The present invention relates generally to capsules, and more particularly to special form capsules.
Special form capsules are containers for radioactive material particularly during transport, that must be sealable and leak proof. The capsules must also withstand the pressure and heat that can be generated in the capsule by radioactive decay. Additionally, such containers can only be opened by destroying the capsule, per 49 CFR 173.403.
A problem with current special form capsules is that some designs require welding to close and seal the container. A properly welded special form capsule offers an excellent seal with a very low leak rate and robust structural integrity. Welding is not an option in all circumstances that call for the use of special form capsules. The environments in which the capsule contents are sealed often preclude the use of welding for a variety of reasons. For example, the environment may contain flammable items which would be ignited by the welding arc. Welding equipment for these capsules can be significantly more expensive and bulkier than that for alternative methods of sealing. The welding equipment, its settings and related fixturing generally require more customization and more time to develop than alternative sealing methods. Welding equipment requires training and expertise to operate. The welding operation and subsequent finishing takes more time to complete than the alternative methods. The materials of the capsule also must be suitable for welding.
Attempts have been made to produce an alternative design of special form capsule that do not require welding. Some previous attempts at non-welded special form capsules rely on a threaded connection to apply pressure between two tapered surfaces. The resulting seal is steadily weakened with increasing pressure, and eventually releases some of the internal pressure and then reseals. It is not visually obvious afterward that this has occurred. The screw thread and tapered surfaces do not seal as consistently, and do not achieve as low a leak rate as some other designs.
A screw-loaded tapered plug seal has been provided for special form capsules. This capsule seals by means of a tapered (conical) plug which is pressed against a matching tapered cavity in the housing via a screw cap. The maximum amount of torque applied is limited to that which is sufficient to shear off the knob. The knob of the screw cap, which has flats, is turned with a wrench. The angle of the tapers of the plug and housing must match very closely to create a good seal. In practice, this is difficult and contributes to very inconsistent sealing performance. The friction in the screw threads can vary significantly, although the proper use of the capsule involves the use of a special grease to help mitigate this issue. The variance in the friction causes a corresponding variance in the force pressing the plug against the housing, contributing to inconsistent sealing performance. Once the plug is pushed into the housing, it is important for the screw cap not to back off the plug so adequate sealing pressure is maintained at the sealing surface. If the screw backs off, which has occurred during testing, sealing performance is reduced significantly or entirely. If the screw cap maintains its angular position while the housing experiences internal pressure (normally due to an increase in temperature), the plug is initially prevented from moving away from the sealing surface. However, as the internal pressure is increased, the plug and screw cap are compressed, while the housing is enlarged, eventually causing the interface pressure at the sealing surface to reduce to the point that the internal pressure bypasses the plug, and a leak occurs. In addition to that, once the capsule has relieved enough of its internal pressure, the housing, plug and screw cap relax toward their original volumes, thus resealing the capsule. It is possible for this capsule to leak out some of its contents, to reseal and not to have any visible signs of having failed on the outside. The sealing surface of the plug and housing, though reasonably large and tolerant of a small amount of debris, still constitute only one sealing interface. If the one interface fails, the whole capsule fails.
A screw-loaded metal o-ring seal has been provided for special form capsules. This capsule seals by means of a metal o-ring which is pressed against a mating surface in the housing via a screw cap. The maximum amount of torque applied is limited to that which is sufficient to shear off the knob on the cap, and the amount of compression of the o-ring is limited by a step in the cap. The knob of the screw cap is turned with a wrench. Although this design has been made to work, the sealing interfaces between the cap, housing and o-ring consist of very narrow regions of contact. Thus, the surfaces where that contact occurs are very sensitive to debris and surface defects. The required care with these surfaces is very difficult in some environments. Once the o-ring is compressed, it is important for the screw cap not to back off so adequate sealing pressure is maintained at the sealing surface. If the screw backs off, the sealing performance is reduced significantly or entirely. The sealing performance has shown signs of weakening during DOT regulatory testing, particularly after the drop test.
A key cap metal o-ring seal has been provided for special form capsules. This capsule seals by means of a metal o-ring which is pressed against a mating surface in the housing using a press to push the cap into position. Once the spring-loaded keys in the cap reach the locking grooves in the housing, they extend and thereby trap the cap in position with the o-ring in a compressed state. The sealing interfaces between the cap, housing and o-ring consist of very narrow regions of contact. Thus, the surfaces where the contact occurs are very sensitive to debris and surface defects. The required care with these surfaces is very difficult in some environments. This design has a significant number of parts and would be more expensive to make. Because this design relies on a metal o-ring for sealing, the sealing performance would likely weaken during DOT regulatory testing, particularly after the drop test.
A capsule for maintaining containment of a substance within a predetermined volume includes a housing having a tubular shape and walls with an inside surface. The housing has at least one open end. A cap is configured to be assembled coaxially to the housing. The cap can include a top and a plug configured to be inside the housing when the cap is assembled to the housing through the open end. An outer surface of the plug is dimensioned to engage an adjacent inside surface of the housing in an interference fit of the cap with the housing.
The plug can include a first interference side portion and a first trough. The plug can further include a first interference protrusion. The first interference protrusion can have an outside diameter greater than the outside diameter of the first interference side portion. The first trough can be positioned between the first interference side portion and the first interference protrusion.
The capsule can further include a second interference side portion and a second trough. The plug can also include a second interference protrusion. The second interference protrusion can have an outside diameter greater than the outside diameter of the second interference side portion. The outside diameter of the second interference side portion can be greater than the outside diameter of the first interference side portion, and the outside diameter of the second interference protrusion can be greater than the outside diameter of the first interference protrusion.
The housing can include a plurality of inner interference surfaces comprising a plurality of inside diameters, and the inside diameters can decrease from the open end. The plug can include a relief. The relief has an outside diameter less than the outside diameter of the first trough and the second trough. The relief can be positioned between the first interference side portion and the second interference side portion to permit flexing of the plug.
The cap can include a flange configured to abut the open end of the housing when the cap is assembled to the housing. The plug can extend from the flange. At least a portion of the plug can have a tubular shape with an open interior. An outer surface of the plug can have a relief to enable flexing of the tubular portion of the plug. The plug in one embodiment can be solid.
The housing can include one of a first material and a second material, and the cap can include the other of the first material and the second material. The second material can have a higher yield strength than the first material. The yield strength of the first material can be at least 10% below the yield strength of the second material. The second material can have a higher thermal coefficient of thermal expansion than the first material. The coefficient of thermal expansion of the first material can be no more than 20% lower than the coefficient of thermal expansion of the second material. The coefficient of thermal expansion of the first material can be no more than 5% higher or lower than the coefficient of thermal expansion of the second material. A friction coefficient at an interface between the first and second materials at a first temperature can be equal to or greater than the coefficient of friction at a second temperature.
The first material can include austenitic-stainless steels, and the second material can include nickel-based super alloys. The first material can be annealed 304 stainless steel, and the second material can be annealed Nitronic 60. The first material can be Ta, and the second material can be Ti.
The capsule can be a special form capsule. The housing can include one or more a grooves disposed at its open end. The grooves are configured to vent, when the cap is assembled to the housing, gas trapped between the housing and the outer surface of the plug. The capsule maintains a vacuum seal.
In one embodiment, the plug has an end with an outer circumferential portion, and the housing comprises a ledge on the inner surface. The outer circumferential portion can be configured to engage the ledge with the plug is assembled into the housing.
A method for sealing a capsule includes the step of providing a housing having a tubular shape and walls with an inside surface. The housing has at least one open end. A cap is configured to be assembled coaxially to the housing. The cap includes a top and a plug configured to be inside the housing when the cap is assembled to the housing through the open end, wherein an outer surface of the plug is dimensioned to engage an adjacent inside surface of the housing in an interference fit of the cap with the housing. The cap is assembled to the housing by positioning the plug through the open end of the housing such that an outer surface of the plug engages an inside surface of the housing in an interference fit.
The plug can include a first interference side portion, a first trough, and a first interference protrusion. The first interference protrusion can have an outside diameter greater than the outside diameter of the first interference side portion. The method can include engaging the first interference side portion and the first interference protrusion to corresponding inside surfaces of the housing in interference fits, such that portions of the housing will be moved into the first trough.
The plug can further include a second interference side portion, a second trough, and a second interference protrusion. The second interference protrusion can have an outside diameter greater than the outside diameter of the second interference side portion. The outside diameter of the second interference side portion can be greater than the outside diameter of the first interference side portion, and the outside diameter of the second interference protrusion can be greater than the outside diameter of the first interference protrusion. The method can further include the step of engaging the second interference side portion and the second interference protrusion to corresponding inside surfaces of the housing in interference fits, such that portions of the housing will be moved into the second trough.
The cap can be engaged to the housing in a process in which one of the cap and the housing is taken to a temperature different to the other of the cap and the housing. The cap is assembled to the housing, and then the assembled cap and housing are taken to the same temperature, whereupon the cap will engage the housing in an interference fit.
There are shown in the drawings embodiments that are presently preferred it being understood that the invention is not limited to the arrangements and instrumentalities shown, wherein:
A capsule for maintaining containment of a substance within a predetermined volume includes a housing having a tubular shape and walls with an inside surface. The housing has at least one open end. A cap is configured to be assembled coaxially to the housing. The cap includes a top and a plug configured to be inside the housing when the cap is assembled to the housing through the open end. An outer surface of the plug is dimensioned to engage an adjacent inside surface of the housing in an interference fit of the cap with the housing.
The plug can comprise structure which facilitates the interference fit. Such structure can include interference side portions which have diameters greater than corresponding diameters of the housing. Interference protrusions have diameters that are greater than the diameters of the interference side portions, but with a reduced height. One or more troughs can be provided which have diameters less than the diameters of the interference side portions and the interference protrusions. The troughs accept housing material which may bulge outward from the housing as the result of the strain created by the interference fit. The number, dimensions (diameter, width) and position on the plug of such features can vary.
There are two separate diameters in the housing that interfere with the cap. In each of these there are two regions of interference. The interference protrusion has a greater interference and is designed to exceed the yield strength of the housing to flow around the interference protrusion and create a better seal. The interference side portion has a lesser interference and is intended primarily to help secure the cap to the housing.
The cap can create additional sealing with sufficient internal pressure. The plug can include a relief. The plug can have a tubular region with a relief having a reduced diameter that allows for some flexing. The relief has an outside diameter less than the outside diameter of the troughs, the interference side portions and the interference protrusions. The relief can be positioned to permit flexing of the plug when the capsule is pressurized. The flexing enhances the interference fit, and the enhancement can be such that the force required to remove the cap is greater than the force required to press the cap into the housing and create the interference fit. Once the capsule is pressurized internally, and if there is sufficient pressure, this design feature generates additional sealing, or grip, to resist the internal pressure forcing out the cap because the region below the relief flares outward, pushing ever harder against the housing with increasing pressure. This pressure sealing effect works in a metal special form capsule to increase the capacity to hold internal pressure. The benefit provided by this feature is extra resistance to internal pressure above that provided by the interference fits. It is possible with this design feature to have a higher resistance (grip) to internal pressure than the force required to insert the cap initially.
Once the capsule is pressurized internally, and if there is sufficient pressure, this design generates additional sealing, or grip, to resist the internal pressure forcing out the cap because the region below the relief flares outward, pushing ever harder against the housing with increasing pressure. This pressure sealing effect works in a metal special form capsule to increase the capacity to hold internal pressure. It is possible with this design feature to have a higher resistance (grip) to internal pressure than the force required to insert the cap initially.
The plug can include a first interference side portion and a first trough. The plug can include a first interference protrusion. The first interference protrusion can have an outside diameter greater than the outside diameter of the first interference side portion. The first trough can be positioned between the first interference side portion and the first interference protrusion. The capsule can include a second interference side portion, a second trough, and a second interference protrusion. The second interference protrusion can have an outside diameter greater than the outside diameter of the second interference side portion. The outside diameter of the second interference side portion can be greater than the outside diameter of the first interference side portion, and the outside diameter of the second interference protrusion can be greater than the outside diameter of the first interference protrusion.
Each cap has four different surfaces that interfere with the housing. The benefit provided by this redundancy is that there are four points of failure before a leak occurs. The interference protrusions have a higher interference fit and a significantly smaller area than the other two. The interference protrusions are configured to create stresses in the housing that exceed the yield strength of its material but not in the cap. The benefit provided is that the housing material flows around the interference protrusions in the cap to enhance the seal already provided by the interferences.
The housing can include a plurality of inner interference surfaces comprising a plurality of inside diameters, and which correspond to the interference side portions and interference protrusions of the plug. The dimensions of the corresponding inside diameters of the housing in general can be less than the outside diameters of the corresponding interference side portions and interference protrusions, such that an interference fit is created when the plug is pressed into the housing. The inside diameters can decrease from the open end.
The cap can take various forms. The interior of the plug can be solid or hollow. At least a portion of the plug can have a tubular shape with an open interior. The top can span the open interior of the plug to provide a sealing cap construction. The cap can include a flange on the cap that is configured to abut the open end of the housing when the cap is assembled to the housing, the plug extending from the flange. The flange can participate in the formation of the seal.
The housing has a tubular shape with a hollow interior. The cross-section of the tubular shape can take different forms. The cross-section can be tubular, square or rectangular. Other shapes are possible. The dimensions of the housing in height and width can also vary.
The housing can be made of one of a first material and a second material. The cap can be made of the other of the first material and the second material. The second material can have a higher yield strength than the first material. The yield strength of the first material can be at least 10% below the yield strength of the second material. In one embodiment the cap is comprised of the second material and has a higher yield strength than does the material making up the housing.
One of the first material and the second material can have a higher thermal coefficient of thermal expansion than the other material. The coefficient of thermal expansion for the two materials must not differ enough, throughout the entire operating temperature range, to significantly reduce the designed interference of the sealing surfaces. For instance, in some implementations, the coefficient of thermal expansion of the first material can be no more than 20% lower than the coefficient of thermal expansion of the second material. The coefficient of thermal expansion of the first material can be no more than 5% higher or lower than the coefficient of thermal expansion of the second material.
The materials selected for the cap and housing are not only based on their yield strengths to accommodate the function of the interference protrusions, but consideration is also given to ensure that the coefficient of friction between the two materials increases (preferred) or at least does not diminish with increasing temperature. A friction coefficient at an interface between the first and second materials at a first temperature can be equal to or greater than the coefficient of friction at a second temperature. The benefit provided is that the grip of the seal joint is uncompromised due to increased temperature.
One of the first material and second material can include austenitic-stainless steels, and the other of the first material and the second material can include nickel-based super alloys. The first material can be annealed 304 stainless steel, and the second material can be annealed Nitronic 60. The first material can be Ta, and the second material can be Ti.
The capsule can be a special form capsule. The housing can include one or more laterally directed grooves disposed at its open end. The grooves are configured to vent, when the cap is assembled to the housing, gas trapped between the housing and the outer surface of the plug.
Because the capsule can contain magnitudes of pressure which far exceed that of vacuum, and because the capsule seal has a very low helium leak rate, the capsule can provide an effective vacuum seal throughout its entire operating range.
The plug can have an end with an outer circumferential portion, and the housing can include a ledge on the inner surface. The outer circumferential portion is configured to engage the ledge with the plug is assembled into the housing.
A method for sealing a capsule can include the step of providing a housing having a tubular shape and walls with an inside surface, wherein the housing has at least one open end. A cap configured to be assembled coaxially to the housing is provided. The cap includes a top and a plug configured to be inside the housing when the cap is assembled to the housing through the open end. An outer surface of the plug is dimensioned to engage an adjacent inside surface of the housing in an interference fit of the cap with the housing. The cap is assembled to the housing by positioning the plug through the open end of the housing such that an outer surface of the plug engages an inside surface of the housing in an interference fit.
The seal is accomplished by inserting the cap into the housing. This can be done by using a press to force the cap into the housing (press-fit) or by creating a sufficient temperature difference between the cap and housing to allow for insertion of the cap into the housing without a press (shrink-fit). This can also be accomplished by some combination of press and shrink fits, as long as the designed interferences are achieved.
The plug can include a first interference side portion, a first trough, and a first interference protrusion, the first interference protrusion having an outside diameter greater than the outside diameter of the first interference side portion. The method includes the step of engaging the first interference side portion and the first interference protrusion to corresponding inside surfaces of the housing in interference fits, such that portions of the housing will be moved into the first trough. The method can also include providing a plug which further includes a second interference side portion, a second trough, and a second interference protrusion. The second interference protrusion has an outside diameter greater than the outside diameter of the second interference side portion, and wherein the outside diameter of the second interference side portion is greater than the outside diameter of the first interference side portion, and the outside diameter of the second interference protrusion is greater than the outside diameter of the first interference protrusion. The method includes the step of engaging the second interference side portion and the second interference protrusion to corresponding inside surfaces of the housing in interference fits, such that portions of the housing will be moved into the second trough.
The interference fits and the lower region of the cap also provide superior resistance to internally-generated pressure in the capsule. Further, pressing capsules together requires less equipment and training than welding them. The interference-fit capsule sealing does not weaken with increasing internal pressure, but rather it fails suddenly, and the cap moves relative to the housing to give a visual indication of failure.
Additionally, the housing has vent grooves to eliminate false positives during leak testing. The vent grooves can be at the top of the housing. These vent any small volume of gas that gets trapped above the interferences between the housing and cap during insertion. The benefit provided is the possibility of false positives during leak testing is eliminated.
Testing was performed which included all three of the relevant DOT regulatory tests (impact, percussive and heat) for each capsule. The helium leak rate for capsules was <1E−8 Atm-cc/s, which is substantially less than the requirement of <2E−8 Atm-cc/s. Hydrostatic testing resulted in excellent retention of internal pressure, substantially exceeding predictions. This is an indication that the self-energizing pressure seal works as intended. Initially, the capsule is sealed by means of several interferences between the cap and housing. Interference fits (press or shrink) enable achievement of low rates of leakage (<1E−4 Atm-cc/s) with interference fits in special form capsules. In four tested capsules, the leak rates were all <2E−8 Atm-cc/s, even after all three DOT regulatory tests (impact, percussive and heat) were performed on each capsule. It should be noted that air can be expected to leak at a lower rate than helium.
Sealing the capsule requires that the cap be pressed into the housing with a press or else assembled as a shrink fit. The press can be a standardized press or one that is specially manufactured for this purpose. Opening the capsule is expected to occur by sawing through the housing at the indicator groove. The term “special form capsule” (SFC) dictates that opening the capsule must have obvious changes (damage) to the capsule afterward.
There is shown in
The plug 108 can also include a second interference side portion 120. The second interference side portion 120 has an outside diameter that is greater than the outside diameter of the first interference side portion 109. The plug 108 can also include a second trough 122 adjacent the second interference side portion 120. The second trough 122 has an outside diameter that is less than the outside diameter of the second interference side portion 120. A second interference protrusion 124 can also be provided. The second interference protrusion 124 as an outside diameter that is greater than the outside diameter of the second interference side portion 120, and also greater than the outside diameter of the first interference protrusion 114.
The cap 102 can further include a relief 126. The relief 126 permits the flexing of the plug 108 under internal pressure within the capsule to further engage the housing in the interference fit. The relief 126 permits the first interference side portion 109 below the relief 126 to flex laterally outward.
The housing 104 is generally tubular and includes tubular side wall 130 and base 132 defining an open interior 133 with a first interference wall surface 136. Housing 104 has an open end 134. The cap 102 can further comprise a flange 111 for abutting and engaging the open end 134 of the housing 104. Adjacent the open end 134, the first interference wall surface 136 is dimensioned to engage portions of the plug 108 in an interference fit. The interference fit is shown in various stages in
As shown in
As shown in
As the cap 102 is pressed further into the housing 104, the first interference protrusion 114 will engage the first interference wall surface 136 of the housing wall 130 (
As the cap 102 is pressed still further into the housing 104, the second interference protrusion 124 will engage the bevel 142 and ultimately will be pressed into the second interference wall surface 138 as shown in
The number of interference side portions and corresponding interference wall surfaces can vary. Also, although the second interference wall surface 138 is shown as having a greater diameter than the first interference wall surface 136 of the housing wall 130, it is possible to have only a single interference wall surface diameter that engages with multiple interference side portions and interference protrusions.
There is shown in
As shown in
The seal created by the invention will be very tight and it will be difficult to remove the cap 102 from the housing 104. A groove or depression 195 can be provided to facilitate the cutting open of the sealed capsule 100. A special form capsule should show evidence of tampering or opening. The breaking of the capsule at the groove 195 will be evidence of such tampering.
During assembly, gases will sometimes be trapped between the cap 102 and the housing 104 outside the intended sealing surface such as in the space above the second interference protrusion 124. Vents 197 (
Other constructions are possible which can take advantage of the coefficient of thermal expansion. As shown in
In this embodiment, an outside surface 214 of the cap 202 is spaced from the recessed inside wall surface 216 of the housing 204. The cap 202 is shown extending above the housing 204, however, the cap 202 can also be flush with the top of the housing 204.
The cap 202 and the housing 204 are made of different materials with different coefficients of thermal expansion. In the embodiment shown in
It is also possible to utilize the coefficient of thermal expansion of the materials making the cap 202 and the housing 204 to make an interference fit even where the coefficients of thermal expansion are the same, in a form of shrink fit process. In such a process, only one of the cap or the housing is taken to a temperature different from that of the other of the cap or the housing. The cap and the housing are then assembled into a capsule, and both the cap and the housing are allowed to normalize to the same temperature, for example room temperature. At this temperature, the cap will engage the housing in an interference fit.
The invention as shown in the drawings and described in detail herein disclose arrangements of elements of particular construction and configuration for illustrating preferred embodiments of structure and method of operation of the present invention. It is to be understood however, that elements of different construction and configuration and other arrangements thereof, other than those illustrated and described may be employed in accordance with the spirit of the invention, and such changes, alternations and modifications as would occur to those skilled in the art are considered to be within the scope of this invention as broadly defined in the appended claims. In addition, it is to be understood that the phraseology and terminology employed herein are for the purpose of description and should not be regarded as limiting.
This application claims priority to U.S. 63/074,698 filed on Sep. 4, 2020, entitled “Press-Fit Special Form Capsule”, the entire disclosure of which incorporated herein by reference.
This invention was made with government support under Contract No. DE-AC05-00OR22725 awarded by the U.S. Department of Energy. The government has certain rights in this invention.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
63074698 | Sep 2020 | US |