This application is based upon and claims the benefit of priority of the prior Japanese Patent Application No. 2011-024110, filed on Feb. 7, 2011, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
The invention relates to a detection and radar apparatus and a target detection method that utilize aperture synthesis.
In detection and ranging apparatuses, for instance in-vehicle radars (hereafter, a radar device is taken as a specific example of the detection and ranging apparatus), it is possible to reduce the size of the device, without sacrificing performance, by resorting to a technology wherein the aperture of a sensor array is enlarged through a combination of a transmission sensor array made up of a plurality of transmission sensor elements and a reception sensor array made up of a plurality of reception sensor elements. Such a technology is referred to, for instance, as holographic aperture synthesis, holograph or aperture synthesis. A radar device that utilizes aperture synthesis radiates probe signals from the plurality of transmission sensor elements (by time-division multiplexing, frequency division multiplexing, code division multiplexing or a combination thereof). The radar device receives then, at the plurality of reception sensor elements, echo signals generated through reflection of the probe signal in a target to be detected. The radar device synthesizes the signals received by the respective reception sensor elements to increase likewise the number of effective reception sensor elements, to increase the number of detectable targets, and to enhance angular resolution. Hereafter, a radar device that utilizes aperture synthesis will be referred to as synthetic aperture radar. Also, the sensor elements are used as antennas (elements), and the sensor array as an array antenna, without distinction.
[Patent document 1] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2000-155171
[Patent document 2] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2006-98181
[Patent document 3] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2007-155381
[Patent document 4] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. H11-231040
However, conventional synthetic aperture radars have a problem in that the target to be detected cannot be precisely detected under some specific conditions. Such conditions include, for instance, instances where a plurality of objects is present at virtually identical relative distances in the line of sight from the radar (hereinafter, referred to simply as “distances”), and instances where the objects move at substantially the same relative velocity (hereinafter, referred to simply as “velocity”) in the line of sight. A detailed examination of such cases reveals that there is a possibility that a target may fail to be detected accurately, also in daily recurrent scenes such as a traffic jam (i.e. where a plurality of objects moves with small velocity differences at close positions). Synthetic aperture radars, as in-vehicle radars, suffer from such problems.
The various aspects disclosed herein adopt the below-described respective configurations with a view to solving the above-described problems.
A first aspect is a radar device that detects a target comprises:
two or more transmitting antennas and two or more receiving antennas, including a combination of two or more transmitting antennas and receiving antennas that form two or more reference paths at which spatial phases become identical;
an envelope detection unit that acquires an envelope of a reception signal received by the receiving antenna in each of the reference paths;
a decision unit that decides a phase correction amount between the reference paths from a delay amount, that yields a minimum value of an integrated distance between envelopes of the reception signals of the reference paths, as acquired by the envelope detection unit; and
a correction unit that aligns phases of all reception signals received by the two or more receiving antennas, using the phase correction amount decided by the decision unit.
Other aspects may be a target detection method that realizes any of the features above, a program that executes such a method, and a computer-readable storage medium in which such a program is stored.
The object and advantages of the invention will be realized and attained by means of the elements and combinations particularly pointed out in the claims.
It is to be understood that both the foregoing general description and the following detailed description are exemplary and explanatory and are not restrictive of the invention, as claimed.
A detection and ranging apparatus according to an embodiment of the invention is explained below. The features in the embodiments below are illustrative in nature, and the invention is not limited to the features of the embodiments.
A comparative example will be explained first, prior to an explanation of the embodiments of the invention. The resolution of detection and ranging apparatuses having a target angle detection function by a sensor array is determined fundamentally by the physical aperture of the sensor. As a result, holographic aperture synthesis schemes (hereafter referred to simply as holographs, or aperture synthesis) wherein an effective aperture is expanded through a combination of a plurality of transmission sensors and a plurality of reception sensors, are used in, for instance, detection and ranging apparatus that are used in in-vehicle radars that are subjected to severe dimensional limitations.
In the explanation of the comparative example below a radar device wherein FMCW (Frequency Modulated Continuous Wave) is used as the modulation scheme is envisaged as a specific example of the detection and ranging apparatus (Accordingly, an antenna serves as a sensor).
The radar device 1 comprises an oscillator (OSC) module (oscillator module) 22. The OSC module 22 comprises a high-frequency voltage controlled oscillator (RF-VCO (Radio Frequency-Voltage Controlled Oscillator)) and a baseband oscillator (BB-OSC (Base Band Oscillator)). On the basis of a modulation input signal inputted by the BB-OSC, the RF-VCO outputs, as a system reference signal, a signal that is subjected to FM modulation (frequency modulation).
The system reference signal from the OSC module 22 is outputted, from the antennas AT1 and AT2, as a probe signal for target detection. The system reference signal is also used to demodulate an echo signal from the target received by the antennas AR1 to ARN.
Probe signals vTX1(t), vTX2(t) constitute the signals of period Tf, taking the probe signals at each time interval, i.e. the probe signals radiated by transmitting antennas AT1 and AT2, as vTX1(t) and vTX2(t). Therefore, vTX1(t) and vTX2(t) are represented by Expressions (1.1a) and (1.1b). Also, Δφ in vTX2(t) denotes phase shift on account of transmission time lag.
[Expression 1]
vTX1(t)=exp{j[ωct+h(t)]} (1.1a)
vTX2(t)=vTX1(t+Tf)=exp{j[ωct+h(t)+Δφ]} (1.1b)
In the equation, ωc represents an RF-OSC carrier angular frequency (the explanation below does not distinguish between angular frequency and frequency); and h(t) is defined by Expression (1.2) below with respect to a modulation input signal f(x).
For simplicity, the time origin of the modulation input signal f(x) is shifted by a half period, and is represented thereupon by Expression (1.3) below. In Expression (1.3), Δω denotes one-sided modulation bandwidth.
Herein, it is assumed that M targets to be detected move continuously at a position of relative distance rm(m) in the line-of-sight direction, at an angle θm (degrees) at a relative velocity vm (km/h) in the line of sight, with respect to the radar device 1 (the angle is assumed to be time-invariant). Herein, echo signals (reception signal) vTX1RX,n(t) and vTX2RX,n(t) received by the respective (n-th) RX antennas can be represented by Expressions (1.4a) and (1.4b) below, using the definitions of Expressions (1.5), (1.6a) and (1.6b) (n=1 to N, and m=1 to M). Needless to say, in the expressions, targets' velocities are treated in (m/s) unit.
The reception signals vTX1RX,n(t) represent the respective signals resulting from reception, by the receiving antennas AR1 to ARN, of the echo signals from the probe signals radiated by the transmitting antenna AT1 at a measurement time [0, Tf]. The reception signals vTX2RX,n(t) represent the respective signals resulting from reception, by the receiving antennas AR1 to ARN, of the echo signals from probe signals radiated by transmitting antenna AT2 at a measurement time [Tf, 2Tf]. Also, nTX1/2n(t) is additive Gaussian noise. To avoid redundancy, the language “line-of-sight direction” will be omitted in the disclosure hereafter.
The echo signals (reception signals) are amplified by low-noise amplifiers (hereafter, LNAs) 12 (12#1 to #N), and are mixed, by mixers 14 (14#1 to #N), with a system reference signal from the OSC module 22, to be converted to baseband signals. By the context, baseband signals, demodulated signals or echo signals are used in the almost same sense.
The baseband signals are subjected to appropriate interface (IF) processing, such as amplification and filtering, and, thereafter, are converted into digital signals by analog/digital converters (A/D) 15 (15#1 to #N), for instance at a sampling frequency ωs=ωf*K (ωf=2π/Tf, K being the number of samplings). Then, the digital baseband signals are subjected to various kinds of signal processing in a signal processing unit 21, to estimate the distance, velocities and angles of the targets to be detected, as desired target data.
Using the same symbols, vTX1RX,n(t) and vTX2RX,n(t), for the various demodulated signals obtained from the reception signals at the respective receiving antennas, they are represented by Expressions (1.7a) and (1.7b) below, where the phase errors, represented by ΔψTX1(t) and ΔψTX2(t) and incurred in demodulation and so forth, are treated as quantities derived from the respective probe signals. In the notation of the various signals, it will be assumed hereafter that, for instance, a time variable t for movement over a time interval [0,Tf] denotes movement at times [0,δt,2δt, . . . , (K-1)δt], as discretized by δt=Tf/K.
Expression (1.8) below is obtained upon rearrangement following extraction of phase terms derived from FM down-chirp, in a state where spatial phase and error are removed from Expressions (1.7a) and (1.7b), on the basis of various specifications of radar devices that are actually available in the market. Device specifications for reference include a detectable distance range (minimum and maximum detection distance) from 1 to 200 (m), a detectable velocity range from 1 to 200 (km/h), Δω of about 50 MHz, and period Tf of a reference signal (modulation input signal to RF-VCO) of about 1 (msec).
Expressions (1.9a) and (1.9b) below are obtained, with reference to Expression (1.8), by replacing −4Δωτm0/Tf, which is the frequency component derived from distance delay (opposite sign in case of up-chirp), by ωBm, and including a constant term ωcτm0+Δωτm0 in ΔψTX1(t), ΔψTX2(t).
In other words, the condition under which aperture synthesis is established for respective demodulated signals vTX1RX,n(t), vTX2RX,n(t) as acquired in the two measurement time bands [0,Tf] and [Tf, 2Tf] is that the phase lengths of the demodulated signals vTX1RX,N(t), vTX2RX,1(t), in combinations (reference paths) of transmitting and receiving antennas that yield a phase reference during synthesis, coincide for both measurement times.
Depending on the device configuration and modulation scheme, and depending on the selection of timing chart, there exists, in some instances, a plurality of combinations of transmitting and receiving antennas for which phase lengths are identical. In the radar device 1, however, combinations of transmitting and receiving antennas for which antenna aperture is maximal after synthesis, and for which phase lengths are identical, are the pair of the transmitting antenna AT1 and the receiving antenna ARN, and the pair of the transmitting antennas AT2 and AR1. Therefore, these combinations will be explained as specific examples of reference paths. In the explanation that follows, the transmitting and receiving antennas may be identified with shorter notations, for instance, “TX1” for “AT1”, and “RX1” for “AR1”.
Handling the phase errors ΔψTX1(t), ΔψTX2(t) in Expressions (1.9a) and (1.9b) is a problem when carrying out aperture synthesis. The aperture synthesis method in the radar device 1 involves performing a first fast Fourier transform (FFT) on the echo signals (demodulated signals) obtained at respective measurement times, and converting the echo signals into frequency domain data.
In a specific example of vTX1RX,N(t), an element having a k-th (k=−K/2+1 to K/2) frequency index is given by Expression (1.10) below. The FFT result for the m-th target is represented by Expression (1.11a), excluding the spatial phase. The left side of Expression (1.11a) is obtained from, for instance, Expression (1.11c), if defined as in Expression (1.11b) below. Herein, g0TX1=1 may apply without loss of generality.
In the light of the considerations above, the frequency domain signals converted from time domain signals as expressed in Expressions (1.9a) and (1.9b) can be represented by Expressions (1.12a) and (1.12b) below.
Next, the signal processing unit 21 acquires a phase error dψ(k) for a respective frequency index k, using a respective demodulated signal corresponding to the reference combination, on the basis of Expression (1.13) below (it should be noted that spatial phases are identical to each other for the reference combination).
Lastly, the signal processing unit 21 multiplies the correction amount exp [−jdψ(k)] based on the phase error dψ(k) by all the n and k of VTX2RX,n(k), to conform thereby the phase error of VTX2RX,n(k) to the phase error ΔψTX1(t) of VTX1RX,n(k). Aperture synthesis was established as a result. The aperture synthesis signal obtained by the signal processing unit 21 of the radar device of
In order to estimate an angle of the target to be detected from the respective signals, such as those in Expressions (1.14a) and (1.14b), the signals of the reference receiving antenna after having being subjected to aperture synthesis are defined by the following Expression (1.15), on the basis of the fact that the spatial phases of the respective signals of the reference receiving antennas are identical to each other. Further, a vector V(k), a noise signal vector N(k), an angular matrix A and a target signal vector X(k), having, as elements, the signals of the reference receiving antenna previously defined and the signals received by the other respective receiving antennas, are defined according to Expressions (1.16a), (1.16b), (1.16c), and (1.16d), respectively, to thereby derive, for the aperture-synthesized signal, a basic relational expression of array signal processing such as that of Expression (1.17) (needless to say, except for the angular matrix, the respective expressions are notations related to the signal elements in which the frequency index is k).
The signal processing unit 21 illustrated in
In the above-described comparative example, two antennas operate as transmitting antennas at two measurement time bands; echo signals from a target to be detected is received by N sets of receiving antennas, and the echo signals are synthesized if it is deemed that the phase lengths in a reference path at which spatial phases are identical become equal to each other. As a result, a function can be realized such that signals are received simultaneously using a radar device (detection and ranging apparatus) that is provided with a reception array antenna comprising 2N−1 antenna elements (in other words the effective aperture can be expanded).
However, aperture synthesis failed sometimes to work properly in a scene where there exists a plurality of targets to be detected at the same distance away from a measurement position, and the targets to be detected move with a small velocity difference with respect to each other (for instance, in a state where a vehicle in which the radar device is installed gets into a traffic jam).
In an enumeration of the various parameters of the radar device used in calculation examples, a system reference signal outputted by the oscillator module 22 is an FMCW signal having a carrier frequency of 76 Gigahertz (GHz) (=ωc/2π), with a basic period Tf of the modulation input signal (reference signal) to the RF-VCO of 4 (msec) and a one-sided modulation band of 50 (MHz) (=Δω/2π). The number of antenna elements N is four, a spacing d between antenna elements is 1.8λ (where λ is the wavelength of the carrier signal), and the number K of samples is 512. The various parameters (distance, angle, velocity) of each target to be detected in the scene setting of
Using the various parameters above, an aperture synthesis operation was performed, in accordance with the procedure described earlier, in the radar device 1 according to the comparative example, and angle measuring was performed in the frequency domain, to yield results such as those illustrated in
Such being the case, and in order to determine the causes of this erroneous estimation, an inverse Fourier transform was performed on the above-mentioned synthesis signal (Expression (1.17)), to transform again thereby the synthesis signal into a time domain signal. Thereafter, an angle measurement algorithm was applied to the time domain signal having been thus re-transformed.
In this example, the relative velocity difference between the two targets to be detected is 1 (km/h) (≅0.28 [m/sec)). Therefore, a distance difference between the targets to be measured, arising from the velocity difference for each Tf (=4 (msec)) time, is merely of about 1.1 (mm), which is a far smaller value than the distance resolution (≅0.75 (m)) of the device. In other words, the distances of the targets to be detected can be regarded as being identical over the two measurement times. Accordingly, the frequencies ωB1 and ωB2 determined by the distance delay may be thought of as being substantially a same value ωB (refer to Expression (2.1). Specifically, the frequencies ωB1 and ωB2 are about 13 (kHz) at 40 (m). Such being the case, Expressions (1.9a) and (1.9b) can be rewritten as Expressions (2.2a) and (2.2b).
Considering now the spatial phase and phase corresponding to the Doppler frequency, it is found that, for instance, the term in the brackets of exp of the summation term of vTX1RX,n(t) in Expression (2.2a) may be represented by Expression (2.3a) below. According to Expression (2.3a), it is found that a time-invariant spatial phase (n−1)d sin(θm) becomes of an order comparable to that of a Doppler phase shift 2vmt that varies with time (the Doppler frequency is about 1.4 (kHz) at 10 (km/h)).
As a result, as illustrated in
Such being the case, a conceivable way of solving the above-described problem involves performing firstly a correction that includes the influence of Doppler phase shift that varies with time, through cancelation of phase differences between signals in the time domain. Specifically, a correction amount is calculated according to Expression (2.4) below using Expression (2.2) for a reference combination. All n and t of vTX2RX,n(t) are multiplied by exp [−jdψ(t)] using the correction amount, to conform thereby the phase error of vTX2RX,n(t) to the phase error ΔψTX1(t) that is common to the phase error of vTX1RX,n(t). Synthesis aperture is performed thereafter.
[Expression 14]
dψ(t)≅arg[vRX,1TX2(t)]−arg[vRX,NTX1(t)]=ΔψTX2(t)−ΔψTX1(t) (2.4)
Therefore, a reassessment of Expressions (2.2a) and (2.2b) reveals that the frequency determined by distance delay is about 13 kHz, whereas the Doppler frequency is 1.4 kHz, i.e. about 1/10. Accordingly, Expressions (2.2a) and (2.2b) may be regarded as expressions resulting from performing amplitude modulation on the carrier signal exp(jωBt) by the time-variant terms within the summation symbol (needless to say, the carrier signal as termed herein is not the system carrier signal of frequency ωc). That is, the summation term alone of vTX1RX,n(t) is extracted from Expression (2.2a), and the expression is reorganized to yield Expression (2.5).
The rightmost side of Expression (2.5) means that, as a result of synthesizing the signals from two targets, the signal is substantially regarded, in the signal processing unit, as one signal that is represented by a product of a complex component exp( ) and a real number component cos( ). That is, the complex component behaves as if there existed one target to be detected having an average Doppler frequency and average angle of the two targets to be detected. A beat component, the real component, is generated from the Doppler signals of the two targets to be detected. The beat component constitutes an envelope of amplitude modulation (AM) components.
The signal resulting from performing amplitude modulation (AM), by the above-described beat signal, on a complex signal derived from the above-described pseudo-single target, constitutes the substance of Expression (2.5). This is the reason why the erroneous estimation of the number and angles of the targets to be detected was not solved even if the change in angle with time was corrected by performing aperture synthesis based on phase correction in the time domain. It is apparent that the beat signal (AM component) between the Doppler signals of the original targets to be detected is worked out as the envelope of Expression (2.5) (generally, Expressions (1.9) and (2.2)).
A detection and ranging apparatus according to a first embodiment of the invention is explained next.
In
The oscillator module 22 such as a DDS (Direct Digital Synthesizer) may be so configured as to directly generate, digitally, an FMCW signal. In
Each PWA (HPA) 13 is provided in a processing system corresponding to a transmitting antenna. In the example of
The array antenna 11 has N antenna (sensor) elements that are arranged at respective dissimilar spatial positions. For example, the array antenna 11 forms a uniform linear array antenna (ULA (Uniform Linear Array) antenna) in which the respective antenna elements are linearly arranged at regular intervals. In the example of
The shared antennas AR1/T1, ARN/T2 can switch between transmission and reception, in time division, by way of the switches 25. The antenna elements that operate as receiving antennas are notated as AR1 through ARN, and the antenna elements that operate as transmitting antennas are notated as AT1 and AT2. In the radar device 1A, thus, an aperture enlarging technique is used in which a plurality of transmitting antennas and a plurality of receiving antennas are combined to increase thereby the number of effective receiving antennas.
The switches 25 switch respective shared antennas AR1/T1, ARN/T2 between a transmission state and a reception state, in accordance with a control signal from the switch controller 24. Specifically, the shared antennas AR1/T1 are switched, by the switch 25 (#1), between a transmission state of being connected to the PWA 13 (#1) and a reception state of being connected to the LNA 12 (#1). The shared antenna AR1/T1 operates as the transmitting antenna AT1 in a transmission state, and operates as the receiving antenna AR1 in a reception state. Likewise, the shared antenna ARN/T2 is switched, by the switch 25 (#2), between a transmission state of being connected to the PWA 13 (#2) and a reception state of being connected to the LNA 12 (#N). The shared antenna ARN/T2 operates as the transmitting antenna AT2 in a transmission state, and operates as the receiving antenna ARN in a reception state.
The switch controller 24 controls the switching timing of the switches 25 in accordance with the transmission cycle information (P/Q) sent by the CPU 23 and in accordance with the period Tf of the reference signal that is outputted by the baseband oscillator of the oscillator module 22.
The transmission cycle setting unit 26 sends, to the CPU 23, an update instruction of the transmission cycle information (P/Q) or the period Tf of the reference signal according to a request by the signal processing unit 21. The transmission cycle information (P/Q) denotes a ratio (P) of time slots that use the transmitting antenna AT1 and a ratio (Q) of time slots that use the transmitting antenna AT2, with the period Tf of the reference signal being taken as one unit (the duty ratio upon switching of the respective shared antennas for transmission or reception during one time slot is ignored).
During PTf(=P×Tf), the switch controller 24 uses the shared antenna ARN/T2 as the receiving antenna ARN, and uses the shared antenna AR1/T1 as the receiving antenna AR1 and the transmitting antenna AT1 while switching in a predetermined period. During QTf(=Q×Tf), the switch controller 24 uses the shared antennas AR1/T1 as the receiving antenna AR1, and uses the shared antenna ARN/T2 as the receiving antenna ARN and the transmitting antenna AT2 while switching in the predetermined period.
With reference to the timing chart of
Returning now to
The mixers 14 (14(#1) to (#N)) are connected to respective LNAs 12. The mixers 14 mix the signals amplified by each LNA 12 with the system reference signal transmitted from the oscillator module 22, to convert thereby reception signals to baseband signals (demodulated signals).
Each A/D converter 15 converts the baseband signal outputted from a respective the mixer 14 into a digital baseband signal at a predetermined sampling frequency. Hereafter, the digital baseband signal may also be referred to as demodulated signal, echo signal or baseband signal by the context.
The HYBs 16 are provided in the respective processing systems corresponding to the receiving antennas AR1 and ARN, in order to process demodulated signals of the signals received by the receiving antennas AR1 and ARN. Specifically, an HYB 16 (#1) is connected to an A/D converter 15 (#1), and an HYB 16 (#2) is connected to an A/D converter 15 (#N).
In other words, each HYB 16 is provided in a processing system that processes a signal received by a receiving antenna of a combination of a transmitting antenna and the receiving antenna the spatial phases whereof are equal to each other, within the array antenna 11. Accordingly, the site at which the HYB and HIL are installed need not be limited to the receiving antennas on the outermost edges of the array antenna, as in
In the first embodiment, the combination of the reference transmitting antenna AT1 and the reference receiving antenna ARN, and the combination of the reference transmitting antenna AT2 and the reference receiving antenna AR1 constitute reference combinations for which the aperture magnification is best. The pathway of the signals transmitted and received in the reference combination will be called a “reference path”. Other specific reference combinations that are conceivable include a combination of the reference transmitting antenna AT1 and the reference receiving antenna AR1, and a combination of the reference transmitting antenna AT2 and the reference receiving antenna ARN. In this case, a reference phase length is zero. The language reference combination and reference path may be used without distinction.
As is apparent from
Each HYB 16 branches the demodulated signal outputted by the A/D converter 15 in the direction of the envelope detector unit 17 and in the direction of the data clipper/phase correction unit 20. The envelope detection units 17 are connected to the respective HYBs 16 in order to process the demodulated signals of the signals received by the reference receiving antenna. The envelope detector units 17 detect envelope components of demodulated signals inputted by the HYBs 16. Hereafter, the envelope components acquired by the envelope detector units 17 may be referred to as “envelope signals”.
When the envelope detection units 17 detect, for instance, the existence of a signal component having a period that is longer (frequency lower) than a minimum frequency resolution of a fast Fourier transform (FFT) performed by the signal processing unit 21, the envelope detector units 17 send the acquired envelope signal to an integrated distance calculation unit 19. When the envelope detector units 17 detect the existence of an envelope component having a period longer than the minimum frequency resolution of the Fourier transform, the envelope detector units 17 may ask the transmission cycle setting unit 26 to request, to the CPU 23, probe signal radiation in accordance with the above-described transmission cycle information (P and Q) (the request may include a modification of the values of P, Q, and Tf). The envelope detector units 17 are realized by using, for instance, a diode detector, a quadrature demodulator, a Hilbert transformer, a wavelet transformer, or a filter bank.
In the first embodiment, a Hilbert transformer is used in the envelope detection unit 17. The Hilbert transformer performs a Hilbert transform on signals that comprise only a real component of a complex signal (demodulated signals actually measured are all real numbers), to work out an imaginary component. A complex signal (analytical signal) can be obtained as a result. Thereafter, the Hilbert transformer works out the square root of the sum of the square of the real component and the square of the imaginary component.
If the output of the mixers 14 or the A/D converters 15 is separated into I/Q (in-phase/quadrature) components, the envelope can be easily worked out based on the formula “sqrt[I2(t)+Q2(t)] (i.e. square root of I2(t)+Q2(t)). In this case a Hilbert transform operation is not required. The obtained envelope is subjected, as the case may require, to a smoothing process for the purpose of noise removal. An unwrap process is performed in phase correction during aperture synthesis by the signal processing unit 21.
The data clipper of the data clipper/phase correction unit 20 can receive, from the respective A/D converters 15, the demodulated signals of the signals received by the respective receiving antennas in the respective time slots, and can retain the respective demodulated signals in a memory (that is, the memory may save the output from the A/D converter 15 obtained in the above-described “one period of operation as a device” in an accessible manner for each time slot and each receiving system (antennas to A/D converters). Data from a desired receiving system in a desired time slot may be appropriately outputted in respective below-described operations).
The data clipper conforms to each other the phases of the envelope components of the respective inputted demodulated signals on the basis of a delay amount as transmitted by the integrated distance calculation unit 19. Specifically, the data clipper clips respective signals for a Tf time after the delay amount from each demodulated signal, during [Tf, 3Tf]. As a result, the data clipper 19 can acquire data for which the envelope phase and the respective demodulated signals match each other, during [0,Tf], from the respective demodulated signals during, [Tf, 3Tf] (that is, there can be obtained a data string in which the phases of the envelopes are matched to each other, from data strings acquired in dissimilar time slots). The data clipper sends the respective demodulated signals, having thus undergone (envelope) phase correction, to the phase correction unit.
The phase correction unit of the data clipper/phase correction unit 20 receives respective demodulated signals, having aligned phases for the envelope components, as sent by the data clipper (in the specific example used herein, the length of data sent by the data clipper is identical to that in the time slot [0,Tf]), and the residual phase error of the demodulated signals is corrected. Specifically, in order to cancel the influence of the residual phase error in the baseband signal, including characteristic variations of the respective circuit elements, there is calculated an amount of correction (in the time domain) by using Expression (2.4) and correction is performed, in accordance with this correction amount, in such a manner that the phase errors of respective demodulated signals at the measurement time [Tf, 3Tf], clipped by the data clipper so that the envelope phases conform to each other, conform in turn to the phase errors of respective demodulated signals at another measurement time [0, Tf] (if the data has aligned envelope phases, then time domain data may be subjected to FFT to yield frequency domain data, and the correction amount is calculated according to Expression (1.13), such that the above-described correction process is performed in the frequency domain). The respective signals having a residual phase error thus corrected are sent to the signal processing unit 21.
The signal processing unit 21 subjects the respective signals transmitted from the data clipper/phase correction unit 20 to aperture synthesis, and applies, to the signals having been subjected to aperture synthesis, a known angle estimation algorithm (hereafter, simply angle measurement algorithm), such as, for instance, DBF (Digital Beam Forming), MUSIC (MUltiple SIgnal Classification), PRISM (PRopagator method based on an Improved Spatial-smoothing Matrix) and the like. The signals that have been subjected to aperture synthesis in the time domain may be converted into frequency domain signals by applying a Fourier transform (such as fast Fourier transform (FFT)), and the angle measurement algorithm may be applied to the frequency domain signals. The aperture synthesis method and the angle measurement algorithm may be carried out using a known technique, and hence an explanation thereof will be omitted herein. In the angle measurement algorithm, the signal processing unit 21 may use a correlation matrix that does not include an autocorrelation component.
The signal processing unit 21 may acquire, from the envelope detector units 17, information on frequencies of the envelopes themselves or information on the respective frequencies of the signal components that constitute the envelopes, and may acquire the envelope components (or above-mentioned respective amounts) through a predetermined method. In this case, the signal processing unit 21 may issue an instruction to change the period Tf of the reference signal from the transmission cycle setting unit 26, if the frequency component (or above-mentioned respective amounts) is smaller than a predetermined threshold value.
In a case where a plurality of targets, the distance whereof is to be measured, is present at a same distance and moves with small velocity differences with respect to each other, as in the comparative example, there arises a amplitude modulation (AM) component that has a frequency according to a Doppler frequency difference. Aperture synthesis cannot be performed appropriately by phase correction in the frequency domain if the frequency according to the Doppler frequency difference is smaller than the resolution of the first frequency analysis unit (for instance, FFT) that is used in the signal processing unit (Signal Processing Unit) 21. In some cases, a sufficient aperture synthesis effect failed to be achieved even upon correction in the time domain.
In the first embodiment, a reference path signal is monitored by the envelope detection unit 17. In this monitoring, probe signals are radiated from TX1 (transmitting antenna AT1) for a PTf time, and from TX2 (transmitting antenna AT2) for a QTf time (P,QεZ), if there exists an envelope component the period of which is longer than the minimum frequency resolution of the first frequency analysis unit.
The integrated distance calculation unit 19 detects a timing until the envelope phases of respective reference paths corresponding to TX1 and TX2 match each other. Specifically, the integrated distance calculation unit 19 calculates a integrated distance dist(τ) relating to a parameter τ, such that the timing until the envelope phases match each other is detected using the value of the parameter τ at the time where the integrated distance is minimal.
The data clipper of the data clipper/phase correction unit 20 clips, by Tf time, data of the respective receiving antennas (demodulated signals) by the probe signal of TX2, from the above-described timing, taking as a reference the phase of TX1 or TX2 (for instance, TX1). The demodulated signal comprising also the envelope component of the reference path is subjected to phase correction by the phase correction unit.
In a case where the frequency according to the difference of Doppler frequency is small to a degree that precludes obtaining an appropriate aperture synthesis result, even through operation of the integrated distance calculation unit 19 and the data clipper/phase correction unit 20, there is outputted an instruction (control command) of modifying the period Tf itself of the modulation input signal to the RF-VCO, from the transmission cycle setting unit (P/Q) 26 of probe signals. The control command can be outputted, for instance, from the CPU 23 to the transmission cycle setting unit 26. The output source of the control command is not limited to the CPU 23, and the command may be outputted by the data clipper/phase correction unit 20, the signal processing unit 21 or some other control unit. In the example of
Alternatively, there may be outputted a control signal for increasing at least one value from among P and Q. Increasing at least one from among P and Q requires an observation time that is proportional to the inverse of a minimum difference frequency. Therefore, a specific value is set in accordance with the travel environment of the vehicle (moving body) installed in the radar device 1A. The value of P and Q is deemed to increase dramatically, in particular, at congested sites such as tolls and intersections. An output trigger of the control command may be a manual operation by the user of the radar device 1A, or a sensor that senses the travel environment and that is installed in a vehicle (moving body) (for instance, motion velocity detected by a speedometer provided in the vehicle body on which the radar is installed, or an infrastructure-based environment information providing device such as a GPS, DSRC or the like).
The essence of the embodiment of the invention is taking the envelopes vTX1,envRX,N(t), vTX2,envRX,1(t) of the demodulated signals as time functions, and finding thereupon a time interval for which there is minimized the distance between these two functions. As a result, the occupancy time of the time slots, various case analyses according to the sequence of the time slots, and/or accessory operations (for instance, setting of integration intervals, an operation (addition PTf or QTf) of matching time intervals in vTX1,envRX,N(t), vTX2,envRX,1(t) upon distance calculation), or an averaging operation or the like (division by the width of integration intervals)) need only be decided appropriately depending on the way in which Expression (3.1a) is to be implemented in the device. In a case where P≠Q, the computation itself of the integrated distance need only be a single expression for working out the integrated distance between ordinary functions, if insufficient data are complemented by zero padding.
The phase correction method in the radar device 1A has proved effective even for small perturbations, namely minimum value of relative velocity difference of merely 0.1 (km/h)=0.028 (m/sec), i.e. distances of merely 0.11 mm to a target, at each period Tf. Distance fluctuations are difficult to measure even using a direct sequence spread spectrum-type radar (specifically, only distances of about 10 cm can be detected at a occupied bandwidth of about 1 GHz). This shows that measurement of small distances, which is difficult even in ultra-wideband detection and ranging apparatuses, is afforded by the radar device of the embodiment.
The phase correction method described above is also applicable to instances where there exists a plurality of targets to be detected having close relative velocities at a plurality of distances. The underlying reasons are as follows. For instance, the may be, hypothetically, a target T1(r1, θ1, v1), and a target T2(r1, θ2, v2) at a distance r1, plus a target T3(r2, θ3, v3) and a target T4 (r2, θ4, v4) at distance r2.
The frequency determined by the distance r1 of the targets T1,T2 can be defined as ωB1≅ωB2≅ωB1. The frequency defined by the distance r2 of the targets T3,T4 can be defined as ωB3≅ωB4≅B3. Thus, defining for instance the spatial phase determined by the angle of each target as φTX1/2,mn, and defining the Doppler frequency determined by the velocity as ωcμm (m=1 to 4), then the baseband signal that is obtained through reception, at the n-th receiving antenna, of a probe signal from TX1, can be represented in accordance with Expression (3.2) (for simplicity, there appears only a one-side TX).
The spatial phase is time-invariant, and hence, for a better comprehension, a vector μ, a vector φ, and a synthetic envelope A(t:μ,φ) are represented as in Expressions (3.3a), (3.3b) and (3.3c). Also, the spatial phase is also expressed as in Expressions (3.4a) and (3.4b), focusing on time-varying terms.
Expression (3.2) can thereupon be rewritten as Expression (3.5) next.
That is, the echo signal that is obtained from each receiving antenna for the probe signal from TX1, including a reference path signal, constitutes a signal that results from modulation, by the synthetic envelope A(t:μ,φ), of a synthesis baseband signal having a frequency (ωB1+α1+ωB3+α3)/2.
Thus, the equiphase planes of echo signals at two time slots can be regarded as being such that a phase relationship, where the synthetic envelopes are the respective radii, rotates with time (as
In the latter approach, the signals vTX1,envRX,N(t), vTX2,envRX,1(t) of the reference paths are acquired at dissimilar time slots, in Expression (3.1a) that gives an integrated distance. Therefore, the residual components after matching of the signal phases become noise components uncorrelated with each other. That is, the integrated distance at a time where the phases of the reference paths match each other becomes identical to that of noise power. As a threshold value for determining phase synthesis of the reference paths there can be used, accordingly, a quantitative criterion, namely a criterion of whether or not the integrated distance is substantially identical to that of noise power at a time of no signal.
In the radar device 1A according to the first embodiment the phases of data (signals) for which aperture synthesis is established at respective measurement times are aligned on the basis of envelope information of reference paths that correspond to TX1 and TX2; as a result, this allows realizing a detection and ranging apparatus that is small and is provided with multiple small sensors, where the number of effective reception sensors is increased under arbitrary conditions. Therefore, the radar device 1A according to the first embodiment affords angle estimation performance, with good precision, for a greater number of targets that can be separated by the actual number of reception sensors.
The radar device 1A of the first embodiment allows establishing aperture synthesis using a simple circuit. However, processing for each frequency is desirable with a view to increasing the response speed of the radar device.
The radar device 1B differs significantly from the radar device 1A as regards the features below. (1) A branching unit (HYB) 30 is disposed before the envelope detection unit 17 (17 (#2) in
In the radar device 1B, a frequency analysis unit 31 performs a Fourier transform on a demodulated signal of a reception signal in a reference path (in
In a case where the processing system of the BPFs 32 is one for each of the N receiving antennas, it is necessary to work out the delay amount (τ) and to repeat the aperture synthesis operation split band by split band. Accordingly, the combination of frequency analysis unit 31 and central frequency-variable BPFs 32 can be replaced by a filter bank.
The radar device 1C differs significantly from the radar device 1A (
The operation of the radar device 1C is as follows. Specifically, frequency components of a demodulated signal (demodulated signal of the receiving antenna ARN in
The processes that are performed thenceforth on the reference-path demodulated signals that pass through the LPF 33 or the through-line are identical to those of the first embodiment. The cutoff frequency of each LPF 33 is set to a frequency equal to or smaller than the minimum resolution of the first frequency analysis unit. If the frequency analysis unit 31A does not detect a signal component equal to or smaller than a minimum resolution of the first frequency analysis unit, the frequency analysis unit 31A sends the signals of each reference path, without modification, to the envelope detector 17, and not by way of the LPFs 33. The frequency analysis unit 31A controls thus a signal route switching operation. In a case where a signal is supplied from a through-line, therefore, aperture synthesis can be performed, in the embodiment, in the time domain using an envelope, or in the frequency domain using a Fourier transform, as in the comparative example.
An explanation follows next on a detection and ranging apparatus (radar device 1D) according to a fourth embodiment of the present invention. The fourth embodiment has features in common with those of the radar device 1A (
To make drawings more compact in the first to third embodiments, specific examples of devices have been used having a configuration wherein one transmission/reception shared antenna (sensor) is disposed at each outermost edge of the array antenna, and reception-only antennas (sensors) are disposed at the space flanked by the two transmission/reception shared antennas (sensors) at the outermost edges. The number of transmission/reception (or transmission and reception) sensors (antennas), however, can be appropriately set as the case may require. The arrangement of the transmission sensors need not be shared by the reception sensors (receiving antennas). The sensors may be arranged at mutually dissimilar positions in space.
That is, the radar device 1D has an array antenna 11A that comprises receiving antennas AR1 through ARN, used only for reception, and transmitting antennas AT1 and AT2 used only for transmission.
The PWAs 13 are connected to respective transmitting antennas AT1, AT2, such that a system reference signal from the OSC module 22 is inputted, through switches 25A, to one of the input ends of each PWA 13. The switch controller 24 performs switching control of the switches 25A. Providing dedicated transmitting antennas instead of transmission/reception shared antennas is disadvantageous in terms of device dimensions, but can be expected to afford better performance in terms of reception signal gain (
In the fourth embodiment, there is set a spacing (N−1)×d between respective transmitting antennas, wherein d is the spacing between respective receiving antennas. As a result, a reference combination is made up of, for instance, the transmitting antenna AT1 and the receiving antenna AR1, plus a combination of the transmitting antenna AT2 and the receiving antenna ARN.
The transmitting antennas can be arranged thus at different spatial positions from those of the receiving antennas. The sensor spacing (spacing between antennas: distance din
<Variations>
In the radar devices of the first to fourth embodiments, as explained above, the phases of envelopes of reference paths are monitored by the envelope detection unit 17, and a minimum envelope integrated distance is worked out by the integrated distance calculation unit 19. Thereby, correction is performed such that aperture synthesis does not collapse for any target.
Therefore, the correction method in the radar devices 1A to 1D of the first to fourth embodiments may be switched to the correction method that is used in the comparative example (
Other instances that require attention upon synthesis include instances where spatial phase and phase derived from a Doppler component are identical, as revealed by Expression (4.1) wherein a spatial phase term is worked into Expression (3.2). Herein, there may be switched between operation modes, in terms of, for instance, modifying a sampling frequency, performing non-uniform sampling, using a value estimated by a means such as a Kalman filter or the like, on the basis of values of various target parameters obtained at a point in time where the target to be detected has been normally detected, shifting the measurement time (or timing) by a predetermined time, or carrying out angle measuring without performing aperture synthesis.
Alternatively, if the frequency ωB determined by the distance delay is detected first, and vTX1/2RX/n(t) is multiplied by exp(−jωBt) to demodulate the component of Expression (4.1), or all vTX1/2RX/n(t) are subjected to envelope detection, then the equation can be rewritten in the same form as that of Expression (1.17). Therefore, the angle estimation process can be handled as if the echo signal is made up of only the Doppler component (in terms of device configuration, this approach is an expansion of the approach of Example 4).
The signal obtained by subjecting the respective signals to envelope detection is |HIL(vTX1/2RX,n(t))|. It must be noted that, therefore, the angle of the target for which the angular spectrum exhibits a peak is opposite/fair in sign to the actual value (in other words, the signal obtained by subjecting the respective signals to the envelope detection is close to 100% modulation. Accordingly, angle estimation is performed on an absolute value of the signal; alternatively, aperture synthesis is realized by time diversity).
[Others]
<Hardware Constituent Elements (Components) and Software Constituent Elements (Components)>
A hardware constituent element may be a hardware circuit, for example, a field programmable gate array (FPGA), an application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC), a gate array, a combination of logic gates, a signal processor circuit or an analog circuit.
A software constituent element is a part (fragment) that realizes the above-described processes in the form of software, but is not conceptually limited in terms of, for instance, the language or development environment in which the software is realized. Examples of software constituent elements include, for instance, a task, a process, a thread, a driver, firmware, a database, a table, a function, a procedure, a sub-routine, a given segment of a program code, a data structure, an array, a variable, and a parameter. Those constituent elements of software are realized, in a computer, on one or a plurality of memories, or are realized through execution of data on one or a plurality of memories by one or a plurality of processors (for example, central processing unit (CPU) or digital signal processor (DSP)).
The way in which the various abovementioned processing units are realized is not limited in the embodiments described above. The processing units may be configured in a manner that is realizable, by a person skilled in the art in technical field in question, in the form of the hardware constituent elements or software constituent elements described above, or in the form of a combination thereof.
The first through fourth embodiments can encompass the below-described aspects.
<<Aspect 1>>
A device and method such that, in a device, in particular a detection and ranging apparatus A in which there are used a transmission sensor array made up of U sensor elements and a reception sensor array made up of N sensor elements (the transmission sensors and the reception sensors may be shared, likewise hereafter); echo signals (hereafter, reception signals) generated through reflection, on a target to be detected, of probe signals radiated by the transmission sensors, are measured by each reception sensor; and a target angle is estimated on the basis of a signal synthesized through aperture synthesis performed using phases of reference paths made up of a combination of transmission/reception sensors for which spatial phases become identical:
the reception signals obtained in the respective reference paths are subjected to envelope analysis; there is worked out an integrated distance thereof; there is worked out a phase correction amount between reference paths from a delay amount that yields a minimum distance value; phases of all the reception signals including the envelopes are aligned using the correction amount; and there is realized an aperture synthesis function regardless of the situation of the target.
<<Aspect 2>>
A device and method in the detection and ranging apparatus A of aspect 1, wherein probe signals are radiated every QuTf times (QuεZ, u=1 to U), from a u-th transmission sensor, for a period: Tf of a modulation input signal, to a RF-VCO, for instance in a FMCW device; the N reception sensors receive signals of a time corresponding to the transmission time, and envelope analysis is performed on signals of each reference path; an integrated distance of the envelopes of reference paths is worked out after conforming, if necessary, data lengths of all reception signals, through zero padding of a shortfall in a reception signal that is less than max (QuTf); there are aligned the phases of all reception signals including the envelopes, through counting from a delay amount that yields a minimum distance value, and clipping of a signal for min (QuTf) time; and there is realized an aperture synthesis function regardless of the situation of the target (in particular, Tf may be used as min(QuTf)).
As a result of working out the integrated distance according to the delay amount, an instance may arise wherein a local minimum appears, at a plurality of sites, very near a minimum value; in this case, however, a local minimum corresponding to a smallest delay amount is used as a signal-clipping reference point. In practice, the minimum value is of the order of noise level. Therefore, the noise level at a time of no signal is held in a memory or the like, and this value is used as a threshold value upon determination of a minimum value.
If phase synthesis fails to be established for an initial delay amount, a conceivable cause that hampers synthesis may be, for instance, a change in the travel environment, such as a sudden change in the number of targets. Therefore, the next smaller delay amount may be used as a reference position for signal clipping, or using an infrastructure-based travel-environment information providing device; the device parameters (time slot length Qu, modulation input signal period Tf and so forth) may be then adjusted, after which aperture synthesis is performed again. Alternatively, a scheme where angular resolution is coarse, for instance DBF or the like, may be used without performing aperture synthesis.
<<Aspect 3>>
A device and method according to Aspects 1 and 2, wherein in the detection and ranging apparatus A of aspect 1, the reception signals obtained in the respective reference paths are subjected to envelope analysis; there is worked out a difference between the sum of autocorrelations of envelopes of the reference paths and the sum of cross-correlations between envelopes between reference paths; a phase correction amount between reference paths is worked out on the basis of a delay amount for which this difference is minimal; phases of all the reception signals including the envelopes are aligned using the correction amount; and there is realized an aperture synthesis function regardless of the situation of the target.
The autocorrelation of reference paths is but the incoming signal power in the reception sensors that make up that path. Instead of working the autocorrelation out, therefore, there may be provided a circuit-based means such as a square-law detector or the like (if necessary, depending on the way in which the integrated distance is defined, accessory operations such as an averaging operation or the like may be realized using appropriate hardware/software, in accordance with the implementation conditions).
<<Aspect 4>>
The device and method according to Aspects 1 to 3, wherein, in the detection and ranging apparatus A of aspect 1, a frequency component of reception signals in the reference paths is analyzed by a second frequency analysis unit that is provided in a reference path corresponding to one appropriate transmission sensor: u0; on the basis of the results of this frequency analysis, the second frequency analysis unit controls a central frequency of central frequency-variable BPFs (Band Pass Filters) that are provided in the N reception sensors; the reception signals obtained in the respective band-split reference paths are subjected to envelope analysis; there is worked out an integrated distance therebetween; there is worked out a phase correction amount between reference paths, for each band, from a delay amount that yields a minimum distance value; phases of all the reception signals, within the band, including the envelopes, are aligned using the correction amount; and there is realized an aperture synthesis function regardless of the situation of the target.
In a case where the processing system of the BPFs comprised in the device is one for each of the N sensors, the delay amount is worked out and the aperture synthesis operation is repeated split band by split band. Accordingly, the combination of frequency analysis unit and central frequency-variable BPFs may be replaced by a filter bank.
<<Aspect 5>>
The device and method according to Aspects 1 to 3, wherein in the detection and ranging apparatus A of aspect 1, a frequency component of reception signals in the reference paths is analyzed by a second frequency analysis unit that is provided in a reference path corresponding to one appropriate transmission sensor: u0; if the result of the frequency analysis includes a frequency component equal to or smaller than the minimum resolution of the first frequency analysis unit used in a signal processing means for working out distance/velocity based on a baseband signal, then the second frequency analysis unit makes send signals of each reference path, via LPFs (Low Pass Filter) provided in a respective reference path, to an envelope detector that is provided after the LPFs; there is worked out a integrated distance between signals outputted by the envelope detectors; there is worked out a phase correction amount between reference paths from a delay amount that yields a minimum distance value; phases of all the reception signal including the envelopes are aligned using the correction amount; and there is realized an aperture synthesis function regardless of the situation of the target.
In a case where a cutoff frequency of the LPFs is a frequency equal to or smaller than the minimum resolution of the first frequency analysis unit, and the second frequency analysis unit does not detect a signal component equal to or smaller than the minimum resolution of the first frequency analysis unit, then the second frequency analysis unit makes send signals of each reference path, without modification, to the envelope detector, and not byway of the LPFs. That is, the second frequency analysis unit controls thus a signal route switching operation.
<<Aspect 6>>
The device and method according to Aspects 1 to 3, wherein there is predicted a measurement time (proportional to a reciprocal of the minimum frequency included in a envelope), until acquisition of the data necessary for performing aperture synthesis, through exchange of information that relates to, for instance, the travel velocity of each target, using the infrastructure, for instance inter-vehicle communication, on-road repeaters, a control center or the like, to improve the response speed by establishing required time slot lengths.
The device and method according to Aspects 4 to 5, wherein an estimated value of the measurement time as acquired by the various means described above is used as a reference value upon execution of filter control by the second frequency analysis unit, to improve the response speed thereby.
<<Aspect 7>>
The device and method according to Aspects 1 to 6, wherein the reception signals obtained in the respective reference paths are subjected to envelope analysis; a basic period: Tf of the modulation scheme of the device or a probe signal transmission time: QuTf from each transmission sensor is modified in a case where a valid and unambiguous minimum value (roughly a noise power level at a time of no-signal in the installed system) is not obtained even by working out the integrated distance for aligning the phases.
The distance resolution and so forth of the device does not impair other performance items, and hence the occupied bandwidth Δω of the device may be modified in concert with Tf. If aperture synthesis cannot be realized even by way of such measures, it may be attempted to use just some of the U transmission sensors.
<<Aspect 8>>
The detection and ranging apparatus according to Aspects 1 to 7, comprising a reception sensor that constitutes a reference path; wherein reception signals by all the reception sensor are subjected to envelope analysis; and there is used an angle estimation algorithm on the envelope signals themselves of the reception sensors as obtained after aperture synthesis.
All examples and conditional language recited herein are intended for pedagogical purposes to aid the reader in understanding the invention and the concepts contributed by the inventor to furthering the art, and are to be construed as being without limitation to such specifically recited examples and conditions, nor does the organization of such examples in the specification relate to a showing of the superiority and inferiority of the invention. Although the embodiments of the present invention have been described in detail, it should be understood that the various changes, substitutions, and alterations could be made hereto without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2011-024110 | Feb 2011 | JP | national |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
4417249 | Zscheile, Jr. | Nov 1983 | A |
6067048 | Yamada | May 2000 | A |
6288672 | Asano et al. | Sep 2001 | B1 |
7196656 | Shirakawa | Mar 2007 | B2 |
7778249 | Shirakawa | Aug 2010 | B2 |
7859450 | Shirakawa et al. | Dec 2010 | B2 |
20010215964 | Shirakawa | Sep 2011 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
10 2009 027 003 | Dec 2010 | DE |
2363727 | Sep 2011 | EP |
11-231040 | Aug 1999 | JP |
2000-155171 | Jun 2000 | JP |
2006-098181 | Apr 2006 | JP |
2007-155381 | Jun 2007 | JP |
2011-185618 | Sep 2011 | JP |
WO 2010145904 | Dec 2010 | WO |
Entry |
---|
“Extended European Search Report” mailed by EPO and corresponding to European application No. 11194889.9 on May 23, 2012. |
Kees et al., “Improvement of Angular Resolution of a Millimeterwave Imaging System by Transmitter Location Multiplexing,” IEEE MTT-S Digest, pp. 969-972 (1995). |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20120200446 A1 | Aug 2012 | US |