Scheme 1,
Including Hill coefficients describing cooperativity (or anticooperativity) into the standard analysis of uncompetitive inhibition provided an adequate model to describe the behavior of the BChE variants against BTC and ATC (Scheme 2,
3. Dynamic Coupling Index (DCI) Analysis Predicts Allosteric Coupling Between the Pentavalent Mutations of pBChEv4 and its Active Site.
While all four variants exhibit novel enzymatic properties, the superior efficiency of cocaine hydrolysis of pBChEv4 compared to other variants (
DCI analysis identified positions that dynamically couple to residues of the catalytic triad, i.e. S198, E325 and H438. According to this analysis, positions exhibiting high DCI values present residues that are dynamically linked to the active site despite being far away from the catalytic residues.
In
The changes in catalytic properties of BChE variants can be partially attributed to the direct allosteric effect of peripheral amino-acid substitution on the catalytic triad suggested by DCI analysis (
4. Dynamic flexibility index (DFI) analysis predicts global flexibility changes upon introduction of mutations.
To further substantiate the hypothesis that the mutation sites are allosterically linked to the catalytic locus and to provide mechanistic insights on how these five mutations lead to changes in enzymatic behavior, the conformational dynamics of the WT and the pBChEv4 variant was explored using a dynamic flexibility index (DFI). DFI computes the fluctuation response of a given position to the perturbations that occur at different parts of the protein using linear response theory, capturing the multi-dimensional effects when the protein structure is displaced out of equilibrium for example when interacting with small molecules or other cellular constituents. DFI allows us to identify and map flexible and rigid positions in the structure. DFI can be considered a measure of the local conformational entropy of a given position within the set of interactions governed by the 3D fold of the protein due to its ability to probe the conformational space of a protein at the residue level.
The DFI values of residues for WT hBChE and pBChEv4 was measured, and the % DFI profiles shows us the flexibility of the proteins in ranking order (
The oligomerization of WT BChE is usually not regarded as affecting the enzymatic properties of the enzyme. However, the sigmoidal nature of the enzyme kinetics observed here in the mutant variants (
With this approach, we can predict global changes in flexibility upon introduction of mutations. The local disruption due to the mutations not only introduce enhanced flexibilities at the mutational sites but can create a global flexibility change in all positions (i.e. change in DFI profile) due to network of interactions. In fact, it appears that the change in the flexibility of one region is compensated by the changes in flexibility of other regions. As could be expected based on the well-documented lack of cooperativity in BChE upon its oligomerization, the DFI profile of the WT hBCHE subunit in monomeric and dimeric form are quite similar (
The DFI analysis suggests that compared to the WT, BChEV4 should have a better propensity to dimerize and that within the mutant dimer there is an increase in flexibility near the gorge (
The aim of this study was to develop a plant-based cocaine-hydrolyzing enzyme toward the generation of anti-cocaine therapeutics (
The mammalian-derived enzyme was shown to be protective of a lethal 180 mg/kg dose of cocaine at a low enzyme dose of approximately 1 mg/kg in mice when delivered 1 minute before cocaine administration. In a separate study, a dose-response curve for seizures was generated using a higher enzyme dose of 10 mg/kg in rats when given 10 minutes prior to cocaine administration. The enzyme was administered five minutes prior to cocaine administration to determine if there was a dose-dependent protection afforded by the enzyme; therefore, both a low (3 mg/kg) and high (10 mg/kg) enzyme dosing regimen was used for this study (
Mice that were pre-treated with the low dose of PCocSH were almost fully protected from a cocaine dose (100 mg/kg) that killed 100% of mice in the vehicle control group (
Mice were then treated with a higher enzyme dose of 10 mg/kg. Mice given this treatment did not exhibit any signs of cocaine-induced seizures or tremors at 100 or 180 mg/kg cocaine, which was 100% lethal in unprotected mice (
To simulate a more clinically relevant scenario, this study determines whether PCocSH provided protection when delivered after cocaine-challenged subjects become symptomatic. To evaluate the potential for PCocSH to rescue mice from cocaine overdose, mice received the LD100 dose of cocaine as determined above (100 mg/kg, i.p.). Immediately upon onset of convulsions, mice were treated by i.v. injection through the tail vein with either low dose (3 mg/kg), high dose (10 mg/kg) of PCocSH or vehicle control (
As expected, all of the mice challenged by cocaine experienced severe effects of cocaine toxicity, except for one control mouse that displayed no severe symptoms and therefore was excluded from the study. The interval between cocaine administration and onset of convulsions was 4.8±0.5 minutes (n=17). One animal from the PCocSH (10 mg/kg) group died later while being restrained prior to receiving further treatment and was subsequently removed from the study.
The 100 mg/kg dose of cocaine was lethal to all 5 control (vehicle-treated) mice that exhibited cocaine-induced convulsions and were euthanized upon moribundity. Strikingly, all of the mice (n=6) that were treated with 3 mg/kg PCocSH soon after the onset of seizures survived (
Similar results of rescue were observed for mice (n=5) treated with the high dose of PCocSH (10 mg/kg) (
In both the low and high enzyme groups, 67% of the mice regained upright posture in 1 minute or less following enzyme treatment, compared to 0% of the mice in the control group (
Another highly problematic issue of cocaine use is addiction-related relapse after a period of abstinence. As the plant-derived enzyme was efficient enough to protect and rescue mice from lethal doses of cocaine, the next investigation evaluated the plant-derived enzyme's potential therapeutic use in managing cocaine addiction-related behavior using the mouse model of reinstatement of extinguished cocaine-CPP (
On the reinstatement test day, mice were pretreated with an i.v. injection of vehicle or PCocSH. The omnibus ANOVA revealed a significant main effect of test day [F(3, 11)=16.8, P<0.001], and interactions between test day and conditioning drug [F(3, 11)=8.195, P<0.001] and test day and enzyme pretreatment given on the reinstatement test day [F(3, 11)=2.98, P <0.05] (
The two-way ANOVA in the PCocSH-treated groups revealed significant main effects of test day [F(3,60)=12.58, P<0.001] and drug [F(1,20)=11.21, P<0.005], as well as a drug by test day interaction [F(3,60)=3.88, P<0.05]. Again, the interaction was due to the saline control group showing only a strong trend toward differences across the 4 tests [F(3,30)=2.91, P=0.051], whereas the cocaine-conditioned group exhibited significant differences across tests [F(3, 30)=12.06, P<0.001]. The cocaine-conditioned group exhibited a significant increase in time spent in the drug-paired compartment compared to baseline during the CPP test [t(11)=11.55, P<0.001] and the extinction test [t(11)=5.92, P<0.001] and a significant decrease in time spent in the drug-paired side during the extinction test compared to the CPP test [t(11)=5.10, P<0.001] (
Previous reports on production of cocaine hydrolase variants of BChE relied on expression using mammalian cell cultures that are notoriously expensive to scale up. It is therefore important to note that the work presented here relied on our use of a cost-effective, sustainable and safe source of recombinant BChE (
a. DNA constructs
Previously, the inventors reported that the full-length human WT BChE gene (UniProt accession number P06276) was optimized for expression in N. benthamiana plants (pBChE). A synthetic gene encoding the A328W/Y332A mutant of pBChE (named here BChEv1) was used as the template for successive rounds of site-directed mutagenesis using the QuickChange method (Stratagene). The resulting mutants are listed in Table 3.
The mutated genes were verified by DNA sequencing. A C-terminal hexahistidine tag was added to the plant-expression optimized variants of BChE. The resulting constructs were then cloned into a deconstructed tobacco mosaic virus (TMV)-based plant expression vector (MagnICON, kind gift of Nomad Inc.) to be used in Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transient expression in N. benthamiana.
b. Transient Recombinant Protein Production in Plants and Purification
An outline of the expression strategy is shown in
All extraction and purification procedures were carried out at 4° C. Large-scale protein preparations were extracted from plant leaf tissue by blending in the presence of 50 mM sodium phosphate, 150 mM sodium metabisulfite, 1 mM EDTA, pH 8.0. Extract was filtered through double-layer miracloth and centrifuged at 22,000×g for 30 min followed by pH adjustment to pH 5.0 and further clarification by ammonium sulfate precipitation. The pellet was resuspended in cold 1X phosphate buffered saline (PBS) and dialyzed overnight against lx PBS, pH 7.4 to remove salts and sodium metabisulfite. The clarified protein preparation was then subjected to sequential affinity chromatography steps with Concanavalin-A-Sepharose followed by procainamide affinity chromatography as previously described.
For PCocSH, the gene was codon-optimized for plant expression and relevant side-directed mutations as made. The gene was then cloned into a transient plant expression vector system such as magnICON vector system based on deconstructed tobacco mosaic virus. This system was transformed into Agrobacteria tumefaciens. The PCocSH enzyme was transiently expressed in WT Nicotiana benthamiana plants. Specifically, to infiltrate the bacteria into the intercellular spaces of the leaf tissue, entire plants were submerged in A. tumefaciens solution, and a vacuum was applied. (
The recombinant PCocSH was extracted as described previously. Briefly, following infiltration, plants were returned to the growth chamber or greenhouse until the day post-inoculation that results in peak recombinant protein expression (established during small-scale time course experiments). On the peak expression day, leaf tissue was homogenized, and total soluble proteins was filtered and clarified. PCocSH was purified by sequential Concanovalin A and procainamide purification steps. Following dialysis into a suitable buffer, the purified PCocSH product can be stored for several years at 4° C. and used for testing.
Specifically, the preparation was subject to ConA purification and was eluted with five stepwise increasing concentrations of methyl-a-D-mannopyranoside (0.05 M, 0.1 M, 0.2 M, 0.5 M, and 1 M). Eluates showing similar degrees of purity were pooled, concentrated, and dialyzed against 20 mM sodium phosphate buffer, pH 7.5. The partially-purified PCocSH was then subject to final polishing using batch procainamide (Sigma, catalogue no. P2240) affinity chromatography to remove any remaining contaminants. Proteins were released by stepwise elution as follows: 0.05 M NaCl, 0.5 M NaCl, 1 M NaCl, 1 M NaCl and 0.2 M Procainamide HCl, 1 M NaCl and 0.3 M Procainamide HCl. Eluates were dialyzed against PBS, pH 7.4 and eluates of similar purity were pooled and concentrated. After concentration, 0.02% sodium azide (NaN3) was added to prevent unwanted organismal growth during storage which was subsequently dialyzed out against PBS, pH 7.4 prior to use for animal experiments.
c. Enzymatic Assays
To evaluate cocaine hydrolysis, a sensitive radiometric assay was used. Briefly, [3H](−)-cocaine labeled on the benzene ring (50 Ci/mmol), purchased from PerkinElmer Life Sciences (Boston, Mass.), was used as a substrate with varying concentrations of (−)-cocaine. In the presence of enzyme this reaction proceeded at room temperature (25° C.) until stopped by the addition of 0.02 M HCl. Any neutralized, liberated, labeled benzoic acid was then extracted with a toluene-based fluor and measured by scintillation counting. On the other hand, the substrate would fractionate into the aqueous phase and would not generate scintillation. Enzyme concentrations in the reaction mix were 800 ng/100 μL (1.21×10−1 μM) for WT pBChE and 4 ng/100 μL (6.06×10−4 μM) for pBChEv4.
Choline ester hydrolysis activity was evaluated by a modified Ellman assay8,63,64. Activity was measured using either butyrylthiocholine iodide (BTC, Sigma) or acetylthiocholine iodide (ATC, Sigma) at 30° C. in a Spectramax 190 spectrophotometer (Molecular Devices). Total soluble protein levels were determined by the Bradford protein assay (Bio-Rad Protein Assay Reagent, Bio-Rad). The assay was conducted in 96-well plate format over varying concentrations of BTC or ATC in final well volume of 200 μL. To account for product formed by substrate self-hydrolysis, initial velocity of non-enzymatic hydrolysis was subtracted from initial velocity of the matched enzyme-catalyzed reactions and reaction rates were then plotted as a function of substrate concentration.
Data were plotted using GraphPad Prism software, which was also used to fit the data by non-linear regression. The following models were fitted.
For Michaelis-Menten kinetics we used Equation (1)
For substrate inhibition/activation, we used Equation (2), following the model in Scheme 1 (
The Radić model ascribes the allosteric effect of substrate binding at the peripheral binding site that causes a change in the catalytic rate bkcat. When b>1 we encounter substrate activation (WT BChE, see below), when b<1 we encounter substrate inhibition and when b=1 we have a Michaelian enzyme (Equation 1). K6ss is the dissociation constant of the peripheral site.
Velocity vs substrate concentration data of some of the BChE variants described here fitted well to a model initially suggested by LiCata and Allewell66 for aspartate transcarbamylase (Scheme 2,
The Hill coefficients n and x need not be integers. Values greater than one describe cooperativity, while values of less than one describe anti-cooperativity. The parameters b and Kss function in the same way as in Equation (2).
d. Inhibition
Inhibition studies were conducted with the OPs paraoxon (diethyl (4-nitrophenyl) phosphate) and iso-OMPA (N [bis(propan 2 ylamino)phosphoryloxy-(propan 2 ylamino) phosphoryl]propan 2-amine), the carbamate neostigmine bromide ([3 (dimethylcarbamoyloxy) phenyl]-trimethylazanium;bromide), or the reversible bisquaternary inhibitor BW284c51 (BW, [4 [5 [4-[dimethyl(prop-2-enyl)azaniumyl]phenyl]-3-oxopentyl]phenyl]-dimethyl-prop-2-enylazanium; dibromide). The four inhibitors were purchased from Sigma (St Louis, Mo.).
Preparations of BChE and variants thereof were incubated in 96-well plate format with indicated concentrations of the inhibitors for 30 min at room temperature followed by activity measurements based on modified Ellman assay using 1 mM BTC as the substrate. IC50 values were determined by non-linear regression (GraphPad Prism) fit according to Equation (4).
The inhibition rate constant (ki) of pBChEV4 treated with paraoxon was determined as previously described.
Inhibition curves were statistically analyzed by the extra sum-of-squares F test (GraphPad Prism) together and were found to be significantly different from each other. Following up with individual comparisons to WT pBChE revealed statistical significance in all except the following: paraoxon inhibition of WT pBChE vs WT hBChE, Iso-OMPA inhibition of WT pBChE vs pBChEV4, and neostigmine inhibition of WT pBChE vs pBChEV3.
e. Dynamic Flexibility Index (DFI) analysis
Dynamic flexibility index (DFI) metric is based on the Perturbation Response Scanning method (PRS) that couples covariance matrix of residue displacement with linear response theory (LRT).
PRS was originally based on the Elastic Network Model (ENM). In ENM, protein is viewed as an elastic network, in which each amino acid is represented by C-alpha position, and a harmonic interaction is assigned to pairs of amino-acids within a specified cutoff distance. Simply put, in the WT BChE, two residues that are interacting with each other are represented by a harmonic interaction with the same spring constant (lower left in
A random Brownian kick was applied in PRS as a perturbation to a single residue in the chain one at a time, sequentially. This perturbation mimics the external forces exerted on the protein through interactions with another protein, another biological macromolecule or small molecule ligand, in silico. The perturbation cascades through the residue interaction network and may introduce conformational changes in the protein. Then, we compute the response fluctuation profile of all other residues to the perturbation as linear response using Equation (5) where F is a unit random force on selected residues, H-1 is the inverse of the Hessian matrix and AR is the positional displacements of the N residues of the protein in three dimensions.
The response fluctuation profile is used to calculate the DFI scores using Equation (6), where [ΔR{circumflex over ( )}j]_i is the response fluctuation amplitude of position i, upon perturbing position j. Thus, the DFI of position i is the total fluctuation response of position i upon perturbing all positions in the chain one at a time. The DFI value for each position is normalized to the overall intrinsic flexibility of the protein chain. High and low DFI scores could be interpreted as dynamically flexible sites and rigid (hinge) sites, respectively. The DFI scores can be converted into percentile ranking scores, namely % DFI.
f. Dynamic Coupling Index (DCI) Analysis
The position-specific metric DCI uses PRS methodology to identify the residues that are allosterically linked to functionally critical positions through residue fluctuation dynamics for a given protein. The index DCI computes whether this position exhibits a higher fluctuation response to a perturbation that occurred at functionally critical sites (e.g. binding sites or catalytic site) compared to the perturbations at the other sites of the chain. It is measured as the ratio of average fluctuation responses of a given residue j upon perturbations of functionally critical sites to the average response of residue j upon perturbations placed on all other residues using
In Equation (7), |ΔRj|i is the response fluctuation profile of residue j upon perturbation of residue i. The numerator is the average mean square fluctuation response obtained over the perturbation of the functionally critical residues Nfunctional; the denominator is the average mean square fluctuation response over all residues.
These DCI profiles can also be converted into rank profiles, which are labeled as % DCI profiles. The positions that have higher % DCI values are functionally important residues that are not linked to the functional residues by direct covalent bonds or non-covalent interactions (e.g. hydrogen bonding and van der Waals interactions), but are allosterically communicating over longer distances (i.e. allosteric dynamic coupling) via residues that form extensive interaction networks.
g. SDS-PAGE and Western Blot
Plant-derived protein preparations were resolved by SDS-PAGE on 8% polyacrylamide gels followed by staining with Pierce Silver Stain Kit (Thermoscientific). In parallel, protein was transferred to nitrocellulose membrane and decorated with rabbit polyclonal anti-hBChE antibodies (kindly provided by Dr. Oksana Lockridge) and anti-rabbit IgG-Horse Radish Peroxidase secondary antibodies (Santa Cruz Biotechnology) followed by chemiluminescence analysis using western blotting luminol reagent (Santa Cruz Biotechnology).
h. Size Exclusion HPLC
SEC-HPLC fractionation of purified preparations of pBChEV4 was carried out as previously described using Alliance HPLC (Waters) with a Shodex KW-803 column (8×300 mm, Kawasaki) 8. All samples were run in filtered, degassed mobile phase buffer (20 mM Na2HPO4/NaH2PO4, pH 8.0, 200 mM NaCl, 0.04% NaN3) at a flow rate of 0.5 mL/min. Molecular mass standards used were blue dextran (2000 kDa) and the proteins β-amylase (200 kDa), bovine serum albumin (66 kDa) and carbonic anhydrase (29 kDa). Fractions were collected and analyzed for cholinesterase activity by the modified Ellman assay.
i. Animals and Intravenous Enzyme and Intraperitoneal Drug Administration
Black C57BL/6 male mice weighing 25-30 g at the start of the experiment were housed 5 mice per cage with free access to food and water in a temperature-controlled colony room with a reversed 12-h light:dark cycle and allowed at least one week to acclimate upon arrival to the housing facility.
All animal experiments were performed in accordance to protocols approved by the Institutional Care and Use Committee of Arizona State University. Moribund animals, and all animals by the end of the observation period were euthanized by CO2 asphyxiation followed by a secondary method of euthanasia (cervical dislocation). Moribundity was defined as prolonged seizures (≥120 s), or more than two shorter seizures within 2 minutes.
For intravenous (i.v.) injections of highly purified PCocSH or vehicle control (PBS, pH 7.4), mice were placed in a commercial mouse restrainer. The exposed tail was cleaned with an alcohol wipe and a U-100 insulin syringe (28G1/2) needle (Becton Dickinson) was used for injection into one of the tail veins. The i.v. injection volume did not exceed 5 μL/g body weight. The (−)-cocaine hydrolchloride (RTI International Triangle Park, N.C., USA) was dissolved in sterile 0.9% saline and filtered through a 0.2 μm membrane. Mice were released from the restraint as soon as the injection was complete and sterile gauze and pressure were applied to the injection site to stop any bleeding. For intraperitoneally (i.p.) injections of cocaine or vehicle (0.9% saline), the same kind of syringe as described above was used. Injection volume did not exceed 10 μL/g mouse.
j. Protection Experiment
Vehicle control (1× PBS, pH 7.4) or purified PCocSH (3 or 10 mg/kg) was administered i.v. (tail) 5 minutes before i.p. administration of varying doses of (−)-cocaine. The presence or absence of convulsions, lethality, and general observations were recorded for 60 minutes after cocaine administration or, if applicable, until euthanasia criteria were met. First, the dose response to cocaine in absence of any enzyme protection was tested using the following cocaine doses: 0, 30, 55, 75 and 100 mg/kg. Higher varying doses of cocaine (100, 180, 325, 585, and 1055 mg/kg) were needed to observe toxicity when PCocSH (3 or 10 mg/kg) was administered 5 minutes prior. For each experimental group n=6 animals at the beginning of the experiment.
k. Rescue from Acute Cocaine Toxicity
Vehicle control (1× PBS, pH 7.4) or purified PCocSH (3 or 10 mg/kg) was administered i.v. (tail) 5 minutes before i.p. administration of varying doses of (−)-cocaine. The presence or absence of convulsions, lethality, and general observations were recorded for 60 minutes after cocaine administration or, if applicable, until euthanasia criteria were met. First, the dose response to cocaine in absence of any enzyme protection was tested using the following cocaine doses: 0, 30, 55, 75 and 100 mg/kg. Higher varying doses of cocaine (100, 180, 325, 585, and 1055 mg/kg) were needed to observe toxicity when PCocSH (3 or 10 mg/kg) was administered 5 minutes prior. For each experimental group n=6 animals at the beginning of the experiment.
l. Conditioned Place Preference
Conditioned place preference (CPP) experiments were conducted using Plexiglas two-compartment chambers. Each chamber contained a removable partition that separated the chamber into two equal-sized compartments, each measuring 35 cm×24 cm×31 cm high. One compartment had a wire 1×1 cm grid floor and alternating black and white vertical stripes (2 cm wide) on the walls. The other had a parallel bar floor (5 mm diameter) and alternating black and white horizontal stripes (2 cm wide) on the walls. Both compartments had corncob bedding beneath the floors.
The testing room was dimly lit with two overhead lamps, each containing a 25 W light bulb. A camera (Panasonic WV-CP284, color CCTV, Suzhou, China) was mounted 101 cm above the center of the apparatus to record the sessions. A WinTV 350 personal video recorder (Hauppage, N.J., USA) captured the live video and encoded it to MPEG streams. A modified version of TopScan Software (Clever Sys., Inc. Reston, Va., USA) tracked the animal's body parts (e.g., nose, head, center of body, forepaws, base of tail, etc.) to estimate the position of the whole body when some parts were not in view in order to yield measures of time spent in each compartment.
Habituation day (Day 1): Mice were transported to the conditioning room and allowed free excess to both sides of the apparatus for 10 minutes to habituate them to the novel environment.
Pre-conditioning/baseline test (Day 2): Initial baseline side preference was assessed by allowing mice to freely explore both sides of the chamber without a middle partition for 15 minutes with locomotor activity and time spent in each compartment being recorded. Time spent on each side of the chamber was used to determine side preference for each mouse. During subsequent conditioning, a biased design was used such that the drug-paired compartment was each animal's least preferred side. Using baseline data, mice were divided into two drug groups that received either saline (controls) or cocaine prior to being confined to their initially nonpreferred side, with specific side preference equally distributed among the groups.
Conditioning phase (Days 3-10): Sessions were held at the same time each day for eight consecutive days. On odd numbered conditioning days, half of the mice in each group received saline and were placed into the non-drug-paired compartment for 30 min and on even numbered conditioning days these mice received their assigned drug [either saline or cocaine (10 mg/kg, i.p.)] and were placed into the drug-paired compartment for 30 minutes. The other half of the mice underwent the same procedure in the opposite order, such that they received their assigned drug prior to placement into the drug-paired compartment on odd numbered days and saline prior to placement into the non-drug-paired compartment on even numbered days.
CPP test (Day 13): Three days after the last conditioning session, mice were tested for the expression of CPP as previously done for the pre-conditioning test. The 72-hour interval between the last conditioning day and the test eliminated residual cocaine and recovery influences and allowed the consolidation of long-term memory of drug reward.
Extinction (Days 14-27): In order to extinguish cocaine-CPP, mice received repeated exposures to the drug-paired compartment without cocaine while also receiving exposure to the non-drug-paired compartment on alternate days to avoid relative novelty on the test day. Extinction sessions occurred at the same time of day across fourteen consecutive days. Mice received a saline injection prior to each session and were subsequently placed into the appropriate compartment for 20 minutes.
Post-extinction test (Day 28): To determine extinction of cocaine-CPP, mice were tested identically to the previous pre-conditioning and CPP tests.
Cocaine-induced reinstatement test (Day 29): On the day following the post-extinction test, mice were assessed for cocaine-induced reinstatement of CPP with and without treatment with PCocSH. To this end, mice were placed into a restrainer and injected i.v. through the tail vein with saline or enzyme at a 3 mg/kg dose at a volume of 5 μg body weight. Five minutes later, a priming injection of cocaine (10 mg/kg) or saline was administered (i.p.) at a volume of 10 μg body weight. The number of mice per group were as follows: vehicle control (no PCocSH) with vehicle control (no cocaine) (n=9), vehicle control (no PCocSH) with cocaine (n=10), PCocSH with vehicle control (no cocaine) (n=12), and PCocSH with cocaine (n=12). After the priming injection, the animals were immediately placed into the apparatus for 15 minutes with unrestricted access to both compartments. Locomotor activity and time spent in the cocaine- and saline-paired compartments were recorded.
m. Statistical Analysis
For protection and rescue experiments, statistical analyses were carried out using the GraphPad Prism software. Log-rank (Mantel-Cox) test was used to determine significance of the difference between treatment and control group survival and recovery curves. Data from the behavioral toxicity studies (percentage of mice showing lethality) were analyzed with two-tailed Fisher's exact probability test. The criterion for significance was set at p<0.05.
For CPP experiments, a mixed factor ANOVA with drug and enzyme treatments as between subjects factors and test day (baseline, CPP, extinction, reinstatement) as a repeated measure was performed. Interactions were further analyzed using smaller ANOVAs and paired-sample t-tests with Bonferroni correction. In addition, planned paired-samples t-tests between the extinction and reinstatement test days were performed to test the hypothesis that PCocSH would prevent cocaine-primed reinstatement.
Cyanovirin and Associated Constructs. Biochemistry 54, 6951-6960, doi:10.1021/acs.biochem.5b00635 (2015).
Between Albumin-Fused Mutated Butyrylcholinesterase and Intravenously Administered Cocaine in Recreational Cocaine Users. J Clin Psychopharmacol 35(4):396-405.
This application claims the benefit of and priority to U.S. provisional patent application 62/726,924, filed Sep. 4, 2018, the entirety of the disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by this reference.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62726924 | Sep 2018 | US |