Process for the production of alginate having a high mannuronic acid-content

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 7838641
  • Patent Number
    7,838,641
  • Date Filed
    Thursday, November 21, 2002
    22 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, November 23, 2010
    14 years ago
Abstract
The present invention concerns a process for the production of alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole %, wherein said alginate is produced by: a) adding algae or seaweed to water under stirring, in a ratio of 1:3 to 1:20 respectively, at a pH above about 2.3, while maintaining a temperature above 20° C. for at least 30 minutes, and b) separating said alginate from the solid material of the suspension in a) by a standard separation method such as filtration, and optionallyc) recovering said alginate from the solution.
Description

The present invention concerns a modified procedure for the production of alginate having a high mannuronic acid-content, in which the initial pre-extraction step of the algae is modified by adjustment of pH in order to separately recover an alginate fraction of a very high mannuronic acid-content. Typically, with this modified procedure, the alginate fraction, when recovered from the initial pre-extraction step contains at least 80 mole % mannuronic acid in the alginate.


BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

Alginates are isolated from marine brown algae. Alginate is also produced in soil bacteria such as Azotobacter vinelandii and Azotobacter crococcum and several different Pseudomonas sp. Brown algae are however generally the source of commercially available alginates.


Alginates are used in foodstuffs and in pharmaceutical, dental, cosmetic and other industrial products. The most common industrial applications are based on their hydro colloidal and poly electrolytical nature, which forms the basis for the gel-forming, thickening, stabilizing, swelling and viscosity-providing properties.


Alginates are salts of alginic acid, a linear, hetero polysaccharide consisting of (1-4) linked β-D-mannuronic acid, designated as M, and α-L-guluronic acid, designated as G. These two uronic acids have the following formulae:




embedded image


The polymers exist as homopolymer sequences of mannuronic acid, called M-blocks, homopolymer sequences of guluronic acid called G-blocks, and mixed sequences of mannuronic and guluronic acid units, designated MG-blocks or alternating blocks.


The following scheme represents an illustration of the structure of alginates:












MMMMMMMGGGGGGGGMGMGMGMGMGGGGGGGGM








 M-block G-block MG-block G-block






Alginates usually contain all three types of blocks and a block typically consists of three to thirty monomer units. The distribution of the blocks depends on the type of algae from which the alginate is isolated, as well as on the age and part of the plant. For example alginate from the stalk may have a different sequence and block composition compared with alginate isolated from the leaves. The time of year at which the algae are harvested also affects the block composition and sequence. According to common knowledge, the highest G-content can be found in the stem of old L. hyperborea. The leaf of the same species has a somewhat lower G-content and shorter G-blocks, but the content is still higher than most other species. Commercially available alginates usually have a G-content of 25%-70%.


Sources which have a high content of M-blocks are for example species of the brown algae genera Durvillea, Laminaria, Lessonia, Fucales and Ascophyllum, in particular the fruiting bodies of Ascophyllum during spring are rich in mannuronic acid.


Alginates which are rich in mannuronic acid have been shown to possess immunostimulating activity as described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,169,840.


DESCRIPTION OF PRIOR ART

Norwegian Patent No. 305,033, corresponding to U.S. Pat. No. 6,121,441 describes a procedure for producing uronic acid blocks from alginate. This patent is however concerned with a fractionated release of the different block-fractions; G, M and MG in an industrial suitable manner wherein the liquid volumes are kept down. Also the conditions described in the fractionated precipitation procedure are optimised in order to obtain pure fractions.


Other preparative processes for the production of Poly M-alginates, wherein the content of mannuronic acid is 80% (FM=0.80) are known from Rosell, K. G. and Srivastava, L. M., Can. J. Bot, 62 (1984), p. 2229-2236, Craigie, J. S. et al, Carbohydr. Polym., 4 (1984), p. 237-252 and Wedlock, D. J. et al., Food Hydrocolloids, 4 (1990), p. 41-47.


A simple modification of the pre-extraction step of an industrial process as in the present invention is however not described. The present invention which separately recovers, or retains a fraction of alginate of a high mannuronic acid-content therefore represents a simple and economic way of production compared with the processes of the prior art.


In PCT/US91/00475, a mannuronic acid-containing alginate wound healing composition and method of its use are described. The composition comprises biopolymers such as alginates of at least 70 mole % β-D-mannuronic acid (M). According to this publication on page 2, line 17, a few algae sources are capable of producing alginate having a G-content of less than 30%. However bacteria are stated as the preferred source of high M-containing alginate. The present invention differs essentially from this teaching in that it describes a modified industrial process for production of alginate, and further that this modified process keep an alginate fraction with a high mannuronic acid-content which is otherwise lost in the industrial standard extraction process.


GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

The standard industrial process of production of water-extractable alginate has now been improved by the modification of the pre-extraction step or the so-called swelling step. This step is modified to be conducted at a certain pH. The pH is kept above about 2.3 in the pre-extraction step which surprisingly results in a 3D soluble alginate fraction with a very high mannuronic acid-content, preferably at least 80 mole % of M. This soluble alginate-fraction can be recovered in a separate fraction before the initiation of the extraction step in the standard procedure as set out below:

    • Step 1: Pre-extraction or swelling of alga material
    • Step 2: Extraction of alga material
    • Step 3: Sieving
    • Step 4: Filtration
    • Step 5: Precipitation with for example acid or alcohol or treatment with earth alkaline metal or alkaline metal salts
    • Step 6: Acid washing (if acid not is used in step 5)
    • Step 7: Drying of alginic acid, and optionally a
    • Step 8: Neutralisation of the alginic acid with a suitable base, and
    • Step 9: Drying of the resulting alginate


Possible intermediate washing steps with diluted acid solutions can be carried out between the different steps 1-9 above. In step 8 the base can be for example sodium or calcium carbonate, resulting in the corresponding sodium or calcium alginate in step 9.


In this invention the pH in the pre-extraction step (swelling step) is kept at a pH above “about 2.3” which means, as used herein, 2.3+/−0.1.


In the aspect of this invention, the mannuronic acid-rich fraction is recovered separately, the pH of the pre-extraction step is kept to a pH above about 2.3, and the liquid fraction is isolated from the suspension of the pre-extraction or swelling step by filtration, or any other standard separation method like centrifugation, or sieving. Subsequently the alginate can optionally be precipitated from the liquid fraction in any conventional manner with alcohol, acid or salt, such as ethanol, hydrochloric acid, sulphuric acid or calcium chloride.


The process according to the invention, wherein the pH is kept at a: pH above about 2.3 in the pre-extraction step, led to a yield in the range 0.05-10% by weight, preferably within 2%-6% by weight of the mannuronic acid-rich fraction as stated in table 2, on page 8. The alginate recovered has a M-content of at least 80 mole %. The present invention thus offers an economic and simple method of production of a high-content mannuronic acid alginate, which is an alginate product particularly suitable for medically, veterinary and dietary applications.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES


FIG. 1 shows the general process for the production and separate recovery of a fraction of alginate having a very high mannuronic acid-content of above 80 mole % mannuronic acid.





DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

An aspect of this invention concerns a process for production of alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole %, wherein the said alginate is produced by:


a) adding algae or seaweed to water under stirring, in a ratio of 1:3 to 1:20 respectively, at a pH above about 2.3, while maintaining a temperature above 20° C. for at least 30 minutes, and


b) separating said alginate from the solid material of the suspension in a) by a standard separation method such as filtration, and optionally


c) recovering said alginate.


The alginate fraction is isolated from the solid material by filtration, or any other suitable standard separation method such as centrifugation or sieving, and the alginate with a mannuronic acid-content is optionally recovered from the solution by precipitation with acid, salt or alcohol.


The starting material of the present invention is algae or seaweed, in particular brown algae, which is treated with formaldehyde, in order to fixate the phenols and preserve the algae. Further the algae can be washed with acid to remove the highly viscous fucoglycans. It is understood that the algae can be pre-treated in any known manner. Commercially available alginates, most preferably dried and milled algae of the species Durvillea can be used, but also fresh, whole or unmilled algae from Durvillea, Laminaria, Lessonia, Ascophyllum or Fucales are suitable as starting materials in the present process.


The invention is illustrated by the following non-limiting examples.


Example 1
Modified Process Wherein the pH is Above 2.3 in the “Pre-Extraction” Step

Description of the Process:


Starting raw material from different Durvillea species, D. potatorum (milled) as sample 1 and D. antarctica (not milled) as sample 2 were added to water in the amounts set forth in the table below, and stirred by hand from time to time, at a temperature of 55° C. for 3.5 hours. After storage at ambient temperature over the night, the algae were extracted a second time at 55° C. for 1 hour, then 2.5 ml formaldehyde was added and the extraction continued for 1 hour.


“Pre-extraction” Step



















Weight
Water
Time
Temperature
Formaldehyde



Sample
[gram]
[ml]
[hours]
[° C.]
[ml]
PH







1
50.0
500
5.5
55
2.5
5.9


2
40.0
500
5.5
55
2.5
6.9










Filtration


The suspension was then sieved on a 60-mesh filter and washed two times with an excess of water. The solution was then filtrated with filter aid on a vacuum funnel and thereafter on a membrane filter.


Acid Precipitation


The solution was then allowed to cool to 10° C. and was then added NaCl to a 0.5%-concentration. Thereafter drops of dilute 5. 5M hydrochloric acid was carefully added by stirring with magnet to a pH 1.8. A white precipitate was formed. The suspension was, after being kept at 10° C. for 30 minutes, sieved on a 120 mesh-filter cloth and pressed carefully by hand resulting in pasty, yellow mass that turned to fine fiber after pressing.


Neutralization


All the acid material was transferred to a 250 ml vessel and added water to bring the volume to 200 ml, before neutralized to pH 7, with solid soda ash under magnetic stirring.


Filtration


The solution was once again filtrated on a 0.8 micron filter membrane of cellulose nitrate.


Alcohol Precipitating


The filtrate was cooled to 10° C. and precipitated with isopropyl alcohol in the ratio 1:1. The fibers formed were washed once with 70 volume % isopropyl alcohol and then a second time with 100 volume % isopropyl alcohol


Drying


The fibers were drawn out with a pincer and then freeze-dried.


Results are given in table 1.













TABLE 1








Product





Weight
Yield
% Alginate


Sample
Alga
[gram]
[gram]
(hot water extracted)







1

D. potatorum

50
1.08
2.1


2

D. antarctica

40
1.59
4.0










Analysis of Product


















Intrinsic
Molecule





viscosity
weight
% Mannuronic acid


Sample
Alga
dL/g
Dalton/g
NIR model ALGLN2D







1

D. potatorum

2.7
 44 009
82


2

D. antarctica

7.0
118 892
88










Block-Distribution of Product Measured on NMR 400 Hz


















Sample
Alga
M
G
MM
GG
GM/MG







1

D. potatorum

85.9
14.1
76.3
4.5
9.6


2

D. antarctica

90.9
 9.1
84.8
3.0
6.1









Table 2 shows yields of mannuronic acid from other seaweed-samples produced as in example 1.













TABLE 2







Dry

Mannuronic




Matter
Yield
acid


Alga/Seaweed
Form
%
w/w %
%




















Ascophyllum nodosum,

Whole, cut
20
0.035
90


spring







Durvillea antarctica,

Unmilled
85
4
91


Chile, 1996







Durvillea antarctica,

Milled
85
6
89


Chile, 1996







Durvillea antarctica,

Whole
85
1.3
87


Chile, 1998







Durvillea antarctica,

Milled
85
2.5
91


Chile, 2000.







Durvillea potatorum,

Milled
85
2.1
86


Tasmania, 1997







Lessonia trabeculata,

Milled
85
0.125
NA


Chile, 1996







Lessonia nigrescens,

Milled
85

NA


Chile, 1995







Laminaria hyperborea,

Fresh, cut
18

NA


leaves







Saragassum, Tanzania,

Milled
85

NA


August, 1991.







Macrocystes pyrifera,

Milled
85

NA


Chile, 1994







Laminaria japonica,

Whole, cut
85
0.2
NA


Japan, 1988







Fucus spiralis,

Whole, cut
15
0.026
91


summer, 1994





wherein NA = not analysed






Example 2
Modified Process Wherein the pH is Above 2.3 and Salt is Added in the “Pre-Extraction” Step

It is possible to further increase the content of mannuronic acid by addition of salt in the “pre-extraction” step.


Description of the process:


“Pre-Extraction” Step


20 gram Durvillea antarctica (milled coarse particles >70 mesh) algae from Chile August 1996 was added 500 ml water and a certain amount of NaCl, and was extracted under stirring on a Jar test machine, at stirring speed 140 rpm for 2 hours, at a temperature of 20° C. The salt was added to a concentration in the solution (% by weight), as set forth in table 3.














TABLE 3







Durvillea









Antarctica

Water
NaCl
Extraction


Sample
[gram]
[ml]
conc.
time, [hours]
Remarks




















A
20
500
0
2



B
20
500
0.2%
2


C
20
500
0.5%
2


D
20
500
1.0%
2


E
20
500
2.0%
2


F
20
500
3.0%
2


G
20
500
3.4%
2


H
20
500

2
Seawater










Sieving


The material was then sieved on a 400 mesh filtration cloth and pressed by hand. The sieved solution was weighed and pH measured as given in table 4.














TABLE 4








Amount






NaCl
sieved





Sample
conc.
[gram]
pH
Remarks





















A
0
377
6.3




B
0.2%
371
6.0




C
0.5%
389
6.0




D
1.0%
397
5.9




E
2.0%
417
5.8




F
3.0%
444
5.8




G
3.4%
455
5.0




H

421
6.4
Seawater










Filtration


The sieved solution was then filtrated by vacuum (water suction pump) on a funnel with filter paper. The viscosity of the filtrated solution was measured on a glass tube and the results are given in table 5.













TABLE 5







Amount of
time
Viscosity



NaCl
filtrate
measured,
calculated


Sample
conc.
[gram]
[seconds]
[cps]



















A
0
277
18.7
11.6


B
0.2%
286
16.0
9.9


C
0.5%
319
13.8
8.6


D
1.0%
330
12.2
7.6


E
2.0%
408
7.5
4.7


F
3.0%
438
4.9
3.0


G
3.4%
445

2.6


H

402

2.9










Acid Precipitating


The filtrate was cooled to below 15° C. and each of the samples were added drops of 5.5 M hydrochloric acid until the pH reached 1.8-2.0, under stirring with a magnetic stirrer. A fiber shaped precipitate was formed. The precipitate was then sieved on a 400-mesh filtration cloth and pressed by hand.


Neutralization


The alginic acid was then diluted with water and neutralized with solid soda; ash to pH 6-7 under stirring until completely dissolved.


Alcohol Precipitating


The solution was then cooled and precipitated with equal parts of isopropyl alcohol. Thereafter washed with 70 volume % isopropyl alcohol, and repeatedly washed with pure 100 volume % isopropyl alcohol.


Drying


The precipitated fiber was pulled out by a pincer and transferred to a vessel and freeze dried overnight in vacuum.


Results


The results are shown in table 6, wherein the amount of yield was calculated assuming that no alginate was lost and that all the alginate is dissolved in the water added.














TABLE 6







Amount


M-block.




alginate
Amount

NIR



NaCl
precipitated
alginate
% yield
Model


Sample
conc.
[gram]
[g/l]
real
ALGLN2D




















A
0
1.26
3.34
6.3
  88%


B
0.2%
1.03
3.60
5.1


C
0.5%
1.11
3.48
5.6


D
1.0%
1.14
3.45
5.7


E
2.0%
1.20
2.87
6.0


F
3.0%
0.80
1.80
4.0


G
3.4%
0.54
1.21
2.7
91.8%


H
Seawater
0.53
1.32
2.7
95.8%









Example 3
Modified Process Wherein the pH is Above pH 2.3 and Salt is Added in the “Pre-Extraction” Step

Description of the Process:


The content of mannuronic acid in the separate fraction was further increased by addition of CaCl2. The starting material was D. antarctica from Chile that was milled to coarse particles of a size >70 mesh.


“Pre-Extraction”


The amounts and conditions of the “pre-extraction” step are set out in table 7. The “pre-extraction” (extraction) was carried out under stirring on Jar tester with about 140 rpm.















TABLE 7






Weight
Water
Time
Temperature

Calcium


Sample
[gram]
[m/l]
[hours]
[° C.]
pH
chloride [N]





















A
20.0
500
2
25
6.08
0.01


C
20.0
498
2
25
5.8
0.03


D
20.0
496
2
25
5.7
0.06


B
20.0
500
2
25
5.85
0.1










Filtration


The material was then sieved on a 400-mesh filter and pressed by hand. The solution was then heated to about 30° C. and filtrated with paper on a vacuum Suction flask.













TABLE 8







Calcium
Sieved sol.
Filtrated




chloride
400 mesh
solution



Sample
[N]
[gram]
[gram]




















A
0.01
404
397



C
0.03
423
398



D
0.06
440
420



B
0.1
462
457










Acid Precipitation


The solution was then cooled to 10° C. and added sodium chloride to 0.5%. Then drops of 5.5 M HCl were added, with carefully magnetic stirring until pH 1.8. A white precipitate was formed. The material suspension was then stored for 30 minutes and sieved on 400-mesh filtration cloth and pressed carefully by hand. The material was a pasty yellow mass, which turned to fine bright fibers after pressing.


Neutralization


The acid material was then transferred to a 250 ml vessel and added water to bring the volume to 200 ml and then neutralized to pH 7 with solid soda ash under magnetic stirring.


Alcohol Precipitating


The filtrate was then cooled to 10° C. and precipitated on stirring with 100 volume % isopropyl alcohol in a ratio 1:1. Large fibers were precipitated. The fibers were washed twice with 70 volume % isopropyl alcohol and finally with 100 volume % isopropyl alcohol.


Drying


The fibers were then pulled out by a pincer, and thereafter freeze dried overnight under vacuum.


Results


The results are given in tables 9 and 10 which show the yields and the increase in content of mannuronic acid in the alginate with more than 80% M, from maximum 91% M when salt not was added (confer table 2), to a maximum of 95% M when salt was added to the “pre-extraction” step.













TABLE 9






Calcium
Yield
Yield




chloride
alginate
alginate



Sample
[N]
[gram]
[g/l]
Yield %



















A
0.01 N
1.29 g
3.19
6.5


C
0.03 N
0.52 g
1.31
2.6


D
0.06 N
0.19 g
0.45
0.9


B
 0.1 N

0
0























TABLE 10






Calcium
% Mannuronic








chloride
acid
% M
% G
% MM
% GM/MG
% GG


Sample
[N]
NIR model LND 2
NMR
NMR
NMR
NMR
NMR







A
0.01 N
 98.7
89.0
11.0
82.0
8.0
3.0


C
0.03 N
101.6
92.0
 8.0
86.0
6.0
1.6


D
0.06 N
102.5
95.0
 5.0
90.0
5.0
0  


B
 0.1 N








E
water only

88.7
11.3
80.4
8.3
3.0









Example 4
Reference Example

Description of a standard process for the production of alginate with a very high mannuronic acid content.


Fresh Ascophyllum nodosum algae from Karmøy, Norway were used as starting material.


Pressing


50 kg of algae were pressed on a roller press type “Haller” with a capacity of 280 kg of algae per hour. A total of 300 ml of extract was collected.


Filtration


The extract was filtrated on coarse filter paper with use of water suction.


Acid Precipitating


Volume of 255 g was added 1,5% NaCl and then drops of 5.5 M diluted hydrochloric acid until pH reached 1.5. Yellow flocs precipitated and was sieved from the solution on a 400 mesh filtration cloth and pressed by hand.


Neutralisation


The flocks dissolved by adding 50 ml of water and solid soda ash to pH 9. The solution was then filtrated with black band filter paper.


Alcohol Precipitation


The solution was precipitated with equal amounts of isopropyl alcohol. The precipitated material was sieved on a 400-mesh filtration cloth and washed once with acetone. The material was then dried 4 hours by 105° C.


Results


The results are given in table 11 below














TABLE 11






Amount
Extract
Alginate
Conc.
Yield (wet algae).


Alga
[kg]
[ml]
[mg]
[mg/l]
[g/kg]








A. nodosum

50
300
35
12
0.0007









The mannuronic acid content of the alginate prepared in reference example 5, was 94.4% M-block and 91.8% MM-block.

Claims
  • 1. A process for the production of alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole %, the process comprising the steps of: a) swelling fresh or dried algae or seaweed selected from at least one member of the group consisting of Durvillea, Laminaria, Lessonia, Fucales and Ascophyllum in water under stirring, in a ratio of 1:3 to 1:20, respectively, at a pH between 2.3 and 7, while maintaining a temperature above 20° C. for at least 30 minutes and forming a suspension of a solid material and a liquid fraction comprising the alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole % with the proviso that said water used to swell said fresh or dried algae or seaweed does not contain formaldehyde,b) separating said liquid fraction comprising the alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole % from the solid material of the suspension formed in step a) by aseparation method, wherein said alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole % is obtained having a yield of from 2-10%, and, optionally,c) recovering said alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole % from the liquid fraction.
  • 2. The process according to claim 1, in which the pH in step a) is 5 to 7.
  • 3. The process according to claim 1, in which in step a) the temperature is maintained at 55° C. and the extraction time is 5.5 hours.
  • 4. The process according to claim 1, in which the separation method is filtration.
  • 5. The process according to claim 1, in which the process comprises step c), and the alginate is recovered from the liquid fraction by precipitation.
  • 6. The process according to claim 1, in which step a) further comprises the addition of 0.1-5% by weight of a salt to the liquid fraction, based on the weight of the liquid fraction.
  • 7. The process according to claim 6, in which the salt is CaCl2 or NaCl.
  • 8. The process according to claim 6, in which the pH in step a) is 5 to 7.
  • 9. The process according to claim 2, in which in step a) the temperature is maintained at 55° C. and the extraction time is 5.5 hours.
  • 10. The process according to claim 2, in which the process comprises step c), and alginate is recovered from the liquid fraction by precipitation.
  • 11. The process according to claim 3, in which the process comprises step c), and alginate is recovered from the liquid fraction by precipitation.
  • 12. The process according to claim 4, in which the process comprises step c), and alginate is recovered from the liquid fraction by precipitation.
  • 13. A process for the production of alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole %, the process comprising the steps of: a) swelling fresh or dried algae or seaweed selected from at least one member of the group consisting of Durvillea, Laminaria, Lessonia, Fucales and Ascophyllum in water under stirring, in a ratio of 1:3 to 1:20, at a pH between 2.3 and 7, while maintaining a temperature above 20° C. for at least 30 minutes and forming a suspension of a solid material and a liquid fraction comprising the alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole % with the proviso that said water used to swell said fresh or dried algae or seaweed does not contain formaldehyde,b) separating said liquid fraction comprising the alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole % from the solid material of the suspension in step a) by a separation method, wherein said alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole % is obtained having a yield of from 2-10%, andc) recovering said alginate having a mannuronic acid-content of at least 80 mole % from the liquid fraction.
  • 14. The process according to claim 13, in which the pH in step a) is 5 to 7.
  • 15. The process according to claim 13, in which in step a) the temperature is maintained at 55° C. and the extraction time is 5.5 hours.
  • 16. The process according to claim 13, in which step a) further comprises the addition of 0.1-5% by weight of a salt to the liquid fraction, based on the weight of the liquid fraction.
  • 17. The process according to claim 16, in which the salt is CaCl2 or NaCl.
  • 18. The process of claim 1 in which salt is not added to the liquid fraction in step a).
  • 19. The process of claim 13 in which salt is not added to the liquid fraction in step a).
  • 20. The process of claim 1 in which the seaweed is Durvillaea antarctica or Durvillaea potatorum.
  • 21. The process of claim 13 in which the seaweed is Durvillaea antarctica or Durvillaea potatorum.
Priority Claims (1)
Number Date Country Kind
20015874 Nov 2001 NO national
PCT Information
Filing Document Filing Date Country Kind 371c Date
PCT/NO02/00431 11/21/2002 WO 00 6/1/2004
Publishing Document Publishing Date Country Kind
WO03/046199 6/5/2003 WO A
US Referenced Citations (4)
Number Name Date Kind
2128551 Le Gloahee Aug 1938 A
3396158 Haug Aug 1968 A
5596084 Sanderson et al. Jan 1997 A
6121441 Simensen et al. Sep 2000 A
Foreign Referenced Citations (4)
Number Date Country
19836960 Feb 2000 DE
862702 Mar 1961 GB
9851710 Nov 1998 WO
0156404 Aug 2001 WO
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20050038237 A1 Feb 2005 US