Recoil brake isolation system

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6802406
  • Patent Number
    6,802,406
  • Date Filed
    Tuesday, December 17, 2002
    22 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, October 12, 2004
    20 years ago
  • Inventors
  • Original Assignees
  • Examiners
    • Siconolfi; Robert A.
    • Kramer; Devon
    Agents
    • Patterson, Thuente, Skaar & Christensen, P.A.
Abstract
A recoil brake isolation system for the hydraulic recoil brake cylinder of a large caliber gun, includes two sets of hydraulic valves disposed respectively within the inlet valve block and return valve block of the hydraulic cylinder, an orchestrated combination of which together block the flow of hydraulic fluid to or from the hydraulic cylinder during the recoil/counterrecoil cycle or upon failure of the hydraulic circuit. A method of hydraulically isolating a recoil brake cylinder of a large caliber gun for survivability and improved weapon performance and a gun incorporating such a system are also included.
Description




GOVERNMENT INTEREST




The invention described herein may be manufactured, used and licensed by or for the United States Government.




TECHNICAL FIELD




The present invention relates to artillery. More particularly, the present invention relates to a valve system for improving the survivability of a large caliber gun by isolating the hydraulic recoil system from the hydraulic power components during the recoil/counterrecoil cycle and preserving the hydraulic fluid in the recoil system upon failure of any, of the hydraulic supply or return components.




BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION




The current trend in the military is for deployable lightweight units which provide comparable lethality and effectiveness as provided by multiple traditional heavier units. This trend particularly applies to artillery which benefits from advances in munitions and automatic loading schemes. For example, currently used 155 mm self-propelled howitzers have a maximum rate of fire of four rounds a minute for up to three minutes. In order to reduce the total deployed units, there is a need then for a single weapon with a rate of fire two to three times that of current units. The drawback to this approach is that a single component failure on the weapon could shut down the equivalent of an entire artillery battery.




There is a need then to ensure that the new artillery unit can withstand the increased operational demands. The weapon must be more reliable while maintaining high fire rates. In order to achieve the required firing rates, a number of subsystems within the weapon must evolve to withstand increased service demands. The sustained rate of fire creates extremely high temperatures within the barrel and the recoil system. Conventional large caliber guns utilize an integral sealed recoil brake in which a piston coupled to the barrel forces a fluid through a set of metering orifices during the recoil movement. As the firing rate increases so does the temperature of the fluid. Eventually the fluid reaches a thermal limit and the gun must stop firing.




There is a need then for a survivable cooled recoil system. A typical cooling system, utilizing a combination of pumps, filters and a heat exchanger, increases the complexity of the recoil system. The gun must be able to continue operating should one of these systems fail due to mechanical or operational reasons. Furthermore, a recoil brake for a large caliber gun generates hydraulic pressures as high as 6500 psi, vacuum conditions, pressure spikes, and reversals of flow all induced by the action of the recoil piston. A hydraulic fluid cooling system subject to such extreme operating conditions would be cost and size prohibitive.




There is a need then to provide a hydraulic recoil system for a large caliber gun that is capable of maintaining high rates of sustained fire. The recoil system should be cooled so as to maintain the high sustained fire volumes. The recoil system should be survivable so that the weapon does not become useless should a thermal control component fail or suffer damage. Further, the recoil system should not hinder deployability of the weapon by excessively increasing weight or size.




SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION




The recoil brake isolation system of the present invention substantially meets the aforementioned needs. The system uses two sets of valves to control fluid flow for use with any piston style hydraulic recoil brake requiring active cooling due to high rates of fire. One set of valves is disposed along the hydraulic fluid supply line for the recoil system while the other set of valves is disposed on the return line. Valve activation occurs due to changes in hydraulic pressure as experienced by individual valves. The system does not require any wiring, software or electrical controls. The present invention relates to the arrangement, orchestration and functioning of the valves during the various modes of recoil, counterrecoil, and subsystem failure.




During normal operations, the valves allow the fluid within the recoil brake to be circulated through the thermal dissipation system (TDS). Upon firing, the recoil/counterrecoil mode is automatically activated so that the valves protect the heat exchanger and fluid circulating equipment from pressure spikes, vacuum, high pressure conditions and reversal of flow. In the event of a subsystem failure, such as the loss of a supply line, the valves revert to a sealed mode system so as to minimize fluid loss and prevent ingestion of air by the recoil system. This allows continued operation of the weapon until thermal limits are reached. The system can return to operation after cooling below the thermal threshold.




The present invention is a recoil brake isolation system, adaptable to any large caliber artillery piece using a piston style hydraulic recoil system, which incorporates an arrangement of valves to control fluid flow within the recoil system so as to maintain high rates of sustained fire under normal firing situations and an isolation mode which allows for continued use if the thermal system is damaged or fails. The present invention is further a method of configuring a valve system so as to minimize weight and maximize survivability of a large caliber artillery piece.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS





FIG. 1

is a perspective view of the gun with the turret area of a self-propelled howitzer in phantom with the gun mount system and thermal dissipation system highlighted.





FIG. 2

is a front perspective view of the gun mount system for a self-propelled howitzer.





FIG. 3

is a side perspective view of the components of the thermal dissipation system for the recoil modules and cannon cooling system.





FIG. 4

is a schematic representation of the recoil brake isolation system including the recoil brake and hydraulic system.





FIG. 5

is a perspective view of a recoil module with cut out section in which the return valve block and piston head are exposed.





FIG. 6

is a block diagram representation of the gun cooling system and recoil cooling system for a self-propelled howitzer.





FIG. 7

is a perspective view of the return valve block with the fluid circuit represented in phantom.





FIG. 8

is a perspective view of the inlet valve block with a cutout which depicts the fluid circuit with excess flow valve and check valve.











DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION




The recoil brake isolation system of the present invention is located within the recoil system


20


of a self-propelled howitzer. Any large caliber weapon, whether mounted on a vehicle platform such as a tank or self-propelled howitzer, or towed, in which sustained high rates of fire are planned, could utilize the present invention. Maintaining a high fire rate requires active cooling for the recoil system


20


. In a first embodiment, the present invention is included on a self-propelled howitzer.




Referring now to

FIG. 1

, the liquid cooled cannon


14


and recoil system


20


are contained within the gun mount


40


and are fluidly connected to the thermal dissipation system (TDS)


30


. The TDS


30


operates to cool both the recoil system


20


and the cannon cooling system


15


. In order to reduce the weight of the vehicle, and allow access for servicing and removal, the TDS


30


is not afforded the same level of armor protection as the adjacent recoil system


20


and cannon


14


. Should the TDS


30


be damaged by enemy fire or fail due to a component malfunction, the recoil brake isolation system


10


, as is illustrated in

FIG. 4

, allows for continued firing.




The gun mount


40


, depicted in greater detail in

FIG. 2

, is comprised of the cannon cooling system


15


, a pair of recoil modules


22


, and a pair of recuperator modules


24


, all installed within the gun cradle


25


. The recuperator module


24


is used to control the position of the gun after recoil in preparation for the next firing. The gun mount


40


is rotationally elevatable about trunion


28


. An armored shield assembly


26


is mounted above and below the cradle


25


. Note that the recoil module


22


and recuperator module


24


are mounted as pairs in alternating order on each side of cannon


14


so as to counteract the dynamic torque created during recoil/counterrecoil.




The TDS


30


, as depicted in

FIG. 6

, contains two separate cooling circuits utilizing a common cooling fan


31


and heat exchanger


33


. The recoil system


20


is cooled through the circulation of a silicone brake fluid manufactured pursuant to Military Specification MIL-B-46176 or MWL-PRF46176, although any comparable fluid would be acceptable. The cannon cooling system


15


dissipates heat through the circulation of an antifreeze solution, the composition of which is well known in the art.




Referring to

FIG. 3

, hydraulic fluid leaving the recoil module


22


flows to heat exchanger


33


which is fluidly connected to the recoil reservoir


32


. Air inlet


34


is disposed proximate to the base of the TDS


30


along the slanting outer sidewall of the howitzer


12


, and provides the air required to cool the heat exchanger


33


. The hot exhaust from the heat exchanger


33


is blown by cooling fan


31


through an exhaust vent


42


mounted on top of the howitzer


12


. Pressurized hydraulic fluid from recoil coolant pump


35


is controllably directed to the recoil relief valve


39


which maintains a predetermined fluid compression. The pressurized fluid is then controllably directed through a filter


41


before reentering recoil module


22


. Likewise, the TDS


30


cooling circuit for the gun


14


utilizes the same heat exchanger


33


and cooling fan


31


and comparable pump


36


and reservoir


38


but provides thermal dissipation by circulating the antifreeze solution.




The present invention isolates the entire TDS


30


during recoil and counterrecoil and, if any component of the TDS


30


fails, the present invention will maintain the isolated mode so as to conserve the hydraulic fluid within the recoil module


20


. The recoil brake isolation system


10


also prevents ingestion of air, potentially a catastrophic failure, should a return or supply line fail. In the event of component failure or damage by an enemy, the recoil brake isolation system allows for continued firing, at a reduced rate of fire comparable to that of a howitzer without active cooling.




An added advantage produced by the recoil brake isolation system


10


is a reduction in the TDS


30


design requirements. The recoil brake isolation system


10


effectively blocks the flow of hydraulic fluid from the TDS


30


thereby eliminating the design requirements of operating with high pressures (on the order of 6500 psi), vacuum, pressure spikes and reversal of flow. In the preferred embodiment, the TDS


30


is sized to withstand pressures of 400 psi. The lower pressure requirements result in smaller components, less weight and less cost for the TDS


30


. Note that the internal valve components of the recoil module


22


must be sized for the higher pressure requirements.




The recoil brake isolation system is comprised of the supply line isolation system


54


and the return line isolation system


59


. Referring to

FIG. 6

, the hydraulic power unit


47


of TDS


30


, which contains pump


35


, reservoir


32


, relief valve


39


, and filter


41


is fluidly connected to recoil module


22


by way of hydraulic fluid supply line


44


and hydraulic fluid return line


46


. Hydraulic fluid supply line


44


is fluidly connected to inlet supply valve block


50


in which the supply line isolation system


54


is disposed and hydraulic fluid return line


46


is fluidly connected to return valve block


52


in which the return line isolation system


59


is located. See FIG.


5


.




As depicted in

FIGS. 4 and 5

, the supply line isolation system


54


, disposed within inlet supply valve block


50


, is comprised of an excess flow valve


56


and a normally closed check valve


58


. A similar valve arrangement exists for the return line isolation system


59


disposed within the return valve block


52


, comprising a mechanically operated two position, two port control valve


66


, a normally closed pilot operated check valve


67


and a normally closed check valve


68


. The placement of the supply line isolation system


54


and return line isolation system


59


within the manifold blocks


50


and


52


advantageously removes unnecessary hydraulic lines from the fluid circuit thus reducing potential leakage points, reducing system size, and consolidating the system for repair/diagnostics.




The valves


56


,


58


,


66


,


67


and


68


themselves are readily available cartridge style valves which fit within cavities appropriately sized within the respective valve blocks


50


and


52


. See

FIGS. 7 and 8

. Mounting and retention of valves


56


,


58


,


66


,


67


and


68


may be accomplished through the use of an expanding sleeve, external threads or with an external holding device. For this embodiment, the valves


56


,


58


,


66


,


67


and


68


operate in a temperature regime of −51F to +400F. The entire recoil module


22


can be fluidly disconnected by way of quick disconnect couplings


69


and


69


′ for servicing or replacement.




In

FIG. 5

, inlet supply valve block


50


is an annular metal flange through which piston rod


61


extends and freely travels. Piston rod


61


is anchored on one end to the gun barrel


14


in a manner well known to those in the art so that the piston rod


61


moves with gun


14


during recoil. A piston head


62


, slidably arranged, disposed within and dimensioned closely to the inner diameter of the inner sleeve


65


of recoil chamber


63


is attached to the opposite end of piston rod


61


. Inlet supply valve block


50


seals recoil chamber


63


on one end while return valve block


52


provides the seal at the opposing end.




In operation, firing of the howitzer results in a barrel


14


recoiling to the right (see

FIG. 5

) which forces the piston


61


to also travel to the right through recoil chamber


63


. The recoil chamber


63


contains a perforated orifice sleeve


65


closely dimensioned to the diameter of the piston head


62


. The inner sleeve


65


contains rows of perforations


70


which decrease in size from left to right. Therefore, the piston head


62


moves to the right with the recoil forcing hydraulic fluid within recoil chamber


63


through the perforations


70


. The piston


61


slows as resistance and pressure increases ahead of the piston head


62


due to the reduction in size and number of the perforations


70


. The hydraulic fluid forced through the perforations


70


travels between inner sleeve


65


and the inner face of recoil chamber


63


and is collected on the vacuum side of the piston head


62


. While the recoil module


20


halts the rearward progress of the barrel


14


, the recuperator


24


, upon completion of the recoil cycle, progressively moves the barrel


14


back to the firing position.




The recoil brake isolation system


10


is activated under normal conditions by the operation of TDS pump


35


. Upon sensing a return to a static state, the recoil brake isolation system


10


allows circulation when pump


35


produces sufficient pressure in the system to open check valve


58


.




Referring to

FIG. 4

, supply hydraulic fluid first passes through the excess flow valve


56


on its way to the recoil module


22


. In fluid communication with the excess flow valve


56


is check valve


58


which performs three functions. The check valve


58


is normally in a closed or blocked position. Check valve


58


is sized with a cracking pressure sufficiently high enough to close immediately if the supply pressure drops to atmospheric, as when the supply line is severed. The check valve


58


prevents fluid from leaving recoil chamber


63


and also prevents ingestion of air during counterrecoil. Check valve


58


opens due to the force exerted by pump


35


during normal cooling. When pump


35


turns off, line pressure decreases and check valve


58


reseats to a block position.




Excess flow valve


56


is also commonly referred to as a velocity valve, a line rupture valve, or a flow fuse. Excess flow valve


56


closes during counterrecoil to prevent an in-rush of fluid into the recoil module


22


since check valve


58


will be open. A vacuum condition downstream of valve


56


induces flow in excess of the valves operating requirements. This closure prevents excess fluid levels in the recoil chamber which would prevent the recoiling mass from regaining pre-fire positioning.




The return valve block


52


, disposed proximate the end of recoil chamber


63


, contains a check valve


68


, a pilot operated check valve


67


and a mechanically operated two position, two port, cartridge style directional control valve


66


. Return valve block


52


, cylindrical in shape, forms a barrier between the recoil chamber


63


and the replenisher


75


. A counterrecoil buffer


72


extends axially from the center of return valve block


52


into the recoil chamber


63


. Piston head


62


contains a recessed central region sized so as to accommodate counterrecoil buffer


72


when the gun


14


is in battery.




Check valve


68


, which acts as a relief valve, is normally in a closed position. It forms a bubble tight seal if return line


46


becomes severed, thus preventing loss of fluid or ingestion of air. The cracking pressure of check valve


68


is set above the maximum spring induced replenisher pressure. Check valve


68


is only open during normal cooling when the TDS pump


35


is operating. Check valve


68


reseats when pump


35


is turned off.




Disposed upstream from check valve


68


is pilot operated check valve


67


. The main purpose of pilot operated check valve


67


is to close during the last few inches of the counterrecoil cycle when directional control valve


66


is activated but piston head


62


is still moving. The pilot port


64


is disposed approximately four inches from the piston head's


62


in battery position. During the end of counterrecoil the pressure at pilot port


64


will be at a vacuum thus closing valve


67


.




When counterrecoil is complete, the piston head


62


will activate the mechanically operated two position, two-port directional control valve


66


. While in battery, valve


66


allows circulation for cooling. The two way, two port directional control valve


66


is disposed immediately upstream from the pilot operated check valve


67


. Its mechanical plunger extends into the recoil chamber


63


. Due to the stroke distance of the plunger, which transitions valve


66


from open to closed, a time delay exists thus necessitating pilot operated check valve


67


.




In the event that the supply line


44


is compromised due to TDS


30


failure or damage from an opposing force, the present invention must minimize the loss of hydraulic fluid and prevent the ingestion of air into the recoil module


22


. Upon loss of the supply line


44


, the inlet check valve


58


will immediately record the pressure drop which will allow the spring within the check valve


58


to block that line. Inlet check valve


58


will remain closed until repairs have been made. When the supply line


44


fails there is no longer any circulation during the static mode of the recoil cycle so outlet check valve


68


also remains closed.




In the event of a return line


46


failure, commencement of the isolation mode is dependent on whether or not the recoil coolant pump


35


is circulating fluid through the recoil module


22


at the moment of failure. As described above, the return line isolation system


59


blocks fluid flow to the TDS


30


during recoil and counter recoil. However, circulation does occur for cooling during the static mode when the pump


35


is activated. In a worst case scenario, if return line


46


is compromised while in a static mode with pump


35


running, hydraulic fluid will be lost until pump


35


runs dry and a pressure drop occurs in recoil chamber


63


resulting in check valve


66


closing. It may require up to 30 seconds for pump


35


to run dry. Check valve


68


will then remain closed until replacement or repairs are effectuated to the system. If return line


46


is compromised when the pump


35


is off, check valve


68


will already be blocking hydraulic fluid flow.




Although an embodiment of the invention has been illustrated in the accompanying drawings and described in the foregoing specification, it is especially understood that various changes such as in the relative dimensions of parts and materials used, modifications and adaptation, and the same are intended to be comprehended within the meaning and range of equivalent to the claims.



Claims
  • 1. A recoil brake isolation system disposed within a recoil chamber, said recoil chamber fluidly connected to a hydraulic brake fluid circulation system which includes a hydraulic pump, a heat exchanger, a reservoir, a plurality of filters, an inlet supply line and an outlet supply line, the hydraulic brake fluid circulation system providing a thermally conditioned hydraulic fluid to the recoil chamber, the recoil brake isolation system comprising:an inlet isolation valve system and an outlet isolation valve system so as to selectively isolate the recoil chamber from a the hydraulic brake fluid circulation system.
  • 2. The recoil brake isolation system of claim 1 in which the inlet isolation valve system and outlet isolation valve system allow fluid circulation to the hydraulic brake fluid circulation system only during static conditions within the recoil chamber and while the hydraulic pump is operating.
  • 3. The recoil brake isolation system of claim 1 wherein the inlet isolation valve system selectively blocks the flow of hydraulic fluid to and from the recoil chamber and prevents an ingestion of air.
  • 4. The recoil brake isolation system of claim 3 wherein the inlet isolation valve system includes a plurality of valves mounted in series immediately upstream from the recoil chamber.
  • 5. The recoil brake isolation system of claim 4 wherein the plurality of valves are fluidly triggered upon recognizing pressure differentials within the recoil chamber and upstream of the recoil chamber.
  • 6. The recoil brake isolation system of claim 1 wherein the outlet isolation valve system selectively blocks the flow of hydraulic fluid to and from the recoil chamber and prevents an ingestion of air.
  • 7. The recoil brake isolation system of claim 6 wherein the outlet isolation valve system includes a plurality of valves mounted in series immediately downstream from the recoil chamber.
  • 8. The recoil brake isolation system of claim 7 wherein the plurality of valves are fluidly triggered upon recognizing pressure differentials within the recoil chamber and downstream of the recoil chamber.
  • 9. A gun comprising a recoilable barrel mechanically connected to a recoil brake, said recoil brake including a recoil brake isolation system for the selective fluid connection of the recoil brake with a hydraulic brake fluid circulation system, the recoil brake isolation system including:inlet flow control means for selectively allowing a hydraulic fluid to pass through an inlet valve block of the recoil brake; and outlet flow control means for selectively allowing the hydraulic fluid to pass through an outlet valve block of the recoil brake.
  • 10. The gun of claim 9 wherein the inlet flow control means includes at least one valve triggered by flow and pressure conditions upstream from the recoil brake.
  • 11. The gun of claim 9 wherein the inlet flow control means includes at least one valve triggered by flow and pressure conditions within the recoil brake.
  • 12. The gun of claim 9 wherein the outlet flow control means includes at least one valve triggered by flow and pressure conditions downstream from a recoil chamber of the recoil brake.
  • 13. The gun of claim 9 wherein the outlet flow control means includes at least one valve triggered by flow and pressure within the recoil brake.
  • 14. The gun of claim 9 wherein the outlet flow control means and the inlet flow control means prevent ingestion of air into the recoil brake.
  • 15. The gun of claim 9 wherein the inlet flow control means and the outlet flow control means allow fluid circulation to the recoil brake only during static conditions within the recoil brake and while the hydraulic brake fluid circulation system is operating.
  • 16. A method of operating a recoil brake isolation system in fluid communication with a recoil brake cylinder and a fluidly connected hydraulic brake fluid circulation system, the method comprising:monitoring flow conditions within the hydraulic brake fluid circulation system with a plurality of fluid control isolation valves disposed within the recoil brake cylinder; monitoring flow conditions within the recoil brake cylinder; blocking flow to and from the recoil brake cylinder when said monitoring indicates an improper flow condition; and opening flow to and from the recoil brake cylinder when said monitoring indicates a proper flow condition.
  • 17. The method of claim 16 wherein a first set of said plurality of fluid control valves are inserted immediately upstream of the recoil brake cylinder and a second set of said plurality of fluid control valves are inserted immediately downstream of the recoil brake cylinder.
  • 18. The method of claim 16 wherein said improper flow condition within the recoil brake cylinder occurs due to movement of a piston disposed within the recoil brake cylinder.
  • 19. The method of claim 16 wherein said improper flow condition within the recoil brake cylinder and hydraulic brake fluid circulation system arises due to an interruption in fluid flow to the recoil brake cylinder.
  • 20. The method of claim 16 wherein said improper flow condition within the recoil brake cylinder and hydraulic brake fluid circulation system arises due to an interruption in fluid flow from the recoil brake cylinder.
  • 21. The method of claim 16 wherein said proper flow condition occurs within the recoil brake cylinder and hydraulic brake fluid circulation system when a piston disposed within the recoil brake cylinder is in a static position and the hydraulic brake fluid circulation system is operating.
  • 22. A gun, including:a barrel arranged to execute a recoil and a counterrecoil after a shot is fired; a recoil brake cylinder containing an operative fluid; a piston received in said recoil brake cylinder and secured at least indirectly to said barrel to move as a unit with during recoil and counterrecoil, said piston comprising a piston head and a piston rod, said piston head axially slidably received in said recoil brake cylinder and being secured to said piston rod for axial movement; a hydraulic power unit for transmission of fluid under pressure to said recoil brake cylinder; a hydraulic brake fluid circulation system conveying said fluid to and from said recoil brake cylinder; and an inlet isolation valve system and an outlet isolation valve system disposed so as to selectively isolate the recoil brake cylinder from said hydraulic brake fluid circulation system.
  • 23. The gun of claim 22 wherein the hydraulic brake fluid circulation system supplies a thermally conditioned hydraulic fluid to the recoil brake cylinder.
  • 24. The gun of claim 23 wherein the hydraulic brake fluid circulation system includes a hydraulic pump, a heat exchanger, a reservoir, a plurality of filters, an inlet supply line and an outlet supply line.
  • 25. The gun of claim 24 in which the inlet isolation valve system and outlet isolation valve system allow fluid circulation to the hydraulic brake fluid circulation system only during static conditions within the recoil brake cylinder and while the hydraulic pump is operating.
  • 26. The gun of claim 22 wherein the inlet isolation valve system selectively blocks the flow of hydraulic fluid to and from the recoil brake cylinder and prevents an ingestion of air.
  • 27. The gun of claim 26 wherein the inlet isolation valve system includes a plurality of valves mounted in series immediately upstream from the recoil brake cylinder.
  • 28. The gun of claim 27 further comprising an inlet supply line and wherein the plurality of valves are fluidly triggered by pressure differentials within the recoil brake cylinder and the inlet supply line.
  • 29. The gun of claim 22 wherein the outlet isolation valve system selectively blocks the flow of hydraulic fluid to and from the recoil brake cylinder and prevents an ingestion of air.
  • 30. The gun of claim 29 wherein the outlet isolation valve system includes a plurality of valves mounted in series immediately downstream from the recoil brake cylinder.
  • 31. gun of claim 30 further comprising an outlet supply line and wherein the plurality of valves are fluidly triggered by pressure differentials within the recoil brake cylinder and the outlet supply line.
US Referenced Citations (14)
Number Name Date Kind
3964365 Zielinski Jun 1976 A
3991650 Garland et al. Nov 1976 A
4088059 Hayner May 1978 A
4587882 Metz May 1986 A
4591342 Lipp May 1986 A
4656921 Zierler Apr 1987 A
4757960 Paris et al. Jul 1988 A
4867038 Metz Sep 1989 A
4875402 Metz Oct 1989 A
4955281 Metz et al. Sep 1990 A
H001010 Kasten et al. Jan 1992 H
5168120 Rossel Dec 1992 A
5555919 Lipp Sep 1996 A
6625983 Kawasaki Sep 2003 B2
Foreign Referenced Citations (1)
Number Date Country
0491106 Mar 1995 EP