This application is based on Application No. 2001-207696, filed in Japan on Jul. 9, 2001, the contents of which are hereby incorporated by reference.
1. Field of the Invention
The present invention relates to a positioning system for receiving signals from a positioning satellite or an apparatus similar to a positioning satellite to perform the positioning thereof, and in particular, to a positioning system for performing positioning with respect to a moving object. A positioning satellite or a satellite referred to in the following description shall include an apparatus similar to a positioning satellite unless specifically described.
2. Description of the Related Art
In positioning performed by receiving signals from a positioning satellite or from an apparatus similar to the positioning satellite, one of the factors which affects the precision thereof is a satellite arrangement. A degree of influence on the precision of the satellite arrangement is called “DOP: Dilution of Precision, ” which can be calculated using schematic trajectory information of the positioning satellite. In a conventional positioning system, the DOP is generally used as an index for selecting the positioning satellite in order to use it upon positioning. This is indicated, for example, on page 93 of “Revised “Basis of GPS surveying”, Jun Tsuchiya and Hiromichi Tsuji,” Japan Association of Surveyors.
A conventional positioning system will now be described with reference to a drawing.
In
Operations of the conventional positioning system will be described next with reference to a drawing.
Electric waves from each positioning satellite have a substantially identical frequency. However, the electric waves can be identified by a correlator because they are not CDMA converted by particular data. Since the frequency of electric waves from each satellite is fluctuated by the Doppler effect of the like, it is necessary to follow it by the DLL. Received data of each satellite is thereafter obtained by a decoder.
Since a detected part can be digitized, detection circuits normally in the order of 8 channels to 16 channels can operate simultaneously to follow signals from the individual positioning satellites. Since the number of positioning satellites is larger than the number of channels of a receiver, each channel does not always follow a particular positioning satellite. Therefore, an N channel output of a receiver includes an identification number of a positioning satellite. The received data further includes a pseudo distance ρ between the positioning satellite and the receiver, trajectory parameters of the positioning satellite or the like.
A matrix A shown in
In
The GDOP is defined by a square root of a diagonal element sum of (AT·A)−l. Here, AT is a transposed matrix of the matrix A, AT·A is a product of the transposed matrix AT and the matrix A, and (AT·A)−1 is an inverse matrix of the matrix (AT·A).
While the precision of a positioning calculation has been conventionally grasped using such indexes, degradation of the precision that cannot be determined by the DOP occurs due to quality degradation of a signal received from the each of the positioning satellites, degradation of trajectory information of each of the positioning satellites or the like.
The quality degradation of a signal is exemplified by the case in which a signal is not directly received from the positioning satellite but is reflected by an obstacle around the positioning satellite to be received, and the case in which, if an angle of elevation of the positioning satellite in a positioning position is low, a propagation distance in the atmosphere becomes longer to make a propagation delay larger.
The present invention has been devised in order to solve the above-mentioned problem, and it is an object of the present invention to realize a positioning system that can determine precision of a positioning calculation using an index different from the DOP.
A positionings system according to a first aspect of the invention comprises: a receiver for receiving signals from a plurality of positioning satellites to output data received from satellites; a satellite selector for selecting a plurality of combinations of positioning satellites to be objects of positioning calculation based on the data received from satellites to output satellite combination data; a positioning calculator for performing positioning calculation based on the data received from satellites and the satellite combination data to output positioning results thereof; and a positioning output determining unit for selecting a positioning result closest to a predicted position out of the positioning results to output the positioning result as a positioning output. As a result, there is an effect that the positioning becomes possible, which can also cope with precision degradation or the like not correlated to a DOP, and moreover, it becomes possible to generate a smooth positioning trajectory output result by performing trajectory prediction of a positioning system, whereby being capable of eliminating a sudden disturbance.
In a positioning system according to a second aspect of the present invention, the satellite selector includes: a satellite combination generator for generating second satellite combination data that combines the data received from satellites; a DOP calculator for calculating a DOP using the second satellite combination data based on the data received from satellites to output a DOP value; an aligning selector for aligning the plurality of DOP values to select a subset according to sizes of the values; and a combination data selecting and outputting unit for selecting a subset of outputs of the satellite combination generator using outputs of the aligning selector to output the satellite combination data. As a result, there is an effect that the positioning becomes possible, which can also cope with precision degradation or the like not correlated to a DOP, and moreover, it becomes possible to generate a smooth positioning trajectory output result by performing trajectory prediction of a positioning system, whereby being capable of eliminating a sudden disturbance.
In a positioning system according to a third aspect of the present invention, the positioning output determining unit includes: a positioning output selector for selecting a positioning result closest to a predicted position using the positioning results and a difference between the positioning results and the predicted position to output the positioning result as a positioning output; a trajectory predictor for predicting a trajectory of the positioning system using the positioning output to output the predicted position; and a difference calculation unit for calculating a difference between the positioning results and the predicted position. As a result, there is an effect that the positioning becomes possible, which can also cope with precision degradation or the like not correlated to a DOP, and moreover, it becomes possible to generate a smooth positioning trajectory output result by performing trajectory prediction of a positioning system, whereby being capable of eliminating a sudden disturbance.
In a positioning system according to a fourth aspect of the present invention, the trajectory predictor includes: a first coordinate converter for converting a coordinate system of the positioning output to a first coordinate system expressed by a latitude, a longitude and an altitude; an trajectory calculator for performing trajectory predicting calculation using a predetermined model based on the first coordinate system and outputting a predicted value of a second coordinate system expressed by a latitude, a longitude and an altitude; and a second coordinate converter for converting the predicted value of the second coordinate system to the coordinate system of the predicted position. As a result, there is an effect that the positioning becomes possible, which can also cope with precision degradation or the like not correlated to a DOP, and moreover, it becomes possible to generate a smooth positioning trajectory output result by performing trajectory prediction of a positioning system, whereby being capable of eliminating a sudden disturbance.
In a positioning system according to a fifth aspect of the present invention, the trajectory calculator performs trajectory predicting calculation on an assumption that the positioning system is taking a uniform acceleration motion. As a result, there is an effect that the positioning becomes possible, which can also cope with precision degradation or the like not correlated to a DOP, and moreover, it becomes possible to generate a smooth positioning trajectory output result by performing trajectory prediction of a positioning system, whereby being capable of eliminating a sudden disturbance.
In a positioning system according to a sixth aspect of the present invention, the positioning output determining unit includes: a plurality of positioning outputs selector for selecting a plurality of positioning results close to the predicted position using the positioning result and a difference between the positioning result and the predicted position to output them as selected outputs; a positioning output calculator for calculating a positioning position using a plurality of selected outputs of the plurality of positioning outputs selector to output it as a positioning output; a trajectory predictor for predicting a trajectory of the positioning system using the positioning output to output the predicted position; and a difference calculation unit for calculating a difference between the positioning result and the predicted position. As a result, it becomes possible to eliminate an error factor that is likely to be included in a selected one positioning result, and in addition, there is an effect that a more precise positioning result using information of a plurality of positioning satellites can be outputted by performing a calculation of a positioning output using a plurality of positioning results.
In a positioning system according to a seventh aspect of the present invention, the trajectory predictor includes: a first coordinate converter for converting a coordinate system of the positioning output to a first coordinate system expressed by a latitude, a longitude and an altitude; a trajectory calculator for performing a trajectory predicting calculation using a predetermined model based on the first coordinate system and outputting a predicted value of a second coordinate system expressed by a latitude, a longitude and an altitude, and at the same time outputting a predicted value of coordinate system fluctuation for predicting that a trajectory of the positioning system fluctuates from a coordinate system currently used; a second coordinate converter for converting the predicted value of the second coordinate system to the coordinate system of the predicted position; and a coordinate system updating unit for updating a coordinate system to be used in trajectory predicting calculation based on the predicted value of coordinate system fluctuation. As a result, there is an effect that a more precise positioning result using information of a plurality of positioning satellites can be outputted.
In a positioning system according to an eighth aspect of the present invention, the trajectory calculator performs a trajectory predicting calculation on an assumption that the positioning system is moving on a predetermined straight line. As a result, there is an effect that a more precise positioning result using information of a plurality of positioning satellites can be outputted.
In a positioning system according to a ninth aspect of the present invention, the coordinate system updating unit includes: a generator of coordinate system updating conversion matrix for calculating an angle deviation between each coordinate axis and a predicted trajectory using the predicted value of coordinate system fluctuation to generate a coordinate system updating conversion matrix that rotates a coordinate conversion matrix in the direction for compensating for the angle deviation; and a conversion matrix updating unit for applying the coordinate system updating conversion matrix to a present conversion matrix to update the conversion matrix. As a result, there is an effect that a more precise positioning result using information of a plurality of positioning satellites can be outputted.
A positioning system according to a tenth aspect of the present invention comprises: a receiver for receiving signals from a plurality of positioning satellites to output data received from satellites; a satellite selector for selecting a plurality of combinations of positioning satellites to be objects of positioning calculation based on the data received from satellites to output satellite combination data; a positioning calculator for performing positioning calculation based on the data received from satellites and the satellite combination data to output positioning results thereof; a velocity detector for detecting a velocity of the positioning system to output velocity data; and a positioning output determining unit for selecting a positioning result closest to a predicted position out of the positioning results to output the positioning result as a positioning output using the velocity data. As a result, there is an effect that the positioning becomes possible, which can also cope with precision degradation or the like not correlated to a DOP, and moreover, it becomes possible to generate a smooth positioning trajectory output result by performing trajectory prediction of a positioning system, whereby being capable of eliminating a sudden disturbance.
In a positioning system according to an eleventh aspect of the present invention, the satellite selector includes: a satellite combination generator for generating second satellite combination data that combines the data received from satellites; a DOP calculator for calculating a DOP using the second satellite combination data based on the data received from satellites to output a DOP value; an aligning selector for aligning the plurality of DOP values, thereby selecting a subset according to sizes of the values; and a combination data selecting and outputting unit for selecting a subset of outputs of the satellite combination generator using outputs of the aligning selector to output the satellite combination data. As a result, there is an effect that the positioning becomes possible, which can also cope with precision degradation or the like not correlated to a DOP, and moreover, it becomes possible to generate a smooth positioning trajectory output result by performing orbit trajectory prediction of the positioning system, whereby being capable of eliminating a sudden disturbance.
In a positioning system according to a twelfth aspect of the present invention, the positioning output determining unit includes: a positioning output selector for selecting a positioning result closest to a predicted position using the positioning results and a difference between the positioning results and the predicted position to output the positioning result as a positioning output; an trajectory predictor for predicting a trajectory of a positioning system using the positioning output and the velocity data to output the predicted position; and a difference calculation unit for calculating a difference between the positioning results and the predicted position. As a result, there is an effect that the positioning becomes possible, which can also cope with precision degradation or the like not correlated to a DOP, and moreover, it becomes possible to generate a smooth positioning trajectory output result by performing trajectory prediction of a positioning system, whereby being capable of eliminating a sudden disturbance.
In a positioning system according to a thirteenth aspect of the present invention, the trajectory predictor includes: a first coordinate converter for converting a coordinate system of the positioning output to a first coordinate system expressed by a latitude, a longitude and an altitude; a second coordinate converter for converting a coordinate system of the velocity data to a second coordinate system expressed by a latitude, a longitude and an altitude; a trajectory calculator for performing trajectory predicting calculation using a predetermined model based on the first and second systems of coordinates and outputting a predicted value of a third coordinate system expressed by a latitude, a longitude and an altitude; and a third coordinate converter for converting the predicted value of the third coordinate system to the coordinate system of the predicted position. As a result, there is an effect that the positioning becomes possible, which can also cope with precision degradation or the like not correlated to a DOP, and moreover, it becomes possible to generate a smooth positioning trajectory output result by performing trajectory prediction of a positioning system, whereby being capable of eliminating a sudden disturbance.
In a positioning system according to a fourteenth aspect of the present invention, the trajectory calculator performs the trajectory predicting calculation on an assumption that the positioning system is taking a uniform acceleration motion. As a result, there is an effect that the positioning becomes possible, which can also cope with precision degradation or the like not correlated to a DOP, and moreover, it becomes possible to generate a smooth positioning trajectory output result by performing trajectory prediction of a positioning system, whereby being capable of eliminating a sudden disturbance.
In a positioning system according to a fifteenth aspect of the present invention, the positioning output determining unit includes: a plurality of positioning outputs selector for selecting a plurality of positioning results close to the predicted position using the positioning result and a difference between the positioning result and a predicted position to output them as selected outputs; a positioning output calculator for calculating a positioning position using a plurality of selected outputs of the plurality of positioning outputs selector to output it as a positioning output; a trajectory predictor for predicting a trajectory of the positioning system using the positioning output and the velocity data to output the predicted position; and a difference calculation unit for calculating a difference between the positioning result and the predicted position.
In a positioning system according to a sixteenth aspect of the present invention, the trajectory predictor includes: a first coordinate converter for converting a coordinate system of the positioning output to a first coordinate system expressed by a latitude, a longitude and an altitude; a second coordinate converter for converting a coordinate system of the velocity data to a second coordinate system expressed by a latitude, a longitude and an altitude; a trajectory calculator for performing trajectory predicting calculation using a predetermined model based on the first and second systems of coordinates and outputting a predicted value of a third coordinate system expressed by a latitude, a longitude and an altitude, and at the same time outputting a predicted value of coordinate system fluctuation for predicting that a trajectory of the positioning system fluctuates from a coordinate system currently used; a third coordinate converter for converting the predicted value of the third coordinate system to the coordinate system of the predicted position; and a coordinate system updating unit for updating a coordinate system to be used in trajectory predicting calculation based on the predicted value of coordinate system fluctuation. As a result, there is an effect that a more precise positioning result using information of a plurality of positioning satellites can be outputted.
In a positioning system according to a seventeenth aspect of the present invention, the trajectory calculator performs trajectory predicting calculation on an assumption that the positioning system is moving on a predetermined straight line. As a result, there is an effect that a more precise positioning result using information of a plurality of positioning satellites can be outputted.
In a positioning system according to an eighteenth aspect of the present invention, the coordinate system updating unit includes: a generator of coordinate system updating conversion matrix for calculating an angle deviation between each coordinate axis and a predicted trajectory using the predicted value of coordinate system fluctuation to generate a coordinate system updating conversion matrix that rotates a coordinate conversion matrix in a direction for compensating for the angle deviation; and a conversion matrix updating unit for applying the coordinate system updating conversion matrix to a present conversion matrix to update the conversion matrix. As a result, there is an effect that a more precise positioning result using information of a plurality of positioning satellites can be outputted.
In the accompanying drawings:
First Embodiment
A positioning system in accordance with a first embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the accompanying drawings.
In
In this figure, reference numeral 6 denotes a positioning output that is an output of the positioning output determining unit 5, 7-1 to 7-N denote pieces of data received from satellites that are N outputs of the N channel receiver of positioning satellite signals 1, 8-1 to 8-M denote M pieces of satellite combination data selected by the satellite selector 2, 9 denotes velocity data that is an output of the velocity detector 4, and 10-1 to 10-M denote M positioning results corresponding to the inputs 8-1 to 8-M to the positioning calculator 3.
In
In addition, in this figure, reference numerals 15-1 to 15-P denote pieces of satellite combination data that are outputs of the satellite combination generator 11, 16-1 to 16-P denote DOP values that are outputs of the DOP calculator 12, and 17 denotes a selection signal that is an output of the aligning selector 13.
In
In
In
On a signal line of each figure, a slash is inserted to clearly indicate that a plurality of signal lines exist.
Operations of the positioning system in accordance with the first embodiment will now be described with reference to the drawings.
As shown in
The positioning calculator 3 performs positioning calculation with a list of the above-mentioned pieces of data as an object, that is, based on the data received from satellites 7-1 to 7-N and the satellite combination data 8-1 to 8-M to output results of the positioning calculation as the positioning results 10-1 to 10-M.
The positioning output determining unit 5 predicts a present position of the positioning system using the past positioning output 6 and the past and the present pieces of the velocity data 9 that are outputs of the velocity detector 4. The positioning output determining unit 5 selects a measurement result closest to the predicted position 20 out of the measurement results 10-1 to 10-M to output it.
Operations of the satellite selector 2 will now be described in detail.
As shown in
The DOP calculator 12 calculates DOPs based on satellite position information (a pseudo distance ρ between a positioning satellite and a receiver, trajectory parameters of a positioning satellite, etc.) included in the data received from satellites 7-1 to 7-N with respect to the combinations to output them as the DOP values 16-1 to 16-P.
The aligning selector 13 outputs a selection signal 17 for selecting a subset of the satellite combination data 15-1 to 15-P including satellite combination data capable of obtaining an optimal positioning result based on these DOP values. This is, for example, a number list having extracted numbers of combinations selected out of combination data of 1 to P. A method of selection is to select the DOP values 16-1 to 16-P included in the range of the DOP in which positioning seems to be possible and select satellite combination data corresponding to these values.
The combination data selecting and outputting unit 14 outputs the satellite combination data selected out of the satellite combination data 15-1 to 15-P as 8-1 to 8-M.
Operations of the positioning output determining unit 5 will now be described in detail.
As shown in
Operations of the trajectory predictor 19 will now be described.
It is important to select an appropriate coordinate system in predicting a trajectory.
As shown in
The coefficient 32 regulator 34 is capable of estimating precision of the prediction by inputting an integrated value of errors between respective coordinate components 27 and respective coordinate component prediction values 28. It becomes possible to further increase the precision of the prediction by finely tuning the coefficients of the coefficient calculator 32 of the trajectory calculator 24 based on the input.
As shown in
Since the trajectory predictor 19 predicts and calculates a positioning position at the present time in accordance with a model using the past positioning output 6 and the past and the present pieces of velocity data 9, it is not susceptible to influence of a sudden disturbance component included in received data of the present time. In addition, predicting calculation in accordance with a model can eliminate high frequency noises. With these effects, the trajectory predictor 19 can output a smooth positioning trajectory output result. This is preferable to a user.
As described above, positioning calculation is performed with respect to a plurality of candidates of a satellite combination, respectively, and the positioning results and a predicted position at the time of positioning by a trajectory predicting calculation are compared to select an optimal positioning result, with the result of which high precision positioning that can cope with precision degradation not correlated to a DOP becomes possible. Moreover, since trajectory prediction of a positioning system is performed, a smooth positioning trajectory output result can be generated and a sudden disturbance can be eliminated.
Further, in the above-mentioned first embodiment, the positioning output determining unit 5 predicts a present position of the positioning system using the past positioning output 6 and the past and the present pieces of velocity data 9 that are outputs of the velocity detector 4 to thereby increase precision of prediction.
However, the present position of the positioning system can be predicted with a positioning output determining unit that uses the past positioning output 6 only without using the velocity data 9. In this positioning output determining unit, parts of the velocity detector 4, the coordinate converter 26 and the trajectory calculator 24 that predict a velocity component for the velocity data 9 becomes unnecessary, which may be deleted, respectively. In addition, in the trajectory calculator 24 of the positioning output determining unit 5 shown in
Second Embodiment
A positioning system in accordance with a second embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the accompanying drawings.
In
In addition, in the figure, reference numerals 45-1 to 45-3 denote coordinate components that are outputs of the coordinate converter 40, 46-1 to 46-3 denote predicted values of coordinate components that are outputs of the trajectory calculator 41, 47-1 to 47-3 denote coordinate components that are outputs of the coordinate converter 43, 48-1 to 48-3 denote outputs of the trajectory calculator 41 that are predicted values of coordinate system fluctuation for predicting that a trajectory of the positioning system fluctuates from a coordinate system currently used, 49 denotes a designated value for coordinate conversion that is coordinate conversion data of the coordinate converter 40, the coordinate converter 42 and the coordinate converter 43, and 50 denotes an initialization signal for, when the coordinate system updating unit 44 updates the designated value of coordinate conversion 49, notifying the trajectory calculator 41 of timing for the update.
In
In
Operations of the positioning system in accordance with the second embodiment will now be described with reference to the drawings.
The trajectory calculator 41 of the second embodiment shown in
This coefficient 53 regulator 55 increases a coefficient of the coefficient multiplier 53 for a short period of time at the time when the initialization signal 50 is inputted in order to cause the internal state of the trajectory calculator 41 to follow each coordinate component 45 at a high speed. Thus, the states of the memories 51-1 to 51-3 can reflect each coordinate component 45.
The coordinate system fluctuation predictor 58 calculates a steady offset variation ratio of errors using an output of the coefficient multiplier 56 and outputs of the memories 57-1 to 57-K. An error following a steady variation ratio including errors indicates a possibility that each coordinate component 45 moves on a straight line different from an assumed trajectory, that is, a coordinate axis employed by the trajectory calculator 41. It is possible to calculate an angle deviation between a present coordinate axis and an actual trajectory by calculating this variation ratio and then using a ratio between the calculated variation ratio and a distance moved or a predicted speed. The predicted values of a coordinate system variation 48-1 to 48-3 are calculated and outputted in this way.
The generator for coordinate system updating conversion matrix 60 shown in
If a trajectory of the positioning system is assumed to take a linear motion, it is possible to make a prediction of a trajectory more accurate by employing a coordinate system adapted to an actual trajectory. This can be explained from the fact that a difference between each coordinate component 45 and each predicted value of coordinate component 46 in the trajectory calculator 41 steadily becomes zero in the case where it is assumed that a positioning result without disturbance is obtained. When the trajectory calculator 41 employs a coordinate system different from trajectory the positioning system's trajectory, a steady error is generated on each coordinate axis.
Therefore, it can be expected that the trajectory predictor 19 of the second embodiment is more precise than the trajectory predictor 19 of the first embodiment.
As described above, since the trajectory predictor 19 performs an operation for sequentially adapting a coordinate system of trajectory calculation to an actual direction of the position system's trajectory, more precise positioning results using information of a plurality of positioning satellites can be outputted. In addition, it is also obvious that the trajectory predictor 19 of the second embodiment can be applied to the trajectory predictor 19 in a third embodiment to be described later.
Further, in the above-mentioned second embodiment, the positioning output determining unit 5 uses the past positioning output 6 and the past and the present pieces of velocity data 9 that are outputs of the velocity detector 4 to predict a present position of the positioning system, thereby improving precision of prediction.
However, a present position of the positioning system can be predicted with a positioning output determining unit that only uses the past positioning output 6 without using the velocity data 9. In this positioning output determining unit, parts of the velocity detector 4, the coordinate converter 43 and the trajectory calculator 41 that predict a velocity component for the velocity data 9 become unnecessary, which may be deleted, respectively. In addition, in the trajectory calculator 41 of the positioning output determining unit 5 shown in
Third embodiment
A positioning system in accordance with the third embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the accompanying drawings.
In
The third embodiment is different from the above-mentioned first embodiment in that a plurality of positioning results close to the predicted position 20 are selected instead of selecting one positioning result closest to the predicted position 20 to calculate the positioning output 6 using these values.
As a first example of the calculation, the positioning output calculator 71 calculates and outputs an average value of the selected outputs 72-1 to 72-L. In addition, as a second example of the calculation, a root mean square value of the selected outputs 72-1 to 72-L are calculated and outputted.
As described above, the positioning output 6 is calculated using a plurality of positioning results close to the predicted position 20, whereby it becomes possible to eliminate an error factor that is likely to be included in a selected one positioning result.
In addition, since a positioning output is calculated using a plurality of positioning results, a more precise positioning result using information of a plurality of positioning satellites can be outputted. In addition, it is also obvious that the positioning output determining unit 5 of the third embodiment can be applied to the positioning output determining unit 5 of the above-mentioned second embodiment.
Further, in the above-mentioned third embodiment, the positioning output determining unit 5 uses the past positioning output 6 and the past and the present pieces of velocity data 9 that are outputs of the velocity detector 4 to predict a present position of the positioning system, thereby improving precision of the prediction.
However, a present position of the positioning system can be predicted with a positioning output determining unit that only uses the past positioning output 6 without using the velocity data 9. In this positioning output determining unit, devices such as the velocity detector 4 relating to the velocity data become unnecessary, which may be deleted, respectively. Also in this case, as a result, there is an effect that the positioning becomes possible, which can also cope with precision degradation or the like not correlated to a DOP. Moreover, it becomes possible to generate a smooth positioning trajectory output result by performing trajectory prediction of a positioning system, whereby being capable of eliminating a sudden disturbance.
Thus, it is seen that a positioning system is provided. One skilled in the art will appreciate that the present invention can be practiced by other than the preferred embodiments which are presented for the purposes of illustration and not of limitation, and the present invention is limited only by the claims which follow.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2001-207696 | Jul 2001 | JP | national |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4928107 | Kuroda et al. | May 1990 | A |
5155688 | Tanaka et al. | Oct 1992 | A |
5323163 | Maki | Jun 1994 | A |
5373298 | Karouby | Dec 1994 | A |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
A3-72285 | Mar 1991 | JP |
A3-108681 | May 1991 | JP |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20030008666 A1 | Jan 2003 | US |