Process for fabricating optical fiber involving overcladding during sintering

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6446468
  • Patent Number
    6,446,468
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, August 1, 2000
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 10, 2002
    22 years ago
Abstract
An improved technique for assembling and drawing fiber from preforms is provided. In one embodiment, the technique involves providing a core rod assembly comprising a core rod and a bushing attached at an end of the assembly. The core rod assembly is inserted into an unsintered overcladding tube, and secured to the tube such that the core rod assembly is suspended within. The overcladding tube and the core rod assembly are heated to sinter the overcladding tube and thereby form a preform assembly. During the heating step, the bushing comes into contact with the interior of the overcladding tube, and, because the bushing has a larger diameter than the core rod, an annular gap is maintained between the core rod assembly and the interior of the overcladding tube. It is then possible to attach a draw handle to the preform assembly, place the preform assembly into a draw tower, and draw fiber from the preform assembly by an overclad during draw technique.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




1. Field of the Invention




The invention relates to fabrication of optical fiber, in particular preparation of the preform from which fiber is drawn.




2. Discussion of the Related Art




Optical fiber is produced from a glass preform. The preform is generally arranged vertically in a draw tower such that a portion of the preform is lowered into a furnace region. The portion of the preform placed into the furnace region begins to soften, and the lower end of the preform forms what is known as the neck-down region, where glass flows from the original cross-sectional area of the preform to the desired cross-sectional area of the fiber. From the lower tip of this neck-down region, the optical fiber is drawn.




Optical transmission fiber typically contains a high-purity silica glass core optionally doped with a refractive index-raising element such as germanium, an inner cladding of high-purity silica glass optionally doped with a refractive index-lowering element such as fluorine, and an outer cladding of undoped silica glass. In some manufacturing processes, the preforms for making such fiber are fabricated by forming an overcladding tube for the outer cladding, and separately forming a rod containing the core material and inner cladding material. The core/inner cladding are fabricated by any of a variety of vapor deposition methods known to those skilled in the art, including vapor axial deposition (VAD), outside vapor deposition (OVD), and modified chemical vapor deposition (MCVD). MCVD is discussed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,217,027; 4,262,035; and 4,909,816. MCVD involves passing a high-purity gas, e.g., a mixture of gases containing silicon and germanium, through the interior of a silica tube (known as the substrate tube) while heating the outside of the tube with a traversing oxy-hydrogen torch. In the heated area of the tube, a gas phase reaction occurs that deposits particles on the tube wall. This deposit, which forms ahead of the torch, is sintered as the torch passes over it. The process is repeated in successive passes until the requisite quantity of silica and/or germanium-doped silica is deposited. Once deposition is complete, the body is heated to collapse the substrate tube and obtain a consolidated core rod in which the substrate tube constitutes the outer portion of the inner cladding material. To obtain a finished preform, the overcladding tube is typically placed over the core rod, and the components are heated and collapsed into a solid, consolidated preform. It is possible to sinter a porous overcladding tube while collapsing it onto a core rod, as described in U.S. Pat. No. 4,775,401.




Because the outer cladding of a fiber is distant from transmitted light, the overcladding glass does not have to meet the optical performance specifications to which the core and the inner cladding must conform. For this reason, efforts to both ease and speed manufacture of fiber preforms focused on methods of making overcladding tubes. One area of such efforts is the use of a sol-gel casting process.




U.S. Pat. No. 5,240,488 (the '488 patent), the disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference, discloses a sol-gel casting process capable of producing crack-free overcladding preform tubes of a kilogram or larger. In the process of the '488 patent, a colloidal silicon dispersion, e.g., fumed silica, is obtained. To maintain adequate stability of the dispersion and prevent agglomeration, the pH is raised to a value of about 11 to about 14 by use of a base, and the dispersion is then aged. Subsequent to aging, as discussed in Col. 15, lines 39-65 of the '488 patent, a gelling agent such as methyl formate is added to the dispersion to lower the pH. Typically, once the gelling agent is added, but before gellation occurs, the mixture is pumped into a tubular mold containing a central mandrel, and the gel is aged in the mold for 1 to 24 hours. The mandrel is removed, and the gelled body is then extracted from the mold. The body is then dried, fired to remove volatile organic materials and water,. and then sintered to form the finished overcladding tube. The tube can then be used to form conventional preforms.




There are several difficulties typically encountered in forming preforms. These include insertion of the rod into the overcladding tube the small clearances demand that the rod and tube be extremely straight, which is difficult in practice. The amount of heat required to collapse a thick-walled overcladding onto a tube is considerable, and often requires a specialized furnace or plasma torch. In addition, some overcladding tubes are treated with an additional plasma etch to smooth their interior prior to placing the core rod therein, and such additional process steps are advantageously avoided. Also, collapsing a tube onto a rod tends to create inhomogeneous sites or nucleation centers for bubbles, and these bubbles can result in undesired airlines in the drawn fiber.




Thus, improved techniques for assembling preforms and drawing fiber from preforms, particularly with sol-gel overcladding tubes, are desired.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The invention provides an improved technique for assembling and drawing fiber from preforms. In one embodiment, the technique involves providing a core rod assembly that comprises a core rod, optionally with an overcladding layer formed thereon. (Overcladding layer indicates that the overcladding material is located directly on the surface of the rod.) The core rod assembly comprises a handle at a first end and a centering bushing attached at a second end of the assembly. The core rod assembly is inserted into an unsintered overcladding tube such that there is an annular gap between the assembly exterior and the tube interior. The first end of the assembly is typically secured to the tube, by use of the handle, such that the core rod assembly is suspended within the tube, and the core rod assembly and tube are typically suspended by the handle for further processing. The overcladding tube and the core rod assembly are then heated to sinter the overcladding tube and thereby form a preform assembly.




During the heating step, the centering bushing comes into contact with the interior of the overcladding tube, and, because the bushing has a larger diameter than the core rod (or core rod plus overcladding layer), most of the annular gap between the core rod assembly and the overcladding tube is maintained. It is then possible to attach a draw handle to the preform assembly, place the preform assembly into a draw tower, and draw fiber from the preform assembly. Specifically, in the draw furnace, the annular gap is evacuated through the draw handle, and the end of the preform opposite the draw handle is lowered into the draw furnace. The combination of the high temperatures, e.g., 2000 to 2200° C. and the reduced pressure in the annular gap induce the tube to collapse onto the core rod as the whole assembly is fed into the furnace. It is possible to perform the process such that the preform assembly contains two or more coaxial overcladding tubes around the core rod, e.g., where the core rod assembly comprises one or more sintered or unsintered overcladding tubes.




Drawing fiber from a preform assembly containing a core rod secured within an overcladding tube, with an annular gap between the rod and tube, has been previously used, but only by insertion of a core rod into a sintered tube. See, e.g., co-assigned patent application Ser. No. 09/515,227, entitled “Apparatus and Method for Making Multiple Overclad Optical Fiber Preforms and Optical Fiber Therefrom,” filed Feb. 28, 2000. The invention, however, provides numerous advantages where overcladding tubes are produced by sol-gel techniques, or other techniques that result in production of an unsintered tube. For example, the typical process sequence for a gel tube is sinter, plasma etch the tube bore, insert a core rod, collapse the tube onto the rod, and draw fiber from the monolithic preform. According to the invention, the plasma etch is no longer necessary since the tube is not collapsed onto the rod, and separate sintering and collapse steps are avoided. Moreover, because an unsintered tube has a larger inner diameter than the final, sintered tube, the clearance for inserting a rod into the tube is greater, and this clearance eases the insertion, reduces the number of damaged tubes and rods, and relaxes the specifications for bow of the tubes and rods.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIGS. 1A

to


1


E illustrate an embodiment of the invention.





FIGS. 2A

to


2


C illustrate another embodiment of the invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




An embodiment of the invention is illustrated in

FIGS. 1A

to


1


E. As shown in

FIG. 1A

, core rod assembly


10


is provided, the assembly containing a core rod


12


. The core rod


12


is generally silica-based and is fabricated by any suitable method, including vapor axial deposition (VAD), outside vapor deposition (OVD), and modified chemical vapor deposition (MCVD). A handle


14


is attached at one end of the core rod


12


, e.g., by fusing the handle onto the rod


12


. (Handle indicates any mechanism by which the core rod assembly is manipulated and/or supported. It is possible, for example, for the handle to be integral with the core rod or separately attached to the core rod.) The handle


14


of this embodiment contains a hole


18


, which allows the handle to be secured in an overcladding tube, as discussed below. A end piece


16


is attached to a second end of the core rod


12


, e.g., by fusing the bushing onto the rod


12


. The end piece


16


(bushing) typically consists of a 1 to 2 mm thick silica disk having a diameter about 110% of the inner diameter of the sintered overcladding tube, although other configurations are possible. Typically, the disk has holes, e.g., 3 mm diameter holes, to allow evacuation of the annular gap during draw, as noted above. The function of the bushing


12


is discussed in more detail below.




As shown in

FIG. 1B

, the core rod assembly


10


is inserted into an unsintered overcladding tube


20


such that an annular gap exists between the exterior of the assembly


10


and the interior of the tube


20


. The tube


20


has a hole


24


through its diameter that corresponds to the hole


18


in the core rod assembly handle


14


. (The handle diameter is typically about 10% less than the inner diameter of the unsintered overcladding tube.) A pin


22


is inserted through both sets of holes


24


,


18


to secure the core rod assembly. A more detailed view of this technique for securing the core rod assembly is shown in FIG.


1


C. Other techniques for securing a core rod or core rod assembly are also possible. Advantageously, the tube and core rod assembly are arranged such that they hang substantially plumb. This arrangement reduces effects of fusing of one side of the core rod assembly to the wall of the overcladding tube. The overcladding tube


20


and core rod assembly


10


are suspended by the handle


14


, and heated to sinter the overcladding tube


20


. During this heating, the tube


20


advantageously shrinks onto the handle


14


thereby forming a seal at that end of the resulting preform assembly.




The bushing


16


generally keeps the core rod


12


from contacting the interior of the tube


20


during the heating, and, at a minimum, substantially reduces the extent. of such contact. Thus, it is possible for some, generally minor, contact to occur between the core rod


12


and the overcladding tube


20


during sintering, but a small amount of such contact does not tend to detrimentally affect the process or the resultant fiber. For example, typically at least 90% of the surface area of the core rod assembly remains free of contact with the tube. Also, the end piece


16


is typically configured to deform during the shrinkage of the tube


20


, to reduce bending stresses on the rod


12


. These effects are reflected in the post-sintered preform assembly illustrated in FIG.


1


D.




Subsequent to the heating step, the portion of the handle


14


and tube


20


through which the pin


22


was inserted are generally cut off. As illustrated in

FIG. 1E

, a draw handle


26


is attached to the preform assembly at the end opposite the core rod handle


14


. The draw handle


26


is generally hollow to allow a vacuum to be drawn when the preform assembly is placed into the draw furnace. The end piece


16


generally contains perforations for this same reason. The preform assembly is then capable of being secured in a draw tower using the draw handle


26


. In the draw tower, the annular gap is evacuated, and the end of the preform opposite the draw handle is lowered into the draw furnace. The combination of the high temperatures, e.g., 2000 to 2200° C. and the reduced pressure in the annular gap induce the tube to collapse onto the core rod as the whole assembly is fed into the furnace.




In addition to simply inserting a core rod into a single overcladding tube, it is possible to incorporate additional overcladding around the core rod and within the unsintered overcladding tube. For example, such additional overcladding is useful for increasing the diameter of the overall preform, and thus the amount of fiber capable of being drawn. Optionally, this first inner overcladding material is doped, e.g., with fluorine. One way to provide this overcladding is to insert a core rod into a first, sintered overcladding tube and collapse the tube onto the rod by conventional techniques, i.e., by forming an overcladding layer directly on the core rod. Then, the overclad rod is placed into a second, unsintered overcladding tube, and the above steps are followed.




Advantageously, however, instead of forming a first overcladding layer directly on the core rod, the core rod assembly comprises a first sintered overcladding tube placed over the core rod, with an annular gap between all or a portion of the core rod and first overcladding tube, in order to attain the benefits discussed above. One embodiment of this technique is illustrated in the cross-sectional schematics of

FIGS. 2A

to


2


C.

FIG. 2A

shows a core rod


30


having a handle


36


and a end piece


34


, the end piece


34


configured as discussed above. To complete the core rod assembly, a first, sintered overcladding tube


32


is placed onto the rod


30


, the tube


32


being supported by the end piece


34


. In this embodiment, holes are provided through the diameters of the rod


30


and the tube


32


at a first end of the rod


30


and tube


32


, such that the holes will be aligned subsequent to placement of the first overcladding tube


32


onto the end piece


34


. (As used herein, core rod assembly includes a configuration such as shown in

FIG. 2A

, i.e., a core rod surrounded by one or more sintered or unsintered tubes, where the assembly is later placed within an unsintered overcladding tube.)




As shown in

FIG. 2B

, the core rod assembly comprising the core rod


30


and the first overcladding tube


32


are inserted into a second, unsintered overcladding tube


38


. The second overcladding tube


38


has a hole through its diameter corresponding to the holes in the core rod


30


and first overcladding tube


32


, and a pin


42


is placed through the holes to secure the first tube


32


and core rod


30


within the second overcladding tube


38


. A silica spacer ring


40


is generally placed on the upper edge of the second overcladding tube


38


prior to insertion of the core rod assembly. The spacer ring


40


assists in centering the core rod assembly, and also promotes a seal upon sintering, as discussed below. (In the embodiment of

FIGS. 1A

to


1


E, this seal was provided by the handle alone. Because such a handle configuration is difficult in a multiple-tube embodiment, a mechanism such as the spacer ring is advantageously used.) The end piece


34


also assists in maintaining the desired coaxial relationship of the core rod


30


and first overcladding tube


32


within the second overcladding tube


38


, in the manner discussed above. The entire assembly is suspended by the handle


36


.




The entire assembly is then placed into a sintering furnace. As shown in

FIG. 2C

, the top of the assembly is sealed in the sintering furnace, i.e., the second overcladding tube


38


, spacer ring


40


, and first overcladding tube


32


are treated to induce their combined collapse onto the core rod


30


to form a seal. The remainder of the assembly is heated to sinter the second overcladding tube


38


, while maintaining the annular gaps between the second tube


38


and first tube


32


and between the first tube


32


and the core rod


30


. As with the embodiment above, when the seal is formed, typically at least 90% of the surface area of the core rod


30


remains free of contact with the first overcladding tube


32


, with a comparable percentage of the outer surface of the first tube


32


remaining free of contact with the second overcladding tube


38


. The sintered assembly is then generally provided with a hollow draw handle and placed into a draw tower, where fiber is drawn as discussed above. The bushing


34


generally has some perforations that allow a vacuum to be drawn in the annular gaps between the rod


30


and the first tube


32


and between the first tube


32


and the second tube


38


in preparation for drawing fiber, as noted above.




It is possible to use variations of this technique, as well as other techniques, to prepare preforms from two overcladding tubes. For example it is possible to place a first overcladding tube over a core rod, and then fuse the top, e.g., the top 2 to 4 cm, of the core rod and tube together, thereby providing a core rod assembly. Fabrication of the preform would then be performed as described above.




It is possible to provide a core rod assembly with two or more such sintered overcladding tubes. It is also possible to use a core rod assembly comprising an unsintered overcladding tube. Such an embodiment involves placing a first unsintered overcladding tube around a core rod and inserting that resultant core rod assembly within a second unsintered overcladding tube. The entire assembly is then sintered such that annular gaps are maintained between the second and first tubes and between the first tube and the core rod.




Various combinations of sintered and unsintered tubes are possible, in accordance with the guidelines presented herein.




The unsintered overcladding tubes are generally formed from a sol-gel process such as disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,240,488, although other processes are also possible. Sintered tubes for multiple-tube embodiments are capable of being formed by sol-gel or other suitable techniques. Briefly, the sol-gel process of the '488 patent involves providing a silica dispersion, inducing gelation of the dispersion and casting the gel in a tube form, and drying and heat treating the gel body. Sintering is then performed as discussed above. During such sintering, the shrinkage of the inner diameter of the tube will vary based on the amount of silica in the silica dispersion. For example, for a sol containing 42 to 52 wt. % silica, shrinkage of the inner diameter generally ranges from 22 to 26%.




For such a sol-gel tube (which has already been through drying and heat treatment steps prior to insertion of the core rod assembly) the whole assembly is optionally fired at a temperature suitable to remove any impurities remaining after earlier treatment, e.g., at temperature around 1000 to 1300° C. (Such firing is also able to be performed prior to insertion of the core rod assembly.) Generally this is performed by translating or traversing the assembly through the hot zone of a furnace. Vent holes provided in the handle are advantageous in that they allow gaseous impurities, including water, to flow out from the interior of the tube. For sintering, the furnace is generally heated to a sintering temperature, e.g., around 1500° C., and the tube is typically pulled up through the hot zone by the core rod assembly handle (referred to as an ascending sinter). The high temperature softens the silica and thereby induces some flexibility to the tube and the handle tip. Thus, at the area where the handle is inserted within the tube, the tube deforms around the handle, forming a continuous seal. Forming this seal at the beginning of the sintering step is an advantage of the ascending sinter. Alternatively, however, it is possible to instead lower the tube through the hot zone of a furnace. It is also contemplated to use a sintering technique in which the tube is passed through the furnace zone several times to sinter the body, as discussed, for example, in co-assigned provisional patent application entitled “Silica-Based Optical Fibers And Multi-Pass Sintering” (our reference Lum 5-10-7-7) filed concurrently herewith, the disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference.




For an embodiment using a single silica-based overcladding tube, the annular gap, i.e., the gap between the exterior of the core rod and the interior, of the overcladding tube as measured in the direction normal to the longitudinal axes of the rod and tube, is about 0.2 mm to about 0.8 mm in the sintered preform assembly. The pre-sintered annular gap will vary depending on the characteristics of the unsintered tube. Controlled experiments are easily performed to determine an appropriate presintering gap to attain a desired post-sintering gap for a particular tube size and type. By way of example, the pre-sintered gap for a typical sol-gel silica tube having an inner diameter of 35 mm and a tube wall thickness of 26 mm is generally about 5 mm to about 6 mm.




For an embodiment using a first sintered silica-based overcladding tube and a second unsintered silica-based overcladding tube, the post-sintering annular gap between the core rod and the first tube is about 0.3 mm to about 0.6 mm, and. the post-sintering annular gap between the first and second tubes is about 0.3 mm to about 0.8 mm. Again, the pre-sintered annular gap will vary depending on the size of the unsintered tube.




According to the invention it is possible to prepare preform assemblies capable of producing at least 600 km of 125 μm diameter optical fiber, optionally at least 2400 km of 125 μm diameter optical fiber.




Other embodiments of the invention will be apparent to those skilled in the art from consideration of the specification and practice of the invention disclosed herein.



Claims
  • 1. A process for fabricating an article, comprising the steps of:providing a core rod assembly comprising a core rod, optionally with an overcladding layer formed on the core rod, wherein the core rod assembly has a first end and a second end, and wherein the core rod assembly comprises a end piece proximate to the second end of the core rod assembly; providing an unsintered overcladding tube; inserting the core rod assembly into the unsintered overcladding tube such that an annular gap is provided between at least a portion of the exterior of the core rod assembly and at least a portion of the interior of the unsintered overcladding tube; and heating the overcladding tube and the core rod assembly to sinter the overcladding tube and form a preform assembly, wherein at the completion of the heating step at least a portion of the core rod assembly remains free of contact with the overcladding tube.
  • 2. The process of claim 1, wherein at least 90% of the surface of the core rod assembly remains free of contact with the overcladding tube after the heating step.
  • 3. The process of claim 1, wherein the diameter of the bushing is greater than the diameter of the core rod or the core rod with the overcladding layer formed thereon, and wherein during the heating step at least a portion the end piece comes into contact with the interior of the overcladding tube.
  • 4. The process of claim 1, wherein the overcladding tube is derived from gelation of a silica particle dispersion.
  • 5. The process of claim 1, further comprising the steps of:removing at least a portion of a first end of the preform assembly; and attaching a draw handle to the end of the preform assembly opposite the first end.
  • 6. The process of claim 5, wherein the draw handle is hollow.
  • 7. The process of claim 1, wherein during the heating step the overcladding tube shrinks onto a portion of the core rod assembly proximate the first end of the core rod assembly, such that a first end of the preform assembly is sealed.
  • 8. The process of claim 1, wherein the average annular gap between the exterior of the core rod assembly and the interior of the overcladding tube, after the heating step, is about 0.2 mm to about 0.8 mm.
  • 9. The process of claim 1, wherein the core rod assembly is secured to the overcladding tube proximate the first end of the core rod assembly, such that the core rod assembly is suspended within the overcladding tube.
  • 10. The process of claim 9, wherein the core rod assembly is secured such that the core rod is able to hang at least substantially plumb.
  • 11. The process of claim 1, wherein the core rod assembly comprises a handle at the first end of the core rod assembly, wherein the handle is secured to the overcladding tube, and wherein the core rod assembly and the overcladding tube are suspended by the handle.
  • 12. The process of claim 11, wherein the overcladding tube comprises a hole through the entire diameter of the tube, the hole being perpendicular to the tube axis and located proximate to a first end of the tube, wherein the core rod assembly handle comprises a hole, the hole being perpendicular to the long axis of the handle and proximate the first end of the core rod assembly, wherein the hole in the core rod assembly handle corresponds to the hole in the tube, and wherein the core rod assembly is secured in the tube by inserting a pin through the hole in the tube and the hole in the core rod assembly handle.
  • 13. The process of claim 1, wherein the contact between the bushing and the interior of the overcladding tube during the heating step induces deformation of the end piece.
  • 14. The process of claim 1, wherein prior to the heating step the core rod assembly further comprises a sintered overcladding tube, the core rod located within the sintered overcladding tube such that there exists an annular gap between at least a portion of the sintered overcladding tube and at least a portion of the core rod.
  • 15. The process of claim 1, wherein prior to the heating step the core rod assembly further comprises an unsintered overcladding tube, the core rod located within the unsintered overcladding tube such that there exists an annular gap between at least a portion of the unsintered overcladding tube and at least a portion of the core rod, and wherein after the heating step at least a portion of the core rod remains free of contact with the overcladding tube.
  • 16. A process for fabricating an article, comprising the steps of:providing a core rod assembly comprising a first sintered or unsintered overcladding tube and a core rod located within the first overcladding tube, wherein there exists an annular gap between at least a portion of the core rod and at least a portion of the first sintered or unsintered overcladding tube, and wherein the core rod assembly comprises a handle proximate to a first end of the core rod assembly and a end piece proximnate to a second end of the core rod assembly; providing a second unsintered overcladding tube; inserting the core rod assembly into the unsintered overcladding tube such that an annular gap is provided between at least a portion of the exterior of the core rod assembly and at least a portion of the interior of the unsintered overcladding tube; and heating the second overcladding tube and the core rod assembly to sinter the second overcladding tube or both the first and the second overcladding tubes and form a preform assembly, wherein at the completion of the heating step at least a portion of the core rod assembly remains free of contact with the first overcladding tube and at least a portion of the first overcladding tube remains free of contact with the second overcladding tube.
  • 17. The process of claim 16, further comprising the steps of:placing the preform assembly into a draw tower; and drawing optical fiber from the preform assembly while evacuating the annular gaps between the core rod assembly and the first overcladding tube and between the first overcladding tube and the second overcladding tube.
  • 18. The process of claim 16, wherein the first overcladding tube is a sintered overcladding tube.
  • 19. The process of claim 16, wherein at the completion of the heating step the average annular gap between the first overcladding tube and the core rod is about 0.3 mm to about 0.6 mm, and the average annular gap between the first overcladding tube and the second overcladding tube is about 0.3 mm to about 0.8 mm.
  • 20. The process of claim 16, wherein during the heating step a first end of the preform assembly proximate the first end of the core rod assembly becomes sealed.
  • 21. The process of claim 20, further comprising the step of placing a spacer ring onto the second unsintered overcladding tube prior to insertion of the core rod assembly.
  • 22. The process of claim 16, wherein the handle is secured to the second overcladding tube such that the core rod assembly is suspended within the second overcladding tube.
US Referenced Citations (14)
Number Name Date Kind
4217027 MacChesney et al. Aug 1980 A
4262035 Jaeger et al. Apr 1981 A
4308044 Myer Dec 1981 A
4775401 Fleming et al. Oct 1988 A
4909816 MacChesney et al. Mar 1990 A
5076824 Miller Dec 1991 A
5090980 Clasen Feb 1992 A
5240488 Chandross et al. Aug 1993 A
5307436 Berkey Apr 1994 A
5352259 Oku et al. Oct 1994 A
5658363 Ince et al. Aug 1997 A
5735927 Sanghera et al. Apr 1998 A
5900036 Mossadegh et al. May 1999 A
5917109 Berkey Jun 1999 A
Foreign Referenced Citations (7)
Number Date Country
176263 Apr 1986 EP
392599 Oct 1990 EP
501429 Sep 1992 EP
2176472 Dec 1986 GB
2284206 May 1995 GB
59-15090 Apr 1984 JP
WO 140126 Jun 2001 WO
Non-Patent Literature Citations (1)
Entry
U.S. Patent Application Ser. No. 09/459775, filed Dec. 13, 1999.