The present invention generally relates to generally to radiation detectors, and specifically to a compact radiation tolerant and magnetic field immune radiation detector using an electro-optical coupling detector.
In modern experimental nuclear physics, radiation detectors are the core components to detect, track, and identify particles produced by nuclear decay, cosmic radiation, or in the accelerator reactions. Most detectors work on the fundamentals of material radiation ionization and/or excitation, such as gaseous ionization detectors, semiconductor detectors, and scintillation detectors. Other detectors work on different principles, such as Cerenkov light and transition radiation. Regardless of the purpose, these detectors are placed together or individually for their designated purposes of particle tracking and identification, as well as to determine many attributes of the measured physics quantities, such as momentum, spin, charge, etc. Unfortunately, conventional radiation detectors are of large size, require a lot of floor space, and are not capable of operating in a harsh environment with high radiation, strong magnetic fields, and/or high electromagnetic interference while maintaining high performances for high-count rate handling, low noise, high-energy resolutions, and high timing resolutions.
Conventional radiation detectors typically include a photon sensor, front-end electronics, and a copper wire transmission line to an analog digital converter (ADC). There are several disadvantages with conventional radiation detectors, including a significant space requirement for the photon sensors and the front-end electronics, and a reliance on electrical wires for data transmission. There is a physical limit on the amount of data that can be transferred by electrical wires, thus limiting the high-speed data transmission required by modern radiation detectors. Data transmission via electrical wires leads to low signal fidelity, low readout density, and complex front-end geometry with high mass and a high space requirement.
Conventional radiation detectors include a front-end portion that converts photons into electrical signals. The front-ends must operate in a harsh environment, which typically includes high radiation, strong magnetic fields, and and/or high electromagnetic interference. The front-ends of current state of the art radiation detectors are very susceptible to the high radiation and strong magnetic fields, which lead to a high amount of noise, low energy resolution, low timing resolution, and inability to maintain high-count rate performance. Operation in a high radiation environment and/or strong magnetic fields precludes the use of traditional photomultiplier tubes (PMTs) as they suffer large gain losses even in a residual magnetic field.
What is needed is a radiation detector that is radiation tolerant, immune to magnetic fields, and includes a front-end that is compact in size. The radiation detector should be capable of transmitting large quantities of data at high-speed transmission rates. The radiation detector furthermore should exhibit high signal fidelity, high readout density, and simplified detector front-end complexity with low mass and compactness.
The current invention is a radiation tolerant and magnetic field immune radiation detector for nuclear physics instrumentation. The radiation detector includes a front-end portion and a back-end portion. The detector front-end can operate successfully inside high radiation and strong magnetic fields and the back-end includes a multi-wavelength light source and at least one optical receiver that can operate in an environment with low background radiation and magnetic fields. The detector back-end can be located at some distance from the front-end. The front-end includes an electro-optical coupling detector (EOCD) that simultaneously modulates and multiplexes pulses from light sensors by transferring them to the optical domain and then transmits them through a single-mode fiber to an optical receiver in the back-end portion. During the fiber transmission, relative phase, amplitude and timing information among multiplexed signals is maintained. A pair of single-mode fibers includes an incoming fiber carrying multi-wavelength light from the multi-wavelength light source to the detector front-end and an outgoing fiber carrying optical signals to the optical receiver. The radiation detector is advantageous over the conventional detector architecture in its high signal fidelity, high readout density, and simplified detector front-end complexity with low mass and compactness. The detector utilizes high-index silica planar arrayed waveguide gratings (AWG) and electro-optical conversion modulators to minimize the effects of radiation damage. The light source module includes a light source including a plurality of standard grid lasers operating at different wavelengths. Optical modulators were installed to modulate electrical signals into the optical domain via the lasers operating wavelength and then multiplexed into a single-mode fiber for optical transmission from the detector front-end to the back-end. In the optical receiver, wavelengths are demultiplexed through an AWG and then electrically converted by optical-photon detectors before digitization. Electrical pulses detected after the electro-optical coupling preserved the original signal characteristics. The EOCD arrangement of the present invention enables a compact, low mass, radiation tolerant and magnetic field immune detector for nuclear physics instrumentation. It also has the potential to greatly reduce the size and complexity of instruments associated with applications of nuclear physics techniques. In order to improve compactness, the front-end portion of the detector includes electronics constructed of Application-Specific Integrated Circuits (ASIC).
One object of the current invention is to provide a radiation detector that includes a front-end that is radiation tolerant and immune to magnetic fields.
As a further object, the radiation detector should be capable of transmitting large quantities of data at high-speed transmission rates to a back-end that can be located at a substantial distance from the radiation tolerant front-end.
The radiation detector furthermore should exhibit high signal fidelity, high readout density, and simplified detector front-end complexity with low mass and compactness.
A further object is to significantly improve the readout density of a radiation detector by use of electro-optical coupling. By using optical fibers or waveguides, the resistive loss that characterizes electrical wires is eliminated.
A further object of the radiation detector is the utilization of wavelength-division-multiplexing (WDM) to further boost the information capacity of optical channels within the detector. An optical fiber is capable of carrying much higher densities of information than electrical wires.
A further advantage of optical transmission of data includes improved signal integrity and timing for either analogue or digital detector front-ends. Low dispersion in optical fibers permits the propagation of optical pulses over distances, as far as 5 KM, with almost no distortion, and thereby ensures the precise timing for analogue radiation pulse signals and high optical signal to noise ratio (OSNR) for digitized signal pulses.
A further object is to provide a radiation detector that utilizes electro-optical coupling in place of the electronics and copper wire transmission of signals of conventional radiation detectors. Electronics and copper wire transmission are replaced by an external modulated photo-electrical charge signal launched into the optical domain with lasers deployed external to the nuclear instrument, thereby providing a compact detector front-end capable of operating in high radiation and strong magnetic fields.
A further object of the radiation detector is to enable simultaneous detector channel transmission over many optical wavelengths through a single-mode fiber.
A further objective is to increase the compactness of the front-end electronics of a radiation detector by use of Application-Specific Integrated Circuits (ASIC). The ASICs are resistant to both high radiation and strong magnetic fields such that detector front-end could operate in a harsh environment.
Reference is made herein to the accompanying drawings, which are not necessarily drawn to scale, and wherein:
With reference to
The EOCD based radiation detector 20 shown in
The method of electro-optical coupling using fiber optics according to the present invention involves the following basic steps:
(1) modulating electrical pulses and creating an optical signal using a modulator,
(2) relaying the signal along the fiber, minimizing distortion and loss, and
(3) receiving the optical signal, and converting it back into an electrical signal.
The radiation detector of the present invention preferably includes silicon-based photosensors. The silicon-based photosensors provide photon spectroscopy with high-energy resolution, vertex detection with high spatial resolution, and energy measurement of charged particles as low as a few MeV. The silicon-based photosensors are capable of withstanding strong magnetic fields as less susceptible to radiation damages than conventional photosensors.
Use of external modulated laser light to achieve electro-optical coupling, as shown in
Nuclear physics and particle physics experiments require a strict amplitude, phase, and timing relationship among detected pulses from a single event. It demands the detector's homogeneous systematic response to these analogue quantities before digitization. The conventional instrumentation design, with ribbon or coaxial cables, however, is susceptible to electro-magnetic interferences as well as differences introduced by inhomogeneities in the transmission line, e.g., connector capacitance or shielding. The EOCD of the present invention utilizes WDM technology through the use of AWGs to maintain the relative amplitude, phase, and timing relationship among detector channels or between different detectors.
WDM is an efficient method where several optical pathways (channels), each carried by a different optical wavelength, are transmitted through a single-mode optical fiber, utilizing more of the available frequency bandwidth without increasing the effects of dispersion. Each channel, as a result of being effectively separated from the others by frequency band gaps, can be operated independently in protocol, speed, and direction of information transportation. AWGs are optical wavelength multiplexers/demultiplexers used to fulfill WDM transmission. In the EOCD, AWG is mainly used to multiplex several modulated wavelengths onto a single-mode optical fiber at the detector front-end and are also used as a demultiplexer to retrieve individual channels of different wavelengths at the receiver end. WDM utilization enables an all-optical nuclear detector architecture where signals are routed according to wavelength.
In the EOCD radiation detector of the present invention, electrical charges are produced in a radiation photon sensor when a nuclear event happens, and these charges are immediately amplified and launched into optical domain by optical modulation—an operation that converts the electrical signal into an optical signal. Two methods can be used to perform this operation. The first method is direct modulation, wherein light is emitted from a semiconductor laser in proportion to the charges received. Current art EOCDs are all based on this modulation scheme. The second method, utilized in the radiation detector of the present invention, is external modulation. In external modulation, a continuous wave (CW) laser is used to emit light whose power is constant with time. The emitted light is fed into an optical modulator to control the amount of light passing through according to the electrical charge intensity. The external modulation enables achievement of a radiation resistant and magnetic field immune radiation detector while maintaining overall linearity and electro-optical conversion efficiency.
In order to preserve the fidelity of the analogue optical signal, the EOCD uses a single-mode fiber rather than multi-mode fiber operated near 1550 nm. Optical signals distributed over many wavelengths, transmitted through a fiber and photo-detected in receivers require minimized signal distortions. The EOCD design takes into considerations several factors, including fiber transmission impairments caused by fiber nonlinearities, inter-modal dispersions, and chromatic dispersion. Because EOCD requires relative short distance fiber transmission, typically less than 2 km, fiber transmission distortions such as chromatic dispersion, polarization-mode dispersion, and fiber attenuations can be largely neglected. The short distance fiber transmission scheme simplifies transmission considerations to only fiber nonlinearities and inter-modal dispersions.
The power dependence of refractive index (fiber nonlinearity) is called Kerr-nonlinearity. Depending upon the type of input signals, the Kerr-nonlinearity manifests itself in three different effects such as Self-Phase Modulation (SPM), Cross-Phase Modulation (CPM) and Four-Wave Mixing (FWM). Except for SPM and CPM, all nonlinear effects provide gains to some wavelengths at the expense of depleting power from other wavelengths. SPM and CPM affects only the phase of signals and can cause spectral broadening leading to increased dispersion. In the EOCD arrangement of the current invention, controlling the amount of optical power injection into the fiber for each wavelength enables avoidance of the Kerr-nonlinearity.
The analogue optical pulse transmission in EOCD requires minimum fiber transmission dispersions for high-fidelity signal preservation. Multi-mode fiber transmission introduces large optical pulse spreading because of inter-modal dispersion—distorting optical pulse amplitude, phase and arrival time even for a short transmission distance, e.g., 100 meters. The current multi-mode fiber electro-optical coupling is useful in a digital transmission scheme where pulse digitization is needed in the detector front-end before transmission and dispersion compensation schemes are implemented after the optical receiver.
For the multi-wavelength laser array, the radiation detector utilizes external laser modulation in the EOCD arrangement. Preferably, the laser array operates at approximately 1550 nm. External laser modulation enables integration of the detector front-end photon-sensor and electro-optical conversion component into a small footprint (compact size), and separates the laser array (light source) from the high radiation and strong magnetic field environment. Use of external modulation to physically separate the detector front-end and laser array guarantees a high quality laser light source with minimum wavelength drifting in all wavelengths for high-fidelity light pulse readout. External modulation enables the sharing of a single laser array between several detectors, thereby enabling detector clustering and homogeneous readout in a detector cluster.
For the laser array light source and receivers, which are placed in the background fields, there are no special requirements. However, the front-end of the EOCD must be radiation tolerant and immune to magnetic fields, and it requires device materials, structures, and functions that can survive in these harsh environments. To meet the radiation hardened and magnetic field immune requirement, the photon sensors 36 are preferably silicon photomultipliers (SiPM) and the AWGs are preferably silica (glass) based.
With reference to
In order to reduce system complexity for the two-wavelength EOCD 60 and lessen optical loss induced by components interconnections, instead of using AWG to multiplex the laser light wavelengths before transmission to the LiNBO3 modulators 68 and 70, the modulated laser pulses are multiplexed by a waveguide combiner 72, which is a much simpler device analogous to AWG multiplexing function for two wavelengths. A 1:16 AWG 76 was used to demultiplex and select a wavelength for each optical receiver 78. All the discrete component optical connectors in the two-wavelength EOCD are either SC/APC (before the waveguide combiner 72) or LC connectors (after the waveguide combiner 72) to minimize optical loss due to conversion for optical connectors. The waveguide combiner 72 combined the two close wavelengths, approximately 1553 nm and 1554 nm, into a single-mode fiber.
The light source consisted of two 1550 nm near-infrared continuous wave (CW) lasers and the two wavelengths were tuned by controlling their independent temperature controllers (not shown). Both lasers have a maximum optical power dissipation of 20 mW and the actual optical power dissipation was controlled by their laser diode drivers (not shown) through laser injected electrical current.
The waveform generator 66 generated a square wave with width 50 ns, and both its leading edge and trailing edges are 10 ns, as shown in
The 1:16 ratio AWG 76 was demonstrated the AWGs capability to separate two close wavelengths with 40 dB side-band suppression, demonstrating that the crosstalk between separated wavelengths is negligible. A planar arrayed waveguide was used to separate two multiplexed wavelengths from a single-mode fiber transmission. The AWG included 100 GHz channel spacing with ITU grid standard WDM wavelength allocations (center wavelength in nm: 1548.515, 1549.315, 1550.116, 1550.918, 1551.721, 1552.524, 1553.329, 1554.134, 1554.940, 1555.747, 1556.555, 1557.363, 1558.173, 1558.983, 1559.794, 1560.606). Each AWG demultiplexed output channel included a unique channel number corresponding to its center wavelength. The radiation detector of the present invention could be constructed with an AWG having a ratio of 1:16, 1:32, 1:64, 1:128, or 1:160.
The two AWG-separated wavelengths are then fed to optical receivers 78 for optical electrical conversion. For comparison and data acquisitions, the converted electrical pulses were subsequently fed into an oscilloscope 80 together with the original square pulse output from the arbitrary waveform generator.
Using the two-wavelength EOCD of
Two separate experiments were conducted. The first experiment tested the high-fidelity electro-optical signal coupling with two wavelengths (wavelength 1554.555 nm—L1 signal—and 1553.365 nm—L2 signal). Afterwards, the second experiment demonstrated negligible inter-wavelength/channel crosstalk in the single fiber 74 of the EOCD 60.
Each experiment included individual wavelength transmission as well as simultaneous two-wavelength transmission. The results are presented in both time domain pulse analysis using capture pulses in the oscilloscope (Tektronix DPO 4104 Digital Phosphor Oscilloscope available from Tektronix, Inc. of Beaverton, Oreg.) as well as optical spectrum analysis (UBICS Model 701, available from GN Nettest, France) in the wavelength domain.
As shown in
For all five experiment types, the FWHM distortion shown in
Referring to
Referring to
To understand the inter-wavelength crosstalk impact towards the EOCD system, one of the two lasers was turned off, allowing only one of the wavelengths to pass through. The peak power difference between the simultaneous two laser-on transmission and the one laser-on transmission were compared, and their difference are less than 0.52% for both 1553.365 nm and 1554.555 nm. This result demonstrated the inter-wavelength crosstalk is negligible.
The optical power in the AWG channel 7 and 8, i.e., actual output wavelengths 1553.365 nm and 1554.555 nm, may contribute its output power to its neighboring channels, such as channel 6 and channel 9. In order to understand the degree of inter-channel interferences, optical spectrum scanning was conducted for both channel 6 in
An optical modulator for use in a compact radiation tolerant and magnetic field immune radiation an electro-optical coupling detector according to the present invention is preferably constructed of LiNBO3, InP, polymers, or silicon. More preferably, the optical modulator is constructed of InP or polymer. Most preferably, as a result of its superior resistance to radiation, the optical modulator is constructed of InP. InP light transportation phase shift can be controlled in a Mach-Zehnder Interferometer and this phase shift is neither sensitive to the magnetic fields nor susceptible to the temperature variations. These desirable characteristics of InP enable an electrical signal to be coupled into optical pulses through its switching voltage Vπ curve in a modulator.
An EOCD system according to the present invention will provide high-fidelity radiation signals in a high radiation and strong magnetic field environment. It is critically important to minimize the modulator size in such an EOCD system as the EOCD front-end requires integrating a plurality of such modulators in an area equivalent to its photon sensor. An EOCD frontend modulator according to the present invention must also meet requirements for low input-voltage with efficient linear electrical-optical coupling conversion (less insertion loss), stable temperature response, and low-cost to manufacture. The reduction of insertion loss in the modulator is particularly important in the EOCD implementation.
All these important modulator design requirements place limits on a desirable electrical-optical conversion material, so that characteristics demonstrated in the two-wavelength EOCD experiments will be inherited while the entire EOCD front-end could be further integrated and manufactured into a compact device resistant to both high radiation and strong magnetic fields. Modulators made of InP material have the potential to fulfill all these stringent requirement with good performance.
In the two-wavelength crosstalk studies, in order to adjust one of two lasers wavelength to 1553.365 nm, we have pushed its thermo-electrical cooler (TEC) to 119° C., which is far from its normal operating temperature. This broadened the laser's wavelength line-width, which introduced a small amount of channel crosstalk. From
Nuclear physics experimentation often requires high timing resolution for short pulses with fast rising edge and/or falling edge, e.g., pulses with 10 ns FWHM and 2-3 ns rise time. The EOCD of the present invention could accommodate these requirements because each wavelength could include a bandwidth of 100 GHz, which is equivalent to 3.5 ps rise/fall time for the pulse. In this case, the system is not restricted by the factors of optical transmission. High-fidelity radiation pulse detection and transmission can be restricted by many factors in the current two-wavelength EOCD system. In the current system, the electronic components (such as the optical receivers and RF transmission wire) restricted the realized transmission bandwidth. If there is insufficient bandwidth for any of the components, pulse distortion could happen. Differing test pulses were tried with a constant FWHM of 50 ns but with different rising or falling edges of 10 ns, 7.5 ns, and 5 ns. It was shown that as pulse rising or falling edges time reduced, the bandwidth impacted the fidelity of the received pulses. In this case, an optimized EOCD bandwidth is the key to achieve EOCDs high-fidelity feature.
The EOCD system long-term stability was also studied. The two-wavelength experiment was setup in a laboratory with stable temperature around 22.3° C. The system had been repeatedly cycled on and off, but there was no significant pulse-level or wavelength drifting observed in a consecutive one-week experiment. Because an external laser modulation scheme was implemented in the EOCD system (separating the laser wavelength generation and the electro-optical conversion/modulation), the multi-wavelength lasers could be controlled reliably by their current and TEC controllers, resulting in long-term system stability. A heated AWG is preferable to an ambient-temperature AWG, because AWGs wavelength response could be precisely specified. However, in the work for this paper, by putting the AWG into a stable room temperature environment, one could control the amount of wavelength shift and stabilize AWG performance.
Although the description above contains many specific descriptions, materials, and dimensions, these should not be construed as limiting the scope of the invention but as merely providing illustrations of some of the presently preferred embodiments of this invention. Thus the scope of the invention should be determined by the appended claims and their legal equivalents, rather than by the examples given.
The United States Government may have certain rights to this invention under Management and Operating Contract No. DE-AC05-06OR23177 from the Department of Energy.