 
                 Patent Grant
 Patent Grant
                     8130167
 8130167
                    The present invention, in various embodiments, relates to radomes for protecting antennas from environmental conditions, to aircraft and spacecraft carrying such radomes, and to methods of manufacturing radomes.
Radomes are structures that are used to protect antennas (e.g., radar antennas) and associated equipment from environmental exposure. Thus, radomes may be subject to both physical and electromagnetic requirements and specifications. For example, radomes are often used in various types of aircraft and missiles carrying radar equipment, and such radomes must be aerodynamic and capable of withstanding physical and thermal stresses encountered during flight. Radomes also are typically subject to electromagnetic performance requirements and specifications such as, for example, minimum transmission loss, minimum reflected power, minimum beam deflection, and minimum pattern distortion. There is often a trade-off in the design of a radome between physical performance requirements and electromagnetic performance requirements.
The term “radome” was derived from the terms “radar” and “dome,” although, as used herein, the term “radome” means and includes any structure configured to protect an antenna from environmental exposure and through which electromagnetic radiation is transmitted to or from the antenna. Radomes may have any shape or configuration, and are not limited to dome-shaped structures, and may be configured to transmit any range of frequencies of electromagnetic radiation therethrough.
There are many different materials used in constructing radomes and many different cross-sectional radome configurations including single layer (often referred to in the art as “monolithic” or “solid-wall” configurations) and multi-layer or “sandwich” configurations including, for example, what are known in the art as “A-sandwich” radome configurations, “B-sandwich” radome configurations, and “C-sandwich” radome configurations. Such radome configurations are discussed in, for example, A. W. Rudge, K. Milne, A. D. Olver, and P. Knight, eds., THE HANDBOOK OF ANTENNA DESIGN, Vol. 2, Chapter 14, Peter Peregrinus Ltd., London, and M. I. Skolnik, INTRODUCTION TO RADAR SYSTEMS, Chapter 7, McGraw-Hill, New York, N.Y.
The “A-sandwich” radome configuration includes a relatively thick inner core that is sandwiched between two relatively thin outer “skin” layers. The inner core is formed of a material that exhibits a low dielectric constant (e.g., a foam material, or a honeycomb structure), and the outer skin layers are formed of a material that exhibits a relatively high dielectric constant. The dielectric constant of the core may be less than the square root of the dielectric constant of the skin layers. The dielectric constant of the core may be reduced by reducing the density of the core material (e.g., by increasing porosity in the core material).
The “B-sandwich” radome configuration includes a relatively thin inner core that is sandwiched between two relatively thick outer skin layers. The inner core is formed of a material that exhibits a relatively high dielectric constant, and the outer skin layers are formed of a material that exhibits a relatively low dielectric constant. The dielectric constant of the core may be greater than the square of the dielectric constant of the skin layers. B-sandwich radomes may exhibit higher power transmission efficiencies relative to A-sandwich radomes, but the physical properties exhibited by the materials of the outer skin layers in B-sandwich configurations may not withstand the conditions experienced in high-temperature, high-velocity applications such as those encountered by radomes on missiles.
What is referred to in the art as a “C-sandwich” radome configuration consists of two contiguous A-sandwiches. In other words, a C-sandwich radome includes two “core” layers that exhibit a relatively low dielectric constant that are separated from one another by a central skin layer. An outer skin layer is also disposed on the outer surface of each core layer, and the exposed major surfaces of these outer skin layers provide the interior and exterior surfaces of the radome. Sensitivity to frequency, incident angle, and polarization may be reduced in the C-sandwich radome configuration relative to the A-sandwich and B-sandwich radome configurations.
Radomes that are lightweight, physically strong, tough, and wear-resistant, and that exhibit desirable electromagnetic performance characteristics continue to be sought for use on aircraft and spacecraft.
In some embodiments, the present invention includes radomes that include an outer wall having a first average thickness and an inner wall having a second average thickness that is different from the first average thickness. At least a major portion of the inner wall is separated from at least a major portion of the outer wall by a space therebetween. The outer wall may comprise a layer of ceramic matrix composite (CMC) material.
In additional embodiments, the present invention includes air vehicles and space vehicles including such radomes. For example, one embodiment of a vehicle of the present invention includes an antenna for emitting electromagnetic radiation over a range of frequencies, and a radome at least partially covering the antenna. The radome includes an outer wall having a first average thickness and an inner wall having a different second average thickness. At least a major portion of the inner wall is separated from at least a major portion of the outer wall by a space. The outer wall may comprise a layer of ceramic matrix composite (CMC) material.
In additional embodiments, the present invention includes methods of forming radomes in which an outer wall that has a first average thickness is formed, an inner wall that has a different second average thickness is formed, and the inner wall and the outer wall are coupled together in such a manner as to provide a space between at least a major portion of the outer wall and at least a major portion of the inner wall. Each of the outer wall and the inner wall may be formed to have a dome shape, and the inner wall may be at least partially inserted into an inner dome area enclosed by the outer wall. At least the outer wall may be formed to comprise a ceramic matrix composite (CMC) material.
While the specification concludes with claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming embodiments of the present invention, the advantages of this invention can be more readily ascertained from the following description of the invention when read in conjunction with the accompanying drawings in which:
    
    
    
    
In some embodiments, the present invention includes aircraft and spacecraft that carry one or more radomes, as described herein. As used herein, the term “aircraft” means and includes any device, apparatus, system, or vehicle designed and constructed for traveling through the air substantially within the Earth's atmosphere. As used herein, the term “spacecraft” means and includes any device, apparatus, system, or vehicle designed and constructed for traveling through space outside the Earth's atmosphere, although spacecraft may also travel through the Earth's atmosphere upon entering and/or exiting space. Aircraft and spacecraft include, for example, airplanes, rockets, missiles, space vehicles, satellites, space stations, etc.
An embodiment of an aircraft of the present invention is shown in 
The radome 12 may be designed, configured, and constructed to protect the antenna 18 from environmental conditions (e.g., wind, rain, dust, moisture, etc.) as the missile 10 travels through the air at high velocity toward an intended target.
  
  
The outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 have different average electrical thicknesses. The electrical thickness TE of a material may be defined as the actual physical thickness Tp of the material multiplied by the square root of the dielectric constant K (also referred to as the relative permittivity) of the material, as indicated in Equation 1 below:
TE=TP√K  Equation 1
where TE is the electrical thickness of the material, TP is the actual physical thickness of the material, and K is the dielectric constant exhibited by the material.
Thus, in some embodiments, the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 have different average actual physical thicknesses (as well as different electrical thicknesses), as shown in 
In some embodiments, it may be desirable to form the average physical thickness T32 of the inner wall 32 to be physically as thin as possible while still having sufficient structural integrity to withstand the forces experienced by the average physical thickness T32 of the inner wall 32 during flight of the missile 10 (
The average distance D between the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 in the space 34 may be about three-fourths (¾) or less of the average physical thickness T30 of the outer wall 30. More particularly, the average distance D between the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 in the space 34 may be about two-thirds (⅔) or less of the average physical thickness T30 of the outer wall 30.
By way of example and not limitation, the average electrical thickness of the outer wall 30 may be about NλO/2, where N is an integer (e.g., 1 or 2) and λO is the wavelength of the electromagnetic radiation in the material of the outer wall 30 at the center of the desired range of operating wavelengths, and the average electrical thickness of the inner wall 32 may be about λI/8 or less, where λI is the wavelength of the electromagnetic radiation in the material of the inner wall 32 at the center of the desired range of operating wavelengths. In such embodiments, the average electrical thickness of the space 34 between the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 may be between about λS/5 and λS/10, where λS is the wavelength of the electromagnetic radiation in the space 34 at the center of the desired range of operating wavelengths. The average electrical thickness of the outer wall 30, as well as the average electrical thickness of the space 34 between the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32, may be increased to compensate for non-normal incidence of the radiating fields.
In some embodiments, one or more of the average physical thickness T30 of the outer wall 30, the average physical thickness T32 of the inner wall 32, and the average distance D between the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 in the space 34 may be at least substantially uniform over the major portions thereof, as shown in 
Referring again to 
The outer wall 30 may comprise a ceramic matrix composite (CMC) material having a ceramic matrix phase. A reinforcing phase may be distributed throughout the ceramic matrix phase. The ceramic matrix phase may comprise a ceramic oxide material such as, for example, magnesium oxide (MgO), aluminum oxide (Al2O3), silicon oxide (SiO2), zirconium oxide (ZrO2), titanium oxide (TiO2), yttrium oxide (Y2O3), a combination of such oxides (e.g., aluminosilicate (Al2SiO5) or mullite), etc. The reinforcing phase may comprise, for example, fibers, particles, and/or whiskers distributed throughout the ceramic matrix phase. In some embodiments, the reinforcing phase may comprise a fabric comprising woven fibers. The reinforcing phase may also comprise a ceramic material. In some embodiments, the reinforcing phase may also comprise a ceramic oxide material such as, for example, magnesium oxide (MgO), aluminum oxide (Al2O3), silicon oxide (SiO2), zirconium oxide (ZrO2), titanium oxide (TiO2), yttrium oxide (Y2O3), a combination of such oxides (e.g., aluminosilicate (Al2SiO5) or mullite), etc. In some embodiments, the ceramic matrix phase and the reinforcing phase may have at least substantially similar chemical compositions. In further embodiments, the ceramic matrix phase and the reinforcing phase may have different chemical compositions.
As a non-limiting embodiment, the ceramic matrix phase may comprise an aluminosilicate (Al2SiO5) material, and the reinforcing phase may comprise a fabric of woven aluminosilicate (Al2SiO5) fibers. An example of a suitable, commercially available fabric of aluminosilicate fibers is sold by 3M of St. Paul, Minn. under the trade name NEXTEL® 312.
In some embodiments, the inner wall 32 may comprise a ceramic matrix composite (CMC) material having a ceramic matrix phase as previously described herein in relation to the outer wall 30.
In some applications, the inner wall 32 may be subjected to relatively lower temperatures (e.g., temperatures below about 450° Celsius). In such applications, the inner wall 32 may comprise a high-temperature organic matrix composite material including a polymeric matrix phase and a reinforcing phase. The reinforcing phase may comprise, for example, a fabric, fibers, particles, and/or whiskers distributed throughout the polymeric matrix phase.
The matrix phase may comprise a thermosetting polymer material, or the matrix phase may comprise a thermoplastic polymer material. In embodiments in which the matrix phase comprises a thermoset polymer material, the matrix phase may be thermally stable (i.e., will not physically degrade, decompose, or combust in any significant detrimental manner) up to temperatures of about 450° Celsius or more. In embodiments in which the matrix phase comprises a thermoplastic polymer material, the matrix phase may exhibit a glass transition temperature of about 450° Celsius or higher.
As non-limiting examples, the matrix phase in such organic matrix composite materials may comprise a cyanate-based polymeric material (e.g., a cyanate ester material) or a polyimide-based polymeric material, and the reinforcing phase may comprise quartz fabric, fibers, particles, and/or whiskers.
Other materials also may be used to form the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32, provided the materials impart physical properties to the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32, respectively, that will allow the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 to sufficiently protect the antenna 18 from the environmental conditions to which the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 will be exposed, and at the temperatures to which the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 may be heated, for example, during flight of a missile 10 (
With continued reference to 
The particular chemical composition of the outer wall 30, the inner wall 32, and any matter within the space 34, as well as the particular dimensions of the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32, and the distance therebetween within the space 34, will vary depending on the particular application in which the radome 12 is to be used and the range of frequencies of electromagnetic radiation that are to be transmitted through the radome 12. In some embodiments, the radome 12 may be operational over a broad range of frequencies. For example, the radome 12 may be configured to exhibit an average insertion loss for a typical missile radome shape of less than about −1.5 dB, or even less than about −0.5 dB, for 15° to 45° scan angles in principal planes over a range of frequencies of electromagnetic radiation extending from a first frequency to a second frequency that is about 1.4 times the first frequency, when the electromagnetic radiation is emitted from an antenna 18 (
A non-limiting example of a method that may be used to form a radome 12 is described herein below.
Generally, the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 may be separately formed from one another, assembled together, and attached to an aircraft, spacecraft, or another device or apparatus carrying an antenna. For example, if the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 have a dome shape, the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 may be separately formed, the inner wall 32 may be inserted at least partially into an inner dome area of the outer wall 30, and the inner wall 32 and the outer wall 30 may be coupled together in such a manner as to provide a space 34 between at least a major portion of the outer wall 30 and at least a major portion of the inner wall 32.
The outer wall 30 may comprise a ceramic matrix composite (CMC) material, and may be fabricated using methods similar those known in the art such as, for example, those disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 4,983,422 to Davis et al., issued Jan. 8, 1991, U.S. Pat. No. 5,395,648 to Davis et al., issued Mar. 7, 1995, and U.S. Pat. No. 6,497,776 to Butler et al., issued Dec. 24, 2002. If the inner wall 32 also includes a ceramic matrix composite material, as previously discussed herein, the inner wall 32 also may be formed using such methods.
The outer wall 30 (and optionally, the inner wall 32) may be formed by introducing a liquid ceramic matrix precursor material into a reinforcement ceramic structure or ceramic material (e.g., fabric, fibers, particles, and/or whiskers), curing the resulting structure to set the desired geometry, and sintering the cured structure to a desired final density.
In some embodiments, a reinforcement ceramic structure may be formed using a two-dimensional or three-dimensional reinforcement fabric, which may be produced by weaving reinforcement strands (e.g., single fibers or yarns) in a desirable pattern. A number of different techniques may be used to form a reinforcement structure from reinforcement strands, including two-dimensional and three-dimensional weaving techniques, filament winding techniques, tape wrapping techniques, etc. Reinforcement fabrics are also commercially available, such as, for example, the aluminosilicate fiber fabric sold by 3M of St. Paul, Minn., under the trade name NEXTEL® 312, as previously mentioned.
Liquid ceramic matrix precursor material may be introduced into the reinforcement structure or material before and/or after shaping the reinforcement structure or material in a desired shape corresponding to that of the outer wall 30 to be formed therefrom. For example, a reinforcement fabric may be pre-impregnated with the liquid ceramic matrix precursor material prior to shaping the pre-impregnated reinforcement fabric into a shape corresponding to the outer wall 30.
The ceramic matrix precursor material may comprise a slurry that includes ceramic particles suspended in a liquid medium. The liquid medium may comprise, for example, water, an alcohol (e.g., ethylene glycol), or a mixture thereof. The ceramic particles comprise material or materials that will form the ceramic matrix phase of the resulting ceramic matrix composite material. The ceramic particles may comprise, for example, from about 20% to about 80% of the slurry by weight. Other additives may be included in the slurry to assist in processing such as, for example, polymeric curing agents, binders, lubricants, dispersants, etc.
After introducing the liquid ceramic matrix precursor material into the reinforcement ceramic structure or ceramic material (e.g., fabric, fibers, particles, and/or whiskers) and shaping the resulting impregnated reinforcement structure into a shape corresponding to the desired shape of the outer wall 30 to be formed therefrom, the impregnated reinforcement structure may be treated to set the desired geometry of the impregnated reinforcement structure.
For example, in some embodiments, the slurry may comprise a polymer precursor material that may be cured to cause the polymer precursor material to polymerize in such a manner as to form a solid three-dimensional structure. In such embodiments, the impregnated reinforcement structure may be heated in order to cure the polymer precursor material and set the geometry of the impregnated reinforcement structure. The curing may also drive off liquids and other volatile components of the slurry. By way of example, the impregnated reinforcement structure may be cured by slowly ramping up the temperature of the impregnated reinforcement structure in a furnace to a curing temperature of between about 125° Celsius and about 200° Celsius (e.g., about 177° Celsius) over a time period of between about twelve (12) hours and about thirty-six (36) hours. The temperature then may be held at the curing temperature for a time period of between about six (6) hours and about twelve (12) hours.
In some embodiments, the impregnated reinforcement structure may be cured while disposed in a bag in which a vacuum is drawn in order to cause the bag to conform to the shape of the impregnated reinforcement structure. In other embodiments, the impregnated reinforcement structure may be cured in a hot press or an autoclave.
After curing the impregnated reinforcement structure, the resulting cured but unsintered structure may be sintered in a furnace to form the outer wall 30 including a ceramic matrix composite material that includes a reinforcing phase disposed within a ceramic matrix phase.
In some embodiments, the cured structure may be sintered in an oxidizing atmosphere (i.e., in an atmosphere including oxygen) such as, for example, in air. In such embodiments, the ceramic particles of the ceramic matrix precursor material may oxidize during sintering to form an oxide material, which may form at least a portion of the ceramic matrix phase in the resulting ceramic matrix composite material of the outer wall 30.
During a sintering process, the temperature may be raised in a stepped profile from room temperature to a maximum sintering temperature over a period of from about six (6) hours to about twelve (12) hours. The temperature in the furnace may be held at the maximum sintering temperature for between about two (2) and about ten (10) hours. The maximum sintering temperature may be above about 800° Celsius. Additional sintering cycles may be performed as necessary or desirable in order to increase the density and/or strength of the outer wall 30.
After sintering, final machining (e.g., grinding, milling, drilling, etc.) and/or other shape-forming processes may be used to ensure that the outer wall 30 (and, optionally, the inner wall 32) has the appropriate final dimensions.
The above-described method is set forth merely as one example of a method that may be used to form the outer wall 30 (and, optionally, the inner wall 32) and other methods may also be employed in embodiments of the present invention. For example, filament winding techniques may be used to form a green (i.e., unsintered) outer wall, and the green outer wall may be sintered to a desirable final density to form the outer wall 30. Furthermore, in additional embodiments, a green outer wall may be formed without employing a curing process, and the uncured, green outer wall may be sintered to a desirable final density to form the outer wall 30.
The coating 38 may be applied to outer surfaces of the outer wall 30 after forming the outer wall 30, as previously described herein, using, for example, a spray-coating process. A slurry may be formed that includes a liquid medium in which particles of the ceramic material (e.g., glass) that will ultimately form the coating 38 are suspended. The liquid medium may comprise, for example, water, glycerin, an alcohol (e.g., ethylene glycol), or a mixture thereof. The slurry may also include processing aids such as, for example, binders, deflocculants, wetting agents, etc. The slurry may be sprayed onto the outer surfaces of the outer wall 30, after which the slurry is allowed to dry, leaving behind the particles of the ceramic material (e.g., glass) that will ultimately form the coating 38 on the outer surfaces of the outer wall 30. The outer wall 30 then may be heated in a furnace to sinter the particles and form the coating 38 on the outer wall 30.
After forming the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32, the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 may be assembled together and attached to the aircraft or spacecraft to which the radome 12 (
With continued reference to 
An end 31 of the outer wall 30 may be disposed adjacent a radially outer surface 55 of the mounting ring 50 and a forward end surface 17 of the fuselage body 16, as shown in 
As previously mentioned, the mounting ring 50 may be similarly attached to the fuselage body 16 using, for example, one or more of an adhesive, bolts, screws, rivets, etc. Complementary features may be provided on the mounting ring 50 and the fuselage body 16 to ensure that the mounting ring 50 is properly positioned with respect to the fuselage body 16 when it is attached thereto. Furthermore, a sealing member 56 (e.g., an O-ring) may be disposed in an annular recess 58 formed on a rearward end surface 57 of the mounting ring 50. The sealing member 56 may be used to provide a hermetic seal between the fuselage body 16 and the mounting ring 50. In this configuration, the mounting ring 50 may be positioned on the fuselage body 16 such that an annular ridge on the rearward end surface 57 of the mounting ring 50 is disposed within the annular recess 58 in an adjacent surface of the fuselage body 16, and the mounting ring 50 may be attached to the fuselage body 16 using, for example, one or more of an adhesive, bolts, screws, rivets, etc.
In some embodiments, the outer wall 30 may be coupled to the inner wall 32 at a forward end 13 of the radome 12. By way of example and not limitation, a nose assembly 70 may be coupled to the inner wall 32 at a forward end 13 of the radome 12, as shown in 
The nose assembly 70 shown in 
The cap 72 is positioned on an exterior surface of the outer wall 30 at the forward end 13 of the radome 12. The cap 72 has a hole 73 that extends at least partially therethrough that is configured to receive the bolt 76 at least partially therein, as shown in 
The insert 74 is disposed between the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 at the forward end 13 of the radome 12. The insert 74 has a generally cylindrical shape, and a hole 75 that is configured to receive the bolt 76 therethrough, extending longitudinally through the insert 74. A forward end of the insert 74 may be substantially cylindrical, and a cylindrical side surface of the insert 74 may have a diameter substantially equal to, but slightly less than, the diameter of the aperture 60 extending through the outer wall 30, such that the substantially cylindrical portion of the insert 74 may be inserted into and received within the aperture 60, as shown in 
A washer 78 may be provided adjacent an inner surface of the inner wall 32 on a side thereof opposite the insert 74. The washer 78 may be used to disperse forces applied to the inner wall 32 by a head 77 of the bolt 76 over a greater surface area of the inner wall 32.
As shown in 
Although not shown in 
Coupling the outer wall 30 to the inner wall 32 at the forward end 13 of the radome 12 may provide additional stability and strength to the radome 12.
Another embodiment of a nose assembly 80 that may be used to couple the outer wall 30 to the inner wall 32 at the forward end 13 of the radome 12 is illustrated in 
As in the nose assembly 70 of 
The cap 82 is positioned on an exterior surface of the outer wall 30 at the forward end 13 of the radome 12. The rod 90 extends from the cap 82, as shown in 
The first insert 84 is disposed between the outer wall 30 and the inner wall 32 at the forward end 13 of the radome 12. The first insert 84 has a generally cylindrical shape, and a hole 85 that is configured to receive the rod 90 therethrough, extending longitudinally through the first insert 84. A side surface of the first insert 84 may have a generally frustoconical shape that is complementary to the frustoconical shape of an adjacent inner surface of the outer wall 30, as shown in 
The second insert 86 is disposed adjacent an inner surface of the inner wall 32 at the forward end 13 of the radome 12. The second insert 86 also has a generally cylindrical shape, and a hole 87 that is configured to receive the rod 90 therethrough, extending longitudinally through the second insert 86. A side surface of the second insert 86 may have a generally frustoconical shape that is complementary to the frustoconical shape of an adjacent inner surface of the inner wall 32, as shown in 
One or more annular grooves may be formed circumferentially about the rod 90 in the cylindrical side surface thereof, and snap rings may be snap-fitted into the annular grooves. For example, a first annular groove 92 may be formed circumferentially about the rod 90 in the cylindrical side surface thereof proximate a rearward surface 88 of the second insert 86, and a first snap ring 94 may be snap-fitted into the first annular groove 92 to hold the second insert 86 (and, additionally, the inner wall 32, first insert 84, and outer wall 30) in position relative to the rod 90 and the cap 82. Optionally, a second annular groove 96 may be formed circumferentially about the rod 90 in the cylindrical side surface thereof proximate a rearward surface 85 of 89 of the first insert 84, and a second snap ring 98 may be snap-fitted into the second annular groove 96 to provide additional support to the first insert 84 (and, additionally, the outer wall 30) for holding the first insert 84 in position relative to the rod 90 and the cap 82.
Washers (not shown in 
Although not shown in 
While the invention may be susceptible to various modifications and alternative forms, specific embodiments have been shown by way of example in the drawings and have been described in detail herein. However, it should be understood that the invention is not intended to be limited to the particular forms disclosed. Rather, the invention is to cover all modifications, equivalents, and alternatives falling within the scope of the invention as defined by the following appended claims and their legal equivalents.
This invention was made with government support under Contract No. N68936-07-C-0007 awarded by the Department of the Navy. The government has certain rights in the invention.
| Number | Name | Date | Kind | 
|---|---|---|---|
| 3292544 | Caldwell et al. | Dec 1966 | A | 
| 3925783 | Bleday et al. | Dec 1975 | A | 
| 4148039 | Lunden | Apr 1979 | A | 
| 4179699 | Lunden | Dec 1979 | A | 
| 4180605 | Gilbert et al. | Dec 1979 | A | 
| 4358772 | Leggett | Nov 1982 | A | 
| 4364884 | Traut | Dec 1982 | A | 
| 4451833 | Traut | May 1984 | A | 
| 4506269 | Greene | Mar 1985 | A | 
| 4520364 | Perry | May 1985 | A | 
| 4615859 | Traut | Oct 1986 | A | 
| 4615933 | Traut | Oct 1986 | A | 
| 4620890 | Myers et al. | Nov 1986 | A | 
| 4659598 | Traut | Apr 1987 | A | 
| 4677443 | Koetje et al. | Jun 1987 | A | 
| 4725475 | Fiscus et al. | Feb 1988 | A | 
| 4797683 | Kosowsky et al. | Jan 1989 | A | 
| 4949095 | Neil et al. | Aug 1990 | A | 
| 4983422 | Davis et al. | Jan 1991 | A | 
| 5129990 | Binnie, Jr. et al. | Jul 1992 | A | 
| 5140338 | Schmier et al. | Aug 1992 | A | 
| 5182155 | Roe | Jan 1993 | A | 
| 5395648 | Davis et al. | Mar 1995 | A | 
| 5400043 | Arceneaux et al. | Mar 1995 | A | 
| 5408244 | Mackenzie | Apr 1995 | A | 
| 5457471 | Epperson, Jr. | Oct 1995 | A | 
| 5569422 | Astier et al. | Oct 1996 | A | 
| 5589115 | Sherwood | Dec 1996 | A | 
| 5600325 | Whelan et al. | Feb 1997 | A | 
| 5650249 | Dull et al. | Jul 1997 | A | 
| 5652631 | Bullen et al. | Jul 1997 | A | 
| 5691736 | Hunn et al. | Nov 1997 | A | 
| 5707723 | Harrison et al. | Jan 1998 | A | 
| 5758845 | Sunne et al. | Jun 1998 | A | 
| 5820077 | Sutliff et al. | Oct 1998 | A | 
| 5849234 | Harrison et al. | Dec 1998 | A | 
| 5884864 | Sunne et al. | Mar 1999 | A | 
| 5958557 | Naor | Sep 1999 | A | 
| 6028565 | Mackenzie et al. | Feb 2000 | A | 
| 6087971 | Clarke et al. | Jul 2000 | A | 
| 6091375 | Goto et al. | Jul 2000 | A | 
| 6094054 | Crist | Jul 2000 | A | 
| 6107976 | Purinton | Aug 2000 | A | 
| 6184842 | Leinweber et al. | Feb 2001 | B1 | 
| 6323825 | Zidek et al. | Nov 2001 | B1 | 
| 6335699 | Honma | Jan 2002 | B1 | 
| 6433753 | Zimmermann | Aug 2002 | B1 | 
| 6476771 | McKinzie, III | Nov 2002 | B1 | 
| 6497776 | Butler et al. | Dec 2002 | B1 | 
| 6518936 | Dull | Feb 2003 | B1 | 
| 6639567 | Chang et al. | Oct 2003 | B2 | 
| 6788273 | Schultz et al. | Sep 2004 | B1 | 
| 6918985 | Geyer | Jul 2005 | B2 | 
| 6975279 | Delgado et al. | Dec 2005 | B2 | 
| 6992640 | Usami et al. | Jan 2006 | B2 | 
| 7006052 | Delgado et al. | Feb 2006 | B2 | 
| 7030834 | Delgado et al. | Apr 2006 | B2 | 
| 7151504 | Boatman et al. | Dec 2006 | B1 | 
| 7420523 | Ziolkowski et al. | Sep 2008 | B1 | 
| 7463212 | Ziolkowski | Dec 2008 | B1 | 
| 7682700 | Sambasivan et al. | Mar 2010 | B2 | 
| 20050024289 | Fredberg et al. | Feb 2005 | A1 | 
| 20060044189 | Livingston et al. | Mar 2006 | A1 | 
| 20080136731 | Wu et al. | Jun 2008 | A1 | 
| 20080186250 | Wolf et al. | Aug 2008 | A1 | 
| 20080316140 | Wu et al. | Dec 2008 | A1 | 
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20110050516 A1 | Mar 2011 | US |