This application is a national stage entry under 35 U.S.C. § 371 of International Application No. PCT/GB2017/053851, filed Dec. 21, 2017, which claims the benefit of GB Application 1701833.4, filed Feb. 3, 2017 and GB Application 1716236.3, filed Oct. 5, 2017. The entire contents of International Application No. PCT/GB2017/053851, GB Application 1701833.4, and GB Application 1716236.3 are incorporated herein by reference.
The disclosure relates to pump cooling systems and particularly, but not exclusively, to pump cooling systems associated with screw pumps.
It is known to cool pumps, such as vacuum pumps, by fixing cooling plates onto the pump casing. Heat conducted from the casing to the cooling plates is conducted away from the pump by a flow of cooling water passing through passages that extend through the cooling plates. These passages in the cooling plates are prone to calcification. This may be caused by hot operation of the pump when the water flow is turned off, for example by use of a solenoid valve, during which time the stagnant water in the passages will increase in temperature and may actually boil. The water flow may be stopped to control the temperature of the pump or during periods in which pump cooling is not needed.
To minimize calcification, the water supply to the cooling plates may be kept on regardless of the heat output of the pump. However, this may result in overcooling of the pump when the heat output is low when, for example, it is operating at low loads. Overcooling is undesirable as it may, for example, cause condensation of the pumped gases in the pumping mechanism. One way to reduce this problem is to provide a long heat-path to the cooling plates. This may be effective, provided the quantity of heat to be removed remains constant. However, the heat load for most dry vacuum pumps will change depending on the pump inlet pressure.
The disclosure provides a pump cooling system comprising, a cooling body to be fitted to a pump housing to receive heat from said pump housing via a heat conducting path between said cooling body and pump housing, said cooling body having a passage through which, in use, a cooling fluid is passed to conduct heat away from the cooling body; and a cooling control mechanism configured to provide a gap in said heat conducting path at pump operating temperatures below a predefined temperature whereby heat conduction from said pump housing to said cooling body is interruptible
The disclosure also includes a pump comprising, a pump housing and a pumping mechanism disposed in said pump housing; and a pump cooling system comprising a cooling body and a cooling control mechanism, wherein said cooling body is to receive heat from said pump housing via a heat conducting path and is provided with a passage through which, in use, a cooling fluid is passed to conduct heat away from said cooling body, and said cooling control mechanism is configured to provide a gap in said heat conducting path between said pump housing and said cooling body at pump operating temperatures below a predefined temperature, whereby heat conduction from said pump housing to said cooling body is interruptible.
The disclosure also includes a method of providing pump cooling comprising the steps of providing a cooling body to receive heat from the pump by heat conduction, said cooling body having a passage through which cooling fluid is passed to convey heat away from said cooling body; providing a cooling control mechanism configured to provide a gap in a heat conducting path between said pump and said cooling body when pump operating temperatures are below a predefined temperature whereby heat conduction between said pump and cooling body is controllably interruptible.
In the following disclosure, reference will be made to the drawings.
The pump cooling system 12 comprises at least one cooling body 24. In some examples, there will be plurality of cooling bodies 24 disposed about the pump housing 14. By way of example,
As shown in
The cooling body 24 may be made of a material with good heat conducting properties, for example, aluminium or an aluminium alloy. When the cooling body 24 is in contact with the pump housing 14 (as shown in
Referring to
Referring to
The cooling control mechanism may further comprise one or more temperature sensors 74 and a controller 76. The temperature sensor, or sensors, 74 may comprise a thermocouple, or thermocouples, connected with the controller 76 and mounted at a suitable location, or locations, in or on the pump housing 14. The controller 76 is additionally connected with the solenoid valves 70, 72. The controller 76 may be a dedicated controller belonging to the cooling control mechanism or integrated, or incorporated, in a system controller that controls other functions of the screw pump 10 or apparatus connected with the pump.
Still referring to
At start-up of the screw pump 10, the cooling body 24 may be in the position shown in
When signals from the temperature sensor 74 indicate that the pump housing 14 has been cooled to a temperature below the desired operating temperature, the controller 76 causes the solenoid valve 72 to close and the solenoid valve 70 to open so that the pressure chamber 50 is connected with the gas source 60. Pressurised gas from the gas source 60 is then able to flow into the pressure chamber 50. The pressurised gas exerts a pressure force on the major surface 56 of the cooling body 24 that combined with the force exerted by the resilient biasing members 58 is sufficient to move the cooling body away from the pump housing 14 to open the gap 46 in the heat conducting path 44 and put the pump cooling system 12 in non-cooling mode. Heat from the screw pump 10 is then no longer conducted into the cooling body 24 so that cooling of the pump by the pump cooling system 12 at least substantially ceases. Because the pump cooling system 12 is operating in a non-cooling mode and its operation no longer affects the operating temperature of the screw pump 10, the flow of cooling fluid through the cooling body 24 can be maintained, which may at least substantially avoid the problem of calcification of the cooling body. When signals from the temperature sensor, or sensors, 74 indicate that cooling is again needed, the controller 76 causes the solenoid valve 70 to close and the solenoid valve 72 to open to cause a repeat of the process described above by which the pressure chamber 50 is evacuated and the cooling body 24 is moved into engagement with the pump housing 14 to close the gap 46 in the heat conducting path 44 and return the pump cooling system 12 to cooling mode.
In the examples illustrated by
Thus, the cooling control mechanism may comprise a pressure chamber 50 that, in use, can be selectively pressurised to control opening and closing of a gap in the heat conducting path 44. The cooling control mechanism may comprise powered valving 70, 72 actuable to selectively connect the pressure chamber 50 with at least one of a gas source 60 and a vacuum source 64 or vent 66 to selectively pressurise the pressure chamber. Although not essential, conveniently, the valving may comprise one or more electrically actuated valves, for example solenoid valves. In some examples, pneumatically or hydraulically actuated valving may be used. The cooling control mechanism, may further comprise a controller 76 and one or more temperature sensors 74 mounted in or on the pump housing 14. The controller 76 may be configured to provide signals that cause actuation of the valving 70, 72 to cause a variation in the gas pressure in the pressure chamber 50 to control the opening and closing of the gap in the heat conducting path 44 in response to signals provided by the one or more temperature sensors 74.
In examples not shown, the pressure chamber 50 may be defined by a separate body disposed between the pump housing 14 and cooling body 24 and separate to the cooling body. However, conveniently, the pressure chamber 50 may be partially defined by a major face 56, 57 of the cooling body 24 so that the pressurised gas acts directly on the cooling body. The pressure chamber 50 may be partially defined by a resiliently deformable sidewall 48. A resiliently deformable sidewall 48 allows the depth of the pressure chamber 50 to vary as the pressure of the gas in the pressure chamber is selectively varied.
The cooling control mechanism may comprise at least one temperature sensor 174 to provide an indication of the temperature of the pump housing 114, a controller 176 and at least one electro-magnet 178. The controller 176 may be a dedicated microprocessor based controller, or embodied in a system controller that controls the pump or a processing system or apparatus associated with the pump. The controller 176 is configured to monitor signals from the temperature sensor, or sensors, 174 and when it is determined that cooling is not required, provide signals to activate the electromagnets 178 to cause the cooling body 124 to be lifted away from the pump housing 114 and held in a position in which it is spaced apart from the pump housing. Thus, if the signals from the temperature sensor, or sensors, 174 indicate a temperature below a desired operating temperature, the electromagnets 178 may be energised to lift and hold the cooling body 124 away from the pump housing 114. This provides a gap (not shown) in a heat conducting path 144 between the pump housing 114 and cooling body 124 so that heat conduction from the pump housing to the cooling body is at least substantially interrupted and the pump is a least substantially not cooled by the cooling body. This allows the provision of a continuous supply of cooling fluid into the cooling body 124 without overcooling, or unwanted cooling, of the pump. When signals from the temperature sensor, or sensors, 174 indicate a temperature above the desired operating temperature, the pump cooling system 112 can be put in cooling mode by de-energising the electromagnets 178.
The cooling body 124 may be enclosed by a side wall 180 and top cover 182 provided with at least one vent hole 184 in at least similar fashion to the cooling body 24 shown in
In an alternative arrangement, resilient biasing elements may be provided between the pump housing 114 and cooling body 124 to push the cooling body away from the pump housing and one or more electromagnets may be provided between the pump housing and cooling body such that when energised, the magnetic force produced by the electromagnet, or electromagnets, overcomes the biasing force and the cooling body is drawn into engagement with the pump housing. The electromagnet, or electromagnets, may be housed in suitable recesses provided in the pump housing 114, in which case it would be necessary to provide magnetically attractable members on a non-ferrous cooling body. Alternatively, in a potentially simpler arrangement, the electromagnet, or electromagnets, may be provided on the cooling body to work against ferrous components of the pump housing 124. To facilitate engagement between the cooling body and pump housing, the or each electromagnet may be embedded in the cooling body or recessing may be provided in the pump housing to at least partially receive the electromagnets when the cooling body is drawn into the pump housing.
In the examples described above, active electromagnets are energised to provide a magnetic force to move the cooling body in a required direction and hold it away from the pump housing. It is to be understood that in other examples, one or more permanent, or latching, electromagnets may be used instead.
In some examples, respective sets of electromagnets may be provided to move the cooling body into and out of engagement with the pump housing. This may be desirable in examples in which the orientation of the pump or the pump cooling system does not allow, or makes unreliable or difficult, movement of the cooling body in one or the other direction in reliance on gravitational force or resilient biasing mechanisms.
The pneumatic cylinder 278 may be a single acting cylinder operating against one or more resilient biasing members 296 that bias the cooling body 224 into engagement with the pump housing 214. There may be a plurality of biasing members 296 that are mounted independently of the pneumatic cylinder 278 as shown in
In some examples, instead of a single acting pneumatic cylinder as illustrated in
In use, if the signals from the temperature sensor, or sensors, 274 indicate that the temperature of the pump housing 214 is below a desired operating temperature, the controller 276 may cause the solenoid valve 294 to open to supply compressed air to the pneumatic cylinder 278 to cause the ram 280 to retract and draw the cooling body 224 away from the pump housing 214. This provides a gap, or break, (not shown) in a heat conducting path 244 between the pump housing 214 and cooling body 224 so that heat conduction from the pump housing to the cooling body is at least substantially interrupted and the pump is at least substantially not cooled by the cooling fluid flowing through the cooling body. This allows the provision of a continuous supply of cooling fluid into the cooling body 224 without overcooling or unwanted cooling of the pump. When signals from the temperature sensor, or sensors, 274 indicate temperatures above the desired operating temperature, the pneumatic cylinder 278 may be vented to allow the cooling body 224 to be moved back into engagement with the pump housing 214 by the biasing force exerted by the resilient biasing members 296, thus returning the pump cooling system 212 to cooling mode.
In the example shown in
Although the description relating to
The heat conducting body 330 may be a plate-like body that has a first major surface 332 and a second major surface 334 disposed opposite and spaced apart from the first major surface. The heat conducting body 330 is secured to the pump housing 314 with the first major surface 332 facing and engaging the outer side of the pump housing 314. The heat conducting body 330 may be secured to the pump housing 314 by a plurality of bolts 336 that pass through the heat conducting body and engage in respective threaded apertures 338 provided in the pump housing 314. The bolts 336 ensure that the heat conducting body 330 is held at least substantially immovably in engagement with the pump housing 314.
Still referring to
The bolts 342 each have a head 346 that is received in a respective recess 348 defined in the cooling body 324. The bolts 342 are each provided with an integral flange, or washer, 350 that has a transverse surface that engages the outer side of the pump housing 314. A plurality of resilient biasing members 352, 354 are provided between the cooling body 324 and the heat conducting body 330. The resilient biasing members 352, 354 are configured to provide a biasing force that biases the cooling body 324 away from the pump housing 314 and heat conducting body 330. The biasing members 352 may take the form of a compression spring or wave washer fitted around a bolt 342 and disposed in a recess 356 defined in the second major surface 334 of the heat conducting body 330. The configuration of the recess 356 and the resilient biasing member 352 is such that the resilient biasing member is able to engage the first major surface 340 of the cooling body 324 to exert a force on the cooling body that is outwardly directed with respect to the pump housing 314 and the heat conducting body 330. Alternatively, or additionally to the one or more resilient members 352, there may be one or more resilient biasing members 354 located independently of the bolts 342. For example, a resilient biasing member 354 may be disposed in a recess defined in one of the cooling body 324 and heat conducting body 330, or as shown in
The arrangement of the resilient biasing members 352, 354 is such that a substantially uniform biasing force is applied to the cooling body 324 pushing it away from the pump housing 314 so that the major surface 340 of the cooling body 324 is held a distance 368 from the pump housing. Although not essential, the distance 368 may be at least substantially uniform. The distance 368 is determined by the distance between the transverse surface of the flange 350 that engages the pump housing 314 and a transverse surface defined by the underside 370 of the bolt head 346 that engages the base of the recess 348. The thickness 372 of the heat conducting body 330 at ambient temperatures is less than the distance 368 so that there will be a gap 374 between the cooling body 324 and the heat conducting body 330 that at least substantially interrupts a heat conducting path 376 between the pump housing 314 and cooling body 324. Preferably at least one seal 378 is provided adjacent the periphery of the cooling body 324 to prevent the ingress of dirt and the like so as to maintain cleanliness in the gap 374.
The coefficient of thermal expansion of the bolts 342 is less than the coefficient of thermal expansion of the heat conducting body 330 so that, in use, when the operating temperature of the screw pump 310 is above a desired operating temperature, thermal expansion of the heat conducting body closes the gap 374 in the heat conducting path 376 so that heat from the screw pump is conducted to the cooling body 324 via the heat conducting body 330. Also, since the bolts 342 provide a permanent thermal bridge between the pump housing 314 and cooling body 324, it is desirable that their thermal conductivity is relatively low. It is also desirable that the head 346 of the bolt 342 is relatively large, or wide, compared with a conventional, or standard, bolt of the same diameter in order to provide a high contact area with the cooling body 324. This is so that the bolt may be cooled during operation of the screw pump 310 to at least assist in minimising fluctuations in the distance 368. The bolts 342 and heat conducting body 330 may, for example, be made of stainless steel and aluminium respectively. In other examples, the bolt 342 may be made of Invar 36, which is a 36% Ni Fe metal with a low coefficient of thermal expansion. Invar 36 bolts will be known to those skilled in the art. Thus, a cooling control mechanism is provided so that there is a gap 374 in the heat conducting path 376 between the pump housing 314 and cooling body 324 when the operating temperature of the pump is below a predefined temperature.
It may be desirable to operate pumps at relatively high temperatures to prevent condensation of pumped gases in the pumping chamber. For example, it may be desirable to operate at temperatures in the range 180 to 320° C. Obtaining a relatively high operating temperature may at least in part be obtained by having a pump cooling system that only operates in cooling mode when the operating temperature of the pump exceeds a desired operating temperature. However, when operating at ultimate, or close to the lowest achievable pressure, a vacuum pump may generate relatively small amounts of heat so that the operating temperature is below the desired operating temperature, even though the pump cooling system is not operating in cooling mode. The pump may be provided with thermal insulation to retain heat to assist in maintaining a relatively high operating temperature. Thus, as shown in
The pump cooling system 412 may additionally comprise one or more heating units 480. The heating unit, or units, 480 may be energised when the screw pump 410 is operating at ultimate in order to maintain a desired pump operating temperature when the heat generated by pumping relatively low volumes of gas is insufficient to maintain that temperature. The heating unit, or units, 480 may comprise one or more electrical resistance elements fitted between the pump housing 414 and heat conducting body 430. The heating unit, or heating units, 480 may be housed in recesses (not shown) provided in the pump housing 414 or recesses 482 provided in the heat conducting body 430 or a combination of the two. The heating unit, or units 480 may be switchable on the basis of signals received from temperature sensors (not shown) or on a detection of the current supplied to the motor that drives the screw pump 410.
In a modification of the pump cooling system 412 shown in
Referring to
The cooling body 524 may have at least one through-passage 526 through which, in use, a cooling fluid is passed to conduct heat away from the cooling body. The or each through-passage 526 may be at least substantially as described above in connection with
The pump cooling system 524 further comprises a cooling control mechanism operable to provide a gap 546 in a heat conducting path 544 between the pump housing 514 and the cooling body 524. The gap 546 may be defined by a space, or chamber, 550 provided between the pump housing 514 and cooling body 524. The chamber 550 may be defined by recessing 552 comprising one or more recesses provided in the major face of the cooling body 524 that in use faces the pump housing 514. This is not essential, as the chamber 550 may be defined by recessing comprising one or more recesses provided in the pump housing 514 or a combination of respective recessing provided in the pump housing and cooling body 524. In other examples, the space, or chamber, may be defined by a hollow body disposed between the pump housing 514 and cooling body 524. One or more seals 548 may be provided between the pump housing 514 and cooling body 524 so that the chamber 550 is liquid tight. Although not essential, sealing may be provided by an endless seal such as an O-ring 548. The seal or seals 548 may be received in recesses, or grooves, provided in one or both of the pump housing 514 and cooling body 524.
The cooling body 524 may be secured to the pump housing by any convenient known means, for example by studs or bolts 551 extending through suitable apertures that may be provided in flanges 553 attached to the cooling body. Alternatively, or additionally, clamps (not shown) may be used to secure the cooling body 524 to the pump housing 514.
The cooling control mechanism further comprises a liquid reservoir 555 that opens into the chamber 550 and is configured to hold a heat conducting body comprising a body of liquid 557. In the illustrated example, the liquid reservoir 555 is shown provided in the cooling body 524 and disposed to one side of the cooling body 524. However, this is not essential as it may be located in any convenient position and there may be more than one liquid reservoir. in some examples, the liquid reservoir may be provided in the pump housing 514 or in a separate body connected with the pump housing or cooling body. In the description that follows, reference will be made to a single liquid reservoir 555 provided in the cooling body 524 as shown in
The liquid 557 may have good thermal conductivity. The liquid 557 may have magnetic properties, for example, as exhibited by ferrofluids and ionic fluids.
The cooling control mechanism further comprises at least one temperature sensor 574, a controller 576 and an actuator, which in the illustrated example is an electromagnet 578. The or each temperature sensor 574 is arranged on the pump housing 514 to sense, or detect, the temperature of the pump housing and is connected with the controller 576 to provide the controller with signals indicative of the local temperature of the pump housing. The controller 576 may, for example, be a dedicated microprocessor based controller or a part of a controller for the pump or apparatus associated with the pump. The electromagnet 578 is disposed on the cooling body 578 adjacent the liquid reservoir 555 so as to be capable of applying a magnetic force to draw the liquid 557 into the liquid reservoir.
In use, at start up or when signals from the temperature sensor 574 indicate that the pump operating temperature is below a predefined temperature, the controller 576 may cause the electromagnet 578 to be energised so that a magnetic force can be applied to the magnetic liquid 557. The positioning of the electromagnet 578 relative to the liquid reservoir 555 may be such that the magnetic force draws the magnetic liquid 557 into the liquid reservoir so that the chamber 550 is at least substantially emptied of the magnetic liquid, thereby opening a gap 546 in the heat conducting path 544 between the pump housing 514 and the cooling body 524. Accordingly, even if a cooling fluid is continuously passing through the or each through-passage 526, the pump cooling system 512 provides at least substantially no cooling for the pump housing 514. When signals from the temperature sensor 574 indicate that the temperature of the pump housing 514 is above a predefined temperature, the controller 576 may cause the electromagnet 578 to be de-energised so that it no longer applies a magnetic force to the magnetic liquid 557. The thus released magnetic liquid 557 is able to flow under the influence of gravity from the liquid reservoir 555 into the chamber 550 so that the gap 546 in the heat conducting path 544 is closed and heat is conducted from the pump housing 514 to the cooling body 524 via the magnetic fluid 557 to be conducted away by the cooling fluid flowing through the at least one through-passage 526.
It will be understood that in the orientation shown in
In the illustrated example, an electromagnet is used to apply a magnetic force by which the magnetic liquid is moved. In other examples, the magnetic liquid may be moved by a movable permanent magnet. For example, a permanent magnet may be mounted on a suitable mechanism or actuator by which it can be moved into or away from a position in which it is able to apply a magnetic force to the magnetic liquid. Suitable mechanisms or actuators may include a stepper motor or fluid powered actuators. Some examples may comprise a system of permanent magnets in which one or more first permanent magnets is movable relative to one or more second permanent magnets so as to cancel the magnet field of the second permanent magnet or magnets. Such a cooling control mechanism needs a mechanism or actuator to move the one or more first permanent magnets. It will be understood that using an electromagnet to move the magnetic liquid may prove advantageous in that the only moving part in the cooling control mechanism is the body of magnetic liquid.
In the illustrated example, the heat conducting body that is used to fill the chamber 550 to selectively open and close the gap 546 in the heat conducting path 544 is a body of magnetic liquid. In other examples, a non-magnetic liquid may be used in conjunction with a suitable mechanism or actuator capable of pushing the liquid into or pulling it out of the gap between the pump housing and cooling body. For example, a fluid powered piston may be used to push a non-magnetic liquid from a reservoir against gravitational forces to fill the gap in the heat conducting path and retracted to allow the liquid to fall back into the reservoir under the influence of gravity. In still other examples, the heating conducting body may be a solid body that can be at least partially withdrawn from the chamber to open a gap in the heat conducting path.
It will be understood that although not shown in
The provision of a pump cooling system configured to selectively provide a gap in a heat conducting path between the pump housing and a cooling body at temperatures below a predefined operating temperature of the pump allows a flow of cooling fluid through the cooling body to be maintained even when pump cooling is not required. This may prevent calcification of the cooling body without overcooling, or otherwise unnecessary cooling, of the pump. Thus, the pump operating temperature may be maintained at, or closer to, a desired operating temperature, without having to shut off the supply of cooling fluid to the cooling body. An improved ability to operate at relatively high operating temperatures when the pump is pumping low volumes and so generating relatively low amounts of heat may be provided in examples in which the pump is provided with one or both of thermal insulation and a heating unit, or units. This is because the heat that is generated will be retained, or heat input may be provided when needed.
In the description of the illustrated examples, the predefined temperature at which the gap in the heat conducting path opens is described as being a desired operating temperature of the pump. It will be understood that this is not essential and that in some examples, the predefined temperature may be a little higher or lower than the actual desired operating temperature. In examples in which the cooling body is moved relative to the pump housing, the predefined temperature at which the gap is opened may be above the desired operating temperature and the gap may be closed at a lower temperature to reduce the frequency with which the cooling body has to be moved into and out of engagement with the pump housing.
Conveniently, cooling bodies, and when provided any non-liquid heat conducting body, may be flat, or planar, bodies configured to engage flat surfaces provided on the pump housing. However, this is not essential and it is to be understood that the cooling bodies, or non-liquid heat conducting bodies, or at least the pump engaging surface thereof, may be contoured to complement a contour of the pump housing.
It is to be understood that the gap between the cooling body and pump housing or heat conducting body shown in the drawings may be exaggerated for the sake of clarity of the drawings and that in practice the gap may be very small. For example, the gap may be in the range 0.1 to 1.0 mm.
In the examples shown in
It is to be understood that the term ‘through-passage’ used in conjunction with a cooling body does not require that the passage extends from one side or end to the other side or end of the cooling body. It merely requires that the passage, or passages, pass through the cooling body so that a cooling fluid can pass through at least a portion of the cooling body to conduct heat away from the cooling body. Thus, for example, in the arrangements shown in
In examples in which there is more than one cooling body, there may be a cooling control mechanism or mechanisms configured so that the respective gaps that interrupt the heat conducting path are closed at different temperatures as, for example, described above with reference to
The pump cooling systems have been described in use with screw pumps. It is to be understood that the disclosure is not limited to use with screw pumps and may in principle be applied to any pump that requires cooling. The disclosure is particularly applicable to cooling twin shaft dry vacuum pumps. The disclosure may be applied to multi-stage Roots pumps.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
1701833 | Feb 2017 | GB | national |
1716236 | Oct 2017 | GB | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/GB2017/053851 | 12/21/2017 | WO | 00 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2018/142095 | 8/9/2018 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3463224 | Myers | Aug 1969 | A |
5875096 | Gates | Feb 1999 | A |
10865000 | Newlin | Dec 2020 | B2 |
20150086328 | Tsutsui | Mar 2015 | A1 |
20170241649 | Cave | Aug 2017 | A1 |
20190219339 | Cave | Jul 2019 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
204371607 | Jun 2015 | CN |
102007008594 | Jun 2008 | DE |
102011102138 | Nov 2012 | DE |
102011112600 | Mar 2013 | DE |
1231383 | Aug 2002 | EP |
2811744 | Jan 2002 | FR |
H048896 | Jan 1992 | JP |
2009097341 | May 2009 | JP |
20120131461 | Dec 2012 | KR |
M492957 | Jan 2015 | TW |
Entry |
---|
International Search Report and Written Opinion dated Mar. 12, 2018 in counterpart International Application No. PCT/GB2017/053851, 14 pp. |
Combined Search and Examination Report under Sections 17 and 18(3) dated Jul. 12, 2017 in counterpart GB Application No. 1701833.4, 6 pp. |
Translation of the Office Action from counterpart Taiwanese Application No. 107101151, dated Dec. 8, 2020, 3 pp. |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20200240414 A1 | Jul 2020 | US |