Patent Application
20070031458
Gram-negative enteric pathogens are the cause of a variety of diseases presenting with a broad spectrum of symptoms ranging from mild watery diarrhea to severe life-threatening symptoms such as fever, bloody diarrhea, perforation or ulceration of the stomach or intestine, alone or in combination. Examples of such diseases include, but are not limited to, typhoid fever, shigeliosis, cholera, infections with enterotoxigenic, enteropathogenic, and enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli, and infections with Helicobacter pylori and Campylobacter jejuni.
The first step of the infectious process of enteric pathogens occurs at the mucosal surface within the digestive tract. Thus, interfering with this initial stage of infection prior to the onset of symptoms offers a particularly attractive approach for providing protection against enteric diseases. The most effective means by which to accomplish this would be to evoke a local protective immune response through the use of an orally administered vaccine (Walker, 1994). At present, two live oral attenuated vaccines against enteric disease have been licensed for human use, namely the Ty21a strain of Salmonella typhi for the prevention of typhoid fever and the CVD 103-HgR strain of Vibrio cholerae for the prevention of cholera (Germanier and Fürer, 1975; Levine et al., 1988).
An effective protection against the enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli (ETEC) would be of particular medical interest. ETEC is one of the major causes of traveler's diarrhea and diarrhea among children in the developing countries and accounts for more than 1 billion diarrhea episodes and at least one million deaths per year, primarily among children.
ETEC isolates that cause diarrhea have several virulence factors that play important roles in the disease process. They include two enterotoxins, heat-labile toxin (LT) and heat-stable toxin (ST), as well as bacterial surface adhesins called pili or fimbriae which allow the organism to colonize the intestinal tract. Either one of the toxins can cause diarrhea. Some clinical ETEC isolates have been shown to produce either LT or ST, while other isolates have both toxins.
The most practical approach for the prevention of the widespread morbidity and mortality caused by diarrheal disease due to intestinal contamination with ETEC strains of E. coli would be by means of vaccination. The following three different types of E. coli antigen have been shown to be effective as immunogens which provide protection against challenge with ETEC strains in experimental models.
In addition to the above-mentioned E. coli immunogenic antigens, there is evidence that the B subunit of cholera toxin (CT-B) from Vibrio cholerae is also protective against ETEC strains expressing LT. This phenomenon may be explained by the similarity of CT-B and LT both in structure and in mode of action. Accordingly, cholera vaccines which include CT-B may be protective against ETEC diarrhea caused by ETEC isolates producing LT (Clemens et al., 1988). For example, Qadri et al. have recently shown that an oral vaccine containing a mixture of different ETEC pili antigens in combination with recombinantly produced cholera toxin B subunit (CT-B) is effective in children. In this phase II study carried out in Bangladesh, an oral vaccine comprising formalin-inactivated ETECs containing a total of six different surface antigens (CS 1-5 and CFA/I) were administered to children in combination with recombinant CT-B (Qadri et al, 2003). However, due to the use of killed cells, the level of immunogenicity afforded by this vaccine may not be optimal. As a consequence, two doses of the vaccine are necessary and the immunity may not be long-lasting. In contrast, live cells are thought to be more immunogenic, as they would more closely mimic a natural infection, also providing a longer-lasting immunity after only one dose (Levine and Kaper, 1993). Besides the fact that the inclusion of a purified toxin component raises the complexity and thus the cost of the vaccine, these considerations make it apparent that a live vaccine may be economically more viable.
An improvement with respect to this strategy would consist in delivering toxin-producing, pili-expressing live cells to the intestinal mucosa. Such a vaccine may be more efficiently sampled by the immune system due to its ability to penetrate the mucus layer overlaying the gut epithelium and adhere to the gut enterocytes. In turn, uptake by these and other specialized cells such as M cells with subsequent processing by antigen presenting cells would guarantee an optimal induction of a highly effective and specific mucosal immune response.
The induction of a local intestinal immune response may be the most efficient means by which to prevent infection with a number of enteric pathogens, including ETEC. A proven and effective method by which to accomplish this is through the use of live oral attenuated vaccine strains. Attenuated vaccine strains such as the above-mentioned Salmonella typhi Ty21a and Vibrio cholerae CVD 103-HgR elicit an abortive infectious process thereby inducing an immune response closely resembling that effected by natural infection. In addition, V. cholerae CVD 103-HgR has been shown to efficiently express a variety of foreign antigens in immunogenic form, among which the O-polysaccharide from Shigella sonnei and V. cholerae 0139, as well as shiga-like toxin Ib (Acheson et al 1993). Rabbits immunized with these constructs elicited significant antibodies directed against the heterologous antigen. Further, WO 94/19482 discloses a genetically engineered V. cholerae chromosome containing a heterologous DNA sequence encoding a bacterial antigen, wherein the DNA sequence is functionally linked to a naturally occurring V. cholerae promoter.
Both Salmonella typhi Ty21a and Vibrio cholerae CVD 103-HgR possess the distinct advantage of being approved as being extremely safe in humans (Dietrich et al, 2003). Safety, however, has been found to be the most difficult attribute to achieve in the development of live oral vaccine strains. Most often, candidate vaccine strains either induce a protective immune response but with an unacceptable rate of adverse reactions or are safe but non-protective (Levine and Hone, 1991).
In earlier studies, pili of ETEC have been expressed in the Shigella flexneri 2a and Salmonella typhimurium vaccine strains (Altboum et al. 2001; Wu et al. 1995). However, these approaches suffer from the fact that the type of immunity elicited by these strains is quite different than that elicited by ETEC. This is primarily due to the infection mechanism of these strains. Whereas Shigella and Salmonella are invasive organisms that cross the gut epithelium and infect cells of the immune system, ETECs are non-invasive. The efficacy of these vaccine strains as ETEC vaccines may therefore be limited, since the presentation of the ETEC antigen(s) to the immune system would not mimic that existing in nature. In this respect, expression from a vaccine strain with virulence characteristics similar to those of ETECs would be highly advantageous.
ETEC itself has also been recently used as carrier for homologous and heterologous pili. However, although immunogenic, these strains present various problems. The pilis can only be efficiently produced in solid CF medium at a temperature of about 37° C. Furthermore, ETEC cells are known to be released by infected people for extended periods of time. Finally, the risk exists of stably acquiring an ETEC plasmid carrying the wild type LT and/or ST toxin genes by conjugation, thereby producing a virulent strain out of a vaccine strain.
According to WO 03/022306, coil surface (CS) antigens may be expressed in ETEC strains. It is not clear, however, whether sufficient surface expression may be achieved.
The technical problem underlying the present invention is to develop a safe vaccine suitable to elicit an efficient immune response to a variety of ETEC isolates in human.
According to the present invention, this problem is solved by the provision of a recombinant Vibrio cholerae vaccine strain comprising DNA sequences coding for at least the ETEC pili CFA/I, CS3 and CS6, wherein the DNA sequences are operationally (functionally) linked to one or more promoters.
Since the virulence characteristics of wild-type V. cholerae are very similar to those of wild-type ETEC, the above-mentioned problems associated with the use of vaccine strains such as Shigella and Salmonella for the expression of ETEC adhesins are overcome by the recombinant V. cholerae strain according to the present invention. Both V. cholerae and ETEC colonize the small intestine without crossing the gut epithelium and secrete powerful toxins which mediate disease by causing net secretion into the intestinal lumen. The cholera toxin (CT) and the ETEC toxin (LT) share a homology of about 83% on the amino acid level and have an identical AB5 structure. Most importantly, both pathogens elicit an immune response in a similar way. They are sampled by the immune system via the M cells of the Peyer's patches and elicit a local intestinal immune response through mucosal sIgA which can clear subsequent infection by immune exclusion.
The term “DNA sequence” refers to a nucleic acid sequence encoding the primary sequence of a protein. The term “ETEC pilus” as used herein refers to a polypeptide consisting essentially of, and having a similar immunological activity as the polypeptides listed in table 1. The immunological activity may be determined by parenteral immunization of mice and is considered as being “similar” if the subsequent detection of specific anti-pili antibodies in an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) provides a significant titer. A significant ELISA titer is defined as being equal or superior to twice the reciprocal of the background ELISA titer.
The definition of “ETEC pilus” intended to encompass polypeptides comprising natural allelic variations, orthologs, artificially constructed variants, and derivatives of the pili listed in table 1. The term “ortholog” refers to a polypeptide from another species that corresponds to the human ETEC polypeptides as listed below. The term “variant” refers to a polypeptide comprising one or more amino acid substitution(s), deletion(s) and/or addition(s) as compared to the polypeptides as set forth in table 1. The term “derivative” refers to polypeptide allelic or artificially constructed variants and orthologs, as defined herein, that have been chemically modified.
aIn parentheses: previous denomination
In humans, 21 different pili types have been described (see table 1 above), some of which occur together in the same organism. One pilus type, coli surface antigen 3 (CS3), is detected in 23% of ETEC isolates and occurs either alone or in combination with CS1 or CS2. CS6, detected in 21% of ETEC isolates, occurs either alone or in combination with CS4 or CS5. Colonization factor I (CFA/I) occurs alone in about one third of all ETEC isolates. These data are consistent with the idea that a potential vaccine comprising CFA/I, CS3 and CS6 may provide protection against a maximum of about 75% of all ETEC cases.
The V. cholerae strain according to the present invention may comprise further DNA sequence(s) encoding ETEC pili. In a preferred embodiment, the DNA sequence comprised in the V. cholerae strain according to the invention is selected from the group consisting of the sequences encoding the 21 pili described in table 1. Up to nine additional sequences coding for an ETEC pilus may be contained. Preferably, the strain of the invention comprises at least one further DNA sequence. More preferably, at least two or three further sequences are comprised. Optionally, pili from other pathogenic E. coli such as EaggEC (AAF/I pili), EHEC, EPEC (BFP, AF/R1), or veterinary ETEC (K88, K99, 987P), as well as from other bacteria may be included.
In a preferred embodiment, expression of the ETEC pili is driven by one or more ETEC promoter(s) (e.g. by the promoter naturally occuring in respective operon). Alternatively, an ETEC promoter from an heterologous pili operon, or promoter(s) from a source other than ETEC may be used (e.g. the lambda phage PL promoters [Schauder B et al., 1987] or the Ptrc promoter [Amann E et al., 1988]),
Genetically, the formation of CFA/I, CS3 and CS6 pili is encoded in operons comprising 4-7 genes each. Thus, in a preferred embodiment, the DNA sequence encoding the ETEC pilus comprises the entire operon.
In addition, the expression of many pili is up-regulated through the translational product of an additional gene which is encoded by a DNA sequence lying outside the respective operon. They are cfaD for CFA/I, ms for CS1 and CS2, and csvR and csfR for CS4. These regulatory genes show homology at the DNA level and were found to be functionally interchangeable (table 2).
In contrast to the expression of CFA/I, CS1, CS2 and CS4 in ETEC, which is enhanced by a regulator, expression of CS3 and CS6 is not enhanced in ETEC cells (Caron et al, 1990). That is, CS3 and CS6 expression obviously occurs independently from any regulation in their natural ETEC host CFA/I expression is up-regulated by the cfaD gene product in ETEC. However, heterologous expression of CFA/I carried on a plasmid is known to occur without the need of a regulator in a foreign host such as a laboratory E. coli strain and Salmonella typhimurium (Wu et al. 1995).
Surprisingly in view of the above, the present authors found that expression of CFA/I and CS3 pili in a V. cholerae recipient strain was very poor even under the media and temperature conditions of growth that are normally known to lead to optimal pili synthesis. In contrast, the expression of CS6 pili was as good as in the ETEC wild-type strain B7A and thus considered satisfactory.
In order to improve the heterologous expression of CFA/I and CS3 in V. cholerae, expression of the CFA/I, CS3, and CS6 pili in the presence of the ETEC regulators was analyzed. For that purpose, the gene for either the CsfR or the Rns regulator was chromosomally integrated in strains carrying either the CFA/I or the CS3 locus. Expression of the ETEC regulator resulted in an increased expression of the structural pili proteins which translated into the surface formation of pili (which could be detected by various means including electron microscopy). Both CS3 and CFA/I expression was highly increased by either CsfR or Rns (see example 7 and 9). This was surprising since these operons are not supposed to be regulated inside ETEC or in a foreign host, respectively (see above). The expression of CS6 pilus was not increased by any of the regulators.
In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, expression of the ETEC pili is therefore enhanced by at least one ETEC regulator. The regulator may be selected from the group consisting of CsfR, Rns, CfaD, CsvR and AggR. In one embodiment of the present invention the regulator is CsfR. In another embodiment of the present invention the regulator is Rns.
The term “regulator” refers to the translational product (polypeptide) encoded by any of the genes listed in table 2, as well as naturally occurring variations, orthologs, artificially constructed variants, and derivatives thereof.
In one embodiment of the present invention a recombinant V. cholerae strain is obtained by introducing the DNA sequences into a recipient strain selected from the group consisting of CVD 103-HgR, CVD111, CVD112 and Peru-15. CVD 103-HgR or an equivalent strain is particularly preferred. Like CVD 103-HgR, equivalent strains show inactivation of the ctxA gene. Inactivation may preferably be achieved by deletion.
The term “recipient strain” refers to the strain which has been transformed, or is capable of being transformed with a DNA sequence and then of expressing a selected gene of interest. The progeny of said strain containing the selected DNA sequence is referred to as the recombinant strain. The term “parent strain” refers to the strain upstream of any given strain in the respective strain history.
CVD 103-HgR is a live oral attenuated V. cholerae vaccine strain which originates from V. cholerae classical Inaba strain 569B and which has 94% of the ctxA DNA sequence deleted but still expresses the immunogenic B subunit of CT (Ketley et al., 1993). As stressed above, expression of the ETEC adhesins from a live oral attenuated V. cholerae vaccine strain such as CVD 103-HgR is advantageous, since the virulence characteristics of wild-type V. cholerae are very similar to those of wild-type ETEC. Other V. cholerae potential live vaccine strains which may be useful for the expression of ETEC pilis are CVD111 (Taylor et al, 1999) and Peru-15 (Kenner et al, 1995), both derived from El Tor O1 strains, and CVD112 (Tacket et al, 1995) and Bengal-15 (Coster et al, 1995), both derived from strains of the O139 serotype. Advantage of use of the above strains stem from the fact that i) V. cholerae El Tor is the only biotype currently isolated worldwide and ii) O139 is the only non-O1 serotype causing disease in humans.
In one embodiment of the invention, the DNA sequences coding for the pili are either present on a plasmid or stably integrated into the chromosome of the recipient strain.
The term “plasmid” is used to refer to a molecule capable of autonomous replication that is suitable for transformation of a recipient strain and contains DNA sequences that direct and/or control the expression of inserted heterologous DNA sequences. Various types of plasmids may be used such as low and high copy number plasmids, narrow and broad-host range plasmids, expression plasmids, and cosmids. High copy number plasmids are preferred, provided that they are not toxic to the cells. The latter seems to be case for the CS3 operon, for example. In these cases, low-copy number plasmids are preferred.
In general, heterologous gene expression is achieved by cloning of the heterologous gene(s) into plasmids which are replicated within the recipient in multiple copies thus leading to high expression of foreign gene product. However, synthetic plasmids are notably unstable, being rapidly lost from the cells when the latter are grown without selection pressure, giving rise to a cell population which does not express the heterologous antigen any longer. A further risk is that of plasmid(s) transfer to other bacterial species either in the environment or in the gut. Although some plasmids have been developed which address the first concern, the safety aspect remains a potential concern. Taken together, the expression of foreign antigens from plasmids is not appreciated by the regulatory authorities. Accordingly, the expression of foreign antigens is preferably achieved from corresponding genes integrated into the chromosome of the recipient strain, where they are stably maintained, while the risk of unwanted transfer to other organisms is excluded.
In order to circumvent both stability and safety concerns, the cfa, cst, and css loci encoding the CFA/I, CS3, and CS6 pili, respectively, preferentially are integrated into the chromosome of the V. cholerae CVD 103-HgR recipient strain. The co-integration of 2-3 operons per one strain is preferred. In a preferred embodiment, the DNA sequence encoding the ETEC pilus is chromosomally integrated into an integration site which is non-essential for inducing a protective immune response by the strain, such as the hlyA , hlyB, rtxA and/or orfU genes, or any gene within the ctxφ region of V. cholerae. The hlyB locus is particularly preferred for integration.
Similarly, the DNA sequence encoding the regulator can either be present on a plasmid or stably integrated into the chromosome of the recipient strain. In a preferred embodiment, the DNA sequence encoding the ETEC regulator is chromosomally integrated into the hlyA, hlyB, rtxA and/or orfU genes, or any gene within the ctxφ region of V. cholerae. The hlyB locus is particularly preferred for integration.
In a further embodiment of the invention, multiple copies of the DNA sequence encoding the pilus and/or regulator are integrated in tandem into a single chromosomal integration site or independently integrated into individual integration sites. Preferably, 1 to 10 copies of the DNA sequence encoding the pilus and 1 to 10 copies of the DNA sequence encoding the regulator are inserted, more preferably 1-2 copies.
In vitro as well as in vivo, the expression of pili is temperature-dependent and occurs at around 37° C., usually less well at lower temperatures (Cassels and Wolf, 1995). It was therefore surprising that it proved to be possible to obtain the same level of expression after growth of the recombinant strains at 30 and 37° C. in a preferred embodiment of the invention, expression of the ETEC pili therefore occurs during growth in liquid medium at a temperature between 25° C. and 42° C. Expression during growth at a temperature of 37° C. is particularly preferred.
In one embodiment of the invention, the recombinant V. cholerae strain is characterized in that the strain has retained the characteristics of the recipient strain with respect to LPS and CT subunit B production, and cytotoxicity.
V. cholerae O1 Inaba lipopolysaccharide (LPS) may be identified by Western blotting with the specific monoclonal antibody VCO4 (Gustafsson and Holme, 1983). CT-B production can be measured by the GM-1 ELISA assay as described (Svennerholm and Holmgren, 1978). A positive production of CT-B is defined by a value of more than 2 μg/ml. Cytotoxicity may be determined by the Y1 adrenal assay as described (Sack and Sack, 1975) and is defined as a rounding of Y1 adrenal cells.
In a preferred embodiment, the strain shows increased adherence to gut epithelial cells as compared to the recipient strain. The adherence may be determined by assessing the capacity of a cell expressing the respective polypeptide to adhere to gut cells. The adherence as defined in the present invention is considered to be “similar”, if the normalized adherence index NAI is in the range of 0.9-1.1 if compared to that of CVD 103-HgR (for details, see example 11); the adherence is considered to be “increased”, if the normalized adherence index NAI is >1.
The capacity of the strain to adhere to gut cells may be determined as outlined in example 11 of the present description. Accordingly, an NAI above 1 indicates higher adherence than that of CDV103-HgR.
In another aspect, the present invention is related to a vaccine comprising the recombinant V. cholerae strain according to the invention, optionally in a mixture with a pharmaceutically acceptable excipient (e.g. lactose and/or ascorbic acid) and/or a buffer (e.g. sodium bicarbonate). In a preferred embodiment, the vaccine may further comprise other bacterial strains and/or toxins. Examples for toxins are given in the table below. A vaccine in which co-expression of 01 cholera LPS, the cholera toxin B-subunit and the ETEC pili is achieved may result in an enhanced protection rate and thus could resemble an alternative vaccine composition protective not only against ETEC, but also against cholera. By inclusion of a CT-B toxin, it may be possible to increase the protection rate to 85% of all ETEC isolates.
In a further aspect, the present invention relates to the use of the recombinant V. cholerae strain according to the invention for preparing a pharmaceutical composition for immunization against ETEC and/or cholera.
Preferably, the pharmaceutical composition is for mucosal administration, most preferred is oral, nasal, and/or rectal administration.
In yet another aspect, the present invention is related to a method for producing the recombinant V. cholerae strain according to the invention, said method comprising the steps of
Further, the present invention also relates to a method for preparing a vaccine composition, comprising formulating the recombinant V. cholerae strain according to the invention in a mixture with a pharmaceutically acceptable excipient and/or buffer.
In another aspect, the present invention is related to methods for increasing the immunogenicity of a V. cholerae strain by increasing its adherence to the gut cells.
This may be achieved by introducing at least one DNA sequence encoding an ETEC pilus into the V. cholerae strain and culturing said strain under conditions which allow surface expression of the pili. A DNA sequence encoding CS3 is particularly preferred. Thus, ETEC pili are expressed on the surface of the V. cholerae cells in addition to homologous V. cholerae pili. In a preferred embodiment, at least one DNA sequence encoding a regulator gene is further introduced into the strain.
Certain V. cholerae strains, such as CVD 103-HgR, are known to present an impaired adherence compared to their parent strains, e.g. CVD 103 (Ketley et al., 1993). Furthermore, various studies suggest that some genetic modifications (Ketley et al., 1990), as well as the expression of foreign antigens in V. cholerae may reduce colonization with respect to the parent strain. In one study, for example, the addition of the eaeA gene of EHEC which codes for an outer membrane protein suppressed the immune response against the cloned subunit B of Shiga toxin. This effect may be due to lower growth and/or colonization by the eaeA-expressing strain (Butterton et al., 1997). In summary, the expression of a foreign antigen in a V. cholerae strain such as CVD 103-HgR may adversely influence the adherence properties of said strain. This, in turn, may negatively influence the magnitude of the immune response elicited by the recombinant strain, since the induction of an efficacious immune response against V. cholerae is linked to the ability of the cells to adhere to the gut cells in order to i) express the CT toxin in vivo, and ii) to be sampled by the immune system at the Peyer's patches. It is therefore indispensable to guarantee the adherence of the recombinant strain. This may be achieved by expressing further adherence determinants in the recombinant strain, thereby increasing its adherence properties.
In the present invention, it was examined whether an increased adherence of CVD 103-HgR could be achieved by expression of the ETEC pili in the V. cholerae strain. For that purpose, the adherence properties of the recombinant strain were compared to those of the recipient CVD 103-HgR strain. It was found that, indeed, the adherence of the parent strain can be increased by this strategy (see example 11).
According to the invention, the surface expression of at least one ETEC pilus in a V. cholerae strain may further be enhanced by co-expression of a regulator gene which is stably integrated into the chromosome of the strain or present on a plasmid (see examples 7 and 9). For that purpose, at least one DNA sequence encoding a regulator gene is introduced into said strain and said strain is then cultured under conditions which allow expression of the pilus and the regulator, wherein the regulator gene is stably integrating into the chromosome of the strain or present on a plasmid. Preferentially, expression of CFA/I and/or CS3 may be enhanced using said method.
The following Figures and examples shall illustrate the present invention in more detail. The examples given shall not be taken to limit the scope of the invention.
Figures
All E. coli K12 strains used for cloning, as well as enterotoxigenic E. coli were grown in LB (Luria broth) medium (Sambrook, Fritsch and Maniatis, 1989). For solid medium, 2% agar was added. Antibiotics were used at the following concentrations: chloramphenicol 17 μg/ml, kanamycin 50 μg/ml. For all strain construction purposes V. cholerae was grown on LBSOY consisting of 10 g/L Soytone tryptone (Difco), 5 g/L Yeast extracts (Difco), and 10 g/L NaCl, pH 7.3, or LBHySoy consisting of 10 g/L HySoy (Quest International, Bussum, Netherlands), 5 g/L Yeast extracts (Difco), and 10 g/L NaCl, pH 7.2.
Pili expression was obtained by growing the recombinant E. coli or V. cholerae strains in CF medium consisting of 10.0 g/L Casamino acids, 1.5 g/L Yeast extracts, 50 mg/L MgSO4×7H2O, and 5 mg/L MnCl2×4H2O, or 2×CF medium consisting of 20.0 g/L Casamino acids, 10.0 g/L Yeast extracts, 100 mg/L MgSO4×7H2O, and 10 mg/L MnCl2×4H2O. The latter medium allowed a similar or better expression of pili than CF, while allowing a higher cell density to be reached. The pH of CF was adjusted to either 6.5 or 7.2 by NaOH. 2×CF medium was used at a pH of 7.3. In some experiments 5 g/L lactose was added to the medium (2×CFL medium). In cell adherence experiments, the bacteria were assayed on BHI plates (DIFCO).
Caco-2 cells for the adherence assay were seeded at 104 cells/well and grown at 37° C. under 5% CO2 in MEM medium until almost confluent.
2. Cloning of Pili Loci into Integration Vectors
2.1. Preparation of the Integration Vectors
The integration of different DNA loci in the same strain has to occur at a specific location for each DNA locus. Therefore a total of two different integration vectors will be described in this Example, reflecting the integration of two different pili operons in the same strain.
2.1.1. Vector for the Integration of the First Pili Operon
The integration vector was based on the suicide integration plasmid pMAKSACA (Favre and Viret, 2000) which was restricted with Xmal and Pstl. The homology region derived from the plasmid pJMK10 (Ketley, et al, 1993), corresponding to a 3559 bp PinAl-Pstl fragment encompassing the 3′-end of the hlyA gene, the entire hlyB gene and the 5′-end of the lipA (hlyC) gene, was cloned in the restricted vector to produce the vector pMAKSACAhly. pMAKSACAhly contains two Nrul sites which are located 8 bp apart in the middle of the insert and within the hlyB gene. These Nrul sites can be used for cloning of foreign genes to produce integration plasmids (
2.1.2. Vector for the Integration of the Second Pili Operon
Strain CHCS3-R2 was taken as the host strain for the integration of the CFA/I operon. The integration vector pMAKSACBhlyAL was constructed by cloning a 2.23 Kb Scal-Bg/II fragment from pSSVI207-2 into vector pMAKSACB cut with BamHI and SmaI. The Scal-Bg/II fragment encompasses 0.93 Kb of sequence upstream of the hlyA gene, the 5′ part of the hlyA gene, the merR gene and the 5′ part of the mer operon in CVD 103-HgR. In this context integration of a foreign gene can be effected at the single Nrul site located within hlyA, 203 bp downstream from the start codon.
2.2. Subcloning of the Pili Loci
2.2.1. CS3
The CS3 operon was excised from plasmid pGB1 as a 4.7 Kb HindIII fragment. This fragment was first cloned in the low-copy number vector pSSVI215 restricted by HindIII. The resulting plasmid was called pSSVI215CS3 and contains the CS3 operon in tandem with a kanamycin-resistance gene (KmR) which serves as a positive marker for the subsequent subcloning. The 6 Kb CS3 operon-KmR gene fragment was further isolated by restricting pSSVI215CS3 with Swal and subcloned in pMAKSACAhly restricted by Nrul. This produced the plasmid pMAKCS3-Km2, whereby the homology region is split between a left-hand segment of 1770 bp and a right-hand segment of 1781 bp. In order to remove the kanamycin-resistance gene, pMAKCS3-Km2 was excised by Scel and the large fragment was self-ligated. This resulted in the final 14.7 Kb integration plasmid called pMAKCS3-2 (
2.2.2. CS6
The CS6 operon was excised from plasmid pM295 as a 4.5 Kb Sacl fragment. This fragment was first cloned in the low-copy number vector pSSVI215 restricted by Sacl. The resulting plasmid was called pSSVI215-CS6 and contains the CS6 operon in tandem with a kanamycin-resistance gene (KmR) which serves as a positive marker for the subsequent subcloning. The ca. 6 Kb CS6 operon-KmR gene fragment was further isolated from pSSVI215-CS6 by restriction with Swal and subcloned in pMAKSACAhly restricted by Nrul. This produced the plasmid pMAKCS6-Km-1 and pMAKCS6-Km-2, whereby the former plasmid contains the cssA, B, C, and D genes of the CS6 operon in the same orientation as the hlyB gene whereas the latter plasmid has the operon in opposite orientation to hlyB. The interruption of the hlyB gene by the CS6 locus produces a left-hand homologous segment of 1770 bp and a right-hand homologous segment of 1781 bp. In order to remove the kanamycin-resistance gene, pMAKCS6-Km-1 and pMAKCS6-Km-2, were excised by Scel and the large fragments were self-ligated. This resulted in the final 14.5 Kb integration plasmids called pMAKCS6-1 and pMAKCS6-2.
2.2.3. CFA/I
2.2.3.1. Long CFA/I Insert
The entire CFA/I operon was excised from plasmid pK18cfaI-a as a 7.3 Kb Sacl fragment. This fragment was first cloned in the low-copy number vector pSSVI215 restricted by Sacl. The resulting plasmid was called pSSVI215-cfaI and contains the CFA/I operon in tandem with a kanamycin-resistance gene (KmR) which serves as a positive marker for the subsequent subcloning. The ca. 8.6 Kb CFA/I operon-KmR gene fragment was further isolated from pSSVI215-cfaI by restriction with Swal and subcloned in pMAKSACAhly restricted by Nrul. This produced the plasmids pMAKcfaIKm-1 and pMAKcfaIKm-2, whereby the former plasmid contains the genes of the CFA/I operon in the same orientation as the hlyB gene whereas the latter plasmid has the CFA/I operon in opposite orientation to hlyB. The interruption of the hlyB gene by the CFA/I locus produces a left-hand homologous segment of 1770 bp and a right-hand homologous segment of 1781 bp. In order to remove the kanamycin-resistance gene, pMAKcfaIKm-1 and pMAKcfaIKm-2 were excised by Scel and the large fragments were self-ligated. This resulted in the final 17.2 Kb integration plasmids called pMAKcfaI-1 and pMAKcfaI-2, respectively.
2.2.3.2. Short CFA/I Insert
Due to genotypic stability problems with strain CHcfaI-RI, a second CFA/I-producing strain was constructed from which most of the ΔcfaD gene was eliminated. Possibly, the presence of the RNS regulator in the vicinity of the nearly homologous defective regulator (ΔcfaD) at the 3′-end of the CFA/I operon has allowed recombination events to occur with resulting unstability. The CFA/I locus was cloned from plasmid pK18cfaI-a as a 5563 bp EcoRV-Sacl fragment lacking most of the ΔcfaD gene and cloned into plasmid pSSVI215 to produce pSSVI215-cfaI/S. The CFA/I locus was further subcloned together with the adjacent kanamycin-resistant gene in the middle of the hlyB gene in the integration plasmid pMAKSACAhly cut by Nrul to produce pMAKcfaIS-Km-4. The kanamycin-resistant gene was removed from pMAKcfaIS-Km-4 by Scel restriction and self-ligation. The resultant plasmid, called pMAKcfaIS-4, was introduced by electroporation in CVD 103-HgR. The CFA/I locus was then chromosomally integrated within the hlyB gene of the host strain. The resulting strain was called CHcfaI-4. In this strain the CFA/I genes are transcribed in the same orientation as the hlyB gene.
3. Construction of an Integration Vector for Integration of the Regulator Genes
The integration vector was based on the suicide integration plasmid pMAKSACB (Favre and Viret, 2000) which was restricted with BamHI and Ns/I, creating a 6724 bp vector. The homology region corresponded to a 1653 bp BamHI-Ns/I fragment derived from pJMK10 (Ketley et al, 1993) encompassing the 3′-end of the hlyA gene and the 5′-end of the hlyB gene. The latter fragment was cloned into pMAKSACB to create pMAKSACBhlyAR. The latter vector contains a unique EcoRV cloning site within the homology region, providing 885 and 772 bp of homology arms, and located 245 bp downstream of the ATG start codon of the hlyB gene (
4. Cloning of Regulators into Integration Vectors
4.1. CsfR
The csfR regulator gene was cloned as a 1099 bp Sspl fragment into pMAKSACBhlyAR restricted by EcoRV. Two orientations of the gene within the vector were found by restriction analysis of the plasmids with Hpal and called pMAKcsfR-1 and pMAKcsfR-2. The former plasmid has csfR in the opposite orientation than the hlyB gene, whereas the latter plasmid has csfR in the same orientation (
4.2. Rns
The ms regulator gene was cloned as a ca., 1.2 Kb Klenowed EcoRI-HindIII fragment into pMAKSACBhlyAR restricted by EcoRV. Two orientations of the gene within the vector were found by restriction analysis of the plasmids with AlwNI and called pMAKms-1 and pMAKms-2. In plasmid pMAKms-1, ms is transcribed in the reverse orientation with respect to hlyB gene transcription, whereas in pMAKms-2, ms is transcribed in the same orientation as hlyB (
5. Integration of Pili and Regulator Loci into the Chromosome of V. Cholerae
5.1. Pili Loci
5.1.1. Construction of Monovalent Strains
In a first phase, the plasmids pMAKCS3-2, pMAKCS6-1, pMAKCS6-2, pMAKcfaI-1, pMAKcfaI-2, and pMAKcfaS4 were transferred in the V. cholerae live attenuated recipient vaccine strain CVD 103-HgR by either transformation or conjugation via E. coli K12 S17.1 (Simon et al, 1983). In all subsequent steps, care was taken to grow cells on either the bovine-free medium called LBSOY consisting of 10 g Soytone tryptone (Difco), 5 g Yeast extracts (Difco), and 10 g NaCl or LBHySoy consisting of 109 HySoy (Quest), 5 g Yeast extracts (Difco), and log NaCl. For solid LBSOY or LBHySoy, 2% agar was added. Where needed, 17 μg/ml chloramphenicol was added to the plates (LBSOY Cm or LBHySoy Cm). Growth from a LBSOY Cm plate with CVD 103-HgR (pMAKCS6-1) and (pMAKCS6-2) was inoculated in 1 ml PBS and homogenized. Growth from CVD 103-HgR (CHCS3-2), CVD 103-HgR (pMAKcfaI-1), CVD 103-HgR (pMAKcfaI-2), and CVD 103-HgR (pMAKcfaIS-4) was inoculated in 2 mls 0.9% NaCl and homogenized. 100 μl of 1×, 10×, and 100× dilutions of these cell suspensions were plated out onto LBSOY Cm or LBHySoy Cm plates and incubated at 42° C. for 16 hours. Individual colonies were then gathered and streaked out onto a 42° C. pre-warmed LBSOY Cm or LBHySoy Cm plate and the plate was incubated at 42° C. Several of the resulting colonies were inoculated in 2 ml of liquid LBSOYS-N or LBHySoy-N and incubated at 30° C. during several hours. LBSOYS-N or LBHySoy-N is LBSOY or LBHySoy without NaCl and with 5% sucrose added. This medium allows the selection of integrants which have lost the vector sequences. The OD600 of the cultures was measured and the cultures were serially diluted in order to have 100 to 10'000 CFU/plate. 100 μl dilutions were plated out onto LBSOYS-N or LBHySoyS-N plates, which were incubated at 30° C. for 16 to 24 hours. Next, the plates containing 100 to 500 colonies were successively replica-plated onto LBSOYS-N Cm or LBHySoyS-N Cm and LBSOYS-N or LBHySoyS-N. After overnight growth at 30° C., the. colonies on both media were compared and 50 Cm-sensitive colonies were short-streaked onto new LBSOYS-N or LBHySoyS-N plates and grown at 30° C. over night (O/N). These plates were subsequently blotted onto nylon filter and the presence of the CFA/I, CS3, and CS6 loci was tested by colony hybridization using specific DIG-labeled probes. A number of strains were found which have lost the vector sequences (Cm-sensitive) while conserving the pili loci. The new strains issued from pMAKCS3-2, pMAKCS6-1, pMAKCS6-2, pMAKcfaI-1, pMAKcfaI-2, and pMAKcfaIS4 were named CHCS3-2, CHCS6-1, CHCS6-2, CHcfaI-1, CHcfaI-2, and CHcfaI-4, respectively.
5.1.2. Construction of Bivalent Strains
Both pMAKhlyAcfaIS-3 and pMAKhlyAcfaIS4 plasmids were electroporated into CHCS3-R2. Subsequently, integration procedure was followed as above for monovalent operon integration (see Example 5.1). Colonies of CHCS3-R2 having an integrated copy of the CFA/I operon were identified for both the pMAKhlyAcfaIS-3 and pMAKhlyAcfaIS4 plasmids and called BB06 and BB07, respectively (
5.2. Regulators
Plasmids pMAKcsfR-1, pMAKcsfR-2, pMAKms-1, and pMAKms-2 were electroporated in CHcfaI-1, CHcfaI-2, CHcfaI-4 and CHCS3 V. cholerae strains containing integrated pili loci. Each strain was grown onto either LBSOY or LBHySoy medium from glycerol stock cultures. The electroporation cultures were plated out onto LBSOY Cm or LBHySoy Cm medium and grown at 30° C. The integration procedure was then followed exactly as for the pili loci. Following integration, various integrants were screened for production of pilin. Three types of strains could thus be isolated, corresponding to CHcfaI-1 having integrated the ms gene from plasmid pMAKms-1, to CHcfaI-4 having integrated the ms gene from pMAKms-1 and to CHCS3-2 having integrated the ms gene from plasmid pMAKms-2 on the other hand. The strains were called CHcfaI-R1, BB01 and CHCS3-R2, respectively.
Some combinations of pili recombinant strains and regulator genes did not allow any pilin production, demonstrating that various factors may affect the expression of pilin from a combination of pili operon and regulator gene. Thus, the choice of such a combination is not a trivial one.
6. Western Blot Assays of Pili Expression with or without Regulator after Growth on Solid CF Agar
The expression of pilin, the structural protein of the pili was studied by Western blotting. The strains to analyze were grown as lawns overnight on CF agar, pH 6.5 at the indicated temperature. Part of the lawn of bacteria was resuspended in 2 mls of 0.9% NaCl, the OD600 was measured and the cell density was adjusted to an OD600 of 3.0. One volume of the cell suspension was then mixed with 1 volume of SDS-PAGE sample buffer. 15 μl were subsequently run on a Criterion™ Precast Gel 4-20% (BioRad Laboratories, Glattbrugg, Switzerland). Following blotting against a nitrocellulose membrane, the membrane was blocked in 10% powdered milk (Rapilait, Migros) for 1 h at 37° C. and incubated in the presence of a 10'000 dilution of pili-specific rabbit polyclonal antibodies. After three consecutive washes in PBS-T the membrane was incubated with a 10'000-fold dilution of a HP-conjugated goat anti-rabbit IgG (H+L). The membrane was again washed and the bands were detected by chemoluminescence after a 5 min contact with 1 ml ChemiGlow™ West Luminol/Enhancer Solution (Alphalnnotech, San Leandro, USA). The bands were detected using a video camera device (Chemilmager, Alphalnnotech, San Leandro, USA).
CS3
As shown in
CS6
In contrast to CS3, CS6 pilin appears to be synthesized in the absence of any regulator (
CFA/I
The expression profile of CFA/I pilin resembles that of CS3.
7. Western Blot Assays of Pili Expression Using Either the CsfR or the Rns Regulator
In a further aspect, it was checked whether the use of any regulator was suitable to express CS3 and CFA/I pili. Accordingly, the ms regulator gene carried on plasmid pEU2040 (high copy number plasmid) or on pCLms (low-copy number plasmid) was electroporated in strains CHcfaI-1, CHcfaI-2, and CHCS3-2, and the expression of CFA/I and CS3, respectively, was analyzed by Western blot.
As the results depicted in
8. Western Blot Assays of Pili Expression after Growth in Liquid CF Medium
Current knowledge holds that the ETEC pili (and, presumably pilins) are best expressed on solid CF plates. It was therefore checked if this holds true in the case of V. cholerae-expressed pilin. In addition, the effect on pilin expression of CF medium at either pH 6.5 or pH 7.3 was compared. Overnight LBHySoy cultures of the strains to test were either spread as lawns of cells on a CF or chloramphenicol-containing CF (CFCm) plate, pH 6.5, or diluted in 10 mls of CF or CFCm medium, pH 6.5 or 7.3. Liquid and solid cultures were grown at 37° C. From the CF/CFCm plates, cell suspensions in 0.9% NaCl were made to an OD600 of 3.0. These suspensions served as reference for production of pilin from solid CF. The overnight CF/CFCm cultures were diluted to an OD600 of 0.1 in 30 ml of fresh CF/CFCm medium at pH 6.5 or 7.3 and the cultures were agitated at 37° C. At OD600 of 0.5, 1.5, as well as after overnight growth, samples of the cultures were withdrawn, pelleted and resuspended to an OD600 of 3.0 in 0.9% NaCl. Finally, 100 μl of the cell suspensions at OD600=3.0 were mixed with 100 μl of sample buffer and 15 μl of each sample was run on a 4-20% gradient SDS-PAGE gel. After the run, the gel was blotted onto nitrocellulose membrane and the pilin proteins were detected by means of specific polyclonal antibodies.
The results are presented in
9. Expression of Pilin from Recombinant Strains with an Integrated Regulator Gene.
The amount of pilin synthesized by strains containing the integrated ms regulator gene was tested by Western blotting.
10. Co-Expression of Two Pilis in the Same Recipient Strain
It was investigated the possibility to co-express two different pilis in a single strain. CHCS3-R2 was chosen as the recipient strain because of its excellent surface expression of the CS3 pili. In preliminary experiments, the plasmids pSSVI215-cfaI or pSSVI215-CS6 were electroporated into CHCS3-R2. The expression of both the CS3 and CFA/I pilis in strain CHCS3-R2 (pSSVI215-cfaI), as well as the expression of the CS3 and CS6 pilis in the strain CHCS3-R2 (pSSVI215-CS6) were studied by Western blotting, immunospots and immunofluorescence. The expression of both the CFA/I and CS3 pili in the double-integrant strains BB06 and BB07 was studied by Western blot and pili ELISA (for the results of the latter see table 8).
10.1. Western Blot
A Western blot was carried out as described above (see example 6). The results are shown in table 4.
10.2. Immunospots Immunofluorescence
To determine the immunofluorescence, the method of Lang et al, 1990 was followed. Briefly, the strains indicated in table 4 were grown onto CF plates at 37° C. A cell suspension was then made in 0.9% NaCl at an OD600 of 1.0-2.0. A loopful of the suspension was smeared on a glass slide and air-dried. The slides were then dipped in cold acetone (−20° C.) for 10 min at 4° C. and air-dried. The glass slides were washed 3× in PBS, air dried, and 100 μl of a 50 times dilution of each of the specific antisera were applied to the corresponding dried cells and incubated at room temperature for 15 min. The slides were again washed 3× in PBS, air-dried and 100 μl of a 1:100 dilution of a FITC-labeled anti-rabbit IgG antibody was applied to the cells at room temperature for 15 min. The slides were again washed 3× by PBS and air-dried. Finally, 5 μl H2O and a drop of MOVIOL was added to each bacterial spot and the preparation was covered with a cover slip. The results were recorded on a Nikon Eclipse E800 fluorescence microscope.
For detection of immunospots, the strains indicated in table 4 were grown in CF medium, resuspended in 0.9% NaCl to an OD600 of 3.0 and diluted to an OD600 of 0.3. 5 μl of the undiluted and diluted cell suspensions were spotted on a nitrocellulose filter. The filter was blocked with 10% horse serum. Then the filter was incubated for 1 h with a 1:10'000 dilution of the specific polyclonal antibody at room temperature. After extensive washing the filter was further incubated for 30 min at room temperature with a 1:10'000 dilution of a horseradish peroxidase-conjugated anti-rabbit IgG antibody. After washing, the filter was either incubated with a chemolumiescent substrate or with a colorimetric substrate. In the former case, the development of chemoluminescence is detected with a video camera device (Chemilmager, Alphalnnotech, San Leandro Calif., USA) or by calorimetric development of the signal.
a− no band, +: thin band, ++ medium band, +++ thick band
b− no visible spot, +: clear spot at OD600 = 3.0 but weak at 0.3, ++: clear spots at both ODs.
c− no fluorescence, cells almost undetectable. +: weak fluorescence. ++: medium fluorescence, readily visible. +++: strong fluorescence.
dND: not done
Table 4 summarizes the results. Immunospots and immunofluorescence results correlate well with each other. In all CHCS3-R2 strains the CS3 pili is very well expressed. In the CHCS3-R2 (pSSVI215-cfaI) strain, as well as in the doubly integrated strains BB06 and BB07, CFA/I pili is also very well expressed. Therefore it appears that a single strain is able to support the synthesis of two heterologous ETEC pili.
11. Adherence of Recombinant Vc/ETEC Strains to Caco-2 Cells
The test was performed using the human gut cells Caco-2. Caco2-cells were grown at 37° C. under 5% CO2 to near confluence in a 24-well plate in MEM medium (GIBCO BRL, Gaithersburg, USA) supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum, thus containing roughly 106 Caco-2 cells per well. The recombinant strains to test, as well as the recipient strain CVD 103-HgR, were grown on CF plates for over 16 h at 37° C. A cell suspension was then made in 0.9% NaCl and the OD600 measured. The cells were then diluted in prewarmed MEM medium to 2×106 CFU/ml. The diluted cells were then further diluted and plated onto BHI plates in duplicate to score the initial viable count (IVC). The medium was removed from the wells containing the Caco-2 cells and replaced by 0.5 ml of the diluted bacterial cells (1:1 multiplicity of infection). Each sample was run in triplicate. The plate was then centrifuged 1'000 rpm for 2 min and incubated at 37° C. for 1 hour. At the end of the incubation, 10 μl of each supernatant is appropriately diluted and 100 μl of the dilutions were plated onto BHI plates in duplicate to score the supernatant viable count (SVC). The medium was removed from the wells, which were then carefully washed 3× with 0.5 ml of 0.9% NaCl. 0.5 ml 0.9% NaCl were then added to each well, the cells were scraped with an Eppendorf tip and the cell suspension added to an Eppendorf tube. The wells were rinsed with 0.5 ml 0.9% NaCl, which was added to the Eppendorf tube. The Eppendorf tubes were subsequently vortexed at maximum speed for a full 2 min. The cell suspensions were then appropriately diluted and the dilutions were plated onto BHI plates in duplicate to score the adherent viable count (AVC). All plates were incubated for 16-20 hours at 37° C. and the colonies were scored.
The adherence of the ETEC/cholera strains was determined relative to that of CVD 103-HgR by dividing the AVC for the ETEC-cholera (AVCEC) by the AVC for CVD 103-HgR (AVCCVD), thus producing an adherence index (AI). Since it was determined in a preliminary experiment that, in our multiplicity of infection range, the number of adherent cells is directly proportional to the inoculum size, the actual ETEC-cholera inoculum (IVCEC) was divided by the actual CVD 103-HgR inoculum (IVCCVD) to produce a inoculum index (II). Finally, the AI value was normalized for the inocula by dividing AI by II, thus producing the normalized adherence index (NAI). An NAI of 1 indicates an adherence identical to that of CVD 103-HgR. An NAI above or below 1 indicates higher or lower adherence than CVD 103-HgR, respectively. The data shown in table 5 indicate that the CS6 recombinant strain CHCS6-2 and CVD 103-HgR may be similarly adherent. In contrast, CHCFA/I appears to be less adherent than CVD 103-HgR, while CHCS3 is more adherent by a factor of about 1.7.
aStrains: CVD 103-HgR (reference strain), CFA/I: CHcfal-2 (pM392), CS3: CHCS3-2 (pM392), CS6: CHCS6-2
bR: viable count ratio of the pili-producing strain Inoculum and the CVD 103-HgR inoculum.
cAI: adherence Index: viable count ratio of the pili-producing strain adherent cells and the CVD 103-HgR adherent cells
dNAI: normalized AI: AI divided by R
12. Immunofluorescence and Electron Microscopy
12.1. Immunofluorescence
To determine the immunofluorescence, the method of Lang et al, 1990 was followed as outlined in Example 10. The test strains were CHcfaI-2 (pM392) expressing CFA/I pilin, CHCS3-2(pM392) expressing CS3, and CHCS6-2 expressing CS6. The primary antibodies were anti-CFA/I, anti-CS3, and anti-CS6 rabbit polyclonal antisera which have been adsorbed against CVD 103-HgR and E. coli K12. The parent strain CVD 103-HgR served as the negative control for each antiserum.
The results shown in
12.2 Electron Microscopy
In addition to immunofluorescence, the presence of pili on the surface of the recombinant strains was studied by scanning electron microscopy. The strains tested were CHcfaI-2 (pM392) and CHcfaI-1 (pM392) expressing CFA/I, CHCS3-2 (pM392) expressing CS3, and CHCS6-1 and CHCS6-2 expressing CS6. The CFA/I positive controls were the ETEC strains H10407, DS7-3, and B7A for the CFA/I, CS3, and CS6 pili, respectively. CVD 103-HgR served as a negative control. All strains were grown onto CF plates at 37° C. The cultures were either fixed directly on the agar or adsorbed on glass slides, gold-covered, and poly-L-lysine treated. Following post-fixation treatment with osmium tetraoxide (OSO4) the fixed bacteria were dried by the critical point method or by treatment by hexamethyldisilazane (HMDS). Finally, a 5 nm layer of carbon/platinum was deposed on the samples by electron beam evaporation. All samples were examined using a LEO DSM 982 scanning electron microscope.
In addition, CFA/I pili expression was investigated in the monovalent CFA/I strain BB01 and in the bivalent CFA/I-CS3 strain BB06 by negative contrast electron microscopy following immunogold-labeling of the pili.
Therefore, it is concluded from these experiments that pili are indeed synthesized on the surface of the recombinant CVD 103-HgR strain.
13. V. Cholerae CVD 103-HgR Characteristics
It is desirable that the ETEC/cholera vaccine strains conserve the same critical characteristics as the host strain CVD 103-HgR. Therefore, the following characteristics were studied: LPS pattern, toxicity, and the production of the B-subunit of cholera toxin (CT-B)
To assess the LPS pattern, overnight cultures of the various vaccine strains were grown in LBHySoy at 37° C. CVD 103-HgR was used as the control. LPS minipreparations were prepared as described (Hitchcock et al., 1983).
To assess toxicity, the Y1 adrenal assay was used as described (Sack and Sack, 1975). In this test, the rounding of cells indicating cytotoxicity is qualitatively described. For the production of CT-B, the GM1-ELISA assay was used as described previously. (Svennerholm and Holmgren 1978). In this assay, the binding of CT-B to GM-1 gangliosides is detected by means of specific anti-CT-B antibodies.
aThe minimum value required for the production of CT-B is 2 μg/ml.
b− = no rounding, + = 0-25%; ++ = 25-75%; +++ = 75%-100%
The data in table 6 indicate that the CT-B is equally well produced by CVD 103-HgR as by the recombinant strains. In the first GM1-ELISA assay some strains were unexpectedly low. However, these strains showed normal values upon retesting. Likewise, cytotoxicity of the recombinant strains and CVD 103-HgR is identically low.
In conclusion, it appears that the expression of ETEC pilin does not alter any of the critical properties of the CVD 103-HgR host strain.
14. Immunogenicity in Mice
Groups of 5 mice were immunized subcutaneously with 100 μl of 0.9% NaCl containing 109 heat-inactivated cells (60 min at 65° C.) of the various recombinant strains. The negative control was the vector strain CVD 103-HgR and the positive controls were the wild-type ETEC strains. A booster immunization was administered at day 14 and the mice were sacrificed at day 29. The results were analyzed by ELISA using purified pili preparations as the coating antigens. Briefly, 2.5 microgram/ml of the specific pili was coated on a blocked ELISA plate (Nunc MAXISORP, Milian, Switzerland). After washing the wells, 100 microliters of serial dilutions of the serum to test was added and the plate incubated at room temperature for 2 hours. The plate was washed again and 100 microliters of a proxidase-labeled goat anti-mouse IgG antibody was added at a 1:2000 dilution and the plate incubated for 1 h at RT. Finally 100 microliters of a peroxidase substrate solution was added and the plate incubated for 10-15 min at room temperature. The results were then recorded in a plate reader (Spectramax Plus, Bucher Biotec AG, Basel, Switzerland) set at 405 nm. A significant ELISA titer is defined as being equal or superior to twice the reciprocal of the background ELISA titer. Alternatively, mice were immunized with 108 live bacteria at day 1, boosted at day 14 and 28 and sacrificed on day 35.
The results given in table 7 showed that a good immune response was obtained from strain CHCS3 (pM392). In contrast no immune response could be obtained from the CFA/I and CS6 recombinant strains. On the assumption that this may have to do with the heat inactivation of the bacteria, new groups of 5 mice were immunized with 109 live bacteria followed by a with 108 live bacteria booster (CFA/I) or by 108 bacteria for both primary and booster immunizations (CS6). The vaccine strains CHcfaI-R1 and BB01 were used in independent experiments for the CFA/I immunizations, while strain CVD 103-HgR (pM295) was used for the CS6 immunization. In contrast to immunization with heat-killed bacteria, immunization with live bacteria led to significant immune responses from the CFA/I and CS6 recombinant strains. These experiments show that CVD 103-HgR is capable of expressing each of the CFA/I, CS3 and CS6 pili in immunogenic form on its surface.
15. Co-Expression of Three Pili in the Same Recipient
15.1 Construction of Trivalent Strains
To demonstrate the feasibility of co-expressing three ETEC pili in one V. cholerae cell, the CS6-carrying plasmid pSSVI215-CS6 was electroporated in both bivalent recombinant V. cholerae strains BB06 and BB07.
The expression of the three pili operons in the resulting strains, named BB06 (pSSVI215-CS6) and BB07 (pSSVI215-CS6), was investigated by western blotting and pili ELISA. Positive controls for CS6, CS3, and CFA/I pili were the wild type strains B7A, DS7-3, and CD79a, as well as the recombinant strains CVD 103-HgR (pSSVI215-CS6), CHCS3-R2, and CHcfaI-4RI, respectively. The negative control was CVD 103-HgR.
15.2 Western Blotting
Results indicate that all three pilins are expressed in similar or even higher amounts than the wild type strain (see
15.3 Pili ELISA
The surface expression of CFA/I, CS3, and CS6 pili in bivalent and trivalent strains was investigated by ELISA. The strains were grown in 2×CF liquid medium overnight at 37° C. The cells were then centrifuged and resuspended at an OD600 of 0.2 in 0.9% NaCl containing 0.5% formalin. The wells of a Maxisorp plate (Nunc) were coated with 100 μl of this suspension and the plate was incubated 2 h at 37° C. The wells were then washed and blocked with a solution consisting of 0.9% NaCl containing 1% horse serum albumin (NH). 100 μl of a 1000-fold dilution of specific anti-pili monoclonal antibodies (anti-CFA/I=2E5, anti-CS3=1G3, anti-CS6=4C9) were added to the wells and incubated 30 min at 37° C. The wells were then washed again and 100 μl of a 1000-fold diluted anti-mouse IgG horseradish peroxidase-conjugated secondary antibody was added to the wells and the plate was incubated 30 min at 37° C. The wells were washed as before and 50 μl of a peroxidase substrate (TMB, Promega Corp., Madison, USA) was added to the wells. Once the color had sufficiently developed, the reaction was stopped by 1 volume of 1M sulfuric acid and the OD450 was measured.
aELISA titer: the values correspond to the value of the sample minus the blank. The blank corresponds to wells where PBS buffer was added Instead of the monoclonal antibody.
The results indicate that both CFA/I and CS3 pili are very well surface expressed in all strains. There is a slight diminution in expression in the trivalent with respect to monovalent (BB01, CHCS3-R2) or bivalent (BB06 and BB07) strains. Surface expression of CS6 is clearly detectable, albeit at a lower level than for CFA/I and CS3. The expression of CS6 in the trivalent constellation is as good as in a monovalent form such as in CVD 103-HgR.
These results confirm the Western blots results and indicate that three ETEC pili can be surface expressed in a single V. cholerae cell.
16. Genotypic and Phenotypic Stability of Recombinant Pili Operons in CVD 103-HgR
The stability of BB01 was studied after growth in 2×CFL liquid medium for more than 70 generations at 37° C. H10407 and CVD 103-HgR were used as positive and negative controls, respectively. Twenty ml 2×CFL medium was inoculated with 5-6 colonies of the tested strains and the cultures were incubated at 37° C. up to stationary phase. The cultures were then diluted again in 20 ml 2×CFL medium to an OD600 of 0.05 and incubated up to stationary phase again. Eight growth cycles were so carried out. Counting the initial growth on solid medium, a total of more than 70 generations of growth was achieved. After each growth cycle appropriate dilutions of the cultures were spread on BHI plates for viable count and colony immunoblotting. For colony immunoblotting, plates with the colonies were blotted onto nitrocellulose filters. The filters were then incubated in the presence of the CFA/I-specific MAb 2E5, followed by an alkaline phosphatase-conjugated secondary antibody incubation and detection. Table 9 shows that 100% of the BB01 colonies were positive, meaning complete genotypic and phenotypic stability. Surprisingly enough, some of the wild type bacteria lost CFA/I expression. As expected no signal was obtained from the negative control CVD 103-HgR.
In conclusion, the complete phenotypic stability of CFA/I expression in BB01 implies that both the CFA/I operon and the ms gene are extremely stable.
| Number | Date | Country | Kind |
|---|---|---|---|
| EP03029082.9 | Dec 2003 | EP | regional |
| Number | Date | Country | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parent | PCT/EP04/14432 | Dec 2004 | US |
| Child | 11454440 | Jun 2006 | US |
