Patent Application
20160379392
This invention relates to the fields of producing visual representation of textual information, and especially to complex works of literature.
Works of literature, such as novels, short stories, textbooks and even legal reference books, contain complex relationships between their elements such as the organization of information, the relationship between the characters presented in the literature, and a plot line within the work of literature.
For works which are more narrative in nature, such as novels and short stories, the plot is a story line which is populated not only with characters and their interactions, but also with information such as natural events, descriptions of scenery, as well as elements such as humor, mystery, suspense, drama, action, struggles, birth, death, betrayal, etc. For works which are more referential, such as textbooks and references books, there characters who are the contributing authors as well as cited authors, and the plot line corresponds to the organization or sequence of presentation of information. All of these types of works of literature can be viewed in segments, such as chapters, or even just in blocks of literature such as page ranges.
As a consumer, whether an avid novel reader or a professional or student using a reference book, one becomes aware of one's preferred content and presentation sequence. For this reason, there is a vast array of novel writing styles as well as reference book formats. One novel consumer may prefer mild humor strewn throughout a drama (e.g. “romantic comedy”) that has at least a small resolution of conflict within each chapter, for example. Another novel consumer may prefer mystery and intrigue, organized initially as separate plotlines which become entangled with each other in the later segments.
For reference works, one consumer may prefer a sequentially-organized presentation of information which starts with an introduction to a subject (e.g. field of science, area of law, etc.), and presents deeper and more detailed information progressively in each chapter, wherein a final chapter is virtually cryptic except to experts in the field.
The methods and systems disclosed herein generate a visualization of literary elements of a work of literature, such as a novel or short story, from meta-data records representing a digital work of literature including literary elements (humor, drama, adventure, etc.), characters, and plot devices related to a position within the work of literature where each appears. A significance level is determined for each of the elements, characters and plot devices at each position within the work of literature, and these are plotted into a sequential graph having position (e.g. timeline) axis and a significance level axis. The sequential graph is then output for printing or display. Human-generated and machine-generated meta-data may be ingested equally well by the method. Colors, line thickness, and a broken line patterns may be employed for greater visual meaning. And, the sequential graph may be annotated according to segments (e.g. chapters, sections) and dominant genre within each segment.
The figures presented herein, when considered in light of this description, form a complete disclosure of one or more embodiments of the invention, wherein like reference numbers in the figures represent similar or same elements or steps.
The present inventors have recognized a problem and opportunity not yet noticed or discovered by those skilled in the relevant arts. The previously mentioned complexities of works of literature and consumer preferences are not easily matched with any available technology. Consumers are relegated to shopping for works of literature from the same author or from the same reference book publisher as their previously preferred books in the hope that the new works will be similar. They are often disappointed with the author or publisher tries a new approach, eliminates a favorite character, or experiments with a new style or organization of information. Thus, authors and publishers with established consumer bases find themselves locked into the successful writing styles, and other authors and publishers find difficulty attracting new consumers.
In the process of developing the present invention, the inventors first tried to locate suitable technologies that would allow an author or publisher to quickly and efficiently communicate the complexities of a work of literature to a consumer, and for the consumer to know the same about a new work of literature. Ideally, such a technology would represent the plot line, interactions of the characters, and various preferred literary elements (humor, mystery, drama, etc.) in a manner that does not spoil the story, but which allows a consumer to know if he or she might like the new work of literature.
Currently there doesn't appear to be an available, convenient and easy way to visualize and know what type of content is contained in a novel or book and the way certain literary elements flow throughout the book. One must have a general understanding of a genre, such as sci-fi, suspense, or drama, and one may can get an impression of the content of a work of literature based on user reviews about the work.
But one cannot readily view the writing style, the elements within the book (e.g. “how humorous”, “how descriptive”, etc.), and how descriptive to certain elements (setting, character, location, food, mind-set) etc. There isn't a quick way to gauge how these elements play out in segments in the book and whether they are prevalent through the book and would match your type of reading interests. The only reasonable way to get somewhat accurate understanding of a book is Cliff™ notes, a NY Times review, other reader reviews, or a collation of reviews by pulling information from readers.
None of these available methods, however, appear to have an easy to comprehend, visual representation of the book content. Therefore, the inventors have discovered that there is a need in the art, not recognized yet by those skilled in the art, for a way to allow a person or system to get a visual representation of the literary elements and tone of the book or flow and content type of literature, showing where it fluctuates or is prevalent throughout the literature, in order to allow potential readers or consumers to better understand what kind of literature it is.
For example, one available technology is described in pre-grant published patent application US2010/0185984 by Wright. To the best of our understanding, this disclosure deals with visualizing temporal and spacial data based on events and people in different physical locations at a particular time, shown in a bar-graph format. However, the Wright visualization does not seem to relate to a timeline and literary elements (e.g. how happy, how mysterious, etc.) in a work of literature.
Another available technology is described in pre-grant published patent application US2007/0132767, also by Wright, which generates stories in time and space and for analysis of story patterns in an integrated visual representation on a user interface. However, Wright's visualization in this disclosure appears to create more of a geographical representation of a storyline, which does not indicate to a viewer how the story changes over time with respect to the intensity of drama, intensity of humor, intensity of mystery, etc., to the best of our understanding.
Another available technology is described in pre-grant published patent application US2009/0063412 to Harris which finds emotional literary elements in text and maps them to main characters in the text. It registers these emotional reactions as positive or negative and monitors shifts in the characters emotional state. It plots or draws the emotional elements for a negative or positive classification in a diagram, but the representation of the literary elements is only binary (positive or negative), and does not relate them to plot elements or events, to the best of our understanding.
Yet another available technology is described in pre-grant published patent application US2009/0248399 to Au, which finds emotional literary elements in text and maps them to main characters in the text. It then registers these emotional reactions as positive or negative and monitors shifts in the characters emotional state. It plots or draws the emotional elements for a negative or positive classification in a diagram. It, too, does not appear to relate these elements of information to the plot line in a visual manner, as far as we can tell.
Having found no suitable process or method which meets our objectives, we now present one or more embodiments of an invention which represents various narrative elements in a visual graph by analyzing and capturing the literary elements, levels of detail, and interesting categories of data. The produced visualization rendered is easy to understand, provided in a segmented format that is easy to comprehend as graphical elements along the story line or literature. Further, the graphical elements are backed by literary metadata scale gathered from the text and across plot themes or category themes. The analyzed and visualized categories are flexible such that they allow different literature types to be examined and formulated in the visual literature graph. The new visualization goes beyond those of the known art by relating the intensity or significance, not just the direction of change, of one or more literary elements to at least one of the following: a timeline, a character, and a plot device.
Included in at least one embodiment of the new visual graph are the occurrences of plot devices which show how various parts of the story-line move and develop relative to one or more literary elements. An advantage of this visual graphical plot graph is to be able to distinctly quickly see the make-up in general of a book or novel. It will allow users to identify with literature much easier, because it is human readable and visual. Another advantage is the ability for publishers or authors to easily see the make-up of a book they are writing or publishing and make adjustments to the content to suit their potential readers.
Potentially, this visualization may be printed on a book, such as on the back cover, or displayed online next to a book available for purchase, to assist a potential reader or buyer in quickly determining if the book may be of interest to him or her.
The invention disclosed herein and several related inventions, also disclosed in U.S. patent applications by the same inventors, fit within a larger architecture for literature analysis, recommendation and annotation. Turning to
Meta-data representing the results of this analysis is stored (904), and optionally aggregated (905) with meta-data which is converted from manually-created descriptions of the works of literature, such as reviews, Cliff™ notes, condensed versions of the works, etc.
In one manner of using this meta-data, which is disclosed in another related patent application, the meta-data may be further analyzed and organized (906) into hierarchical layers of abstraction to allow ready comparison with other works of literature via their abstracted meta-data representations.
In yet another manner of using this meta-data, and optionally using the abstracted models, which is disclosed in another related patent application, the meta-data and models may be used by an inferential engine (907) to discover deep similarities between two or more works of literature, and to yield one or more recommendations (908) to a potential consumer. The potential consumer's preferences may also optionally be factored into the inferential engine's analysis, as is disclosed in the related patent application.
The presently disclosed process receives the computer-generated meta-data (904), or the meta-data converted from manually-generated reviews, or a combination (905) of both, to generate (909) a visualization of the work of literature (910) which relates segments of the literature to plot events and intensity or significance of the literary elements (humor, mystery, scenery, etc.). This visualization (910) may then be used to annotate the work of literature (902) that it represents, such as printing it on the back cover of the paper book or displaying it relative to the digital book on a web page.
Regardless of whether the visualization is generated based upon a meta-data representation of a work of literature which was automatically or manually created, the visualization will take a general form of a bar graph as shown in
In
In this example, plotted line 1 represents the literature descriptor of humor. Its intensity can be seen at any point in the novel (time corresponds to position of the left-right axis) as the distance of the line from the baseline (intensity corresponds to the up-down axis). Beginning in the first segment (101a), humor in this example starts moderately significant, grows in significance until plot element 5 (triangle), wanes a bit, and then continues to intensify into the second segment, and so forth as shown.
Now, consider plotted line 4 which represents the intensity or significance of suspense in the work of literature, which begins in the first segment (101a) less significant than humor (plot line 1), and remains less significant throughout the first segment, but then becomes more significant that humor in the second segment (101b), peaking at maximum significance at the transition from the second segment (101b) to the third segment, but ends the third segment as the least significant of the plotted literary elements (humor, imagery, and mood). One can infer from this visualization that the suspense is resolved at the end of the work of literature, which some readers may prefer. Some works of literature, however, leave suspense high with unresolved issues, as a hook to a sequel story. While some readers are OK with unresolved suspense, others may not prefer it.
As one can see from this graph, and especially if it were rendered using colored lines without circled number indicia, plot events can be readily correlated to the literary elements so that a reader can see how each element flows through each segment. Please note, however, that this visualization conveys this deep, detailed information about the work of literature without revealing the actual story itself, unlike a detailed review or synopsis which may require a spoiler alert. Thus, a first advantage of the present invention is seen.
Turning now to
Now, turning to
Referring now to
This particular example logical process begins (201) by ingesting (202) the meta-data for a work of literature. The extraction of characters, character relationships, and plot devices, as well as the determination of significance levels of one or more literary elements is typically performed manually or automatically prior to beginning (201) the visualization generation process. These data may be converted to compatible meta-data for ingestion a logical process according to the present invention at this time, or upon starting the current process. In some embodiments, the extraction and conversion may occur concurrently with the visualization process, as well, such as the visualization process invoking or requesting extraction and conversion as it is needed.
If (203) the meta-data is not already segmented, then it is segmented (204) according to one or more segmentation schemes, such as along chapter boundaries, or by dividing the total number of pages of the work of literature into N equal length segments, etc.
Next, the first segment (205) is analyzed to determine (206) the significance level of each literary element within the segment, such as the significance of humor, of mystery, etc. From this, a dominant genre for the segment is determined (207) and recorded. One example rule for determining the dominant genre may be counting the number of sentences or paragraphs in which each literary element appears, and the genre with the greatest count is determined to be the dominant genre.
If more segments (209) are to be processed, then the next segment (208) is analyzed (206) for significant literary elements through it and a dominant genre is determined (207) and recorded for it. After the segments have been assigned dominant genres and significance level of each literary element throughout the segment has been determined, the entirety of the work (all segments) is considered, and the significance levels of the literary elements are normalized (210).
For example, referring back to
Now that all the significance scores for all the literary elements are normalized across the entire work of literature (or a selected portion of it), a bar graph is generated (211) in which the plotted lines are created (213) using the legend or key indicia (colored lines, weighted lines, broken or patterned lines, etc.) for each literary element's significance as a function of time progressing through the work of literature. Segment boundaries may be marked on the graph (212) optionally, and still further, backgrounds within the segments may be shaded, colored or patterned according to a legend or key (e.g. blue for suspense, red for action, yellow for romance, orange for humor, etc.).
And, the significant plot elements, such as events or changes of scenery or location of the story, may be marked (214) on the bar graph. Here it is important to note that the events are not being plotted as a geographical sequence, such as is done in the noted available art on a geographical map, but instead, they are marked relative to the timeline. In the example embodiment of
Various embodiments of the invention may combine generation of these indicia differently, omitting some, adding others, and using different graphical techniques such as colors, patterns, shapes, etc., to convey the information.
Lastly, the visualization is rendered, such as by creating a digital image or movie file (.JPG, .PIC, .GIF, .MOV, .MP3 files, etc.), which may then be printed to paper for application to a book cover or inside leaf page, or shown in a computer screen relative to the work of literature under consideration.
There is a wide array of known line plotting methods which generate a smoothed curve line based upon a set of coordinate points, and which visually display multiple items relative to each other's significance levels. For example, the well-known Gartner Business Intelligence Magic Quadrant accomplishes this type of visualization.
Some works of literature follow a linear beginning-to-ending timeline, but others involve jumps in timelines, such as flashbacks and flashforwards. Still other works of literature may present different character perspectives of different timelines in a non-linear manner. Embodiments of the present invention may linearize such non-linear timelines for the purposes of arrangement for display and visualization. While linearization of a non-linear timeline may be useful for some purposes of visualization (e.g. understanding a story line such as Cloud Atlas by David Mitchell), it may also spoil the story for the reader and lose literary effect such as creation of wonder, intrigue, or emotion. So, other embodiments, or options within embodiments, may show a visualization with a timeline axis that does not map directly to a linear timeline, but instead maps to the actual progression of literary elements, characters, relationships and plot devices presented in the order they appear in the work of literature. Still other embodiments may allow for linearization on just one character, one relationship, one literary element, etc.
At least one embodiment of the present invention receives meta-data from a deep semantic analyzer as shown in the architectural arrangement of
The information annotated is specific to the set of literary elements required in that analysis, whether it's a novel, series of books or just a short story. For example, one embodiment for determining intensity of humor for may be to analyze text to find and annotate words such as laugh, guffaws, smiles, and certain key relationships like “corner of mouth turns up” into a synonym table and mapping to a language ware based model for humor. An advanced analyzer would further provide a confidence level and a weight towards how much humor exists by the number of participants, the type of writing style used to determine and how strong the language was. For example, a “smile” is subtle humor, while a guffaw would carry more weight. Each annotation for humor is annotated with metadata, by the Literary Element Data (metadata) Capturer, also shown in
For example, consider that a malapropism is detected in the text:
Such an analyzer would identify laughter after the text, back trace and analyze subset of text prior to the “Mark laughs” by paragraph(s) and after for entire paragraph. To analyze text for type of humor, the process would run through a fact check for Noun, possessive verb, and subject. A correction would denotes malapropism, and an identifiable pattern for malapropism would be developed that can be learned and fed into the system.
Meta-data in the form of a record for this detection might appear as such:
For this example, a meta-data recording of this event may appear as the 293rd entry in a full set of metadata as such:
Similarly for other literary elements and genres, relevant types may be applied as to the humor example above (level, relationships, weight, line/page/section, etc.). For example, Adventure may be typed as Discovery, Knowledge, Area, Excitement, Danger, or Risk. Other literary elements may include, besides humor and adventure, tragedy, revenge, romance, satire, suspense, sadness, drama, mystery, heroism, and villainy.
Element details may include environment setting, imagery, food, emotional state, character mood(s), cultural settings, and character personae.
Plot devices may include themes, tone, styles, character personae, and devices. Here, we refer to a plot device as is a means of advancing the plot in a story, often used to motivate characters, create urgency or resolve a difficulty. This can be contrasted with moving a story forward with narrative technique, that is, by making things happen because characters take action for solid, well-motivated reasons. Types of plot devices may be events (e.g. encounters, fights, romantic interludes, chases, journeys, storms, etc.), time changes, location changes, jumping backwards in time, leaping forwards in time, etc.
Genres may include adventure, action, mystery, social drama, fantasy, comedy, horror, romance, thriller, etc.
These are not exhaustive lists, of course, but they are meant to provide the present reader an illustration of how flexible the meta-data representations are for covering a wide variety of works of literature and their content.
The preceding paragraphs have set forth example logical processes according to the present invention, which, when coupled with processing hardware, embody systems according to the present invention, and which, when coupled with tangible, computer readable memory devices, embody computer program products according to the related invention.
Regarding computers for executing the logical processes set forth herein, it will be readily recognized by those skilled in the art that a variety of computers are suitable and will become suitable as memory, processing, and communications capacities of computers and portable devices increases. In such embodiments, the operative invention includes the combination of the programmable computing platform and the programs together. In other embodiments, some or all of the logical processes may be committed to dedicated or specialized electronic circuitry, such as Application Specific Integrated Circuits or programmable logic devices.
The present invention may be realized for many different processors used in many different computing platforms.
Many such computing platforms, but not all, allow for the addition of or installation of application programs (501) which provide specific logical functionality and which allow the computing platform to be specialized in certain manners to perform certain jobs, thus rendering the computing platform into a specialized machine. In some “closed” architectures, this functionality is provided by the manufacturer and may not be modifiable by the end-user.
The “hardware” portion of a computing platform typically includes one or more processors (504) accompanied by, sometimes, specialized co-processors or accelerators, such as graphics accelerators, and by suitable computer readable memory devices (RAM, ROM, disk drives, removable memory cards, etc.). Depending on the computing platform, one or more network interfaces (505) may be provided, as well as specialty interfaces for specific applications. If the computing platform is intended to interact with human users, it is provided with one or more user interface devices (507), such as display(s), keyboards, pointing devices, speakers, etc. And, each computing platform requires one or more power supplies (battery, AC mains, solar, etc.).
The terminology used herein is for the purpose of describing particular embodiments only and is not intended to be limiting of the invention. As used herein, the singular forms “a”, “an” and “the” are intended to include the plural forms as well, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise. It will be further understood that the terms “comprises” and/or “comprising,” when used in this specification, specify the presence of stated features, steps, operations, elements, and/or components, but do not preclude the presence or addition of one or more other features, steps, operations, elements, components, and/or groups thereof, unless specifically stated otherwise.
The corresponding structures, materials, acts, and equivalents of all means or step plus function elements in the claims below are intended to include any structure, material, or act for performing the function in combination with other claimed elements as specifically claimed. The description of the present invention has been presented for purposes of illustration and description, but is not intended to be exhaustive or limited to the invention in the form disclosed. Many modifications and variations will be apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art without departing from the scope and spirit of the invention. The embodiment was chosen and described in order to best explain the principles of the invention and the practical application, and to enable others of ordinary skill in the art to understand the invention for various embodiments with various modifications as are suited to the particular use contemplated.
It should also be recognized by those skilled in the art that certain embodiments utilizing a microprocessor executing a logical process may also be realized through customized electronic circuitry performing the same logical process(es).
It will be readily recognized by those skilled in the art that the foregoing example embodiments do not define the extent or scope of the present invention, but instead are provided as illustrations of how to make and use at least one embodiment of the invention. The following claims define the extent and scope of at least one invention disclosed herein.
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | 14488424 | Sep 2014 | US |
| Child | 15263703 | US | |
| Parent | 14094911 | Dec 2013 | US |
| Child | 14488424 | US |
