Patent Application
20230398522
The present invention pertains to catalytic hydrogenation in the gas phase or liquid phase of organic carbonyl compounds in the presence of a catalyst comprising Cu, Zn and Al. It also pertains to a method of preparing such a catalyst and to the catalyst obtainable by the method.
Organic carbonyl compounds are those organic compounds which contain at least one C═O group such as aldehydes, ketones, esters and carboxylic acids.
Catalytic hydrogenation of organic carbonyl compounds to their corresponding alcohols is an important reaction in the chemical industry. Aldehydes, ketones, esters and carboxylic acids can be hydrogenated to alcohols. The process is employed for the manufacture of important alcohols such as 1-propanol and 2-propanol, n-butanol and iso-butanol, 2-ethylhexanol, fatty alcohols, various glycols and diols and many more. For many years, it has been common practice in the chemical industry to use catalysts containing environmentally problematic compounds such as chromium and nickel. Although the more benign Cu/Zn/Al catalysts have catalytic activity for these reactions, it has hitherto not been possible to make Cu/Zn/Al catalyst formulations with sufficient mechanical strength, chemical inertness and catalytic activity and selectivity to replace Cr- or Ni-containing catalysts in industrial applications.
A frequently used Cu-based catalyst for hydrogenation of organic carbonyl compounds is Adkins catalyst, often called copper chromite in the industry. The chromium is beneficial for the mechanical strength of the catalyst, but it is an environmental and health concern. Ni-catalysts are also employed in the catalytic hydrogenation of carbonyl compounds to alcohols. Hydrogenation catalysts based on Ni are inherently more active than the Cu-based catalysts but are typically less selective.
Furthermore, nickel compounds may cause allergy and are classified as human carcinogens. In some hydrogenation processes, Cu-catalysts can replace Ni-catalysts provided that the former has sufficient activity, selectivity, mechanical stability and chemical inertness.
U.S. Pat. No. 10,226,760 regards a method for producing a shaped Cu—Zn catalyst for hydrogenating organic compounds containing a carbonyl function. The shaped catalyst is suitable for hydrogenating aldehydes, ketones and also carboxylic acids and/or their esters. It also regards Cu—Zn catalysts obtainable by the production process.
In U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,142,067 and 5,008,235 a process and catalysts are disclosed for hydrogenating organic feeds containing bound oxygen into their corresponding alcohols.
U.S. Pat. No. 6,455,464 discloses a non-chrome, copper-containing catalyst and a method of preparing the same.
Commercially available catalysts of the Cu/Zn/Al kind usually have a high Cu-content and contain significant amounts of free ZnO. These catalysts have low mechanical strength, which precludes their use in hydrogenation reactions. Furthermore, these known catalysts are sensitive to carboxylic acids, since carboxylic acids tend to react with zinc oxide under the reaction conditions, thus deteriorating the catalyst. Furthermore, state of the art Cu/Zn/Al catalysts do not have sufficiently stable activity, resulting in a relatively short catalyst lifetime.
In U.S. Pat. No. 5,142,067 Cu—Al—X catalysts for hydrogenation are disclosed having a high copper content. The third metal may be zinc.
In Shi Zhangping et al., “Effects of the preparation method on the performance of the Cu/ZnO/Al2O3 catalyst for the manufacture of L-phenylalaninol with high ee selectivity from L-phenylalanine methyl ester”, Catal. Sci. Technol., vol. 4, 1 Jan. 2014. In Shi et al., Cu/Zn/Al catalyst compositions are produced by fractional coprecipitation which in its oxidized form has no or very little spinel phase. Shi et al. conclude that lower calcination temperatures provide higher copper surface areas which provide higher activities and/or selectivities. A calcination temperature of 450° C. is exemplified. It is evident from their
EP 0 011 150 discloses a Cu/Zn/Al catalyst for synthesis of methanol.
However, there is still a need for industrially applicable catalyst compositions useful in hydrogenation of biobased feeds and in particular of organic carbonyl compounds present in biobased feeds. The invention also regards the use of potassium or sodium aluminates for preparing catalyst compositions useful in industrial hydrogenation of biobased feeds.
The present inventors have developed a novel and improved catalyst composition for catalytic hydrogenation of organic carbonyl compounds. They developed an improved process for producing the catalyst composition which provided an improved internal structure to improve activity, selectivity, stability and mechanical strength without using harmful elements such as nickel or chromium.
According to an aspect of the present invention a catalyst composition is provided for catalytic hydrogenation of an organic carbonyl compound, the composition comprising in its oxidized form 12-38% by weight of Cu, 13-35% by weight of Zn, and 12-30% by weight of Al; and the composition having a molar ratio of Zn:Al in the range 0.24-0.60; and the composition comprising in its oxidized form at least 50% by weight of a spinel structure as determined by X-ray diffraction (XRD).
The catalysts of the present invention are particularly appropriate for hydrogenation of organic carbonyl compounds to their corresponding alcohols. The catalysts obtained according to the present invention comprise, in their active form, metallic Cu and ZnAl2O4 as the main components as observed by XRD. An important advantageous feature of the invention is that the catalyst contains, in its active (reduced) form, a limited amount of free zinc oxide. It is characteristic for the catalyst of the present invention that on calcination of the catalyst precursor, a mixed Cu/Zn spinel is formed, which transforms gradually at increasing temperatures in an O2-containing atmosphere to CuO and ZnAl2O4.
The catalysts are additionally characterized by their high activity, selectivity and high mechanical strength and by being free of elements such as chromium and nickel, which are hazardous to human health and the environment. In addition, the catalyst composition according to the invention has an improved catalytic stability in the sense that it retains its hydrogenation activity for a prolonged period of time. All these advantages make the catalyst compositions according to the present invention highly suitable for industrial applications.
The inventors found an improved process for preparing the catalyst according to the invention. They found that combining the features of a new aluminium source with selecting certain relative ranges of copper, zinc and aluminium—upon calcination—resulted in surprisingly good catalysts for use in industrial hydrogenation processes. They also surprisingly found that for the disclosed compositions there is an optimal calcination range—which is higher than expected. The improved characteristics are disclosed throughout the document.
According to another aspect of the present invention a method is provided for preparing an oxidized form of a catalyst composition for catalytic hydrogenation of an organic carbonyl compound comprising the steps of:
The inventors found that following this method resulted in the improved catalytic compositions described herein. In particular, they found that using alkali aluminate as aluminum source, dissolving it in a basic solution and coprecipitating it with an acidic solution comprising copper and zinc ions, provided an improved precursor which upon calcination at 250-900° C. provided catalyst compositions having much higher amounts of spinel phase than prior art Cu/Zn/Al catalysts. In particular, the inventors found that at lower calcination temperatures in the range of from 250 to 550° C. most copper and zinc would be bound as a mixed spinel of the type CuxZn1-xAl2O4. The spinel phase may make up as much as above 90% by weight of the catalyst composition as determined by XRD at the lower calcination temperatures in the range of 250-550° C. Without being bound by theory, the inventors hypothesize that an advantage of this is that upon reduction (activation) of the catalyst, the metallic Cu particles forming the active phase in the catalyst are born from copper ions in the spinel structure, which leads to well dispersed Cu nano particles. Furthermore, the inventors hypothesize that upon calcination at higher temperatures, e.g. at 600° C., well dispersed CuO nano particles will form, which similarly will lead to well dispersed Cu nano particles upon reduction (activation). Another advantage is that the zinc spinel formed after activation of the catalyst provides a higher and more stable surface area to disperse the Cu nano particles than zinc oxide does, leading to a higher stability compared to prior art catalysts. In fact, ZnAl2O4 seems to form smaller particles than ZnO, given the same calcination temperature.
As the skilled person will know, the aluminate ion of step ii. is only stable at high pH. Accordingly, it should be dissolved in a strongly basic solution such as an alkali hydroxide solution and/or an alkali carbonate solution. The Cu and Zn solution of i. is acidic. Both solutions are preferably aqueous solutions. The coprecipitation may be conducted by mixing equal volumes of i. and ii. and adjusting the pH to remain around a neutral pH. In the present context “neutral pH” is meant to refer to a pH in the range of from 6-9. The coprecipitation step a. may be conducted at a pH in the range of 6-12, such as in the range of 6-9, 7-9, 7.2-9, or 7.5-8.5.
In the method according to the present invention, the use of NaAlO2 and similar aluminate salts seems to lead to the direct precipitation of a mixed Cu—Zn spinel phase, exemplified by the reaction
Cu2++Zn2++4AlO2−=2(Cu0.5Zn0.5)Al2O4
Without being bound by theory it is hypothesized that this is the key to obtaining the improved hydrogenation catalysts of the invention
According to another aspect of the present invention a process is provided for hydrogenating a carbonyl group of an organic carbonyl compound into its corresponding hydroxyl group, the process comprising contacting the organic carbonyl compound with a reduced form of the catalyst composition according to an aspect of the invention, in the presence of hydrogen to obtain an alcohol corresponding to said organic carbonyl compound.
According to an aspect of the present invention a use is provided of the catalyst according to the present invention, for hydrogenation of a feed comprising at least two of the carbonyl compounds selected from the group comprising formaldehyde, glycolaldehyde, glyoxal, pyruvic aldehyde and acetol.
The inventors found that all the advantages related to the catalyst according to the invention made it highly suitable for use in hydrogenation of biobased feedstocks and in particular of feedstocks derived from thermolytic fragmentation of sugars. In particular for industrial scale hydrogenation.
According to another aspect of the present invention a use is provided of alkali aluminate, such as potassium aluminate or sodium aluminate, for preparing a catalyst composition for hydrogenation reactions.
The inventors found that using alkali aluminate as aluminum source, dissolving it in a basic solution and coprecipitating it with an acidic solution comprising copper and zinc ions, provided an improved precursor which upon calcination at 250-900° C. provided catalyst compositions having much higher amounts of spinel phase than prior art Cu/Zn/Al catalysts. In particular, the inventors found that at lower calcination temperatures in the range of 250-550° C. most copper and zinc would be bound as a mixed spinel of the type CuxZn1-xAl2O4. The spinel phase may make up as much as above 90% by weight of the catalyst composition as determined by XRD at the lower calcination temperatures in the range of 250-550° C. Without being bound by theory, the inventors hypothesize that an advantage of this is that Cu is retained in the spinel structure and only upon heating above 450° C. a phase transition takes place resulting in a fraction of the copper particles transforming into copper oxide. This somehow seems to result in a higher dispersion of the copper oxide compared to prior art catalyst compositions.
In the context of the present invention when referring to X-ray diffraction (XRD) this is meant to refer to XRD analysis yielding phase composition and lattice parameters, for example carried out based on powder X-ray diffraction measured in Bragg-Brentano geometry, with Cu Kα radiation, and analyzed using a full profile Rietveld analysis. Such analysis will indicate the size of the crystals in the powder analyzed. The larger the crystals of the materials, the more narrow the X-ray diffractogram peaks.
When referring to the content of metals present in the catalyst, such contents may be calculated by elemental analysis, such as by the ICP-OES method.
The copper surface area, SA(Cu), may be determined by surface titration of the catalyst in its reduced form with nitrous oxide; the so-called N2O-RFC method as explained in S. Kuld et al. Angewandte Chemie 53 (2014), 5941-5945
Pore volumes (PV) may be determined by the mercury intrusion method. The mercury intrusion is conducted according to ASTM D4284.
Mechanical strength is measured as the Side Crush Strength (SCS) according to ASTM D4179-11.
Acid resistance may be determined by the acid resistance test involving boiling of pre-reduced and passivated catalyst in butyl benzoate/benzoic acid/water for 24 hours and then visually inspecting how much of the catalyst was intact, retaining its overall geometrical shape.
In the present context “catalyst precursor”, “catalytic precursor composition” “precursor” and “precursor composition” all refer to the composition obtained after coprecipitation and drying but before calcination.
In the present context “catalyst”, “composition for catalytic hydrogenation”, catalytic composition” and “catalyst composition” all refer to the composition after calcination. The catalyst is in its oxidized when in an oxidizing atmosphere, such as air or its reduced (active) form when in a reducing atmosphere, such as hydrogen gas. The reduced form is the form where the composition is considered catalytically active in hydrogenation reactions.
Catalytic Composition and Preparation Thereof
In an embodiment of the present invention, the catalysts do not contain Cr or Ni. In an embodiment according to the present invention the catalyst composition in its oxidized form comprises less than 0.01 Wt % Ni and/or less than 0.01 Wt % Cr. The inventive catalysts comprise, in their oxidized form, oxides of Cu, Zn and Al.
Said catalyst comprising Cu, Zn and Al and further being characterized, in its oxidized form, by
In an embodiment of the method according to the invention the aluminate salt may be provided as an alkali aluminate selected from the group consisting of lithium, sodium, potassium, rubidium and cesium. It is considered within the capabilities of the skilled person to identify suitable sources of Cu and Zn. Particularly suitable are nitrate salts of Cu and Zn. It is also considered within the capabilites of the skilled person to estimale the releative amounts of the Cu, Zn and aluminate sources required to achieve the desired relative amounts of Cu, Zn and Al.
By limiting the Zn/Al molar ratio to the range 0.24-0.60, the amount of free ZnO in the active catalyst is limited since most of the Zn is bound in a spinel structure which is much less reactive towards acids than ZnO and which furthermore has a higher and more stable surface area than ZnO, thus providing a better support to disperse the Cu nano particles formed upon activation of the catalyst. According to an embodiment of the present invention catalyst composition comprises in its oxidized form less than 15% by weight of ZnO, such as less than 13, 11, 9, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1% by weight of ZnO. By calcination at a temperature of at least 250° C., such as between 350° C. and 700° C. or preferably between 550° C. and 700° C., a spinel phase is formed which has improved mechanical strength, improved thermal stability (less sintering) and improved tolerance towards e.g. carboxylic acids. Without being bound by theory, it is hypothesized that the high amount of spinel phase and the resulting minimal sintering provides a large surface area for the Cu crystals to disperse on. Furthermore, limiting the Cu content to no more than 38% helps to ensure a sufficient mechanical strength in the catalysts of the invention.
In an embodiment of the method according to the invention the calcination of step b) of the catalyst precursor composition is conducted at a temperature Tcalc in the range of from 250-450° C. to obtain an oxidized form of a composition for catalytic hydrogenation of an organic carbonyl compound, the composition comprising in its oxidized form at least 75% by weight, such as at least 80% of a spinel structure as determined by X-ray diffraction.
In an embodiment, the method according to the invention has the calcining of the catalyst precursor composition to be conducted at a temperature Tcalc in the range of from 450-900° C., such as from 550-750° C. to obtain an oxidized form of a composition for catalytic hydrogenation of organic carbonyl compounds, the composition comprising in its oxidized form at least 50% by weight, such as at least 60% of a spinel structure as determined by X-ray diffraction.
In an embodiment, the method according to the invention has a percentage Z of visible CuO in the range of from 20% to 100%, defined as the percentage by weight of CuO according to XRD relative to the maximum possible percentage by weight of CuO calculated from the amount of Cu present in the catalyst precursor composition of step a).
The catalyst of the invention and the catalyst utilized in the process according to the invention is further characterized by a low content of zinc oxide (ZnO) as determined by powder X-ray diffraction (XRD). Free zinc oxide is sensitive to acids which may be present in the surroundings. Thus, the catalyst may deteriorate or lose mechanical strength in the presence of acids, if any significant amount of zinc oxide is present during hydrogenation/use. The key to achieving this low ZnO content is twofold. Thus, the Zn/Al molar ratio is in the range 0.24-0.60, such as in the range 0.40-0.499, which allows for the formation of zinc spinel (ZnAl2O4) with a Zn/Al ratio of 0.50, and calcination in the interval 250-900° C., such as 350-700° C., 450-800° C. or 550-700° C. ensures a high degree of spinel formation. The high content of zinc spinel ZnAl2O4 and the limited Cu-content ensures a high mechanical strength.
The catalyst composition may be defined by (in the oxidized form of the catalyst) a Cu-content in the range 12-38 wt %, such as 15-30 wt %, or such as 17-28 wt %, or such as 20-27%, and by a Zn/Al molar ratio in the range 0.24-0.60, such as in the range 0.30-0.55, or such as in the range 0.30-0.50, or such as in the range 0.40-0.499, where the content of zinc (as elemental Zn) is in the range 13-35 wt % and the content of aluminum (as elemental Al) is in the range 15-30 wt %. According to an embodiment of the present invention the catalyst composition has a molar ratio of Zn:Al in the range of from 0.30-0.55, such as from 0.35-0.50, or from 0.40-0.499. According to an embodiment of the present invention the catalyst composition comprises in its oxidized form 15-38% by weight of Cu, such as 15-28% or 18-28% or 20-25% by weight of Cu. According to an embodiment of the present invention the catalyst composition comprises in its oxidized form 13-24% by weight of Zn, such as 15-25% by weight of Zn. According to an embodiment of the present invention the catalyst composition comprises in its oxidized form 17-24% by weight of Al. According to an embodiment of the present invention the catalyst composition comprises in its oxidized form at least 60% by weight, such as at least 70%, 75%, 80%, 85% or 90% by weight of a spinel structure as determined by X-ray diffraction. Within these ranges high-performing catalyst compositions are obtained, but the optimal combination of those features may vary to some extent depending on the hydrogenation reaction to be catalyzed and the demands to catalyst stability, mechanical strength and chemical inertness.
In an embodiment of the invention, said catalyst has been exposed to a temperature Tcalc of between 250-900° C., such as between 350-700° C., 450-700° C., 450-800° C., 550-800° C.
In an embodiment of the invention, said catalyst has been exposed to a calcination temperature Tcalc, in the range of 550-700° C.
The oxidized form of the catalyst is the form obtained after calcination. The state of Cu depends on the calcination temperature, Tcalc, so that at low calcination temperature, typically in the interval 250-550° C., Cu forms a mixed spinel of the type CuxZn1-xAl2O4 with only a small amount of the Cu being present as CuO. In this case the color of the catalyst (in its oxidized form) can be described as olive green (See
Without being bound by theory, we believe that the phase transition that occurs in the oxidized forms of the catalysts of the invention when exposed to an O2-containing atmosphere from low temperature (e.g. 450° C.) to high temperature (e.g. 650° C.) (during calcination) can be described as follows for a catalyst with a Zn/Al ratio of 0.50 and a Cu/Zn ratio of x:
At low temperature, the ZnO present together with the mixed spinel phase is difficult to observe by XRD. This is probably due to a combination of low crystallinity of this phase and overlying diffraction peaks from the spinel phase.
It is important to note that the catalyst can be activated the same way no matter the calcination temperature and thus no matter the distribution of Cu(II) between the spinel phase and the cupric oxide (CuO) phase. Catalyst activation can be done e.g. by exposing the catalyst to a H2-containing gas at a temperature in the interval 100-250° C., whereby the Cu(II) ions in the two phases, CuxZn1-xAl2O4 and CuO, in both cases are transformed to elemental Cu.
On activation of the catalysts of the invention as e.g. by treatment with hydrogen at elevated temperature, elemental Cu is formed with high dispersion and thus high cupper surface area and accordingly high activity. Without being bound by theory, we believe that this high dispersion is a result of either small CuO particles formed in the above reaction by calcination at a temperature of 550-900° C., or is a result of reduction of the Cu(II) ions in the mixed spinel phase as in the catalysts calcined at 250-550° C. According to an embodiment of the present invention the catalyst composition has in its reduced form a copper metal surface area above 10 m2/g Cu, such as 10-30 or 10-20 m2/g Cu.
An important feature characterizing the oxidized form of the catalysts of the present invention is the percentage Z of XRD-visible CuO, defined as the percentage Wt % CuO according to XRD relative to the maximum possible Wt % CuO calculated from bulk elemental analysis (ICP or similar method):
Thus, Z is a measure of how much of the Cu is present as CuO. If all Cu is present as CuO, Z is 100% while if no CuO is visible by XRD, Z is 0%.
Z depends on the maximum temperature the catalyst has been exposed to in atmospheric air for a period of in the interval of 1 to 10 hours (Tcalc), so that
0<Z<0.125·Tcalc
where the unit of Tcalc is ° C. This inequality is a characteristic of the catalysts of the present invention.
In an embodiment, the method according to the invention has a percentage Z of visible CuO in the range of from 0.1 to 23%, defined as the percentage by weight of CuO according to XRD relative to the maximum possible percentage by weight of CuO calculated from the amount of Cu present in the catalyst precursor composition of step a).
The phase composition of the oxidized form of the catalysts of the invention depends on the calcination temperature. If calcined at a temperature in the range 250-550° C., a spinel phase, (possibly including small amounts of ZnO), accounts for 80-100% by weight of the catalyst in oxidized form according to X-ray diffraction (XRD), while if calcined at a temperature in the range 550-900° C., the spinel phase accounts for 50-100% by weight of the catalyst in oxidized form.
According to an aspect of the present invention an oxidized form of a catalyst composition is provided which is obtainable by any of the embodiments of the method for preparing the catalyst or which is obtainable by any of the embodiments of the catalyst composition disclosed herein.
According to another aspect of the present invention a catalyst precursor composition is provided which is obtainable by step a. of the method according to the invention. The catalyst precursor composition is suitable for preparing a catalyst composition suitable for catalytic hydrogenation of an organic carbonyl compound in an industrial setting.
According to yet another aspect of the present invention a reduced form of a catalyst composition is provided which is obtainable by reducing the catalyst composition according to any of the embodiments of the catalyst composition disclosed herein.
Tabletting
In an embodiment of the invention, tablets of said catalyst in its oxidized form have a radial crush strength, SCS, of between 25 and 150 kp/cm, said tablets having a tablet density in the range of 1.45-2.35 g/cm3, such as in the range of 1.65-2.35 g/cm3.
In an embodiment of the invention, tablets of said catalyst in its freshly reduced form have a radial crush strength of between 10 and 75 kp/cm, said tablets having a tablet density in the interval 1.45-2.35 g/cm3, such as in the range 1.65-2.35 g/cm3.
Catalytic Hydrogenation
Thus, this invention provides a process for the catalytic hydrogenation of organic carbonyl compounds containing at least one functional group belonging to the group of aldehydes, ketones, esters and carboxylic acids, whereby said at least one functional group is converted to an alcohol by contacting said carbonyl compound with hydrogen and a hydrogenation catalyst according to the present invention at elevated temperature and pressure.
The following examples serve to illustrate the invention. Comparative examples are included.
In the following examples it should be understood, that calcination is carried out by heating a sample of the catalyst, typically 1-10 gram, to the specified temperature for 4 hours. It should be noted that if the catalyst contains graphite, this will be combusted in air starting at around 550-600° C., contributing to increase the temperature in the catalyst. This effect is modest when handling small samples (1-10 gram) as can be observed by monitoring the temperature in the calcination crucible during calcination. When handling larger samples, excessive temperature rise must be prevented. Elemental analysis was carried out by the ICP-OES method. XRD analysis yielding phase composition and lattice parameters, was carried out based on powder X-ray diffraction measured in Bragg-Brentano geometry, with Cu Kα radiation, and analyzed using a full profile Rietveld analysis. See
Catalyst A was prepared by coprecipitation as follows. An aqueous solution containing 240 g Cu(NO3)2*2½H2O and 333 g Zn(NO3)2*6H2O was prepared and the volume was adjusted to 1 liter. Another solution containing 217 g NaAlO2, 42 g NaOH and 38 g Na2CO3*10H2O was prepared separately and the volume adjusted to 1 liter. Equal volumes of the two solutions were mixed at pH=8.0±0.2 using a third solution of Na2CO3*10H2O to continuously adjust the pH. After precipitation, the product was ripened for 1 hour at 85° C. The product was filtered, washed several times with hot water and dried at 100° C. The powder was mixed with 4 wt % graphite and shaped in the form of cylindrical tablets, 4.5 mm diameter×3.5 mm height, which were finally calcined at 450° C. The composition of the catalyst was 18.5 wt % Cu, 20.6 wt % Zn and 20.2 wt % Al. Calculated as the oxides, this corresponds to a content of 23.2 wt % CuO, 25.6 wt % ZnO and 38.2 wt % Al2O3. The Zn/Al molar ratio based on the analysis was thus 0.42. According to powder X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis, the sample contained (apart from the graphite) a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, while no CuO was visible. Measured as an average of 10 tablets, the tablet density was 1.88 g/cm3 and the radial crush strength was 49.3 kp/cm.
Catalyst B was prepared similarly to catalyst A but with an altered composition. Thus, the catalyst composition was found to be 23.5 wt % Cu, 19.8 wt % Zn and 18.6 wt % Al. Calculated as the oxides, this corresponds to a content of 29.4 wt % CuO, 24.6 wt % ZnO and 35.1 wt % Al2O3. The Zn/Al molar ratio based on the analysis was thus 0.44. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained (apart from graphite) a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, while no CuO was visible. Measured as an average of 10 tablets, the tablet density was 1.99 g/cm3 and the radial crush strength was 88.9 kp/cm.
Catalyst C was prepared similarly to catalyst A but with an altered composition. Thus, the catalyst composition was found to be 21.8 wt % Cu, 23.8 wt % Zn and 17.5 wt % Al. Calculated as the oxides, this corresponds to a content of 27.3 wt % CuO, 29.6 wt % ZnO and 33.1 wt % Al2O3. The Zn/Al molar ratio based on the analysis was thus 0.56. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained (apart from the graphite) a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, while no CuO was visible. By further heating to 900° C., the XRD phase composition was found to be 67% spinel, 4% ZnO and 29% CuO thus close to the theoretical amount of CuO of 27.3%.
Catalyst D450 was prepared similarly to catalyst A but with an altered composition. Thus, the catalyst composition was found to be 23.7 wt % Cu, 19.2 wt % Zn and 20.2 wt % Al. Calculated as the oxides, this corresponds to a content of 29.7 wt % CuO, 23.9 wt % ZnO and 38.2 wt % Al2O3. The Zn/Al molar ratio based on the analysis was thus 0.39. The dried precursor was calcined at 450° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained (apart from the graphite) a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, while no CuO was visible.
Catalyst D550 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst D450 by calcination at 550° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained (apart from the graphite) a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, while no CuO was visible. Prolonging the calcination to 50 hours at 550° C. caused a change in XRD phase composition, which at that point was found to be 92% spinel and 8% CuO.
Catalyst D650 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst D450 by calcination at 650° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained 90% of a spinel phase and 10% CuO. Prolonging the calcination to 50 hours at 650° C. caused a change in XRD phase composition, which at that point was found to be 82% spinel and 18% CuO.
Catalyst D750 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst D450 by calcination at 750° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained 79% of a spinel phase and 21% CuO. Prolonging the calcination to 50 hours at 750° C. caused only a slight change in XRD phase composition, which at that point was found to be 78% spinel and 22% CuO.
By further heating to 900° C., the XRD phase composition was found to be 73% spinel and 27% CuO thus approaching the theoretical amount of CuO of 29.7% as given in Example 4.
Catalyst E450 was prepared similarly to catalyst A but with an altered composition. Furthermore, the catalyst powder was not tablettized and was therefore not mixed with graphite. The catalyst composition was found to be 20.1 wt % Cu, 21.4 wt % Zn and 19.8 wt % Al. Calculated as the oxides, this corresponds to a content of 25.2 wt % CuO, 26.6 wt % ZnO and 37.4 wt % Al2O3. The Zn/Al molar ratio based on the analysis was thus 0.45. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained 91% of a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, and 9% CuO.
Catalyst E550 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst E450 by calcination at 550° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained 95% of a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, and 5% CuO. Prolonging the calcination to 50 hours at 550° C. caused a change in XRD phase composition, which at that point was found to be 92% spinel and 8% CuO.
Catalyst E600 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst E450 by calcination at 600° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained 83% of a spinel phase, 3% ZnO and 14% CuO.
Catalyst E650 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst E450 by calcination at 650° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained 86% of a spinel phase and 14% CuO. Prolonging the calcination to 50 hours at 650° C. caused a change in XRD phase composition, which at that point was found to be 81% spinel and 19% CuO.
Catalyst E750 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst E450 by calcination at 750° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained 79% of a spinel phase and 21% CuO. Prolonging the calcination to 50 hours at 750° C. caused a change in XRD phase composition, which at that point was found to be 78% spinel and 22% CuO.
By further heating to 900° C., the XRD phase composition was found to be 75% spinel and 25% CuO thus approaching the theoretical amount of CuO of 25.2% as given in Example 8.
Catalyst E800 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst E450 by calcination at 800° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained 75% of a spinel phase, 2% ZnO and 23% CuO.
Catalyst F350 was prepared similarly to catalyst A but with an altered composition and with a calcination temperature of 350° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained (apart from graphite) 94% of a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, and 6% CuO. The color of the catalyst is olive green.
Catalyst F450 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst F350 by calcination at 450° C. The catalyst composition was found to be 24.4 wt % Cu, 19.7 wt % Zn and 17.0 wt % Al. Calculated as the oxides, this corresponds to a content of 30.5 wt % CuO, 24.5 wt % ZnO and 32.1 wt % Al2O3. The Zn/Al molar ratio based on the analysis was thus 0.48. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained (apart from graphite) 94% of a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, and 6% CuO. Measured as an average of 10 tablets, the tablet density was 1.94 g/cm3 and the radial crush strength was 53.3 kp/cm.
Catalyst F500 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst F350 by calcination at 500° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained (apart from graphite) 87.4% of a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, and 12.6% CuO.
Catalyst F550 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst F350 by calcination at 550° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained (apart from graphite) 86.7% of a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, and 13.3% CuO.
Catalyst F600 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst F350 by calcination at 600° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained (apart from graphite) 84.9% of a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, and 15.1% CuO. The color of the catalyst is dark brown.
Catalyst F650 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst F350 by calcination at 650° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained (apart from graphite) 77% of a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, and 23% CuO.
Catalyst F700 was obtained from the dried precursor to Catalyst F350 by calcination at 700° C. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained (apart from graphite) 72.2% of a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, and 27.8% CuO.
Catalyst G was prepared similarly to catalyst A but with an altered composition. Furthermore, the catalyst powder was not tablettized and was therefore not mixed with graphite. The catalyst composition was found to be 22.4 wt % Cu, 13.8 wt % Zn and 23.4 wt % Al. Calculated as the oxides, this corresponds to a content of 28.0 wt % CuO, 17.2 wt % ZnO and 44.2 wt % Al2O3. The Zn/Al molar ratio based on the analysis was thus 0.24. According to XRD analysis, the sample contained 99% of a spinel phase, possibly together with ZnO, and 1% CuO. By further heating to 900° C., the XRD phase composition was found to be 71% spinel and 29% CuO thus close to the theoretical amount of CuO of 28%.
Catalyst H was prepared similarly to catalyst A but with a different composition. Furthermore, the calcination temperature was 350° C. The catalyst composition was found to be 41.0 wt % Cu, 22.2 wt % Zn and 5.5 wt % Al. Calculated as the oxides, this corresponds to a content of 51.3 wt % CuO, 27.6 wt % ZnO and 10.4 wt % Al2O3. The Zn/Al molar ratio based on the analysis was thus 1.67. Measured as an average of 10 tablets, the tablet density was 1.89 g/cm3 and the radial crush strength was 16.5 kp/cm. For analysis, a sample of Catalyst H was calcined at 500° C. and analyzed by ICP and XRD giving a Z-value of 94% (
Catalyst I was prepared similarly to catalyst A but with a different composition. Furthermore, the calcination temperature was 350° C. The catalyst composition was found to be 45.6 wt % Cu, 20.0 wt % Zn and 4.6 wt % Al. Calculated as the oxides, this corresponds to a content of 57.1 wt % CuO, 24.9 wt % ZnO and 8.7 wt % Al2O3. The Zn/Al molar ratio based on the analysis was thus 1.79. Measured as an average of 10 tablets, the tablet density was 1.97 g/cm3 and the radial crush strength was 29.4 kp/cm. Another batch of tablets had a tablet density of 1.90 and a radial crush strength of 45 kp/cm. For analysis, a sample of Catalyst I was calcined at 500° C. and analyzed by ICP and XRD giving a Z-value of 99% (see
Catalyst J is a copper chromite purchased from Merck as a powder. The powder was mixed with 4% graphite and compressed to 4.5 mm diameter×3.5 mm height cylindrical tablets. The catalyst composition was found to be 37.1 wt % Cu and 29.5 wt % Cr, which roughly corresponds to the stoichiometry CuO*CuCr2O4. Calculated as the oxides, this corresponds to a content of 46.4 wt % CuO and 43.1 wt % Cr2O3. Measured as an average of 10 tablets, the tablet density was 2.76 g/cm3 and the radial crush strength was 16.6 kp/cm.
Catalyst K is a Ni catalyst made by impregnation of an alumina support. The powder was mixed with 4% graphite and compressed to 4.5 mm diameter×3.5 mm height cylindrical tablets. The catalyst was found to contain 14.5 Wt % Ni.
25 g of Catalyst A was pre-reduced by heating to 220° C. and treatment with 5% hydrogen in nitrogen at 50 Nl/h for four hours. The catalyst was cooled to room temperature and passivated by treatment with 1% oxygen in nitrogen at 50 Nl/h for two hours. This passivation procedure causes a surface oxidation of the copper particles. Thus, X-ray powder diffraction reveals that most of the copper is present as metallic Cu while only a minor fraction is present as Cu2O and very little as CuO. For the acid resistance test, 5 grams of benzoic acid and 1 gram of water were dissolved in 94 grams of butyl benzoate (boiling point=250° C.). 5 g of pre-reduced and passivated Catalyst A in the shape of 4.5×3.5 mm tablets was added. The suspension was heated to reflux for 24 hours. The liquid was decanted off and the tablets were inspected. It was found that most of the tablets were intact and almost no powder was observed.
25 g of Catalyst B was reduced and passivated as described in Example 26. The acid resistance test (boiling in butyl benzoate/benzoic acid/water for 24 hours) was carried out as in Example 26. The liquid was decanted off and the tablets were inspected. The majority of the tablets were intact and the appearance was similar to that of Catalyst A.
25 g of Catalyst H was reduced and passivated as described in Example 4. The acid resistance test (boiling in butyl benzoate/benzoic acid/water for 24 hours) was carried out as in Example 4 with 5 g of catalyst. The catalyst was found to have deteriorated completely. Thus, no tablets were identified. Instead, a dark brown mud was found in the bottom of the flask.
These tests were carried out separately with Catalyst F450, F500, F550, F600, F650 and F700. 50 mg catalyst was mixed with 6 g of SiC, both in the sieve fraction 0.15-0.30 mm. The mixture was loaded into a cylindrical reactor with inner diameter 5.0 mm. The catalyst was reduced with dilute hydrogen as described in Example 30. The reactor was heated to 230° C. Liquid feed (acetol and water) was evaporated and mixed with gaseous feed (H2 and CO2) to give a feed composition of 2.5 mol % acetol, 10.3 mol % H2O, 67.1 mol % H2 and 20.1 mol % CO2. The reaction was carried out at P=0.3 MPa and T=230° C. at a total feed flow of 35.8 Nl/h. Results in terms of acetol conversion after 60 hours on stream are shown in
A 6.2 mm cylindrical, copper-lined reactor was loaded in Single Pellet String fashion with 6 catalyst tablets, each tablet separated from its neighbors by 4 spheres of dead-burned alumina. Prior to test, the catalyst was reduced with dilute hydrogen (3.0% H2 in N2) at 150-220° C. (2° C. per minute, hold at 220° C. for 2 hours). The Ni catalyst was reduced at 400° C. The tests were carried out at a pressure of 10 barg with a flow rate of 41.9 g/h butyraldehyde (13 Nl/h) and 75 Nl/h H2. Butyraldehyde was evaporated and mixed with hydrogen before entering the reactor. The amount of loaded catalyst was 0.68 cm3 resulting in a GHSV of 129412 Nl/h. These experiments allowed for comparison of hydrogenation activity of butyraldehyde between the various catalysts. Four catalysts (Catalyst A, Catalyst F450, Comparative Catalyst I and Comparative Catalyst K) were tested separately under these conditions over a 50-hours period at the temperatures 190, 180, 170, 160, 150 and again at 190° C. The exit gases were analyzed by gas chromatography (GC). The non-condensable part of the exit gas was analyzed by an on-line GC and satisfying carbon mass balances were obtained for all measurements (C(ex)/C(in)=1.00±0.03). The BuOH yield was calculated based on all the GC analysis. The high GHSV ensured a butyraldehyde conversion in the range 13.5-51.3% for all catalysts within the entire temperature range. The BuOH selectivity based on the condensable part of the exit gas was in the range of 99.97-99.99% for all catalysts over the entire temperature range. However, while only H2 was observed in the non-condensable part of the exit gas for the Cu-based catalysts, propane and CO were observed with the Ni-based catalysts in increasing amounts with increasing temperature. The BuOH yield at start of run (SOR) and end of run (EOR) for each of the four catalysts is shown in
Some of the catalysts of the invention were studied by measurement of the copper surface area, SA(Cu), by surface titration with nitrous oxide; the so-called N2O-RFC method as explained in S. Kuld et al. Angewandte Chemie 53 (2014), 5941-5945 (Supporting Information). 500 mg catalyst in sieve fraction 150-300 um was loaded into a U-type quartz reactor with an inner diameter of 4.0 mm and the system was flushed with helium. The catalyst was reduced in 1% H2 in N2 from room temperature to 175° C. at a rate of 1 K/min and a hold time at 175° C. for 2 hours. Reduction continued, heating at 1 K/min from 175° C. to 250° C. and a hold time of 10 minutes. Reduction gas was then switched to pure hydrogen and a hold time at 250° C. of 2 hours. The temperature was adjusted to 210° C. and maintained in a flow of He for 40 min and then cooled to 50° C. The reactor was then closed off and isolated in He atmosphere at 50° C. The system with the reactor bypassed was flushed with 1% N2O in N2, first 5 min at a flow of 50 Nml/min and then 5 minutes at a flow of 12 Nml/min. The reactor was opened, and the catalyst surface was titrated at 50° C. for 35 minutes in the 1% N2O at a flow of 12 Nml/min and the consumed N2O in this step was used to calculate the Cu surface area. All gas flows were at a rate of 100 Nml/min unless stated otherwise. The copper surface area was calculated as SA(Cu)=0.081905 m2 Cu/μmol N2O. The copper surface area (m2 Cu area per gram of catalyst) very often correlates with catalytic activity, since it is a measure of the number of active sites. This is not strictly correct since most Cu catalysts are structure sensitive, and also since the support or part of the support may impact the Cu sites or the catalytic cycle. Nevertheless, those who are skilled in the art would expect that the most active catalysts are those with the highest SA(Cu). This is indeed what we observe, at least qualitatively. Other factors, such as the porosity of the catalyst, may also influence the observed activity and other catalyst performance parameters to some extent.
Catalyst pore volumes (PV) were measured by mercury intrusion for selected catalysts of the invention. A higher PV is beneficial if the catalytic reaction is mass transfer limited. The pore volume and the porosity will depend on the tablet density. For typical tablet densities, which are in the range 1.7-2.1 g/cm3, the pore volume (PV) is in the range 150-350 ml/kg and the porosity is in the range 35-65%. For tablets with a tablet density in the range 1.8-2.0 g/cm3, we find PV in the range 200-300 ml/kg and porosity in the range 40-60%. We find that the highest PV and porosity is achieved by calcination at around 600° C.; see Table 2.
Tables 1, 2 and 3 gather examples of catalysts of the invention and comparative catalysts. All characterization data are obtained from catalysts in their oxidized form except for the copper surface area and the acid resistance which was determined on the reduced catalyst compositions.
The sum of Wt % oxides (CuO+ZnO+Al2O3) is less than 100% (in the range 87-93%) due to residual water and to the added graphite lubricant.
Table 1 shows that catalysts of the present invention contain a spinel phase as the major phase according to XRD. Thus, for all the examples of the invention illustrating calcination temperatures in the range 350-900° C., the spinel content according to XRD is from 67-100%. The content of CuO according to ICP is in the range 23-31.5 Wt % in the examples, corresponding to 18-25 Wt % Cu. The invention includes catalysts with even higher Cu content, up to 38 Wt %. Even in that case, the spinel phase would make up at least 50% of the catalyst. The examples include catalysts with a Zn/Al molar ratio from 0.24 to 0.56. Table 1 includes calculated values of Z. This parameter is simply the ratio between Wt % CuO as observed by XRD to the theoretical or maximum Wt % CuO as calculated from ICP elemental analysis. In other words, the value of Z expresses how much of the Cu is present as a distinct CuO phase. The value of Z depends very much on the calcination temperature as shown in
Table 1 also lists examples of mechanical strength in terms of SCS. This is further addressed in
Table 2 shows the elemental composition for selected catalysts. Catalysts of the invention have a Cu content of in the range 12-38% by weight, preferably in the range 18-25% by weight, a Zn content of in the range 13-35%, preferably in the range 13-24% and an Al content of in the range 12-30%, preferably in the range 17-24%.
Table 3 shows pore volume (PV) and porosity for selected catalysts of the invention. By comparison of examples 8, 10 and 13, it is seen that there is an optimum in porosity for a calcination temperature of 600° C.
Embodiment 1. Process for the catalytic hydrogenation in gas phase or in liquid phase of organic carbonyl compounds containing at least one functional group belonging to the group of aldehydes, ketones, esters and carboxylic acids, whereby said at least one functional group is converted to an alcohol by contacting said carbonyl compound with hydrogen and a hydrogenation catalyst at elevated temperature and pressure, said catalyst comprising Cu, Zn and Al and further being characterized, in its fully oxidized form, by
Embodiment 2. A process according to embodiment 1, wherein said catalyst has been exposed to a temperature Tcalc of between 300-900° C., preferably between 450-750° C.
Embodiment 3. A process according to any one of embodiments 1 or 2, wherein said catalyst has been exposed to a calcination temperature Tcalc in the range of 550-700° C.
Embodiment 4. The catalyst according to any one of embodiment 1 to 3, wherein tablets of said catalyst in its oxidized form have a radial crush strength, SCS, of between 25 and 150 kp/cm, said tablets having a tablet density in the range of 1.45-2.35 g/cm3, preferably in the range of 1.65-2.35 g/cm3.
Embodiment 5. The catalyst according to any one of embodiments 1 to 3, wherein tablets of said catalyst in its freshly reduced form have a radial crush strength of between 10 and 75 kp/cm, said tablets having a tablet density in the interval 1.45-2.35 g/cm3, preferably in the range 1.65-2.35 g/cm3.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20209523.8 | Nov 2020 | EP | regional |
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/EP2021/082821 | 11/24/2021 | WO |
