Plastic retorable container system having a closure with an improved conformable liner

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6702133
  • Patent Number
    6,702,133
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, October 12, 2000
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, March 9, 2004
    20 years ago
Abstract
A retortable all-plastic closure having a generally circular top portion and a generally cylindrical downwardly depending skirt. The top portion has upper and lower surfaces. The lower surface of the top portion forms a circumferentially extending ridge that projects downwardly. The ridge forms a first structural wall. A second structural wall is formed in the top portion adjacent the first wall. A flexible liner made from a thermoplastic elastomer is bonded to the lower surface. The portion of the liner covering the first structural wall forms a downwardly extending liner wall. The portion of the liner covering the second structural wall forms a top liner wall. The diameter of the downwardly extending liner wall is greater than the diameter of the top of the container neck inner wall to which the closure is applied so that the container neck compresses substantially the entirety of the downwardly projecting liner wall. In addition, the diameter of top liner wall is greater than the uppermost portion of the container neck so that the top liner wall is also compressed. Grooves are formed in the closure top portion opposite the ridge so as to minimize the thickness gradient in the top portion. A network of ribs are formed in the grooves.
Description




FIELD OF THE INVENTION




The current invention is directed to a closure for a container. More specifically, the current invention is directed to a plastic closure having a seal adapted to withstand retorting.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




Certain beverages and food stuffs, for example, liquid pediatric nutritional products, must be sterilized after being hermetically sealed in the containers in which they will ultimately be sold. Sterilization is typically accomplished by a retorting process in which the container is heated to relatively high temperatures, such as 260° F. or above. Although steam is used to subject the container to external pressurization during retorting in order to reduce the effects of the increased internal pressure generated by the heating, there is nevertheless a pressure imbalance that imposes additional forces on the container and closure. Thus, the closures for such containers, which are typically referred to as “retortable closures,” must be capable of maintaining a hermetic seal when subjected to the temperatures and pressures associated with retorting.




Although closures for many applications, such as carbonated beverages, are made entirely from plastic, in the past, closures for retortable containers were made from metal or, more recently, composites of metal and plastic, such as polypropylene. Such a composite retortable closure is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 4,813,561 (Ochs). In such closures, sealing between the closure and container neck is provided by a bead of sealant, such as plastisol, applied to the metallic portion of the closure. The use of metal in a retortable closure was thought necessary because the high temperatures associated with retorting weakens and distorts plastic. It was thought that unless metal was used to stiffen and stabilize the closure, especially the portion supporting the sealant, the high temperatures and pressure resulting from retorting would result in loss of the hermetic seal.




Consequently, it would be desirable to provide a retortable plastic closure with improved sealing capability.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




It is an object of the current invention to provide a retortable plastic closure, especially an all-plastic retortable closure. This and other objects is accomplished in a retortable container system, comprising (i) a container having a neck portion forming an approximately cylindrical inner wall, the upper portion of the inner wall having a diameter d


2


, (ii) a closure, the closure comprising (i) a generally circular plastic top portion having upper and lower surfaces, and (ii) a generally cylindrical plastic skirt portion extending downwardly from the top portion, the skirt portion having means for securing the closure to the container neck portion, (iii) a seal for sealing the closure to the container. The seal comprises a (i) circumferentially extending ridge integrally formed in the plastic top portion so as to project downwardly from the lower surface thereof, the ridge forming a first structural wall extending downwardly from the lower surface of the plastic top portion, and (ii) a flexible liner bonded to the lower surface of the plastic top portion, a first portion of the flexible liner covering at least the first structural wall so as to form a downwardly extending liner wall, the liner wall having a diameter that is greater than the diameter of the container neck inner wall upper portion, whereby the container neck inner wall compresses the liner wall when the closure is applied to the container.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is an elevation of a closure according to the current invention as applied to a conventional retortable plastic container.





FIG. 2

is a plan view of the closure according to the current invention shown in FIG.


1


.





FIG. 3

is a cross-section taken along line III—III shown in FIG.


2


.





FIG. 4

is an isometric view of a portion of a cross-section of a closure according to the current invention showing the stiffening ribs.





FIG. 5

is a detailed view of a portion of a cross-section of the closure shown in

FIGS. 2 and 3

.





FIG. 6

is a detailed view of a portion of a longitudinal cross-section through the neck portion of the container shown in FIG.


1


.





FIG. 7

is a detailed view of a cross-section of the closure shown in

FIGS. 2 and 3

after installation on a container.











DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT




A retortable plastic closure


2


according to the current invention is shown applied to a conventional retortable plastic container


60


in FIG.


1


. As shown in

FIGS. 2 and 3

, the closure


2


is comprised of a circular plastic top portion


4


, having upper and lower surfaces


5


and


7


, respectively, and a cylindrical skirt


6


extending downwardly from the top portion and integrally formed with it. Axially extending ribs


12


, which aid gripping of the closure, are circumferentially distributed around the skirt


6


. As is conventional, a thread


50


is formed in the inner wall of the skirt portion


6


that mates with the thread


51


formed on the outer wall of the neck portion


40


of the conventional retortable container, shown in FIG.


6


. Although threads are used in the preferred embodiment, those skilled in the art will recognize that other methods of securing the closure to the container may also be utilized, such as a snap-on configuration.




As shown in

FIG. 6

, the neck


40


of the container


60


forms an approximately cylindrical inner wall


42


that is preferably slightly conical so as to be oriented at an angle A


2


to the container axis that, for example, may be about 8°, so that the neck inner wall tapers outwardly (i.e., become thicker) as it extends downwardly. The topmost portion


45


of the straight section of the inner wall


42


has a diameter d


2


, while the uppermost portion


44


of the container neck


40


is formed by a convex segment, the top of which has a diameter d


3


.




Although not necessary for the practice of the current invention, as is conventional, a tamper evident band


10


may be formed on the lower portion of the skirt


6


and may include ratchet teeth that engage mating ratchet teeth formed in the container neck, such as disclosed in the aforementioned U.S. Pat. No. 4,813,561, hereby incorporated by reference herein.




Preferably, the top portion


4


, skirt


6


, and tamper evident band


10


are integrally formed by injection molding a plastic, such as polypropylene. The polypropylene is of a grade having a sufficiently high heat distortion temperature, typically referred to as HDT, so as to be able to withstand retorting, such as SV 954 grade polypropylene available from Montell U.S.A. Inc. of Wilmington, Del. In the preferred embodiment, the closure is made entirely of plastic and no metal is used to strengthen the top portion


4


or skirt


6


.




A number of half-moon shaped openings


18


are formed in the periphery of the top portion


4


. The openings


18


allow the threaded portions of the closure and container neck to be washed after the closure


2


has been secured to the container, for example, to remove fluid that spilled onto the threaded portions during filling and capping.




According to one important aspect of the current invention, a circumferentially extending ridge


24


is integrally formed in the lower surface


7


of the top portion


4


. The ridge


24


serves to resist radially inward pressure resulting from compression of a liner


20


by the container neck, as discussed below. Preferably, the ridge


24


projects downwardly from the adjacent portions of the lower surface


7


by at least about 0.075 inch (1.9 mm).




As shown best in

FIG. 5

, the inner surface of the ridge


24


forms a circumferentially extending wall


23


that is oriented at an angle C to the axis of the closure


2


that is at least about 45°, and preferably about 60°. The angling of the wall


23


allows the liner material to flow over the lower surface


7


during compression molding, as discussed below. The outer surface of the ridge


24


forms a circumferentially extending structural wall


25


that is preferably disposed an at angle A


0


to the axis of the closure


2


so that the wall tapers inwardly as it extends downwardly. Preferably, the angle A


0


is at least about 5° but not more than about 15° greater than the angle A


2


of the container neck inner wall


42


. Most preferably, A


0


is about 7° greater than A


2


. In one embodiment of the invention, the angle A


0


is approximately 15° and the angle A


2


is about 8°. A circumferentially extending structural wall


26


is also integrally formed in the lower surface


7


disposed adjacent the ridge wall


25


. Preferably, the wall


26


is oriented approximately radially. Finally, an axially oriented, circumferentially extending structural wall


29


is formed adjacent the wall


26


.




If no additional modifications are made to the design, the presence of the ridge


24


would increase the difference between the thick and thin portions of the top portion


4


. In one particular embodiment of the invention, the thickness of the central panel portion of the top portion


4


is about 0.06 inch (1.5 mm) and the ridge


24


projects downwardly about 0.077 inch (2.0 mm). This would result in a thickness in the ridge area of approximately 0.137 inch (3.5 mm) so that the ratio of the maximum to minimum thickness of the top portion was almost 2.3. Such a nonuniform thickness profile can result in temperature gradients that cause distortion of the closure


2


as it cools following injection molding, creating sink marks.




Therefore, in a preferred embodiment of the invention, a circumferentially extending groove


14


is formed in the upper surface


5


of the top portion


4


opposite the ridge


24


so that the distance between the bottom of the groove and the surface of the ridge defines the thickness of the top portion in the vicinity of the ridge, thereby resulting in a more uniform thickness throughout the top portion. For example, in the particular embodiment discussed above, the depth of the groove


14


is about 0.047 inch, so that the thickness of the top portion


4


in the vicinity of the ridge


24


is only 0.090 inch (2.29 mm). This reduces the maximum to minimum thickness ratio in the top portion


4


to about 1.5 and prevents distortion of the closure


2


following injection molding.




Unfortunately, the presence of the groove


14


can also reduce the strength of the closure


2


, especially in light of the presence of the washing openings


18


nearby. Thus, in a preferred embodiment of the invention, a network of ribs


16


and


17


are integrally formed within the groove


14


, as shown best in

FIGS. 2 and 4

. Preferably a first portion


17


of the ribs are distributed around the circumference of the groove


14


at 45° intervals and extend in the approximately radial direction. A second portion


16


of the ribs extend at an angle B to the radial direction so as to form crosses. Preferably, the angle B is about 20° to 30°.




According to the invention, a flexible sealing liner


20


is attached to the lower surface


7


of the top portion


4


. The liner


20


is made from a flexible plastic material, preferably a conventional thermoplastic elastomer, such as Kraton™, developed by Shell Chemical Company and available from GLS Corporation's Thermoplastic Elastomers Division. Most preferably, the liner


20


is a thermoplastic elastomer with oxygen barrier properties, such as Trefsin™, available from Advanced Polymer Systems LP of Akron, Ohio, or Polyliner™, available from D.S. Chemie of Germany.




Preferably, the liner


20


is formed by extruding a bead of thermoplastic elastomer onto the center of the top portion lower surface


7


and then compression molding it so as to form a liner bonded to the portion of the lower surface


7


encompassed by the axially extending wall


29


. Preferably, the liner


20


is compression molded so as to have a thickness of about 0.030 inches (0.76 mm) in the central portion of the lower surface


7


and about 0.040 inches (1 mm) in the vicinity of the ridge


24


—that is, the portion of the liner


20


covering the ridge


24


should be about ⅓ thicker than the central portion of the liner in order to minimize the amount of liner material utilized. Although additional increases in the thickness differential by further thinning of the central portion of the liner


20


would reduce material usage even more, it may require the application of excessively large pressures by the punch during compression molding and, therefore, is preferably avoided.




As shown best in

FIG. 5

, the liner


20


covers the entirety of the ridge


24


formed in the lower surface


7


, including the inner ridge wall


23


and the outer ridge wall


25


. The portion of the liner


20


covering the inner ridge wall


23


forms a downwardly extending liner inner wall. The portion of the liner


20


covering the outer ridge wall


25


forms a circumferentially extending and downwardly projecting outer liner wall


27


. Preferably, the length of the downwardly projecting wall is at least about 0.075 inch (1.9 mm) long. Preferably, the downwardly projecting liner wall


27


is oriented at an angle A


1


that approximately matches the angle A


0


of the structural wall so that the liner wall tapers inwardly as it extends downwardly to a lowermost portion


41


. Thus, the angle A


1


to is greater than the angle A


2


of the container neck wall


42


, preferably by at least about 5° and more preferably by at least about 7° but not more than about 15°. In addition, the diameter D


2


of the uppermost portion


47


of the downwardly projecting liner wall


27


is greater than the diameter d


2


of the upper portion of the container neck wall


42


.




Since the diameter D


2


of the upper liner wall is greater than the diameter d


2


of the upper neck wall, as the closure


2


is threaded onto the container neck


40


, the upper portion


47


of the liner wall


27


will initially make line contact with the neck wall


42


. Under the action of the threads, further rotation of the closure


2


drives it downward onto the container neck


40


. This causes the liner


20


to compress so that the upper surface


47


of the liner wall


27


conforms to the upper portion of the neck inner wall, resulting in surface contact between the liner wall


27


and the container neck inner wall


42


at the upper portion of the liner wall. As the closure


2


is tightened further onto the container neck


40


, the surface of the liner wall


27


conforming to the neck outer wall


42


spreads downward so that middle surface of the liner wall then conforms to the neck wall. Preferably, this is followed by the lower portion


41


conforming to the container neck inner wall


42


when the closure


2


is fully tightened onto the container neck. Thus, the diameter D


2


is sufficiently greater than d


2


so that, despite the fact that A


1


is greater than A


2


, the compression of the liner


20


will eventually cause a major portion, and most preferably the entirety, of the downwardly projecting liner wall


27


to conform to the surface of the neck outer wall


42


. Preferably, the diameter D


2


of the top of the liner wall


27


is at least about 0.010 inches (0.25 mm) greater than the diameter d


2


at the top of the container neck wall. In one embodiment of the invention, D


2


is about 0.014 inch (0.36 mm) greater than d


2


.




Causing the compression of the liner


20


to spread downward as described above causes the majority of elastic deformation or flow of the liner to occur downwardly, thereby maximizing the compression of the liner that results from a given magnitude of torque applied to the closure


2


—that is, the amount of compression that is ultimately achieved is greater than it would have been if the initial contact had been along the entire surface of the liner wall


27


so that further compression required the liner to flow elastically not only downwardly, but upwardly, where there is greater resistance to such elastic flow.




As also shown in

FIG. 5

, the portion of the liner


20


covering the radially extending wall


26


, which is adjacent the downwardly extending liner wall


27


, forms a radially extending upper liner wall


28


. Since the liner


20


preferably extends to the axial wall


29


of the top portion, the diameter of the periphery of liner wall


28


is also D


3


. Preferably, D


3


is greater than the diameter d


3


of the top of the uppermost portion


44


of the container neck


40


so as to ensure that a major portion, and preferably, substantially the entirety, of the upper liner wall


28


is compressed by, and conforms to, the surface of the uppermost portion


44


of the container neck


40


when the closure is threaded onto the neck.




As shown in

FIG. 7

, preferably, when the closure


2


of the current invention is threaded onto the container neck


40


, substantially the entirety of the liner downwardly projecting wall


27


is compressed radially inward by the upper portion of the neck inner wall


42


. In addition, substantially the entirety of the liner upper wall


28


is compressed axially upward by the uppermost portion


44


of the container neck


40


. (Note that the uncompressed location of the liner walls


27


and


28


is shown by the dashed line in

FIG. 7.

) This compression ensures that flexible liner


20


creates sealing contact over a large surface so as to provide a robust hermetic seal between the closure


2


and the container neck


40


. The compression also causes a portion


21


of the liner


20


to extrude outward through the gap formed between the upper portion of the container neck outer wall


43


and the closure axial wall


29


, as also shown in FIG.


7


. This provides further sealing contact between the container neck


42


and the closure


2


. Thus, a seal is provided not only along the uppermost portion


44


of the container neck


40


but also along the upper portion of its outer wall


43


.




As a result of the extensive and robust sealing discussed above, and despite the fact that the closure


2


is preferably made entirely of plastic and is, therefore, subject to distortion and weakening during retorting, retorting will not result in a failure of the hermetic seal. Rather, such distortion will be accommodated by variation in the compression to which the liner


20


is subjected along both its downwardly projecting wall


27


and its upper wall


28


.




Although the present invention has been illustrated in a system in which an outward facing liner wall contacts and conforms to the inner container neck wall, the invention could also be practiced by arranging the ridge on a larger diameter so that the inner facing liner wall contacted and conformed to the outer wall of the container neck. Thus, the present invention may be embodied in other specific forms without departing from the spirit or essential attributes thereof and, accordingly, reference should be made to the appended claims, rather than to the foregoing specification, as indicating the scope of the invention.



Claims
  • 1. A retortable container system, comprising:a) a container having a neck portion forming an inner wall tapering radially outwardly as it extends upwardly so as to be inclined at an angle (A2) to the axial direction, said wall having an upper portion having a diameter (d2); b) a closure, said closure comprising (i) a generally circular plastic top portion having upper and lower surfaces, and (ii) a generally cylindrical plastic skirt portion extending downwardly from said top portion, said skirt portion having means for securing said closure to said container neck portion; c) a seal for sealing said closure to said container, said seal comprising (i) a circumferentially extending ridge integrally formed in said plastic top portion so as to project downwardly from said lower surface thereof, said ridge forming a first structural wall extending downwardly from said lower surface of said plastic top portion and tapering radially inwardly as it extends downwardly so as to be inclined to the axial direction, and (ii) a flexible liner bonded to said lower surface of said plastic top portion for compression by said container neck inner wall, a first portion of said flexible liner covering at least said first structural wall so as to form a downwardly extending liner wall having an outer diameter (D2) and tapering radially inwardly as it extends downwardly so as to be inclined at an angle (A1) to the axial direction, prior to compression of said liner by said container neck said liner wall angle (A1) being sufficiently greater than said neck inner wall angle (A2) and said liner wall outer diameter (D2) being sufficiently greater than said diameter (d2) of said container neck wall so that said container neck wall initially contacts said liner wall at said uppermost portion thereof and compression of said liner wall as said closure is tightened onto said container proceeds progressively downward.
  • 2. The container system according to claim 1, whereby said diameter (D2) of said liner wall upper portion is sufficiently greater than said diameter (d2) of said container neck wall so that substantially the entirety of said liner wall is compressed by and conforms to said container neck wall when said closure is applied to said container.
  • 3. The container system according to claim 1, wherein said seal further comprises an approximately circumferentially extending second structural wall integrally formed in said plastic top portion adjacent said first structural wall, a second portion of said flexible liner covering at least a portion of said second structural wall so as to form a second liner wall, whereby an uppermost portion of said container neck compresses said second liner wall when said closure is applied to said container.
  • 4. The container system according to claim 3, wherein said seal further comprises an approximately circumferentially extending third structural wall integrally formed in said plastic top portion adjacent said second structural wall and disposed radially outward therefrom, said liner extending radially outward from said first structural wall to said third structural wall.
  • 5. The container system according to claim 1, wherein said plastic top portion forms a circumferentially extending groove in said upper surface thereof, said groove disposed opposite said ridge, whereby the distance between said groove and said ridge define a thickness of said plastic top portion.
  • 6. The container system according to claim 5, wherein said plastic top portion forms a plurality of ribs disposed in said groove.
  • 7. The container system according to claim 6, wherein a first portion of said ribs extend in a first direction and a second portion of said ribs extend in a second direction so as to form a network of ribs.
  • 8. The container system according to claim 1, wherein said angle (A2) is about 8°.
  • 9. The container system according to claim 1, wherein said liner wall angle (A1) is at least about 5° greater than said container neck wall angle (A2).
  • 10. The container system according to claim 1, wherein said liner is formed from a thermoplastic elastomer.
  • 11. A retortable container system, comprising:a) a container having a neck portion forming an inner wall tapering radially outwardly as it extends upwardly so as to be inclined at an angle (A2) to the axial direction, said wall having an upper portion; b) a closure, said closure comprising (i) a generally circular plastic top portion having upper and lower surfaces, (ii) a generally cylindrical plastic skirt portion extending downwardly from said top portion, and (iii) a circumferentially extending ridge integrally formed in said plastic top portion so as to project downwardly from said lower surface thereof, said ridge forming a first structural wall extending downwardly from said lower surface of said plastic top portion; c) a flexible liner bonded to said lower surface of said plastic top portion of said closure, a first portion of said flexible liner covering at least said first structural wall so as to form a downwardly extending liner wall having an outer diameter (D2) and tapering radially inwardly as it extends downwardly so as to be inclined at an angle (A1) to the axial direction; d) means for causing said liner wall to progressively conform to said container neck wall along a surface of said liner having upper, middle and lower portions when said closure is applied to said container neck, whereby said liner wall conforming means causes said liner wall to conform to said neck wall along said upper portion of said liner surface first, followed by said middle portion of said liner surface, followed by said lower portion of said liner surface so that said conformance of said liner wall to said neck wall proceeds progressively from said first upper portion to said lower portion of said liner surface.
  • 12. A retortable container system, comprising:a) a container having a neck portion forming an inner wall tapering radially outwardly as it extends upwardly so as to be inclined at an angle (A2) to the axial direction, said wall having an upper portion; b) a closure, said closure comprising (i) a generally circular plastic top portion having upper and lower surfaces, (ii) a generally cylindrical plastic skirt portion extending downwardly from said top portion, and (iii) a circumferentially extending ridge integrally formed in said plastic top portion so as to project downwardly from said lower surface thereof, said ridge forming a first structural wall extending downwardly from said lower surface of said plastic top portion; c) a flexible liner bonded to said lower surface of said plastic top portion of said closure, a first portion of said flexible liner covering at least said first structural wall so as to form a downwardly extending liner wall having an outer diameter (D2) and tapering radially inwardly as it extends downwardly so as to be inclined at an angle (A1) to the axial direction; d) said liner wall angle (A1) being greater than said neck inner wall angle (A2) prior to conformance of said liner to said neck wall, thereby causing said liner wall to progressively conform to said container neck wall along a surface of said liner having upper, middle and lower portions when said closure is applied to said container neck and causing said liner wall to conform to said neck wall along said upper portion of said liner surface first, followed by said middle portion of said liner surface, followed by said lower portion of said liner surface so that said conformance of said liner wall to said neck wall proceeds progressively from said first upper portion to said lower portion of said liner surface.
US Referenced Citations (56)
Number Name Date Kind
1448094 Sorgan Mar 1923 A
1972280 Von Till Apr 1934 A
3428208 Kosar Feb 1969 A
3482725 Exton Dec 1969 A
3494496 Livingstone Feb 1970 A
3536224 Green Oct 1970 A
4156490 Peraboni May 1979 A
4196818 Brownbill Apr 1980 A
4299328 Ochs et al. Nov 1981 A
4418828 Wilde et al. Dec 1983 A
4432461 Mumford et al. Feb 1984 A
4458822 Ostrowsky Jul 1984 A
4478343 Ostrowsky Oct 1984 A
4506795 Herr Mar 1985 A
4511054 Shank Apr 1985 A
4512493 Von Holdt Apr 1985 A
4526282 Dutt et al. Jul 1985 A
4545496 Wilde et al. Oct 1985 A
4546892 Couput Oct 1985 A
4550844 Lininger Nov 1985 A
4592475 Hannon et al. Jun 1986 A
4595110 Herr Jun 1986 A
4657153 Hayes Apr 1987 A
4694969 Granat Sep 1987 A
4697716 Mumford Oct 1987 A
4732289 Granat et al. Mar 1988 A
4774134 Kehe et al. Sep 1988 A
4796770 Begley Jan 1989 A
4801030 Barriac Jan 1989 A
4813561 Ochs Mar 1989 A
4813562 Begley Mar 1989 A
4848614 Csaszar Jul 1989 A
4875594 Ochs Oct 1989 A
4907709 Abe et al. Mar 1990 A
4978016 Hayes Dec 1990 A
4981230 Marshall et al. Jan 1991 A
4991731 Osip et al. Feb 1991 A
5004110 Osip et al. Apr 1991 A
5020683 Strassheimer Jun 1991 A
5054268 Hayes et al. Oct 1991 A
5058755 Hayes Oct 1991 A
5060813 Gollasch et al. Oct 1991 A
5062538 Ochs Nov 1991 A
5078290 Ochs Jan 1992 A
5080246 Hayes Jan 1992 A
5090788 Ingram et al. Feb 1992 A
5204181 Suzuki et al. Apr 1993 A
5341949 Hayes Aug 1994 A
5346082 Ochs et al. Sep 1994 A
5443171 Sprowl Aug 1995 A
5660290 Hayes Aug 1997 A
5677053 Moriga et al. Oct 1997 A
5755347 Ingram May 1998 A
5913434 Fukuhara et al. Jun 1999 A
5947311 Gregory Sep 1999 A
6202871 Kelly Mar 2001 B1
Foreign Referenced Citations (6)
Number Date Country
0 447 021 Aug 1991 EP
0 560 051 Sep 1993 EP
0 616 951 Sep 1994 EP
0 801 005 Nov 1995 EP
7-257624 Oct 1995 JP
WO 9203378 Mar 1992 WO