Process insensitive electronic driver circuitry for integrated RF switching diodes

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6650151
  • Patent Number
    6,650,151
  • Date Filed
    Wednesday, December 26, 2001
    22 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, November 18, 2003
    21 years ago
Abstract
An electronic driver circuitry for an RF switch diode used in Acoustic Ink Jet Printing (AIP) systems is disclosed The electronic driver circuitry consists of a PMOS transistor and a poly resistor used to control the on/off states of the RF switch diode wherein the drive current for the RF switch diode is the same as the current in the PMOS transistor. To compensate for undesirable variations in the RF switch diode, the driver circuitry is designed such that the current in the PMOS transistor is adjusted in an opposite direction to cancel the unwanted variations.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




In most RF applications, discrete P-i-N diodes are used in RF switch arrays because they have the correct diode characteristics to operate correctly. However, using discrete P-i-N diodes increases both the size and the cost of the RF switch arrays. Another impact of using discrete P-i-N diodes is that a discrete RC circuit is needed to isolate the P-i-N diode from a driver chip that will be used to drive the P-i-N diode. Therefore, it would be preferable to use integrated diodes in building RF switch arrays but current technological limitations have prevented their use. This is because current CMOS integrated diodes are not capable of sustaining the performance requirements necessary for the RF switch array.




To solve some of the above stated problems a technique has been found which allows for the fabrication of a CMOS integrated diode, such as that disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,757,065 and assigned to the assignee of the present application. U.S. Pat. No. 5,757,065 entitled HIGH VOLTAGE INTEGRATED CIRCUIT DIODE WITH A CHARGE INJECTING NODE discloses using an injecting node in a CMOS integrated diode for producing diode characteristics more closely resembling the characteristics of a discrete P-i-N diode. Additionally, these integrated P-i-N diodes need electronic driver circuitry for biasing the injecting node for proper switching. The P-i-N diode characteristics, which in turn directly determine the efficiency of RF switching in Acoustic Ink Jet Printing (AIP) systems, are extremely sensitive to temperature and process parameters variations. Therefore what is needed is a design for the driver circuitry such that those inefficiencies due to process parameters and temperatures variations are compensated and canceled out.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




In accordance with the present invention, there is provided an electronic driver circuitry for an RF switch diode used in Acoustic Ink Jet Printing (AIP) systems that compensates and cancels out undesired variations and non-idealities. The electronic driver circuitry consists of a PMOS transistor and a poly resistor used to control the on/off states of the RF switch diode wherein the drive current for the RF switch diode is the same as the current in the PMOS transistor. To compensate for undesirable variations in the RF switch diode, the driver circuitry is designed such that the current in the PMOS transistor is adjusted in an opposite direction to cancel the unwanted variations.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS




The objects, features and advantages of the invention will become apparent upon consideration of the following detailed disclosure of the invention, especially when it is taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings wherein:





FIG. 1

is top view of a CMOS integrated circuit diode;





FIG. 2

is a cross-sectional view of the CMOS integrated circuit diode shown in FIG.


1


and taken through cross-section line


2





2


; and





FIG. 3

is an electrical schematic showing biasing circuitry for the CMOS integrated circuit diode that compensates and cancels out undesired variations and non-idealities according to the present invention.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




Turning now to

FIG. 1

, a top view of a CMOS integrated circuit diode


8


for use as a RF switch diode in the present invention is shown.

FIG. 2

shows a cross-sectional view of the CMOS integrated circuit diode


8


shown in FIG.


1


and taken through cross-section line


2





2


. RF switch diodes must have very low on-impedance and at the same time they must have very low capacitance for efficient and fast switching. However, these two parameters contradict each other in that by making the diodes' on-resistance very low, the diode must have a very large area, which increases its capacitance drastically. Regular N+ or P+ integrated CMOS diodes have low breakdown voltages and high capacitance values.




Referring to

FIGS. 1 and 2

, adding an injecting node


14


to the integrated diode


8


solves the problem. The RF switch diode


8


itself is a cylindrical device with centerline C. The RF switch diode


8


is constructed by implanting a ring to form an n-well cathode


12


in a substrate comprised of p+ substrate


26


and p− epi


18


leaving a p− epi anode


10


in the center. The n-well cathode


12


is connected to electrically by a n+ metal contact


20


. Using the n+ metal contact


20


the n-well cathode


12


can now be connected to using a metal line


22


. The p− epi anode


10


of the diode


8


created by the n-well cathode


12


is connected to ground via a topside p− epi anode contact


16


shown in FIG.


1


. The p+ substrate


26


is connected to ground via a backside wafer contact (not shown). Decreasing the depth of the p− epi


18


increases the capacitance and off impedance, and decreases the breakdown voltage.




The RF switch diode


8


defines a n+ injecting node


14


forming a broken ring outside of the n-well cathode


12


and separated from it by a portion of the p− epi


18


region. The distance the n+ injecting node


14


is located from the n-well cathode


12


vary depending on what breakdown voltage is desired. The n+ injecting node


14


alters the characteristics of the RF switch diode


8


by biasing the diode in either a forward biased mode or a reverse biased mode during operation of the RF switch diode


8


. When the n+ injecting node


14


is forward biased there is a negative bias on the n+ injecting node


14


as referenced against the p− epi anode


10


and the p− epi


18


. The forward bias on the injecting node


14


injects electrons into both the p− epi


18


and the p− epi anode


10


. The n-well cathode


12


then drops to a voltage of approximately negative 0.7 volts, or 0.7 volts below the p− epi anode


10


and the p− epi


18


, and the diode


8


remains turned on as long as there are electrons in the p− epi


18


and the p− epi anode


10


. The injected electrons from the forward biased n+ injecting node


14


reduce the on-impedance of the Rf switch diode


8


. This biasing and impedance setting feature allows the diode to handle a large RF voltage signal when the diode is turned off and to handle a large RF current signal when the RF switch diode


8


is turned on.




Referring now to

FIG. 3

, there is shown electronic driver biasing circuitry for the RF switch diode


8


. The biasing circuitry compensates and cancels out undesired variations and non-idealities according to the present invention. In accordance with the present invention, the injection node contact


24


must be biased properly to turn the RF switch ON or OFF. For the ON situation, the injecting node contact


24


must be biased to a voltage approximately −0.7 volts with respect to the grounded substrate


26


to inject electrons into p− epi


18


. The injected minority carriers reduce the on-resistance more than if the injection node


14


was not available. To turn the diode


8


OFF, the injecting node


14


must be biased to a positive voltage with respect to grounded substrate


18


. Referring once again to

FIG. 3

, a digital signal is applied to node N


1




76


(ON/OFF control node) which determines the state of the integrated RF switch diode


8


. When this signal is “LOW”, the voltage of the node N


2




36


is positive and diode


8


is OFF. When this signal is “HIGH”, the voltage of node N


2




36


is about −0.7, so the minority carriers are injected into substrate and the integrated RF switch diode


8


is on.




Turning once again to

FIG. 3

, the RF switch diode


8


is turned off when the PMOS FET's M


5




98


and M


6


,


100


respectively are turned off, thereby allowing no current to flow to the injection node


24


. This is accomplished by applying a zero bias voltage on node N


1




76


which turns on the PMOS FET's M


2




80


with the NMOS FET M


1




78


in the ON state do to the bias voltage from VPOS


60


. By way of example but not of limitation, the voltage of VPOS


60


is 5 volts. With both M


1




78


and M


2




80


in the ON state, PMOS FET's M


7




92


and M


8




94


are turned on by the bias voltage supplied by VNEG


74


. With M


7




92


and M


8




94


in the ON state, voltage VHV


90


through resistor


102


allows power to be switched from the RF power source


30


to the transducer


34


. The zero voltage on none N


1




76


turns on M


4




96


providing a positive voltage on node N


3


which turns OFF M


6




100


. The voltage turns OFF the RF switch diode


8


.




Likewise, the RF switch diode


8


is turned on when the PMOS FET M


6




100


is turned on, thereby allowing current to flow to the injection node


24


. This is accomplished by applying a positive bias voltage (typically 5 volts) on node N


1




76


which turns off the PMOS FET M


2




80


. With M


2




80


in the off state, PMOS FET's M


7




92


and M


8




94


are not turned on by the bias voltage supplied by VNEG


74


. With M


6




100


in the onON state, the RF switch diode


8


is closed creating a short circuit for the RF signal


30


a path from node


22


to the substrate


18


to ground allowing no power to the transducer


34


.




Also the positive (5V) voltage on node N


1




76


turns off M


4




96


so there is no large current in resistor RP


184


due to M


4




96


. The small current in RP


1




84


is only provided by transistor M


3




82


such that the voltage of node N


3


is negative (by Vneg


74


) allowing M


6




100


to be on to provide a current path for RF switch diode


8


which is turned on.




Therefore, the on-impedance of the RF switch diode


8


can be varied by changing the amount of current injected into the n+ injecting node


14


. When there is no current, the RF switch diode


8


acts as a normal two-terminal diode because there are no injected electrons to reduce the on-impedance. However, as the current into the n+ injecting node


14


rises, more electrons are injected and the on-impedance is lowered. When the n+ injecting node


14


is reverse biased there is a positive bias on the n+ injecting node


14


as referenced against the p− epi


18


. When there is a forward bias on the n+ injecting node


14


no electrons are injected into the p− epi


18


. The RF switch diode


8


then behaves as it normally would, however with the n-well cathode


12


and p− epi


18


doping values the RF switch diode


8


has a low reversed biased capacitance.




Turning once again to

FIG. 3

, in the described driver circuitry, a PMOS transistor M


6




100


and resistor RP


1




84


are provided such that when the RF switch diode


8


is on, the current in the RF switch diode


8


is the same as the current in transistor M


6




100


. In accordance with one embodiment of the present invention, the RF switch diode's


8


current is basically controlled by controlling the current in M


6




100


. The current in M


6




100


itself is controlled by the voltage Vgs (voltage between gate and source) of M


6




100


(which is proportional to the voltage drop across RP


1




84


), K


P


the gain factor and V


T


the threshold voltage of PMOS transistor M


6




100


. RP


1




84


is a “Poly” resistor and the voltage drop across it is affected by the value of this resistor and the current through this resistor which is the same current in transistor M


3




82


.




The values of RP


1




84


, K


P


and V


T


can vary from one fabricated lot to another and may also be changed due to temperature change and variations in power supply Vpos. These variations can change the current in different RF diode switches


8


and ultimately degrade the switch array uniformity. To compensate for these undesirable variations, the driver circuitry is designed such that the current in M


3




82


and therefore the Vgs voltage and current of M


6




100


(and therefore the current in the RF diode switch


8


) is adjusted in an opposite direction to cancel the unwanted variations.




Referring once again to

FIG. 3

, a second “poly” resistor RP


2




66


is added to compensate for variation in the value of the poly-resistor RP


1




84


. Although during fabrication of the driver circuitry the values of RP


1




84


and RP


2




66


may change drastically due to process or temperature variations. However, their ratio remains almost constant because their variation (increase or decrease) are in the same direction. Therefore, if value of RP


1




84


is increased due to process variations, the value of RP


2




66


will vary by the same rate since it is fabricated on the same wafer. The compensation for the resistance of RP


1




84


by RP


2




66


is due to the connection of PMOS transistor M


10




62


to the PMOS transistor M


3




82


. As shown in

FIG. 3.

, the transistors M


10




62


and M


3




82


form a “Current Mirror” such that current in M


3




82


follows the current in M


10




62


. The transistor M


10




66


is connected to the resistor RP


2




66


through an NMOS transistor M


12




64


. Therefore, an increase in the resistance value of RP


2




66


will cause a decrease in the current i


m10


at transistor M


10




62


. Since M


3


is acts as a current mirror, the current in i


m3


will also decrease and compensate for an increase in the resistance RP


1




84


. Since the ratio between RP


1




82


and RP


2




66


are always approximately the same, the gate to source voltage Vgs of M


6




100


is always held constant and therefore the current in M


6




100


is constant and therefore the RF switch diode's


8


current is held constant.




Turning once again to

FIG. 3

, a cascaded branch of PMOS transistors


50


,


52


,


54


are added to compensate for variations in K


P


and V


T


in the RF switch diode


8


. Once again during fabrication of the driver circuitry the values of K


P


and V


T


may change drastically for PMOS transistor M


6




100


due to process or temperature variations. However, cascaded PMOS transistors


50


,


52


,


54


will have the same K


P


and V


T


variations as the K


P


and V


T


values of M


6




100


due to process variations since they are all fabricated simultaneously on the same wafer. The compensation for the K


P


and V


T


values of M


6




100


by cascaded PMOS transistors


50


,


52


,


54


is due to the connection of PMOS transistor M


13




50


to the PMOS transistor M


11




56


. As shown in

FIG. 3.

, the transistor M


13




50


and M


11




56


also form a “Current Mirror” such that current in M


11




50


follows the current in M


13




50


. If during fabrication, the K


P


and V


T


values of M


6




100


is increased or decreased, so are all the PMOS transistors


50


,


52


and


54


. The PMOS transistors


50


,


52


and


54


may be represented as a branch of resistances Rm in series. When K


P


is increased, the Rm's are decreased resulting in less resistance in the branch and thus an increase in current i


m13


at PMOS transistor M


13




50


. Since M


13




50


and M


11




56


act as a current mirror, the current in i


m11


will also increase. As shown in

FIG. 3

, PMOS transistor M


11




56


is connected to PMOS transistor M


10




62


such that the value of the current i


m10


is equal to the current i


m12


in M


12




64


minus the current i


m11


in M


11




62


. Therefore, if the current in i


m11


increases, the current in i


m10


decreases and as described above, the current i


m10


is equal to the current i


m3


. With an increase in K


P


a resulting decrease in i


m3


occurs resulting in a drop of the Vgs across transistor M


6




100


and i


m6


once again remains constant and the current in the RF switch diode remains constant.




Similarly, when V


T


is increased, the Rm's are increased resulting in more resistance in the branch and thus a decrease in current i


m13


in PMOS transistor M


13




50


. Current i


m13


in M


11




56


will also be decreased resulting in larger current in M


10




62


and thus in M


3




82


which increases the gate voltage of M


6




100


and canceling the effect of increase in V


T


such that the current in the RF switch diode


8


remains constant.




To compensate for variations in the power supply Vpos


60


, a branch of cascaded NMOS transistors


44


,


46


,


48


are added to the circuit and connected to the NMOS transistor M


12




64


, as shown in FIG.


3


. If the Vpos


60


voltage varies up or down, so does the voltage at node N


4


. The cascaded NMOS transistors


44


,


46


,


48


act as a voltage divider circuit such that an increase for example in Vpos


60


results in an increase in the voltage of N


4


and hence the current of transistor M


12




64


. Similarly an increase in current appears at the PMOS transistor M


11




56


due to cascaded PMOS transistors


50


,


52


and


54


acting as a voltage divider. Since the current i


m10


is equal to the current i


m11


subtracted from the current im


12


, and the currents are always constant, the current at i


m10


will remain constant. When the current at i


m3


is constant, Vgs will also be constant and thus the current i


m6


and the RF switch diode current will once again be constant.




Lastly, to compensate for variations in the power supply Vneg


74


, RP


2




66


and M


12




64


play a role. Referring once again to

FIG. 3.

, if the power supply Vneg


74


varies, its variations affects the voltage of node N


3


which changes the current in M


6




100


and thus the current in RF switch diode


8


. For example of the absolute value of the Vneg decreases the voltage of N


3


decreases as well. But the decrease in Vneg increases the current in RP


2


since it is connected to the same Vneg


74


. The increase in this current will increase i


m3


, the current in M


3




82


such that the voltage of node N


3


remains constant making the current in M


6




100


and thus the current in RF switch


8


constant.




As described, the biasing voltage of node N


2


is directly determined by various process parameters which can vary significantly in different process lots. Also, this voltage is affected by temperature and power supply variations. As a result the injecting current and RF diode characteristics are very sensitive to these variations which can drastically degrade the speed and efficiently of RF switching in AEP systems. Lastly, the described technique is applicable to both MOS and bipolar circuitry and to the complement of the circuitry illustrated.




While there have been shown and described what are at present considered embodiments of the invention, it will be obvious to those skilled in the art that various changes and modifications may be made therein without departing from the scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims. While the present invention will be described in connection with a preferred embodiment and method of use, it will be understood that it is not intended to it the invention to that embodiment or procedure. On the contrary, it is intended to cover all alternatives, modifications and equivalents as may be included within the spirit and scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims.



Claims
  • 1. An electronic driver circuitry for an integrated RF switching diode, comprising:a CMOS integrated circuit diode for RF switching; a first PMOS transistor and a first poly-resistor circuit electrically connected to and for switching ON/OFF said CMOS integrated circuit diode, said first PMOS transistor having an equal current as said CMOS integrated circuit diode; a second poly-resistor in electrically connected with said first polyresistor for compensating variations in resistance; a plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors in circuit connection with said first PMOS transistor for compensating variations in gain and voltage threshold of said CMOS integrated circuit diode; and a plurality of cascaded NMOS transistors in circuit connection with said plurality of PMOS transistors for compensating for variations in supply voltage, wherein all compensation cancels out undesired variations keeping current across the CMOS integrated circuit diode constant.
  • 2. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 1 wherein said resistance compensation is due to a connection of a second PMOS transistor to a third PMOS transistor, said second PMOS transistor and said third PMOS transistor connected such that current in said second PMOS transistor follows the current in said third PMOS transistor and said third PMOS transistor is connected to said second poly-resistor through a fourth NMOS transistor.
  • 3. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 2 wherein a change of poly-resistor value of said second resistance causes an opposite change of current in said third PMOS transistor with said current in said second PMOS transistor having like current thereby compensating for an increase in resistance of said first poly-resistor wherein source voltage and current of said first PMOS transistor is held constant said current across the CMOS integrated circuit diode constant.
  • 4. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 3 wherein said plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors are electrically connected to a fifth PMOS transistor electrically connected to said third PMOS transistor, and said fifth PMOS transistor and said third PMOS transistor connected such that current in said fifth PMOS transistor follows the current in said third PMOS transistor wherein variations in gain and voltage threshold are compensated by the electrical connection of said plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors through said fifth and third PMOS transistors.
  • 5. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 4 wherein said plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors is three PMOS transistors connected in series defining a series voltage divider.
  • 6. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 4 wherein said cascaded NMOS transistors are electrically connected to said fourth NMOS transistor, said fourth NMOS transistor electrically connected to said fifth PMOS transistor wherein variations in supply voltage are compensated through saidfifth, third and second PMOS transistors said fourth NMOS transistor.
  • 7. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 6 wherein said plurality of cascaded NMOS transistors is three NMOS transistors connected in series defining a series voltage divider.
  • 8. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 6 wherein a change of poly-resistor value of said second resistance causes an opposite change of current in said third PMOS transistor with said current in said second PMOS transistor having like current thereby compensating for an increase in resistance of said first poly-resistor wherein negative voltage of said first PMOS transistor is held constant said current across the CMOS integrated circuit diode constant.
  • 9. An electronic driver circuitry for an integrated RF switching diode, comprising:a CMOS integrated circuit diode for RF switching; a first PMOS transistor and a first poly-resistor circuit electrically connected to and for switching ON/OFF said CMOS integrated circuit diode, said first PMOS transistor having an equal current as said CMOS integrated circuit diode; a second poly-resistor in electrically connected with said first polyresistor for compensating variations in resistance; a plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors in circuit connection with said first PMOS transistor for compensating variations in gain and voltage threshold of said CMOS integrated circuit diode; and a plurality of cascaded NMOS transistors in circuit connection with said plurality of PMOS transistors for compensating for variations in supply voltage, wherein said resistance compensation is due to a connection of a second PMOS transistor to a third PMOS transistor, said second PMOS transistor and said third PMOS transistor connected such that current in said second PMOS transistor follows the current in said third PMOS transistor and said third transistor is connected to said second poly-resistor through a fourth NMOS transistor whereby all compensation cancels out undesired variations keeping current across the CMOS integrated circuit diode constant.
  • 10. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 9 wherein a change of poly-resistor value of said second resistance causes an opposite change of current in said third PMOS transistor with said current in said second PMOS transistor having like current thereby compensating for an increase in resistance of said first poly-resistor wherein source voltage and current of said first PMOS transistor is held constant said current across the CMOS integrated circuit diode constant.
  • 11. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 10 wherein said plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors are electrically connected to a fifth PMOS transistor electrically connected to said third PMOS transistor, and said fifth PMOS transistor and said third PMOS transistor connected such that current in said fifth PMOS transistor follows the current in said third PMOS transistor wherein variations in gain and voltage threshold are compensated by the electrical connection of said plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors through said fifth and third PMOS transistors.
  • 12. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 11 wherein said plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors is three PMOS transistors connected in series defining a series voltage divider.
  • 13. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 12 wherein said cascaded NMOS transistors are electrically connected to said fourth NMOS transistor, said fourth NMOS transistor electrically connected to said fifth PMOS transistor wherein variations in supply voltage are compensated through said fifth, third and second PMOS transistors said fourth NMOS transistor.
  • 14. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 13 wherein said plurality of cascaded NMOS transistors is three NMOS transistors connected in series defining a series voltage divider.
  • 15. An electronic driver circuitry for an integrated RF switching diode, comprising:a CMOS integrated circuit diode for RF switching; a first PMOS transistor and a first poly-resistor circuit electrically connected to and for switching ON/OFF said CMOS integrated circuit diode, said first PMOS transistor having an equal current as said CMOS integrated circuit diode; a second poly-resistor in electrically connected with said first poly-resistor for compensating variations in resistance; a plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors in circuit connection with said first PMOS transistor for compensating variations in gain and voltage threshold of said CMOS integrated circuit diode; and a plurality of cascaded NMOS transistors in circuit connection with said plurality of PMOS transistors for compensating for variations in supply voltage, wherein said resistance compensation is due to a connection of a second PMOS transistor to a third PMOS transistor, said second PMOS transistor and said third PMOS transistor connected such that current in said second PMOS transistor follows the current in said third PMOS transistor and said third transistor is connected to said second poly-resistor through a fourth NMOS transistor wherein a change of resistance value of said second poly-resistor causes an opposite change of current in said third PMOS transistor with said current in said second PMOS transistor having like current thereby compensating for an increase in resistance of said first poly-resistor wherein source voltage and current of said first PMOS transistor is held constant said current across the CMOS integrated circuit diode constant whereby all compensation cancels out undesired variations keeping current across the CMOS integrated circuit diode constant.
  • 16. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 15 wherein said plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors are electrically connected to a fifth PMOS transistor electrically connected to said third PMOS transistor, and said fifth PMOS transistor and said third PMOS transistor connected such that current in said fifth PMOS transistor follows the current in said third PMOS transistor wherein variations in gain and voltage threshold are compensated by the electrical connection of said plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors through said fifth and third PMOS transistors.
  • 17. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 15 wherein said plurality of cascaded PMOS transistors is three PMOS transistors connected in series defining a series voltage divider.
  • 18. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 15 wherein said cascaded NMOS transistors are electrically connected to said fourth NMOS transistor, said fourth NMOS transistor electrically connected to said fifth PMOS transistor wherein variations in supply voltage are compensated through said sixth, fifth, third and second PMOS transistors said fourth NMDS transistor.
  • 19. The electronic driver circuitry of claim 15 wherein said plurality of cascaded NMOS transistors is three NMOS transistors connected in series defining a series voltage divider.
CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION

Attention is directed to copending application Ser. No. 10/025,475, filed herewith, entitled, “Process and Temperature Compensation Circuit for Integrated RF Switching.” The disclosure of this reference is hereby incorporated in its entirety.

US Referenced Citations (3)
Number Name Date Kind
5757065 Buhler et al. May 1998 A
5969561 McGillan Oct 1999 A
6208191 Alexander Mar 2001 B1