Patent Grant
7014556
This invention relates to powder spray coating and, in particular, to the recovery of powder which has not adhered to the article to be coated from a powder spray booth.
The powder which does not adhere to an article to be coated in a powder spray booth is known as the “overspray”. Overspray powder may miss the article to be coated, rebound from a surface of the article, or be deflected by the electrostatic fields in the spray booth away from the article.
It is known to recover overspray powder by exhausting the air from the booth and hence the air-borne overspray powder. The filter elements which have been used to recover overspray from powder spray booth are capable of removing substantially all the overspray from the spray booth exhaust air so that the powder may be reused. It is also known to use cyclone separators instead of, or in conjunction with filter elements for recovery of overspray. Cyclone separators are effective in removing the majority of the overspray from the spray booth exhaust air and are easier to clean than filters because very little powder is deposited inside the cyclone housing.
In known arrangements the cyclone separators have been connected to the powder spray booth by a duct extending from an overspray intake near the floor of the booth to the inlet of the or each cyclone. European Patent Application No. 94929600.8 discloses a powder coating system where the duct is built into the powder spray booth, with one of the side or end walls of the booth forming part of the duct.
In European Patent Application 98940476.9 there is disclosed a further development wherein the portion of the side or end wall which forms part of the duct is removable from the remainder of the wall to allow easy cleaning of the duct. That Application also discloses a system for collecting deposited overspray powder comprising a scraper bar which continuously reciprocates across the booth floor between the end walls to collect powder on the booth floor and move the collected powder towards the end walls of the spray booth adjacent to each of which overspray intakes are provided.
In recent years there has been a growing desire to be able to spray multiple colours in a single booth in rapid succession. However, changing powder colour requires cleaning of the booth to remove powder deposited on the walls, ceiling and floor which was not extracted by air exhaustion. Proper cleaning of the walls and floor of the powder spray booth between colour changes is very important to ensure acceptable production quality. Such cleaning may be carried out manually by an operator using a scraping and/or compressed air jet apparatus. However booths have been proposed which are intended to automate the deposited overspray powder cleaning process including the booth of European Patent Application No. 98940476.9 referred to above with its reciprocating scraper bar.
Whilst many developments have been made, there is a customer driven demand for even more rapid cleaning capability to reduce cleaning time still further. Furthermore, whilst automatic mechanical devices such as the reciprocating scraper bar of European Patent Application 98940476.9 do accelerate the cleaning process, they also increase construction cost and can be vulnerable to mechanical failure.
Cleaning is preferably conducted from one end of the booth to another and so, from the point of view of cleaning, the overspray intake of the powder recovery system would ideally be located at one end of the booth. However, from the point of view of spraying, the best location for the overspray intake is commonly held to be in the lengthwise centre of the booth to give balanced extraction air flow along the booth and therefore even air flow across the openings which are provided for the spray devices. When the overspray intake is provided at one end of the booth, attempts have therefore been made to modify the booth cross-section to produce the desirable air flow balance. In one known system the booth floor has side portions which slope downwards and the region therebetween is vertically offset to define a trough between the sloped side portions. A triangular insert is positioned in the trough during spraying. The combination of the sloped side portions and triangular insert helps balance the air flows along the length of the booth. However difficulties arise when the powder colour is to be changed as the triangular insert has to be removed for cleaning which adds to the cleaning time.
In another arrangement, shown, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 4,715,314, the booth floor is formed with a slot which extends the length thereof and connects to a duct also running the length of the booth. However the slot can accumulate powder when one colour is sprayed for a long period of time which makes cleaning more difficult.
It is also been proposed to reduce cleaning time by preventing powder from ever depositing on the floor of a spray booth. German Patent 3408014 describes a system where the floor of the booth is formed as a series of descending steps and air is blown across each step from the slot between it and the step thereabove. The aim is to provide an air stream across the width of the booth which will carry all powder falling towards the floor into the overspray intake and prevent the powder reaching the floor and depositing there. The step form of the booth floor however increases the overall complexity of the booth and this, and the fact that air has to be continuously supplied, makes the booth expensive.
German Patent Application No. 19644360 describes a booth which is also intended to prevent overspray powder reaching the floor. The booth has one or more nozzles for creating a generally horizontal airflow across the booth floor. The air flow diverts descending overspray powder towards the inlet of a powder recovery system and prevents the overspray powder from depositing on the floor. In one embodiment, a central baffle positioned above the floor creates an open-sided duct leading to the inlet and a nozzle directs air to each side. As with the system of German Patent 3468014 a continuous air supply is required.
As noted above, booths in which part of the floor is sloped are known. However, according to U.S. Pat. No. 3,905,785, sloping alone is insufficient to cause all the overspray powder to flow by gravity to the recovery system. The Patent proposes a booth in which the floor is constituted by at least one air-permeable inclined plate. Air is sucked from the booth through the plate which acts to filter out air borne overspray. Periodically air is blown up through the plate to fluidise the deposited overspray thereon and cause it to flow to a recovery system. The suction period may be five to twenty times longer than the blowing period. The concept is similar to that of cartridge filters which are periodically purged by reverse air jets.
The majority of known booths are rectangular. However, it is also known to provide circular booths. A circular booth is disclosed in, for example, EPA 0839522. A problem with known circular booths is that these have conical floors leading to a suction duct by which overspray powder is transferred to a recovery system. A pit is generally required to accommodate the cone and duct in order that articles to be sprayed can be received at the same level as other elements in the production line.
It is an object of the present invention to provide a colour spray apparatus in which powder colour can be changed quickly and easily and which, moreover, is of relatively simple construction.
It is another object of the present invention to provide a powder coating system in which both air borne and deposited overspray can be recovered by a system involving a small number of relatively simple parts which are themselves readily cleaned.
It is a further object of the present invention to provide a powder spray booth in which the collection of deposited overspray is facilitated whilst still balancing the extraction air flow along the length of the booth.
It is a still further object of this invention to provide a powder spray booth of generally circular configuration which can be easily incorporated in a production line and which is simple to clean.
The invention will now be summarised with respect to four principal aspects: a diverter plate; sloped floor with cleaning air; pulsed cleaning air apparatus, and pulsed cleaning air method.
In one aspect the present invention provides a powder coating system comprising a powder spray booth with walls and a floor having two side portions and a downwardly offset region therebetween which defines a trough between the side portions, one or more powder spray devices positioned with respect to the booth walls to spray articles passed through the booth via openings in the walls, a powder recovery system having an overspray intake communicating with the interior of the booth, the powder recovery system including suction means for drawing overspray powder from the booth interior via the overspray intake, and, a diverter plate held within the booth between the floor side portions such as to close at least part of the trough and form a duct which is in communication with the overspray intake, the diverter plate including at least one aperture for the passage of overspray powder deposited thereon to the duct.
It has been found that with this apparatus it is possible to even out air extraction to give balanced air flow in the booth whilst still providing an arrangement which is easy to clean particularly if, as is preferred, the diverter plate is movable to a second raised position allowing access to the trough. The provision of at least one aperture allows overspray powder deposited on the diverter plate to be drawn therethrough and into the powder recovery system.
Preferably the side portions are sloped down towards the diverter plate. The diverter plate may define a slot between it and each of the side portions.
Deposited overspray powder on the side portions will trickle down towards the diverter plate and be extracted by the air flow to the powder recovery system via the slots between the plate and the side portions. As already noted, deposited overspray powder on the surface of the plate will be extracted via the apertures therein. As a consequence the amount of deposited overspray powder in the booth at the start of the cleaning operation will be reduced so reducing the scale of the cleaning operation and consequently its duration.
The booth may have any desired configuration. It may have the common rectangular shape with the longitudinal axis running generally horizontally. Alternatively, the booth can be circular with the central axis running generally vertically. The provision of an air distribution duct in a circular booth formed by the diverter plate enables limitation of powder build up and optimisation of air distribution and velocities in the booth through control of the size and shape of the apertures in the diverter plate. Advantage can therefore be taken of the easy cleanability of circular booths without requiring that a special pit be provided to position the booth in a production line. This is a significant benefit as is the fact that operators can safely walk into the booth which is not possible with known circular booths having a conical base.
In a rectangular booth, the overspray intake may be provided at or near one end of the booth with the diverter plate extending from that end along part of the length of the booth. In a rectangular booth provided with a plurality of automatic powder spray devices and having slots in the side walls for the automatic powder spray devices, the length of the diverter plate may be the distance between the end and the gun slot furthest from the end plus an offset. The offset can be comparatively small, a suitable value for a common booth design being 200 mm.
It has been found that it is only necessary to provide the diverter plate in the part of the booth where automatic guns are employed. This is because there are a higher number of guns in the automatic gun portion of the booth and therefore more powder flow into the booth there from the guns. Also, this part of the booth is closest to the extraction fan. Without the diverter plate, the fan can distort the powder spray patterns from the guns and may draw the powder into the collection system before it has a chance to adhere to the part. The effect of the diverter plate is to equalize the suction force of the fan so that powder has more time to adhere to the part and oversprayed powder is drawn evenly towards the fan. In the manual gun section of the booth, there are fewer guns and they are farther away from the fan, so the patterns from those guns are not affected to such a great extent by the fan. Therefore, the diverter plate is not as necessary in the manual gun section of the booth.
In a rectangular booth of the design shown in European Patent Application No. 98940476.9 with an overspray intake at each end, a diverter plate may be provided extending from each end. It has been found that a booth with air intakes at both ends in fact produces the best balancing of the air flow in the booth and actually results in a “dead” zone in the middle of the booth where powder coating is particularly efficient since powder particles have an opportunity to adhere to the part relatively unaffected by the collection system air flows. The plates can be arranged to extend to either side of this “dead” zone.
In a particularly preferred embodiment, the diverter plate is formed in two or more sections, the diverter plate sections being arranged at different vertical spacings from the bottom of the trough such that the duct has different heights along its length. It has be found with this arrangement it is possible to improve still further the air flow balance in the booth and to obtain more even suction.
In this embodiment, the plate section or sections adjacent the or each overspray intake may have the greatest vertical spacing from the trough bottom. With a rectangular booth having an overspray intake at one end, the sections may be arranged in a descending series of steps towards the other end. With a circular booth having a centrally located overspray intake, the section thereabove may be at maximum spacing with one or more lower sections on either side. The narrowing of the duct away from the overspray intake produces the desired even suction and more balanced air flow.
The diverter plate is suitably provided with a plurality of apertures arranged in a pattern. With a rectangular booth, the pattern may be triangular with the apex being at the end of the booth closest to the fan. This pattern has been found to give the best combination of powder collection and air balancing. The total hole cross-sectional area gradually increases from the end towards the middle of the booth.
The apertures in a preferred form are elongate in the lengthwise direction of the plate to give maximum circumference for given cross sectional area and therefore maximum ability to draw deposited overspray from the upper surface of the diverter plate.
In accordance with a second aspect, the present invention provides a powder coating system comprising a powder spray booth having floor and walls, one or more powder spray devices positioned with respect to the walls to spray articles passed through the booth via openings in the walls, and a powder recovery system having an overspray intake communicating with the interior of the booth, the powder recovery system including suction means for drawing overspray powder from the booth interior via the overspray intake, wherein at least a portion of the booth floor is sloped and wherein cleaning air supply means is provided for directing air down the sloped portion(s).
Whilst it has been known to make at least a portion of booth floors sloping, the intended result of this, that deposited overspray powder will eventually trickle down the sloped portion, does not always occur. There can be significant build ups of deposited overspray powder on the sloped portion or portions which adds to cleaning time and also gives rise to danger of explosions. By providing a cleaning air supply which directs air down the sloped portion or portions, downward movement of deposited overspray powder is ensured to bring the deposited overspray powder to a region where it can be easily cleaned, either manually or automatically by a mechanical scraper or the like and/or extraction in the exhaust air of the powder recovery system.
The cleaning air supply means may comprise a source of air and at least one plenum extending along at least part of the sloped portion and located at the upper edge of the sloped portion, the plenum having at least one air outlet, preferably plural air outlets.
Very preferably the air source provides periodically pulses of air to the air outlets. It has been found that it is an unnecessary waste of energy to constantly direct air across the slope portion or portions and it suffices just to pulse the air to start movement of deposited overspray powder down the sloped portion or portions. It is currently believed that the best effects are achieved when the cleaning air supply means directs the air generally parallel to the surface of the sloped portion or portions, preferably at an angle of 1–3° to the sloped portion or portions.
In the particularly preferred configuration of the first aspect, the cleaning air supply means of the second aspect may direct air down the side portions along the length of the diverter panel.
In accordance with a third aspect, the present invention provides a powder spray system having a floor, and walls, one or more powder spray devices positioned with respect to the walls to spray articles passed through the booth via openings in the walls, and a powder recovery system having an overspray intake communicating with the interior of the booth, the powder recovery system including suction means for drawing overspray powder from the booth interior via the overspray intake, wherein a cleaning air supply means is provided comprising a source of air and at least one plenum with plural air outlets, the air source providing pulses of air to the air outlets and the plenum being arranged to direct the air pulses across an internal surface of the booth on which overspray powder is deposited.
It has been found that pulses of air may be effective for collection of deposited powder across any internal surface of the booth not just sloped surfaces. The pulses of air cause the deposited overspray powder to collect, either by falling in the case of the ceiling or walls, or by movement along or across the booth in the case of the floor and so facilitate extraction of the deposited overspray powder by the powder recovery system. Good results are achieved without the need for a constant air flow or a complicated structure for directing the air. Thus the system is very economical both as regards manufacture and operation.
The air source may be a compressed air source, one or more fans or an air supply of the powder recovery system. The former has the advantage of cheapness whilst the latter makes for compactness and quietness since fans are relatively noisy.
Very preferably the first aspect is combined with the second and/or third which results overall in a very significant reduction in cleaning time coupled with even air distribution across the booth which produces higher transfer efficiency since the powder particles are given a greater opportunity to adhere to the part. These advantages are accomplished while good powder containment within the booth is also being achieved.
The invention also provides in a fourth aspect a method of operating a powder coating system including a powder spray booth having a floor and walls, one or more powder spray devices and a powder recovery system with an overspray inlet communicating with the interior of the booth, the method comprising periodically directing jets of air across an internal surface of the booth to collect deposited overspray powder thereon.
The method thus involves providing air assist in the booth which facilitates collection and removal of deposited overspray powder.
The internal surface may be the floor and/or one or more walls and/or the ceiling of the booth.
The jets of air are preferably directed sideways across the surface, or lengthwise along the booth. In this way the powder is gathered together and easily collected by a cleaning operation along the booth which may be either manual or automatic.
It has been found that good results are achieved when the air jets are pulsed on for five seconds for every five minutes of spraying of articles in the booth. This prevents any significant build-up of deposited overspray powder by causing removal of the majority of deposited overspray from the booth with the result that the inventory of powder moving around in the system, particularly the quantity within the booth itself, is kept to a minimum.
Alternatively or additionally the jets of air can be pulsed just prior to a colour change so that the amount of deposited powder which has to be removed during the cleaning operation is minimised.
Very preferably this fourth aspect is combined with the second aspect and the air jets are directed across at least part of a sloping portion of the booth floor. For effective movement of deposited overspray powder on the sloping portion(s), the air jets are directed generally parallel the sloping portion(s), preferably at an angle of between 1–3° thereto.
The invention will now be further described by way of example with reference to the accompanying drawings in which:
The ceiling, walls 4, 6 and floor 10 of the booth 2 are preferably made from a non-conducting material such as plastic. By using plastic, the powder sprayed by the spray devices if electrostatically charged will have a reduced tendency to adhere to the ceiling and walls 4, 6 since it will not be electrostatically attracted to the walls 4, 6 and ceiling and instead will fall under gravity and collect on the floor 10 of the booth 2. For durability the floor 10 or at least the part or parts on which an operator will walk may instead be made of stainless steel.
The booth 2 will be provided with a powder recovery system which may include filters and/or one or more cyclone separators as further described below with respect to other embodiments of the powder coating system. Whatever form the powder recovery system takes, there will be an overspray intake communicating with the interior of the booth 2 and providing a current of exhaust air within the booth and into the overspray intake. The current of exhaust air will serve to extract airborne overspray powder. The skilled man can readily choose a suitable powder recovery system from those known in the art.
As rectangular powder spray booths are preferably cleaned from one end to the other, for the purposes of cleaning the overspray intake is preferably located at one end of the booth. In the booth depicted in
The floor 10 of the booth 2 shown in
A diverter plate 26 is positioned in the trough 24 at the end where the overspray intake 18 is located and extends from that end. The length of the diverter plate 26 is preferably equal to the distance from the end of the booth 2 to the centre line of the automatic spray device slot 14 which is furthest from that end plus an offset. The offset may suitably be of the order of 200 mm. The plate 26 is suitably spaced from the side portions 22 to define slots 27 therebetween.
The plate 26 has a pattern of holes 28 therein. Two possible patterns are shown in
The diverter plate 26 is supported by tabs 29 in the position shown in
The booth 2 shown in
In the arrangement of
The plenum is supplied by a series of air feed tubes 39 spaced along the length of the booth. The feed tubes 39 are in turn supplied by a valved pressurised air source as in the arrangement of
Whichever arrangement is employed, that of
The plenum 34 of the arrangement shown in
In use, the booth 2 is employed to spray powder on to objects passing therethrough either from automatic guns extending through the slots 14 and/or by manual guns directed through the openings 16. Air borne overspray powder is extracted from the interior of the booth 2 on the current of exhaust air produced by the powder recovery system via the overspray extract 18 and duct 20. Overspray powder which falls out of the transport air provided by the powder recovery system will be deposited on the floor 10 of the booth 2 and so on the side portions 22, the bottom of the trough 24 and the plate 26. The flow of exhaust air caused by the air recovery module along the trough 24 will tend to draw deposited overspray powder on the upper surface of the diverter plate 26 down into the trough 24 therebelow either through the holes 28 or the slots 27 between the side portions 22 and the diverter plate 26. It has been found that the elongate shape of the holes 28 maximises the area therearound from which deposited overspray powder is drawn into the holes 28 and thence to the overspray intake 18 on the current of exhaust air. The peaking of the upper surface 29 of the plate 26 assists the passage of deposited overspray powder not drawn through the holes 28 into the slots 27 and so again to the overspray intake 18.
Deposited overspray powder on the side portions 22 will to an extent by gravity naturally trickle down the side portions due to their sloping and into the trough 24 and so into the current of exhaust air produced by the powder recovery system. The booth 2 of
The air assist provided by the plenums 34 not only helps keep the side portions 22 clear but also increases the collection of deposited overspray powder on the upper surface from the diverter plate 26.
The great majority of deposited overspray powder which is collected off the side portions 22 and the diverter plate 26 is re-entrained in the exhaust air flow of the powder recovery system and so extracted as, in effect, air borne overspray powder from the booth 2.
The diverter panel 26 could extend the full length of the booth 2. However it has been found that it suffices for it to extend just past the slots 14 for automatic guns by an offset which, as noted above, can be in the order of 200 mm. This is because the higher number of guns in the automatic gun portion of the booth produces more powder flow, and this greater powder flow is closer to the fan than the manual guns. The effect of the diverter plate is to equalize the suction force of the fan so that the powder has more time to adhere to the part and oversprayed powder is more evenly drawn into the collection system. Since the manual guns are farther from the fan, their spray patterns are not as greatly affected by the fan and the need for the diverter plate is therefore reduced with respect to those guns.
The diverter plate 26 functions to even out air distribution along the booth 2 to give an air balance in the powder booth which leads to higher transfer efficiency while ensuring good powder containment. Thus it serves to reduce the amount of deposited overspray powder and so increase the amount of air borne overspray powder. This balancing effect is achieved in part by the pattern of holes 28. As the diverter plate 26 is an air flow restrictor, the size, number and pattern of the holes determines the air velocity through the overspray intake 18. As an example, the diverter plate 26 may be arranged so that in combination with the input air velocity of the powder recovery system and the cubic feet per meter rating of the booth 2, the air velocity through the overspray intake 18 is 2000 ft/min.
The booth 2 shown in
During spraying, air is periodically supplied to the plenums 34 to produce air jets down the side portions 22 and so cause movement of deposited overspray powder thereon into the trough 24 and on to the diverter plate 26. The air jets will also assist in keeping the diverter plate 26 clean. In one working embodiment, the plenums 35 had 0.5 mm diameter holes set at a 15 mm spacing and powder collection was achieved by blowing air at 4 bar pressure for five seconds every five minutes. As will be appreciated, the air assist parameters given for any given booth will depend on various parameters such as the type of powder coating material, the configuration on the booth, and in particular, the angle of sloping of the side portions 22. The provision of air assist means that if desired the angle of sloping can be reduced which makes it easier for operators to move around within the booth 2 and facilitates construction of the booth 2.
The advantage in embodiments illustrated in
Whilst rectangular booths as shown in
It has now been found that it is possible to obtain good overspray powder recovery with a circular booth having a flat base by incorporating therein a diverter plate and using this in conjunction with a powder recovery system which exhausts air from the booth.
The circular booth 2 has a low height and so no pit or platform is required. An operator can easily walk into the booth 2 so that it can be cleaned of any residual powder when changing colours by wiping. There is no safety issue as in current commercial booths since the operator cannot fall into a deep conical floor as there is none.
As can be seen in
The circular booths 2 of
In order to allow manual powder coating guns to be used in combination with automatic powder spray guns, the circular configuration shown in
All of the circular booths embodiments may be provided with air assisted overspray collection by fitting plenums to direct air jets down the floor side portions 22 and so cause movement of deposited overspray thereon into the trough 24 and onto the diverter plate 26. As with the rectangular booth embodiments, the provision of air assist will mean that the sloping of the side portions 22 may be reduced which will make it easier for operators to move around within the booth 2 and facilitate its construction.
The air assist need not be used in conjunction with a diverter plate 26.
In a circular booth, the whole of the booth floor 10 may be sloped. This is illustrated in
In still further alternatives, the air assist is provided across other non-sloped internal surfaces of the booth 2, for example, one or more of the walls or the ceiling. Air assist can also be provided to an advantage with a non-sloped floor. A particular embodiment which may have great utility is to provide air assist centrally of the booth disclosed in European Patent Application No. 98940476.9 such that the jets of air are directed towards the ends of the booth and thus to each of the overspray intakes provided at those ends. The air assist will facilitate collection of deposited overspray powder on the floor and movement thereof towards the overspray intakes for recovery by the powder recovery system.
In all these alternatives, the air assist may be continuous or pulsed. The latter has the advantage of economy due to reduced energy requirements for the air source and therefore cost savings.
With a long run between the colour powder changes, it is desirable that an air pulse be provided periodically, whilst with short runs, it can suffice to provide a pulse just prior to the colour change.
Reverting to
The amount of deposited overspray powder which has to be removed in this operation is much less than with known booths because a significant proportion of the deposited overspray powder will have already been removed due to the action of the diverter plate 26, sloped side portions 22 and the air plenums 34. Consequently the amount of recycling work to be done during the cleaning process is reduced which reduces labour costs. Also, in some prior systems, powder has to be collected in a dust pan or waste container and thrown away because recycling has not been completed by the time the cleaning process is over. This waste of powder coating material will not occur in the present system due to the reduced time and effort required to clean the booth.
In tests with this booth, it has been found to be possible to reduce booth cleaning time to below fifteen minutes.
These improvements in colour change capability are achieved whilst at the same time improving the actual performance of the booth since the diverter plate 26 acts to even out, or balance across the length of the booth the air flows which draw oversprayed powder into the system. This has the effect of improving the transfer efficiency of the guns because the powder particles have a better opportunity to attach to the part being coated. In addition, oversprayed powder is more effectively contained within the booth by mans of this design.
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/GB01/01116 | 3/14/2001 | WO | 00 | 11/25/2002 |
| Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| WO01/74497 | 10/11/2001 | WO | A |
| Number | Name | Date | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3516388 | Barnes | Jun 1970 | A |
| 3714926 | Ofner | Feb 1973 | A |
| 3719030 | Blankenmeyer et al. | Mar 1973 | A |
| 3814002 | Rombach et al. | Jun 1974 | A |
| 3905785 | Fabre | Sep 1975 | A |
| 3918640 | Piccino et al. | Nov 1975 | A |
| 3918641 | Lehmann et al. | Nov 1975 | A |
| 4153008 | Marino et al. | May 1979 | A |
| 4378728 | Berkmann | Apr 1983 | A |
| 4409009 | Lissy | Oct 1983 | A |
| 4430956 | Koch, II | Feb 1984 | A |
| 4504292 | Vöhringer | Mar 1985 | A |
| 4530274 | Lyons et al. | Jul 1985 | A |
| 4537120 | Josefsson | Aug 1985 | A |
| 4704953 | Wilson | Nov 1987 | A |
| 4715314 | Ramseier et al. | Dec 1987 | A |
| 4770089 | Vinicombe | Sep 1988 | A |
| 4926746 | Smith | May 1990 | A |
| 5042420 | Gerdes | Aug 1991 | A |
| 5107756 | Diaz | Apr 1992 | A |
| 5153028 | Shutic et al. | Oct 1992 | A |
| 5153034 | Telchuk et al. | Oct 1992 | A |
| 5178679 | Josefsson | Jan 1993 | A |
| 5256201 | Gelain et al. | Oct 1993 | A |
| 5275634 | Kramer | Jan 1994 | A |
| 5346553 | Pingel | Sep 1994 | A |
| 5421885 | Trevisan | Jun 1995 | A |
| 5518543 | Pietrowski et al. | May 1996 | A |
| 5615980 | Mauchle | Apr 1997 | A |
| 5634975 | Josefsson | Jun 1997 | A |
| 5681390 | Lacchia | Oct 1997 | A |
| 5766355 | Josefsson et al. | Jun 1998 | A |
| 5928423 | Toyota et al. | Jul 1999 | A |
| 6010571 | Josefsson et al. | Jan 2000 | A |
| 6264745 | Diaz | Jul 2001 | B1 |
| 6461431 | Ainsworth et al. | Oct 2002 | B1 |
| 6471737 | Cole et al. | Oct 2002 | B1 |
| Number | Date | Country |
|---|---|---|
| 529 590 | Oct 1972 | CH |
| 7014433.1 | Sep 1970 | DE |
| 30 28 588 | Feb 1982 | DE |
| 34 08 014 | Sep 1985 | DE |
| 37 15470 | Nov 1988 | DE |
| 8907538 | Oct 1990 | DE |
| 295 18 478 | Jan 1996 | DE |
| 195 17 729 | Feb 1996 | DE |
| 195 00 873 | Jul 1996 | DE |
| 196 44 360 | Apr 1998 | DE |
| 19644360 | Apr 1998 | DE |
| 0 223 660 | May 1987 | EP |
| 0 165 815 | May 1989 | EP |
| 0 698 421 | Aug 1994 | EP |
| 0 678 336 | Mar 1995 | EP |
| 0 689 875 | Jun 1995 | EP |
| 0 701 868 | Mar 1996 | EP |
| 0 839 582 | May 1998 | EP |
| 0 839 583 | May 1998 | EP |
| 2 675 061 | Apr 1991 | FR |
| 2 724 583 | Sep 1994 | FR |
| 429028 | May 1935 | GB |
| 2 120 303 | Mar 1983 | GB |
| 2 141 642 | Jan 1985 | GB |
| WO 9510365 | Apr 1995 | WO |
| WO 9912658 | Mar 1999 | WO |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20030175416 A1 | Sep 2003 | US |
