Patent Application
20060263352
The invention relates to a method for determining the quantity of pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance contained in a sample.
The determination of the quantity of pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance contained in a sample is generally made through the measurement of the lethal dose LD50 for this substance in mice or rats. This method is in particular used presently for the determination of the quantity of active botulinum toxin. Such LD50 methods are synonym of a large number of animals killed.
The present invention offers a new method which spares the life of a significant number of animals compared to the usual LD50 methods.
Accordingly, there is provided according to the present invention a method for determining the quantity of a pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance in a sample which comprises the following steps:
(i) determining the minimum voltage Vm needed to induce the contraction of muscle tissue, said muscle tissue being connected to an electrical stimulator through a motor nerve;
(ii) adding the sample containing the pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance;
(iii) electrically stimulating, at a voltage at least equal to Vm, the muscle tissue at certain time intervals;
(iv) comparing the effect induced by the sample to the effect induced by a reference substance and thereby determining the quantity of the pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance in the sample.
By pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance should be understood in the present application a substance that prevents and/or inhibits transmission of the chemical messages and signals involved in pre-synaptic neuromuscular activity. Examples of pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substances are substances that inhibit acetylcholine (ACH) synthesis or release; those include notably biological toxins (such as botulinum neurotoxins and bungarotoxins) and chemicals (such as hemicholinium or triethylcholine which inhibit ACH synthesis, aminoglycoside antibiotics which inhibit ACH release or tubocurarine and similar compounds). Preferred pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substances according to this invention will be botulinum neurotoxins and bungarotoxins (α-bungarotoxin being preferred among the bungarotoxins).
By botulinum neurotoxins (or botulinum toxins) is meant in the present application botulinum neurotoxin complexes (whether of type A, B, C, D, E, F or G) as well as high purity botulinum neurotoxins (whether of type A, B, C, D, E, F or G). botulinum toxin type A includes all types of botulinum toxin type A, including A1, A2 and A3.
By botulinum neurotoxin complex (whether of type A, B, C, D, E, F or G) should be understood in the present application a botulinum neurotoxin (whether of type A, B, C, D, E, F or G) associated with at least another non-toxic protein.
By high purity botulinum neurotoxin (whether of type A, B, C, D, E, F or G) is meant, in the present application, botulinum neurotoxin (whether of type A, B, C, D, E, F or G) outside from complexes including at least another protein. In other words, a high purity botulinum neurotoxin (type A, B, C, D, E, F or G) does not contain significant quantities of any other Clostridium spp derived protein than botulinum neurotoxin (type A, B, C, D, E, For G).
By muscle tissue is meant, in the present application, a muscular fibre sample comprising one or more muscle fibres.
Preferably, the muscle tissue is immersed in a buffer, such as a physiological buffer. The buffer may comprise an energy source. The energy source may be an ATP energy source, for example one or more of the following: ATP, a sugar such as glucose and/or creatine (including creatine phosphate), a fatty acid, an amino acid, glycogen and pyruvic acid. The buffer may be oxygenated, particularly for longer assays.
In a preferred embodiment, the buffer is an oxygenated physiological buffer containing glucose.
The buffer in which the muscle tissue is immersed will preferably contain at least 10 mM of glucose (e.g. 11 mM). Preferably also, the buffer will be saturated in oxygen (e.g. by bubbling oxygen or a 95/5 O2/CO2 mixture through the buffer). Furthermore, the buffer will preferably contain from 100 to 200 mM of NaCl, from 1 to 5 mM of KCl from 10 to 15 mM NaHCO3, from 0.5 to 2 mM of MgCl2 and from 1 to 5 mM of CaCl2. The pH of the buffer will preferably be about 7.4.
Preferably, the method will be such that the electrical stimulation of step (iii) is carried out at a voltage at least equal to the supramaximal voltage VSM. By supramaximal voltage is understood the minimum voltage to get the maximum twitch response of the muscle tissue.
According to a first variant of the invention (hereafter variant A), the effect induced used for the comparison of stage (iv) of the method is the time to paralysis of the muscle tissue (also named “lifetime” in this application). According to subvariants, the time to paralysis may be determined based (variant A1) on the muscle contraction distance (paralysis being achieved once the contraction distance is equal to zero) or (variant A2) on the muscle twitch frequency (paralysis being achieved once the twitch frequency is equal to zero).
According to another variant of the invention (hereafter variant B), the effect induced used for the comparison of stage (iv) of the method is the variation in the contraction rate of the muscle tissue.
According to another variant of the invention (hereafter variant C), the effect induced used for the comparison of stage (iv) of the method is the variation in the contraction distance of the muscle tissue.
According to still another variant of the invention (hereafter variant D), the effect induced used for the comparison of stage (iv) of the method is the variation in the force of contraction of the muscle tissue.
According to a further variant of the invention (hereafter variant E), the effect induced used for the comparison of stage (iv) of the method is the variation in the end plate potential or the miniature end plate potential of the muscle tissue.
Combinations of the variants A (including its subvariants), B, C, D and E may be used by the person skilled in the art in order to achieve an improvement in the accuracy of the results obtained. In particular, the person skilled in the art may think of combining subvariant A1 and subvariant A2.
Preferably, the pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance will be a botulinum neurotoxin. In particular, the botulinum neurotoxin may be selected from botulinum neurotoxin type A, botulinum neurotoxin type B and botulinum neurotoxin type F. More preferably, the botulinum neurotoxin will be selected from botulinum neurotoxin type A and botulinum neurotoxin type B. In a particularly preferred manner, the botulinum neurotoxin will be botulinum neurotoxin type A, notably a botulinum neurotoxin type A complex like the active principles of the commercial products Dysport® or Botox®).
In a general manner, the method will be more sensitive at lower concentrations (for example 0 to 100 LD50 units/ml, and preferably 0 to 50 or 0 to 10 LD50 units/ml) while it may not work when high concentrations in pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substances are present in the sample (the muscle tissue remaining paralysed despite electrical stimulation). As a consequence, the sample to be tested will preferably be prepared in at least two or three dilutions (for example, non diluted, diluted 10 times and diluted 100 times) on which the invention method will be carried out; in that way, higher concentrations in pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substances can also be determined. However, the sensitivity of the method described previously can be improved as mentioned below.
According to a preferred execution mode of the invention, the muscle tissue will be constituted by a piece of rib muscle obtained from a mouse or a rat. Preferably, this piece will have a dimension of at least 2 mm by 10 mm. The muscle tissue could for example have a size corresponding to a 2-rib section of the rib muscle.
According to a further preferred execution mode of the invention, each electrical stimulation will always consist in applying a voltage VS which is at least equal to the minimum voltage Vm that is needed to induce the contraction of the muscle tissue, VS being besides inferior or equal to a voltage which is slightly above Vm. The “voltage that is slightly above Vm” may be Vm plus 3 Volts, Vm plus 2 Volts or Vm plus 1.5 Volt. For example, the stimulation voltage applied may be chosen as Vm plus 1 Volt.
Further possible features of the invention include the use of a video camera combined with a video recorder. The films produced can then be analysed and the effect of the pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance precisely evaluated. The quantity of pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance present in the sample can then be derived from the effect observed for the sample compared to that observed for the reference.
Alternatively, for the variant D stated above, the force displacement transducer used to measure the force of contraction of the muscle tissue can be associated with an automatic real-time electronic data capture system.
In order to reduce result variability, the electrical stimulator will send at specified time intervals the chosen voltage VS, which each time will bring about a certain effect. Using the mean effect observed in these conditions will allow to make a more accurate determination of the quantity of pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance present in the sample.
A way of increasing sensitivity for the method consists in carrying out the method over a longer period of time, allowing more data to be captured (for example over a period of at least 5, 10 or 30 minutes and of up to 1, 2, 4, 8, 12, 24, 48, 72 hours or even more). For example, for variant D of the method, the method could be carried out until a reduction in a certain proportion of the force of contraction of the muscle tissue is measured (e.g. a reduction of 10, 20, 25, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 75, 80 or 90%).
In order to carry out this preferred execution mode, the life span of the muscle tissue needs to be extended compared to the more general method explained earlier.
In one particular approach aimed at extending said life span, oxygen and glucose (or other ATP source) are provided in a regular manner to the muscle tissue.
One way to achieve this is to exchange at regular intervals an oxygenated physiological buffer bath containing glucose (or other ATP source) with a new one in order to have the consumed oxygen and glucose (or other ATP source) replaced (wherein said intervals are preferably not less than 1 minute and not more than 24 hours, e.g. every 1, 2, 5, 10, 15 or 60 minutes). Another way consists in using a bath wherein oxygen is constantly bubbled, which allows to keep the oxygen concentration of the bath constant; additionally, glucose (or other ATP source) may be added at regular intervals to replace the glucose (or other ATP source) consumed by the muscle tissue.
Alternatively, a flow-through bath system can be used, which has the advantage of keeping constant glucose (or other ATP source) and optionally oxygen levels. In this system, the oxygenated physiological buffer containing glucose (or other ATP source) is pumped in at one end of the vessel in which the muscle tissue is immersed and pumped out at the other end.
Other means to extend the life span of the muscle tissue include the use of a train pulse stimulation which reduces the sample's fatigue. By train pulse stimulation is meant stimulations lasting a time tS separated from each other by periods lasting a time tP during which no stimulation is exerted. The time tS will preferably be from 50 μs to 500 ms, more preferably from 100 μs to 250 ms and even more preferably from 100 μs to 1 ms (e.g. 200 μs or about 200 μs); the time tP will preferably be from 0.1 to 10 s, and more preferably from 0.5 and 2 s (e.g. 1 s or about 1 s); the ratio tS/tP will preferably be from 1:2 to 1:50 000, more preferably from 1:5 to 1:20 000 and even more preferably from 1:500 to 1:10 000 (e.g. about 1:5 000).
The present invention also provides a method for determining the quantity of neutralising antibodies to a pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance in a sample which comprises the following steps:
(i) determining the minimum voltage Vm needed to induce the contraction of muscle tissue, said muscle tissue being connected to an electrical stimulator through a motor nerve;
(ii) adding a mixture of the sample to be tested containing the neutralising antibodies to the pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance and a determined quantity of said pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance, said mixture having been pre-incubated at a temperature from 0 to 45° C. for a period from about 15 to about 120 minutes;
(iii) electrically stimulating, at a voltage at least equal to Vm, the muscle tissue at certain time intervals;
(iv) comparing the effect induced by the mixture to the effect induced by the determined quantity of said pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance and thereby determining the quantity of neutralising antibodies to the pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance in the sample.
All the variants indicated previously for the method for determining the quantity of a pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance in a sample are applicable mutatis mutandis to the invention method for determining the quantity of neutralising antibodies to a pre-synaptic neuromuscular blocking substance in a sample.
The term “about” refers to an interval around the considered value. As used in this patent application, “about X” means an interval from X minus 10% of X to X plus 10% of X, and preferably an interval from X minus 5% of X to X plus 5% of X.
Unless they are defined differently, all the technical and scientific terms used here have the same meaning as that usually understood by an ordinary specialist in the field to which this invention belongs. Similarly, all publications, patent applications, all patents and all other references mentioned here are incorporated by way of reference.
The following examples are presented to illustrate the above and must in no case be considered as a limit to the scope of the invention.
In the following Examples, 1 Speywood unit or 1 U corresponds to the median intraperitoneal LD50 dose of botulinum toxin in mice.
Materials Used
a) Buffer Solutions Used:
The modified Ringers buffer identified hereafter as “Lillies Ringers buffer” is prepared by diluting the following in water:
Immediately prior to use, glucose (11 mM) is added to the solution prepared previously and a gas mixture of 95% O2 and 5% CO2 is bubbled through the buffer solution to yield the Lillies Ringers buffer.
The Phosphate Buffered Saline solution (PBS) referred to hereafter is prepared by dissolution of a tablet supplied by Sigma which, when added to 200 ml of water, provides the following characteristics to the buffer:
b) Isolation of Tissue:
Wistar rats (approximate weight 275 g) are sacrificed by neck dislocation following CO2 exposure (approximately 3 min to induce loss of consciousness). The rib cage is dissected from each animal, placed in Lillies Ringers buffer and transported to the experiment place (journey time: approximately 15 min). There the rib cage is separated into two sections by careful dissection along the spinal column. The tissues are stored in oxygenated buffer prior to carrying out the experimental procedures.
c) Determination of Minimum Voltage Vm Needed to Induce Muscle Contraction:
Each intercostal preparation (half rib cage) is placed into a Petri dish containing Lillies Ringers buffer. For each preparation, one intercostal nerve is carefully dissected to reveal approximately 1-2 mm of nerve bundle. Following dissection, the preparation can be revived in freshly oxygenated Lillies Ringers buffer for approximately 15-20 minutes before being returned to a Petri dish containing 10 ml of oxygenated Lillies Ringers buffer. The dissected intercostal nerve is then connected via a suction electrode to a stimulator (Grass Instruments Model S48), with a return contact electrode placed in the media. The minimum voltage Vm needed to induce muscle contraction is determined. If stimulation cannot be achieved below 10V, another nerve is dissected and the preparation revived prior to continuation.
Method for Determining the Quantity of Botulinum Toxin Contained in a Sample
The nerve is stimulated with a pulsed voltage (5-9V, 1 Hz), the voltage chosen always being 1 V above the threshold voltage Vm required to achieve stimulation and muscle contraction. Video microscopy of the section is carried out with a Nikon SMz800 stereomicroscope equipped with JVC TKC1481EG video camera connected to a combined TV/video recorder.
Dysport® (active principle: botulinum toxin type A) is added in PBS directly above the intercostal preparation (slightly submerged within 10 ml of buffer). For the 50 Speywood units (U) per ml dose, 500 U of toxin is adds the culture dish (10 ml buffer) to yield a final concentration of 50 U/ml. For the 10 U/ml dose, 100 U is added to the culture dish to yield a final concentration of 10 U/ml. For the 1 U/ml dose, 10 U is added to the culture dish yielding a final concentration of 1 U/ml. For the placebo (which has the same composition as Dysport®, except that botulinum toxin is absent), the full contents of the vial (in 0.2 ml PBS) is added to the culture dish.
Data Analysis
The recorded video clips are converted to MPEG files. To assist with subsequent analysis, each movie is cut into 2-minute sections and these sections are slowed to ½ their initial speed using Adobe® Premiere® 5.1 software. Analysis is then performed by counting the number of twitches in a 10 s period (20 s on half speed clips) and averaging the number of twitches over this 10 s period to yield a value of twitch frequency. Contraction distance can also be measured by playing the movie with a superimposed scale bar (of arbitrary units—nominally a 6-7 point scale), the data being averaged to give the contraction distance over each 10 s period, or alternatively said distance is compared to the initial contraction distance.
The experiments are repeated a certain number of times (0 U/ml: n=5; 1 U/ml: n=5; 10 U/ml: n=4; 50 U/ml: n=4) and the results are averaged.
Results
From
As can also be seen from
The twitch frequency lifetime (i.e. the time needed from the moment the toxin is added until the point when the twitch frequency becomes zero) is also reduced by Dysport® in a dose-dependant manner as is shown in
Using the same procedure as described for Example 1, α-bungarotoxin instead of Dysport® is tested at the concentration of 21 μM (n=3). The mean twitch lifetime of the α-bungarotoxin preparation is 225 s (±sem 93, n=3) and 238 s (±sem 93, n=3), measured from contraction distance and twitch frequency respectively.
Material Preparation
a) Buffer Solutions Used:
The modified Ringers buffer or “Lillies Ringers buffer” used in this Example is the same as for Example 1.
The Gelatine Phosphate Buffer (GPB) used in this Example is prepared by diluting the following in 1 litre of water:
B) Isolation of the Tissue:
Male Wistar rats (approximately 230-300 g) are sacrificed by neck dislocation following CO2 exposure (approximately 3 minutes to induce loss of consciousness). The rib cage is dissected from the animal, placed in Lillies Ringers buffer and transported to the experiment place (journey time: approximately 20 minutes). There the rib cage is separated into two sections by careful dissection along the spinal column and sternum. The two halves of the rib cage are stored in approximately 300 ml of continually oxygenated Lillies Ringers buffer for at least 30 minutes prior to experimental procedures.
c) Determination of Minimum Voltage Vm Needed to Induce Muscle Contractions:
One half of the rib cage is placed in a Petri dish containing approximately 10 ml of Lillies Ringers buffer and an intercostal nerve is carefully dissected to reveal approximately 1-2 mm of nerve bundle. This nerve is then connected via a suction electrode to a stimulator (Grass Instruments Model S48) with a return electrode placed in the media. The minimum voltage Vm needed to induce muscle contraction is determined. If stimulation cannot be achieved below 10 V (1 Hz, 200 μsec duration), another nerve is dissected. The 2-rib section containing the dissected nerve is dissected from the half rib cage, ensuring as much excess muscle tissue as possible remains either side of the 2 ribs for later attachment to the force displacement transducer.
d) Attachment to the Force Displacement Transducer:
With reference to the static bath system shown in
Method for Determining the Quantity of Botulinum Toxin Contained in a Sample
The 2-rib tissue sections are stimulated for approximately 90 minutes at 15 V, 200 μsec duration using train pulse stimulation (1 pulse/second for the first 5 seconds of every 30 second period).
The required concentration of toxin is reconstituted in GPB immediately prior to application. The toxin delivery is via one of two methods:
Twitch force readings recorded from the force displacement transducer are first amplified throughout a Grass Instruments AC/DC strain gage amplifier (Model P122) and signals are then recorded using Grass PolyVIEW™ software.
Data Analysis
From the traces recorded, the time taken for the initial maximal twitch force measurement (after addition of toxin/placebo) to decrease by a certain percentage was measured. The experiments are repeated a certain number of times (direct application method: placebo: n==4; 500 U: n=8; 1000 U: n=5; 1500 U: n=11; immersion method: placebo: n=3; 3 U/ml: n=5; 6 U/ml: n=2, 12 U/mil: n=2). Due to the long life span of the tissue when exposed to placebo and low levels of toxin, values illustrated at the 90% reduction in twitch force are estimated results based on the extrapolation of the data assuming a constant rate of decline.
Results
A) Direct Application Method
Over time, a gradual reduction in twitch force measurements are recorded in all samples, including after the addition of placebo as seen in
B) Immersion Method
Reductions in twitch force measurements were recorded after the addition of placebo with a 50% reduction in maximal twitch force observed after approximately 20 hours as seen in
As one can see, a repeatable dose dependent toxin-induced suppression of muscle contraction is observed using both the direct application and immersion methods of toxin delivery.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0303997.1 | Feb 2003 | GB | national |
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/GB04/00697 | 2/20/2004 | WO | 12/20/2005 |
