Patent Application
20220260657
The following relates generally to superconducting persistent magnets, and in particular, to a system and method for preventing damage to high temperature superconducting current leads in a superconducting persistent magnet for magnetic resonance imaging, and related arts.
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scanners commonly use a superconducting magnet to generate the static (Bo) magnetic field. The superconducting windings are typically constructed as superconducting fibers embedded in a copper matrix, and are immersed in liquid helium to maintain the windings at below the critical temperature for superconductivity at the operating electric current. The liquid helium is contained in a vacuum jacketed cryostat with a cold head operated by a compressor maintaining the helium at cryogenic temperature (e.g. 4K or lower).
A disadvantage of this design is that some helium boil-off usually occurs, and the helium supply may occasionally need to be replenished. Moreover, if the magnet is brought up to room temperature to perform maintenance, the entire helium supply is usually lost and must be replenished.
Some more recent superconducting magnet designs employ a sealed cooling system that is charged with gas helium at elevated pressure (e.g. 1000 psi in some systems) and disposed in a vacuum cryostat. A cold head operates to cool the sealed cooling system to cryogenic temperature (e.g. 4K or lower), and the helium charge is at least partially liquefied at this low operating temperature. The magnet windings are in vacuum inside the cryostat and are outside of, but in thermal contact with, the sealed cooling system. Such “sealed” superconducting magnets are not prone to helium loss and use a much smaller helium charge compared with conventional superconducting magnet designs in which the magnet windings are immersed in liquid helium.
One potential disadvantage of sealed superconducting magnets is that they are more prone to quench due to a temporary loss of cold head function (for example, due to an electric power outage). However, modern superconducting magnet windings are capable of undergoing quench without damage due to the copper matrix providing high electrical conductivity when the superconducting fibers enter the normal state, together with winding designs that promote relatively uniform spread of the quench and heat dissipation from the point where quench initiates.
In either the immersion or sealed superconducting magnet design, galvanic contact is made with the terminals of the superconducting windings in order to energize or deenergize the magnet. Ports in the cryostat are typically provided for this purpose, through which metal leads may be inserted to contact magnet terminals. This may produce a non-superconducting region (i.e., a region of normal conductivity) proximate to the point of galvanic contact due to heat transfer from the leads to the superconductor around the terminals of the superconducting windings. The electric current in this region of normal conductivity is carried by the copper matrix. Urbahn et al., WO 2017/178560 A1 published Oct. 19, 2017 discloses an alternative design which employs high temperature superconducting (HTS) leads, for example made of an HTS material such as bismuth strontium calcium copper oxide (BSCCO), yttrium barium copper oxide (YBCO), or magnesium diboride (MgB2). The HTS leads have a critical temperature for superconductivity of 25K to as high as 90K or higher depending upon the HTS material and the electric current magnitude. The HTS leads advantageously provide a smoother transition from room temperature outside the cryostat to the 4K or lower temperature of the superconducting magnet windings.
The following discloses certain improvements to overcome these problems and others.
In one aspect, an apparatus includes a cryostat containing a volume of cryogenic fluid. One or more electrically superconducting coils is disposed within the cryostat. The one or more electrically superconducting coils is configured to produce a magnetic field when an electrical current is passed therethrough. One or more high temperature superconducting (HTS) current leads is permanently disposed within the cryostat and coupled to the one or more electrically superconducting coils. One or more sensors is positioned at or near the one or more HTS current leads to monitor the status of the HTS current leads. An HTS protection switch is selectively coupled to the one or more HTS current leads. A magnet controller controls the HTS protection switch to divert current from the one or more HTS current leads upon detection via the sensors of a quench of the one or more HTS current leads.
In another aspect, an apparatus for a medical imaging device includes at least one superconducting current lead. At least one voltage sensor is configured to measure a voltage in the at least one superconducting lead. A protection switch is operative to divert electrical current from the at least one superconducting current lead. Electronics are configured to control the protection switch to break the electrical power circuit in response to a break condition including the voltage sensor detecting a voltage in the at least one superconducting lead exceeding a break threshold.
In another aspect, a method of protecting high temperature superconductor (HTS) leads in a medical imaging device from quenching includes: measuring a voltage across at least one HTS lead; determining whether the measured voltage is outside of a corresponding predefined threshold; and severing a connection between the at least one HTS lead and electronics of the medical imaging device when the measured voltage is outside of the predefined threshold.
Some illustrative embodiments disclosed herein solve the problem of requiring specialized personnel travel to the site of the superconducting magnet by having a power supply and current leads permanently installed. Control equipment monitors the cryogenic conditions inside the magnet, and uses a decision tree to decide to automatically de-energize the magnet, or automatically energize it back up to nominal field. In addition, a user interface is provided to allow an authorized user (e.g., an operator) to automatically de-energize the magnet, or automatically energize it back up to nominal field when needed or otherwise desired.
For example, energizing conventional magnets requires the presence of service personnel and specialized equipment. If a magnetized foreign object (e.g. patient bed or floor buffer) is stuck to the magnet, the time and cost to remove the object from the magnet can be a considerable burden for the user (e.g. hospital, clinic, etc.). For newer type “sealed” magnets, which have only a fraction of the original helium inventory, automatically energizing the magnet becomes even more desirable. Contrary to the helium bath type magnets, the small helium inventory can only support a cooling failure for a few hours. After that, residual heat that has travelled into the cryostat has increased the coil temperature to the point that superconductivity is no longer sustained and the magnet “quenches” (thermal runaway causing rapid decay of field and increase of coil temperature). It is unlikely that service personnel can reach the site in time, and prepare the magnet for de-energizing. With automatic ramping or user-initiated ramping (e.g. energizing, de-energizing), this state can be prevented by releasing the magnet's energy to an external dump. A cooling failure may occur due to a power outage at the site of the MRI scanner. After the power is restored, the automatic power supply can energize the magnet again without need for human intervention. Likewise, a user may initiate de-energization of the magnet when a foreign object is stuck to the magnet or any other desired purpose. When the foreign object is cleared from the magnet or the user determines it is desirable to re-energize the magnet, the user may initiate energization of the magnet. This maximizes the up-time, and as a result increases the value of the system to the customer.
One advantage resides in protecting HTS leads of a superconducting magnet in the event of a quench of the HTS leads.
Another advantage resides in preventing quenching of HTS leads of a superconducting magnet.
Another advantage resides in reducing maintenance time and costs by preventing damage to HTS leads
Another advantage resides in diverting current from HTS leads to prevent quenching of the leads or, if an HTS quench occurs, to prevent damage to the HTS leads.
Another advantage resides in providing a MRI device employing a superconducting magnet with one or more of the foregoing advantages.
A given embodiment may provide none, one, two, more, or all of the foregoing advantages, and/or may provide other advantages as will become apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art upon reading and understanding the present disclosure.
The disclosure may take form in various components and arrangements of components, and in various steps and arrangements of steps. The drawings are only for purposes of illustrating the preferred embodiments and are not to be construed as limiting the disclosure.
HTS leads offer advantages over other schemes as an electrical connection between portions of a magnet that operate at cryogenic, but different, temperatures. The low-to-zero electrical resistance of an assembly incorporating HTS significantly reduces ohmic heating when used to carry currents between magnet portions, while the high thermal resistance reduces the heat transfer between those portions.
On the other hand, Low-temperature-superconductor (LTS) leads, such as those used in superconducting magnet windings, employ superconducting metallic filaments inside a copper matrix. When a critical temperature of these filaments is exceeded (e.g., the filaments “quench”), the surrounding copper matrix begins to conduct electricity, shunting current around the now-resistive (normal) filament portions. This prevents permanent damage to the delicate filaments as ohmic heating in the filaments is reduced, and any heat generated is quickly conducted away from the normal zone through the copper.
In contrast, HTS components are typically a superconducting ceramic material bonded to comparatively minimal metallic volumes. Therefore, the current shunted around the normal zone and the heat carried away from the normal zone during a quench are often insufficient to prevent permanent damage to the delicate ceramic. Depending on what electrical currents the HTS is carrying during this quench, permanent damage to the HTS can occur within hundreds of milliseconds.
The situation is to be distinguished from the case of the superconducting magnet winding which has a copper matrix providing a low (albeit finite) electrical resistance if the superconducting fibers enter the normal state; by contrast, the HTS material is typically a ceramic which exhibits a high electrical resistance and cannot take the electrical current load if the HTS lead quenches. Hence, the HTS lead may rapidly suffer irreparable damage, e.g. within one second of quench initiation, and in practice likely much faster than this, e.g. 100 msec or a few hundred msec.
Disclosed herein are persistent superconducting magnets that have energizing current leads permanently installed and connected to a power supply. The temperature of the coil's magnet needs to stay below a cryogenic temperature to maintain superconductivity. The permanent electrical connection between the superconducting coils and the outside world minimize the heat leaking from the outside to the superconducting coils. In addition, they should not produce too much Joule heating (ohmic heating) while carrying current, or else the heat drives the coils out of superconductivity.
Disclosed herein are persistent superconducting magnets that employ HTS lead assemblies as part of an electrical connection between the superconducting coils and equipment outside the magnet's vacuum space. Specifically, the HTS is used to carry high (hundreds of amps) current between the LTS coils and higher-temperature (i.e. LTS-prohibiting, but HTS-accommodating) portions of the magnet.
HTS Rare Earth Barium Copper-Oxide (ReBCO) leads are used instead because they cover both areas; they can carry high current without Joule loss up to much higher temperatures, and they can be manufactured with a particularly low thermal conductivity. For further reduction of heat leak into the magnet, mechanical switches (thermal switches) are installed inside the magnet between the HTS current leads and the external current terminals. These switches are only closed if current is required to flow through the HTS leads, otherwise they are open. HTS is well suited to this application. The heat transferred to the LTS from the higher-temperature magnet regions, and from ohmic heating within the HTS, is small enough that the LTS can remain at superconducting temperatures during the various magnet operating modes.
In some embodiments disclosed herein, an automated current shutoff system is provided for abruptly breaking electric current in the case of an incipient HTS lead quench. The system includes voltage sensors at opposite ends of the HTS lead which are electrically connected with rack-mounted electronics including a differential voltage meter with high common mode rejection capability. If the measured differential voltage across the HTS lead exceeds some threshold (e.g. 50 mV in one embodiment; note this voltage is theoretically identically zero for the HTS lead in the superconducting state) then an actuated (e.g. solenoid driven) cutoff switch is opened to break the current. In variant embodiments, the current shutoff logic includes a noise delay, low pass filter, or the like to avoid unnecessary current shutoff due to noise. In some embodiments the electronics are all analog (e.g. using analog op amp circuits) so as to be insensitive to computer glitches. While one HTS lead is described above, both HTS leads are preferably analogously monitored and the current shutoff switch is thrown if either HTS lead exhibits voltage over the triggering threshold thus indicating incipient quench of the HTS lead.
The term “incipient quench” as used herein is intended to denote the HTS lead or portions thereof transitioning from the superconducting state to the normal state or having just transitioned to the normal state, but before the resultant Joule heating has reached a level sufficient to damage the HTS lead.
In some embodiments disclosed herein, an automated system is provided to interrupt current flow through quenching HTS. Superconducting materials exhibit very low (theoretically, zero) resistance. Therefore, notable voltage generated across HTS carrying current indicates that some part of the HTS has quenched. The system monitors the voltage across all assemblies containing HTS and electrically opens the current loop containing any HTS generating voltage above a threshold. This prevents further heating within that HTS and damage. The low differential-mode (tens of millivolts) and high-common mode voltages (hundreds of volts) of these measurements are of note. In some variants, this monitored voltage is passed through a noise filter (e.g. a low-pass filter or time delay) to prevent nuisance trips. In some variants, this protection system is implemented entirely in analog (i.e. with no software) circuitry for the sake of immunity to computing glitches.
In other embodiments disclosed herein, a temperature sensor (e.g. thermistor or temperature sensitive diode) is provided. Temperature can be a lagging indicator compared with differential voltage, and reliance upon detection of a temperature rise of the HTS lead for triggering the electric current cutoff switch could be too slow to prevent damage to the HTS leads. A temperature sensor at the hot end of the HTS lead (that is, near the connection with the galvanic lead) is useful to implement less aggressive remediation, such as lowering the magnitude of the electric current in response to the HTS temperature at the hot end approaching the critical temperature (Tc). Lowering the electric current increases Tc (since it is dependent on electric current magnitude) and may also reduce the (rate of) temperature rise if it is due to Joule heating of the metallic conductor connected with the HTS lead.
In some embodiments disclosed herein, an automated system is provided to prevent the HTS from quenching due to temperature. This system monitors the temperature of all assemblies containing the HTS and adjusts system electrical currents to levels safely within the critical current that corresponds to the measured temperature. Note—temperature increase of an HTS assembly due to ohmic heating within the ceramic is a lagging indicator of a quench, and is unlikely to provide response time adequate to prevent damage to quenching HTS.
A system is disclosed herein to actively prevent damage to the HTS current leads in the event of thermal runaway when they carry current. These current leads are permanently installed inside the magnets cryostat, and can only be replaced by de-installing the magnet from its site and returning the magnet to the factory where it was built or similar facility.
These systems are implemented to prevent damage to HTS portions of the magnet. Repairing or replacing assemblies using HTS within a magnet requires returning the magnet to its factory or similar facility, specialized labor, and considerable time, making it highly undesirable.
Referring to
The cryostat 202 is further configured to house one or more high temperature superconducting current leads (i.e. one or more HTS leads) 206. The high temperature superconducting current leads 206 are permanently disposed within the cryostat and coupled to the one or more electrically superconducting coils 204. The one or more high temperature superconducting current leads 206 are formed from Rare earth-Barium-Copper Oxide (ReBCO). High temperature superconducting (HTS) ReBCO leads are used instead of conventional leads because they can carry high current without Joule loss up to much higher temperatures, and they can be manufactured with a particularly low thermal conductivity, thereby minimizing any heat transfer from the ambient of the atmosphere into the temperature sensitive superconducting coils.
A high temperature superconducting protection switch (i.e. HTS protection switch) 208 selectively couples to the one or more high temperature superconducting current leads and external devices (e.g., energizing device 212, de-energizing device 214). The high temperature superconducting protection switch 208 is preferably disposed outside the cryostat 202. The high temperature superconducting protection switch 208 is in a first state (i.e. open) the one or more electrically superconducting coils 204 are in a persistent state and when the high temperature superconducting protection switch 208 is in a second state (i.e. closed), the high temperature superconducting current leads 206 are configured to energize or de-energize the one or more electrically superconducting coils 204. In one embodiment, thermal switches 210 are configured to electrically couple the one or more high temperature superconducting current leads 206 to devices (e.g., energizing device 212, de-energizing device 214) disposed outside the cryostat. As seen in
The system 200 includes a magnet controller 220, which generally controls and/or monitors the various components of the system, including controlling the state of the high temperature superconducting protection switch 208. For example, the magnet controller 220 is coupled to voltage and temperature sensors 222, which are disposed at or near one or more of the high temperature superconducting current leads 206, the energizing device 212, and the de-energizing device 214). Such voltage and temperature sensors are configured to monitor the status of the high temperature superconducting current leads 206.
The magnet controller 220 monitors signals from the one or more sensors 222 of the system 200. The magnet controller 220 may determine, for example, by analyzing the signals from the one or more sensors 222, whether or not a fault or malfunction is detected. In particular, the magnet controller 220 may determine whether a fault or malfunction indicating that a quench is occurring or may be impending. If the magnet controller 220 detects a fault or malfunction in the system 200, particularly a fault or malfunction which indicates that a quench of the superconducting coils 204 is or may be impending, the magnet controller 220 connects the high temperature superconducting protection switch 208 from the persistent state to a second state to divert current from the high temperature superconducting leads 206 to the energy dump unit (de-energizing unit) 214, which is located outside of or external to the cryostat, across the opposite end of the electrically conductive coil of the superconducting magnet via the pair of high temperature superconducting leads 206.
The magnet controller 220 monitors the one or more fault conditions. In operation, the magnet controller 220 determines, for example, by analyzing the one or more sensor signals 222, whether or not a fault or malfunction condition has been corrected. If the fault has been corrected so that the superconducting coils 204 are no longer at risk for quench, the magnet leads are uncoupled from the energy dump unit 212 and are coupled to the energizing device 212 in order to return the electrically superconducting coils to the persistent state. Once the electrically superconducting coils 204 are at or near persistent state, the high temperature superconducting protection switch, and the one or more high temperature superconducting current leads are switched to the persistent state. Operation of the system 200 proceeds in the persistent state until the magnet controller 220 detects a fault or malfunction in the magnet system, as described above.
By this process, a quench within the cryostat 202 and damage to the high temperature superconducting current leads 206 may be prevented, thereby avoiding damage to the cryogenic materials and/or the electrically superconducting coils 204.
One aspect of the current invention applies to persistent superconducting magnets that have energizing current leads permanently installed and connected to a power supply. The temperature of the coil's magnet needs to stay below a cryogenic temperature to maintain superconductivity. The permanent electrical connection between the superconducting coils and the outside world are required to enable energizing and de-energizing of the magnet automatically without the need for intervention of field service personnel. In addition, they cannot produce too much Joule heating (ohmic heating) while carrying current, or else the heat drives the coils out of superconductivity. For further reduction of heat leak into the magnet, mechanical switches (thermal switches) are installed inside the magnet between the HTS current leads and the external current terminals. These switches are only closed if current is required to flow through the HTS leads, otherwise they are open.
Another problem (i.e. failure mode) addressed herein is that if the high temperature superconducting current leads 206 are driven into normal state (quench) for any reason while they carry current, damage from Joule heating may render them inoperable. Another failure mode is that if any of the thermal switches 210 are opened while it carries current, an arc will cause damage to its contacts, and it will need replacement as well. The problem is that both the high temperature superconducting leads 206 and the thermal contactors are inside the vacuum of the sealed cryostat 202. Therefore, repair work can only be done at a dedicated location such as their factory of origin or similar facility. This causes considerable cost and inconvenience to the user due to down-time of the MRI scanner, as well as the renovation work needed to replace the magnet.
As described above, the embodiment of
In one embodiment, the thermal switch(es) 210 are latching. For example, they only need an electrical pulse to switch between opened and closed state or vice versa. This means that the switches will remain closed if the MRI site experiences a power outage when the magnet is energizing or de-energizing. The control software further ensures that these contactors cannot be opened when they carry current. The latching operation of the switches 210 ensure that the switches 210 do not change their state (whether open or closed) in response to a power outage. Hence, if the switches 210 are closed and carrying electric current at the time of a power outage, the switches 210 will remain closed. By contrast, if non-latching normally-open solenoid-driven switches were to be used, then loss of electrical power during the power outage would result in electric current to the solenoid being lost causing the switch to revert to its normally open state, potentially leading to an electric arc that could cause damage to the HTS leads 206 and/or other components in the electric circuit.
Conversely, if non-latching normally-closed solenoid-driven switches were to be used, then loss of electrical power during the power outage would result in the switches closing potentially creating an undesired short-circuit. The latching switches 210, on the other hand, hold their current state (either open or closed) unless and until an electrical pulse is sent to the latching switches 210 by the magnet control electronics 220, thereby causing the latching switches 210 to switch state (either from open to closed, or from closed to open). The control software suitably ensures the latching switches 210 cannot be opened when they carry current—for example, the magnet control electronics 220 may include an ammeter measuring the electric current in the circuit flowing to/from the latching switches 210 and only sends an electric pulse to switch latch state of the latching switches 210 if the measured current is zero.
In another embodiment of this invention, software for processing the signals and sending commands to open and close the HTS protection circuit is provided. In addition, control of the magnet controller may occur on-site at the MR scanner or remotely from a computer communicatively coupled to one MR scanner through a network (e.g., Internet, Cloud, remote server, service provider, etc.).
Each HTS lead 206, 206′ has a first end labeled E1 which is galvanically connected with a metallic conductor (e.g. copper, aluminum, an alloy thereof, or so forth) and an opposite second end labeled E2 which is galvanically connected with a terminal of the superconducting winding 204. In general, the second ends E2 are at or near the operating temperature of the superconducting winding 204, that is, at around 4K or lower in temperature. By contrast, the first ends E1 are at a substantially higher temperature, for example a few tens of Kelvin to around 70K to 80K depending on the detailed configuration. In a suitable approach, the first cold station CS1 of the cold head 304 is thermally connected with the first ends E1 or with the corresponding galvanically connected metallic conductors in order to assist in maintaining the first ends E1 at the desired temperature. Note,
The at least one voltage sensor 322, 322″ is configured to measure a voltage in the at least one HTS lead 306, 306″. In illustrative
As shown in
The electronics 220 are configured to control the protection switch 208 to break the electrical power circuit in response to a break condition. The break condition can include the at least voltage sensor 322, 322″ detecting a voltage in the at least one HTS lead 206, 206″ exceeding a break threshold. To do so, when the at least one differential voltage sensor 322, 322″ measures the differential voltage across the at least one HTS lead 206, 206″, the electronics 220 detect whether the magnitude of the measured differential voltage is increased above a predetermined voltage threshold (e.g., 50 mV). When this condition occurs, the electronics 220 are configured to open the protection switch 208 to divert the electrical current from the at least one HTS lead 206, 206″. In one example, the electronics 220 detect the magnitude of the differential voltage as increased above the predetermined voltage threshold if the magnitude of the differential voltage after filtering by a low pass filter is above the predetermined voltage threshold. In another example, the electronics 220 detect the magnitude of the differential voltage as increased above the predetermined voltage threshold if the magnitude of the differential voltage is above the predetermined voltage threshold for a predetermined time interval.
Such approaches reduce the likelihood of noise causing the HTS protection switch 208 to be thrown and unnecessarily breaking the electrical power circuit potentially leading to a quench of the superconducting windings 204. If the predetermined time interval is used, it should be chosen to be short enough to ensure that the current will be broken before the HTS leads 206, 206′ can be damaged by Joule heating. In general, the predetermined time interval is expected to be 1 second or lower, and more preferably 100 milliseconds or lower; the choice of the predetermined time interval should take into account any time latency in actuating the opening of the HTS protection switch 208 and other factors such as the HTS type, length, geometry, and so forth. Similar considerations are apropos in selecting the time constant or transient behavior of a low pass filter used to reject noise—its response time should be sufficient to avoid damage to the HTS leads due to Joule heating.
In some examples, at least one temperature sensor 324, 324″ detect a temperature of the at least one HTS lead 306, 306″. If the temperature exceeds a threshold, the electronics 322 can open the protection switch 308 to divert the electrical current from the at least one HTS lead 306, 306″. However, as noted previously, since temperature tends to be a lagging indicator of quench compared with the differential voltage, more preferably the temperature sensors are not used to trigger opening of the HTS protection switch 208 (or at least are not relied upon as the primary trigger for this). Rather, in some preferred embodiments the temperature sensors 324, 324″ are used to trigger less aggressive remedial action when the temperature at one or both first ends E1 begins to approach the HTS superconducting temperature Tc. For example, the remedial action may be to reduce the electric current magnitude flowing through the HTS leads 206, 206′ by control of the operating energizing or deenergizing device 212, 214. This will reduce the Joule heating in the metallic conductors galvanically connected with the first ends E1, and also increases the HTS superconducting critical temperature Tc which usually decreases with increasing electric current amplitude.
With reference to
In a different possible fault condition (shown at 412), an incipient quench of one or both HTS leads 206, 206′ is detected, e.g. based on a voltage measured across the at least one HTS lead 206, 206″ by the at least one voltage sensor 222, 222″. In this case, at 412, the electronics 220 are configured to determine whether the measured voltage (which may be a differential voltage as previously described) is outside of a corresponding predefined threshold. If so, then at 414, the electronics 220 operate to interrupt the electrical current flowing in the at least one HTS lead 206, 206″ by opening the HTS protection switch 208 when the measured voltage is outside of the predefined threshold. This may result in quench of the magnet windings 204, as previously noted; however, it is recognized herein that quench of the windings usually does not result in damage to the windings, and is preferable to uncontrolled Joule heating of the HTS leads which is very likely to lead to expensive damage to the HTS leads.
In another possible fault condition (shown at 422), a call for toggling the latching thermal switches 210 is generated. Such a call may be generated automatically by the electronics 220, or manually by a user. In this case, at 424, the call to toggle the latching thermal switches 210 is executed only if the amplitude of the electric current in the HTS leads 206, 206′ is zero (or, to simplify implementation, is below some threshold). This ensures that the switches 210 are not opened while carrying electric current thereby producing a damaging electric arc. It may be noted that this fault remediation path 422, 424 does not interfere with either the windings quench remediation path 402, 404 or the HTS leads quench remediation path 412, 414 for the following reasons. First, if the latching switches 210 are in the open state then the current is going to be zero, and hence the remediation path 422, 424 can never prevent toggling the latching switches 210 from the open state to the closed state. Next, if the latching switches 210 are in the closed state and a windings quench is detected at 402, then the operation 404 will not call for toggling the latching switches 210 because they are already closed. Finally, if the latching switches 210 are in the closed state and an HTS lead quench is detected at 412, then the remedial operation is to open the HTS protection switch 208 which does not generate a call to toggle the latching switches 210.
The disclosure has been described with reference to the preferred embodiments. Modifications and alterations may occur to others upon reading and understanding the preceding detailed description. It is intended that the exemplary embodiment be construed as including all such modifications and alterations insofar as they come within the scope of the appended claims or the equivalents thereof.
| Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| PCT/EP2020/066005 | 10/6/2020 | WO |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 62864037 | Jun 2019 | US |
