The present invention relates generally to methods and apparatus for protection of machinery components or vehicle components against corrosion under varies conditions. In particular, the present invention relates to cathodic protection and sealing methods against corrosion for critical areas of railway axle such as axle fillet, axle dust guard, as well as critical areas in railway bearing such as backing ring, seal wear ring, cone and bearing cup.
Railway axles presently used are designed to have infinite fatigue life if axle surfaces are kept defect free. However, under constantly increased rail car loading and higher car running speed, and with surface defects caused by corrosion or impacts railway axles have recently experienced high failure rate in terms of axle cracking, leading to high number of catastrophic train derailments, costing the North American railroads millions of dollars.
Almost half of the axle cracking incidents occurs at fillet or groove area where highly concentrated mechanical stresses combines with accelerated localized corrosion. However, for most of axles in service, those critical areas have not been so far fully protected in terms of:
The present railway practice requires application of black tare like sealant/rust preventative in axle fillet, axle dust guard and axle groove to protect axle against corrosion pitting. The newly designed fitted bearing backing ring that is fitted onto axle dust guards with a interference does improve the effectiveness of sealing of axle fillet, but still provide no protection on axle dust guards. Furthermore, large population of axles currently in use have smaller diameters in their dust guard areas due to lack of precision during initial machining or due to surface damages during subsequent mounting/dismounting or road services and can not achieve designed interference fit. Those axles can only be used with non-fitted bearing backing ring and can not benefit from the fitted bearing backing ring design.
The investigations/analysis on cracked axles as well as on other secondhand axles back from field services found that axle fillet area or axle groove area are often subject to severe localized corrosion and the sealant/rust preventative presently used cracks and degrades quickly during road service and cease to be effective as physical barrier against water/moisture ingress. The degraded/cracked sealant/rust preventative coatings actually induce severe localized corrosion in the axle fillet or the axle groove that eventually develop into major cracks under car loading.
Actually, many coatings, such as epoxy or polyurethane types, are capable of providing good long-term corrosion protection by developing high bonding strength with substrate and forming firm/tough film on the substrate. Some coatings can even provide certain impact resistance if heavily applied. However, due to following reasons, those coatings are not the most desirable choices:
Regarding to railway roller bearings, certain measures have been taken to protect encased internal moving components against corrosion, such as improved seals, special formulated bearing greases containing corrosion inhibitors. Nevertheless, “water etch”, a kind of corrosion damage due to water ingress, occurs frequently on surfaces of encased internal bearing components, causing sometimes serious bearing failures and catastrophic car accidents.
Accordingly, what are needed in the art are improved methods and apparatus to fully protect railway axles and railway bearings against corrosion during long term field service while keeping the protected area easily inspected and maintained at low cost.
One object of the present invention is to provide methods and apparatus that will promote cathodic protection in selected critical areas of railway axle and/or selected critical areas of bearing components, preventing localized corrosion and resulting severe axle corrosion cracking.
Another object of the present invention is to provide methods and apparatus that will protect all critical areas for large population of existing railway axles/axle mounted bearing components from corrosion and impact damages.
Another object of the present invention is to provide those above-mentioned protection methods and apparatus while keeping the protected areas readily accessible for visual or non destructive inspection and allowing conventional bearing mounting/dismounting method be used.
Other objects and advantages of the present invention can become more apparent to those skilled in the art as the nature of the invention is better understood from the accompanying drawings, as well as detailed descriptions.
Referring to
The wheel 120 is mounted and secured on the axle 110 with interference fit.
The roller bearing assembly 130 includes a fitted backing ring 131, a pair of seal wear rings 132, a pair of bearing seals 133, a pair of bearing cones 134, a plurality of roller 135, a spacer ring 136, a bearing cup 137, an axle end cap 138 and a plurality of cap screws 139.
The straight end section of the axle 110 enveloped by the bearing assembly 130 is referred as axle journal 111. The section of the axle 110 where wheel 120 is mounted is referred as axle wheel seat 112. The relatively smaller diameter curved section of the axle 110 underneath the backing ring 131 is referred as axle fillet 113 and the relatively larger diameter curved section of the axle 110 located between axle fillet 113 and axle wheel seat 112 is referred as axle dust guard 114.
Accordingly, the curved surface area of the axle fillet 113 is referred as axle fillet surface 113S while the curved surface area of the axle dust guard 114 as axle dust guard surface 114S and the straight surface of the axle journal 111 as 111S.
Surfaces of roller bearing components are named in a similar manner except all the bore surfaces being designated with “SI” and the exterior surfaces with “SO”.
The inner bore surfaces in
The exterior surfaces in
The axle sacrificial metal reserve 160 is a plurality of sacrificial metal films deposited to following areas that remain substantially contact free during and after wheel set assembly:
The sacrificial metal films contain, at high percentage, single or multiple metal or alloys that are electrochemically anodic to substrate axle steel or substrate bearing steel. The sacrificial metal films may have a single or multiple layer structure and be applied by single or multiple suitable processes including but not limited to painting, thermal spraying, electroplating, and galvanizing. The preferred deposition processes for the present railway wheel set application are inorganic zinc painting, zinc or Zn—Al thermal spraying, zinc or Zn—Ni brush plating. All those preferred processes are capable of depositing sacrificial metal films locally, selectively and at low temperatures.
Since zinc or zinc alloy film is electrochemically anodic to axle and bearing steel, the zinc or zinc alloy film prevents corrosion of the underlying axle or bearing steel surfaces by providing cathodic sacrifical protection. In addition, the coating forms an impermeable barrier with zinc salts against further water or ion penetration and self heals to resume protection once the painting being damaged accidentally.
The most preferred area for zinc or zinc alloy film deposition are bearing component surfaces such as 131SI, 132SI and 136SI because
Under rail car loading, the axle fillet 113 and adjacent areas in the railway axle 110 are subject to locally concentrated mechanical stress due to abrupt diameter changes in the axle fillet 113. To avoid any possible stress concentration, it is a common design practice that mating bearing components, the bearing backing ring 131 and the seal wear ring 132, remain contact free from the axle fillet 113.
Since sacrificial metal films are deposited on those axle fillet surface 113S and on the bore surface 131SI and 132SI of the bearing 130 that remain substantially contact free during and after wheel set assembly, there are no risk of film damages during the bearing mounting process and dismounting process. The sacrificial metal films are also protected by the mounted backing ring 131 during the long-term field services.
During regular inspection or requalification, the previously applied sacrificial metal films can be kept or only partially removed without causing any damages on axle or bearing surfaces and additional films may be further applied afterwards on top of them.
It should be noted that the sacrificial metal films are of any suitable type including but not limited to zinc, zinc alloys, tin, tin alloys, cadmium and aluminum.
It should also be noted that the axle sacrificial metal reserve may be one or a plurality of sacrificial metal strip components mounted to the above-mentioned contact free axle or bearing surfaces. Those mounted metal strips, preferably in zinc or magnesium, act as sacrificial anode, protecting cathodically axle and bearing surfaces in case of water or moisture ingress.
It should also be noted that the sacrificial metal films or sacrificial metal strips may be applied or mounted to above mentioned contact free bearing surfaces only or to above mentioned contact free axle surfaces only. Since bearing 130, axle 110 and residual mounting/sealing compound 180 are all in electrical contact, the sacrificial metal films or mounted sacrificial metal strip components, although only applied or mounted to bearing surfaces or only to axle surfaces, can actually protect both axle and bearing components at the same time. The preferred sacrificial metal film deposition processes in this case are the ones that are capable of depositing dense metal films such as electroplating, brush plating, HVOF thermal spraying, galvanizing.
For example, the zinc electrodeposit or magnesium strip may be applied or mounted only to inner bore surface 131SI of the bearing backing ring 131 and 132SI of the seal wear ring 132. Since
It should also be noted that the axle sacrificial metal reserve 160 may be one type or a plurality types of sacrificial metal dusts contained, at high percentage, within the bearing mounting lubricant/sealant 180 that is applied on the axle or bearing surfaces before bearing mounting. Upon completion of bearing/axle assembly, the sacrificial metal dusts contained within the residual bearing lubricant/sealant 180 are compacted and deposited to the above-mentioned contact free axle or bearing surfaces. Those metal dusts maintain electrical contact with the axle 110 and the bearing 130, protecting cathodically axle and bearing surfaces in case of water/moisture ingress.
The bearing internal sacrificial metal reserve 170 includes a plurality of sacrificial metal films deposited or a plurality of sacrificial metal strips mounted to the internal bearing areas where no high-pressure contacts will be made among internal bearing components such as the outer bore surface 136SO of the spacer ring 136 and the mid section of the inner bore surface 137SI of the bearing cup 137.
Due to the fact that all internal bearing surfaces are in contact with bearing lubrication grease 190 at the same time, and the electrical conductivity of the grease 190 increases significantly in case of water or moisture ingress, the sacrificial metal films or strips, although applied only to surface 136SO and 137SI, will act as sacrificial anodes and will provide cathodic protection to other internal surfaces of bearing components being in contact with the same bearing lubrication grease 190, for example, the surfaces of the bearing cup 137 and surfaces of the bearing cone 134.
The bearing internal sacrificial metal reserve 170 is made of any suitable metal including but not limited to zinc, zinc alloy, tin, tin alloy, magnesium, cadmium and aluminum.
Referring to
The structure and assembly of the axle 210, the wheel 220 and the bearing 230 are identical to the axle 110, the wheel 120 and the bearing 130 shown in
The axle dust guard 214 of the axle 210 has a varying diameter section, thereby defining a minimum diameter at the starting of the axle dust guard 214 and a maximum diameter at the end of the axle dust guard 214.
The protective sleeve 240 has one end 241 pre-mounted and sealed to the external surface of the backing ring 231 of the bearing assembly 230 before bearing mounting. The full sealing is achieved by substantial deformation of initially smaller bore of the pre-mounted end 241 of the protective sleeve 240 than the outside diameter of the backing ring 231. Such sealing may be further enhanced by additional adhesive or tightening device applied to the mounting area. The other end 242 of the sleeve 240 extends out of the backing ring 231 with a length substantially longer than the length of the axle dust guard 214. The end 242 of the sleeve 240 has an inner flange 243 with a diameter larger than minimum diameter of the axle dust guard 214 but substantially smaller than the maximum diameter of the axle dust guard 214.
During final stage of installation of the bearing 230 onto the axle 210, the inner flange 243 of the sleeve 240 starts to engage with the axle dust guard surface 214S and is forced to roll/flip inward before fully resting on the axle dust guard surface 214S. The mid section of the sleeve 240, which is longer than the axle dust guard 214, is forced to climb and roll onto the axle dust guard surface 214S, creating a bulged double seal in the varying diameter section of the axle dust guard surface 214S.
Under rail car loading, the axle fillet 213 and adjacent axle dust guard 214 in the railway axle 210 are subject to locally concentrated mechanical stress due to abrupt diameter changes in the axle fillet 213 and the axle dust guard 214. Upon presence of corrosive ingredients, an accelerated corrosion stress cracking can quickly develop and lead to catastrophic axle failure. The installed sleeve 240 prevents occurrence of corrosion stress cracking by effectively stopping the ingress of any corrosive ingredients. The sleeve 240 not only provides effective seal for the axle dust guard area but also forms an additional sealing for the axle fillet 213 that is primarily protected by bearing backing ring fitted type or non fitted type. The protruded bulgy section of the sleeve 240 also protects the axle dust guard 214 against impact and protects rust preventative/sealing compound 250 that is applied on the axle dust guard surface 214S and now rests underneath the sleeve 240, against impact and UV aging.
The protective sleeve 240 is made of any suitable material including but not limited to polyurethane, neoprene, nitrile or fluoroelastomer, other rubber, other elastomeric or plastic material.
Upon disassembly of the roller bearing 230 from the axle 210, the protective sleeve 240 can be easily removed from the axle 210 together with the bearing backing ring 231. The flexible and thin walled sleeve 240 can be deformed during the bearing dismounting process, allowing direct usage of regular tool for bearing removal.
Referring to
Upon completion of the wheel set assembly, the protective sleeve 340 has one end 341 mounted to the backing ring 331 and the other end 342 mounted to the adjacent hub section 321 of the wheel 320.
The sleeve 340 is either pre-mounted to the backing ring 331 or pre-mounted to the wheel hub 321. The other end of the sleeve will be self-mounted upon installation of the roller bearing 330 to the axle 310. The mounted sleeve 340 may be further secured on the backing ring 331 or on the wheel hub 321, either by a pair of clamp means 343 and 344 as shown in
The mid section of the sleeve 340 is substantially longer than the length of the axle dust guard 314 thereby once bearing 330 is fully installed on axle 310, the sleeve 340 becomes bulgy, being forced into close contact with both backing ring and wheel hub, and remaining tightly sealed during long term field service. The installed sleeve 340 seals not only the axle dust guard area but also forms an additional sealing for the axle fillet 313 that is primarily protected by bearing backing ring, fitted type or non fitted type. The bulged section of the sleeve 340 also protects the axle dust guard 314 against impact, and protects rust preventative/sealant 350 that is applied on the axle dust guard surface 314S and now underneath the sleeve 340, against impact and UV aging.
The protective sleeve 340 is made of any suitable material including but not limited to polyurethane, neoprene, nitrile or fluoroelastomer, other rubber, other elastomeric or plastic material.
Upon disassembly of the wheel set, the flexible and thin walled sleeve 340 can be deformed during the bearing dismounting process, allowing direct usage of regular tool for easy bearing removal. The sleeve 340 can also be safely removed for reuse by flipping/rolling over to the backing ring 331 and dismounted from the axle 310 together with bearing assembly 310.
Thanks to substantially large elastic deformation range of the elastomeric sealing material, the protective sleeve 240 and 340 are able to provide effective sealing in large axle diameter range and in large bearing backing diameter range, allowing direct applications of the arrangements presented in
Referring to
Instead of pre-mounting to the external surface of the bearing backing ring as shown in
The sealing member 440 is pre-mounted into the groove 439. The pre-mounted end of the sealing member 440 has inner diameter substantially smaller and outer diameter substantially larger than the axle dust guard 414. Upon installation of the bearing 430 onto the axle 410, the sealing member 440 is substantially deformed, filling the gaps between the axle dust guard and the end of the bearing backing ring and forming additional sealing for the axle fillet 413. The sealing member 440 made of an elastomer provides protection against impact damages for a portion of the axle dust guard 414.
Thanks to substantially large elastic deformation range of the elastomeric sealing material, the sealing member 440 is able to provide effective sealing in much larger axle diameter ranges than the existing fitted type backing ring made in steel, allowing direct applications of the arrangement presented in
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Application No. 60/510,042 filed on Oct. 9th, 2003, which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
60510042 | Oct 2003 | US |