Protecting medium voltage inductive coupled device from electrical transients

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 7529073
  • Patent Number
    7,529,073
  • Date Filed
    Monday, August 7, 2006
    18 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, May 5, 2009
    15 years ago
  • Inventors
  • Original Assignees
  • Examiners
    • Jackson; Stephen W
    • Kitov; Zeev
    Agents
    • Ohlandt, Greeley, Ruggiero & Perle, LLP
Abstract
There is provided a method for protecting loads associated with power distribution system inductive signal couplers. The method includes (a) providing an inductive signal coupler having a first winding in series with a line conductor of a power distribution system, and a second winding having first and second connection terminals, (b) connecting a first terminal of a first fuse to the first connection terminal, and a first terminal of a second fuse to the second connection terminal, a second terminal of each fuse being connected to a communication device, and (c) connecting a first terminal of a first choke to the second terminal of the first fuse, and a first terminal of a second choke to the second of the second fuse, a second terminal of each choke being connected to an electrical ground.
Description
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

1. Field of the Invention


The present invention relates to coupling communication signals to electrical power distribution systems.


2. Background of the Related Art


Radio frequency (rf) modulated data signals can be coupled to and communicated over medium and low voltage power distribution networks. Use of inductive couplers for this purpose is described in U.S. Pat. No. 6,452,482, entitled “Inductive Coupling of a Data Signal to a Power Transmission Cable”, and U.S. patent application Ser. No. 10/082,063, filed Feb. 25, 2002, entitled, “Coupling Broadband Lines”, both of which are assigned to the assignee of the present application, and the contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.


Power distribution networks are occasionally subject to significant transients in voltage and current. For example, a strong current pulse of fast rise time is created when a power line device such as a distribution transformer short circuits, or when power lines fall and touch each other. Similarly, a lightning strike to a nearby point on the power line generates a traveling wave on the power line. A standard method of simulating a lightning strike is the Basic Impulse Loading (BIL) pulse, used for testing power line devices that would be connected to power lines, and it has a rise time of 1.2 microseconds, with a much longer fall time. The amplitude of such test pulses can vary between 90 and 200 kV peak.


A power line inductive coupler is basically a transformer whose primary is connected to the power line and whose secondary is connected to a communications apparatus such as a modem. The primary winding has one or just a few turns and presents a very low impedance at a power frequency. However, the coupler is capable of coupling the high frequency energy represented by the fast onset of a lightning pulse or other transient, and substantial voltage would be induced in the coupler secondary circuit.


Coupler flashover of medium voltage from a primary power wire to ground occurs when the wire's voltage exceeds the insulation capability of the coupler, whether during normal operation or during transient voltage pulses originating in lightning strikes or switching transients. Flashover can occur on the outer surface of the coupler or internally between parts of the coupler. Flashover may be considered a very rare event for suitably insulated devices attached to a medium voltage power line. For example, current and potential transformers commonly used by utilities often do not carry special protective circuitry. But in the case of a data coupler, which is intended to be used ubiquitously for a large customer base, it is considered prudent to protect against rare events, to prevent injury or damage.


In addition, since the modem is connected to lines leading to customer equipment, the modem is grounded. Therefore, the distribution power voltage must be insulated from the modem. If the inductive coupler's secondary were insulated from ground, then the voltage difference between the power line and ground would be divided across (a) the coupler's primary to secondary insulation and (b) the insulation of other devices in the chain of devices leading to the modem. The voltage drops would be proportional to the impedances across each insulation interface, and thus inversely proportional to the stray capacitance across each such interface.


When dealing with medium voltage ac power lines, with voltages in excess of 2,000 volts rms relative to neutral or ground, this capacitive voltage division would be difficult to make deterministic, as the coupler capacitance would depend on the position and diameter of the power line within the coupler. Therefore, any other insulating devices would need to be capable of insulating the full power line voltage, and thus be large and expensive.


SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

Embodiments of the present invention are directed to techniques for protecting an inductive coupler of data signals to a power distribution network from electrical transients such as transient over-voltage and over-current conditions. More specifically, embodiments of the present invention enable an inductive coupler to withstand voltage spikes and provides protection against surges from flashover, i.e., the sudden breakdown of electrical insulation in the coupler, with optimal coupling of the rf data signal between an rf data modem and the power line. Embodiments also protect against transient current pulses that may develop on the power distribution line from such causes as a lightning strike or short-circuiting of the line to electrical ground.


A method for protecting loads associated with power distribution system inductive signal couplers includes (a) providing an inductive signal coupler having a first winding in series with a line conductor of a power distribution system, and a second winding having first and second connection terminals, (b) connecting a first terminal of a first fuse to the first connection terminal, and a first terminal of a second fuse to the second connection terminal, a second terminal of each fuse being connected to a communication device, and (c) connecting a first terminal of a first choke to the second terminal of the first fuse, and a first terminal of a second choke to the second of the second fuse, a second terminal of each choke being connected to an electrical ground.


Another method for protecting loads associated with power distribution system inductive signal couplers includes (a) providing an inductive signal coupler having a first winding in series with a line conductor of a power distribution system, and a second winding having first and second connection terminals, and (b) connecting each terminal of the second winding to an electrical ground via a choke, the choke presenting a high impedance to signal frequencies and a low impedance to current from an electrical fault signal.


An arrangement of components includes (a) an inductive signal coupler having a first winding in series with a line conductor of a power distribution system, and a second winding having a first connection terminal and a second connection terminal, (b) a first fuse having a first terminal connected to the first connection terminal, and a second terminal for coupling a signal to a first terminal of a communication device, (c) a second fuse having a first terminal connected to the second connection terminal, and a second terminal for coupling a signal to a second terminal of the communication device, (d) a first choke having a first terminal connected to the second terminal of the first fuse, and a second terminal connected to an electrical ground, and (e) a second choke having a first terminal connected to the second terminal of the second fuse, and a second terminal connected to the electrical ground.


Another arrangement of components includes (a) an inductive signal coupler having a first winding in series with a line conductor of a power distribution system, and a second winding having a first connection terminal and a second connection terminal, (b) a first choke between the first connection terminal and an electrical ground, and (c) a second choke between the second connection terminal and the electrical ground. Each of the first choke and the second choke present a high impedance to a signal frequency and a low impedance to current from an electrical fault signal.


An inductive signal coupler for coupling a signal to a power distribution system includes a first winding in series with a line conductor of the power distribution system, and sheds for providing a leakage path to avoid external flashover during an electrical transient.


Another inductive signal coupler for coupling a signal to a power distribution system includes a winding in series with a line conductor of the power distribution system, and a conductive plate at an end of the coupler distal from the first winding, for routing a flashover current to an electrical ground.





BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

The present invention will be more readily understood by reference to the following detailed description taken with the accompanying drawings, in which:



FIG. 1 shows an inductive coupler circuit according to one embodiment of the present invention, which is protected against over-voltage transients.



FIGS. 2A, 2B and 2C show embodiments of the present invention in which an arrangement of capacitors and surge suppressors protect against electrical transients.



FIG. 3 shows the equivalent circuit for a voltage transient created by flashover.



FIG. 4 shows a cross-section of one particular physical implementation of an inductive coupler according to an embodiment of the present invention.



FIG. 4A shows a section 4A-4A of the inductive coupler of FIG. 4.



FIGS. 5A and 5B shows particular specific implementations of a dual fuse according to an embodiment of the present invention.





DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

One embodiment of the present invention grounds the secondary winding of an inductive coupler by appropriate rf devices. This protects against over-voltage transients and takes full advantage of the principle of magnetic coupling, which is not affected by the thickness of the winding insulation. Consequently, the medium voltage of the power line is insulated from the modem solely by the insulation of the secondary winding. This approach prevents flashover current from propagating to low voltage lines and loads, and so prevents damage to the modem and other equipment to which the coupler may be connected.



FIG. 1 shows an inductive coupler circuit according to one embodiment of the present invention, which is protected against over-voltage transients. Power distribution line 100 forms a primary winding 105 of inductive coupler 110, which in turn is connected to an rf data signal modem (not shown) via output terminals 160 and 165. Secondary winding 115 has terminals 120 and 125, which connect to the upper terminals of transient protection fuses 130 and 135 respectively. Rf chokes 140 and 145 connect the lower terminals of the fuses to ground 150, typically via a wire 155 connected to the “pole ground,” a ground wire running from a ground rod at the base of the electric pole, up to the top of the pole. This pole ground 150 will generally be readily available in typical applications of a power line inductance coupler 110 used to bypass a distribution transformer on electric power poles.


The coupler 110 physically bridges a space between the power line 100 and the ground 150 connected to the coupler secondary winding 115. Thus, a leakage path is needed that is long enough to preclude external flashover. A typical embodiment provides “sheds.” In case external flashover occurs anyway, the coupler 110 may include an exposed metal base connected to the ground 150 to which an external flashover arc may jump without harm.


The rf chokes 140 and 145 are provided to ground any potential internal flashover current within the coupler 110. The secondary winding 115 is typically embedded in insulating material body of the coupler 110, which should be thick enough to provide a sufficient insulation rating for both steady state (“withstand”) voltage and for fast high voltage BIL pulses. The rf chokes 140 and 145 provide an rf impedance substantially greater than the rf impedance of the coupler secondary winding 115, while providing a low impedance to ground 150 after a few microseconds of a fault pulse. The connection of chokes 140 and 145 in shunt with the signal voltage provides a high pass filtering effect, as low frequencies are effectively shorted to ground 150. For modem frequencies above 1 MHz, chokes 140 and 145 might typically have an inductance of 10 uH each, providing a reactance across the coupler secondary winding 115 in excess of 124 ohms and rising with frequency. The chokes 140 and 145 should have a self-resonant frequency above the highest frequency of interest.


Flashover current is limited only by the capacity of the power line 100, typically up to 10,000 amps rms or about 14,000 amps peak. This flashover current is interrupted by and divided roughly equally between the fuses 130 and 135. Until the fuses 130 and 135 blow open, the rf chokes 140 and 145 need to carry the short circuit current without failing. Thus, rf chokes 140 and 145 should be wound with wire capable of withstanding the flashover current pulse that might flow.


The speed and size of a possible flashover current pulse suggests use of suitably rated expulsion fuses or current limiting fuses for the transient protection fuses 130 and 135. An expulsion fuse can interrupt current up to 8 milliseconds after the onset of a flashover transient. A current limiting fuse may interrupt faster, estimated not to exceed 4 milliseconds after the onset of a flashover transient. To maintain compliance with electromagnetic radiation standards, data signal current is expected to be much less than one ampere, so a 1 amp current rating for the fuses 130 and 135 would be suitable for minimizing the duration of any flashover current after an internal insulation failure.


Both current limiting and expulsion fuses have considerable length and breadth, as needed to extinguish the high energy arc initiated and maintained by the kilo-ampere short circuit current of power distribution lines. Placement of two such individually packaged fuses 130 and 135 next to each other creates a substantial enclosed area in the plane of the fuse pair, producing a substantial inductance in series with the high frequency signal. It may be noticed that during normal operation, only the small signal voltage is applied between the fuses 130 and 135, and that during an internal flashover, they would both be clearing essentially the same fault. Therefore it may be advantageous to combine the two fuses 130 and 135 into a single housing, and share the arc extinguishing mechanism. By placing the two fuses 130 and 135 in parallel with each other with a spacing and thickness commensurate with the characteristic impedance seen from the coupler secondary winding 115, the effect of spurious inductance and capacitance would be minimized, to the extent that the coupler secondary impedance was constant over frequency and known.


In the case of a current limiting fuse where wires would be wound in a double helix on a “spider” coil form, in preparation for filling the volume with sand, there is a further technique to reduce the spurious effects of fuse reactances. A magnetic core stick may be inserted inside the helix, transforming it into a common mode choke. Such a choke has minimal differential mode attenuation, even when the coupling coefficient between the windings is much less than unity.


One inherent mechanism that limits the transfer of fault energy is the saturation of the coupler cores. Once a fault current causes core saturation, magnetomotive force and induced secondary voltage are basically clamped. Power line fault transients and surges possess a waveform containing energies over a broad spectrum of frequencies. Only frequencies relevant to the modem communications should reach the modem. To that end, series capacitors can be used as high pass filters that limit the transient energy reaching the modem.


Another side-effect of attaching an inductive coupler to a power line is the flow of circulation current. The inductive coupler may be viewed as a current transformer (CT), and in the choke circuits described below, the CT secondary is short circuited by the series combination of the two chokes.


Flashover can be treated as an instantaneous short-circuiting of the secondary circuit to the primary circuit, and since the choke inductors 140 and 145 initially act as an open circuit, the entire primary voltage would appear across each choke 140 and 145, for an initial few tens of nanoseconds. This can be addressed as shown in FIG. 2A by adding high frequency coupling capacitors 200 and surge suppressors 205, which lower the initial instantaneous voltage impressed on both the chokes 140 and 145 and capacitors 200, by acting as a temporary short circuit for the critical first tens of nanoseconds. This allow use of chokes 140 and 145 and capacitors 200 whose voltage rating is 10 to 100 times less than the peak primary voltage.


In an alternative embodiment shown in FIG. 2B, a spark gap or gas tube arrestor 220 is connected across secondary winding 115, to absorb at least part of the energy coupled to the secondary by a fast risetime surge current. The addition of this device in any of the embodiments shown in FIGS. 1 and 2 would reduce the surge energy that subsequent surge protectors need to safely absorb.


In an alternative embodiment shown in FIG. 2C, an additional surge suppressor 210 may be placed in parallel with the surge suppressors 205. The surge suppressors 205 and 210 act as a low impedance when a current fault generates voltages exceeding their clamping voltage. If the devices are identical, suppressor 210 would act as the primary voltage limiter for the differential mode, while the series pair of suppressors 205 would act as a backup limiter in case the primary suppressor 210 failed in the open circuit condition.


The high pass filtering of the shunt chokes and series capacitors limits the duration of fault pulses, and allows the use of relatively low power surge suppressors. Only such low power devices are available with the low terminal capacitance necessary to avoid high frequency loading of the signal by the surge suppressors. The very small power-frequency impedance of a high frequency coupler reduces the electromotive force (emf) generated in the inductor secondary 115, and the existence of sufficient fuse resistance, or optionally the addition of a small value resistor 215 in series with each secondary lead (typically, one half to one ohm), typically can reduce the resultant current flow to less than one ampere per thousand amperes flowing on the power line 100.


We can consider an internal flashover of coupler 110, from primary winding 105 to the secondary winding 115, simplified here to one terminal 120 of that winding (see FIG. 1). FIG. 3 shows the equivalent circuit as seen by the flashover voltage transient. A 10 kV dc source 300 represents the instantaneous peak voltage of a 15 kV class distribution transformer having a typical phase to neutral voltage of 7-8 kV rms. Source resistance 305 limits current to a 10 kA short circuit value. Transmission lines 310 and 315 represent a single phase of overhead distribution lines. The closing of switch 320 represents an instantaneous short circuit due to internal flashover. Resistor 325 represents the resistance of a fuse such as 130 and 135, and choke 330 (equivalent to choke 140 of FIG. 1) closes the circuit to pole ground 335. Capacitor 340 high pass couples the communications signals to modem terminals 345, and surge suppressor 350 (equivalent to suppressor 205 in FIG. 2) protects the modem against over-voltage transients. The shunt capacitive loading of capacitor 340 and suppressor 350 (the latter acting as nearly a short circuit during transient events) lowers the initial transient voltage at node 355, and therefore across capacitor 340, allowing use of a lower cost capacitor.



FIG. 4 illustrates in cross-section one particular physical implementation of an inductive coupler according to an embodiment of the present invention. FIG. 4A shows a section 4A-4A of the inductive coupler of FIG. 4. Coupler 410 includes a magnetic core having an upper portion 405 and a lower portion 406 that form an aperture therebetween. Coupler 410 is situated on a primary power line 400 such that primary power wire 400 passes through the aperture, in the vicinity of upper portion 405. Coupler 410 also includes a secondary wire 415 that passes through the aperture, in the vicinity of lower portion 406. Secondary wire 415 and lower portion 406 are encapsulated in an insulating material 417 so that a layer of insulating material 417 is situated between secondary winding 415 and lower portion 406. The layer of insulating material 417 between secondary winding 415 and lower portion 406 has a thickness 420 appropriate for the line's withstand voltage and BIL voltage. Sheds 425 provide the appropriate leakage path. Conductive plate 430 is attached to the base of the coupler body, and connected via wire 435 to the pole ground 440.


If the coupler body does not provide a sufficient leakage path or insulation commensurate with the steady state or transient voltage on the power line conductor 400, then a flashover could occur. Flashover current external to the coupler 410 would jump to the conductive plate 430, and be routed harmlessly to the pole ground 440.



FIG. 5
a illustrates a dual fuse 500, as implemented in an expulsion fuse. Wires 505 connect the fuse elements 510 to two-terminal headers 515. The fuse elements 510 are tensed by springs 520, and the entire volume is encased in an arc-quenching material, with ports (not shown) through which any arc gasses are expelled.



FIG. 5
b illustrates a dual fuse 550, as implemented in a current-limiting fuse. Fuse elements 555 are wound on spider form 560 and terminate on two-terminal headers 565. Optionally, the spider may have a hollow core in which magnetic core 570 optionally may be inserted. The entire volume is filled with sand (not shown).


Although various exemplary embodiments of the invention have been disclosed, it should be apparent to those skilled in the art that various changes and modifications can be made which will achieve some of the advantages of the invention without departing from the true scope of the invention.

Claims
  • 1. A method for protecting loads associated with power distribution system inductive signal couplers, the method comprising: providing an inductive signal coupler having a first winding in series with a line conductor of a power distribution system, and a second winding having first and second connection terminals;connecting a first terminal of a first fuse to said first connection terminal, and a first terminal of a second fuse to said second connection terminal, a second terminal of each fuse being connected to a communication device;connecting a first terminal of a first choke to said second terminal of said first fuse, and a first terminal of a second choke to said second terminal of said second fuse; andconnecting a second terminal of each choke to an electrical ground,wherein said first choke is a wire wound choke capable of conducting a transient current of 10,000 amps, andwherein, in a case of a power surge on said second winding, said first fuse and said first choke provide a path to said electrical ground for a surge current.
  • 2. A method according to claim 1, wherein each of said first and second chokes uses wire of sufficient gauge to withstand high current flowing during an actuation time of its associated fuse.
  • 3. A method according to claim 1, wherein each of said first and second chokes possesses a self-resonant frequency in excess of a highest frequency utilized by said communication device.
  • 4. A method according to claim 1, further comprising connecting a first terminal of a surge suppressor to said first connection terminal of said second winding and connecting a second terminal of said surge suppressor to said second connection terminal of said second winding.
  • 5. A method according to claim 4, wherein said surge suppressor is selected from the group consisting of a spark gap and a gas tube surge arrestor.
  • 6. A method according to claim 1, wherein said first fuse and said first choke form a first series resistance, and said second fuse and said second choke form a second series resistance, and wherein said first and second series resistances are each great enough so as to minimize power frequency circulation current.
  • 7. A method according to claim 1, further comprising: providing a first resistor in series with said first fuse and said first choke to form a first series resistance, and providing a second resistor in series with said second fuse and said second choke to form a second series resistance, wherein said first and second series resistances are each great enough so as to minimize power circulation current.
  • 8. A method according to claim 1, wherein said first and second fuses are packaged in a single common housing.
  • 9. A method according to claim 8, wherein said first and second fuses are helical current limiting fuses having a helix axis.
  • 10. A method according to claim 9, further comprising: placing a magnetic core is in said helix axis.
  • 11. A method according to claim 1, further comprising: connecting a capacitor in series with said second terminal of each of said first and second fuses and said communication device; and connecting a surge suppressor between a communication device side of each capacitor and the electrical ground, so that capacitive loading reduces the magnitude of an initial voltage transient resulting from a flashover between said windings of said inductive signal coupler.
  • 12. A method for protecting loads associated with power distribution system inductive signal couplers, the method comprising: providing an inductive signal coupler having a first winding in series with a line conductor of a power distribution system, and a second winding having a first terminal and a second terminal; andconnecting said first terminal to an electrical ground via a first choke; andconnecting said second terminal to said electrical ground via a second choke,wherein each of said first and second chokes: (a) presents a high impedance to signal frequencies and a low impedance to a surge current from an electrical fault signal from a power surge on said second winding.(b) is a wire wound choke capable of conducting a transient current of 10,000 amps, and(c) provides a path to said electrical ground for said surge current.
  • 13. A method according to claim 12, wherein leads of said second winding are connected to output terminals that are connected to a communication device via series capacitors.
  • 14. A method according to claim 13, further comprising connecting at least one low capacitance surge suppressor across said output terminals.
  • 15. An arrangement of components, comprising: an inductive signal coupler having a first winding in series with a line conductor of a power distribution system, and a second winding having a first connection terminal and a second connection terminal;a first fuse having a first terminal connected to said first connection terminal, and a second terminal for coupling a signal to a first terminal of a communication device;a second fuse having a first terminal connected to said second connection terminal, and a second terminal for coupling a signal to a second terminal of said communication device;a first choke having a first terminal connected to said second terminal of said first fuse, and a second terminal connected to an electrical ground; anda second choke having a first terminal connected to said second terminal of said second fuse, and a second terminal connected to the electrical ground,wherein said first choke is a wire wound choke capable of conducting a transient current of 10,000 amps, andwherein, in a case of a power surge on said second winding, said first fuse and said first choke provide a path to said electrical ground for a surge current.
  • 16. The arrangement of claim 15, further comprising a surge suppressor having a first terminal connected to said first connection terminal of said second winding, and a second terminal connected to said second connection terminal of said second winding.
  • 17. The arrangement of claim 16, wherein said surge suppressor is selected from the group consisting of a spark gap and a gas tube surge arrestor.
  • 18. The arrangement of claim 15, further comprising: a first resistor in series with said first fuse; anda second resistor in series with said second fuse.
  • 19. The arrangement of claim 15, wherein said first and second fuses are packaged in a single common housing.
  • 20. The arrangement of claim 19, wherein said first and second fuses are helical current limiting fuses.
  • 21. The arrangement of claim 20, wherein said helical current limiting fuses have a magnetic core.
  • 22. The arrangement of claim 15, further comprising: a first capacitor having a first terminal in series with said second terminal of said first fuse, and a second terminal for said coupling said signal to said first terminal of said communication device;a second capacitor having a first terminal in series with said second terminal of said second fuse, and a second terminal for said coupling said signal to said second terminal of said communication device;a surge suppressor between said second terminal of said first capacitor and said second terminal of said second capacitor.
  • 23. An arrangement of components, comprising: an inductive signal coupler having a first winding in series with a line conductor of a power distribution system, and a second winding having a first connection terminal and a second connection terminal;a first choke between said first connection terminal and an electrical ground; anda second choke between said second connection terminal and said electrical ground,wherein each of said first choke and said second choke presents: (a) high impedance to a signal frequency and a low impedance to a surge current from an electrical fault signal from a power surge on said second winding,(b) is a wire wound choke capable of conducting a transient current of 10,000 amps, and(c) provides a path to said electrical ground for said surge current.
  • 24. The arrangement of claim 23, further comprising: a first capacitor in series with said first connection terminal and having a device-side terminal for coupling a signal to a first terminal of a communication device; anda second capacitor in series with said second connection terminal and having a device-side terminal for coupling a signal to a second terminal of said communication device.
  • 25. The arrangement of claim 23, further comprising a surge suppressor for suppressing a fault voltage between said device-side terminal of said first capacitor and said device-side terminal of said second capacitor.
  • 26. The method of claim 1, wherein said first fuse is selected from the group consisting of an expulsion fuse and a current limiting fuse.
  • 27. The arrangement of claim 15, wherein said first fuse is selected from the group consisting of an expulsion fuse and a current limiting fuse.
CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

The present application is a divisional of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 10/388,115, filed Mar. 13, 2003, now U.S. Pat. No. 7,116,007 which claims priority of U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 60/364,321, filed on Mar. 14, 2002, and U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 60/376,377, filed on Apr. 29, 2002.

US Referenced Citations (38)
Number Name Date Kind
1868483 Austin Jul 1932 A
1889552 Keinath et al. Nov 1932 A
3056037 Diebold Sep 1962 A
3156866 Anderson et al. Nov 1964 A
3257501 Sauer Jun 1966 A
3331023 Adkins et al. Jul 1967 A
3459881 Painter et al. Aug 1969 A
3723818 Zocholl Mar 1973 A
3942170 Whyte Mar 1976 A
3961287 Cacciola et al. Jun 1976 A
4016429 Vercellotti et al. Apr 1977 A
4142178 Whyte et al. Feb 1979 A
4199743 Martincic Apr 1980 A
4319224 Tappeiner et al. Mar 1982 A
4347540 Gary et al. Aug 1982 A
4395590 Pierce et al. Jul 1983 A
4408186 Howell Oct 1983 A
4413230 Miller Nov 1983 A
4443662 Nakhla Apr 1984 A
4558271 Poole Dec 1985 A
4775849 Lucas Oct 1988 A
4823096 Hash Apr 1989 A
5053910 Goldstein Oct 1991 A
5081440 Ott et al. Jan 1992 A
5210519 Moore May 1993 A
5252913 Falkowski et al. Oct 1993 A
5698831 Abdelgawad et al. Dec 1997 A
5751536 Haddad et al. May 1998 A
5952914 Wynn Sep 1999 A
6140573 Smith et al. Oct 2000 A
6452482 Cern Sep 2002 B1
6590494 Gohr Jul 2003 B2
6678139 Greuter et al. Jan 2004 B1
6760206 Daharsh et al. Jul 2004 B2
6785110 Bartel et al. Aug 2004 B2
6809633 Cern Oct 2004 B2
6965302 Mollenkopf et al. Nov 2005 B2
20040032320 Zalitzky et al. Feb 2004 A1
Foreign Referenced Citations (6)
Number Date Country
53-136909 Nov 1978 JP
55-15092 Feb 1980 JP
56-007531 Jan 1981 JP
57-181237 Nov 1982 JP
63-290023 Nov 1988 JP
04-242910 Aug 1992 JP
Related Publications (1)
Number Date Country
20060268487 A1 Nov 2006 US
Provisional Applications (2)
Number Date Country
60364321 Mar 2002 US
60376377 Apr 2002 US
Divisions (1)
Number Date Country
Parent 10388115 Mar 2003 US
Child 11500259 US