The present application claims priority to Singapore Patent Application No. 201308391-0, filed 12 Nov. 2013.
The present invention relates to polymerase chain reaction (PCR) biological assay. In particular, it relates to a quantitative real-time colorimetric PCR system for end-point melt curve analysis.
Genotyping has traditionally involved the use of costly assays, such as real-time PCR and DNA sequencing. Various strategies have been attempted in real-time PCR such as modifying the annealing temperature so that the PCR product is not amplified in the event of a base pair mismatch between the probe and target amplicon. Genotyping can also be performed via end-point hybridization using DNA microarray systems where wild type-specific probes and mutant-specific probes are immobilized on a solid substrate. DNA sequencing opens up the possibility for detecting mutations over a very long sequence and potentially the entire genome. However, the high cost incurred due to the use of fluorophores and fluorescence imaging devices in the aforementioned methods is a major limitation. Alternatively, the use, of fluorophores can be avoided via regular PCR, where primers can be designed such that the 3′ side falls on a mutation site so that no PCR amplification can take place if the site is indeed mutated. However, this would require manually intensive and time-consuming gel electrophoresis to be performed to verify if the PCR product has been amplified.
One conventional method demonstrated a simple and cost-effective colorimetric assay for genotyping. The assay enabled the detection of gene mutations via a melt curve analysis on single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) targets hybridized to gold nanoparticle-conjugated morpholino probes. The hybridization gave the solution a pinkish hue. However, upon melting, the ssDNA-probe solution would turn colorless. The assay was highly sensitive whereby a single base pair mutation resulted in a melting temperature difference of approximately five to twelve degrees Centigrade between the wild type and mutant. The DNA probes used were significantly less expensive than conventional fluorophore-conjugated probes. Since it was colorimetric, there was no need for an expensive and bulky light source, optical filters and high-end imaging devices. In fact, genotyping in accordance with this conventional method was as simple and straightforward as adding the DNA probe and salt to the PCR-amplified product and observing, with the naked eye, the temperature at which the pinkish hue disappears.
However, the visual assessment of color change is highly subjective, and this may result in variations to the melting temperature recorded by different operators. The interpretation may also be biased by external factors such as ambient lighting. A visual assessment also significantly limits the number of samples that can be monitored at any given time, as it may not be possible for an operator to simultaneously monitor color change in a large number of samples, unless multiple operators perform this task together. A further drawback is that the process is labor-intensive, as it requires the operator to continuously monitor color change, thus preventing him/her from performing other laboratory tasks at hand. It is also tedious and causes fatigue, which in turn adversely impacts the visual interpretation. The operator may not be able to precisely identify the melting temperature due to the subtle color change in certain cases.
A more accurate outcome could be achieved by computing the derivative of color change as in a standard fluorescence melt curve analysis, which is not possible in a visual assessment. Fluorescence-based PCR imaging technologies have thus far dominated the molecular diagnostics space, but the advent of colorimetric-based assays for real-time PCR and end-point PCR such as a melt curve analysis has underlined the need for quantitative colorimetric devices.
Thus, what is needed is a low-cost and quantitative real-time colorimetric PCR system which can perform image acquisition, image analysis and thermal cycling in a real-time PCR setting with end-point melt curve analysis. Furthermore, other desirable features and characteristics will become apparent from the subsequent detailed description and the appended claims, taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and this background of the disclosure.
According to the Detailed Description, colorimetric-based DNA diagnostic system is provided. The colorimetric-based DNA diagnostic system includes a detector module, a processor and a memory. The detector module is disposed to record an image of a DNA sample illuminated by a light source. The memory includes computer program code which along with the memory is configured, with the processor, to at least perform (a) sending a signal to adjust the temperature of the DNA sample to be within an approximate temperature range over which the color of the DNA sample changes, (b) sending a signal to the detector module to capture an image of the DNA sample at defined intervals within the approximate temperature range, (c) processing the captured images to extract color information, and (d) processing the extracted color information to objectively determine a melting temperature within the approximate temperature range at which the color of the DNA sample changes.
The accompanying figures, where like reference numerals refer to identical or functionally similar elements throughout the separate views and which together with the detailed description below are incorporated in and form part of the specification, serve to illustrate various embodiments and to explain various principles and advantages in accordance with a present embodiment.
And
Skilled artisans will appreciate that elements in the figures are illustrated for simplicity and clarity and have not necessarily been depicted to scale. For example, the dimensions of some of the elements in the illustrations, block diagrams or flowcharts may be exaggerated in respect to other elements to help to improve understanding of the present embodiments.
The following detailed description is merely exemplary in nature and is not intended to limit the invention or the application and uses of the invention. Furthermore, there is no intention to be bound by any theory presented in the preceding background of the invention or the following detailed description. Herein, low-cost and quantitative real-time colorimetric polymerase chain reaction (PCR) systems are presented in accordance with present embodiments. The PCR systems can perform image acquisition, image analysis and thermal cycling in both a real-time PCR setting and in end-point melt curve analysis. One embodiment is designed for point-of-care (POC) applications, whereas the other embodiment is a bench-top device for laboratory use.
Both PCR systems generally comprise (i) a color camera such as a HD Webcam C525 sold by. Logitech International S.A. of Switzerland, (ii) a Peltier heating module such as those sold by Ferrotec Corporation of California, USA, (iii) software control by a software system such as the Matlab Image Acquisition Toolbox licensed by the Mathworks, Inc. of Massachusetts, USA, (iv) a light-insulating device such as those sold by Whits Technologies of Singapore, and (v) a LED light source, such as a cool white 24 cd LED light source (e.g., C503C-WAS-CBADA151) sold by Element 14 of Singapore.
The software controls both the Peltier heating module and the color camera, such that a single-stranded DNA probe (ssDNA-probe) solution is heated from room temperature to a pre-defined temperature. At fixed temperature intervals, an image of the sample is acquired and its color information is extracted and quantified. The light-insulating device prevents ambient light from illuminating the samples, and the built-in LED is used for sample illumination so that the entire process is repeatable and not subject to fluctuations in ambient lighting.
Both PCR systems involve colorimetric genotyping assay for detection of gene mutations via a melt curve analysis on single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) targets hybridized to DNA probes. The hybrid solution, which initially has a visible color, turns colorless upon melting. However, while colorimetric assays may enable visualization of color change with the naked eye, they still entail a high degree of subjectivity where the interpretation of the instance and extent of color change vary from one individual to another.
The PCR systems in accordance with present embodiments are cost-effective since they have no moving, parts, and the various components such as the web-based camera, the Fresnel lens, the LEDs and the insulating device, are low-cost. The PCR systems are also completely automated, whereby the software provides real-time control of the Peltier heating module/thermal cycler and camera. The software also incorporates image and signal processing routines to generate the melt curve profile and precisely calculate the melting temperature. The combination of Fresnel lens, polarizing filter and LEDs ensures that the entire field of view is captured by the bench-top device, thus removing the need for a scanner. The devices also ensure that the colorimetric assays are quantitative and repeatable. Thus, the PCR systems in accordance with the present embodiments can be potentially adapted for any colorimetric assays, such as enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA) and PCR-ELISA.
Referring to
In accordance with the present embodiments, the PCR device 102 is an integrated design for performing colorimetric genotyping at the point of care. It enables both the PCR and subsequent genotyping steps to be performed on the same platform. The battery-operated LEDs 112 provide a white broadband light source for illuminating the samples such that the resulting absorbance color (i.e., a pinkish hue) can be captured by the camera 118. As shown in the view 100, the LEDs 112 are tilted in a 45° orientation to prevent the light from saturating the camera's 118 field of view. The PCR device 102 requires a low voltage supply of five volts DC and draws a current of less than two amperes, and can potentially draw power from a car battery in a remote outdoor setting.
Several conventional fluorescence-based real-time PCR devices have been developed for POC diagnostics, however in accordance with the present embodiments a colorimetric real-time PCR device 102 is implemented. The POC PCR device 102 is better designed for portability. It can be operated by a five volt DC power supply instead of the typical twelve volt power supply. In addition, the heating module 104 has a smaller footprint for the same patient throughput of three samples in 200-μL PCR tubes, where each sample is illuminated by a dedicated one of the white LED light sources 112. Further, instead of using the typical photomultiplier tube (PMT), the focusing lens 116, excitation and emission filters 114, and a low-cost webcam 118 are employed in the PCR device 102.
While the POC device is designed for portability, the bench-top device is designed for a larger throughput of 96 or 384 samples by interfacing the device to a conventional thermal cycler, where the heat block accommodates up to 96 or 384 samples. Referring to
Traditionally, conventional bench-top real-time PCR devices are fluorescence-based and therefore require expensive imaging components. In most cases, these devices also incorporate expensive optical scanners. In accordance with the present embodiments, a low-cost bench-top PCR system 202 including an imaging module is provided which can be potentially interfaced to various thermal cyclers commonly used in laboratories and hospitals. The PCR system 202 is designed to be cost-effective and, as such, a low-cost webcam 208 is used for imaging. The camera 208 is mounted as close as possible to the microtiter plate without compromising its coverage of the entire plate given that colorimetric signals typically have poorer contrast than fluorescence signals and that webcams 208, unlike scientific cameras, have poorer sensitivity. The camera 208, the built-in LED light source, the light insulating device 204, the battery power supply 210, the Fresnel lens and the microtiter plate function as a module (as seen in the view 200) which can be plugged into the standard thermal cycler 212 and coupled to the standard computer 214 for measuring and quantifying the colorimetric assay.
Referring to
The Fresnel lens 302, which is acrylic, is placed directly on the microtiter plate 304 thereby advantageously ensuring that the rays 308 emanating from each sample in the wells 306 and the LED light rays impacting each sample in the wells 306 are approximately telecentric on the object as shown in the view 300. The white opaque 96-well microtiter plate 304 provides a good contrast for the colorimetric read-out. In addition, each well 306 advantageously has a round bottom to concentrate the hybrid solution into a small area to further increase absorbance intensity. In accordance with the present embodiments, eight LED lights are positioned at the corners and sides of the ceiling within the light-insulating device 204 and the insulating device 204 is fabricated using black anodized aluminum for detection clarity. All LED lights are connected in parallel to the 4.5 volt DC battery 210 and the camera 212 is mounted in the detector module 312 at the center top portion of the module.
Real-time control of the camera 212 and the thermal cycler 212 and Peltier heating modules is implemented in Matlab via the USB interface 218. Referring to
The Peltier heating module includes a temperature controller of the PCR system 202, such as a FTC 100 PID Controller sold by Accuthermo Technology Corporation of California, USA, which is also controlled via a serial port driver of the computer 214 using the serial port cable 218 together with a USB-to-serial port adapter. Referring to
A melt curve is a x-y plot whereby the y-axis represents the relative absorbance unit (a.u.) and the x-axis represents temperature in ° C. A melting temperature (Tm) is defined as the temperature at which the ssDNA-probe hybrid solution changes from a pinkish hue to colorless.
The color information is extracted by first converting the acquired images into the luminance (Y)—blue chrominance (Cb)—red chrominance (Cr) or YCbCr color space using the Matlab Image Processing Toolbox. This is done to decouple color from the luminance information. Subsequently, the red chrominance information is extracted as a proxy to monitor the change in color since red is a dominant component in the pinkish hue of the hybrid solution. Given that the melt curve is represented by the red chrominance Cr vs. temperature T, the melting temperature Tm is defined as the point on the melt curve at which
is a maxima.
Referring to
Thus, it can be seen that systems for low-cost, rapid, automated and colorimetric-based genotyping devices have been provided for both POC and bench-top use. Although the POC device has limited throughput, whereby three DNA samples can be analyzed at one go, it is portable and can be operated by a battery. In contrast, the bench-top device has a high throughput as it leverages on a standard thermal cycler format, but it is meant for laboratory use.
Further, the present embodiments enable the generation of melt curves and localization of melting temperature. The arrangement of the LEDs is crucial in ensuring uniform illumination of the field of view, i.e. the 96-well microtiter plate 304. Instead of placing the LEDs at the corners and sides of the ceiling within the light-insulating device 204, a ring-like configuration of the LEDs around the optical axis of the camera 208 results in more uniform illumination. In addition, increasing the distance of the LEDs from the microtiter plate 304 and/or increasing the number of LEDs fitted would increase the overlap of individual LED light projections onto the microtiter plate 304, and this in turn would promote better light uniformity.
Also, in accordance with the present embodiments, the Fresnel lens 302 provides a cost-effective method for imaging the entire microtiter plate without the need for a scanning system. Internal reflections and glare from the glossy surface of the Fresnel lens 302, which may adversely affect the colorimetric read-out, can be removed or significantly reduced by incorporating a polarizing filter at the inlet to the camera 208. The transmission loss due to the polarizing filter can be offset by increasing the number of LEDs. Alternatively, the LEDs can be positioned in a manner such that the reflections do not occlude the wells.
While Fresnel lens 302 with a focal length of ten inches may only enable partial visualization of the well bases at the corners of the microtiter plate, using a Fresnel lens of a shorter focal length or increasing the distance from the microtiter plate 304 to the camera 208 advantageously brings the bases of peripheral wells 1202, 1204, 1206, 1208 within the field of view of the camera 208. While exemplary embodiments have been presented in the foregoing detailed description of the invention, it should be appreciated that a vast number of variations exist.
It should further be appreciated that the exemplary embodiments are only examples, and are not intended to limit the scope, applicability, operation, or configuration of the invention in any way. Rather, the foregoing detailed description will provide those skilled in the art with a convenient road map for implementing an exemplary embodiment of the invention, it being understood that various changes may be made in the function and arrangement of elements and method of operation described in an exemplary embodiment without departing from the scope of the invention as set forth in the appended claims.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
201308391-0 | Nov 2013 | SG | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/SG2014/000524 | 11/7/2014 | WO | 00 |